Video summary
The video transcript explores the theological question of Judas Iscariot's ultimate fate after betraying Jesus, challenging the common belief that he is currently in hell. The speaker argues against viewing spiritual matters through a "carnal mind," suggesting instead that believers should consider how a righteous and loving God would orchestrate salvation history. A central point of discussion is whether it makes sense for God to use a human being like Judas to fulfill His plan while simultaneously condemning that same person eternally. The speaker posits that if God sovereignly chose Judas for this specific role, as indicated by Jesus knowing his identity beforehand and even calling him a friend, then condemning him forever contradicts the nature of a just and loving deity who orchestrates such complex events in creation.
To support the traditional view that Judas is lost, the speaker cites several biblical passages, including John 6:70 where Jesus identifies one of the twelve as a devil, and John 13:27 where Satan enters Judas immediately after he accepts the morsel. The discussion highlights Jesus' statement in John 13:10 that while the disciples are clean, not all are, implying that Judas was the exception who had not been regenerated by the Holy Spirit. Furthermore, Acts 1:18-20 describes Judas purchasing a field with his wages and falling headlong, resulting in his death, after which the land became known as "Hakeldama" or the Field of Blood. The speaker also references Hebrews 12:16, which labels Esau as immoral and godless, drawing a parallel to suggest that Judas, having never placed faith in Christ and actively betraying Him, similarly lacks salvation.
However, the conversation introduces significant nuance regarding the interpretation of these texts and the nature of God's sovereignty. The speaker points out textual criticism issues with Luke 23:34, noting that the famous prayer "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do" may not be in the original manuscripts, yet argues that even if it were, its application to Judas is debated. Additionally, the discussion touches on other figures like Pharaoh and Esau, questioning whether God uses wicked individuals for His glory without necessarily guaranteeing their eternal salvation, or if there is a distinction between being used in a plan and receiving forgiveness. The speaker acknowledges that while Judas repented of his specific act of betrayal with great remorse, this sorrow did not lead to the saving faith required for redemption, as evidenced by his continued rejection of Jesus even after witnessing His miracles.
Ultimately, the video concludes that despite the complexities of God's sovereignty and the mysterious ways He employs human actions, scripture provides clear indicators that Judas was not saved. The consensus presented is that Judas never accepted Christ, actively denied Him, and died without having placed his faith in the Messiah. While the speaker invites listeners to think spiritually about God's character rather than carnally judging His justice, the final takeaway remains firm: Judas serves as a solemn warning against betrayal and a testament to the necessity of genuine faith. The narrative emphasizes that while God is sovereign over all events, including the actions of those who ultimately reject Him, there is no biblical evidence to suggest that Judas received a second chance or was forgiven in the way necessary for eternal life.
Read the full video transcript
I'm blessed and highly favored. How you
doing, my brother?
>> I'm pretty good. Let me ask a question.
Is that a real background? Is that Is
that real or is that uh one of those
backgrounds they put on on you in the Is
that real? [laughter]
>> Oh, that ain't real.
>> Okay. I was like, that's that is a nice
background. That's that's real nice. I'm
think Okay. [laughter]
>> Oh, boy. You tickle me. Listen,
>> I thought it was real. [snorts]
>> No. Um, so
I got two things that we might be able
to get into.
>> Give me your best one because I I got
>> Okay, so
>> a bunch of folks waiting.
>> All right, I'mma go with the one that's
going to be really challenging and I'm
hoping that,
>> okay,
>> you can consider doing even a lesson on
this one.
>> Okay.
>> All right.
I appreciate how you share with folks
the story. If people would just get the
story of the Bible
>> and allow the Holy Spirit to lead them
and guide them, man, they will see the
fullness of God and all that he has done
for us.
But it's unfortunate that I believe too
many people are trying to
receive and understand spiritual things
with the carnal mind.
>> So that leads me to this.
Okay. I was in a conversation with a
sister that
swear up and down that Judas is in hell.
>> That who?
>> And I'm like there's Judas. Judas is
scariot. the betrayal of Jesus.
>> Okay?
>> And I told her there's no scripture that
affirms that Judas is in hell.
Then I tried to explain to her, "Honey,
do you think that
the role that Judas played in God's plan
of salvation
was something that Jesus and God wasn't
aware of, it caught them off guard?"
And do you believe that a righteous,
just loving God would birth a mere
mortal
to play the role that Judas played
in God's plan of salvation? Cuz Jesus
knew exactly who Judas was, even called
him friend, and even told him to go and
do quickly what you must do.
So, as I begin to share those comments
with her, I asked her to go back in
Matthews and see what Matthew recorded
about Judas acknowledging with great
remorse. Some scriptures say great
remorse. The old King James version said
that he was godly sorrow. He repented
that he caused a innocent man to be led
to death.
And so I said, 'Now I want you to think
from a spiritual standpoint.
Try to have the mind of Christ in the
mind of God. Do you really think a
righteous, just loving God is going to
cause a mere mortal to play his role in
God's plan of salvation and then condemn
him forever? And last but not least, I
had her to think about when scripture
said, "Where do you think Jesus was
those three days that he was in the
tomb?" Where do you think his spirit
was?
Scripture said he ministered to those in
Hades.
And if Jesus said to the father and said
to himself in Luke 23:34,
"Father, forgive them for they know not
what they do." anything he asked of the
father, it was done. So I share all that
to say I wanted her to start thinking
and trying to think spiritually and not
cardally.
So again, that might be a lesson that
you might want to consider to teach on.
>> No, no, we can cover this real quick. Um
Judas, um hold on one second.
This is Acts. Uh let me go Hold on.
Let me pull up a couple passages.
Acts one.
Okay. So, let's go to a couple passages.
One, let's look at John 6 and hold on.
6 and 70. Jesus answered them, "Did I
not myself not choose you, the 12, and
yet one of you is
>> a devil?" Uh the right
>> now he meant Judas the son of Simon's
scariot
>> for he one of the twel was going to
betray him.
>> John 17:12 while I was with them he
sprayed of the father while I was with
them I was keeping them in your name
which you have given me and I guarded
them and not one of them perished but
the son of predition. They call him the
son of predition
>> uh which is destruction the son of ruin
so that the scripture would be
fulfilled.
Okay. Now, he's referring to Psalm 41:9.
Let's go to Psalm 41:9. I type this in.
Come on.
>> Psalm 419.
Even my close friend in whom I trusted
who ate my bread has lifted his heel
against me. So, that's the that's the
passage that he's saying that fulfilled.
>> Then, let's look at uh what he says
about John. I mean by uh Judas that the
part that you brought up about what you
do do quickly in John 13:27 after the
morsel Satan then entered who into
Judas.
>> Therefore Judas said to him what you do
do quickly. And so the devil entered
into Judas.
>> He could not be saved, could he? And
then let's go a little further up in
John 13.
Notice let's let's go up to where Jesus
was.
um washing their feet. If I go a little
further, there it is. So, this and I've
covered this passage before where he's
talking to them and he's washing their
feet,
>> right?
>> And Peter said, "Lord, then wash not
only my feet." I'm sorry, let's go back.
He says, uh Peter says, "Never shall you
wash my feet." Jesus said, "If I do not
wash you, you have no part with me."
Peter said, "Lord, then wash not only my
feet, but also my hands and my head."
She said to him, "He who has been bathed
needs only to wash his feet." The part
where I I've talked about before about
being bathed, perfect tense. This is
someone who's been cleansed. This is
what the word is. He's already been
clean. How so? In his heart. He says,
"Needs only to wash his feet, but is
completely clean and you are clean." So,
how are they clean? This is by their
heart being regenerated, but not all of
you. So, all of them have had their
heart regenerated except for who? Except
for Judas. for he knew the one who was
betraying him. For this reason, he said,
"Not all of you are clean." So, thus
far, I think we've got more than enough
proof to conclude that Judas is not
saved. If he's not saved, where must he
be? He must be in hell. Let's go to Acts
chapter 1.
>> Okay.
>> Uh let's see. Speaking about Judas,
speaking about where he purchased this
field, um he was counted among us and
received his share in this ministry. Now
this man acquired a field with the price
of his wickedness, the price of his
wickedness, and falling headlong, he
burst open in the middle of all, and all
of his intestines gushed out, and it
became known to to all who were living
in Jerusalem, so that in their own
language that field was called uh
haeldom, that is field of the blood. For
it is written in the book of Psalms, let
his homestead be made desolate, and let
no one dwell in it, and let another take
his office. Have you ever read those
texts? Because oh yes if you so it calls
him it go it goes on and calls him a
wicked man.
>> So he chose a wicked man. So the person
that he chose though he looked like he
was a good guy
>> he was still wicked.
>> So so go ahead. I'm sorry.
So those scriptures that you read,
>> all of that took place before Jesus died
on the cross,
>> the washing of the feet and all of that.
>> The disciples still did not fully
understand who Jesus was because they
didn't even show up at his crucifixion.
>> But what would that have to do with with
Judas, though?
>> Because they didn't understand. Again,
these are just mere mortal human being.
They didn't fully understand all what
Christ had came to do. And so, yes, he
washed their feet, but and you said
their heart was regenerated.
I don't believe their heart was
regenerated. They still was followers of
Christ, but they fully didn't
understand. That's why they were hiding
when he was crucified.
>> So, Mary had to go. If you don't think
their hearts were regenerated,
what does Jesus
>> Okay, so for me, here's when their heart
was regenerated.
>> Okay.
>> When the resurreed Christ met them
>> when what?
>> In John what?
when Christ the resurrected Christ,
okay,
>> met them,
>> okay,
>> in John chapter 20
and he began to as you know he Thomas
had to touch his hands and stuff to feel
>> and then Jesus himself
began to minister to them about what it
was that he was now going to need them
to do. And we talked about this before.
He told them, "Receive the Holy Spirit."
Did they?
>> And breathed on them,
>> did they?
>> So now they fully understand cuz he is
the resurrected Lord. He has appeared
before them. And so before he descended
into heaven, remember what he had to say
to Peter.
Peter, do you love me? Three times,
right?
>> Mhm.
>> To confirm that Peter's heart was
regenerated. And so I share all that to
say again,
I know when folks think with a carnal
mind, oh Judas did this, Judas did that.
But when you think about the whole story
and you think about God and all that God
has done for creation and for humanity,
>> do we really believe that a just,
righteous, loving God would condemn a
mere human being,
>> for eternity, for the role that God
birthed him to play?
>> Okay, so couple things. Cuz one, I
wouldn't I wouldn't use the phrase that
a carnal mind would think that because
other folks who like I'm not carnal. Why
would I think that? But I'd say this.
Would God ever choose ordain something
or use a man for his plan and condemn
him for being used in God's plan? Well,
there are a lot of people that fit that
bill. Pharaoh, for one, Pharaoh's
clearly um a evil, wicked person. How
about uh Esau?
clearly
um is not in uh uh in heaven with the
Lord, but he played a part, did he not?
Or how about someone like um uh uh like
>> really
>> or like Huh?
>> Really? You you really believe that?
>> That that those two mentioned Esau.
>> Uhhuh.
>> God is the one that determined that Esau
wasn't the chosen one.
And so Esau's in hell.
>> What do you think Esau is?
>> I think Esau just like um Joshua
when Joshua came back and Esau embraced
him and stuff.
>> Okay. So next question. So last
question.
What what what would what would Judas
>> have to do or Esau have to do or Pharaoh
have to do to not be in hell?
>> Okay, I didn't use Pharaoh because
Pharaoh did not acknowledge God.
>> What did Esau have to do?
Esau understood that he was a descendant
of Abraham
and in that lineage that and so all he
had to do is just continue to worship as
they worshiped
uh from their knowledge of their father
Abraham.
>> Did he did Esau ever do anything worth
being atoned for?
So,
what did Joshua do to be atoned for?
See, that's that's that's the issue.
>> So, hold on. Hold on. So, let's
>> accepted Christ.
>> Let's pull up a text to prove that Esau
was not saved.
>> Hebrews 12.
>> Look at Hebrews 12.
>> Look at this text. Go ahead.
>> That there be no immoral or godless
person like Esau.
Mhm.
>> So he calls them
immoral and godless.
So I think it's safe to assume that Esau
is in hell.
>> Okay. Um
again,
>> right?
>> So that's what the scripture said. And
I'm not going to argue with the
scripture cuz that's what the scripture
said. I'm just talking about the
character of God.
>> Okay. So let me ask the question. So,
could God choose a person to play a part
in his scheme or in his plan and that
person go to hell?
>> Well, where were they going anyway? If
God did not if God didn't use Judas,
where was Judas going anyway?
>> If he didn't accept Christ, but again,
at that time, none of them fully knew.
>> Okay. But but my question though, absent
that, where was he going anyway?
>> Okay. So if he did end up in hell,
that's why I said those three days that
Christ was supposed to be in Hades
ministering to those souls that were
captive,
Judas soul had to be there also. And if
anybody was going to accept Jesus'
ministry during those three days in
Hades, it would have been Jew Judas
because he seen the miracles. Why? Why
would Judas So you think Judas would get
a second chance?
>> The scripture said that those folks that
Christ ministered to them in Hades,
>> it didn't say they got a second chance,
though.
>> No, it didn't specifically say that.
You're right.
>> So, we can't So, so we don't want to add
something there. We don't want to say go
beyond scriptures, right?
>> I understand that. But again, why would
scripture even mention that Jesus went
to minister to the captives?
>> There could be it could it could well,
first of all, the people that he said he
mentioned he that he went to and spoke
to were those who were died during the
time of Jonah.
>> I'm sorry, during the time of Noah. So
that that's not that's not Judas, right?
>> Yeah. But again, and
>> what what you're having difficulty with
is that what you're having difficulty
with is that God would use this person
>> for his plan and then send him to hell
afterwards. Well, first of all, every
God uses everything and everybody for
his plan. He's sovereign.
>> So if he wants to use if he wants to use
this whatever this is for his glory, he
can do it. Remember Paul says he gives
he gives a story. How can you say to the
the create the one that's created say to
the one who's creating how could you
have made me this way?
>> Who are you oh man to question him? He
can do what he wants to.
>> Example A exhibit A job. Ask Job. He can
do what he wants to. The Bible says that
the earth is the Lord. And here's here's
the uh the New Ghetto version. Everybody
in it
>> are his as well. So everybody inside the
earth also belongs to and he does what
he pleases. Now, Judas was never going
to place his faith in Christ. He was
never going to do so. That's why the
Bible say he he chose a wicked man. He
was wicked before. And so, I'm going to
use this wicked man for my glory.
>> He can do that, right?
>> God can do whatever God chooses to do
cuz he's sovereign. But the scripture
did say that the young man was remorse
and repent that he caused the innocent
man death. And God knows the heart. See
that's and so that's where I'm coming
from.
>> God know why why would you assume that
Judas Okay. So here's what we know.
Judas was not faithful.
Judas the devil entered his heart. He
was a wicked man chosen as a wicked man
before he was he was called predicted to
be wicked from the Old Testament that he
would choose a wicked man. That's Judas.
So he was wicked before he chose him. He
just didn't walk around acting like he
was wicked but he was
um he was clearly financially motivated.
He says that all of you have been
cleaned. Now this before John 20 breathe
on all of you have been cleaned except
for who? Who was the one person that was
not previously cleaned?
>> Judas.
>> And by the way, this is how we know it's
regeneration because when the Bible
talks about a person being clean or
cleansed, he's talking about their
heart. So, they had already been
cleaned. Remember when Jesus asked him,
"Who do who do men say that I am?" And
then he says, "Well, who do you say that
I am?" He says, "You are the Christ."
And who does Jesus say, "Let them know
that?" The the the father.
>> Flesh and blood has not revealed that to
you, but my father who's in heaven.
Well, that's only because they had been
regenerated priv previous previously.
And so, he has done something in them
that he hadn't done to Judas.
>> So, Judas, there's there's no verse that
gives us any indication that Judas would
have been saved. It's what all you're
relying on is I don't think God would do
that. But,
>> okay. So, then I I go back to Luke
23:34, and that's my favorite scripture.
>> Okay.
If Jesus asked God to forgive folks for
they knew not what they do, Judas had to
be in in that forgiveness.
>> Okay. Um
>> cuz anything Jesus asked of the father,
the father granted him. Cuz of course
Jesus being the father in the person of
Jesus Christ.
>> Were were you watching me earlier? Were
you were you watching me earlier when I
when I um was covering what we call
textual criticism and showing which
verses belong and how we know and so
forth. So here's that text.
>> Jesus was saying, "Father, forgive them
for they do not know what they are
doing." You see this little part over
here? Let me make this bigger so
everybody can see this. Y'all see this
over here?
>> These little things that are
highlighted.
>> So everything between here and here is
not in the original text. So this part
where it says father forgive them for
they do not know what they are doing is
not actually in the original text.
>> Okay.
>> So
>> but even if it was he's not talking
about Judas anyway.
>> Okay. I'll have to go with the lesson
that I learned today that that part of
Luke 23:34 was not in the original text.
Now, by the way, let's just say it was.
Let's say it was. Is that a get out of
jail free card for everybody that's not
saved? No.
Cuz if it applies to Judas, it applies
to everybody else too then, doesn't it?
>> Come on.
>> So,
>> I got you. I got you.
>> So, Judas without question is in. And
matter of fact, Judas is the proof to
show. By the way, by the way, here
here's here's the passage that also lets
us know that Judas I'm sorry that Judas
is in hell. Here's another passage.
[snorts]
When John says this in 1 John 21:19,
they went out from us because they were
not really of us. For if they had been
of us, they would have remained. If
Judas would have been of us, he would
have remained.
>> Remain. But he just didn't. You
literally have Jesus there
and you denied him. You sold him out.
You betrayed him.
>> Peter denied him. Judas just betrayed
him.
>> Yeah. Peter [clears throat] Yeah. He
betrayed him. Betrayed him. Sold him
out. He's the Now,
how it's a it's an example for us to
see, man, we can we need to be careful.
We have We have the word of God with us.
Mhm.
>> And we have all that we need and let's
not do what what Judas did. Let's not
betray him. Not necessarily in the same
way. We can't betray him in the same
way, but let's not betray him uh in any
sense. It's possible that you can walk
with you can know be be familiar with
the Lord or the way the word of the Lord
and still do your own thing. Judas is
our lesson. And so I I don't think
there's any question. I don't know
anyone I I I couldn't find I wouldn't be
able to find a scholar that would say
that that Judas is not in hell. One, he
didn't do anything deserving to be in
heaven or to to to um to be atoned for.
He never placed his faith in Christ.
That part we know he never did that. So
the only way that he could have been
saved, he didn't do it. He did the
matter of fact, he did the opposite.