Video summary
The video argues that while most dating advice focuses on superficial elements like attraction, chemistry, and physical connection, the true foundation of a lasting emotional bond lies in "discourse." Discourse is defined not merely as talking or exchanging small talk about movies and music, but as an active engagement with another person's inner world. The speakers emphasize that meaningful relationships are built through deep conversations where partners explore their ideas, feelings, beliefs, and perspectives without the intent to win an argument. Instead of viewing differences in opinion as adversarial, couples should approach them with genuine curiosity about why the other person holds a specific viewpoint, which fosters understanding rather than conflict.
To illustrate how this works in practice, the speakers share ten examples of topics they discuss regularly, starting with exploring each other's childhood experiences and family dynamics to understand who someone is before their current relationship began. They also highlight the importance of sharing vulnerabilities early on, such as fears about travel or struggles with planning, which can initially feel risky but ultimately builds trust and intimacy. Another key aspect involves defining what love means personally for each partner rather than relying on clichés, ensuring that both individuals understand how to give and receive affection in a way that feels authentic and safe. This approach helps partners move beyond the fear of being "interrogated" or judged, transforming deep questioning into an opportunity for connection.
The transcript further challenges common assumptions about gender roles in dating, noting that many men are not challenged to go deeper because they lack encouragement from women who may assume all men seek only superficial connections. The speakers recount a story where they met a seemingly stereotypical "alpha" man on the street who turned out to be deeply thoughtful and willing to engage in profound conversation once given the chance. This example reinforces the idea that depth is not limited by appearance or initial impressions but requires an intentional effort from both parties to look past surface-level judgments. By asking questions like, "What came up for you when that happened?" couples can uncover emotional reactions and patterns that might otherwise remain hidden.
Ultimately, the video concludes that without rich discourse, a relationship risks becoming nothing more than living together as roommates who happen to share a bed but lack spiritual or intellectual connection. The speakers encourage viewers to adopt a mindset of exploration rather than evaluation when meeting new people, using games like "Skin Deep" on early dates to facilitate these deeper conversations in a playful environment. They stress that while attraction and romance are important entry points, it is the quality of communication and the willingness to dive into one another's inner worlds that creates true meaning. By prioritizing curiosity over judgment and depth over distraction, individuals can transform their dating experiences from casual encounters into profound partnerships based on mutual understanding and shared growth.
Read the full video transcript
Today we're going to talk about how to
create meaning in your relationship.
We're going to revamp the dating game
today. Are you ready for that, Paula?
Okay. Most dating advice focuses on
attraction and chemistry and flirting
and texting and sex.
And yet what keeps a man and woman
emotionally bonded over time is
something simpler. Do you know what it
is, Paula?
>> Um,
tell me.
>> Oh, you tell me.
>> I was going I'm going to say
conversation, communication, things like
that.
>> What's the D word?
>> Discourse.
>> Discourse. There you go. I thought you
were like a yeah. Discourse is the
exchange of ideas, thoughts, feelings,
beliefs, experiences, and perspective.
It's not merely talking. It's engaging
with another person's inner world. And a
lot of couples think they're
communicating, yet very few people have
meaningful conversations. And we're
going to talk about the importance of
this because,
you know, well, I want your take on this
because did you give this thought before
we met?
>> Oh my god, all the time. Yeah.
>> Oh, really? Talk to me about that.
>> I I well, we'll talk about the the game
I used to
bring out every so often, but I felt
like if somebody couldn't sit in
communication and discourse and have
conversations about and I'm not I'm not
talking about politics, religion, things
that like that that are polarizing per
se, but something a little beyond like
what movies do you like and what music
do you like, you know.
>> Reminds me of that Seinfeld episode.
How's your day going? Did you have a
good day? I hope you had a good day. You
know, and and in fact, our first
meeting, I don't call it a date, I call
it a meeting, um, we started with a bit
of discourse.
>> We started with a lot of discourse.
>> Okay. [laughter] And and let me just say
this, you know, I I think of discourse
and I think of discord, you know, kind
of being [clears throat] Yeah, it's it's
really about expressing ideas, thoughts,
feelings about something. And so our
first meeting, we started off on this
whole debate I I call it a debate, okay?
But, we had a slightly difference of
opinion on something.
>> We had opposing views.
>> Opposing views. Not radically opposing
views. But, why this is so important,
which most people would say, "God, this
is the way you two started?" Like,
that's analytical or something like
that.
>> I think
>> Well, let me share Let me share what it
was. So, really quickly. We had a debate
or a difference of opinion on masculine
and feminine energy related to polarity,
related to courting, and we had two
different points of view. So, our our
conversation started not adversarial,
but kind of
>> And And this is where I'm going with it.
I want to say that we both felt like we
had equally valid
arguments, for lack of a better
>> Yeah, yeah, yeah.
>> And where it went was into I'm curious,
why do you think like that?
>> Yes.
>> And that was what started the
communication along that line. But, I
think what's important about it is that
we we got into curiosity very quickly
about how the other thinks and feels
about
not just that subject.
>> No, I Yeah, I mean, By the way, in a few
moments, I'm going to share 10 examples
of discourse that we engage in, and
maybe this might help you in your
relationship or even in the dating
practice, and we're going to turn you on
to a game that we like to play as well.
So, what was interesting about that? It
wasn't like I'm right, you're wrong.
It's more It was more like, "Well, I
feel strongly about this, and you and I
you'd go, "Well, why do you feel so
strongly about it?" And then you felt so
strongly about it. I'm like, "Why did
you feel so strongly about that point of
view?"
And as you said a moment ago, it was
about the curiosity.
>> Yeah.
>> And why I believe I want Why I wanted to
even do a a video about this, and you
were the one that said, "Let's talk
about it from the context of meaning."
>> Yes. Yes.
>> Okay.
>> Yes.
>> I looked at the idea of discourse as an
activity two people do, but you said,
"No, no, no, this has to do
>> about the activity. I feel like
when I was in the dating world, for me,
and and even early relationships, for
me, it was important to establish depth.
>> Yeah.
>> important for me to establish
how deep can you go, you know? And and
yeah, that could have been a turn-off
for some people. For the most part, I
think if done
I don't even want to say well, if done
>> with
>> sincerely
>> from the heart and with curiosity and
and and and under the category of
exploration.
>> Yes.
>> Right? That it then becomes a I'm
interested in what you have to say. I'm
interested in how you feel about this
thing, and I'm interested about what you
think.
>> So, here's where my beef is in so much
dating rhetoric and the advice out
there, and it's so focused on attraction
and romance and entertainment and
physical connection that you're really
not getting to know another person.
Through our 5-hour first meeting, I was
like, I think I kind of get a sense of
how you think. I mean, now, it was a
baseline. I mean, I didn't really the
more I got to know you, the more I
realized who you are at a much deeper
level, but what happened was because we
spoke so much from the heart,
>> Yeah.
>> um that we were finding ourselves
getting closer to one another, even
though this wasn't our first, you know,
we didn't have that intense chemistry,
per se, but I still felt a desire to get
to know you
>> Yes.
>> because of that.
>> that's where a lot of people
lack
in the very beginnings of their dating
relationships.
>> Yeah.
>> I think
there are some women who fear in some
ways going into the deep and they're
questioning because it might feel like
almost like an interview process.
Um and then I feel some men
are not challenged to go there.
>> Ah.
>> And if they're not challenged, they just
don't.
>> Yes.
>> For whatever reason, maybe they fear
that, you know, they're
you know, not going to be taken properly
or
>> So So you mentioned interview process
and you know, if you've known me for a
while, you know, I I believe that you
don't interview a person, you
interrogate that.
Now, what is interrogation? If you look
at it from the definition, it's about
getting to the truth of something. You
know, that's what a detective does. It
gets to the truth of Did you commit the
crime or not? And we do it under the hot
lights. And I'm saying this tongue in
cheek and yet if two people are meeting
with the intent of exploring a dating
scenario or exploring a relationship
scenario, then who cares if you go deep
quickly? Now, does that mean you share
secrets right from the very beginning?
No, you don't share private personal
things that until trust has been built.
But going deep is how you genuinely get
to know someone to create meaning out of
the relationship.
>> Yeah.
>> Now, you said something. Most men won't
go there.
>> No, what I said is most men are not
challenged to go there, so they don't
go there.
>> So it's interesting. We had dinner last
week with dear friends of Mars or mine
and now they're yours. And you were
sitting with my oldest dearest friend
and you were like going deep with him.
You were like
>> Yeah, you dug in. And And you were
surprised that he was willing to go
there with you.
>> And it was the second time. But you were
surprised also. The very first time that
happened, you were surprised that he
went into the deep with me.
>> You know, no. I mean, only surprised is
because I've given the characterization
he doesn't go there. But it didn't occur
to me. He doesn't go there cuz he's not
challenged to go there. And so, why is
this important for women to know is if a
man doesn't go deep, well, then he's
probably not your guy. But better to try
and see if he's willing to go to the
deep end instead of being fearful he's
incapable of going in the deep end.
>> and then not not doing so could
sacrifice your own boundaries and your
own
desires to go into the deep and have a
meaningful relationship. I mean, what
what is meaning if we're not going into
the deep?
>> Yeah. So, let's share with everybody 10
things that 10 things we went down
the rabbit hole and we still do this on
a regular basis. So, the first one was
And and by the way, this is in no
particular order, everyone. But the
first one I wrote down was exploring
each other's childhood experiences.
How your how our family shaped who we
are, our belief system about love,
safety and relationship.
>> question on that end would simply be,
"Tell me about your mother. Tell me
about your father. What was your
relationship like with them?"
>> Yeah.
>> Uh do you still have a relation I mean,
if they're still alive. I mean, in our
case, both our parents have passed. But
like, do you still have a relationship
with your parents? It's surprising how
many people don't have a relationship
with their parents. And and there's
probably a story in there. And within
the story can reveal so much about a
person's emotional maturity when you
start diving in.
You know, you got the sense, you know,
I've always said I tend to choose women
like my mother, you know, who were
emotionally unavailable.
>> [laughter]
>> Um I think partly
>> got there because I was curious about
what your relationship was like with
her.
You know, we started talking about past
relationships and my favorite question,
by the way, is what would your ex tell
me about you?
>> Well, we got that later on down the
list, okay.
>> Um but that but that also, you know,
really
>> By the way, which ex?
>> [laughter]
>> All of them.
>> I've got my ex-wife and my two other
significant relationships before I met
you. Fact is I reflect upon that, you
know, some people would think, "Oh my
god, you've had three, now four
significant relationships." By the way,
we're coming up on 1 year together this
week. Yay! So, um and now we live
together. Um but each one I I think for
the most part, well, you met my ex-wife
and you met my other previous
relationship. Uh so, and I think they
both say relatively nice things about
me.
So, but talking about our childhood
experiences was something to give us a
flavor of who you were before you got
here to this moment in time when I met
you. In fact, many of our conversations
in the beginning to create that that
discourse was about who were you before
I met you, which included things um and
another thing we talked about was
discussing fears and vulnerabilities
early on. Do you remember one of my
vulnerable, fearful things I shared
>> you told me you that you you're not How
did you put it? You're challenged by
traveling.
>> Yes.
>> [laughter]
>> Well, I I openly
Well, I don't know if I suck at it. We
haven't gone We've gone on a trip and I
did very well. Um I've said that I
struggle with international travel when
I'm in a place I'm unfamiliar with. Now,
why I led with that was because I know
so many women put on their dating
profiles, you know, "Please have
passport, will travel" for those of us
in midlife. So, I wanted to lead with
"Hey, look, I'm not good at it." But,
what was
>> In some ways, I think you almost were
using reverse psychology on me.
>> Yeah, yeah, yeah. [laughter]
Well, the other thing is I'm not good at
planning it. So, I'm like, I want to
know, "Hey, listen, are you" I'm trying
to find a Can you plan it and be okay
with it? Well, no, Jonathan, that's not
part of the masculine energy and that
totally makes me lose my feminine and I
go into my masculine and all that. I
want to vomit kind of
>> Yeah, that was part of our conversation,
too. You know, that that you shared this
vulnerability about your struggles with
traveling. And and and and your And
that's how we veered into the masculine
and feminine conversation.
>> Yeah, yeah, yeah. I agree with that.
>> it was one of those, well, you know, can
you get on a plane? Can you get on a
train? Can you get in an automobile kind
of thing? Like, you know, what are you
willing to to work with out there,
right? So.
>> You shared a vulnerability with me about
maybe not being able to fully surrender
to love.
>> Yes.
>> You know, that in your past you had
reservations in that area. And what was
interesting about you sharing that is
that put gave me a pause.
>> Yeah.
>> Because I'm like, "Uh-oh, is she going
to be like the pattern of women I've had
before?"
>> Yes.
>> But, what we did is we talked with each
other. I I can't stress this enough. You
know, most couples talk at each other.
They're talking about and they're trying
to win the conversation. And to the
extent that I wanted to win our first
conversation, I mean, I wanted you to
see my point of view.
And you tended to You started to come to
the dark side, you know.
>> That's true.
>> On this whole conversation. So, the
third thing on the list that I wrote
down was talking about the meaning of
love and not just I love you. But,
what love actually is and
Do you remember my little saying about I
love you? You probably don't.
>> So well I hopefully I embody what I'm
about to share but I've said I love you
means to me is I'm here.
>> Yes.
>> You matter.
We are important.
I've got your back. I'm not going where
and I only want you and I'm here means
I'm present.
>> Yeah.
>> And and
>> You are all that by the way.
>> Aw thank you. I appreciate that. But
where where I'm going with this is to be
present. You know how many people are
thinking about their work? They're
thinking about something else going on.
They're thinking about what they want to
say next. They're thinking about their
>> Or their next sentence.
>> Exactly. Their next sentence.
>> present in the conversation and I think
that that really
cannot lead itself to curiosity because
you're you're busy thinking about what's
next.
>> Exactly and so I'm here you matter means
you matter you know when I say I love
you it means your feelings matter
commensurate to my feelings. You know
your what's in your best interest is my
best interest.
We
>> So a lot of people that you would ask
that to in the dating world though
>> Yeah.
>> wouldn't necessarily know a good answer
to that. That's a that is a loaded
>> love you I means?
>> You are versed in
verbage around love.
>> Okay.
>> Okay. And and to ask the average guy
let's just say or the average gal
what the answer to that is I think many
of us would struggle.
Because love is a very esoteric
um
and meaningful experience and I think it
shows itself in so many different ways.
So I I think there's an pat answer for
that. I think the answer is the right
answer if it matches the other person.
>> Okay, so well, here's where I want to go
with that and and to the extent that
>> Anybody who answers the question of what
is love is all right in my book anyway.
Like
>> Well, it's at least the exploration of
it, but you know, here's the thing.
It is said that we humans all want
connection. So, whether you're a man or
woman out in the dating realm, everybody
wants some level of connection. Most men
drive it through physical connection,
but they want connection. But most
importantly, I think everyone wants to
at least feel loved.
It doesn't mean they have the capacity
to give love, but they want to feel
loved. And if you don't have a sense of
what that is and you're in the dating
marketplace,
well, then figure that out. Like
figure out what that really means to
you. What does commitment mean to you?
What does a relationship mean to you?
What does it look like for you? Instead
of the half-hazard
haphazardly cavalier casual way people
are dating. I'm a little bit more, you
know, what is it? Puritan in this.
>> So, I you know, I've come across those
who are, you know, somebody in there
said a lot of men are looking for more
of a superficial relationship and I
think that there are plenty of those,
too. But I've also dated where
um
uh you know, the guy has said to me
"What do you mean you're just looking
for, you know,
fun time?" I mean, like this is several
years back when I was
and he he got a little PO'd at me
and said, "Well, if you're not
intentional about this, then you and I
aren't a fit."
>> Good for him.
>> was it was so I think that the
communication piece is really strong. Um
it and it can be strong on both sides.
It really does depend.
Um but I think a lot of women are
assuming men are only in the superficial
uh space and I think what happens is it
is a a um
What's the word? An assumption on their
part without having to go further into
the deep.
>> So So, um really quickly, yesterday Paul
and I went for a walk. We live at the
beach. And we came across a guy who was
reading a book. Um
and um it was a self-help book.
>> And you had read it before. It was
something like um don't believe
everything you think.
>> Don't believe everything you think. Now,
this guy wasn't wearing a shirt. He had
a tattoo on his arm here and he was very
buff. And you know, to look at him you
go, "Oh, this guy's an alpha guy."
>> I would have thought if I had seen him
on the dating apps that this was a gym
rat.
>> Yeah.
>> That's what I would have thought.
>> And and I so I I stopped him and I said,
"Oh, I've you know, I've been meaning to
read this book. I have it and I haven't
read it yet." And we end up having a
20-minute conversation with him. This
guy was a 43-year-old man, went through
a divorce, uh has two children and he
was deep. And to look at him you
wouldn't think it based on a superficial
judgment.
>> Right.
>> superficial judgment.
>> Right. I would not have thought that
about him.
>> So coming back to this conversation, I
want to share a few more of the
discourse.
>> And can I just say I would have blown
that guy off on the dating apps. I would
have been like, "This guy is not going
to be deep."
>> Yeah. And then
>> And then we ended up having a beautiful
conversation.
>> the guy was
>> vulnerable and I just I it totally
changed my idea of like what is
possible.
>> Yes. So. Okay, really quickly, I want to
share those 10 things. Uh another one is
sharing our spiritual Oh, excuse me,
examining relationship dynamics. Why
conflict happens, how each of us
experiences connection. That's one of
our topics of conversation, sharing
spiritual perspectives with each other,
what higher self is, what our divine
self is, personal growth, life
experiences. That's a topic that we
spend a fair amount of time in
discourse, coming back to this. Um
>> Well, can I
We had discourse only because I
approached it differently. You
approached it from a very somatic
Let's just say almost trauma-based, you
know, experience.
>> Yes, yes.
>> And I approached it from a little more
esoteric, more spiritual, more
intentional belief systems.
>> And you brought me to your dark side.
>> That's true.
>> I'm like, you know what? You don't have
to do therapy to experience a
self-examined life. You don't have to do
all the workshops I've done to be able
to have emotional maturity. And I was
kind of stuck in that box,
believing that, and you brought me to
the dark side on that. Couple other
things that is discourse for us is
discussing emotional reactions. For
example, what came up for you when that
happened? I'm going to repeat that. Can
someone write this in the chat box? What
came up for you when that happened? We
spend a fair You always say I talk about
feeling things. Can you share that with
everybody?
>> Well, you know, people think People say,
"Oh, Jonathan, you know, I call him
noodles for a reason because he thinks
all the time. He's You know, he's I I I
equate him to Alice in Wonderland who
wakes up and thinks six impossible
things before breakfast."
>> [laughter]
>> Like,
I'll come up the stairs and I haven't
had my coffee yet and he's like, "So,
what do you think about love in a
vacuum?"
>> [laughter]
>> What?
>> Yeah, you say I'm analyzing my dreams.
>> Totally, totally.
>> But Do you remember yes Finish your
thought.
>> So, but you know, it's the it's the um
Connor's birthday was just recently or
>> Yeah. Yeah, we
>> And and
>> we was honoring him. And I and you know,
it's the how does it feel for you today
kind of thing, you know, what is it that
you're going through sort of sort of
questioning.
And um I think that again, that comes
down to curiosity.
>> Yeah. Um and and being curious not just
about thinking things, but about feeling
things. And and it's interesting the
gentleman that we spoke to yesterday, he
says, "I'm an overthinker." And I go,
"No, you're not an overthinker." I go,
"It's just you're thinking just right."
You know, that's a judgement when we say
overthinking. I think the exact perfect
amount of thinking I need to do for me.
Okay, couple more things and then we'll
we're going to move on. Exploring future
uh vision for our relationship is
something that we have a fair amount of
discourse on. Questioning our cultural
beliefs on masculinity, dating rules,
relationship myths, we talked about
that. Reflecting upon our past
relationships, we we Sometimes every
once in a while we're looking at our
relationship and we reflect upon a
previous relationship just to just to
notice the contrast between that.
>> yes, yes.
>> And lastly, I wrote down wondering
together. Wondering together, human
behavior, dreams, why people do what
they do, the mystery of life, you know.
We This is the conversations we have, I
mean, daily, in-depth um
And I think you know, the reason why I
wanted to do this video is because
dating could be, you know, attraction,
entertainment, romance, and physical
connection,
um
but what really makes a relationship
is the rich conversation two people can
have. The rich conversation. So, when
you're saying things like, "What came up
for you?" opens the door for rich
conversation.
And without rich conversation,
you might as well just be with a
roommate.
>> Yeah.
>> You know?
>> Yeah.
>> That you have sex with maybe, you know?
But I mean, I'm sorry. I I I I wonder
how many people are just roommates with
each other
and they don't have a deep rich
meaningful relationship. And if these 10
things give you any context to look at
dating from a different lens, I hope
here
um
you know, Deb agrees. Um but my Oh, one
last thing.
If you're going on a first date with
someone, bring up something known as the
And game. Here, I'll put it up closer.
Can you see that?
>> It's by a company called the Skin Deep.
>> Skin Deep.
>> And uh you can go online and do this I
think it's the skindeep.com.
But I've done it where, you know, I've
taken this game on maybe a second or
third date. I you know, I ask. I I I you
know, I ask for consent. Um and usually
I'll be I'll I'll do it very playfully.
Like, "Hey, you want to play a game
while we're at dinner?" You know? And um
I've had
guys who I've been dating say, "Sure.
Tell me a little bit about it." And I'd
be like, "It's just a card game, but you
know, it kind of
>> But it affords the opportunity to go
deep and
>> will say it asks some of the deeper
questions.
>> Mhm.
>> And you know, and their response is key.
>> So, with that said, did you get value
out of this conversation? We'd like to
hear your thoughts. Do me a favor, post
a comment below. We do our best to read
them all in the first 24 hours. As
always, if you like these videos, please
hit that like button. Please share this
video. Please subscribe to the channel.
Hit the notification bell so you can be
notified of new videos. And if you want
to connect, hey, there's links below.
Schedule a discovery call to see if
working with a coach is right for you.