Video summary
This workshop session at the San Francisco Public Library introduces librarians Kelsey and Jonathan as they guide participants through the process of writing one's own obituary within a broader legacy planning context. The speakers define the essential anatomy of an obituary, which ranges from brief functional death notices to comprehensive life tributes that serve three primary purposes: notifying current acquaintances, establishing a personal narrative voice for future generations, and creating a permanent genealogical record. Participants explore how these documents can be tailored with distinct messages intended either for immediate mourners or descendants centuries later, while examining various publication options from local newspapers like the San Francisco Chronicle to regional aggregators and online platforms such as Legacy.com. A significant discussion focuses on the high costs associated with print publications versus free digital alternatives, highlighting concerns about link rot and data permanence in purely online services compared to microfilm archives held by libraries.
The presentation delves into specific examples drawn from newspaper databases to illustrate diverse approaches to storytelling, including short tributes, narratives addressing personal struggles like alcoholism that transformed into stories of recovery, lengthy pieces filled with both platitudes and intimate details written by widowers, and announcements regarding estranged family members that balance humor about childhood memories with acknowledgments of complex relationships. To ensure authenticity and avoid the sterile feel often associated with artificial intelligence generation, speakers emphasize incorporating intentional imperfections such as funny anecdotes or slight typos to make the document sound genuinely human. For those seeking professional assistance, options include hiring ghostwriters, utilizing funeral home AI tools, or attending memoir workshops offered by local library branches, all of which can help structure a life story while preserving the individual's unique voice and tone.
As the session moves toward practical application, an interactive demonstration showcases how generative AI can be used to draft obituaries based on detailed questionnaires containing up to 142 questions about a person's life. The speakers instruct users to guide these tools with specific guardrails that prevent inventing details while maintaining a factual yet celebratory tone, noting that although AI can produce surprisingly good drafts for visioning purposes or filling memory gaps, the final output often requires manual editing to inject true personality and humor. Ultimately, the workshop advises participants on securing funding for publication through estate planning measures like bequests in wills and encourages self-authorship whenever possible to ensure accuracy is preserved while leveraging technology responsibly without compromising personal privacy or emotional truth.
Read the full video transcript
Hello. Welcome to everyone that are
joining us for our webinar today. We're
just going to hang out for a couple more
seconds and let people in from the
waiting room. So, thanks for your
patience.
All right, we're going to go ahead and
get started. Uh, we just hit 25
attendees. We had about 75 people
registered. So, hopefully we'll have
some late comers coming in. Uh, but I
got a packed schedule for today. So,
let's go ahead and do it.
So, welcome to the SFPL workshop. Write
your own obituary.
We'd like to pause, take a minute to say
that San Francisco Public Library sits
on the unseated ancestral homeland of
the Ramayat Aloney peoples and we give
thanks for our ability to work, learn,
and study here. We put the full land
acknowledgement in the chat, so you can
check that out.
Hello, my name is Kelsey. I'm a
librarian in the magazines and newspaper
center here at the main library and I'm
joined by my colleague Jonathan who's
the personal finance librarian and he's
going to be helping me run this show
smoothly today. So he'll be answering
questions on chat or helping me see
questions on chat and putting links in
the chat of things that I refer to. So
how many of you just attended the legacy
planning workshop that Jonathan hosted a
couple hours ago? I think maybe you
could put it in the chat or raise your
hand. Um, however, yeah. So, I see Anita
raised her hand. Cool. Anita, hope you
learned something great from the legacy
planning
for this work, we're going to talk about
writing your ownuary because that is a
type of legacy planning that's a little
bit different. So, in the magazines and
newspaper centers on the fifth floor of
the main library and we offer a service
called the obituary request service. So
we get requests from people all over the
world who are asking us to look up
obituaries from really long time ago
from the historic newspapers and also
people asking us for obituaries of
people they know that have passed
recently within the last couple months.
So we're kind of experts on the topic of
obituaries, what kind of content goes
into them and uh the conventions of the
form. And when we're here in this
workshop today thinking about our own
obituaries and our own legacy of our
life story, it's kind of a tough topic,
right? So, we're all going to die and
that can be pretty dis discouraging at
moments when you're enjoying living your
life. But perhaps we can feel a little
bit less afraid to die if we can write
our own obituary and think about the
great life that we've lived and what we
want to leave for the people after us.
So today my goals for you are to give
you a start in writing the content of
your obituary and also give you an idea
of where you can publish it and how much
it will cost to publish it. So the cost
is not negligible. So that is definitely
something that's um a financial aspect
that we'll talk about too.
So we're going to go ahead and get
started with an activity. So hopefully
you've got a piece of paper and a pen or
a pencil and I want you to take about
five minutes to respond to this prompt.
Imagine it's the moments immediately
following your death. What do you want
the people you just left behind to know
as they cope with your absence over the
next few months?
So, Jonathan is putting that prompt in
the chat and so you can think about it,
draft some ideas down, and I'm going to
start a timer for five minutes.
Hey, we have a little bit less than a
minute remaining, so we can wrap up your
thoughts on what you're jotting down.
Okay. So, hopefully you got some good
stuff down there. I wrote a couple
things down myself and even though I've
been preparing to give this presentation
to you all for a while, I hadn't really
thought about, you know, bigger message
or whatever. So that was interesting for
me too. Okay. So now we're going to do
another activity. So turn the page or
get a new piece of paper out. Now
imagine it's 100 years after your death.
What do you want your descendants doing
geneal genealogy research to know? So
take another five minutes, maybe we'll
make it a little bit shorter, maybe four
four minutes or so, and write that down
and see. Um, imagine yeah 100 years in
the future.
Maybe now is a good time to start
wrapping up whatever you're jotting down
if you're uh in the middle of a But
okay, so now we're going to bring it all
together with a third activity, which is
to reflect on the differences between
the two things that you just wrote down.
So, there's two very different audiences
that you're thinking about writing to
when you wrote your your ideas of what
you want to include in your orbituary.
Were there different pieces of
information that you included one or the
other? Um, were it pretty much the same?
So, take a couple minutes to reflect on
that and please share in the chat. I
would love to hear from you how those
differed for you. Maybe there's no
difference at all. Maybe it was wildly
different. Um I think if any of you out
there have done genealogy research or
are interested in that, you know that
different questions animate that process
than um the people who are mourning
someone that they just lost and what
they want to see in an obituary.
So, I'll take a uh give you a couple
minutes to uh write that down. Put it in
the chat or
um just write it for yourself on your
own notebook.
So, I really like the comments that
people are sharing already. Um, see
here,
Gloria mentions that she wants anyone um
in 100 years from now to know that she
didn't belong to one country but was a
resident of the world of mother earth.
Mary asked a question about if other
people care about the family
genealogical materials.
Um, it's hard to know because when
people are really young, maybe they
don't care about it as much, but I think
it's something that people start caring
about more the older they get and the
more interesting pieces of information
they find in their family history.
Uh earlier in response to the first
question
um Angelita shared something very tender
that most importantly that they should
know that I love them. Thank them for
sharing their lives with me and that I
enjoyed my life and had a great one. So
enjoyed their life as well. I love that
positivity and just the the tender the
tenderness of it. Um Mary has uh shared
a couple things as well and she's
getting all of her stuff in order. So uh
that's really great. Good job, Mary.
Um, let's see here.
Uh, Marina shares that there was some
overlap between the two, especially the
factual information.
And Angelita shares that um she would
like them to know the ups and downs of
how it was for me living in an immigrant
in in the United States. So, as I
reflected on it and seeing the
differences of what people really really
want to have when they're doing
genealogical research way down the line,
um they want stories of the family as a
whole and they want to know how you fit
into the whole. And so I was just doing
my little freewrite and thinking how
would I describe um how my family kind
of dispersed over the United States and
how some people had children, some
people didn't. um everyone pretty much
has been leaving California when our
grandparents originally had come to
California. So those like rhythms of the
bigger picture is maybe what I would put
thinking about the audience of 100 years
in the future.
But I think that all of this really
brings up some important questions that
are kind of philosophic questions about
obituaries. Are obituaries for us? Are
they our messages to our survivors or
are they for others? Are they for these
genealogologists in the future? Are they
for our children who might read it? Are
they for our distant colleagues that we
haven't seen maybe in 20 years but are
want to know about our passing? And you
know, I was just telling some co-workers
uh before this started that I was going
to be doing this and and people said, "I
love reading obituaries." So maybe
you're writing your obituary for a
complete stranger and they you're going
to give them a little bit of a thrill.
And so these are all things to keep in
mind as you decide what information to
include and what information to leave
out and also where you're going to
publish it.
So there's kind of like these three
pillars to an obituary and why it
matters. So the first one is the
notification of the death. So this is
concerning the present moment of letting
old friends, former colleagues, distant
acquaintances know that you have passed
and any plans for service, funeral,
memorial, stuff like that. Then the
second pillar is about your personal
legacy in terms of the narrative that
you're going to provide. So this is not
only your opportunity to share the facts
of your life, but also your worldview,
um your voice, your unique quirks, your
foibless, all of those things can come
out as you're writing your own obituary.
And then third, there's this audience
way in the future that we've been
talking about, which is the genealogical
research or the genealogical record. And
this is archiving for the future. So
unless you're, you know, really famous
or did something really important that
was lasting in the cultural record, the
only piece of evidence of your life 100
years years later will be this obituary.
And so you know this is an important
moment to say what do I need to be in
that and what is going to be left of my
history.
So let's look at some definitions. So, I
have the actual definition of the
orbituary from the Oxford English
dictionary. It's actually pretty long if
you look it up in the Oxford English
dictionary, which you can do through the
library subscriptions, but um the brief
version is an appreciation of a person
who has recently died, typically
including a brief biography. So, the
brief biography is the main thing that
we're talking about today. And in the
old days or if you're pretty famous,
this was written by a staff journalist.
And nowadays, it's really more about um
being self-authored or family authored.
And um unfortunately, gone are the days
where a lot of newspapers did employ a
journalist to do obituaries for random
members of the community. Um that
definitely doesn't really happen in San
Francisco anymore. So, it is important
for you or your family to do it. Now,
contrast this with the death notice. And
the death notice is really more
functional and brief. And it's about uh
also known as a funeral announcement.
And it's about telling people, okay,
here's the basic information. You died
um and you're having a service. It's
going to be at this funeral or this
cemetery at this time. and the funeral
or cremation service that you're working
with, it's their responsibility to pay
for the newspaper to publish that. So,
if you are taking care of a lot of your
legacy stuff and you've made
arrangements um at a cemetery or crem
cremation service, then this is
something you talk to them about making
sure they have the right information to
be published.
And so here's a basic anatomy of what
the chronicle calls a tribute, but we
can kind of interchangeably use the
terms obituary, death notice, funeral
arrange, funeral announcement or a life
tribute. So the very top we have the
basics. So this um part in blue. So you
want names including maiden names if um
important and also sometimes they
recommend putting nicknames in. So from
a searching perspective, what we do in
the magazines and newspaper center,
people will often give a full name of
somebody like their first name, their
middle name, and their last name. And
they will use that to go search in a
newspaper and we don't find the thing
because the person actually just went by
their first name and their last name. So
I suggest using whatever type of um that
you were whatever format you were
commonly known as. So if you did
commonly use your middle name in your
dealings with the world in a public way,
then include that, but otherwise you
could probably leave it out.
Then so you want when you were born,
where you were born, where you died,
when you died, and where you died. And
then the second part is this part in
green, which is number two, the life
story or like the heart. And so this is
the biography. Um, so this is your
schooling, your military service, your
career milestones, hobbies, your
personal quirks. Um, any little funny
detail that you want to include. And
this is really where your personality
and your unique voice can come out. Then
we have the portion about the survivors.
And so, you know, you list your if your
spouse survives you, uh, your children,
grandchildren, nieces, nephews, even
pets or very close friends, um,
community members that you were close
to. Um, sometimes if you're going to do
a longer one, you can also do those that
predesceased you. So, you know, if your
parents died before you, you could say
that, you know, include that
information. And this is those are the
type of details that's really important
for the genealogologist and the person
in the future. Uh then lastly or next to
last we have number four an
appreciation. So it's commonly included
to thank uh friends and healthcare
workers that were there for you in your
end of your life. I do want to point out
that in this one it says we would also
like to thank his caregivers. And so
this one is told from the perspective of
the survivors. And so it's in um their
from their perspective as I guess um not
the first person and not the third
person but like we and then um number
five is service details. So, this is
like what we talked about if there's
going to be a funeral or um a spreading
of a service to spread the ashes or
whatever. And if there's going to be a
celebration of life for or a memorial at
a later time, I would encourage you to
put that too that it will be scheduled
later cuz that's something that people
who are dealing with um the who mourning
the death like in the moment or
contemporary mourers that's something
that they want to know is you know how
can I go to the grave or is there a
funeral or a memorial service where I
can pay my respects.
So, I shared with you all a handout. And
so, this is kind of a takeaway that
you'll have to refer back to after our
webinar here is done. And so, um, maybe
you have it printed out. Um, maybe you
just have it on your computer, but I
have a screenshot of it here. And,
um, Jonathan is also putting a link to
it on Google Drive in the chat. So, you
can click on that link and then download
it from there if you would like.
And so on this on the front page of this
handout, there's this colored table that
has a lot of details for the kind of
information you can decide to include in
your obituary.
And this is adapted from one of the
books that we recommend that you can use
to guide your writing of an obituary. So
it's adapted from Laura Brown. And I
want to encourage you just to take a
moment to go through this and determine
what you think would be valuable
information that you would include in
your obituary. So if you have a printed
one, maybe you can just circle or star
the things that you think are important.
Um, if you have a digital one, maybe you
can just look at it and jot down on your
on your notepad or your note paper what
you think is important. So I'll give you
a couple minutes to look through that.
There's basically
um about uh six sections. There's the
basics of the name announcement and then
that's kind of in green if um if you can
see colors the green top left portion.
Then there's this middle purple left
portion survived by. So these are the
kinds of people that you might want to
mention. And then there's on the bottom
left in the blue section there's
predesceased by. So the people who have
died before you and then uh going over
to the right column there's the facts of
your life. So when you were born um
important milestones stuff like that
kind of that's where the biography is
and then there's the service port part
the middle the yellow part in the middle
on the right and then the closing which
is the bottom right.
So feel free to put any
reflections you have about this and what
you would include and not include in the
chat and I'll be looking looking through
to see what you all are And
Um, I I'm loving the feedback that
everyone's been putting in the chat. Um,
hopefully I'll get a chance to boost it
all. But I like Daniel's question if
it's appropriate to address the darker
instances of our lives or if we should
only have the good things. And that's
totally up to you. But I have some
examples that we're going to look at uh
uh in a little bit where we get a mix of
the good and the bad and the honest. And
so you can see uh the effect that it has
and and what you think of it.
And Daniel also has a question about
celebration of life services. Do they
need to be announced? And what if you
want to keep it private? Yeah, I think
you could just mention that they'll be
um a private service with close friends
and family only or something like that.
Um, or you could just leave it out and
then replace that with something about
if you want to make a a memorial
donation, do so to this place and this
honor um in in the honor of the deceased
or whatever.
And Christy mentions that she would love
to add add places that she loved to
travel or visit to. And I have a longer
form that does ask that kind of
information that uh we'll get to towards
the end as well. This is kind of like
really the basics.
Yeah. And so I think so thank you all
for um giving your feedback. And Brenda
Grant, can an obituary be too long? It's
like that joke too long didn't read,
right? Um I guess it's a good question.
If it's published online, there's no
such thing as too long because it's just
digital ple pixels and it you don't have
to pay per line. But if you're paying in
a newspaper, yeah, probably you don't
want to spend like five grand on your
obituary or whatever. Um, but I think
that at some point a really long
obituary that you wrote yourself crosses
over into memoir. And so, um, maybe if
it is really long, just think about
writing your memoirs instead.
Um, so we just did this. You looked at
the handout and decided what would be
important information. And if you have
more questions about that as we go
forward, please feel free to put them in
in the chat.
Um, Daniel mentioned AI is a great help
for too long and I have uh some
anecdotes about that as well that I hope
we have time to get to.
All right. So now the question of where
to publish. I already kind of hinted at
the difference between publishing online
versus publishing in a paper. So this is
kind of the snapshot of the situation
right now. So there's local and national
newspapers. And so, uh, for example, in
our area in San Francisco specifically,
the two main newspapers that are printed
still besides the little local papers,
the neighborhood papers are the San
Francisco Chronicle and the San
Francisco Examiner. The San Francisco
Examiner does not print obituaries in
the print paper anymore, but they do
have a website, which we'll talk about
later. So the San Francisco Chronicle is
really the only place that you can get a
print obituary published related to
specifically San Francisco. And I'll
talk about some other regional options
later. Then there's these um digital
hubs that aggregate or or syndicate
obituaries from print papers. So
legacy.com is a great example of that.
And so if you publish an obituary in the
San Francisco Chronicle, it also gets
published online on the legacy.com
website. And other um newspapers in the
area do something similar, but maybe not
with Legacy. And then the third node is
funeral homes and memorial sites. So, if
you have gone through a funeral home or
a mortuary and you've purchased that
package, they're going to put up um a
memorial for you on their website, which
will include an obituary and a guest
book and stuff. And also, if you book it
books um your take care of your remains
through a cremation service, a lot of
those have a website as well. And so,
but with all of these aspects, you have
to think about longevity and what is
going to be perpetually preserved. So
from a library perspective, we are very
obsessed with preservation and stable
mediums. And so if um you are publishing
something in a online format only, you
have to think about is this going to be
preserved for 100 years. So there's
these questions of you know electricity
and the internet and stuff like will we
even recognize the world in 100 years in
terms of being so computer oriented as
it is now. Um, but then there's also
questions of just like in a capitalist
system, um, a a funeral is a funeral
home is a business. Um, legacy.com is a
business. What if they go bankrupt? What
if they don't support their website
anymore? Will we lose all of these
obituaries? So, you know, the
genealogical tool ancestry, um, it has a
lot of obituaries in it. And it's a tool
that we use when we're looking up
obituaries for our service that we
provide. And there's this whole data set
of obituaries that were loaded into
Ancestry in like the early 2000s from a
website that no longer exists. So
sometimes I'll find a record to an
obituary for someone that I'm looking
for and then when I try to click the
link, it doesn't go anywhere. And so
already within the last 25 years, we've
seen link rot happen with online
obituaries. And so that's why we like to
say a newspaper has more permanence. So
from a library perspective, we are
committed to preserving and providing
access to our local newspapers because
they're an important information source
for the community. Um, in terms of the
San Francisco Chronicle, we have it on
microfilm from 1865 when it started
through 2021, but then starting in 2021,
we only have it in digital replica
through a database called NewsBank. But
we're committed as much as we can to
always keeping that NewsBank
subscription going and hopefully if
something ever happened to NewsBank, we
could transfer all those files over to a
new platform and continue providing
access. Um, but we do have other
microfilm of other newspapers that we
continue to get up until the current
day. So we do what we can based on our
constraints and and because of all that
we tend to think of newspapers as more
of a stable medium even though they
don't they can't reach as far and wide
as a website.
So in terms of where you can do it in
the Bay Area u we already talked about
the San Francisco Chronicle. The San
Francisco Examiner has a free website
where you can or it's a website where
you can put obituaries for free. That's
also on your handout that I'll point out
in a little bit. Then there's the Bay
Area News Group. So that's the publisher
of the Marin Independent Journal, the
East Bay Times, the San Jose Mercury
News, and other ones. So each one costs
a little bit different, but um you can
go through their website, and there's
links on the handout, and you can price
it out. And so like I like it says on
the handout generally we recommend
publishing an obituary in the place
where the person spent the majority of
their life or the most the local the
most prominent paper of the general
region. So, I had a colleague whose
father just passed away in Fairfield.
And so, it's kind of in the greater Bay
Area, but he's looking into publishing
an obituary in the local Fairfield paper
kind of as an announcement to um to the
community members over there who might
still read the newspaper. And then, you
know, the last option is just the online
legacy um that we already kind of talked
about.
So, get ready to have your pocketbook
blown away because this is not cheap. Um
the the very basic print obituary for
the San Francisco Chronicle starts at
$299
and that doesn't even include a picture
and it's less than $130 words. So when
we were talking about length and if
length how how length matters. Yeah, it
matters a lot. Um so it can go up to
four columns can can be up to 600 start
at $600 and it goes on from there. Then
the Bay Area News Group, the one that
does, you know, indep the Marin
Independent Journal, San Jose Mercury
News, etc. Um, their pricing is kind of
is a different model, but it also starts
it's pretty high as well.
And so these are all little bit of
research that you'll have to do and
decide. And just um and each one has an
interactive
uh editor on their on their web form.
And so as you type the obituary or paste
it in, you'll see, oh, it's going to
cost this much. You can delete some
lines. Oh, now the price went down. So
you can really fine-tune it that way.
So I'm going to go back to the handout
and just point out that on the back side
of the handout is where we have this
section places to publish. So, uh, all
this stuff that I just talked about is
linked here and you can go directly to
the order, um, the the order portal and
you could play around there. I will say
I created an account with the Marin
independent journal and was playing
around just to try to get some pricing
and then I abandoned it cuz I don't
obviously want to do my obituary yet.
And then somebody from their sales
department reached out pretty fast to be
like, "Hey, is there anything I can help
you with?" and I was like, "Yeah, I'm
doing a program for the library. Can you
tell me how much it costs?" And so
that's kind of how I got the the figures
that I was able to include. Um, but you
know, it's all here. And so they're
they're pretty responsive. It's a money
maker for the for the local newspapers.
And so that's the other thing like I'm
obviously a big supporter of newspapers.
I'm a magazines and newspapers
librarian. And so to me, it's also like
this little way that you can support the
newspaper because it's like taking out a
classified ad and giving them some
money. And so, um, you know, maybe it
shouldn't be a subsidized service, but
you know, maybe it kind of helps them a
little bit, too.
So, feel free to put in the chat what
your thoughts are. Are you going to
spring for a newspaper and have it
immortalized in print, or do you think
you're just going to do the online
version? You think I'm just going to put
it in the package with my funeral
package, or what are you thinking that
you'll do? I'll be uh really interested
to hear your perspective on it.
I'm also curious if anything has changed
for you through the course of this. So,
I've been talking to you and we've been
doing activities for about 40 minutes
now. And so, did did you decide did you
have anything changed in your mind of
what you want to do? So, I would love to
hear about that in the chat as well. So,
I see some chats coming through. So,
let's take a look.
Oh, Angelita has a good good question.
Any idea of how and where to send your
obituary to a different state or another
country? I think you would have to do
some research on what newspapers are in
that country and if they offer an
obituary service. Um, we have a platform
that we offer through the library called
Press Reader and it has newspapers from
all over the world in it. And so, um, if
you email MNC at sfpl.org and ask about
presser, I can give you some
information. But that would be a good
way to see what kind of newspapers are
in different areas. And also, Legacy to
me is pretty much like in the English-
speakaking world, it's like anybody who
has an English language obituary, you
see it on Legacy. Uh, so I see ones from
other countries there too, like Ireland
or whatever.
Um, but maybe there's local ones for
different countries or maybe Europe
there's some sort of legacy
version for European or maybe similar
for South America, but it's a good
question. We'd have to just look a
little bit into it.
Mary says she was going to leave it up
to her survivors. So yeah, just put that
on them.
And Marina said she's planning on doing
part of her funeral package and the SF
Chronicle. Go Marina. I feel the same
way. Um I recently told my significant
other, make sure that you publish my
obituary in the San Francisco Chronicle
when I die because um to me that's like
the gold standard or whatever. And
Sylvia says she would do their crown,
too.
Um,
yeah. So, Rosalyn says that many
families are keeping it private and only
sharing with family, relatives, and
close friends. And honestly, I feel like
that's a really that's like really
disappointing. Um, I know that we kind
of view death as being a private uh
situation, but you never know like the
distant acquaintances that your person
that you lost their lives that might
have been touched. And um, just also for
the public record of like these
genealogy researchers in 100 years or
whatever. Um, so that's kind of sad to
me a little bit because like we get a
lot of requests for obituaries in our
department and we do everything we can
to find any trace of somebody and we
can't even determine that the person
even died for sure. And so you I think
you can't even always estimate um the
thirst for information that will be out
there after someone passes.
Um
so get a lot of good feedback. Thank you
very much. And um some other comments.
Um I just want to be make sure that we
have time for the rest of everything
else. So I'm going to keep the chat
going. Please feel free and I will
hopefully be able to return to it in a
little bit.
But I have some examples that I'm
excited to share with you from just
reading the paper and also doing our
obituary lookup service. So, here's an
example of one. So, these are all from
the San Francisco Chronicle from the
life tribute section. And um a lot of
them will go to the database and we'll
actually look at them. And Jonathan will
put the links in the chat, too, so you
can see what it looks like in the
chronicle and how to get to it from the
libraryies subscription.
But this is kind of like the most basic
one you can do. It's got a picture and
it's this really short like about 60word
snapshot of this person's life. It has
the basics, you know, where they lived,
where they died, when, when, where, who,
you know, the family that he left
behind. And then in terms of the
biography or like the about, it just
says, "As a teacher, poet, and
translator, Nick deeply touched many
lives." And then to drive the point home
and to give that place where people can
donate, it says, "To honor Nick's
memory, a new literary word has been
created in his name." And this is where
you can donate the money to. And so, um,
if you want to follow the links that
Jonathan is putting in the chat, you'll
have to have your library card number
and your PIN ready. Um, but and then
you'll be able to connect to the
NewsBank database and see what it looks
like in Sichu.
So, this one here, I estimate would cost
about $500 to run one time in the San
Francisco Chronicle. And then, of
course, it would also appear on the
legacy.com website.
So, here's a second obit. I'm going to
click through to the database so that we
can actually
zoom in on it and take a look.
So, here's the full page of life
tributes.
And here is the one we're going to look
at, Margaret Sherman Zukin. So, let me
zoom in here.
Okay, so here she is. Uh, first of note,
there's two pictures. So, there's her as
a young person and her as an older
person. And that's a decision you'll
need to think about as well. What
picture do you want to include? And if
you want to do one or two, obviously,
it's going to cost more to do two. But
maybe that's an important, you know,
thing to to illustrate the progression
of life. So, it starts out
straightforward enough. uh you know
where she was born, how she grew up,
where she went to college, how she met
her husband,
when they got married, where they lived,
all the kids that they had. But then we
get to this part that's a little bit
different.
So it says, "Like many young people at
that time, Peggy and Joe Joe enjoyed
drinking with friends at dinner parties,
and that was a lot of fun until Peggy's
drinking crossed the invisible line into
alcoholism. Her drinking became a
problem for the whole family until
finally she found AA and got sober on
May 29th, 1974, which opened a new
chapter in her life. So, I think this is
an example of content that could be the
bad maybe or something that a family
could be ashamed of and that would want
to be left out or pushed under the rug.
But in this case, as we continue to read
through her obituary, we find out it's
central to her life story. It caused her
to become a sponsor to help all these
other people through AA to become sober.
Then it led to a 18-year career as a
alcohol and drug counselor.
And and then it goes on, you know, to
describe these other things, places she
liked to travel. like Chrissy said, you
know, that's what is also really
important to people too. And so in this
case, um my question is, you know, if
she had left this up to her family to
write it after she passed away, would
they have included this important
information about her work in AA and
being a drug and alcohol counselor? Or
if she had did she tell them, make sure
you include this, they maybe drafted up
a little bit of something. So, if you
have something in your life that you
know maybe people will feel
uncomfortable including after you die,
but you feel like it's really important
to your story, make sure you provide for
that.
Okay, so here we are back to our
examples. Oh, by the way, that one I
estimate that one would cost um around
$1,200. probably maybe $900 to $1,200
cuz it's pretty long and it has two
pictures even though it's only two
columns.
Okay, so for the third example, uh we
I'm going to click through to this one
cuz it's very long too. So I think this
one might be another one of the
questions of how long is too long for an
obituary. So let me zoom out here. So
here I'm going to talk about this one.
Natalyia set and casillas.
So this is four columns and each column
is very long. And the thing that I want
to point out is let me zoom in right
away when we started.
My wife Natalia set and biny casilus
passed away on November 13th, 2025 after
at the age of 83 after a courageous
battle with heart disease. So as it goes
on, this is very much told from the
perspective of the widowerower, the
husband that she left behind. He just
has platitudes upon platitudes about
her. She was my rock, my sun, my moon,
my stars, my everything. Um, but then he
really gives a lot of body to the life
that they share together and her
personality really does come out. He
tells all of these stories about her
being on Hollywood squares and in the
opera community and blah blah and then
positions it within historic events like
in 2007 the iPhone burst onto the scene
and changed the world. And so in this
case, you know, this is another question
of perspective and the voice that it's
told in. So maybe she wanted her husband
to write this obituary from his
perspective telling his story of his
life with her. But do you think he
remembered all these details without her
helping or prompting him? So maybe even
if you want one of your survivors to
write her obituary, remind them, hey,
remember the time this happened?
Remember this, remember that? like
provide an outline or whatever and help
them write this really lively, full of
voice um obituary from their
perspective.
Now, this one I estimate will cost
between $13.90 and $1,800
because it's so long, but it's still
it's only four columns, but the more
columns the more expensive, but the more
words more expensive, so maybe even more
than that.
Okay. And then our last example, Jack
Floyd Schaefer. Let's take a look at
what that looks like in the database.
So, I'm going to zoom out here. So, this
one not too long. It's just this part of
the page, but let me point out to you,
this is from the May 29th, 2026
Chronicle. And whoops, let me zoom in.
But let me point out his death was in
2020. So this is one of the longest
periods in between the death and the
obituary that I've ever seen. And so it
kind of makes you wonder who was this
being published for and to serve what
end. Um but when we start reading it
immediately it says it is with heavy
hearts that the siblings of Jack Floyd
Schaefer announce his passing. Jack died
of COVID 19 at California Pacific
Medical Center. And then it goes on and
so um you know
I think that in in this case it's
sharing the basics of you know the
family that he left behind and they're
reminiscing about his childhood that
they the childhood that they all had
together, the love of um astronomy and
the telescope that he passed on to them.
even this joke that even they saw an
occasional UFO during summer's splint at
Clear Lake. And then they also make made
this joke about um he had the annoying
habit of cutting seized candy in half
and replacing it if the filling didn't
appeal to him, which was against all
family candy protocol. So there's some
levity and some um humor used in this.
Um but then it does go on to a little
bit of the darker aspect. So like Daniel
had asked. So um let me read this part.
Though we were estranged in the last
years of his life, we remember and honor
the qualities that made Jack unique. He
did not have an easy life. He was a
complex person with deep and diverse
sensitivities for whom the vicissitudes
of life presented challenges. And then
it goes on to say who um he who the
other people he survived by a quote from
one of the siblings. And then we find
out that they spread his ashes in 2022.
So, it's already been even four years
since they spread his ashes. So, this
one is just such an interesting example
to me because it's doing a lot of work.
Um, I feel like it's really for the
family to grieve and to and to move
forward. And it's almost like they're
saying, you know, to everybody out there
who's lost a family member and they
didn't have a perfect relationship, it's
okay. feel like you can still love the
person and mourn their their passing.
And so that's like a really beautiful
thing to share. So maybe that's
something that you'll want to think of
as well. And I would estimate that this
one will cost about $900 to publish.
All right. So those are my examples. I
had no historic examples. This historic
examples are pretty a little bit more
boring. um they're a little bit shorter,
but the the hunt for them on the
microfilm can be exciting.
So, kind of we're wrapping up. Um I do
have a little bit to uh say about using
AI to write an obituary. I don't think
I'll have time unless you want to stay
on after three. We can look at that a
little bit. Um but I'm going to kind of
do a wrap-up now and then we'll have
time for some more questions and I can
read some of your comments from the
chat. So in a nutshell, you know,
originally we think of a journalist is a
person who writes an obituary for famous
people, prominent people, or if you live
in a small community, that newspaper
might have had a journalist assigned to
the obituary beat. But as time
progressed now, it's something that
usually a grieving relative has to take
care of. And we also like to say when
people are asking us to find an obituary
and the death has been pretty recent. We
just explained, you know, the friends
and family are are mourning and it's a
very difficult time for them. There's a
lot to take care of and if the person
who passed away isn't wasn't good about
setting up their will and their estate
like I'm sure you all are, then that's
going to be even more stuff for the
survivors to have to do. And so the the
obituary might be the last thing that
they think of. So maybe the new era is
the era of self- authorship which is
where you come in where you can ensure
the accuracy of your life the voice that
you want to convey and also maybe give a
little bit of care to your morning
family members so that they don't have
to worry about it.
So the first step today we did a little
bit of drafting. So, we were able to do
the activities where you wrote down some
things. You have kind of two different
audiences that you can think about and
you can maybe do a little bit more
drafting now that you have a more out a
further outline or if you want to play
around with AI to do it, you'll get a
draft that way. And like I said, maybe
we could take a look after I take your
questions if you want to stay on a
little bit later. And then you really
got to secure the funds. So, we see that
this is a commercial service. The
newspapers are making money on this and
you're going to have to make sure that
you say, you know, in your will or your
estate documents, I'm leaving $1,000 to
publish my obituary in the San Francisco
Chronicle or, you know, however you want
to decide. And then whoever is the
executive of your estate, you'll just
want to make sure that they have those
instructions from you as well and that
your wishes are communicated.
So, I'm going to keep the AI thing to
the side for a moment. We'll come back
to it. Um, but on the the handout, we
also have some books that you can check
out. They're available as ebooks or in
print in the library. So, there's links
if you clicking on the digital version
of the handout. The link will take you
to the library catalog and you can
request it or access it.
And I just want to know how confident do
you feel about writing your own
obituary? Do you feel good about this?
Do is there more questions that you
have? Um, feel free to put them in the
chat or the Q&A function and we'll be
talking about those for the next couple
minutes till we end. And you're also
welcome to contact us at the magazines
and newspaper center. Um, Jonathan put
the link to our obituary lookup service
in the chat, but it's also linked off of
our website. This is the short URL for
it. And you can email us or call us.
There's a reference librarian at our
desk whenever the main library is open.
So, thank you all so much. I'm going to
stop sharing my screen just so we can go
through the comments.
So, some um feedback on these obituary
examples. So, that's cool. Thank you for
the feedback.
Yeah. So, Marina pointed out that from
time to time the SF Chronicle publishes
obituaries that are like commemorations
of a passing. So, that's possible too.
It's you go to their website, it's a
little bit different. It's um called a
memorial. So there's a life tribute
which is like an obituary and then
there's like I think it's called a
memorial and then that's a way that you
can um yeah commemorate a milestone
anniversary of a death.
Oh yeah, I forgot. Thank you Jonathan
for putting the funny obituary link in
the chat. Um, I forgot to mention that,
but when I was talking about your voice
can be heard, there's this New York
Times article that has funny obituaries.
Um, let me just show it really quick.
Let me share my screen. Hold on.
Okay. So, um, you can look at this on
your own. Um, you can also get the New
York Times for free through the library.
So, th this is ones that people wrote
themselves and it was just it's full of
humor. So, here's an example.
Hersan Maynard croked at the age of 90
years old on August 1, August 7th, 2021.
I wrote this obit and paid for it.
Um, then it go I think it goes on to
say, "I will be remembered for a while
by my family, all whose names I am by
far too cheap to list and a few friends,
too."
And it has a typo in it, too. So, really
authentic in terms of I always like to
say I don't mind typos anymore because
it shows that a real person wrote it and
not AI. Um, but then he goes, "I had a
pretty good life and everybody dies.
Bye-bye."
So maybe that's like your message to the
world after you die is just to inject
some humor into it. So feel free to read
the rest of that article. It's pretty
funny.
And then yeah, thanks for sharing that
link, Jerry. Um there's this video. It's
a documentary from the library
subscription, a canopy about obits from
the New York Times. So New York Times is
like the gold standard of obits. you
know, if you you know, you really had a
good life if if the New York Times wrote
writes an obituary about you because
you're, you know, a prominent New Yorker
or whatever. Uh, Sylvia, thank you so
much for the positive feedback. And
um,
Anna asks, "How to identify appropriate
journalists to write the document? And
also, do you have memoir writing
workshop?"
Well, I think if you were to have a
journalist write your obituary, it would
be a fee for service situation where you
would have to find somebody and contract
them to help you. Um, maybe even like a
ghost writing service. And I think that
we do have memoir and other writing
workshops. Um, we'll have to try to get
back to you about that and answer you.
They come and go and they're organized
by different department and also
different branch. If you have like a
branch library in your neighborhood, you
can ask directly to them about it cuz
they do their own programming and then
we do our programming at the main
library.
Um,
and Gloria says that she thinks she's
the one that can provide the true facts
and feelings of my life and of my own.
And so good. Gloria is empowered to
write her own. Oh, thanks Sherry. you uh
responded to Anna's question. There's a
memoir writing workshop on
the 1st of July. Perfect timing. Great.
So, if your obituary feels too long,
take this memoir writing workshop
instead. So, you're all very welcome. Um
if anybody wants to stay on, I can talk
about the AI thing for a minute. And
you're very welcome, Sharon.
Um so, if you if you want to head out,
that's totally great. Have a great rest
of your day. We'll send the recording
out later um probably tomorrow. But if
you want to stay on, let me show you
what I did playing around with AI a
little bit.
So,
okay, we're going towards the end. Here
we are.
Um, so a common thing that people are
doing a lot is using AI to help them
draft something. And there's pros and
cons to it. Um, I'm kind of very
lukewarm about AI cuz it always like
lets me down a little bit. But I have to
say that I played around with it for
this and I found it was pretty
interesting. Oh, and Jonathan, if you
need to go, I totally understand, too.
Um, so feel free to sign off. I can do
like the links and stuff, but if you do
want to stay, that would be great.
So, um, on our little handout here, I
have a link to on.sfpl.org/right-year-
obit. And this is a very long
questionnaire that you can use um, and
part of your prompt into the AI. And on
the back side of the handout, I have
some listed here, popular AI tools. So,
the two that are more general that
people really like for drafting text are
ChatGpt and Claude, but you can also use
Copilot or Gemini. The one that I used
was Copilot. Then there's one that's
specific to milestone events and
celebrations and it's called Celebrate
Ally. So, that one's um for if you need
help writing a wedding speech or an
obituary, you can use that one. And then
if you have arranged with a funeral home
for a package, then they have software
packages that have a AI obit writing uh
tool in them. And so you could ask about
that at your um cremation or obituary
service. So let me show you what I got
going on over here.
So this is the link um on your handout.
If you click the link to the AI prompts
and questionnaire, it's this. And it's
very long. It is
five pages including up to 142
questions. So, this could be like how
long is too long? So, you can answer as
little or as much of this as you want.
It's adapted from this guy who actually
um
who actually did this AI developed the
AI tool to do this and then he abandoned
the project and gave me permission to
adapt his questionnaire for our workshop
today. And so what you can do from this
page in Google Drive, you could just go
to file and then make a copy and then
you'll have a copy of it that you can
edit and then copy and paste into your
generative AI tool. So I had done it
earlier. I was playing around with it
and
um I just went this isn't actually like
the details of my life but I answered
some of the questions and pretended like
you know I was had lived a hundred years
and now I can look back on my life and
share my information. So, there was a
lot that I didn't answer and there was
um some that I did and then I just, you
know, said, "Okay, I'm going to add
whatever I want." And then I came up
with this prompt to put into
the tool. So, this is an example one.
The one in blue is the one that I
actually used. So, I told uh I told
Copilot, "Write three drafts of an
obituary with the answers to the
questionnaire I provide below. Make one
a short version no longer than 65 words.
Make another a longer version 200 words
in length. And make a third version 350
words in length. Do not invent details.
Use a factual tone that is slightly
celebratory and humorous. So you have to
really give it guard rails because the
AI will just go crazy sometimes with
like using s um just overly exaggerated
language and stuff. So that's why I said
do not invent anything and use factual
details. So I already did it, but I'm
going to show you live uh what you could
do. So almost all of them they start on
the the uh co-pilot chat GBT whatever.
They all kind of start like this where
there's just this text box. So I'm going
to put it in there. This was my prompt
that I just read to you all.
Now it's going to say, "Okay, I can do
it. I got I got the assignment. Lay it
on me. So now I'm going to go back over
here and
I'm just going to highlight all of this.
So
just wait a minute while I go through.
Okay, here we are.
Okay, copy that. I'm going back over to
Copilot. I'm going to paste it in there.
All right, it got my info.
Now it's thinking hard. It's going to
give me something really good. All
right, check this out. Short version.
Well, I won't read the whole thing to
all of them to you all, but you can see
there's a short version, the a medium
version, and a long version.
And even the long version, 350 words,
that's not that long. But um for someone
who's an AI skeptic, I was pleasantly
surprised by this. And I think also, you
know, being I'm be like half my life
right now. And so, um to project like as
a visioning experience almost of like
what I expect to accomplish by the time
I die and how long I want to live or
whatever. Um and then to put it in here,
it was almost it was like a weird Yeah.
like like a vision board or something
almost where I'm like that sounds really
good. I would be really pleased if
someone read about my life and found out
um that you know that I was also a
philosopher cuz I made up this detail
that after I retired I got a PhD in
philosophy and so um I don't know it's
just like pretty cool to see it
and um you know I could download this I
could go and copy and paste it from
Copilot and I think I did. Yeah. So, I
have it down here in my Google Doc. And
so, then I could start editing it and
make it better or worse or maybe put
some more of my voice and humor into it.
So, that's the little AI demo. I don't
know. Tell me, would you do would you
use AI to write your obituary? As a
writer, I'm kind of offended because I'm
like, I want to write my own obituary,
but it's kind of fun to fill out a
questionnaire and then have it do it.
Yeah, I like I like your uh skepticism
uh to both of you, NP and Anna
and Tommy. Yeah, you're gonna
you don't want to put your personal data
in it. That's really good. The the good
thing is the co-pilot that I can use
through my job with the city. It's
locked down. It's more protected.
There's things you can't do supposedly.
What we put in isn't shared. But you
never really want to share any of your
really personal information with it.
Yeah. I like I like your your all you
all have some really good criticism and
uh guidelines for what you would want to
use AI for and what you wouldn't. Yeah.
Supposedly, right? Yeah.
So, I made up a lot of those details
about myself. So, I wasn't really
telling AI. Some of it was true, but
some of it wasn't. So, all right. Thank
you all so much for coming. Uh, like I
said, feel free to email us or call us
if you have more questions and good luck
writing your obituaries.
Oh, get out there and do the work. Bye.
Have a great day.