The Science of Protein and Its Role in Longevity, Cancer, Aging, and Building Muscle
Watch on YouTubeVideo summary
The video explores the critical yet often debated role of dietary protein beyond its basic function as a muscle building block, emphasizing its importance for metabolism, insulin sensitivity, and disease prevention. A central argument is that maintaining or increasing skeletal muscle mass through resistance training combined with adequate protein intake significantly slows age-related decline, reduces frailty, and lowers mortality risk. The transcript highlights that after the age of 50, individuals naturally lose about one percent of their muscle mass annually, but this process can be reversed or mitigated by engaging in strength training while consuming sufficient protein to overcome "anabolic resistance," a condition where aging muscles become less responsive to amino acids unless physical activity is maintained.
Regarding optimal intake levels, the discussion challenges the traditional Recommended Dietary Allowance (RDA) of 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight as being too low for most people seeking health benefits or muscle maintenance. Instead, evidence suggests that a daily range of 1.2 to 1.6 grams per kilogram is more effective for general health and preventing age-related loss in lean mass, with some scenarios like body recomposition benefiting from even higher intakes up to two grams or slightly above. The video clarifies that high protein intake does not harm kidney function in healthy individuals; any observed changes in kidney markers are normal adaptive responses rather than signs of damage, dispelling long-standing myths about the dangers of excessive protein consumption for those without pre-existing conditions.
The content also addresses common misconceptions surrounding protein timing and distribution, explaining that while spreading intake across meals is ideal, consuming larger doses at once does not result in wasted nutrients because the body can utilize significant amounts over time. The concept of a narrow "anabolic window" immediately following exercise has been debunked by research showing elevated muscle protein synthesis for up to 24 hours post-workout, meaning total daily intake matters more than precise timing relative to workouts. Additionally, the video discusses pre-sleep protein consumption as a beneficial strategy to enhance overnight recovery and support those practicing time-restricted eating without compromising morning appetite or subsequent performance.
Finally, the transcript examines the nuances between animal and plant-based proteins, noting that while animal sources generally offer higher digestibility and complete amino acid profiles rich in leucine—the key trigger for muscle synthesis—vegetarians can effectively meet their needs through diversified diets and protein isolates. The video concludes by addressing concerns about cancer risk linked to high IGF-1 levels from protein intake, arguing that physical activity fundamentally alters this dynamic by directing growth factors toward beneficial tissues like muscles and the brain rather than allowing them to accumulate in a way that promotes disease. Ultimately, for physically active individuals, higher protein consumption supports longevity, performance, and overall health without posing significant risks when paired with an active lifestyle.
Read the full video transcript
welcome to today's deep exploration into
one of nutrition's most critical and
debated topics protein Beyond its
well-known role as the building block of
muscle protein is fundamental to our
metabolism insulin sensitivity and the
prevention of diseases such as type two
diabetes and sarcopenia but how much
dietary protein do we really need and
could too much protein especially from
meat actually be harmful today we'll
discuss why maintaining and even
building muscle is critical for everyone
not just athletes you'll discover how
protein intake coupled with resistance
training drives muscle repair and growth
enhancing athletic performance improving
metabolic health and promoting longevity
by acting as a defense against age
related Frailty you'll learn about
optimal protein amounts based on age
activity level and goals whether you
want to actively gain muscle maintain it
or just improve body composition we will
critically examine current protein
recommendations challenging the adequacy
of the RDA of 0.8 G per kilogram body
weight drawing on the latest research we
discuss why higher intakes ranging from
1.2 to 1.6 grams per kilogram are more
beneficial for General Health and why up
to two grams or higher may be best for
body recomposition addressing the
contentious links between high protein
diets and health risks we will analyze
evidence surrounding proteins
association with cancer heart disease
and kidney function we'll explore how
lifestyle factors particularly physical
activity profoundly influence these
risks specifically we'll uncover how
exercise modulates growth factors like
igf-1 diverting them towards muscle and
brain tissue where they support repair
and growth while potentially mitigating
their procancer effects in other tissues
we dissect the differences between
animal and plant proteins in stimulating
muscle protein synthesis we'll provide
practical strategies for vegetarians and
vegans to meet their protein needs
effectively through increased total
intake Diversified sources and the use
of plant-based protein concentrates
we'll also dispel myths around protein
intake timing you'll learn how
Distributing protein evenly across males
can maximize muscle protein synthesis
and why the so-called post exercise
anabolic window may not be as narrow as
once thought additionally we highlight
the pivotal role of the amino acid
Lucine in activating muscle building
Pathways and how this impacts protein
quality considerations by the end of
this episode you'll be equipped with all
of the evidence-based insights you need
to better navigate common misconceptions
and ultimately harness protein for
muscle maintenance performance and a
Frailty free future so let's get into it
how much muscle we have tells us more
about how we are aging than body weight
or BMI ever could here's a startling
fact after the age of 50 the average
person loses about 1% of their muscle
mass every single year and it's not just
muscle mass strength plummets even
faster dropping around 3% annually by
the time you reach 75 if you're not
engaging in regular strength training
you could be losing up to 4% of your
strength every year so what can we do
about this exercise both before you need
it building muscle Reserve but also in
old age to slow and reverse the decline
while resistance training is the most
important factor for building and
maintaining muscle mass and strength
protein intake plays an important role
too a metaanalysis from Dr Stuart
Phillips and colleagues highlights the
importance of protein intake by showing
that people who engage in resistance
training and supplemented with
additional protein taking their total
daily protein intake up to 1.6 gram per
kilogram body weight increase their
muscle mass by 27% and their strength by
10% more than those who did resistance
training without additional protein
supplementation
so these people were getting around 1.2
g of protein per kilogram body weight so
dialing in that protein intake matters
for both muscle mass and strength when
combined with resistance training
skeletal muscle makes up around 30 to
40% of our lean body mass more muscle
doesn't just mean more strength it means
better metabolism enhanced insulin
sensitivity and a pretty good defense
against type two diabetes it also
dramatically decreases Frailty and the
risk for sarcopenia one of the the main
risk factors for Falls and fractures in
older adults research has shown that
individuals who suffer from a fragility
fracture are twice as likely to die
compared to those without such fractures
and between 22 to 58% of people with a
hip fracture pass away within just 12
months after the injury in old age
falling and breaking a hip can literally
be a death sentence a better body
composition dramatically improves
quality of life and reduces disability
risk having a higher muscle mass can
decrease the risk of early death by 30%
whereas having a high fat Mass can
increase that risk by
56% so what explains our greater
susceptibility to lose muscle mass as we
get older there are a few factors that
play a role in this but a big player
here is a phenomenon called anabolic
resistance so as we age our muscles
become less responsive to amino acids
meaning they don't trigger muscle
protein synthesis in response to protein
intake as effectively so for older
individuals the same amount of protein
results in a smaller increase in muscle
protein synthesis compared to younger
people some Studies have shown that an
older person requires almost twice as
much protein for the same response for
example around 0.24 gram of protein per
kilogram body weight or 0.1 G per pound
that's 20 gram of protein for about an
80 kgam man maximally stimulates muscle
protein synthesis in someone young but
this dose is higher for older adults who
need about 0.4 gram of protein per
kilogram or 0.18 gam per pound of
protein per dose an older adult man
weighing about 80 kilg would need about
32 grams of protein to maximally
stimulate muscle protein synthesis by
the way for anyone taking notes this
suggests that the optimal amount of
protein per dose is between 20 and as
high as 35 gram of protein depending on
your personal level of anabolic
resistance so this means a few things
the first is that if you're older you
need a higher total daily protein intake
to maintain or increase muscle mass it
also means that you need a higher dose
of protein at each meal to stimulate
muscle protein synthesis but anabolic
resistance is not inevitable or only due
to aging as some might suggest in fact
physical inactivity may actually be the
biggest contributor reducing physical
activity worsens anabolic resistance for
example taking fewer steps for just 2
weeks causes anabolic resistance in
older adults and reduces their insulin
sensitivity imagine what decades of
inactivity can do that's the bad news
but the good news is that exercise makes
muscle more sensitive to protein and
essentially negates anabolic resistance
when older adults exercise before
protein intake their muscle anabolic
response is identical to that of a
younger adult so how do I interpret this
active old older adults probably don't
experience as much anabolic resistance
as inactive people and therefore it
might not be such an issue for people
that are Physically Active the most
effective way to combat anabolic
resistance as we age is through regular
physical activity combined with a higher
daily protein intake ideally around 1.6
gram per kilogram body weight we do not
have to be frail in old age we can build
muscle into our 40s 50s 60s and even our
70s and Beyond and we can def Ely
increased muscle strength and power
output at this age in one study that
recruited adults aged 90 years and older
8 weeks of high-intensity strength
training produced a 174% increase in
muscle strength muscle strength and size
increased even in the ninth decade of
Life an age when most people wouldn't
even think twice about touching a weight
so let's talk about the optimal protein
intake the optimal amount of protein
will not be the same for everyone some
people want to build muscle mass some
people want to Main ttain it and others
want to improve their body composition
by building muscle and losing fat each
of these goals requires a more tailored
approach the first thing to knowe is
that it's generally agreed upon that
protein needs should be calculated based
on a lean body mass or an adjusted body
weight reflecting a healthy body fat
percentage so for example 12 to 15% for
men and around 20% for women this
prevents unrealistic targets especially
for those who are overweight or obese so
when I refer to protein intake in grams
per kilogram of body weight per day what
I'm ideally referring to is your ideal
or goal body weight let's address one
thing up front the recommended dietary
allowance or the RDA for protein of 0.8
gr per kilogram per day is thought by
many to be too low this is because the
RDA was derived from nitrogen balance
studies which have limitations due to
incomplete collection and inaccurate
estimates of amino acid loss
the optimal range for daily protein
intake is closer to 1.2 to 1.6 G per
kilogram body weight per day or roughly
0.54 to 0.72 G per pound this is based
on alternative methods like stable
isotope studies which consistently show
that higher intakes are necessary to
maintain a positive protein balance far
above the 0.8 G per kilogram often cited
so aiming for at least 1.2 gr and up to
1.6 G is what we're talking about for
optimal protein intake there's good
evidence to suggest this for example
older adults consuming at least 1.2
grams of protein per kilogram body
weight per day prevented age related
losses in lean mass when compared to
consuming the RDA of 0.8 gr per kilogram
body weight older women were also 30%
less likely to experience Frailty when
consuming protein above the RDA so what
is the optimal protein intake for
building muscle while resistance
training for people engaged in
resistance training a protein intake of
1.6 gram per kilogram body weight per
day has been shown to maximize gains in
lean body mass with a 27% increase in
muscle mass over even a 1.2 gam per
kilogram intake that's a lot and it
really just serves to really underscore
how low the RDA really is when you're
talking about 0.8 G per kilogram body
weight by the way for an excellent
discussion of the protein RDA and much
more see my interview with Dr Stuart
Phillips in episode 76 of the Fami
Fitness podcast there are special
circumstances where even a higher
protein intake might offer some marginal
benefit the first example is people
undergoing body recomposition where they
are in an energy deficit to lose fat
Mass while preserving or even increasing
muscle mass so let's talk a little bit
more about body recomposition and weight
loss a higher protein intake tends to
improve satiety it helps you feel Fuller
for longer and may help prevent
overeating for people who want to lose
weight this is a major benefit eating
more protein is also essential during
weight loss to prevent the loss of lean
body mass when you eat a higher protein
calorie restricted diet more weight loss
comes from fat mass than muscle mass but
remember resistance training is also
important to prevent the loss of lean
mass high protein diets may also cause a
slight increase in the metabolic rate
due to the thermic effective food
helping you burn a few more calories
throughout the day the second example
where a higher protein intake above 1.6
G per kilogram may be beneficial is with
professional athletes where extremely
marginal improvements in muscle protein
synthesis gives them an edge on
competition so in this scenario this is
where up to 2.2 grams of protein per
kilogram per day or one gram per pound
May provide marginal benefits despite
common misconceptions a very high
protein intake is not harmful to Kidney
Health in people without pre-existing
kidney conditions research consistently
shows that high protein diets are safe
for most people and any concerns over
kidney damage are largely unfounded so
let's talk about this myth early
interpretations of certain studies
suggested that excessive protein intake
might overwork the kidneys while protein
restriction can slow the progression of
kidney disease in some individuals we
now know this does not imply that a
healthy people should limit their
protein consumption higher protein diets
do induce changes in kidney function but
they do not overburden the kidneys The
observed increase in markers in kidney
function is a normal adaptive response
to eliminate Ura and other waste
products generated during protein
metabolism this is entirely normal for
individuals with healthy renal function
so current evidence does not support an
association between higher protein
intake and kidney disease among healthy
adults or those at risk such as
individuals with obesity hypertension or
even diabetes I abetes moreover research
and athletes has shown that consuming
protein intakes as high as 3.2 to 4.5
Gams per kilogram of body weight per day
for up to one year does not cause any
adverse changes in kidney function and
is considered safe this intake is four
to six times higher than the RDA for
protein and emerging research even
suggests that higher protein intake may
actually be beneficial for people with
chronic kidney disease some Studies have
found that consuming protein at levels
above the RDA is associated with reduced
mortality risk in this population
challenging the traditional approach of
protein restriction the bottom line we
can finally put to rest the myth that
high protein diets harm healthy kidneys
it's time to tackle another important
aspect of protein intake and that's how
often and when we should consume it
we'll tackle two key points first how we
consume our daily protein intake whether
we should spread it evenly across 3 to
four meals or load it up into one or two
meals second and related does protein
have to be consumed within a critical
anabolic window or timed with our
workouts in short the answer to both of
these is that factors are less important
overall than you might expect emerging
evidence reveals that the body can
effectively utilize even very large
protein doses this challenges the notion
that protein must be meticulously spread
over multiple meals to maximize muscle
protein synthesis even though an even
daily protein distri distribution is
ideal this doesn't mean that consuming
the same total amount of protein in
fewer high protein meals is ineffective
protein distribution is important but
not vital when you eat a larger dose of
protein it takes longer to digest but
your body will eventually use it this is
contrary to what some people think
happens when you consume more than 20 to
25 grams of protein in a single meal
they think that the excess protein will
just be excreted by the body and
otherwise wasted in fact fact a study by
Dr Luke Van Lon and colleagues found
that consuming 100 grams of protein
after exercise led to a more robust and
prolonged anabolic response than did 25
grams of protein but had negligible
effects on amino acid oxidation the
conclusion from this study was quote the
magnitude and duration of the anabolic
response to protein has no upper limit
in humans and has been severely
underestimated end quote this dispels a
few myths about how the body can use
only 20 to 25 gram of protein at once as
a practical takeaway a more evenly
distributed pattern of protein intake
throughout the day is probably what we
should be striving for but evidence like
this highlights why more and more
experts seem to be aligning on the
simple fact that the vast majority of us
athletes or not should be thinking about
protein intake from the standpoint of
total daily intake with less overall
focus on factors like timing or the per
meal intake another question that people
have regarding protein timing is whether
protein needs to be consumed immediately
after exercise to enhance the effects of
training this idea is known as the
anabolic window the anabolic window is a
period after exercise typically lasting
from 30 minutes to 2 hours during which
the body is primed to absorb and utilize
nutrients particularly protein and
carbohydrates for muscle repair and
growth it occurs because the body's
ability to synthesize protein and
replenish glycogen stores is heightened
aided by exercise induced hormonal
changes like increased insulin levels
consuming 20 to 40 grams of high quality
protein often paired with carbohydrates
can enhance Muscle Recovery and growth
during the anabolic window or so it was
once thought recent scientific evidence
reveals that muscle protein synthesis
remains significantly elevated for a
full 24 hours following exercise
effectively debunking the notion of a
very narrow anabolic window lasting only
a few hours furthermore supplementing
with protein before exercise has the
same effects on body composition and
strength compared to supplementing with
protein immediately after exercise in
other words there are no meaningful
differences between pre and post
exercise protein ingestion this means
that you're free to choose when you want
to consume protein in relation to
exercise so long as your total daily
intake of protein is adequately High to
support optimal muscle protein synthesis
of course there is definitely no
downside to consuming protein
immediately after a workout especially
for people interested in achieving
marginal gains in strength or muscle
mass to wrap up our discussion on
protein timing and distribution I want
to bring up one more strategy to help
with muscle building that relates to
protein distribution and timing
pre-sleep
protein there's two ways to look at this
one way is through the lens of Tim
restricted eating and the other is
through the lens of actively optimizing
for muscle protein synthesis on training
days it's been shown in Studies by Dr
Luke Van Lun and colleagues that protein
consume before bed is digested and
absorbed overnight it also increases
overnight muscle protein synthesis rates
and improves net protein balance in
people who had performed resistance
training earlier in the day to enhance
Muscle Recovery the benefits of
pre-sleep protein have also been shown
during chronic resistance exercise
training consuming about 30 grams of
protein before bed every night while
resistance training appears to increase
muscle mass and muscle strength another
thing about pre-sleep protein is that it
does not seem to reduce appetite or
diminish the muscle protein synthesis
response at breakfast the next morning
which may have been a concern for some
people overall I think pre-sleep protein
is just one way to increase total daily
protein intake if you don't like going
to bed hungry having a low calorie
protein shake on training days may have
the benefit of potentially enhancing
your muscle gain on those training days
but don't use this as an excuse to go
wild we should still be mindful about
the fall and insulin sensitivity that
happens as we get close to our habitual
bedtime and this is particularly true if
you're not actively training so let's
summarize some key points about protein
timing and distribution first while it's
not necessary to consume protein
immediately after a workout there's no
harm in doing so for those who exercise
fasted having a protein Rich meal right
after may be beneficial ultimately total
daily protein intake is the most crucial
Factor second evenly Distributing
protein across meals is ideal but your
body can use even large protein meals
and finally consuming protein before bed
isn't essential but it can be a helpful
strategy to boost total daily intake or
support Muscle Recovery especially in
those who are actively training all this
talk about protein lacks context unless
we discuss the best sources of protein
particularly when it comes to
stimulating muscle protein synthesis is
animal protein better than plant protein
what about whey protein compared to
casine protein a highquality protein can
be efficiently digested and utilized to
maximize muscle protein synthesis
several factors influence a protein's
digestibility including whether it's a
whole food source an animal-based or
plant-based protein Source the presence
of other nutrients like fiber which are
mainly present in plant foods and the
amino acid composition of the protein
when it comes to the amino acid
composition Lucine is of particular
importance for protein quality
the main anabolic component of protein
is the branch chain amino acid Lucine
which is a potent stimulator of muscle
protein synthesis Lucine stimulates
muscle protein synthesis by activating
the mtor pathway which is our body's
Central regulator of cell growth and
Metabolism in fact Lucine appears to be
more critical than the total protein
content of food or supplement in
determining the muscle protein anabolic
response this concept is referred to as
the loosen threshold or the Lucine
trigger hypothesis which suggests that a
specific amount of Lucine must be
consumed to activate muscle protein
synthesis essentially Lucine acts as a
switch kickstarting the muscle protein
building process about 0.25 grams of
protein per kilogram body weight in a
single meal provides a saturating dose
of Lucine and amino acids to stimulate
muscle protein synthesis for up to 6
hours that's about 2 to three grams of
Lucine which can be obtained by
consuming 20 G of a high quality protein
like whey protein even though Lucine
might be the most important amino acid
for stimulating muscle protein synthesis
all of the amino acids are required to
allow the process of muscle protein
synthesis to sustain for 4 to 6 hours
loosing is the signal but we also need
to have all of the building blocks to
build and repair muscle protein exercise
lowers that loosing threshold because it
makes muscle more sensitive to amino
acids this means a lower dose of Lucine
and therefore a lower dose of protein is
needed to reach the Lucine threshold and
stimulate muscle protein synthesis after
exercise aging does reduce the
sensitivity of lucing and other amino
acids it takes a larger dose of protein
or Lucine to stimulate the same muscle
protein synthesis response for someone
who is older compared to a younger adult
but again older adults who routinely
exercise can help overcome this since
exercise increases sensitivity Lucine if
you're consuming a variety of
plant-based and animal-based food
sources and or supplementing with whey
protein you probably don't have to worry
about consuming enough Lucine at each
meal or throughout the day focusing on
Whole Foods is the best way to ensure
you're getting enough Lucine but of
course if you're concerned adding whey
protein or Branch chain amino acid
supplement to your diet is another way
to get additional Lucine now let's talk
about the difference between protein
from animal and plant-based sources
animal versus plant prot protein whether
your loyalties are towards a plant-based
diet or a meat inclusive diet from a
standpoint of just focusing on
optimizing for muscle protein synthesis
an animal Source protein is better it is
also easier for most people to obtain
protein from an animal-based food source
for a few reason for one animal protein
sources have a greater protein density
plant-based foods contain less protein
per gram than most animal based foods
for example getting 20 gram of protein
from potatoes means you need to consume
more than a kilog of potatoes but just
70 gram of meat like chicken or beef
contain 20 gram of protein second
plant-based foods have a lower
digestability than animal-based Foods
largely due to the presence of a food
Matrix consisting of fiber fiber can
slightly reduce the body's ability to
extract and utilize protein found in
plants it also slows the digestion
process sprouting and fermenting can
overcome some of this and improve the
digestibility and absorption of plant
protein third plant proteins are often
deficient in one or more of the
essential amino acids for example lysine
methionine and most importantly Lucine
remember that essential amino acids are
needed to be consumed in the diet to
build complete proteins in the body a
lower essential amino acid content means
that most plant proteins are incomplete
proteins and stimulate a lower anabolic
response compared to animal-based
protein if you're eating plant-based you
do have options protein needs can be met
on plant-based diets by supplementing
with plant-based protein isolates and
concentrates by consuming a larger
quantity of protein each day to
compensate for a lower protein quality
and also by diversifying the intake of a
variety of plant-based sources of
protein so creating complimentary
proteins that have the right amino acid
profile despite the lower anabolic
potential of plant-based protein sources
studies generally support the idea that
as long as the total daily protein
intake is high enough a vegetarian or a
vegan diet can support daily muscle
protein synthesis and gains in muscle
size and strength as much as a diet
containing animal-based protein but
because plant protein is lower in
quality you'll have to consume more food
overall to reach your daily protein
intake but Whole Foods aren't the only
source of protein many people choose to
obtain their protein through protein
supplements or protein powder and
there's a good reason to think that this
is a fairly sensible practice whey
protein is one of the most popular
protein supplements in part because it's
an extremely high quality protein Source
whey is a rich source of the essential
amino acids cysteine and the branch
chain amino acids Lucine isol leucine
and veiling Whey also contains several
bioactive peptides the loosing content
of whey is what makes it stand out the
loosing content in way is 50 to 75%
higher than other protein sources
compared to the other component of milk
protein like casin whey protein is more
rapidly digested and stimulates muscle
protein synthesis more effectively at r
and after exercise making it a go-to
protein source for many athletes the
slower digestion of casine compared to
whe isn't necessarily A downside because
this means casine provides a prolonged
release of amino acids that can be
helpful for sustaining the muscle
protein synthesis response for a longer
period of time whey and caseine protein
are both much higher quality protein
sources than collagen which has a lower
quality amino acid profile it's rich in
Glycine and Proline but lacks essential
amino acids like Lucine furthermore
collagen does not significantly enhance
muscle protein synthesis or muscle
connective protein synthesis at rest or
after exercise making it a suboptimal
protein choice for those engaged in
resistance training and wanting to
improve skeletal muscle protein
synthesis it should be clear from our
discussion thus far that dietary protein
especially when optimized to suit your
individual goals and needs has an array
of health benefits for nearly everyone
it's performance enhancing anti-aging
from the standpoint of Frailty
prevention and can help you lose weight
however this might come as a surprise to
many but there is a school of thought
within the Aging community that too much
dietary protein increases cancer risk
and contributes to accelerated aging yet
today many athletes consume a high
protein diet and the fact of the matter
is being an athlete even a recreational
one is one of the best things we can do
to age well this is both intuitively and
scientifically obvious how do we
reconcile these facts let's get into it
some researchers argue that a high high
protein intake especially for meat
accelerates aging and even raises the
risk of cancer and early death this idea
stems largely from laboratory studies
showing that restricting protein intake
extends lifespan in animals and
observational data linking High animal
protein diets to a higher mortality rate
supporting this idea one study found
that middle-aged adults consuming high
protein diets where 20% of their
calories came from protein were 75% more
likely to die from any cause and four
times more likely to die from cancer
this is a pretty shocking statistic and
animal evidence corroborates some of
this at the mechanistic level however
there is more to this story in another
major study middle-aged adults consuming
high protein diets did show increased
mortality rates but only if they had
other unhealthy lifestyle factors like
obesity smoking heavy drinking or being
sedentary among healthy people this
Association disappeared so does a High
animal protein diet really pose a health
risk or is it more about what unhealthy
lifestyle factors exist in someone's
life this is where it gets interesting
protein particularly from animal sources
spikes levels of a hormone called igf-1
which can help build muscle support
brain health it enhances muscle repair
but high igf-1 levels also come with
potential downsides like promoting the
survival of pre-cancerous cells and
potentially allowing them to form cancer
numerous Studies have found an
association between elevated igf-1
levels and an increased risk of various
cancers so should we cut protein
drastically to lower igf-1 levels not
necessarily lowering igf-1 too much can
come with its own set of risks for
example calorie restriction which
significantly drops igf-1 has been
linked to brain matter loss in non-human
primates this raises questions about
whether low igf-1 might have trade-offs
in terms of brain health so is it better
to significantly cut protein intake and
avoid these risks or is there a balance
to be struck that gives us the best of
both worlds muscle strength muscle
repair cognitive health and protection
against cancer a recent meta analysis by
Dr wter Longo and colleagues highlighted
this idea showing a U-shaped
relationship between igf-1 levels and
mortality both very high and very low
igf-1 were linked to higher death rates
what was the optimal range it was
actually around 120 to 160 nanog per
milliliter and to reach this igf-1 sweet
spot researchers estimated a daily
protein intake of around 50 to 80 gam
which is not very much protein not to
mention this study did not specifically
look at healthy Physically Active people
and that's a critical piece to the
puzzle because a strong response to
exercise requires igf-1 so it raises a
philosophical question are these
recommendations aimed at healthy
Physically Active individuals or are
they tailored to people maintaining a
largely sedentary lifestyle physical
activity fundamentally changes how igf-1
behaves in the body exercise lowers
igf-1 in the bloodstream redirecting it
to where it can be beneficial like the
muscle and notably the brain here's why
that's important when you exercise
whether it's cardiovascular exercise or
strength training or high-intensity
interval training it stimulates muscle
fibers and increases igf-1 receptor
density in the muscle cells this makes
muscle tissue more sensitive to igf-1
potentially enhancing its uptake while
this precise mechanism is still being
explored in research what's clear is
that exercise increases the ability of
igf-1 to cross the bloodb brain barrier
once in the brain igf-1 plays a crucial
role in promoting neurogenesis that's
the growth of new brain cells especially
in regions of the brain like the hypoc
campus which is important for learning
and memory exercise doesn't stop there
exercise particularly intensive exercise
also raises levels of proteins that bind
to igf-1 and reduce its bioavailability
to damage cells that could potentially
form cancer cells exercise alone causes
more amino acids to be taken up into
skeletal muscle which also has the
effect of reducing circulating igf-1 in
fact when protein is consumed after
exercise igf-1 levels do not increase in
the ensuing 24 hours like they do when
protein is eaten with without exercising
beforehand so by channeling how igf-1 is
used and making it less available to
potentially stimulate cancer cells
exercise acts as a protective shield
regular physical activity has long been
shown to strongly reduce the risk of
many types of cancer and this may just
be one crucial mechanism that accounts
for that fact furthermore exercise
enhances the immune system's ability to
find and destroy cancer cells it lowers
chronic inflammation which is a known
risk factor for cancer and it improves
insulin sensitivity which can further
influence igf-1 levels so in short
higher igf-1 levels aren't inherently
dangerous it's the context that matters
exercise and a healthy lifestyle change
the story entirely showing us that igf-1
can be a powerful Ally for health
strength and also longevity when Guided
by an active balanced lifestyle this
brings us to another important question
if protein truly is inherently pro-aging
wouldn't we expect a population with a
higher protein intake athletes for
example to experience reduced life
expectancy but this doesn't appear to be
the case and in fact the opposite is
true athletes who we can reasonably
expect generally consume higher protein
amounts and are known to have elevated
igf-1 levels consistently show longer
lifespans and a better health metric on
average they live 2 to eight years
longer than the general population they
also die less of cancer and
cardiovascular diseases let's Circle
back to the amino acid Lucine whether
we're talking about optimizing muscle
protein synthesis or controversies in
the Aging field surrounding igf-1 and
mtor Lucine is at the heart of it Lucine
is the critical signal driving robust
activation of mtor animal protein has a
lot of lucing and whether you consider
that a good thing or not actually
depends on your views of igf-1 and mtor
mtor plays key roles in skeletal muscle
growth by driving muscle protein
synthesis and recovery but this brings
us to another area where mtor pathway
has also sparked controversy it's
potential connection to
atherosclerosis a study from early 2024
suggested that a high protein intake
could accelerate the development of
atherosclerosis which is the hardening
and stiffening of arteries the study
suggested that Lucine which activates
mtor and muscle tissue to drive muscle
growth might also activate mtor in the
vascular system promoting plaque buildup
through immune Cell Activation the
important thing to remember is that
exercise causes Lucine to be taken up by
muscle where it activates mtor in muscle
to build and repair muscle rather than
spending time in the bloodstream
triggering mtor in the vascular system
this is yet another example of how being
physically active versus sedentary
changes the entire equation it's a
different game for people who exercise
regularly okay so I hope it's clear by
now that the evidence suggesting high
protein diets are harmful to health is
not particularly strong when it comes to
some observational data suggesting a
potential link between high protein
intake and risk like cancer this risk
primarily applies to sedentary
individuals with other unhealthy
lifestyle factors like obesity for
physically active people it's a
different story exercise ensures that
protein and Lucine are directed toward
muscle growth and repair keeping mtor
activation where it's beneficial in the
muscles rather than in peripheral
tissues this explains why athletes
despite consuming more protein enjoy
Better Health and longer lifespans than
the general population the bottom line
is that for active individuals higher
protein intake supports performance
longevity and health all right everyone
that just about does it for our
discussion on the science of protein to
wrap up I want to provide eight of the
most important takeaways number one for
most adults a protein intake in the
range of 1.2 to 1.6 G per kilogram of
body weight per day should be consumed
to to support overall health older
adults athletes and people who want to
lose weight while sustaining lean body
mass should consume 1.6 gram per
kilogram per day or more protein need
should be calculated based on lean body
mass or an adjusted body weight that
reflects a healthy body fat percentage
this is typically around 12 to 15% for
men and 20% for women this means that if
you're not at your ideal weight you
should determine your protein
requirements using the target weight
you're aiming to achieve number two when
it comes to protein timing the so-called
anabolic window after exercise isn't as
narrow as once believe consuming protein
either before or after a workout is
effective but also just focusing on
total daily protein intake is what is
most important for optimizing resistance
training gains number three it is ideal
to try and distribute your protein
intake evenly across the day aim for
around 3 to four protein Rich meals each
containing around 20 to 25 gram of high
quality protein to stimulate muscle
protein synthesis for older adults
increasing each meal's protein content
to 20 to 30 grams may be advantageous
due to their higher protein needs and
anabolic resistance but remember that
total daily protein intake is much more
important than how protein is
distributed throughout the day number
four consuming protein before bed a
practice known as pre-sleep protein
intake this can be particularly
beneficial for older adults and athletes
this strategy enhances overnight muscle
protein synthesis and AIDS in Muscle
Recovery it contributes to better muscle
health and performance number five for
those considering protein
supplementation high quality sources
like whey and casine proteins are
excellent options whey protein is
rapidly digested and effective at
stimulating muscle protein synthesis
making it a great choice post exercise
or even before bed to provide additional
boost of amino acids casine protein
digests more slowly providing a
prolonged release of amino acids even if
meeting your protein needs through diet
alone supplementation can offer targeted
benefits such as supporting recovery
during sleep or after very intense
exercise number six animal proteins are
generally Superior to plant proteins for
maximizing muscle protein synthesis due
to their higher protein density better
digestability and complete essential
amino acid profiles particularly their
Lucine content however vegetarians and
vegans can still meet their protein
needs by consuming larger quantities of
plant-based proteins diversifying their
protein sources and incorporating
plant-based protein isolates and
concentrates to ensure they get all
their essential amino acids number seven
concerns about high protein intake
harming healthy kidneys are largely
unfounded for individuals without
pre-existing kidney issues and finally
number eight despite some schools of
thought in the longevity field that
higher protein intakes May reduce
longevity or promote cancer growth the
available evidence in humans just isn't
convincing enough exercise positively
influen uences how the body uses amino
acids and growth factors like igf-1 and
proteins like mtor directing them
towards the muscle and brain health
where they're most beneficial that
brings us to the end of this special
episode on all things protein I
sincerely hope that you learned a few
new things and have a greater
understanding of the incredibly
important role that protein plays in
promoting physical
health for