Submind YouTube summaries
Thumbnail for Why Women Cheat - Macken Murphy

Why Women Cheat - Macken Murphy

Watch on YouTube

Video summary

The podcast explores the primary motivations behind female infidelity, challenging the notion that all women's affairs are driven solely by a dual mating strategy focused on pairing good genes with high investment. Data indicates that relationship dissatisfaction is a top driver for many women, specifically when they perceive their partners as uninvested; approximately 20% of respondents cited this lack of partner investment as a primary reason for cheating. This statistic suggests that not all female affairs stem from genetic diversification or fertility backup strategies, but rather often signal a pragmatic concern regarding the stability and commitment within the relationship. The speaker notes that while some women do pursue new partners to secure both genes and resources simultaneously, this does not account for every instance of infidelity among women. Revenge is identified as another significant factor in female cheating, accounting for roughly 15.5% of cases where women admitted to having an affair specifically because their partner had cheated on them first. Although the speaker acknowledges that men generally cheat more frequently than women and report being less likely to be cheated upon themselves, there remains a substantial truth to the idea that women often retaliate in response to male infidelity. This dynamic may reflect both genuine strategic retaliation and statistical opportunities, as higher rates of male cheating provide women with more frequent occasions to cite revenge as a motivation for their own actions. Consequently, while men are statistically more likely to initiate affairs across various cultural contexts, the reasons behind female participation often differ significantly from those driving male behavior. The discussion delves into evolutionary psychology concepts such as obligate versus optional investment in offspring, explaining why women might be particularly sensitive to cues of low partner commitment. Because women face biological constraints like pregnancy and lactation, their reproductive strategy involves a high degree of obligatory investment, making them naturally choosy about mates who can provide resources and stability. In contrast, men's investment is pragmatically optional, allowing for the possibility of "seduce and abandon" strategies without immediate physical consequences to themselves. When a woman perceives that her partner is not investing in the relationship or signaling an intent to leave, it serves as a strong indicator of potential mate switching or breakup, prompting some women to seek new partners who can offer both genetic quality and necessary investment before their lineage ends. The episode also addresses the concept of "mate poaching" success rates among women versus men, noting that while overall infidelity is more common in males, female cheaters often have a higher hit rate when attempting to secure new relationships involving three parties: the primary partner, the cheating individual, and the affair partner. The speaker clarifies that dual mating theory does not explain all instances of female infidelity; instead, it coexists with other motivations like revenge and dissatisfaction stemming from uninvested partners. Furthermore, the transcript highlights a specific case where women who feel their current relationship lacks investment are more likely to pivot toward an affair partner as a new primary relationship, effectively lowering the cost of leaving for genetic or resource-based reasons. The conversation concludes by emphasizing that female infidelity is multifaceted and cannot be reduced to a single evolutionary explanation like dual mating strategies alone. While some women do engage in mate switching to secure better genes or resources when their current partner fails to invest, others cheat primarily due to emotional dissatisfaction or as retaliation for their own partners' unfaithfulness. The speaker uses these insights to illustrate the complexity of human relationships and infidelity dynamics, suggesting that understanding the distinction between obligate female investment and optional male investment helps explain why women are often more cautious about who they mate with yet still susceptible to leaving a relationship if it lacks sufficient commitment. Ultimately, the data supports a nuanced view where biological imperatives intersect with social realities like revenge and perceived partner neglect.
Read the full video transcript
top motivations for women relationship dissatisfaction number one and a high number one again most women mention that second place and and second place by quite a bit only only 20% that's still a high 22% um mentioned that their primary partner was uninvested and this also illustrates an important point which is that not all women's Affairs are explained by dual mating it seems that there might be a psychological bias towards the Dual mating strategy but many women had affairs with Affair Partners who they perceived as less attractive right 77% more likely is not you know that's not an infinite Gap and then um if there there one of the reasons that many women cheated one in five women cheated precisely because they thought that their primary partner wasn't invested enough so if it's pairing good genes and good investment that doesn't make that doesn't make a lot of sense um with for those women and then the third most popular motivation for women was Revenge so 15.5% of women said that they were cheating to get revenge and they did they say what on um well in this case the 15.5% figure is Revenge for their partner's Affair specifically so I remember I spoke to a guy who was kind of an unofficial marriage counselor in his neighborhood and I asked him you know why why do women cheat in your experience like what what do you see and he very flatly said he said women cheat when men cheat now that doesn't seem to be 100% true but there's certainly some truth to it in our data in the sense that women were much more likely to cheat for revenge and you could interpret that as a genuine Strat but since cheat more than women women have more opportunity to cheat for revenge or at the very least they have opportunity at the very least they have more opportunity to cite Revenge as one of the reasons why they cheated whether it was going to happen or not yes what are what what is the state of who cheats more men or women oh that that's a pretty open and shut case men cheat more men say they cheat more when you ask them uh men say they get cheated on less when you ask them so women report getting cheated on more and then women who are the third person right so some people might say oh well maybe women are just understating things when you ask you know who's more successful as a mate poacher uh women who mate poach tend to have a higher hit rate so there are three people involved in any given Affair there's the primary partner there's the person who cheating and then there's the affair partner and you can do studies on any one of those three groups and you generally find the same result which is that the man is generally more likely to have an affair in some studies it's not a big gap in some cultural context it's a huge gap but that that would be the overall state of the science there and so the Revenge difference it may just be Downstream of uh the sex difference in committing infidelity they have more opportunity to have what do you what do you learn from a woman's concern about investment from their partner it's a good question so this is pretty consistent with it's not consistent with the Dual mating strategy but it's consist and it it's actually a really good thing to illustrate that women cheat for many reasons they cheat maybe for traditional variety based motivations such as genetic heterogeneity or you know uh fertility backup so uh some percent of couples are infertile and so if you're mating with multiple males you're really lowering the probability that that's going to result in the end of your lineage um there there there are many motivations for Affairs Revenge um so so having being an uninvested partner low investment I would say that it signals I would say that it signals kind of the traditional Evy difference which is that women's investment in Offspring is largely obligate physically obligate in the sense that women have to go through pregnancy and lactation this is part of why women seem to be more careful about who they mate with more choosy uh a lot of men complain about you know women having high standards for their mates but really what do you expect right like if you could get pregnant surely you'd be pretty careful as well about who you mate with and so women's investment is partially obligate whereas men's investment is not morally but pragmatically entirely optional men have the option to seduce and abandon mates and so you'd expect given that that women would be very sensitive to cues that a man might seduce and abandon her and really try to avoid that as much as possible and so if they're in a relationship and they think oh my my partner is not investing in me he's not invested well that's a huge signal that he's mate value mate essentially it's like oh I this isn't going to work and maybe that maybe that's evidence for mate switching but maybe it's also evidence for breakup or backup or just lowering the cost of infidelity again the discount infidelity idea I was going to say you know this doesn't mean that no woman ever leaves her partner to get into a relationship with the cheating partner yeah reliably that does happen and also I'm going to guess that if you looked at the cohorts of women and you were to find the one that said I was worried about investment from my relationship partner that would probably result in more likely of a pivot to the new um infidelity partner as a new relationship I'm going to guess that that would probably be predictive of that because like what am I sticking about for if I'm going to have genes and investment and I don't have investment then I might as well try and get genes and investment together yes exactly so the so the Dual mating it doesn't explain all of women's certainly and we did see some mate switching in our samples several women in our sample were matate switching this episode is brought to you by element stop having coffee first thing in the morning your adenosine system that caffeine acts on isn't even active for the first 90 minutes of the day but your adrenal system is and salt acts on your adrenal system element contains a signs backed electrolyte ratio of sodium potassium and magnesium with no sugar no gluten no coloring no artificial ingredients or any other BS it plays a critical role in reducing muscle cramps and fatigue while optimizing brain health regulating appetite and curbing Cravings the orange flavor in a cold glass of water is literally the best way to start your morning I've done it every single day for over three years now way before they were a partner on the show and I love it best of all there is a no BS no questions asked refund policy so you can buy absolutely risk-free and if you do not like it for any reason they will give you your money back and you don't even need to return the box right now you can get a free sample pack of all eight flavors with your first box by going to the link in the description below or heading to drink lnt.com slod wisdom that's drink LM nt.com SL modern wisdom thank you very much for tuning in if you enjoyed that clip you will love the F length podcast in all its Glory which is available right here go on press it