Video summary
The concept of deliberate deoptimization challenges the prevailing societal belief that one should constantly strive to improve every aspect of their life. While most people benefit from tightening up and becoming more obsessive about details, this approach often backfires for "perma-optimizers" who already operate at high levels of intensity. For these individuals, the advice to optimize harder only reinforces a cycle where overthinkers convince themselves that even trivial areas require perfect attention. The speaker suggests that listeners likely fall into this category, having learned that deliberate effort yields success in professional domains but failing to recognize when this obsession bleeds into unimportant aspects like sleep routines or house cleanliness. The core argument is that the brain naturally attempts to apply perfectionist strategies from high-stakes environments to low-stakes ones, leading to unnecessary stress and diminishing returns. The speaker illustrates this with examples such as obsessing over credit card points for air miles when one's capacity for concern is already full, or fine-tuning intraworkout nutrition with specific supplements like pre-digested whey instead of focusing on the primary goal of hitting the gym five times a week. Similarly, spending all day analyzing stock market candle charts can damage relationships just as much as it might theoretically improve investment returns. The speaker notes that while not everything is life-or-death, people often behave implicitly as if they are, necessitating a conscious effort to recalibrate their priorities. To counteract this tendency, the solution proposed is deliberate deoptimization: purposefully allowing areas of life that could be dialed in further to fall by the wayside so mental energy can focus on what truly matters. This involves identifying a small bucket of pursuits worth obsessing over and resisting the urge to expand that list with minor details like toenails or specific nutrition tweaks. The speaker cites Oliver Burkeman's question, "How much should you care about things?" as inspiration for realizing that caring at an absolute maximum level all the time is neither necessary nor healthy. By acknowledging these intrusive thoughts of perfectionism and consciously deciding not to engage with them in non-critical areas, individuals can regain a sense of sanity without trying to solve this conflict completely. The process of balancing obsession in one domain while attempting to induce "atrophy" in others is described as difficult because it feels like walking on a balance board where stasis never truly exists; instead, one must constantly make small adjustments. The speaker frames this not as a paradox to be solved but as a problem to be managed through continuous calibration rather than reaching a final state of equilibrium. This approach acknowledges that the stress generated by trying to be perfect in every area will ultimately harm an individual more quickly than their imperfections would. By choosing which few things are unbelievably important and letting go of everything else, people can prevent the "flood" of optimization from ruining other parts of their lives. The discussion concludes with a practical application involving zinc supplementation as a reminder that sometimes simple biological needs underlie performance issues unrelated to complex training plans or diets. The speaker highlights Momentous's Zinc as an NSF-certified supplement that supports testosterone production, strength recovery, and energy for those who might be chronically low on it. While this serves as a promotional interlude within the broader philosophical argument, it reinforces the theme of focusing resources effectively—whether mental or physical—rather than overcomplicating solutions with unnecessary variables like specific cashback bonuses or excessive supplement stacks that distract from core goals.
Read the full video transcript
deliberate
deoptimization. How much should you try
to optimize your life was a question
that I asked myself. Sort of how much
should you be thinking about ways to
improve? How much should you care about
things? And for many people, perhaps
even most people, the answer to all of
those questions is more. The world
largely belongs to the intense
optimizers and not the less a fair guy
chilling in a hammock who's hit snooze
three times this morning. So telling
people to optimize harder is a reliable
way to improve the lives of most people
because most people need to be tightened
up rather than loosened off and being
more obsessive will tend to deliver
better results in worldly success.
Most advice is charitably given to
people who need to think more carefully,
be more deliberate, and work harder. The
problem is when this message lands with
the wrong audience, the perennial perma
optimizers, then it creates a world
where overthinkers are convinced to
think even more. And these people need
loosening off, not tightening up. And
given the fact that you listen to this
podcast or read my newsletter, I'm going
to guess that you fall into this
category. I'm not saying that you
shouldn't be obsessive and pay attention
to detail. The problem arises when you
can no longer delineate between the very
small number of things that matter
enough to obsess over and everything
else. Assume that you have a small
bucket of pursuits which are important.
You've probably learned that a very
deliberate, effortful, optimized
approach is a successful strategy. This
obsession and addiction begins to bleed
into all other areas of your life. And
turning off the tap of optimization is
hard. Soon enough, the entire map is
flooded with the same desire to always
push for perfect. Your brain tells you,
"Look at how effective your
perfectionism has been in your
professional life. Why don't we try and
apply that to your your sleep routine
and your training plan, your love life,
and the house cleanliness and your
toenails?"
and it doesn't go well. One solution I
learned
about actually from the CTO of RP
Strength um a guy called Andrew Z who
works with Mike Israel is deliberate
deoptimization. So you purposefully let
areas which could be dialed in further
fall by the wayside in order to give
your brain capacity to focus on the ones
that really matter. focusing on your
pounds and not everyone else's pennies.
Sure, you could have five credit cards
with special cashback bonuses and
capture all of the points for your air
miles, but given that you're already
close to capacity on the things to give
a about list, is it wise to add yet
another thing onto that? Sure, your
intraworkout nutrition could probably be
dialed in more with pre-igested
grass-fed whey and dextrose, but what if
this takes your energy away from the key
area of just hitting the gym five times
a week? In the same way, you could spend
all day watching the stock market
instead of just investing in an index
fund, but how much damage will this new
candle graph addiction do to your
relationship? Uh Oliver Burkeman
inspired me with this thought recently
which is how much should you care about
things? Question how much should you
care about things? Answer I'm unsure
exactly but I know that it's not the
absolute maximum amount all the time for
everything. Basically not everything is
a life or death situation. And even if
you know this cognitively you still
behave implicitly like it is. So,
deliberately letting go of certain areas
is a good way to give overthinkers like
you and me uh more space to regain a
little bit of sanity. Basically, the
stress of trying to be perfect will kill
you more quickly than your
imperfections. and choosing the very
small bucket of things that are
unbelievably important to you and that
you want to have your obsession focus
on. And when that habit, that thought
pattern, that framing starts to appear
in other areas of your life, you just
sort of notice it. you go, "Oh, yeah,
that's that thing that I really love at
work and really don't want in my
relationship or in my sleep routine or
in the way that I keep my house or
whatever. So, I'm I'm just going to
like, thank you for that and I
appreciate you. I see you there, but I
don't really need to worry so much." And
it's difficult because you're going to
be hypertrophying this muscle in one
very particular domain or a few
particular domains and you're going to
be trying atrophy the same muscle in
other domains and it's really really
tough. This is a
uh problem to be managed not a paradox
to be solved perhaps that there is no
point at which this is going to be
stopped and just learning like being on
one of those balance board things where
there's a sphere in the middle of it. At
no point are you actually at stasis.
You're always just making little
adjustments. And I think maybe it's kind
of like that. Before we continue, if
your workouts feel flat, your recovery
is slow, or you've just been feeling
off, it might not be your training plan
or your diet. It might be something a
bit more boring like zinc. And while
most supplements like tonkatali can
help, zinc quietly plays a huge role in
testosterone production, strength,
recovery, and energy. And most people
are chronically low on it. which is why
I'm such a huge fan of Momentous's Zinc
because it supports testosterone, boost
vitality, and it helps keep everything
running like it should. Plus, it is NSF
certified for sport, which means it's
been independently tested and approved
for purity, safety, and zero shady
ingredients. Just clean, effective,
sciencebacked goodness. And if you're
still unsure, Momentus offers a 30-day
money back guarantee. So, you can try it
for 29 days. If you don't like it,
they'll give you a money back. Plus,
they ship internationally. Right now,
you can get 35% off your first
subscription. and that 30-day money back
guarantee by going to the link in the
description below or heading to
livemomentous.com/modernwisdom using the
code modernwisdom at checkout. That's li
i v m o m n o s.com/modernwis wisdom and
modernwisdom at checkout. Would you look
at that clip is already over. But if you
want more, don't be sad. The full
episode is available right here.
[Music]