Video summary
Dr. Stacy Sims argues that the health and fitness industry systematically fails women because medical research has historically relied on male physiology, leading to guidelines that ignore critical biological differences between XX and XY bodies. This oversight extends from in utero development through aging, affecting everything from genetic protections against miscarriage to unique hormonal profiles that influence cortisol responses and oxygen carrying capacity. Consequently, standard recommendations regarding heat exposure, cold therapy, nutrition timing, and supplementation often prove inappropriate for female physiology; for instance, women experience stronger sympathetic nervous system responses to extreme temperatures compared to men, making moderate sauna sessions more beneficial than ice baths or high-heat extremes. Furthermore, the industry's failure is evident in how it generalizes data without accounting for period-specific variations, leading to misinterpretations of blood tests and a lack of diverse research populations that include women with irregular cycles or from different ethnic backgrounds.
The core physiological challenges facing women are exacerbated by lifestyle choices that conflict with their natural metabolic rhythms, particularly during perimenopause when weight gain is driven not just by hormones but by a sympathetic nervous system shift that conserves energy under stress. Fluctuating sex hormone levels reduce gut microbiome diversity, promoting inflammation and the storage of visceral fat rather than burning fuel for energy, which often compels women into restrictive calorie counting or late-night fasting that further disrupts circadian rhythms and sleep cycles. To counteract this, Sims advocates for eating early in the day with adequate protein and fiber to stabilize blood sugar without phase-shifting sleep, while avoiding fasted training that increases cortisol production. Instead of ineffective moderate-intensity classes that induce stress without providing necessary adaptation stimuli, women should engage in true high-intensity interval training (HIIT) or power-based strength work using heavy loads at 80% intensity to stimulate neuromuscular connections and improve cognitive health through lactate production for the brain.
Beyond exercise intensity, proper supplementation and monitoring are essential for maintaining bone density, muscle mass, and overall metabolic health as women age. Dr. Sims recommends a consistent daily intake of creatine (3–5 grams) for all women to support brain function, heart health, and gut integrity, alongside adequate Vitamin D3 for immune regulation and mood management during perimenopause or PMS. While menopause hormone therapy can slow muscle loss and protect bone density, it does not stop visceral fat accumulation entirely, making the combination of heavy lifting—specifically compound movements like squats—and multi-directional impact exercises crucial for longevity and countering age-related myosin dysfunction. Women should also prioritize establishing baseline blood tests to track trends over time rather than relying on single snapshots that miss cyclical variations, including annual DEXA scans for bone density and regular ferritin checks if previously low, while remaining cautious about unregulated peptide markets due to potential contaminants and a lack of robust human trials.
Ultimately, the path forward requires women to take an active role in their health advocacy by seeking out knowledgeable physicians who specialize in female-specific issues like fertility or endurance athlete care rather than relying on generalized advice derived from male data. Patients are encouraged to empower one another, bring scientific articles to appointments, and clearly communicate their history within limited visit times to ensure they receive tailored guidance that respects their unique biology. By shifting focus away from calorie restriction and ineffective steady-state cardio toward a regimen of early morning nutrition, heavy resistance training, specific high-intensity intervals, and appropriate environmental stressors like cool water baths for inflammation management during conditions such as endometriosis, women can optimize body composition and cognitive function. This holistic approach not only addresses the immediate needs of aging but also fosters long-term resilience against age-related decline, ensuring that health strategies are built on a foundation of accurate science rather than outdated generalizations.
Read the full video transcript
I'm going to introduce our host, Mr.
Rich Roll.
>> How's everybody doing? Are you having
fun today?
I think this promises to be a
potentially life-altering conversation
with one of the world's most renowned
exercise physiologists and nutrition
specialists. So, without further ado,
let's welcome the wonderful Stacy Sims.
>> Thank you.
>> Stacy, what a delight to have you here
today. I'm so excited to talk to you and
I want to start
um with just uh
you know, the quote that gets the most
traffic. This thing that you constantly
refer to. This idea that women are not
small men. So, what do you mean by that?
What are you trying to communicate?
>> Yeah, I think um a lot of people don't
really understand like the biological
and physiological factors that make us
XX versus XY. Cuz from a cultural
standpoint, you go in any shop and then
you have like the men's section, the
women's section and it doesn't really
matter. Like you just go where you want
to go.
But when we're looking at scientific
research or we're looking at health
outcomes, we know that most of the
research in health and and sports
science has been done on men and
generalized women. Even small things
like aspirin for heart attack. There
were no women who were in the original
study. So, they were looking at men and
generalizing to women.
Uh same with osteoporosis research. So,
when we start going women are not small
men, it's because we as women deserve to
have research done on our bodies and our
physiology because the dose of the X
chromosome changes if you have a double
X versus an XY. And we see this from in
utero all the way through uh aging
processes and into death.
So, the women are not small men kind of
started as a funny when I was teaching
in the afternoon and trying to wake my
students up and I was teaching sex
differences in training principles and
practice and it's like women are not
small men and this is why in the
cardiovascular system. And then when I
started a sport nutrition company way
back, we started with a women's line and
the tagline was women are not small men
to differentiate and then that just
became a resounding mantra for so many
people.
>> How did we get here? Why is it that so
much of the fitness and dietary advice
that you see out there is really
oriented around men and not women?
>> This is This is more of a historical
kind of question to ask. If we think
about the origins of medicine and
science, women were not invited into the
room cuz they were as much as I love
Darwin, I also don't like him because he
said women had smaller brains.
And when we're looking at the origin of
scientific design, it was men in the
room and women weren't even thought of
as we need to include them because at
that point no one really thought that
women could be different. They were just
smaller versions of men.
So the origins of the scientific design
of medicine all came through the male
lens. But as we've progressed and
science has progressed, we realize that
that's not really adequate. So now we're
looking retrospectively, well, how do we
really look at women in a different
light? How do we really investigate
their physiology? So we're going back
and we're looking at methods. How do we
actually nail methods down to
accommodate for things like the
menstrual cycle? Even that isn't really
nailed down yet. We start looking at
it's 2026, we don't have an answer for
PCOS or endometriosis. Why? Because of
the patriarchal way that medicine and
science started and how ingrained it is
in all of society. So there is a little
bit of a push now, I shouldn't say a
little, a big push now to really look at
scientific methods and make sure that we
are including women not from a hormonal
status, but from a biological genetic
status of XX as well as how different
hormone profiles will affect the
outcomes.
>> So your sense is it is changing, maybe
not changing fast enough, but uh there
is change afoot.
>> Yes.
Yes.
>> Um what is
the main thing that
we need to understand about the
fundamental differences at play here
before we get into the specifics? Like
how is it and why is it that women are
different? What are those What are those
differences?
>> So one of the studies that I was talking
to Mary Claire about and she didn't even
know this and she is a OB is in utero,
we see that a woman who is pregnant with
a baby and XX or a boy baby is under
high emotional and environmental stress
will have a higher chance of miscarrying
than if she was carrying an XX because
we see that some of the genetic coding
that really protects an XX fetus is
driven by some of the epigenetic
stressors that the mom experiences. And
then after the baby is born, we think
that kids are pretty similar, but you'll
see through development there are just
inherent things that boys will gravitate
to versus girls.
And then when we look at puberty, the
changes that happen at puberty, we see
that girls with the epigenetic exposure
of their sex hormones, we see a shift in
our biomechanics. So women's heart or
hips will widen, their shoulder girdle
widens to accommodate for the widening
of the hips and that happens because in
a reproductive sense you need a wider
hips to have a baby. With that we also
see a really fast uh
lengthening of our extremities. So women
become more quad dominant and so they
have to really relearn how to do all the
fundamentals.
And this is one of the play factors of
why girls drop out of sport because
their body doesn't feel like themselves.
Whereas boys at puberty will get
stronger and fitter faster more
aggressive because of testosterone.
And then as we go through our
reproductive years, we have ultimate
changes in the reproductive years. No
one really has a regular menstrual cycle
and even within that there's variation
from month to month. If you're
traveling, if you're not, daylight, that
kind of stuff. Then we have things
hormonal contraception, IUDs, then you
might have PCOS and endometriosis, all
these things that affect women. But
inherently, even aging is different. We
know that not associated with hormones,
women have more dysfunction in one of
their proteins for muscle contraction
that makes them lose power and strength
early before they lose actual muscle
mass. Whereas men don't have that
dysfunction, they just lose muscle mass.
So when we're looking at aging from a
biological sex difference, we have to
really say, are you XY or are you XX?
Because the aging factors differentiate
not from a sex hormone decline, but
actually from what's happening from a
genetic code. And I mean, I could spend
the whole time talking about
cardiovascular system, how our lungs are
smaller, we have less hemoglobin, we
have less oxygen carrying capacity
uh from a sports standpoint. We also see
differences in mood and anxiety compared
to men and women under the same stress.
We also see that women become less uh
their bodies become less accommodating
for cortisol stress even if they're
exposed to the same stressor, whereas
men do. So they have less extremities of
cortisol peaks when they're stressed
with the same stress.
So it becomes this whole big thing of,
okay, it's becoming very complex. But if
we just kind of look at male and male
data, it'll be good enough. But it's
not.
>> Well, maybe the the easiest way into
this conversation is to start with a
very common question that a lot of women
face when they
enter perimenopause, which is
why is it that the things I used to do
are no longer working? Like, why is it
so difficult for me to like lose weight?
I'm gaining weight, and everything that
I used to do to manage my weight and my
well-being seems ineffective all of a
sudden.
>> Yeah, and this is um some new research
is coming out that's really interesting.
So, we're teasing out aging versus
what's happening in perimenopause. So,
we used to think that the symptoms
associated with perimenopause was just
based on hormonal dysfunction.
Cuz usually when you're thinking about
what's happening in perimenopause,
you're having more and more what we call
anovulatory cycles. So, if you don't
ovulate, then you don't produce
progesterone. So, you start to have wild
disruption in our ratios of estrogen and
progesterone. Why that is important is
because we have estrogen progesterone
receptors in every system of our body.
So, as I was saying at puberty, how
everything changes because of the
epigenetic exposure of estrogen and
progesterone, same thing is happening
cuz there's a wind down. And our body
becomes very sympathetically driven. The
other thing that happens with it is all
of our metabolism goes down. So, our
resting metabolism decreases, our sleep
metabolism decreases, the energetics
required for
bone and and bone turnover and muscle
turnover also decreases because the body
is under extreme stress. So, we see at
any point when the body is under extreme
stress, it starts to wind down its
metabolic processes. So, this this is
attributing to some of the weight gain.
We also see that about 4 years before
that one point in time of menopause,
there's an incredible decrease in our
gut microbiome diversity. Which then
exacerbates
the body's ability to store body fat
because we start having an overgrowth of
the phyla that is obesigenic or prefers
to grab all of the energy out of all the
food that we're eating and make you
crave simple carbohydrates.
>> What is the root cause of the microbiome
dysregulation?
>> This is your drop of your sex hormones
because we look at how sex hormones are
metabolized and distributed through the
body.
There's
a point where it is our sex hormones are
released and then they are bound with
sex hormone binding globulin to be
effective in their work. This is
excreted into the intestines through
bile and then unconjugated or taken off
the sex hormone binding globulin and
shot back out in circulation. So, our
gut bugs do that. As we start losing our
sex hormones or having wide variations
in estrogen and progesterone and to some
extent testosterone,
those gut bugs die off. And so, what
happens because the body is extremely
stressed and sympathetically driven,
the phyla that really thrives in those
stressful situations starts to overgrow.
And unfortunately, that is that
obesogenic phyla, which is why when we
start looking at what is one of the big
things that women can do is increase the
fiber and diversity in their diet to
make sure that gut microbiome diversity
stays.
>> And also downstream of this of these
hormonal shifts is
correct me if I'm wrong is this
signaling to the body that it needs to
conserve its fat and its energy stores,
right? So, in conjunction with
the the kind of microbiome changes is
that hormonal signaling that's that's
that's leading to a retention of that
like visceral fat and and belly fat.
>> Yes, and we know that estrogen is a very
strong anti-inflammatory agent. And so,
as that starts to decrease, we have a
conversation that is happening between
the liver and free fatty acids. And
because there is more inflammation in
the body, the way that the body responds
is
is to change the
molecular structure of free fatty acids
to make them what they're called
esterified. And esterified is stored as
a visceral fat. So, it's it's like we
have this very stressed body. We have
all these things that are happening
that's causing inflammation. Our main
driver anti-inflammatory responses is
decreasing. So then, the response is we
are in this tizzy, we have to be able to
conserve things, have extra fuel. So,
we're going to downregulate the things
that take a lot of of which is bone and
muscle. We're going to upregulate the
storage of things that will provide
fuel, which is fat.
>> And how uh does that evolve as women age
up into menopause from perimenopause?
>> So, it happens all across menopause. If
we don't do anything, we're going to
have significant body composition
change. We know that the like the peak
of all the changes is the 2 years before
that one point on the calendar called
menopause.
In postmenopause, early postmenopause,
we start to see some leveling out, and
then things start to get better on the
other side. You're not going to have any
real change in body composition unless
you make an active effort to do things
during perimenopause, and also when you
get to postmenopause. If you haven't
done anything, it's not too late.
So, we always look at an exercise stress
to create an adaptive response, as well
as what kind of nutrition we're putting
in to really support and kind of counter
all the negativity that's happening in
the body. Cuz we know that feedback
mechanisms and and some of the
adaptation mechanisms from exercise
stress really do increase
anti-inflammatory responses. Changes in
epigenetic
uh
protein or causes an epigenetic response
within the cells to be able to pull more
glucose in without insulin. So, there
are many, many things that we can do
without pharmaceuticals for the most
part to counter what's happening to the
body, to improve body composition and
mental health to carry women through
perimenopause and have a better baseline
at postmenopause and keep building.
>> Before we tease out some of those
specific counters,
what in your mind is the biggest myth or
misconception that gets
propagated out there about
uh this phase of life for women?
>> That it's something to be afraid of.
Because we see now that there is so much
fear factor in the marketing around it
like you shouldn't do high-intensity
exercise. You're going to get a cortisol
belly, you're going to break your bones,
you need to take this supplement, you
need to take MHT, you need to do all of
these things.
And in the reality
>> fragile.
>> Right. And you become fragile. And in
reality, it's we have to change that
conversation. It's like let's do the
basics. Let's hit the good sleep, the
exercise, the nutrition, the mindfulness
and community, and then we build from
there. But so many people will get so
afraid that they drop out of everything
that they're doing cuz one, they don't
know what the what's going on, and two,
they feel awful. They don't want to
exercise, and then they feel like
they're letting their friends down if
they're the slow person in the group, or
they're not motivated, or they had poor
sleep. So it's like let's change that
conversation. Empower women to
understand what's going on so they're
not afraid, and they can still keep
doing all the things they love, but with
modifications.
>> So we're going to talk about nutrition,
we're going to talk about fitness, and
then other just general uh daily
lifestyle habits. But these things all
overlap, like the Venn diagram overlaps.
But let's let's begin with nutrition.
You have a very specific kind of take on
how women should be eating
as they're, you know, inching into their
later decades. So what is your thesis on
this?
>> I've been doing a lot of um reading and
have some colleagues who are in the
chronobiological world of research.
And what I really want women to
understand is their circadian rhythm. So
men and women have different circadian
rhythms, where women's is a little bit
shorter than a man's.
And our circadian rhythm is tightly tied
to different hormone pulses. So hormones
don't rise and fall in a linear fashion,
they're pulsed out throughout the day.
So it's not only our sex hormones, but
it's our appetite hormones, it's our
thyroid, everything that is part of the
endocrine system.
So if we are doing something like
holding a fast till 11:00 or so, and we
are eating in a a small window cuz we'll
stop eating at 6:00 because then we want
to sleep well.
We have effectively phase shift our
circadian rhythm. Because the most
powerful ways that you can change your
circadian rhythm is light and dark and
food intake. So, if you wake up and
you're withholding food and maybe you're
exercising or not and you're going
through a stressful day, the body is
like,
"Wait, what's going on?"
So, we know that the hypothalamus comes
into play because when a woman wakes up
with her cortisol awakening response,
that peak is higher than a man's.
And with that comes um
acylated ghrelin, which is the active
form of our hunger hormone, and PYY,
peptide YY, which is appetite
suppressant. So, it's a counter.
If you don't have food, then with the
rise in cortisol, it kind of stays
elevated, which keeps that um acylated
ghrelin active. And the peptide YY can't
make you not feel hungry. So, the
hypothalamus is going, "Wait, wait,
what's going on?" So, then we start
having a cascade of responses that
starts to downregulate things like your
incidental movement. We see less
incidental movement. We see more of the
walling in the afternoon. We see more of
a craving for simple carbohydrate in the
afternoon cuz your body feels like it's
in this such a fatigued state. And then
in that smaller window of eating that
women are holding a fast,
um they aren't necessarily getting all
the micronutrients they have. But then
we also see from population research for
those people who hold a fast later, they
end up with no metabolic control that a
fast is supposed to give them. So, when
we start looking at how should women
eat? It's like, let's work with the
circadian rhythm. We know that you want
to eat within a half an hour or so as
you wake up. It doesn't have to be a
large meal, but just enough to bring
blood sugar up and signal that yes,
there's some nutrition coming on. Then
we look at having protein and fiber at
every eating opportunity. So, that's at
every meal, every snack. We want to stop
eating with dinner. Don't eat after
dinner so that you have a good two two
three hours before bed. And then you
have your overnight sleep where you're
having all your reparation. So, if we're
thinking about fasting, if you don't eat
at 7:00 or you stop eating at 7:00, and
then you wake up at 7:00,
and then you don't have breakfast till
7:30 or 8:00, you're looking at a 12, 12
and 1/2, 13-hour fast, time-restricted
eating. So, you're getting the benefit
of having a break from eating as you are
going into night, which is beneficial.
It's how your body works. But, then
you're not interfering with key signals
throughout the day that your body relies
on to be able to overcome stress and be
stress resilient, to have cognition and
focus, and to be able to understand what
an exercise stress is and recover from
it. Um so, I think that there's this
whole disconnect of like, I need to fast
and hold calories because I've heard
about all this stuff how fasting helps
with the autophagy and helps with
parasympathetic and telomere length and
metabolic control, but that's for male
data. So, when we start looking at the
female data and looking at
chronobiology, we see that the best way
a woman can eat is according to eating
during the day, fueling at hand, and
then having that break overnight. So,
we're not phase shifting, we're not
going to bed with an a full stomach
where we can't get into a deep sleep,
and we are actually able to follow that
rhythm, which it improves our oxidative
capacities, it improves our
anti-inflammatory capacities, and by the
way, it improves our sleep.
>> How does everything you just shared
correlate with a woman's age? Does this
become more acute the older that you
get, or do these principles apply across
the board irrespective of age?
>> Well, the circadian rhythm doesn't
change with age, but what does change is
sleep and sleep architecture.
So, the biggest problem that a lot of
women have when they hit their 40s
onwards is sleep and having a lot of
difficulty sleeping. And we see, yeah,
there's a
change in serotonin and melatonin
production, partly because of gut bug
changes, but also we become more
sympathetically driven. So, we're really
trying to improve sleep, then we want to
really pay attention to what we're doing
in the day. Because if you're eating
well in the day and front-loading
calories, then you aren't going to be
sympathetically driven and unable to get
into a parasympathetic response for good
sleep. Why do we want good sleep?
Because we can't have any kind of
metabolic or body composition change if
we have poor sleep.
And that's the biggest limiting factor,
especially when when we get into
perimenopause, with changes in body comp
and the inability to sleep, and then
they're fighting back and they're trying
fad diets, or they're trying to hold a
fast, and that's interrupting sleep even
more, which becomes this big cascade of
events where it's like just hold up.
Let's look how the body works. Let's
look at that circadian rhythm. Let's
work on sleep. Because once we get sleep
nailed down, become more stress
resilient, your body can start making
changes.
>> It seems like those principles would
apply to men, also.
>> You would think, right? But, we see that
phase shifting is more difficult in men,
because they are not as sensitive to
calorie changes and nutrient density as
women are.
Uh I pull uh
a lot of the examples out of what we
call low energy availability, which is
really high in active women and men.
And we see that the calorie
kind of intake bare minimum for women
before they start have dysfunction is
around 30 calories per kilogram of
fat-free mass, but for men it's 15. So,
we're looking at the baseline level for
our nutrient needs, it's different. So,
men can hold a fast, and they're not
going to get dysregulation, they're not
going to have necessary changes in their
pulses, because it's not as strong of a
stimulus for change as it is as it is
for women. It becomes more of a
protective factor from a biological
standpoint if there isn't a lot of
nutrition around, women's bodies start
to really conserve.
>> Right. So, the translation is basically
if men are undergoing some kind of
fasting protocol, intermittent fasting
or whatnot, they're able to lean out and
still maintain or build lean muscle
mass, whereas women's bodies the signal
is conserve and so they're going to
retain
uh they're going to retain that fat. So,
the fasting is at cross purposes with
the aim.
>> Right.
Granted, of course, there are outliers.
Like, if you have a a really
significantly obese woman, then fasting
can be beneficial cuz they're trying to
get control and see we see that um
fasting can be more beneficial than
severe calorie restriction. But, when do
we break the fast is the question,
right? So, if we're looking at a woman
who is obese and trying to get control,
it's not breaking the fast late, it's
breaking the fast early and then having
the fasting window or the eating window
in the day and then stopping eating at
like 4:00. So, you have a longer
overnight fast. It's not about working
in the in the morning because even in
women who aren't active, they still have
this circadian disruption.
>> Yeah, that was my question. I mean,
obviously, if you're obese, uh that's a
you know, set up for a cascade of all
kinds of lifestyle ailments. Um and I
can understand why a fasting protocol
would be efficacious in that regard, but
what about like how much of this is
applicable to someone like yourself who
is super fit, very active versus, you
know, the average 40-plus or 50-plus
year-old woman who, you know, does
enough here and there, but also is, you
know, working full-time and is a mom and
has all of these other kind of stressors
or or pressures in their life. Like, is
there
a use case where fasting might be
beneficial from your perspective or are
you taking it off the board?
>> I'm taking the traditional idea of
holding your fast till 11:00 or 12:00
off the board.
Um and that is I'm like I look like I'm
really super fit and everything, but I'm
not. I'm the mom who's rushing around
and have a really hard time like
maintaining my mass. I don't have a lot
of time to train. But no, across the
board it's like
>> Suns out, guns out, Stacy.
>> Yeah. No, I got harassed last weekend
because I wore jacket on stage and
people like, "Where are your arms?" I
didn't know it was a thing.
Um but no, if we're looking at like the
traditional case that I have that will
come see me and say, "I I really really
need help." is a woman who is in her
mid-40s, has two kids, super busy,
having intermittent sleep issues, highly
stressed, um exercises when she can.
She's trying to, you know, eat clean, do
all the things and she's like, "Help."
But then it's like she leans into it's
really easy not to eat first thing in
the morning cuz I'm so busy. I have a
training session with my friends or I go
to the gym at 5:00 and I get home at
6:00 and then I get the kids up and get
them out the door and then I have
meetings and emails and then it's like
10:00 before I've had any food. The very
first thing that I do is like, "Let's
re-examine the morning." Yes, I'm not
going to have you have a full meal
before you go work out at 5:00 or 6:00
in the morning, but let's have
something, something really small. We
know that Abby Smith-Ryan, who's a
researcher at UNC, has done research in
this and shows that just 10 g of protein
before strength training program
significantly helps avoid phase shift
and improves exercise adaptations. If
you're going to do cardiovascular type
work like a strength a circuit or
putting in some Metcon in there, adding
30 g of carbohydrate to that does the
same thing. So, we just look, it's like
how do we support the body in the times
of stress where it actually needs
nutrition.
Because then we're avoiding any kind of
phase shift and when women start to
adopt that and even even if it is just
the infamous protein coffee, they're
like, "Oh my gosh, I feel feel in my
workout. I have more clarity in the day.
I have energy. Then when the 3:00 slump
comes, I'm not craving simple
carbohydrates. I can actually reach for
something that's good so that when I get
home, yeah, I'm stressed and I'm tired
from the day, but I'm not at that
tipping point where I just can't deal
anymore. So, it becomes really important
for the normal, really highly stressed
woman to acknowledge the fact that not
eating is not good. It doesn't make you
stress resilient. It actually
exacerbates the condition.
>> But you can imagine the vicious cycle
of, oh my goodness, I'm putting on
weight. I'm working out more than I used
to and I still can't seem to manage
this.
Uh so, I'm going to eat less or I'm
going to skip breakfast or and then, you
know, that impairs appetite control
later in the day and you have all these
sort of, you know, kind of energy um
lulls, etc. and you're just compounding
the problem.
>> 100% See it all the time, especially in
the the age group of women who are in
mid to late perimenopause,
postmenopause, that grew up with the
supermodels and the Kate Mosses and the
ideal that skinny is best. And I hear
the rhetoric all the time, I'm just
trying to lose weight. But in order to
lose weight in a highly stressed
situation or not even a highly stressed
situation, you need food. So, when I
tell people, you actually need to eat
more to lose weight. We need to look at
the quality and not volume of training.
You actually need to eat more. And it's
a mind switch. And people like, what? I
need to eat more? I'm like, yes, but
it's not like calories. We don't talk
about calories in, calories out. We talk
about the quality of the food and the
timing of the food. And once we start
getting that in place, then the body
composition changes.
>> In the Stacy Sims hierarchy of needs
though, sleep, it seems, is at the top
of that pyramid.
>> Mhm.
>> Nutrition and exercise can inform your
sleep hygiene, but first things first,
you got to dial in your sleep.
>> Yep.
Yes, you do.
>> Um one of the things you you have also
said is that women are often more
metabolically flexible than men. So,
what does that what does that mean?
I mean, you're you're dancing around it
in everything that you've just shared,
but maybe just drill down on that
concept.
>> So, when we talk about metabolic
flexibility, this is where a lot of the
zone two stuff came out. Like, we need
to be able to train our bodies to burn
more free fatty acids.
And we look that there is This is where
we have sex differences, not hormone
factors. Sex differences that occur
within the muscle itself. So, women are
born with more of the endurance type
fibers, so our our slow twitch fibers.
We're also born with more mitochondria,
protein for mitochondria respiration,
that So, that means a more robust
ability to use free fatty acids.
Um, this is why we see women can go
really long and slow without so much
fuel. Men, on the other hand, are born
with more fast twitch and glycolytic
fibers. And so, they actually have to do
more of the long slow training to
enhance their fibers to be able to build
more mitochondria, to be able to use
more free fatty acids. The other thing
is when we look at our reproductive
years for women, they go through times
of relying more on carbohydrate versus
relying more on fat, depending on
ovulation and progesterone. Because
after ovulation, the body is taking a
whole bunch of carbohydrate to grow this
really lush uterine lining in case an
egg is implanted. So, we have more
glycogen being stored in the uterus than
we do in the muscles.
So, when we start looking at
carbohydrate versus fat and exercise
adaptations of carbohydrate versus fat,
women are already metabolically flexible
by the nature of the sex hormone coming
into play.
So, when we start looking at metabolic
flexibility and the issue with that,
it's should we be telling every woman
that we need to be doing zone two to
improve free fatty acid metabolism? Not
necessarily. Because we already are
metabolically capable of using those
free fatty acids. Do we need it to
become more metabolically flexible?
Well, actually, no, cuz our body is
already metabolically flexible. It's
learned that. We start having hormone
dysfunction. Yes, there is an uptick of
not being able to use carbohydrate very
well, becoming more insulin resistant.
But, if we do the right kind of
exercise, then we are creating an
environment where we become more
metabolically flexible and can use that
carbohydrate really well.
So, this is where we start getting into
how old are you? You're not getting any
change. What you're doing isn't working
for you. So, yeah, let's look at how we
can can modify what you're doing to
create an exercise stress that's
actually going to create an adaptation
the way hormones used to support or the
way that your training used to. We just
have to look at what that stress is.
>> With the FIFA World Cup 26 coming up
this summer, I have been thinking about
the ripple effect of something like
that. Thousands of people traveling,
showing up in new cities, looking for a
place to land, which got me thinking
about something pretty practical. When
you're away from home, whether it's for
travel, work, or just getting out of
town, your space is just sitting there,
and listing it on Airbnb is a simple way
to make some extra income while you're
gone. Doesn't have to be complicated.
You can list your entire place or even
just a room, whatever fits your
situation. And with an event like the
FIFA World Cup 26 bringing visitors from
all over the world, there's real demand
for places to stay. It's one of those
small shifts in thinking, turning
something you already have into
something that works for you. If you've
ever thought about hosting, this summer
is a great time as we welcome FIFA World
Cup fans. Your home might be worth more
than you think. Find out how much at
airbnb.com/host.
If you're a creator or even just someone
with an idea, building something online
has probably crossed your mind. A blog,
a podcast, of course, or maybe even a
membership community. But, where to
begin? I'm not a designer. I don't know
how to build a website. I can't afford
to pay someone else to do it all for me.
Forget about all that, says Squarespace.
Take a seat. Relax. I got you. Because
I, Squarespace, am an all-in-one
platform that takes all the complexity
and unaffordable cost out of building a
beautiful website. Their design tools
are especially powerful. You can start
with professionally designed templates
and customize everything with intuitive
editing tools, so your site actually
reflects your voice and your brand. And
if you create content, videos, articles,
courses, Squarespace makes it easy to
organize everything into a polished
library, and even put premium content
behind a paywall to create recurring
revenue.
Plus, you can stay connected with your
audience using built-in email campaigns
that look just as good as your site.
Head to squarespace.com/richroll
for a free trial, and when you're ready
to launch, use offer code richroll to
save 10% off your first purchase of a
website or domain.
So, a little over 9 months ago, I
underwent spinal fusion surgery. And
since then, my focus has shifted away
from chasing these really big, audacious
performance goals, like I did in the
past, to now accepting my limitations in
this current reality, and learning how
to build a daily rhythm that actually
feels sustainable for where I'm at right
now, today. And Whoop, this wearable
health and fitness coach that you see
right here on my wrist, every time you
see me, is this amazing tool that gives
me insights into all the things that
influence how I feel and how I perform.
My sleep, my recovery, my strain, and my
overall health, so that I can better
understand how my habits are influencing
how I feel. And what's interesting is
how these insights translate beyond
training. Better sleep changes improve
how I show up at work. Recovery changes
how patient I am with my family. And
when I'm planning for bigger goals, like
lining up to participate in the New York
City Marathon to celebrate my 60th
birthday this fall, Whoop helps me stay
grounded in what my body needs right
now, not what my ego wants it to do, or
what I used to be able to do. And I
think that's really what adding more
life to your years means, making
decisions today that allow you to show
up more fully tomorrow. Go to
join.whoop.com/roll
for 1 month free of Whoop.
>> Let me just back up and say, uh
basically
uh on this idea of like a cascade of
wrongs, like you know, you're in this
phase of life, what you're what you have
done in the past isn't working. You're
off your rhythm in terms of what you
need to be doing nutritionally,
uh but you're kind of you know,
literally and figuratively on this
treadmill where you're just upping the
cardio because that's the solution to
the weight gain problem, right? And so,
the nutrition's off, the sleep's off,
but but you know, you're doubling down
on all you know, like the orange theory
and the F45 and like all of these kind
of like fitness classes.
Um what say you,
Dr. Stacy Sims?
>> So, I'm going to preface it with any
movement is good movement, right? And I
come from it from how do we optimize?
So, if I'm looking at a woman whose
journey is I'm just going to start
exercising cuz I'm having all these
changes and I don't know what to do.
Then, yeah.
Do what you love. But, if we're looking
to optimize, we want to make sure that
we're really polarizing the exercise.
So, this is where we're very specific in
our interval and our interval training.
We're very specific in the type of
strength training we're doing.
>> Mhm.
>> Because we know that any beginner is
going to get massive gains, but as you
are more and more trained, you have to
really look at what kind of stress
you're putting on the body to get
absolute change.
So, if we're looking at someone who has
been a lifelong exerciser and has been
doing lots of running, doesn't really
like strength training, starts to have
body composition change, and it's like,
"Oh, I need to do some high intensity
work." And her friend goes to F45, "Hey,
come join me." And this is the first
time she's ever done any kind of
strength training or anything like that.
She might, in the first couple of
months, see some change, but after that,
it's not there's nothing there's going
to be no change because it's not truly
high intensity work. So, we're looking
at an F45 or an OrangeTheory, you're
sitting 45 minutes at an intensity that
isn't high intensity. It feels that way
cuz we've all been conditioned to come
out of a workout feeling really sweaty
and wasted. But, that's not effective.
And I say that because when we look at
the intensity needed to invoke change
has to be really, really strong. This is
a survival mechanism for the body. So,
if we're looking at high intensity
exercise, 45 minutes is really moderate
intensity. So, it's not hard enough to
be hard to invoke change. It's not easy
enough to be easy for recovery. It's
just kind of put you in the middle.
So, then we start to see an increase in
cortisol, we don't have a post-exercise
response for growth hormone, and we
don't have a post-exercise
anti-inflammatory response.
We are sympathetically driven, so that
doesn't help with sleep. It becomes uh a
continuation of the problem that we
already have. So, when we start looking
at optimization, we have to look at,
okay, high intensity interval training
is really good when we do it right. So,
the Norwegian 4 by 4 that everyone talks
about, 4 minutes at about 80% where
these 4 minutes feel like 4 hours. And
then your 4 minutes recovery where
you're like, "Gosh, that felt like 4
seconds." Because we're really working
to one develop lactate, which is really
important for brain health. But two, we
want more metabolic control. So, if
we're holding a threshold um intensity
for 3 to 4 minutes, then our body's
like, "I need carbohydrate." So, it
creates a response within the muscle and
in the cells to what we say translocate
GLUT4 protein. So, it's taking proteins
from within the cell, it's pushing to
the cell wall to open up the cell wall
so carbohydrate can come in without
insulin.
And if we do the stimulus enough, then
we are reducing our insulin resistance.
Because now the body has more of these
proteins, understands carbohydrate
glucose can come in without having to
rely so much on insulin.
And when we look at lactate, lactate is
super important for women to produce
because one, we have less glycolytic and
fast-twitch fibers than men. But two,
it's preferred fuel for the brain. And
we know that there's a massive sex
difference in things like dementia and
Alzheimer's. And part of it is our brain
metabolism and dysfunction that occurs
with glucose metabolism in the brain.
So, if we're introducing more lactate
and the body understands what lactate
is, it helps equalize some of that
metabolism, which is a reduction in the
risk factor for dementia cognitive
decline.
>> Did everybody follow that?
You're going to be tested the end of
this. Um
>> I need a flow chart.
>> Yeah, I I have I have plenty to say
about that, but before I do, is is
anyone
Does anyone want any clarification on
that or do you have any questions that
come up about what Stacy just shared?
>> Just a question on the interval
training, you know, you say 45 minutes
is is too long. Um or or sorry, maybe
not long enough, but
can you can you do effective training in
in shorter amounts of time? Can you do
like a 30-minute workout that's as
effective as 45 minutes or an hour. Is
it And is it just like
the intensity level and then the break
level that you need to dial in?
>> Yeah, that's more it. So, I mean, like
if we're thinking about a 45 minute to
an hour,
um in that you would have someone that
warms up really well
and then leads into really dialed in
uh
intervals. So, we know it could be 1 to
4 minutes of variable uh variable
intensity from 80 to 90% and variable
recovery. So, your whole work time
within that might be 20 25 minutes with
your interval and your recovery. So,
then if you have a long warm-up and a
cool down, you could easily fill up an
hour. But, when we're looking at the
classes, they don't do the interval part
right. So, if anyone's ever been to an
F45 or an Orange Theory, I know they
already have targets on me, so I'm happy
to talk about them now.
Um they don't They're all about go go go
go go go go go go go go go go go go and
they don't really explain what you're
supposed to be doing and how you're
supposed to be feeling. It's all about
the fast movement. It's about the sweat.
It's like go go go from um station to
station to station. So, you're not
really doing the interval properly. So,
this is why when you're looking at those
classes, yeah, it's a sweat sesh, but
what did you really get out of it?
For me, I don't want to take it away
from people because it's their social
connection. So, I tell them, "If you
understand what you're trying to do and
you go to these classes, you can modify
those classes for yourself." So, you
know, F45, instead of doing more reps
with less weight, why don't you use that
interval and lift heavier with less
reps? So, that you can make it work for
you and your body and still get that
social connection. And we're seeing that
happening more and more and more in
these classes where people are owning it
and saying, "I know I need this for my
body and I don't want to give up the
time I have with my friends or the
camaraderie that comes." It's just what
are you doing specifically for that
interval?
>> Thank you.
>> Yeah.
>> The
the TLDR of all of this is women need to
be lifting
heavy weight more. They need to be doing
true high intensity training. And that
should be mixed in with, you know, some
some polarization, some zone one, some
walking.
>> Mhm.
>> From my perspective, this gets
translated and help me clarify this.
This gets translated on the internet to
stop doing zone two and just lift heavy
weights. And if I could translate a
little bit what you just shared, which
I'm totally on board with, basically
what you're talking about is most people
are, you know, generally unbeknownst to
them,
uh, engaging in like zone three. They
think they're doing zone two or zone
five.
>> Mhm.
>> Uh, so they're in that gray zone where
they're not really, uh, developing their
aerobic capacity,
uh,
you know, getting that mitochondrial
density, recruiting those slow twitch
fibers, and increasing their ability to
utilize fat for fuel.
Uh, and they're also not going hard
enough to get the stimulus to increase
muscle mass and bone density and the
like. And when you're in that middle
zone and you're new to fitness, you
will, like all movement's good movement,
you will have you know, you will have
gains and you will get more fit, but you
will quickly plateau. And people who are
in that zone either think they're doing
the hard work or they think they're
doing the zone two work and they're not
doing either.
>> Right. I I mean, I've had people came
after me and go, "You're such an
absolutist and you're telling women
things they can't do. You can't do zone
two. You can't do this. You must do
lifting in the heavy range and you must
do interval training." And I come back
and like, "Look, to optimize women who
have already been exercising, these are
the things we know that work, but I'm
not saying that's the only thing they
can do. That's not what I do. I go to
the gym three three a week specifically
for lifting. It's taken me a very long
time to learn how to lift heavy
properly. And I'm also adding
plyometrics in there because one of the
other things that you really lose as you
get older is proprioception and um the
ability for power. So, it's like let's
work some plyo in there.
On the weekend, you're not going to find
me at home or in the gym. I'm either
going to be out ocean swimming for a
couple of hours cuz we have a 7K loop or
I'm going to be on my gravel bike. None
of that is zone two or zone five. It's
my soul food. So, when we're looking at
optimizing and for women who have a very
short amount of time and let's face it,
every woman and man who get up on
purpose to exercise at oh my god, it's
still night is an athlete in my mind.
And I want people to think like an
athlete. And you know from being an
athlete that there's a specificity for
every session that you do.
So, I'm like I'm not going to tell you
that you have to do high-intensity
interval training every day of the week
and then throw in some heavy strength
training. That's the only thing you can
do. Let's look, how many days do you
have to exercise in a week? Let's
optimize. If we hit two high-intensity
sessions and we have two heavy lifting
sessions, that's great. So, what is
that? Maybe an hour and a half to two
hours of your entire week. So, what are
we going to do the rest of the time?
Let's move how you want to. I don't want
to restrict anybody. But we're looking
to optimize for brain health, for bone
health, for muscle, these are the things
we know that work inherently really well
for women who are not only having an age
factor that diminishes muscle power and
capabilities as well as bone. We also
have a fluctuation in our hormones that
also affect the same systems. So, let's
look at how the body is aging and going
through perimenopause and use things to
optimize the body for change.
>> So, women lifting heavy weight.
>> I know.
>> Uh
what do you say to the woman who says, I
I don't want to do that cuz I don't want
to get all bulked up?
>> I know, I hear this all the time. You
won't get bulky. If you have a genetic
predisposition for putting on a lot of
muscle mass, then yeah, you probably
will, but it's really, really difficult
for women to get bulky.
Um, and when we start looking at the
power-based end of our ranges, which is
your 80% of one rep max, and we're
looking at that heavy load, it's a
neuromuscular connection that we're
after. We're looking at how is the
nervous system now going to come down
and stimulate the muscle fibers to
create a really strong contraction and a
powerful contraction. We want to lift a
heavy load, so we have a neuromuscular
connection because estrogen is not there
on your side anymore. And when I talk
about um myosin dysfunction, which is
you have actin and myosin as your two
contractile proteins, the form of myosin
becomes dysfunctional with age as well
as a drop in estrogen. So, with age, we
want to do some heavy power-based stuff.
When we lose estrogen, same thing,
because then we are changing the
molecular or the isoform of myosin so
that it will grab on to actin the way it
used to. And this is why the basis of
that power-based stuff is really
important. But, the other thing is we
see from a randomized controlled trial
that came out last month that those
people who lift on the heavy end, both
men and women, lift on the heavy end,
get more prefrontal cortex neuro
connectivity. So, that means they're
actually empowering the neurons in the
prefrontal cortex more so than those
people that are lifting moderate weight
or body weight. Those people who are
lifting moderate weight and body weight
do affect other in the brain and it's
like BDNF increases, we have a little
bit more connectivity, but only the
heavy end of lifting really does affect
the prefrontal cortex.
>> So, there's a neuroplasticity
aspect to this.
>> And essentially what you're saying is as
estrogen goes down,
you need to replace that stimulus with a
central nervous system stimulus, and
lifting heavy weights accomplishes that.
>> Yes. And then you can look at we get
that increase in our neuromuscular
stimulus in this pure strength and
power. And then if you really want to
try to put lean mass on, you have to eat
a lot and you have to be in the gym a
lot and you have to look at what are
some of the other rep ranges to cause
hypertrophy. Because I think the
confusion in the space is people are
missing the mark when they're talking
about strength and resistance training.
Where people are thinking about building
muscle mass is also strength. Yes,
you're going to get strong, but you're
not going to get as strong as if you
were to stay at the lower end. And the
way I try to get people to understand
this is you can train to do 50 push-ups.
Are you going to have more strength? A
little bit. Are you going to have a lot
of muscle mass and endurance from that?
Yes.
I'd rather you train to do 10 push-ups
with a 20 kilo pound on your back or 20
kilo plate on your back cuz then we know
you're going to be strong.
Are you going to have more endurance?
Yeah, a little bit. Are you going to
have more lean mass? Probably not that
much, but you're going to be really
strong and powerful. And that's the eye
that we want for women because we know
that power strength is really, really
important for longevity. It is a
critical factor for how we age and our
proprioception. So I'm now at the point
where I'm like, let's optimize women not
so that they are in the moment now
aesthetics. Yeah, that's part of it, but
we know that women live for a much
longer period of time than men, but in
really poor state of health. So all the
things we do now is kind of
banking that we aren't going to get in
that poor state of health. We're doing
everything to protect our bones, our
muscle, our brain, our heart. And these
are the things that women need to start
thinking about.
>> To get really specific, uh like how many
rep like you're going into the gym,
okay? How many reps? Like what is the
how do I set the weight? How many reps
should I be able to do? How many sets of
those exercises? Like what it what would
be a typical
like routine? Like on this day I do
these muscle groups and I do this many
sets of this and that. Like what does
that look like?
I mean obviously it's customized it's
very specific to the person but in a
general sense.
>> So this one is hard to answer. Every
woman's journey is different and how
they approach weight strength strength
training. If you are a woman who has a
long history in strength training and
you're like I'm going to start to
embrace this heavier lifting stuff.
First you want to have a periodized
program. So if you're coming in and
you're like this is the
strength like the really hard base
building part. Then we look at 5 by 5's
and that's five reps
five sets at about an eight on a scale
of one to 10 more talking about our
rating perceived exertion. You're
working hard.
>> So meaning you could probably do two
more reps or so. You're not going to
failure.
>> Correct. But you probably are by the
time you get to that fifth set and maybe
the third or fourth rep. So you are
pretty much going to failure but that's
not necessarily the end goal.
And you're not doing that on every
muscle group. We talk about compound
lifting because you have your
stabilizers as well as the actual major
muscle groups. So maybe Monday you're
doing a squat focus and it's that knee
hinge type focus.
And then you do some subsidiaries around
it. So your main focus is your compound
squat focus and that's your 5 by 5's.
Then maybe you do some residual
Brazilian squat or
some split Bulgarian split squats. So
you might be doing eight to 10 reps but
it's more about further fatiguing the
muscle and getting more of a stimulus
for the strength as well as some of the
muscle hypertrophy.
Maybe Wednesday's a push pull. So it's
upper body you're doing overhead press
maybe you're doing bench press maybe
you're doing a pull so it's all the push
pull.
And then Thursday or Friday you're doing
posterior chain. So it's all like these
are the the muscle groups and the
compound movements we want you to do,
but how do you do it? We need you to
have a program. We need you to go,
"Okay, I'm going to do this for 6 weeks
and then I'm going to have a deload and
then I'm going to move into this." So,
we're continuously adding
load and we're recovering from it and
then we're changing up the loads cuz the
body likes to have a challenge. So, to
see progress, we need consistency and we
need to be able to challenge the body.
>> It's very difficult to adhere to a truly
periodized program without a a plan and
you know, in the best case scenario like
working with somebody who's monitoring
this.
The typical experience and this applies
to men and women, you go to the gym, you
kind of have your thing, you do your
routine and that's just what you do and
it's the equivalent of zone three, I
think, you know, in in in for endurance
athletes like and you just kind of hit
this ceiling and you never really see
the gains because you're not taking
those deload weeks off, you know, you
periodize we you know, daily, weekly,
monthly, yearly, right? To really
be able to figure out how to like
optimize what you're doing and you need
somebody guiding you.
>> Yeah, and for a lot of people it's hard,
right? And so, one of Well, there's two
things I tell both men and women when
you're looking at a periodized program.
If you don't have a coach and you don't
have a plan, then we're kind of wasting
time, but not really. So, if you want to
do a quick hit, let's deload during
school holidays. So, you know, your kid
has a week off
and instead of focusing on going to the
gym, let's spend more time with your kid
or know that that's a point where you
need to deload cuz the school year is
broken up into pretty good breaks where
you have a week off and then maybe 2
weeks and then you have summer break.
So, you can use that as like a baseline
for how am I I'm going to focus for this
before the next school break. Just gives
you an eye to a calendar.
And the other thing I have for for women
because they're more afraid to push
themselves cells heavier,
I go, "Okay, I want you to go pick up
the weights that you're going to use for
a Romanian deadlift. And I want you to
tell me how many you can do with that
weight." They'll go pick up some lighter
weights. They might do a set of 20. I
might, "That's way too light. Let's go
pick up the next set." They'll go to
from like the 10s to the 12 and 1/2. I
might, "Skip the 12 and 1/2. Let's go to
the 15."
And they're surprised they can still do
15 reps without an issue. So, it's like
really trying to challenge yourself
instead of doing more reps, let's pick
up a heavier weight.
And it's getting that mindset of, "Okay,
for this block before the next school
break, let's focus on lifting up a
heavier weight even though you're doing
the same routine. Let's just change up
what routine you're doing by increasing
the load or maybe we're doing resistance
bands and some pogos as a warm-up
instead of a static stretch." Just small
little things cuz I don't want people
not to go to the gym. I don't want to
break up their consistency, but it's
just reframing what they're doing by
adding a little bit or taking away a
little bit and breaking up the calendar
and something that makes sense.
>> On the other end end of the spectrum, we
have the high-intensity work. Uh you
mentioned the Norwegian 4x4 like
everyone likes to talk about that.
That's just one example of of of Yeah,
of many, of course. Um
but
what is something else that somebody
should know like what does that look
like? Like you're talking about like all
out efforts with plenty of recovery
other than, you know, some kind of
uh indoor cycling or treadmill sprint
situation. Like what is another type of
high-intensity sprint-based workout? Is
the circuit training
like fall into that category? Yes or no?
Like what are some other options that
women can think about?
>> Yeah, so if we think about circuit
training, I tell people we can go on the
the aspect of every minute on the minute
or every 2 minutes on the on the 2
minute where one minute you're doing one
exercise and you might have 20 seconds
where you get to the next one. So, you
have four exercises and then a minute of
recovery. And then you might do that two
or three times. And you can do that
outside on the playground, right? You
could do air squats and then you can go
into
uh hang on the on the monkey bars. You
can do walking lunges. You can do some
sit-ups.
Um there's lots of availability. Rebecca
Rush, she goes and she lifts rocks on
her run. So, there's lots of things you
can do outside of the gym.
And it's it's about the intent and the
intensity. It's not necessarily where
you are that you have to do it. So,
there are I mean gym intimidation is
real. I get gym intimidation depending
on where I am in some things. And I've
been in and out of gym since I was 16.
So, I know gym intimidation is real. So,
I'm not going to push every woman to go
to the gym.
Might not be time effective. Also, fear
factor. So, let's look. Okay, maybe we
start with 10 minutes in your house and
we're just doing bodyweight circuits
where again, we're doing 30 seconds on,
a minute off. Maybe we're doing a minute
on, a minute off. Just starting slow.
So, it does become more feasible when
people start to think about that. It's
not about running for 2 minutes on the
treadmill, jumping off and doing
30-second kettlebell swing, 30 seconds
off, and then getting back on. Like
that's more personalized and and really
high-intensity.
But if we're a woman who's just starting
this journey and she's used to walking
for 5 miles in the morning or 3-mile
loop, during that walk, let's pick up
the pace. Or maybe you have some stairs.
Instead of avoiding the stairs, let's do
a couple of ups and downs of the stairs.
So, that becomes an intensity factor. Or
you're meeting your friend in the park
to walk your dogs. Well, let's see.
Let's do a bodyweight circuit while
we're there. You walk to the end of the
the you're going around the lake. You
get to a certain point in the lake and
both you stop and you do some jump um
some
air squats or maybe do some jumping
lunges. So, there's lots of ways that
you can fit it in.
But I think we've all have been so
conditioned that high-intensity means
XYZ in the gym and strength training has
to be in the gym or has to be, I don't
know, in a personal training session.
But, it isn't like that. It's like it's
available to everybody. We just have to
know who the person is, the personality,
do they need a buddy or not, would they
like an app or not, do they want to go
to the gym or not, are you more of an
outdoor person? I go to the gym so that
I can be strong enough to do things I
love to do outside. I didn't go to the
gym because I love it. I go to the gym
for protection against injury. So, there
are a lot of people like, "I don't want
to go to the gym. I want to be outside."
Great. Let's see what can we do outside
that's going to hit these marks.
>> You mentioned jump training and when I
hear that I think about
bone density.
You know, obviously when women age up,
you know, we hear a lot about
osteoporosis and and bone density loss.
What are the exercises that drive bone
density retention or improvement the
most and what are some myths out there
about that?
>> Myths are rampant. Well,
running improves bone density.
We think about yoga, like all these
modalities, they don't. They're not a
strong enough stress. So, if we want to
improve bone density, we need a
multi-directional stress coming up. The
ground doesn't move, our body does. So,
we want something that's really hard to
come up through the skeletal system to
invoke that stimulus for for bone
turnover and bone strength. When I talk
about jump training, so many people,
especially um perimenopausal women, are
like, "I can't. My joints hurt." It's
like, "I'm not talking about plyometric
high box jumps." It could be something
as simple as a toe raise and a hard heel
slam. Because you're dropping hard and
you're absorbing all those forces,
that's a multi-directional force through
the skeletal system. There's a fantastic
um research program over in Australia
called Lift4 More and they look at
strength training and proper jump
training where it's hard landing and
they're getting significant improvements
in women who have had osteoporosis into
the bone density of normalcy in men as
well.
Uh, out of New Zealand as well,
OsteoGains. It's all about the kind of
jumping and hard landing that you're
getting, not soft landing that we've all
learned to absorb the forces. And it's 3
minutes a few times a week to really
improve bone density over the course of
3 or 4 months.
>> You mentioned plyometrics earlier. Uh, I
don't know that I even know what that
means. Does that include things like
yoga and Pilates?
>> No, so
>> And where do those
>> Where do they fit?
>> fit in?
>> Yeah. So, plyometrics is power-based
training, explosive training. So, this
is your box jumps. This is your counter
movement jumps. So, all that stuff
that's really fast and reactive. Um,
when we talk about Pilates and yoga, uh,
there's a whole subgroup of people who
are Pilates lovers that hate me cuz they
think I hate Pilates. I was in a Pilates
class before I got here. Not today, but
a couple of days ago. I don't hate it. I
think it's really good and people should
look at it as
really fantastic for
uh, proprioception, for balance, for
isometric hold. We need all this stuff,
especially for tendons and ligaments.
Same thing with yoga. If you heard um,
Keith Baar talk about tendons and
ligaments, he really does like yoga in
the last bit of the hold where you're
shaking cuz that gives you
a stress in the ligament and the tendon
to instigate more plasticity and and and
strength within those tendons.
They're complementary. They aren't
strength training in the way that we're
viewing strength training for brain
health and neuromuscular connection.
They all can can all fit together. So,
if you're someone who loves Pilates, you
don't have to give it up. But, add 1 day
of of pure strength training in. If
you're someone who loves yoga, same
thing. You don't give it up. It's like,
how are we going to
change what you're doing to optimize
your life? I don't want anybody to give
up their love. It's like, how are we
going to look at what you're doing in
the time in the week? And strength
training doesn't have to take a long
time. It could be 10 to 15 minutes if
it's focused.
It's not an hour and a half in a gym
that you don't like. So again, it's
individual and how do we look at it and
what are we looking to do? I think yoga
and Pilates are really important as we
get older because we lose
proprioception, we lose the ability for
flexibility and mobility. And those two
um modes of activity really do help with
that. But it again, it doesn't tax the
bone and the muscle the way we need to
to age well.
>> The supplement world. Let's just say
it's a bit noisy out there with endless
products promising quick results or
products that are making all kinds of
unsupportable claims. But over many,
many years, what I have learned is that
lasting progress usually comes from
getting a few simple basics right and
then doing them consistently. I bang on
about this all the time on the podcast,
but the one area that doesn't get nearly
enough attention is fiber. In fact, and
amazingly, almost 95% of Americans
aren't getting enough. Let that sink in.
Which makes it one of the most
overlooked gaps in health and
performance despite the fact that fiber
is crucial to disease prevention, to
performance, and to overall well-being
by supporting gut health, nutrient
absorption, steady energy, focus,
recovery, and on and on and on.
Momentous Fiber Plus, which is what I've
got right here in my hands,
uh was built to address that foundation
directly. It combines multiple forms of
fiber to support digestion and helps
stabilize blood sugar so your energy
stays more even throughout the day. And
as is with everything Momentous makes,
it's science first. Clearly formulated
and independently tested with NSF
Certified for Sport standards. That
commitment to fundamentals and
transparency is is really why I trust
them the most. If you want to improve
performance at the source and eliminate
the guesswork, shop Momentous Fiber Plus
at livemomentous.com
and get up to 35% off your first order
with the code Rich Roll.
There's a pretty good chance you've
cottoned on to this channel and pulled
up this podcast because you've got
goals. You aspire to be better, to eat
better, to have more energy, to be more
consistent. All of this is great, but
you got to have an actual plan or all
your good intentions will soon tend to
drift. And that is what I appreciate
about ProLon. It's a 5-day plant-based
nutrition program designed to give you
many of the benefits of fasting, but you
get to keep eating. It sounds nuts, but
it's true thanks to the exhaustively
studied, evidence-backed fasting
mimicking diet devised by world-leading
fasting science researcher and friend of
the pod, Dr. Valter Longo. Everything
comes pre-packaged in a gorgeous box
labeled by day, so there's no guesswork,
which makes it surprisingly doable even
when life is busy. For me, it's about
creating a reset point, a way to step
back, recalibrate, and return to my
routine with more clarity and intention.
Ready for your reset? For a limited
time, ProLon is offering my listeners
15% off sitewide plus a $40 bonus gift
when you subscribe to their 5-day
program. Just visit
prolonlife.com/richroll.
That's p r o l o n l i f e {dot} com
{slash} richroll to claim your discount
and your bonus gift.
From a weight management perspective,
what is your message to the person
who says, "You're asking me to dial back
my favorite aerobic exercise that I've
relied upon for decades to keep my
weight in check and you want me doing
three to five reps of these heavy
weight. Like how is that going to impact
like my bottom line which is like I got
to keep I got to keep the weight, you
know,
down.
>> Yeah.
I like to talk about what we stand to
gain, not what we stand to lose.
Because in the diet culture, it's all
about weight loss and fat loss. I'm very
conscious not to say those words. I
don't use them on my YouTube channel. I
don't want to instigate anything about
loss.
I want to think about what we're what we
stand to gain if we get into the weight
room. We stand to gain muscle. Muscle is
a very active tissue that helps regulate
all sorts of things. Body weight, our
blood glucose, our immunity, just so
many things. We get in the gym, we're
also protecting our bones. So we stand
to gain so much more from those few
times in the gym than we do pounding and
increasing cortisol doing our favorite
aerobic 90-minute aerobic session.
Um and when we start thinking about what
do we stand to get to gain when we're in
the gym and gaining all those things for
brain health and muscle health and bone
health and longevity
versus what we stand to lose if we stop
doing the 90 minutes. We actually aren't
losing if we stop doing the 90 minutes.
We're gaining so much more because if
we're looking at the more muscle that we
have and the more muscle centric we are,
the more that your body composition is
in a better place.
And it is it's a really hard for all of
us that grew up in the idea of 90-minute
step aerobics and going for
massive long run on the weekend and all
of these things to keep our weight in
check or doing fasted training cuz it
keeps our weight in check. When we get
this mental shift of being in the gym to
help with all of that, it's time
effective and we also see significant
body composition change. But it is a
significant work on the brain to do
that. A lot of times a buddy system is
really helpful because you don't want to
let a a friend down if you're both
starting on this journey.
Um sometimes I'll have run groups where
I'm like, "We're going to start the run
with doing some strength training and
then we're going to Now we've prepped
the muscles that you're going to run
more effectively and more economically,
so it it reduces injury risk." So then
we can lean in on we want to reduce
injury, you want to improve your running
form for the things that you love. Let's
get in Let's do these these preps and
let's stimulate the muscle in a way that
it does.
>> Um I made a big to-do about this being
participatory. I don't think I've
actually lived up to that. So like let's
get some questions. Yeah, there's one in
the back there.
>> Uh I was just curious regarding what you
were saying earlier regarding uh
circadian rhythms and how it pertains to
the optimal time for women to uh fuel
and you know, start their day with
nutrition and everything else.
Um how does that factor into uh training
schedules? Is there an optimal time of
day for women to train? And how does
that compare with men?
>> I don't know. That's hasn't actually
been done.
From a research standpoint. We know from
behavioral standpoint that anybody who
exercises first thing in the morning is
probably going to stick with what
they're doing.
Um we also see at the end of the day
tends to drive a little bit more low
energy availability and sleep disruption
because people are going into a session
not that well fueled or they come home
and it's too late. They don't feel that
hungry or they feel hungry an hour
before bed so they overeat. And that's
both men and women. So from a behavioral
standpoint, we always try to say let's
do more in the morning if we can.
Um but really fit it in. And if you have
to do it at night, there are things that
we can do to help mitigate metabolism
and help with the refueling and help
with sleep.
>> Thank you. We need some women questions.
Yeah, okay. Thank you.
>> Um I have a question. This is Sarah.
Thank you for basically outlining my
upcoming nutrition and workout plan.
>> You're welcome.
>> Um, that'll be $1,000.
>> Yeah, thank you.
>> Um, so for the interval piece that
you're mentioning, you just kind of
mapped a few different versions of that.
Are there specific
modalities or movements within that
interval plan that you would consider
more optimized than others? Right, you
mentioned a few few movements in there,
but like is cycling versus running
versus mixed movement more optimized?
>> Whatever you like. Whatever is going to
motivate you. If you're learning how to
go super hard, I always tell people to
get on the assault bike with a friend
next to them telling them, "Go, go, go,
go, go, go, go, go." Cuz you cannot
cheat on an assault bike. Once you know
what that feels like, then anything
goes.
>> We are very behind on the research and
women's bodies are complex. How do we
get there faster so that we can know
more and make more advances in women's
health?
This becomes a group of people working
together cuz we see, especially in
academics or in academia and in the
research world, there's lots of silos
and people are like elbows out, this is
my realm. But there is quite a group of
us that are coming together to really
try to close that gap.
I'm finding that I'm an expert in one
thing, but I'm not an expert in all the
things that Emily's an expert in.
So it's like let's gravitate and bring
all of us together cuz we can really put
an impact on and have a louder voice and
find money and grants and distribute it.
And then
part of it is we're launching company
about that same thing where we're going
after AI and we're really vetting
research to be able to give output and
insight for women that's going to drive
research and improve it the touch
points. So there's behind the scenes
where we're all really trying to close
that gap and address the funding issue
and find innovative ways to actually go
after that.
But it isn't it isn't an individual,
it's a team. And we're finding that
there is a really good group of men and
women who are doing research in the
space that are coming together and being
complementary
to really hone in and try to close that
gap. In in the different areas, we have
the oncology area that is is really
booming with all sorts of different
techniques and and you have a lot of
researchers coming together to help each
other. Same in the sports space, same in
the reproductive rights and reproductive
research space. So it's an exciting
time.
>> Hi thanks to Ambrose. I'm the dad to a
14-year-old young woman and
I want to be the best parent. I want to
be the greatest parent I can to her.
What are some habits that I can help
instill with her and support her in and
she's as she's in this part of her her
growing up?
>> Girl dads, I love girl dads. My
husband's a girl dad.
So it it one of the biggest things is
communication.
A lot of times girls will shut down
especially with their dads. So if you
just have a like we still instigate
family dinner every night and have
conversation. So it's like how was your
day? What were some of the high points?
What were some of the low points?
And then at night having conversation
with her and I she'll offload and I'm
like just vent. I'm not going to fix. So
when they know that you're a safe
place to vent and not looking for
solutions or they know that they can
come to you and say things and not be
judged, it's really important especially
as they're going through their teenage
years. There's going to be ups and
downs. They're going to have all sorts
of mood swings. But if you just
consistently there as someone who's not
judging and they can vent, it's like I
tell my daughter when you get to the
point where you might be going to
parties
and you feel unsafe, call me.
I'm not going to judge. I'm not going to
get mad until maybe the next day.
But I don't tell her that. She'll know
now cuz she'll watch this. But it's just
really important to understand that both
physically and mentally is an enormous
change right now and we want to do
everything to foster a positive
environment. So it's like we don't have
any kind of body language in the family.
So we aren't we talk about being strong
and how fast you can run and all the
things that she loves for soccer. We
don't talk about food in a negative way.
If you want chocolate, you can have
some. It's a sometimes food. Just
remember your soldiers don't want to
grow on sugar. Our soldiers are your
immune system. So just really coming to
a place where I understand you. I got
you. I'm not going to judge you unless I
really have to because I'm the parent.
But for the most part that undercurrent
of just being supportive goes immensely
far and then the other thing that is
really important is your phone.
Put it in the phone jail when you first
walk in the house. That way you're not
on the screen all the time which becomes
a habit for all of us and then they lead
by example because if everyone puts
their phone in the phone jail, then you
end up with a very safe environment in
the house.
>> Thank you.
>> You're welcome.
>> Hi, I'm Meredith.
Um I guess my question is about sleep. I
am chronically a terrible sleeper,
always have been and in the last
probably 10 years it's gotten so bad
that I
am well and people around me are also
like looking for ways to get through the
night, to stay asleep, to go to sleep
and so it's like there's pharmaceutical
options, there's herbal options, there's
you know friends that can't go to sleep
without a glass of wine and I'm just
curious is like is sleep sleep or does
it have to be good sleep? Does it have
to be
like sleep that naturally comes to be
able to have that recovery?
>> We want to see that you have a really
good sleep architecture cuz you need REM
sleep, you also need slow wave sleep. We
know that if you're using alcohol, then
you don't get into slow wave which is
your deep reparative sleep.
One of the things that is really
effective is cognitive behavior therapy.
There's a
a
group out of the Veterans Association
that has I sleep. And it is was designed
to help people with PTSD coming back
from Afghanistan to be able to sleep.
And it's really effective. So one of the
the most effective ways is like
cognitive reshuffling or some other
cognitive behavior therapy with things
like L-theanine and magnesium threonate
that cross blood brain barrier that have
an active uh part in parasympathetic
responses. It does take some time. And
it's it is a bit of a frustration when
you first start, but stick with it
because it it significantly improves
sleep and sleep architecture.
>> Hi, my name is Emily. Thank you so much.
I'm getting so much from this. Um as a
34-year-old woman you realize how little
education you have on your own body. And
so I'm all here to optimize everything
you're saying. One thing I'm coming to
is working with the cycles of my body,
especially someone who has endometriosis
and is on a fertility journey. So I hear
about these three to five workouts a
week, and then I think about how I might
be during my period or something like
that.
Um what are some of the ways that we can
help to support ourselves instead of
looking at every week as the same? I
know that that's where I'm going to drop
off with that consistency.
>> Yeah, so um it's
it's knowing that three times a week you
should be doing strength training,
right? So does it mean you have to go do
the same thing every Monday, every
Wednesday, every Thursday or Friday? No.
You have your periodized plan, but
sometimes you go and you're like, I just
want to lift really heavy or I don't. I
just want to work on technique. It's
it's feeling how you are, and I tell
people when you go to do a session,
there's two things. You have the
physical and the mental.
And if you show up at a session,
mentally you're a two, but physically
you might be a six. Let's do a little
bit of a warm-up with mobility. Maybe we
do a couple of heavy lifts to stimulate
central nervous system. So, here mental
goes. If your mental doesn't come up,
call it. Have an active day. Just do
what you love. But, most often that
mental comes up. And then you're like,
I'm super motivated. I feel great. So,
maybe your physical now comes up to an
eight, and your mental comes up to an
eight. And people
usually will give up within the first 10
minutes when they come in feeling that
way. But, if you are doing specific
things to kind of boost mental in this
10 minutes, you're like, I'm here. I
feel great. Let's go.
Um and then again, listening to your
body, cuz I think that so many people
disregard how you feel on the mental
aspect of how you feel. So, if you are
suffering from uh severe endometriosis
and the symptomology that comes with it,
then you're not going to push yourself,
and that's fine.
It is absolutely fine not to push
yourself. Um we know that the
inflammation that comes with
endometriosis can be very systemic and
and be very impactful. So, then maybe
you want to look at an environmental
stress. So, we look at heat, and we look
at at cool water, not ice water, but
cool water, cuz those both induce a
massive anti-inflammatory response that
helps with endometriosis. So, instead of
going and pushing yourself through
exercise, maybe you just look at an
environmental stress. One, it brings
more mental and parasympathetic
activation to calm, but it also does
great things for inflammation in the
body.
>> In furtherance of that, how do uh things
like birth control uh and hormone
replacement therapy impact training, how
one how a woman should think about their
their nutrition uh and just overall
health and energy levels?
>> I'd like to say we have solid answers
for that, but we don't. Because with
hormonal contraception, there's so many
different variations of the formulas,
and a lot of research hasn't been done
on it. We do know that in general
combined or a contraception knowing that
we have estrogen progesterone in it
increases oxidative rates. We see it
increases inflammation. So those are
factors to consider if you're trying to
adapt. Um so we look at having more
anti-inflammatory foods. We look at what
can we do to calm post exercise uh
inflammation and and recovery.
Um but for the most part how does it
truly impact training and adaptation?
It's an individual response and depends
on the formulation.
When we get to menopause hormone
therapy, part of it's a wild west
because we had the Women's Health
Initiative in the States versus the UK
Million Women Study in the UK with
vastly different outcomes. So depending
on where you are in the world, you hear
mixed messages.
What we do know is that when you're
using menopause hormone therapy,
it slows a rate of change but it doesn't
stop it. So if you're looking at body
composition,
it isn't going to help just on its own
preserve body composition. It will slow
the rate of the um laying down of
visceral fat.
It will slow the rate of muscle loss but
it doesn't stop it. The only thing it
does help we know emphatically helps
with is bone and bone density. It's very
protective.
Um so when someone's considering
hormonal options, it's like yes, have an
informed choice but you can't neglect
the lifestyle parts that come with it.
And if you I have um younger
reproductive year
clients and and um athletes. And if
they're changing their a pill or they're
going from a pill to an IUD, we want to
track how they're feeling because
symptoms really will dictate how they're
responding. Because if you feel awful,
you're not going to be able to put in a
good session. So, we want to know what
the patterns are over their hormonal
contraception or their IUD and if they
change it, how that affects them, too,
so that we can dial back and we can push
forward when we know that we have the
opportunity.
>> You you opened answering that question
with a with a sort of we don't, you
know, we don't know enough. Like, so
what I take from that is like, how is it
possible that these aren't studies that
are being done? Like, is there there's
clearly not enough research being
performed on this.
>> No, but I will borrow from Lisa Mosconi.
She's like, we don't know this yet.
We have studies that are down the track
and we're planning for them and she has
a massive grant to really look at
menopause hormone therapy and the way it
affects the brain. There are other
people that have um a long There's the
menstrual cycle research group that's
doing is collabing across the world to
really nail down what's happening with
hormonal contraception and the different
formulations. So, it's in the pipe. It
just hasn't been done yet. It's in the
process of. So, hopefully in two to
three years I'll have more definitive
answers.
>> You mentioned uh
hot and cold water. Uh
so, let's talk a little bit about that.
Like, sauna, cold plunge. Everybody
loves to talk about their protocol,
their routine. Uh you know, where do you
stand on this from a women's point of
view, women's health point of view?
And what's different about women with
respect to men when you're thinking
about these
>> Yeah.
>> activities?
>> So, this is where I bring it down to sex
differences, not hormonal differences.
There is an inherent sex difference in
thermoregulation, where men will
um start to sweat and they'll really
offload heat through sweating when they
get hot, but women will vasodilate first
before they start sweating.
Women's thermoregulation
um baseline also switches across the
menstrual cycle cuz progesterone
increases your core temperature and the
body adjusts to accommodate for that.
So, if we're looking at the sauna, women
will have more robust responses from
being in the heat because their body's
used to change. So, when they go there,
the body's like, "Hey, I know what this
is." And it will really improve our
metabolic control, improve heat shock
protein responses. Men will still have
the same, but they have to have higher,
or I guess more times in the sauna for
that actual longevity. If we're looking
for heat acclimation, it takes women
longer the body is used to the
perturbation of the temperature. So, we
see men who are
doing sauna exposure for performance,
they need less time in there because
they hit get a big boost to
cardiovascular responses faster than
women.
So, when we're looking for health
outcomes, women, they can tolerate the
heat more, they can get in there, they
can stay in there longer, and they get
more robust responses than men. Cold's
different.
>> Staying on sauna, just to be really
specific, like how long and what
temperature Is there a temperature
threshold? Like, where do you where do
you set the thermostat, and where do you
set your kind of timer on how long you
need to be in?
To get that response.
>> Yeah, the response. So,
in research, we can't keep people in
heat
when their core temperature goes up
above 39.5°.
So, that's about 104°
Fahrenheit.
So, when we're looking at how does that
play into responses, you get responses
well below that cuz I'm saying that
because I think Bryan Johnson was like,
"I have to keep my core temperature
>> Yeah.
>> It's like, "No."
>> He said, "I hadn't been I wasn't in long
enough. I didn't have it hot enough. I
had to stay in there crazy long."
>> Yeah, no. That's That's hazardous. Like,
we can't get ethics to drive people to
get their core temperature up. So, at
39.5, you're out.
So, when we're looking at all the
responses that we're seeing, it's well
below that. So, we see about 38.5°.
So, what is that? Uh
I don't know. Quick do do the math.
Someone do the conversion for
>> Somebody do the math on that
>> Cuz I'm just going to stay with metric.
As a scientist and someone is an expert,
we talk metric all the time.
>> Uh one on one.
>> Okay, one on one.
>> Tap yes, time time day, duration.
>> Okay.
Time of day, ideally if you can do it
after training for 10 minutes, it
extends the training stress. So, you
actually get more out of your training
than if you were not to go in the sauna.
Uh but if you're timing it, generally
whenever you can, right? We know at the
end of the day when you're passively
dehydrated and your core temperature is
a little bit more elevated, then that
can promote more red blood cell
responses. But for general health and
continuing aspects of of actually
getting that heat exposure, 10 to 15
minutes three times a week tends to be
the minimum. And we're looking at 80° C
cuz some people crank it all the way up
and it's way too hot. Um and so it's
it's pretty moderate. It's like we sit
in an environment that's so controlled
all the time. We have central heat, we
have central air, we get in our cars, we
turn the air on or roll the window down.
We're not really used to being above 80°
cuz we become very uncomfortable. Women
find 80° super comfortable, men start to
find it a little bit too warm, but
that's beside the point. So, we're
looking at heat exposure, it's a
moderate dose more regularly, and we get
really good health benefits from it.
We're talking about heat acclimation, we
know that five days in a row at
um that 80° C mark for up to a half an
hour is what your body needs as a man to
get cardiovascular, meaning blood volume
expansion, sweat rate changes to be able
to perform well in the heat. For women,
it's nine days because we have to ex-
extend it cuz our bodies are really used
to that fluctuation. For health, it's
not the same thing.
So, we look the minimum dose is 10
minutes three times a week.
>> Cold plunge.
>> Oh, yeah. I caused an international
shitstorm with this one.
And it wasn't my opinion. I was just
reading the research that's been around
since the '90s.
Where again, we look at sex differences
in thermoregulation. So, the ice water,
the ice bath that comes along is way too
cold for women. It causes more of a
sympathetic drive. And once we get over
that sympathetic drive, then the
responses for parasympathetic still are
not as robust as we see for men.
So, men can do fine in ice water. But
for women to garner parasympathetic
changes and metabolic changes, cool
water. So, we're looking at 55° F,
around 14 to 16° C. It is in the
research. Women do well in that where
it's cold enough to create a stress
where the body will adapt, but it's not
icy cold that causes an opposite
response.
>> Why did that cause a shitstorm?
>> Because of the entire
>> their
>> their ice baths. Yeah, their
billion-dollar ice plunge.
>> Yeah. Where's Julie? Julie should be
happy about the other she's
>> Oh, good. No ice for you.
>> no, she's she's not into it.
Um
let's talk a little bit about a little
bit more about nutrition. Uh fair to say
you're a pro protein person?
>> I am. Yeah.
>> Uh underscore your perspective here.
>> So, when we look at protein, I'm glad
it's making the heyday, right? So, we
look at it as when you're looking at the
initial RDAs, people have to remember
that a recommended daily allowance is
the bare minimum someone needs to
prevent malnutrition. So, when we start
looking at protein, the recommend
recommendation that is there in general
for women in the US guidelines is enough
just to exist. But when you start adding
activity, you start adding age, we need
more.
Not only that, higher protein diet is
satiation. Because we're in an
ultra-processed world where a lot of
people are gravitating to really fast
foods, meaning not fast food, but fast
to grab and eat. And those
ultra-processed, they don't really feel
satiated. But if we have a higher amount
of protein, not only are we able to
contribute to
more muscle generation and and bone
building and all the things that we
think about with protein, we also get
better appetite control.
So we start looking at the guidelines
for protein, we know from the research
that 1.6 to 2.2 g per kilo, which is
about that 0.8 to 1 g per pound is
optimal.
As we get older, we become more
anabolically resistant. So that means
our body doesn't use protein as well,
doesn't respond to strength training as
well. So we really do have to make sure
that we stay on an upper end of an
intake. There've been some research
recently that shows that it doesn't
matter what time of day you take it or
how much you have at any meal, as long
as you get what you need in the day.
There's a caveat for that. Because as
you get older and you're more resistant
to protein intake, try to get it as
close to the end of exercise as you can,
because that's going to really enhance
those post-exercise mechanisms for
muscle repair, tendon repair, all of the
things that we think about with protein
intake.
>> And that's more particularly acute for
women versus men.
>> We see, yeah, because the metabolism
aspect for women post-exercise comes
back down to baseline a way faster than
men. We see that for women, we're back
down to a euglycemic or a a blood
glucose control of baseline within about
90 minutes. For men, it's 2 to 18 hours,
depending on what they've done.
>> So more important to make sure that
you're replenishing your protein
post-workout,
uh
in that 30 to 60-minute window, then it
that's more important than it is for
men.
>> Yes, and the other thing is women tend
to undereat anyway. So, if we're looking
at let's nail food before and after
exercise, then we can make sure we're
keeping you out of signals for low
energy availability.
I know Emily Dr. Emily Kraus is here and
she does a lot of work in RED-S and low
energy.
And the eating opportunities that are
available, we look at every eating
opportunity. Most people are like,
"Yeah, post-exercise I should eat. What
do I eat? When do I eat it?" It's like,
"Okay, well, let's make sure we really
maximize that post-exercise eating
window to help eliminate low energy
availability."
>> No fasted training.
>> Correct.
>> Say you.
>> Yes.
>> Yeah, this is another controversial
flash point
for you on at least as far as the
internet goes. Yeah.
>> Yeah, exactly.
>> And that's that's that's sort of
flies in the face of somebody who's
thinking, "Well, if I'm trying to lose
weight." Like if if weight loss is like
what's guiding those decisions, like I
should just get up and get after it
without eating anything and then just,
you know, try to
manage portion control throughout the
day. Of course,
your appetite is going to spike in the
aftermath of that and you're depriving
the body of the nutrients it needs to
basically create like a a stasis point,
right? And repair itself.
>> Exactly. And I mean, when you think
about why are you going to do exercise?
You're not getting fitter in the
exercise session. You're trying to
create a stress.
And the stronger that stress is, the
better your body adapts. So, if you're
going to create a stress without food,
you're not going to create a really
strong stress. You feel like you are,
but from the body from a cellular level,
it's not as strong
of a stress to create the adaptation
that you want. You're going to have more
catecholamines, so that's your cortisol
and your breakdown hormones that are
being produced so that it can fuel your
workout. But let's just take that
negative stress away by putting a little
bit of food in before you go training so
that you can really maximize the
exercise stress and then get the
adaptations that you want from the
post-exercise recovery.
>> Your critics out there
say that your position on fasted
training or just intermittent fasting in
general for women is is not supported by
the evidence. So I wanted to give you an
opportunity to respond to that. Like
what is your What do you say to that?
>> Yeah, there's also the rumor that only
cite rodent studies and that's not true
either.
Um so when we're looking at the evidence
for fasting and fasted training,
most of the stuff that people are coming
out with, yeah, you should do fasted
training, it doesn't matter, you should
do intermittent fasting, is still guided
by male data. You go into the chat GDP,
it tells you the same thing. Why?
Because there's this echo chamber in the
bell curve that's just pulling up the
rhetoric that everyone is talking about.
When we go into the research and we're
looking specifically from things like
endocrinology and we're looking at
fertility and we're looking at
population research where the appetite
and appetite control, it all gravitates
to women do better in a fed state. We
look at the studies that have been done
in the sports science world, there
aren't a lot, but there are ones that
are done, it still points to women do
better in a fed state. We have this
variation in appetite and appetite
control, like I was talking about with
chronobiology. We look at the exercise
stress points and how people adapt and
we see that women, their bodies respond
when there's fuel on board. We look at
the people that are pushing out, well,
she's not based on evidence, it's
because they're looking at that bell
curve as of just sports science
evidence. There's so much more to
exercise training, appetite than this
really small amount of sports science
research. So, I'm always like, here's
the evidence. It's not coming from the
Journal of Sport and Exercise Science.
No, it's coming from endocrinology, or
it's coming from this population, but
these are randomized controlled trials.
This shows the the variation of of
exercise versus fed, and here is the
evidence. And I give that to them, and
they'll still critique.
>> So, maybe just
walk us through a
a day in your life of eating. Like, what
does that What does that look like?
You're like, oh, you should feed before
you work out and after, and all of that.
But, like, what are you doing
specifically?
>> Yeah, so there's the ideal, and then
there's reality. And I'm more than happy
to share reality, because I'm
I'm here, and I don't eat very well when
I'm stressed.
>> real. This is reality, Stacy.
>> is reality.
>> a real moment.
>> I know we are. So, um regardless where I
am, I do get up, and I have something
first thing in the morning. That's where
the protein coffee thing came in, cuz
people were always asking, "What do you
have first thing in the morning if
you're going to go swimming or
training?" I'm like, I'm not hungry. I
know most people in the 5:00 and 6:00
a.m. club aren't hungry, but I love
coffee, and I want to maximize that. So,
I'm also going to put in some protein
and some almond milk, so that I'm
getting some protein and eating some
carbohydrate. And that's how the protein
coffee thing became a thing.
It doesn't mean that you have to do it.
There's no evidence behind it, but it's
what I do.
Because then I get a boost of protein,
some carbohydrate. I'm going into a
training session.
I can maximize my training, and I have
caffeine, and everyone loves that, well,
for the most part. Then I come home, and
I have real breakfast. And I try to have
it with my daughter before she goes to
school.
I'll have
uh a bowl of overnight oats with some
chia seeds and some nuts. Um might put
in um some protein powder. I'll have
another espresso.
And then I get on with my day. Lunch is
a variation of a Buddha bowl. Afternoon,
as we call it in New Zealand, afternoon
tea when you come home from school.
Um is another variation of nuts and
veggies, crackers, hummus, and then we
have dinner. And my husband isn't
plant-based.
My daughter isn't either, but we all
start with the base of the same thing.
So, it is um more of the Buddha bowl
where you're having different grains,
you're having different veggies, you're
having different greens. Um then I put
in some roasted uh sweet potato or other
roasted veggies, some tempeh, edamame,
some garbanzo beans, and then I'll put
tahini on top as my dressing.
Cuz I'm not a big fan of salad dressing,
but I love tahini and then mix it all in
and some avocado, and then there's a
bowl of about 40 g of protein and some
fat, and it's great.
And then later I'll have some dark
chocolate cuz I love dark chocolate.
>> I mean, that all sounds like very doable
and reasonable.
>> Yeah.
>> You know, and I think when you see uh
1.1 g of protein per pound of
body weight, like that's intimidating.
That sounds like a lot, but walking
through like what you eat in a day, I'm
like, yeah, that sounds basically like
what I do without really thinking about
it. It's not like
it takes some kind of ultra focus on the
protein aspect of this to meet that
requirement.
>> No. And also leaning into like fiber and
30 different plants a week.
>> Diversity.
>> Right? And so, it's like if we can get
protein and fiber at every eating
opportunity, people get what they need
in a day. They get the higher protein
intake. They get the diversity. They get
the fiber. Let's not make it difficult.
I
quote the research, and those are all in
numbers, but the reality is it's pretty
easy if you're thinking I just want
regular normal food.
>> people like to make it difficult. They
want to make it difficult.
>> People like to pick fights. They like to
make it difficult.
>> Um supplements.
>> Yeah.
>> Let's talk about creatine. This is
another topic that's there's a lot of
discourse happening right now around
this.
This supplement that's been around
forever kind of began in the
bodybuilding world and now has made its
way into mainstream discourse.
Uh
Uh and there's a lot of discussion
around amounts. So, first maybe
explain what creatine is, what it does,
and how one should think about uh using
it.
>> Yes, so creatine if we're thinking and
I'll get a little bit biochemical right
now, we're talking about fast
energetics. The first 0 to 20 seconds of
inner any cellular process um requires
creatine because we have
ATP and CP. So, that's adenosine
triphosphate and creatine phosphate. So,
when ATP splits to produce energy, you
have this
floating thing that then gets taken up
by creatine.
So, when we're looking at why we need
creatine, we need it for every fast
energetic in the body. Anything about
the brain, the heart, the gut, the bone,
everything requires creatine.
Um for women, by the nature of being
women, we have less lean mass than men
for the most part. So, we have less
stores
um
just by the lean mass part of it. We
also tend not to eat as much creatine
containing foods, which we think about
you have to eat five chicken breasts to
get your, you know, dose of 5 to 6 g of
creatine.
If we're looking at supplementing, we
know a lot from Darren Candow's work and
Abby Smith-Ryan's work that it takes
about 3 weeks to saturate the body with
3 to 5 g. So, what does that mean? When
you're fully saturating, your body has
more availability for those fast
energetics. The brain works better, the
heart works better. We see that we have
better um mucosal lining integrity. So,
the very first thing that erodes when
you start exercising or get stressed is
the mucosal lining of our intestinal
cells. And if we don't keep that, then
we know that we get some endotoxin
release, which people call leaky gut. We
see more of an IBS situation for women
that are running. So, if we're just
boosting the levels of creatine and have
more available for all the fast
energetics, then the body works a little
bit better.
Um you can not use it, and that's fine.
Your body naturally produces 1 to 3 g a
day from the liver, but we want to
maximize and optimize, and that's where
the research is coming where we're like,
"Okay, every fast energetic works really
well." We see now from brain research
and TBI or concussion research that
creatine becomes really important for
improving brain metabolism and helping
getting over the concussion. Why is
that? Cuz it's trying to repair itself,
as well as still function. So, improving
um the amount of creatine is available,
it can do all the fast energetics it
needs.
We see that for um building bone, we
need some creatine, it's part of the
fast energetics.
So, we're starting to see all this
research come out, and there's a
systematic review that was published 2
weeks ago that was looking at all the
studies not in the fitness world, but
actually in the health world of the
studies that have come out to synthesize
who should optimize their health by
using creatine.
There are 153 studies in the systematic
review. Of it, the conclusion was women
18 to 60 should be using 3 to 5 g of
creatine supplementation to optimize and
improve overall health.
And so, that's where the research is
leaning into. Yes, you have outliers
like, if you're a shift worker or jet
lag or if you have overnight combat
missions, then there's a time and a
place to use higher doses. I think the
circulation is 0.38 g per kilogram,
which ends up being about 20 g for a
130-lb person.
So, there's variations within it, but
for the baseline to improve fast
energetics and overall mood, heart,
brain, all those things, it's just 3 to
5 g.
>> Uh yeah, the the the conversation now is
sort of creatine maxing, you know, like
oh if you didn't sleep well or you're
jet lagged
take 20 g and it will compensate for
that. It will give you some degree of
mental acuity to overcome the the lag in
your sleep.
>> Yes, but it takes more time for the
creatine to cross blood-brain barrier.
So an acute dose actually isn't
effective on that acute time. You need
to do it dosing up to knowing when you
are going to be traveling.
>> so you have to you have to uh you have
to predict the future and take it before
you have the night of sleep where you're
not going to sleep.
>> So consistently consistently take low
dose so it helps, but yeah.
>> Is this something that should be cycled
or is it safe to just take if you're
taking like 5 g a day, just do that?
>> it, yeah. We look at cycling creatine in
the higher doses and that's a lean into
the bodybuilding muscle performance side
of things where was 5 g four times a day
with 20 g of carb to really maximize
what's in the muscle then cycle it off
to lose some of the water weight and
then cycle it back on for different
training modalities. So we're looking at
cycling on the lower doses, it's it's a
kind of a moot point because when we
look it takes 3 weeks for your body to
fully saturate and then if people cycle
off it then it comes back down to
baseline. So if you're just taking that
continuous low dose, your body fully
saturates and then stays there.
>> The same woman who has the concern about
getting too bulky from
lifting heavy weights may have this
concern around creatine that it's going
to lead to bloating and water retention
and there's a you know, there's some
other things that come with that. You
can get
you know, like some diarrhea, some stuff
like that. So what do you what do you
say to that person?
>> There are two things that we want to
kind of nip in the bud here. First is
how much is she starting with? Because a
lot of women who start with a 5 g dose
and they're smaller in physique, then
they might have retention because with
creatine you're also storing more water
in the muscle, so that's a given. It's
transient. It It will go by the wayside
within 2 to 3 weeks and most women who
are freaking out about bloating and and
water retention are they don't want to
wait the 3 weeks. So, let's start at a
smaller dose. Let's start with 1 to 1
and 1/2 g and work our way up to the 5 g
over the course of a month. That way
your body is starting to saturate, it's
getting used to it, you don't get the
bloating and the side effects.
The other one that's really critical is
the quality of the creatine that you're
using.
The cheaper versions of creatine use
more of an acid wash and so we're
looking at the residual acids that are
in there, it's not that great, it causes
side effects. So, the higher qualities
like our good friends Momentous, they
use a water wash. And that reduces any
kind of the residuals that cause side
effects. So, first make sure you have a
high quality and two, let's start with a
lower dose and work our way up because
we're not looking for an acute hit here,
we're looking at how are we going to
saturate and really improve and optimize
over time.
>> Any burning creatine questions out
there?
>> I have a question about creatine in
different stages of your life. So, you
know, you talked about perimenopause
or on a fertility journey, if you're
pregnant, like
what is like the optimal time and are
there times to avoid using it?
>> Um so, there's even been pregnancy
research that shows that um
supplementing with creatine is
beneficial. So, we look at creatine is
beneficial across the whole lifespan.
There are individual cases where it's
like
if you're iron deficient with
endometriosis,
it's probably not a good idea because
there's an interplay between some of our
fair potions and and and things that
affect iron absorption
and increasing endometrial cell
proliferation. So there's some small
research that suggests that. So then
that becomes more of an individual
case-by-case. Let's see what are your
symptoms? Are you iron deficient? How
severe is endometriosis? So yes, there
are causes and cases within each that we
have to be aware of but in general
you are safe to take creatine across the
lifespan.
>> Other than creatine, what are the other
supplements
that you would suggest
women
be taking
and maybe some supplements that they
should be avoiding?
>> So I will also say vitamin D3 is really
important
for those of us that live in the
extremities of the hemispheres. It's
really important in the low light for
people who live in places like Seattle
where you have winters that are super
gray as well.
And just in general get your vitamin D
levels checked because we know that low
vitamin D
is associated with more severe PMS and
PMDD in women, more severe
perimenopausal symptoms. We also see
this is oppression immunity. We also see
vitamin D is really important for things
like bone and bone density. So it is
pretty important. It works as a hormone
within the body to facilitate a lot of
the responses. We also see that women
who have low iron and low ferritin also
tend to be low in vitamin D.
So in general I tell women just taking a
vitamin D supplement will help boost. If
you are worried about having super high
vitamin D levels, get tested first.
Then we start looking at what you should
not take. We see that there that
like nitric oxide is a very widely used
one for sport performance. We see oh
yeah, it's a vasodilator. We know from
the research that it doesn't work in
premenopausal women, but it works really
well in postmenopausal women.
Because estradiol or estrogen is really
tightly tied to
endothelial cell function. So, that's
the lining of our capillaries or
our blood vessels. So, when we start
introducing nitric oxide, it interferes
with the natural response.
So, premenopausal women who have
adequate estrogen will have a negative
response. They don't have as much
vasodilation. They might end up having
more of an orthostatic like uh
stand up with head rushes. So,
orthostatic hypo- hypotension, so low
blood pressure.
But women who are postmenopause who
don't have estradiol on board benefit
greatly. They have improvement in
circulation. They get really good
vasodilation. We see women in late
perimenopause with severe hot flashes
can have some benefit by using nitric
oxide cuz it helps with the vasodilation
constriction. So, there's like this is
the efficacy of
knowing that there's been research done
in women in in the supplement. A lot of
the other supplements haven't been
studied in women.
So, we're looking at beta-alanine.
There has been very few studies done in
women. So, a lot of the sport
performance supplements haven't been
studied, but we know that protein
supplementation has been studied. It's
beneficial for women. We know that
vitamin D has been and omega-3s have
been. So, most of our general health
ones that are promoted have been studied
in women and are beneficial.
>> On that topic, uh of all the things that
you shared today,
uh what
uh where is like the the strongest
evidentiary basis and where is the
evidence like more emergent where we
need more research?
>> For women?
>> Yeah.
>> Across the board, I'd say we need more
research in everything.
>> With that as a baseline.
>> Okay. As that is a baseline.
>> Yeah.
>> Within that world,
um
you know,
you've shared a lot of insights today uh
and I'm sure there's a spectrum in terms
of like what's what's, you know, where
there's enough kind of evidentiary basis
and where you would like to see more
studies being done.
>> Yeah, I think um for the most part, I
really want people to understand there's
a significant division line between
what's clinical
and what's health and fitness and there
tends to be this blur.
So, if we're like dividing the line down
and going, "Okay, from optimization
health and fitness, everything that I've
talked about has evidence behind it." Um
what do I want to see more of? I want to
see more research in um strength
training and how does the methods within
the health and fitness world crossover
to the clinical instead of everything in
clinical crossover into the health and
fitness.
So,
uh for example,
I won't say who has given us the grant
cuz it hasn't been announced yet, but we
now have a grant to look at strength
training in prevention and the heavier
end of things. So, like that kind of
stuff, I want the merger from high
performance to come over, especially in
women. So, we have some pretty good
tight controlled studies in high
performance because when we're in that
world, we can really garner and
leverage. When the clinical world with
the randomized controlled trials,
we can't really generalize. We can say
in this population of pre-diabetics, we
know that this works in women like here.
But then the biggest thing is we need
more diversity in all research. I was on
the stage this weekend at a longevity
and women's health summit and someone
stands up and says, "As a black woman,
my symptomatology is is more apparent
and I've heard that it's worse for
perimenopausal symptoms in black women."
And
there is Jessica Shepherd and she's
like, "Yes, this is true, but no one
really knows it." And I'm like, "I'm a
white woman and I know that most of the
research that's been done has been done
on white upper-class women. So,
regardless of if it's clinical or if
it's health, we need to be able to look
at other populations.
The idea of a human ovary or naturally
cycling woman with really spot-on
periods and menstrual cycles, no pun
intended, is rare.
So, when we start saying we need to do
um really tight controlled trials on
women with menstrual cycles that are X
amount of days and we know that have
specific phases, it's a very very very
very very small population that can't be
generalized out. So, we have to look at
those nuances, too.
So, what is the big foundation of
evidence?
We look and say, "Okay, well, let's look
at the methods first." And what is that
and where does it come from? Can I say
what has a lot of robust research? A lot
of the stuff that has the the population
research and the anecdotal studies as
well as some of the randomized control
trials. So, we see that in muscle
development. We see that in bone
development. We see that in sleep and
mood. But, every area needs more
research and every area needs to be more
diverse in the population of the
research.
>> If funding wasn't an issue, there's no
budgetary constraints, what is the dream
research
project that you would like to see
happen? Like, how would you design a
study that would answer your most
pressing questions?
>> Uh
I don't I have so many pressing
questions.
I don't think there's enough money in
the world to answer them. Well, no,
there's money.
>> Just pick one then.
>> There's money in the world, but it's the
time factor.
So,
um
I I think it changes. Like, right now
I'm really interested in
heat and how we see an increase in
ovarian function after controlled heat
exposure.
So, I'd like to do a really large study
on a whole bunch of different
ethnicities and cultural nuances in
women who are having fertility issues.
Cuz if we see that post-controlled
hypothermia, we have an increase in
estradiol, luteinizing hormone, and
follicle-stimulating hormone,
can we get that to a point where we can
use that as fertility treatment?
So, that's one really massive pressing
question I have right now. So, if anyone
wants to fund that and has a team that
could research it.
So, it's like looking at these
environmental conditions that the world
is now entering into. We have severe
heat, we have severe cold. How's that
affecting different pockets of
populations with the big fertility
issue? Like, that's not something that
someone like me coming from high
performances as an environmental
exercise physiologist would really come
out with, but I'm really concerned. I'm
like, "Okay, well, we know this happens
in controlled heat, but we also see this
whole change in the global environment
and this uptick in infertility. Well,
let's see what happens if we're using
these little things to our advantage."
So, that would probably be a big
pressing question because if we're
killing off the human race
because of things that we're not doing
right, well, is that a good thing or
not? Maybe that's the bigger plan for
whatever is out there, but right now I'm
like, I want to be able to make an
impact and really investigate this with
regards to what's happening from a
global impact as well as a population
impact.
>> I don't know if you all know this, but
last year Stacy appeared on
some of the biggest podcasts in the
world, Diary of a CEO, Mel Robbins,
Huberman You did Huberman, so yeah. And
not only
was she a star guest on these shows.
>> Thanks.
>> Your episodes on those shows were the
most viewed or listened to like for that
show for that year, which is kind of an
amazing thing, right? So, it it really
catapulted you, you know, into like this
different kind of sphere of influence
in your areas of expertise.
But I'm curious like what is the what is
the question that you're not being asked
or that you wish you were being asked
that that just doesn't come up in these
sorts of scenarios?
>> Yeah. Um
one I can't believe that that's happened
cuz I'm still like Jiro's mom and I
still like to like do research and I
like to help people. So when I'm stopped
in the bathroom washing my hands, "Oh my
god, you're Dr. Stacy." I'm like, "Who's
that person?"
And so it's just been like this big
push.
I think one of the conversations that
has been had is the optimization versus
general. And we had that today. So I
thank you for that. It's like what are
we doing to optimize health and what are
we doing just to improve health? And
those are the nuances.
>> Performance and longevity and general
health are are, you know, sometimes
contradictory.
>> Right, exactly. It's like what you do to
help someone win an Olympic gold is
completely different than what you would
do for someone who's just trying to
optimize their health for
a long period of time. But a lot of
times that research and those
conversations get blurred. So again,
thank you for asking about optimization
versus general cuz that is is something
that hasn't been asked.
>> One question I want to ask you is what
do you what can you share with men to
help them understand the women in their
lives to support them?
Like this is a mystery box, you know,
for someone like myself and you know,
it's just like there should be a woman
up here into talking to you about this,
not a guy, but I want to understand and
you know, just as a as a sort of an
avatar of all men out there like help me
understand how to, you know, be as
supportive as possible and that comes
with greater understanding, of course,
but you know, help us out.
>> Yeah, well, first we need men in the
conversation. So you should be in that
chair interviewing, not a woman. So, I
appreciate that, too, and all the men
here in the audience.
Um cuz the more we understand, the more
we can be supportive. It's like
if your wife comes to you and is like,
"I'm having this horrible time. I have
severe anxiety." It's like just listen.
Just like I was talking about with his
daughter and being a a girl dad. It's
like, "Listen.
You don't try to fix." Cuz that becomes
a problem where women feel like they go
to talk to their partner and their
partner's listening to fix something,
not listening to be empathetic. Um and I
also want to I'm not doing this to
promote, but I'm doing it to to say that
Joe Warner is uh a guy in the UK who
used to work for Men's Health. He's a
journalist. And we had a podcast episode
and he was really like wanting to know
more about the perimenopausal journey
for his partner. And he interviewed a
whole bunch of experts and he just
released a book. It's called um
Frozen Out and Burning Up. And it's to
help men understand what's going on and
how to listen to their wives and help
them. So, there are more and more
resources coming up, too, but I think
the bottom line is listening,
understanding, and trying to be
empathetic, and not trying to fix.
>> Awesome. Let's put it out for any
questions before we wrap it up.
>> This is a little bit of a follow-up to
the creatine conversation. Um
I have two daughters and they are
athletes. So, I think
my curiosity and question really is more
about what
how should we guide female athletes,
young female athletes, on this journey
in terms of supplementation, nutrition,
um understanding. What would be your
suggestion
there?
>> I I would refer to the FASTER Women's
Program at Stanford.
Um but in general, when we talk about
it, we want to change that diet culture.
Like we don't want to introduce that.
So, we're talking to our young female
athletes, it's all about fuel for what
you're doing. If you are fueling your
body, you're becoming stronger, you're
becoming more resilient. And then we
also have to think about the mental
mental stress of of trying to grow,
develop,
understand your personality, and become
part of this world. So, it's also having
the eye to what is the mental status
today? Like how am I talking to my
daughter? How am I using empowering
language instead of negative language?
Um when we're looking at a sporting
culture as well, unfortunately, the
default is to be compared to boys. We
see this in coaching and
and it's really disheartening for girls
to always be
compared to that norm. So, if we're
trying to change the sporting culture,
we're trying to encourage our girls,
it's talking about being fueled, it's
talking about being fast and powerful
and strong. And all of that positive
language and not talking about oh,
calories. Oh, you need to eat this. It's
not about that. It's like, let's put it
in that performance space. Let's talk to
them like they are athletes, cuz they
are. You need to eat enough, you need to
fuel for your training, you need to fuel
for your brain, you need to fuel for
your endocrine system. It's all about
fueling, because your body is growing,
you're learning, you want to be the best
that you can be in your sport, and you
want to do all of these things. We need
fuel for that.
>> Would you suggest supplementation as
they start to get more serious about
their sport, depending on their sport?
>> I would I would hesitate to say yes.
It's trying to do real food first,
because the problem with it, even though
there is some evidence that creatine
helps in young girls,
and protein supplementation helps, but
then it opens the whole Pandora's box.
And we want to not we want the training
to come through for adaptation. We want
the fuel to come through for supporting
that adaptation.
I always think about when I was back in
the day when Interbike was in Las Vegas.
I was sharing a cab back to the airport
and this guy got in and he didn't look
healthy at all and he was talking about
how he's going to go to a bike on a bike
ride, but he had to use his beta alanine
and beet juice first.
And I was like, "What are you talking?"
And he goes, "Oh, yeah, well, that's how
I can go hard on my bike." I was like,
"Have you tried training without?" He
goes, "Why would I do that?" And I was
like, "Okay.
Where do I start?" But cuz that is an
enhancement. We want your body to
understand first before you try to
enhance. Hi Stacy.
>> And hello Dr. Kraus. Thanks for the
shout-outs. Um I I am surprised this
question hasn't come up yet, but want to
ask about wearables.
>> Oh, yeah.
>> Oh, yeah. There are a lot There's a lot
of data out there and it can be
overwhelming for women to interpret
whether it's sleep, whether it's
recovery. Sometimes um some athletes
have unhealthy relationships with data.
So, what do you recommend as far as
wearables and how we can interpret
wearables as as girls and women?
>> So, first and foremost when we look at
wearables, the algorithms are based on
male data.
And I like to use the example of heart
rate variability. How many people have a
wearable and pay attention to heart rate
variability? Yeah, okay.
So, there are a lot of women who are
like, "What's going on? My Garmin's
yelling at me. You're in the red. What's
going on? What's going on? You're sick.
You're sick." But actually, they just
ovulated. And these algorithms are not
picking up the fact that
when we look at physiology for women,
there's an inherent change across the
menstrual cycle with regards to
autonomic nervous system. So, we know
after ovulation with progesterone, our
respiratory rate comes up.
Our resting heart rate comes up. Our
heart rate variability goes down. the
algorithms read it as you're not
recovered.
So, when I tell women with the
wearables, look at it trends over time
so that you can compare your follicular
to follicular or in perimenopause, you
can see things going all over the show
knowing that after you get through
perimenopause, you have a new baseline.
So, really you're just looking for
trends over time. With sleep and sleep
architecture, they're not fine enough to
actually pick up sleep architecture.
The benefit of using a wearable
overnight that I find for women is if
they don't eat enough, they have a lot
of awakenings at night from
hypoglycemia.
So, you're having a lot of poor sleep
and you're like, "Oh, I've got a lot of
awakenings." It could be you haven't
fueled well enough in the day and you're
getting hypoglycemic when you're
sleeping. We see this in some of the C
the seam
the continuous glucose monitor CGMs that
that are being used. So, there is
usefulness in them, but only for trends
over time.
>> I really appreciate that you spoke about
not fearing perimenopause.
I'm definitely still a little scared of
it.
>> Don't be.
>> How can women know that they're entering
that phase? Like, what what are the
signals that will specifically tell you
that you're you've entered that? And if
you could boil it down to one thing,
like what's the first thing to tackle
when when you do enter that phase?
>> There isn't any one like bell that goes
ding ding ding, you're in perimenopause.
It could start as early in your mid-30s.
Maybe it doesn't start until you're in
your mid-40s with regards to
symptomatology.
But, we knew do know that you have more
and more an ovulatory cycles as you get
older. So, we generally say that once
you hit 40, then we know you're in
perimenopause.
It's a rough guide. Some people have
really severe limiting symptomatology.
Some people breeze through until like
the last couple of years before that one
point in menopause hits. But it's a it's
a significant individual journey and
although everybody who's born with a
uterus goes through it, we're still not
sure why.
Why do we have this ovarian wind-down?
Why are we having all these changes?
And what are the definitive tests that
we can do? We don't have those. So it is
an individual journey.
Um if you're like, I'm starting to be
really anxious and I'm not sleeping,
that's probably perimenopause.
You are finding more soft tissue
injuries, that's most likely
perimenopause.
One of the big tells for runners is they
start getting more and more plantar
fascia issues
because we start having disruption in
tendon um tensile strength and we are
getting weaker in our calf muscles
because we lose strength and power
first. So we start getting more and more
tendinopathies and soft tissue injuries.
So all of those are in line with yes,
you're perimenopausal.
But don't be afraid cuz there's lots of
things you can do.
>> I'd like to follow up on these two
questions. I'm Rachel. Um so I'm a
researcher and I do a lot of diagnostic
testing in my labs. So you've mentioned
many of the tests, the blood tests
specifically. And these are becoming
more and more available in the
commercial space. Everybody's talking
about testing 9,642
biomarkers.
Um particularly hormones and I'm
wondering if you have blood tests that
you recommend and if you do, how
regularly you think that you should be
getting them? Thinking about the
difference between what you're calling
out as general health and maybe some of
the more sophisticated things that you
or I might like to do in the lab.
>> Yeah, I'm not a fan of hormone testing
because it's just giving a snapshot of
that time of day. If you're really to
optimize getting something like
estrogen, you have to know day two.
Well, women's cycles are all over the
place. so I really don't put stock in
getting hormone testing unless you have
fertility issues.
Um, when we look at blood tests, I find
it it really useful to have things like
ferritin and to know your baseline
cholesterol. We also look at CRP, so
some of the basic inflammatory markers
we want to keep track of.
Uh, one of the the tells for
perimenopause actually is a change in
your cholesterol and you have an an
increase in LDL.
So, we see this you haven't had any
cholesterol problems all and then all of
a sudden your LDL is elevated and your
HDL has dropped out. And then you're
told, "Oh, you need to eat more fiber."
Actually, it's perimenopause. What do we
do about that? So, having a baseline of
just your basic blood tests for trends
over time is very useful cuz if you
start having symptoms and you go get a
blood test, that's just telling you that
one point in time confirming something
you already know, but you don't know
what your previous normal was. So,
that's why I tell women it's like, "Get
a DEXA every year. Know what your bone
mineral density is. Know what your body
composition is. Hold on to that."
Get your ferritin tested every 3 to 6
months if you have a history of low
ferritin.
Keep track of your cholesterol every
year. See your CRP. Get your vitamin D
tested at the beginning and end of sum
um the season, so end of summer and the
beginning and end of winter. So, just
small things to be able to optimize, but
you don't have to go spend $500 a month
to get all these biomarkers uh because
we just need to take care of the
baselines first. I love cold plunging.
>> Okay. Is it inherently bad for me if I'm
doing it at like I normally it's like
45° F, which is like 7° C, but like is
that inherently bad?
>> It's not It's not bad for you. It's if
you've already acclimatized to it,
great. I'm not going to tell you not to
do it. But for all the rhetoric of every
woman needs to do really cold ice baths,
It's intimidating because you don't have
to.
There are other things like if you're
already doing it, great.
If you're a cold water ocean swimmer,
it's really beneficial so you can keep
doing it. But if you're someone who's
looking to optimize health and you're
trying to see what environmental
stressors do, cool water if you want to
examine that. But for the most part, I
try to push women to the sauna.
But other people are like, I can't
handle the heat. I was like, okay, well,
maybe cool water plunge is good for you.
If you're already doing ice and you're
already doing cold, your body's adapted.
It's fine. But maybe you also want to
add sauna to get some better health
benefits.
>> Oh, I've got the sauna, too. Perfect.
>> Yeah.
>> I find I have so many women in my life
who um have mysterious chronic illnesses
or women's health issues and they're
exhausted by it. They come into clinical
settings where they are not believed or
it doesn't feel like the doctors are
necessarily
asking the right questions.
Um
what's your advice? I I hear you speak
today and I actually have so much hope
and excitement for where women's health
are going now that we're included in
studies. But for today, we are still in
that sticky period. What are ways that
we can
advocate for ourselves in these clinical
spaces and advocate for ourselves
outside of these clinical spaces?
>> Yeah, so um
I come from a cuz I don't live in the
states, so I navigate a different kind
of environment with regards to health
care where we can go and advocate and
say, I want to I want to get a DEXA and
you can either pay out of pocket for
like 100 bucks or you can get a referral
and wait 3 weeks to get it. Here is
completely different.
So when we're looking at advocating for
ourselves is having conversations. It's
empowering each other as women. It's um
talking to your physician and saying,
these are things I have. I'm not Dr.
Google, but I have been talking to the
other women that's similar and you just
really try to be on the level of the
conversation.
And there's not a lot of time. It's like
maybe 15 minutes of an appointment. So,
if you can go in and and have a a more
of an empowerment approach. Cuz I'll
talk to physicians that like 15 minutes
isn't enough because I don't know what
the history is. I don't know what
they've tried. I don't know if they've
Googled it. I don't know. So, the more
information that you can provide and you
can bring in scientific articles or
whatever just to put them on the right
track is very helpful. Both they learn
and two they realize that you're coming
in with something that's genuine. You're
not just coming in as a hypochondriac.
The other thing is to look at the
physicians that are available that are
in the know in this space. So, if you're
looking for female fertility issues, you
go to someone like Natalie Crawford
who's in Texas, but you can also see her
list of friends and and her network
across. If you are an endurance athlete
and you're having issues, you can again
at Emily's program at Stanford and see
what her network is. So, we're all
coming together and creating these
networks. It's just trying to figure out
who's the person to follow and that's
where the conversations can really be
beneficial.
>> Hi, I'm Julie.
>> Hi.
>> Um
in the large world of peptides,
>> Oh, yes.
>> have any input on that?
>> We were just having conversations about
this.
So, um in the large world of peptides, I
really lean into there's no evidence for
them and it's the wild wild west right
now. Um they're not regulated. I think
someone was telling me that they just
read a New York Times article that the
peptides in general bought from
reputable places still had a lot of lead
and things in them.
So, it's like you don't really know what
you're injecting cuz they aren't
controlled. They're for research
purposes only.
Most of the research that's been done on
the peptides are still rodent studies.
They're very very small like in a five
or six men. So, we don't have any of the
robust research. I'm hopeful because
people are putting such stock in it that
there is going to be more research.
We know that GLP-1 is a peptide and
there's lots of research going on
because of all the benefits there and
that's kind of the push for all these
other peptides. So, the bigger demand
there is, the more research is going to
go into it. It's just kind of a holding
pattern.
Let other people be lab rats for
themselves while you see what happens
and then you can make a decision.
>> Thank you.
>> You're welcome.
>> Hi. Um we talked about strength training
as part of this conversation and you've
expressed the need for women to really
lift heavy.
What is heavy? Like how should a woman
think about where they should be
targeting with that?
>> Yeah, so um
I often tell women if they're first
starting their strength training
journey, I don't want them think about
lifting heavy.
I want them to go in and just
just do any kind of strength training.
Get the resilience, get the gains and
then when we start looking at increasing
load, when we talk about lifting heavy
on a scale of 1 to 10, the effort needs
to be about an eight or if you go pick
up a dumbbell or barbell and you can do
five or six reps really well with
really, really good form and you think
maybe you could do one or two more,
that's where you stop. Cuz it is very
relative.
>> Thank you.
>> Yeah.
>> Stacie, I just wanted to acknowledge you
for
uh the tremendous public service that uh
you are providing people. You're you're
a powerful and important voice. Uh we
need more women uh like you out there
who are
advancing women's health and I just want
to commend you for the work that you're
doing and uh I appreciate you coming
here and sharing so openly with all of
us. So, thank you.
>> Thank you.
>> Yes, let's hear it for Dr. Stacy Sims,
everybody.
Thank you.
And thanks for coming.
Cool.
>> Yeah, thanks for coming.
>> Yeah, sure.
>> Woo.
Woo.