The Pain Children Feel About Divorce But Can’t Say - Erica Komisar
Watch on YouTubeVideo summary
Erica Komisar describes divorce for children as a psychological death within the family, where the loss of two parents who serve distinct functions shatters the illusion of a safe and stable nest. Children are born with an innate need to view their parents as perfect, omnipotent protectors capable of handling any situation; however, when parents separate, this sense of permanence is broken before children feel ready. This disruption forces them to confront the imperfections and humanity of their parents prematurely, leading to a crisis in trust regarding romantic connections later in life. Komisar emphasizes that while no relationship has true permanence due to factors like illness or accidents, society relies on the illusion of stability for healthy development, making divorce particularly devastating as it disillusiones children at an unprepared moment. A significant psychological mechanism driving this trauma is "magical thinking," a common pattern where young children believe they are responsible for their parents' separation because they feel they control everything around them. Komisar illustrates this with the example of a child who, after being angry at a parent or having negative fantasies about them dying due to an unmet desire, feels guilty when that event actually occurs. This belief system stems from early childhood experiences where children are treated as the center of the universe; if they learn that love must be earned through hard work rather than given freely, they internalize the idea that their actions dictate parental affection and stability. Consequently, many children blame themselves for the divorce, believing that if they caused it, perhaps they can fix it by working harder to prevent a breakup or regain lost security. Komisar argues that fairness between divorcing parents must often be sacrificed in favor of what is adaptive for the child's emotional well-being. The way divorced couples communicate, collaborate, and prioritize their children over their own desires will determine whether those children view future relationships as trustworthy. Parents are advised to avoid "leaking" their pain, loneliness, or personal grievances onto their children, who often end up acting as therapists for their parents' separation issues. Instead of burdening the child with adult conflicts, parents should seek external support and therapy themselves so they can process these traumas without involving the family unit in a way that creates attachment wounds. The emotional journey through divorce follows the standard stages of grief identified by Kubler-Ross: disbelief, sadness, anger, and acceptance. Komisar notes that while society often suggests moving on quickly, such as the Jewish custom of waiting a year before unveiling a memorial stone, many people get stuck in specific stages like depression or anger for years, much like a scratch on an old record preventing smooth playback. Children frequently become trapped in these earlier stages of grief and fail to reach acceptance if their parents do not model healthy processing. To prevent long-term damage where children carry unresolved trauma into adolescence and adulthood, it is crucial that both the child and the adults involved navigate this mourning process fully rather than holding onto pain indefinitely.
Read the full video transcript
You talk about divorce as something that
children experience almost like a death
in the family.
What's being lost psychologically?
So,
when we when we have
again, another politically incorrect
thing or maybe politically correct thing
to say, it's better to have two parents.
It's better to have a mother and father
because they serve different functions.
But, as as they say in the UK, better to
have an heir and a spare, right? So, the
idea that you have two parents means
that if you lose one, you have another.
But, the concept is when you have a
nuclear family, when you have two
parents, you're under the illusion that
it's a safe nest, that it is a safe,
stable environment in which to grow up.
And that stability provides you with the
emotional security you need to develop
in a healthy way.
When that sense that illusion, you know,
there is an illusion because there's no
permanence in life, right? I mean,
your parents could die, they could get
sick, they could, you know, get hit by a
bus, you know, I mean, there's no
permanence, but we're born with a sort
of a need for that illusion of
permanence.
Um, and in fact, people with very
healthy defenses, me included, with
everything that's going on in the world,
as you know,
um, which could be crazy-making, I my
defenses help me not to obsess over it
or focus on it because
I can stay optimistic, my resilience
allows me to cope with the adversity of
the world. It's It's like having shock
absorbers, right? On a It's And And so,
it's that sense of stability and
permanence. When you divorce, that
permanence is
the children are disillusioned
in a way before they're ready.
I always say every every child is born
with the need for a sense of omnipotence
in their parents. They need to believe
their parents are perfect. They can do
anything. They'll protect them. They're
um
Yeah. And so, I always tell this story
of my husband when he was a little boy,
um his father always drove. It was more
traditional. His mother never drove when
the father was in the car. And he would
sit in the back and he said, "I always
felt like my father knew every road on
every map in the whole world."
That's what childhood is.
Is a sense of feeling protected and as
if your parents are bigger and bigger
than life characters. When they divorce,
you see the imperfections of your
parents and you start to see them as
human before you're ready. But also the
impermanence of relationships and the
lack of trust, right? So, then you no
longer necessarily trust in the
permanence of those connections, of
those romantic connections. So, you
know,
many kids from divorce,
uh have trouble
trusting in the permanence of of
marriage and connections later on. Um
not all. So, the reason I wrote this
book is how do you
how do you help them? The way you talk
to them, the way you treat each other,
the way you care about each other as a
divorced couple, the way you work
together and collaborate and cooperate
and communicate, that's going to
determine, you know, that you can put
them first and sacrifice your desires
and needs for fairness and put them
first. All of that is going to dictate
whether that child in the future
can see relationships as trustworthy.
Isn't it crazy, the idea of fairness,
that that needs to be put to one side,
that there is something unfair to the
parents that is adaptive for the kid,
that's good for them, that's good for
their their upbringing? I think
a lot of children blame themselves for
their parents' divorces. Yeah. Why do
you think that's such a common pattern?
It's It's magical thinking. So, children
who are very young um
There was a great commercial on
television.
A little boy is in a Darth Vader outfit
and he's got a
a wand or whatever it's called a
lightsaber.
And A wand. Yeah.
A lightsaber.
Darth Vader going Expelliarmus.
A lightsaber. Yeah. And he flashes it
towards his car, the car the family car,
and the father is behind with the
the remote control and the father
presses it. And the little boy goes,
"Oh my god, I turned it off with my
lightsaber." That's magical thinking.
Magical thinking is something children
have when they're very little and they
outgrow, which is the belief that they
are the center of the universe. It's a
good thing.
Um we're born if our parents focus on us
as as if we are the center of the
universe,
then we believe that we are the center
of the universe and that gives us a
sense of steadiness and stability and
security from which to develop. We
outgrow magical thinking where we feel
we're in control of everything, but it
helps us to feel secure when we're
little. So, if something bad happens to
our parents when we're angry at them,
like if your father or mother get into a
car accident and die, let's say, when
you are really angry at them because
they didn't give you that toy or you
know, and you have terrible fantasies
and thoughts as a child that you wish
they would die or you know, which aren't
so terrible, they're just fantasies,
Mhm. and that parent actually does die,
that child then feels responsible for
that death. That's magical thinking. So,
basically, they believe they control
uh what's around them. So, it's very
common for children to believe that they
are responsible for the breakup of their
parents. And so, that's one of the
things in the book that I talk about.
How do you talk to children so you
disavow them of those illusions that
they are not responsible, that
you know, that you will always love them
because again, that that destruction of
that sense of permanence in a
relationship and that breaking of trust,
children can easily understand parents
break up as something parents could do.
If If parents can leave one another,
then can't they leave them as well? Mhm.
>> And so, there's a lot of things that
parents need to consider when they talk
to their children, and there is a way to
talk to children about a divorce. Is
there a sense as well like how a lot of
attachment wounds from early childhood
get replayed in adult relationships that
if I can redeem myself in this
situation, I will fix the wound that
existed before. That sort of classic
Luke. Is there something similar to that
going on with the magical thinking from
the kids that if I caused it, I can fix
it? Just line that I wrote in an essay a
couple of weeks ago which was
if as a child you're taught that you
need to work hard to be loved, if you
don't feel loved, you just need to work
harder. Yeah. And it kind of feels a
little bit
similar to that. Yeah, absolutely. I
mean,
it again, I think it's very important,
I'll say this, that if you if if you're
going through a divorce that you get
support, you know, and and I'm going to
I'm not going to be one of those
therapists who says like everybody needs
therapy. Not everybody needs therapy,
but a lot of people do, particularly if
they're going through life transitions
or traumas or, you know, and so if you
think about divorce is a trauma for
everyone, for parents, for children, and
so parents need support. The one of the
main reasons they need support is so
they don't leak all over their children
cuz it's very common for parents to
overshare their pain with their
children. To leak all over their
children.
>> Treating the kids, the kid of the
separation as the therapist for the
separation.
>> Yes, and also just as a container a dump
dumping into them about, you know,
either over sharing about their
loneliness or their pain or their or
their sex lives or so so basically
parents need therapy so they can so they
can raise children without burdening
those children.
Children need therapy because they can't
always go to their parents and tell them
what they're feeling and thinking
because they might feel uncomfortable.
Um and so they need a safe space that
isn't
either parent to bring their feelings.
Um that doesn't mean that parents aren't
also safe spaces, but children need to
have therapy to make sure that you're
addressing these conflicts and these
traumas early on. So as you say it, they
don't carry them into adolescence and
young adulthood and adulthood. What are
the typical stages that children go
through emotionally during a divorce?
It's it's the same stages any morning
process. Think of it as grief. They go
through the same Kubler-Ross. I always
say grief is grief, morning is morning.
Uh it's a death and so when when someone
dies, you go through the disbelief and
you go through the sadness and you go
through the anger and you go through the
acceptance. Um and the problem is if
your child gets stuck or if you as a
parent as an adult while you're going
through a divorce gets stuck. I've had
patients who gotten stuck for a decade
in grief. Meaning they get stuck in
anger or they get stuck in sadness and
despair where they can't you're meant to
move through grief. Um
so I'm Jewish so we say, you know,
morning is a year. You know,
from this from the moment someone dies,
we don't unveil the stone. We don't take
a cloth off the stone. We don't put the
stone up actually for a year. So it's
it's a year, but we have a year to go
through the process, right? But then
we're meant to unveil the stone and move
on with life.
Um what's happening is that people are
holding on. They're getting stuck like
almost like a scratch in an old LP
record. They're getting stuck at certain
stages of the grief and mourning
process.
And they'll either get stuck in the
depression or the disbelief or the
anger, but they
many don't get to the acceptance stage.
And children also aren't getting to the
acceptance stage. They're getting sort
of stuck in one stage of grief or
another.
Before we continue, as you're probably
aware, I'm not a massive drinker, at
least not anymore. But even if you too
are not drinking, sometimes you just
want something cold, frosty, and tasty
without the fear of a hangover the next
day, which is why I'm such a huge fan of
Athletic Brewing Co. Thank you very
much. Their non-alcoholic brews taste
just as good as the real thing. They've
got IPAs, hazy goldens. They're so good
that you'll forget that there's no
alcohol in them until you wake up the
next day feeling fantastic. It means
that you can enjoy the ritual without
the wreckage. No hangover, no 3:00 a.m.
panic, no wasted Sunday recovering from
Saturday. That is why I partnered with
them. You can find Athletic Brewing
Co.'s best-selling lineup at grocery or
liquor stores near you. Or, best option,
get the full variety pack of four
flavors shipped right to your door.
Right now, get up to 15% off your first
online order by going to the link in the
description below or heading to
athleticbrewing.com/modernwisdom.
Using the code modernwisdom at checkout.
That's athleticbrewing.com/modernwisdom
and modernwisdom at checkout. Near beer
terms and conditions apply. Athletic
Brewing Company
fit for all times.