The Common SLEEP MISTAKES You Make That DESTROY Your Health! | Matthew Walker
Watch on YouTubeVideo summary
In this episode of Health Theory, host Tom and renowned sleep scientist Matthew Walker explore why sleep is biologically essential despite its evolutionary disadvantages. Walker explains that Guinness World Records no longer recognizes attempts to break records for sleep deprivation because even a single night of shortening sleep to four hours can cause a 70% drop in natural killer cell activity, critical immune cells used to fight cancer and viruses. Furthermore, one week of "short sleep," defined as getting only four or five hours per night over several days, reduces testosterone levels by an amount equivalent to aging ten years. Walker illustrates the severity of this issue with data from daylight savings time transitions: losing just one hour of sleep in spring leads to a 24% increase in heart attacks the following day, whereas gaining that hour in autumn results in a 21% decrease. He contrasts these physiological risks with extreme feats like Felix Baumgartner's space jump, noting that while Guinness allows records for breaking sound barriers, they have banned attempts at sleep deprivation due to its catastrophic impact on mental and physical health. The conversation delves into the mechanisms of dreaming, which Walker describes as providing two primary benefits: creativity and emotional first aid. During deep sleep, memories are consolidated or "saved," but it is REM sleep that acts like informational alchemy by connecting disparate pieces of information in non-obvious ways to foster creative solutions. More importantly for mental health, dream sleep functions as nocturnal therapy by shutting off the stress-related neurochemical noradrenaline while reactivating emotional centers and memory areas. This unique state allows the brain to strip away the bitter emotional rind from painful memories without losing their informational content. Walker draws a parallel between this natural process and therapies involving MDMA or prazosin, noting that in PTSD patients with high noradrenaline levels who suffer repetitive nightmares, medications like prazosin—which block noradrenaline—can successfully stop these traumatic dreams by allowing the brain to finally detach emotion from memory during sleep. Walker also details the discovery of the glymphatic system, a waste-clearance mechanism that operates only when we are in deep sleep. Research led by Maiken Nedergaard revealed that this "sewage system" is not active throughout the day but kicks into high gear at night when brain cells shrink and cerebrospinal fluid washes away metabolic detritus. This process removes beta-amyloid, a protein linked to Alzheimer's disease, effectively performing a power cleanse for the brain; wakefulness itself generates low-level brain damage that sleep repairs. Consequently, insufficient sleep is identified as one of the most significant lifestyle factors determining whether an individual develops dementia later in life. The discussion also addresses nightmares, which are often part of this same emotional regulation process but can become pathological if they cause distress or harm, particularly in conditions like PTSD where noradrenaline levels prevent proper processing. Finally, the hosts address practical strategies for optimizing sleep and overcoming common pitfalls such as waking up at night and suffering from sleep inertia. Walker advises that when one wakes after three or four hours of sleep due to stress or excitement clearing adenosine (sleep pressure), they should not stay in bed awake but instead get out into a dim room to read, listen to an audiobook, or meditate until sleepy again before returning to bed; this prevents the brain from associating the bedroom with wakefulness. To combat morning sleep inertia—the grogginess upon waking—Walker suggests warming up the body through hot drinks and raising ambient temperature rather than relying on cold showers or caffeine spikes, as these methods help regulate core body temperature more naturally. He also emphasizes understanding one's chronotype via genetic markers like those found in the "morningness-eveningness questionnaire," noting that society often unfairly penalizes evening types who are genetically predisposed to wake up later and struggle with early morning routines designed for morning larks.
Read the full video transcript
From an evolutionary perspective,
sleep is the most idiotic of all
behaviors.
You know, when you think about it,
because firstly, when you're asleep,
you're not finding a mate, you're not
reproducing, you're not caring for your
young, you're not foraging for food, and
worse still, you're vulnerable to
predation.
Now, on any one of those single grounds,
but especially all of them as a
collective, sleep should have been
strongly selected against.
Hey everybody, welcome to another
episode of Health Theory. I am here with
somebody that's going to blow your mind.
His name is Matthew Walker. Matthew,
welcome to the show.
It's a delight to be here, Tom. Thank
you for having me. Dude, super excited.
I was telling you before we started
recording that you wrote a book called
Why We Sleep, and I'm always worried
when I'm bringing somebody on that's
covering a subject that I've talked
about before, if they're going to hit it
in a new way. And I loved your book. You
come at it from a totally different
angle. I wore my brain shirt out of
acknowledgement of how much you talk
about sleep and the neurological impact.
And so, I want to start with
two things from the book that really
blew my mind. And the first is that
sleep is so important that the Guinness
Book of World Records will not let
people try to set records for sleep
deprivation.
Walk us through why not. I think this is
a great entry to your world.
Yes, so what we know is that a lack of
sleep
will
impact just about every major
physiological system in your body and
almost every operation of your mind. For
example, if I were to take you and limit
you to just 4 hours of sleep for one
single night,
there is almost a 70% drop in what we
call natural killer cell activity, which
are critical anti-cancer fighting immune
cells. That's after one night of 4 hours
of sleep. That's crazy.
Secondly, if I were to short sleep you
for just 1 week, your levels of
testosterone would be that of someone 10
years your senior. Define short sleep.
What How many hours are we talking
So, here we could be talking about 4 to
5 hours a night for 4 or 5 nights in a
row, which if you look at the data on
the survey, that's not unusual for
perhaps even 20 to 30% of the
population.
Certainly during the week.
Um we also know from daylight savings
time that it doesn't take very much.
Because there is a global experiment
that's performed on about 1.6 billion
people across 70 countries twice a year,
and it's called daylight savings time.
Now, in the spring when we lose 1 hour
of sleep, we see a 24% increase in heart
attacks the following day. Yet in the
autumn in the fall, we see a 21%
decrease in heart attacks.
Now, you collide all of that information
together as well as the impact on the
brain, the mental health issues
regarding anxiety, suicidality,
depression, as well as increased risk
for Alzheimer's disease, and we've been
seeing that as well.
Um all of these things created this
perfect storm for Guinness to take a
step back. They used to recognize world
record breaking attempts.
And to put this in context, you know,
several years ago, a remarkable
individual, I think his name was Felix
Baumgartner, an Austrian,
um with Red Bull, he went up in a space
capsule. He went to the outer edges of
our atmosphere, of our planet. He opened
the door,
and then in a space suit, he jumped out.
He hurtled back down to Earth at over
1,000 km per hour. He broke the sound
barrier with his body.
And Guinness says, "That's just fine.
However, sleep deprivation attempts no
longer because they are that much more
concerning to your mental, your
physical, and your cognitive health.
That is the perfect explanation. Like
that dichotomy of Felix Baumgartner
versus just not getting enough sleep.
And I don't think it's a mistake that
the Navy SEALs use it just catastrophic
sleep deprivation as a part of their
Hell Week to really find out like who's
got the mental resilience to make it on
the other side.
Because when you're talking to cuz I if
I remember right, they get like
3 hours of sleep over 5 days or just
something stupid like that.
It's remarkably minimal. And they start
hallucinating. You know, I had a friend
who was
um who was in the British version of
that.
Um and they were saying, you know, they
were running around on these hills
during sort of these combat training
events. And they were just seeing sort
of gravestones popping up in front of
them. They were just delusional and
hallucinating.
What's going on? Like what is it that
causes us to hallucinate? Do we know the
mechanism, whatever breakdown there is
between the conscious and subconscious?
I'm not even sure what's happening.
Yeah, what we think is happening is that
after some degree of sleep deprivation,
you build up this pressure for the
different stages of sleep. And one of
the two main stages of sleep of human
sleep at least is something called rapid
eye movement sleep or REM sleep, which
is the stage that is principally
associated with dreaming.
And what we've learned is that once you
start to go through sleep deprivation
and including REM sleep deprivation, the
brain gets so starved of this thing
called dream sleep that it just simply
says, "Look, at some point I've got to
get this thing called REM sleep. And if
you're going to stay awake, I don't
really care. I'm just going to produce
this state of REM sleep." And so it's
almost as though you're awake, but the
veil of REM sleep dreaming comes over
the brain. And therefore, you're
essentially dreaming while you're awake,
and that's why you start seeing these
hallucinations and delusions. That's our
our current understanding. All right.
Now, that's really interesting. So, one
one of the questions I was most excited
to ask you about is the nature of
dreaming. So,
if the brain is saying, "Hey, look, I'm
going to do this whether you're awake or
asleep,
why is it so contextual? Like, there's
no question there were times where the
dream is so bizarre, like I can't anchor
it to my life, but a lot of times I can,
where I'm like, "I know exactly why I
started dreaming about that thing."
Do we have a sense of what the brain is
trying to do with dreams?
We do, and dreaming seems to offer at
least two different benefits for the
brain. The first is creativity. The
second is essentially emotional first
aid. It's overnight therapy.
So, point number one, creativity. One of
the things that REM sleep actually does
is
it takes all of the information that
you've been learning, and I should take
a step back. It's during deep sleep,
which actually happens more in the first
half of the night, that those memories,
those freshly minted memories that
you've recently learned and laid down in
the brain,
deep sleep will hit the save button on
those new memories so that you don't
forget. So, so deep sleep strengthens
and solidifies those individual
memories.
But, sleep, we've learned, is much more
intelligent than we ever imagined.
Because thereafter, it's dream sleep,
it's REM sleep, that takes all of those
individual memories, and it starts to
intelligently collide them and
interconnect them. Essentially, it's
informational alchemy.
Um you could almost think of it like um
group therapy for memories, that you
know, everyone gets a name badge and REM
sleep gathers in all of these pieces.
And it forces you to go and speak to the
people not at the front of the room that
you think you've got the most obvious
connection with, but to the people at
the back of the room that you think
you've got no connection with at all,
but it turns out that you do. It's a
non-obvious one. But it's a potentially
powerful one nonetheless.
And so after dream sleep, you wake up
with essentially a revised mind-wide web
of associations every single day. And as
a consequence, you are able to divine
solutions to previously impenetrable
problems.
And it's the very reason that no one has
ever told you to stay awake on a
problem.
And that's one of the benefits of dream
sleep, of REM sleep.
The second, however, is something that
we've more recently discovered and we've
done a lot of work in this area
regarding mental health,
is that REM sleep provides this
emotional first aid.
And what seems to happen is that sleep
will take in these difficult, often
concerning, even painful traumatic
emotional experiences.
And dream sleep acts like this beautiful
nocturnal soothing balm. And it just
takes the sharp edges off those painful
difficult experiences, so that you come
back the next day and they don't feel as
difficult anymore.
So in other words, it's not time that
heals all wounds. But it's time during
sleep that provides that emotional
convalescence, as it were.
So why does this relate to your
question, which is
there are times when it seems strange
and there are times when I can
definitely pick it up. What we know de
facto, definitively,
is that dreaming is not simply you
rewinding the videotape of the day and
then playing it back over again. In
fact, only about 5% of your dreaming
life is a veridical replay of anything
you experience during the day. However,
what is dominant, if there is a
if there's a red thread narrative that
runs through from your waking life into
your dreaming life, it is emotional
themes and concerns. That's the sort of
mental health benefit. That's the mental
first aid, the emotional first aid.
So, the emotional first aid was the
second thing that I wanted to talk
about. That was one of the the most
striking things about your book. And I
want to go a little bit deeper. Um
So much around dreaming and I don't I
don't want to stray too far from that
cuz there's so many more questions I
have about dreaming. But talk to me
about some of the research with um
noradrenaline and PTSD and the work
there because this was where I was like,
"Whoa, there is a layer to sleep that
I've never heard anybody talk about the
way that you're talking about it." This
is really fascinating.
Yeah, so several years ago um I
developed a theory as to exactly how
this emotional first aid would actually
work. Where
it it's what's remarkable about
dreaming, it's the only time during the
24-hour period where your brain shuts
off the stress-related neurochemical
called noradrenaline. We never see it at
any other time, any other stage of
sleep, or any time when you're awake.
And the sister chemical everyone will
know about in the body, which is called
adrenaline. But upstairs in the brain,
it's noradrenaline.
And I propose that what happens during
dream sleep, which is remarkable, is
that firstly we know from brain imaging
studies that we've done where we put
people inside of a scanner and we watch
their brain as it lights up as it goes
into dream sleep. Emotional centers of
the brain and memory centers of the of
the brain are reactivated during dream
sleep. So, firstly, we know that the
brain is capable and is probably
reactivating these emotional
experiences.
But, secondly, unlike when you're awake,
it's reactivating and re- sort of um
uh playing those memories in a brain
state that is devoid of any of the
stress-related neurochemical.
And so, in other words, dream sleep, we
sort of put forward as a theory, allows
the brain to take this sort of highly
charged emotional memory and strip away
the bitter emotional rind from the
informational orange. So, that you come
back the next day and it's peeled away.
And as a consequence, dream sleep has
divorced the emotion from the memory
because of this neurochemical state,
this kind of mollifying, soothing
neurochemical bath.
Are you familiar with what they're
studying with MDMA? Cuz it feels to me
like the same idea, right? So, hey, I've
got this guy that has PTSD. I'm going to
make him relive it, but I'm going to hit
him with MDMA, which neurochemically is
going to move him into a radically
different state. They now revisit the
same emotion cuz for And look, you know
so much more about this than I do, but I
find this so interesting. You will
correct me where I go wrong, but we're
not we're not faithful to the truth of
what has happened in our past. We pull a
memory forward. As we're sort of holding
it in working memory, it becomes
manipulable. And then when we restore
it, it's restored with whatever new
context we give it. So, if you revisit,
you can make it worse or you can make it
better.
And that feels like it's an echo of this
mechanism that you're talking about in
dreams.
It's exactly that. And you know, and
what we know is that when I was
describing that deep sleep hits the save
button on those new memories, that's
what we call consolidation. But, there's
also a process of reconsolidation.
You're absolutely right. And a great
analogy here is a word document. You
know, you would never open up a word
document and then create a new set of
sort of text, which is the memory, then
hit the save button, and then
double-click it the next day, open it
back up, and you can't do anything with
it. It's you can't change it, you can't
edit it. That's a ridiculous system of
storage, of information storage. And the
brain works just like that. When you
recall a memory, a memory once you've
hit the save button
is not simply permanent and immutable.
It's modifiable, and you can change it
and modify it, and then you can
reconsolidate it, you can resave it. Now
it's edited, and that's what therapy
does. That's what we think happens with
MDMA. That's what we think is partly
happening with dream sleep, but dream
sleep is quite different there. It's
this neurochemical strange state that
allows you to sort of soothe that memory
as well. And as I said, sort of strip
away, it's almost like detoxifying
the memory of the emotion. So that you
come back the next day, and you have a
memory of an emotional event, but it's
no longer emotional itself. And so I had
a theory that was in search of data, and
I went to a conference in Seattle, and I
presented the theory, and then the next
person up was a psychiatrist called
Murray Raskin, and he was working in the
VA system with veterans who had terrible
PTSD, and he was treating them with a
blood pressure medication that was
generic, cuz it's the VA system.
And that blood pressure medication was
called prazosin. Now, prazosin will
actually cross the blood-brain barrier.
It will not only affect the body, it'll
go up into the brain, and one of the
things that it shuts off is
noradrenaline.
And what we knew before is that in PTSD,
those patients have too high levels of
noradrenaline.
And what he was finding and scratching
his head over was to say, "Look, I've
been treating these patients with this
blood pressure medication,
and they're coming back to me because
one of, By the way, one of the
diagnostic features of PTSD is
repetitive nightmares. In fact, you
can't get a diagnosis of PTSD without
having repetitive nightmares.
And so, he was coming um these patients
were coming back to him and saying,
"Look, doc, I I don't know if my blood
pressure is any better, but my trauma
dreams are starting to go away, and I
don't know why." And he was publishing
this data.
So crazy.
So,
I had a And that's exactly what the
model would predict, that in PTSD,
levels of noradrenaline are too high, so
the brain is unable to do this elegant
trick of stripping the emotion from the
memory. So, the next night, when they
come back to dream, the brain comes back
and sleep to sleep and says, "Look, I've
still got this highly charged trauma
memory. Please do your trick of
separating emotion from memory." It
fails again. It's a broken record. It is
the repetitive nightmares of PTSD.
And I said, "Look, I I've got to speak
with you.
Um I flew him down to Berkeley um a few
weeks later. We had spent the whole day
together. We went out to dinner. We just
jammed on this. He started doing these
remarkable studies with prazosin,
looking at REM sleep, looking at
dreaming. And um several years later, it
became the um one of the only approved
medications for um repetitive nightmares
uh in PTSD.
Wow. Dude, that that to me is like just
when it feels like, "Man, we really know
a lot about something," and then a
breakthrough like that will occur. This
whole
field of beginning to really understand
cuz when the the title of the book, Why
Do We Sleep? is no one's been able to
give a satisfying answer to that. Like,
you get a lot of these hypotheses, but
this is really starting to feel like
we're at the beginning of beginning to
understand some of the stuff. So, give
us the explanation in in sort of an
evolutionary context of why we know
sleeping just absolutely has to be
crushingly important.
Yeah, and I'll just touch on your first
point, which is to say you're right. So,
you know, the book was um called Why We
Sleep because we do have now a pretty
good understanding. 50 years ago,
you know, we used to ask the question,
"Why do we sleep?" And the the crass and
unhelpful answer was at the time was
that we sleep to cure sleepiness.
Which is the the factious equivalent of
saying, and you would know this better
than anyone, you know, I eat to cure
hunger. Well, that tells you nothing
about the nutritional dynamics of food.
But it was the best that we had at the
time. Now, 50 years later with over over
10,000 empirical research studies, we've
actually had to upend the question.
We've actually now had to ask, "Is there
anything within the body, any major
physiological system in the body, or any
sort of major function of the mind that
isn't wonderfully enhanced by sleep when
we get it, or demonstrably impaired when
we don't get enough?"
And so far, the answer seems to be no
for the most part.
So, sort of to come back to your
sort of the the the second part of the
question, you know, from an evolutionary
perspective,
sleep is the most idiotic of all
behaviors.
You know, when you think about it,
because firstly, when you're asleep,
you're not finding a mate, you're not
reproducing, you're you're not caring
for your young, you're not foraging for
food, and worse still, you're vulnerable
to predation.
Now, on any one of those single grounds,
but especially all of them as a
collective, sleep should have been
strongly selected against in the course
of evolution.
But what we know is that sleep, if you
look from an evolutionary perspective,
sleep appears to have evolved with life
itself on this planet.
And then it has fought its way through
heroically every step along the
evolutionary pathway.
And it's long been said that as a
consequence, if sleep doesn't serve an
absolutely vital set of functions, then
it is the biggest mistake that the
evolutionary process has ever made.
And what we're now learning from the
science is that Mother Nature did not
make a spectacular blunder in creating
this beautiful thing called a full night
of sleep.
Yeah, it's really interesting to think
through. And one of the things that m-
gave me the first hook into why sleep
might be ridiculously important is the
fact that when you're sleeping, the
brain actually shrinks and allows you to
clear out amyloid plaques and like
basically you're brainwashing
yourself, literally washing your brain.
Yeah. Um at night, the glymphatic system
and and then I was like, okay, that's
interesting that you would need to go
into sort of this altered state to clear
this stuff out. Um
that to me gets interesting. What have
you found there in the literature that
um shows that it needs to specifically
be an altered state?
Yeah, we never thought that the brain
had its own cleansing mechanism.
Um and we all know that the body has
that mechanism. It's called the
lymphatic system. But it was only um
probably six or seven years ago that a
remarkable scientist, Maiken Nedergaard
at the University of Rochester, made a
stunning set of discoveries in mice.
What she found was that the brain
actually does have its own cleansing
system. It's called the glymphatic
system, named after the glial cells in
the brain that make it up.
Now, if that wasn't remarkable enough,
she went on to find two additional
discoveries.
The first is that um that sewage system
is not always switched on in high flow
volume across the 24-hour period.
It's specifically during deep sleep when
that um that cleansing mechanism kicks
into high gear. And as you said, these
brain cells will actually shrink and
allowing the cerebrospinal fluid to wash
away all of the metabolic detritus
that's been building up whilst we're
awake. Because make no mistake about it,
from a biochemical perspective,
wakefulness is low-level brain damage
and sleep is sanitary salvation.
Um and the third thing that she
discovered, which is something you
mentioned there, one of the pieces of
toxic metabolic protein uh product that
that cleansing system was washing away
was something called beta amyloid, which
is what we know is a protein culprit in
the cascade of Alzheimer's disease. And
we've now done a lot of work, and others
have done this work, showing that
insufficient sleep may be one of the
most significant lifestyle factors
determining whether or not you will
develop Alzheimer's disease in later
life. And it it seems to be that it's
this particular state of deep sleep and
these pulsing these slow pulsing
electrical big powerful brain waves that
happen during deep sleep that may be
driving the pulsing of this
cerebrospinal fluid. And this is
wonderful work by Laura Lewis at Boston
University most recently in humans
that are coupled to the brain waves that
you have. So, the reason that it's this
specific state, which was your question,
why deep sleep in particular, because
it's only that time period where we get
these huge powerful deep brain waves and
we get the shrinking of the cells and we
get therefore the flow of this pulsing
glymphatic system. So, in other words,
it's it's almost like a power cleanse
for your brain. You know, it's it's good
night sleep clean, as it were, in that
regard. So complex. It's crazy. This is
exactly why I don't like to take
supplements. It's like, man, there there
are levels of complexity that I assure
you we have not discovered yet and you
never know, like the heart medication
that's also, oh, this one's bypassing
the brain and dealing with
noradrenaline. And it has this huge
impact. Now, that one happens to be
positive, but there are some in certain
cases. But there are some that very much
are not. And speaking of are not
positive, so if sleep is so good for me
and dreams are amazing and they help
with creativity and they they take the
sharp edges off my emotions. Why the
hell do I have nightmares?
Yeah, so what we know is that nightmares
aren't necessarily
um and
we we know that in some conditions and
PTSD is a is a very good example of this
that they can sort of step over that
threshold from being normative to
non-normative. I mean, they can be very
concerning and and and disruptive to
people and it's also very traumatic too
to relive those and and wake up from
them. We do think it's part of the same
process of sort of emotional regulation
that it's the brain trying to understand
and better comprehend what this thing
called waking life and all of its
emotional peaks and troughs are all
about. So
the bottom line here is that as long as
they're not causing you distress and
harm then you don't have to worry about
them.
If they are doing that though, there are
new clinical therapies um what we call
nightmare um disorders.
And it involves usually just what you
were describing before which is speaking
with a therapist, writing down
the nightmare and then replaying it
while you are awake sort of you know,
speaking about it, writing it back down,
working with the therapist and
essentially trying to sort of just say,
look, okay, in that context it's safe.
Let's better understand that.
And re- repeatedly doing that type of
work where you're sort of reactivating
the nightmare and then trying to change
the context to something that's safe or
that's less fearful or that's less
negative, gradually over time that type
of work can dissipate the frequency and
the severity of those nightmares. So,
nightmares by themselves not necessarily
a bad thing. If they are causing you
problems, you can go and speak to your
doctor and there are some for that that
you can sort of just Google around
nightmare therapy etc. and those will
help.
Yeah, and that like the way in which
your brain chooses to interpret it's
sort of dream reassessment of the real
world will have huge implications in
your life. It could be PTSD, it could be
a bazillion things. I have a feeling, I
have never had this thought before, but
I have a feeling that
the more we learn about how individual
brains recontextualize things and how
much the conscious mind and subconscious
mind sort of come into cahoots to decide
how they're going to align things up
because when I was in my early 20s and I
was convinced I was stupid, I was
interpreting the world one way that was
just had me paralyzed by fear and then
as I began to realize sort of the nature
of the brain and oh just cuz I'm stupid
now doesn't mean I can't learn about
this,
you know, that Carol Dweck's notion of
yet, right? I'm not good yet. And so
that since then consciously I have
changed the way that I frame things, but
I would bet a bazillion dollars that I'm
also doing that subconsciously as my
brain sort of processes the day.
I think that's what, you know, dreaming
if if it's one of its functions is that
recontextualizing of those experiences.
You know, dreaming I think is a is a way
for us to understand the world in which
we live.
And we can do it whilst we're awake. You
know, I'm not suggesting that we don't
form connections and we don't see links
between different pieces of information.
But, the way that we do it in dreaming
is very different. You know, I often
liken it to when we're awake, you're
sort of inputting this information into
the brain, and it's almost like a Google
search page one. Where you insert your
search term, you hit return, and you get
the most obvious immediate hits, the
direct connections. That's what waking
is all about. Dreaming is you inserting
the search term, hitting the return
button, and being taken straight to page
20.
You know, and you inserted, you know,
impact theory university,
and all of a sudden, on page 20, it's
about a field hockey game in Utah, and
you think, "Hang on a second, what on
earth is But, then you read it, and you
think, "Ah, I can It's a distant wacky
connection."
And it's not obvious to me that I would
have made that, but it's a potentially
powerful one. Because when you start to
fuse things together that shouldn't
normally go together, but they cause
these marked advances in evolutionary
fitness, it sounds like the biological
basis of creativity.
And that's one of the things that we're
learning about with dream sleep as well.
Contextualization,
emotional resolution, creativity.
Yeah, so, you know, as we start talking
about dreaming and nightmares and all of
the different ways that the brain is
sort of interacting,
uh, trying to make sense of the
conscious world. One thing I heard you
talk about is cognitive behavioral
therapy for insomnia, which I found very
interesting, and I know so little about
it, but knowing what I know about
cognitive behavioral therapy in terms of
pattern interrupting and things like
that. Are you Is this like us sending a
sort of subconscious signal to our
brain? Like, how does that work?
Not quite. So, uh,
what we know, obviously, has been the
rise of sleep difficulties in society
and that has been matched by
unfortunately a rise in pharmacology and
particularly sleeping pills. And I say
unfortunately not because I'm
anti-medication and I know a lot of
people who work at these pharmaceutical
companies and they're good people, great
scientists wanting to good do good
things.
But unfortunately sleeping pills are
largely blunt instruments and they don't
produce naturalistic sleep. Um they're
in a class of drugs that we call the
sedative hypnotics. And when we take
sleeping pills, we mistake sedation for
sleep, but it's not natural sleep. And
in fact, um sleeping pills have been
associated with a significantly higher
risk of death as well as cancer.
So much so that in 2016, the American
College of Physicians made a landmark
recommended um intervention. They said
that sleeping pills must no longer be
the first-line treatment for uh
insomnia. Instead, the American College
of Physicians said it has to be
cognitive behavioral therapy for
insomnia that must be the first-line
recommended treatment for those sleep
problems.
And so cognitive behavioral therapy in
general really tries to target two
things, cognitive and behavioral. And so
the cognitive aspects for insomnia are
aspects where we try to correct your
beliefs or your misbeliefs around sleep
and some of your ideas around sleep.
Some of those things that can be either
uh inappropriate, incorrect, or just
triggering anxiety or worry. So we try
to modify those cognitions, those
beliefs, but then we also look at what
you're doing in your life, the different
behaviors that you're doing or things
that you're not doing and try to correct
the behaviors as well. For example,
how's your caffeine intake? How's your
alcohol intake? Uh what time are you
going to bed? What time are you waking
up? What's your chronotype? Are you a
morning type, evening type? Are you
sleeping in harmony with your chronotype
or against your chronotype?
Um, are you getting daylight in the
morning? Are you getting too much
daylight at light at night, artificial
light at night? Do you exercise?
And so, we change behaviors and we
change thought patterns and together,
cognitive behavioral therapy for
insomnia is just as effective as
sleeping pills in the short term, but
what's great is that when you stop
working with that clinician
or your online program and I should say
that I
I'm work with a a company I'm an advisor
to a company called Shuni.
It's s h u n i .io if people want to go
and explore it and you can get cognitive
behavioral therapy online there. But you
work with your therapist and after about
five or six sessions,
you can continue that benefit of
improved sleep for up to five years, the
studies have demonstrated now. Whereas
with sleeping pills, when you stop their
use, then not only do you go back to the
bad sleep that you you were having, you
typically go back to even worse sleep.
It's called rebound insomnia and now you
have to go back onto the use. So you
become dependent. There is an addiction
dependency cycle. So that's really what
CBTI is and that's really the best
approach for sleeping problems right
now.
All right. So I have two sleeping
problems. One is that there are times
where I will get
either really stressed or I'll get
really excited and I have a very easy
time falling asleep, but then I'll wake
up after three or four hours and I find
it very difficult to fall back asleep.
And then the second part just so I don't
forget is sleep inertia in the morning.
But what can I do to um optimize for
staying asleep?
Yes, so there it's a case of trying to
deal with that sort of downgrade the
activation of the nervous system. The
reason that people typically wake up uh
in the middle of the night and can't get
back to sleep, not always, but often, is
because they have this sort of stress
related carrying this anxiety. And
anxiety biologically is the principal
mechanism that we think underlies most
insomnia. And what happens in part is
that the fight or flight branch of the
nervous system becomes overactive. And
that's exactly the opposite
down? Like I find it so easy to fall
asleep, but I can tell on the nights
where I'm going to wake up.
It just seems weird that it builds, but
then my subconscious mind kicks it back
alive. Yeah, why why would it be that
way? And the reason is because after
about 16 hours of wakefulness, you've
built up a lot of that healthy
sleepiness, what we call sleep pressure.
And the longer that you're awake, the
more of that sleep pressure builds up.
And it's a chemical that builds up in
the brain called adenosine.
And then when we go into sleep, it's the
time when the brain can actually start
to clear out that adenosine. And it's so
it starts to lower the sleep pressure.
And after about 8 hours of sleep, you've
cleared away 16 hours of that adenosine,
of that sleepiness. And so you wake up
naturally and you feel refreshed and
restored.
But what will happen is that you can be
stressed and sort of or excited, but the
sleepiness, the weight of sleepiness
pulling you down is so heavy at that
point that you can get to sleep. But
then three or four hours later, you've
jettisoned maybe 50% of all of that
adenosine, maybe even more cuz it
principally happens during deep sleep.
And so now your brain is much more
vulnerable to those awakenings because
it doesn't have the weight of that
sleepiness. If does that make some
sense? It makes total sense and makes me
want to punch myself back to sleep. It's
so obnoxious. Well, because the the
benefits or or I should say the the
damage that you do by not getting sleep
is so terrifying that I'm every time I
wake up I'm like
come on. Like you know how much better
you will perform if you just sleep and I
am not one of those guys that's like hey
I you got to grind and 4 hours sleep.
I'm like if I need 9 hours of sleep I
want to get 9 hours of sleep every
single night forever until the end of
time. So it's just always super
obnoxious. If you're hoisting that flag
I will salute it and I definitely
you know, not everyone but certainly in
the type A sort of particularly business
culture maybe there is this sort of
sleep machismo attitude where people
wear their lack of sleep like a badge of
honor. Um, but you're right it's it's
foolhardy for a number of reasons. But
let me come back to that issue of of you
know, beating ourselves up because
we need to have some degree of
self-compassion when it comes to sleep.
You know, I am not invulnerable to sleep
problems myself. I've had bouts of
insomnia throughout my life to be
completely transparent and open with
you. Um,
and everyone every one of us is going to
have a bad night of sleep. It's not
unusual. Don't worry. Don't stress. You
know, back when I was starting to write
the book it took me about 4 years to
write it in 2014.
You know, sleep was sort of the
neglected step sister in the health
conversation of that time.
And I was so saddened by the sickness
and the disease and the suffering that
was happening because of a lack of
sleep. You know, I came out, you know,
all guns blazing.
And
I think that that was important but
for those people who were struggling
with sleep, those people who had sleep
problems with insomnia, you know, the
book kind of felt almost as though it
was, you know, sleep or else, dot dot
dot. Um
and I didn't mean it to be that way. So,
I want to say right now, because I've
I've learned to soften and become a a
much better appreciator of these
conditions, just like you described.
If you wake up and you can't get back to
sleep, don't worry. Just realize tonight
is not my night. It's not the end of the
world. I'm still going to be able to
function somewhat tomorrow.
Don't stay in bed awake for too long,
though. That's the important message
here, because very tricky.
I'm super curious to see what you think
about this, because I know where you're
going, right? Yeah, you're training
yourself that being in bed is is being
awake is okay while you're in bed. So, I
used to get up and whether I slept for 2
hours, 3 hours, whatever, if I couldn't
fall back asleep in like 15 minutes, I'd
get out of bed. And I would go to work
and start doing my thing, and then I
would go lay back down and sleep, and
sometimes I'd fall asleep for, you know,
2 or 3 more hours. But the number of
times I would wake up with a headache
after that was just too much. So, I was
way frustrated and I'm like, all right,
there's got to be something else. So,
what I found is if I put an audio book
on, dude, I will be back asleep in like
10 or 15 minutes. It's crazy. And the
only thing that wakes me up is the fact
that I have headphones in my ears, or if
they start yelling in the book or
something like that, which always pisses
me off. Uh but it puts me back to sleep
so reliably, it's crazy.
That's great. That's exactly what we
recommend. So, don't go to work, don't
start checking emails, don't eat,
because it trains the brain to expect
food. But instead, in a dim room,
somewhere different, so you change the
context, so you're changing the learned
association. Just read a book, listen to
an audio book, um meditate in dim light.
All of these things are great. Find out
whatever works for you.
And then, only when you're sleepy, do
you return to bed, and there's no time
limit for that.
And that way you train the brain back
out of a bad association that it's
learned, which is my bed is this place
of being awake, which if you repeat that
over time, you become trained to be
awake in the bed.
And then you will relearn the
association that your bed is the place
where you're asleep. So, you're 100%
right. That's exactly what we recommend.
Um to your second question, which is
sleep inertia, it's a real thing. Sleep
inertia is typically where we wake up
and your brain requires some time to
kind of warm up to operating
temperature. Like an old vintage car,
you know, you can't just turn the engine
on and start, you know, flooring it and
going up to redline. You need to sort of
circulate the fluids and warm the oil up
and get the engine warm and then you can
really start to push it. It's the same
way with our brain in some ways. Now,
um different people have different
severities of sleep inertia. I might
actually, like you, I suffer from quite
bad sleep inertia. You know, for the
first hour, you know, my partner, she
when I come through in the morning, she
wakes up a little bit earlier than me,
you know, she kind of knows that I can
say, "Look, honey, I am not the best
version of myself in the first hour. I I
know that I may have done something bad
yesterday and we should talk about it
and I I want to resolve that, but can we
not do it in the first hour because I'm
not the best version?" So, firstly,
accepting that it's normal and it's
real.
The second thing though, however, is you
can
sleep inertia typically happens in very
severe amounts if you're mismatched
between your sleep schedule and your
chronotype and some schedule.
And so, you can go on um and you can go
online and type Google um morningness
eveningness questionnaire.
And it's a questionnaire that you fill
out and it figures out what your
chronotype is. Are you um a morning
type, somewhere in between, or you an
evening type?
And what we find is that morning types,
when they wake up in the morning at
their normal time, which is very early
or early, they don't have sleep inertia.
They're good to go. They can jump into
the gym and they're like Energizer
bunnies and they're all happy and, you
know, joyful and to me I'm just like,
"Ah."
You know,
whereas evening types waking up at the
time that morning types have to wake up,
which is in some ways the way society is
designed. Society is desperately biased
against evening types.
And wrongfully so, because it's not your
fault. It's genetically determined.
There are about six or seven genes that
we know right now that dictate what your
chronotype is. It's not your fault.
Gifted to you at birth.
Um you don't get to choose.
Now, if you are suffering from sleep
inertia, what we find is that if you can
sleep a little bit later into the
morning, go to bed a little maybe a
little bit later, sleep later, play
around with that and see if the speed
with which you wake up is better, that
your sleep inertia is less.
That's one way. It may not always work.
Another way is temperature.
Now, it turns out that when people have
a cup of coffee, they say, "Look, I just
need like 5 minutes." And I swig a
couple of, you know, mouthfuls of coffee
and now I'm alert. That's nonsense.
Caffeine doesn't actually get into your
system until about 12 to 15 minutes. So,
if you're feeling any effects of
caffeine before that, it's not the
caffeine.
It turns out that when we go to sleep,
we drop our core body temperature. We
get very cold. We become almost
hypothermic.
Now, to wake up, we have to warm up.
So, to to get to sleep, we need to get
cold. To stay asleep, we need to stay
cold. And to wake up, we need to warm
up.
And so, one way that you can
artificially accelerate or try
accelerating
your inertia in a quicker dissipating
manner is to try to warm up more
quickly. So, get a hot drink in the
morning. Doesn't have to be caffeine if
that's not your thing. I don't drink
caffeine, but I'm not against it.
Caffeine is an issue
It's not the really the dose that makes
the poison, it's the timing that makes
the poison when it comes to sleep and
caffeine, which we can come on to, but
drink a hot drink, get your body
temperature up. If you like, if you've
got a smart thermostat, program it to
start to rise temperature in your
bedroom or in the house in the last hour
before your alarm.
And you can it can really start to help
you wake up. And then play around with
these smart lights. I have one where it
sort of starts to bring me out of sleep
about 5 minutes before my alarm. That
can help, but the data is not good on
that. The data on temperature, much
better. That's interesting. Yeah, Tom.
It does, but I'm surprised that you say
to get warm because Have you done cold
showers before?
Yeah, cold showers are
sort of more of a noradrenaline thing.
Well,
they they wake you up real fast.
They do. Now, that's not necessarily a
normative thing, you know, that's you
you know, shocking your fight or flight
branch of the nervous system to go from
a temperature that it's become
accustomed to and it's acclimated to to
then all of a sudden being dumped in ice
water, as it were, and it doesn't know
it's a threat mechanism. It thinks
you're under attack, and so of course
you're going to wake up.
Now, that comes with an adrenergic spike
in the body. It comes with an
accelerated heart rate. It could come
with a cortisol spike. So, I'm not
against that, but we don't have to go to
those extremes. You can do it in these
more subtle manners, which are are the
more natural ways. Mhm, fair enough.
Um
I have a question going back to waking
up in the middle of the night.
One thing that is super weird is things
that during the day are not in any way,
shape, or form intimidating or daunting
when I'm supposed to be sleeping. So, if
I wake up in the middle of the night,
I'll start stressing about something,
and I'll I'm literally like, once I get
out of bed, this is not going to stress
me out. So, why is it stressing me out
at night? Is there a part of my brain
that shuts off? Is there a part of my
brain that becomes active? Like, why are
things at night do they seem so big and
dramatic? Whereas in the day, it's like,
man, it's not a big deal.
Yeah, I we actually don't really fully
understand it in truth, but part of this
is to do with context. That it's dark.
Um you don't have full awareness. You
don't have full functioning of the brain
because when we wake up, that sleep
inertia, by the way, in part is because
your prefrontal cortex, which is the
part of the brain that makes us most
human, it's like the CEO of the brain.
It's very good at understanding
high-level concepts, putting things into
contextually appropriate boxes, making
top-down control decisions. It regulates
our emotions.
That part of the brain is the last thing
to come back online as we wake up, and
that's why we're not very, you know,
brilliant if we have sleep inertia. But
when we're waking up out of sleep in the
middle of the night, we also have some
of that. So, we don't have the rational,
logical part of our brain fully engaged.
Plus, the context is one that's dark.
And so, we don't have sort of the
daylight sort of giving us this sort of
normative, safe feeling. And so, what
happens is that the brain starts to
default to rumination and
catastrophization.
You know, it's almost like this Rolodex
of anxiety that then starts to unfold.
And that one memory that, you know, you
bring back into mind um at that moment
of waking up is the finger that flicks
the domino on that cascade of of, you
know, rumination. So, again, just
realize I've done this before. I've
experienced this before. I know that
tomorrow by, you know, 1:00 or 2:00 p.m.
in the afternoon, I think about this and
I think, "That was ridiculous to be
worrying about. It's it's okay." Try to
remind yourself of that. No question.
Dude, thank you so much for joining me
today. The way that you look at sleep,
your insights, they are absolutely
magically delicious. Where can people
uh keep up with you? Where can they get
the book? Uh what's the best way? Oh
gosh, after listening so long to this,
they shouldn't listen to any more of me,
but um if you want to find more of me,
uh you can find me at um sleep diplomat.
That's my handle. sleepdiplomat.com.
Um you can buy the book. The book is
called Why We Sleep. It's now out in a
second edition following some uh needed
corrections. Um
you My publisher would say, "You know,
you don't have to read the book. You
just have to buy it." But I would say,
um go and find a second-hand used copy
of the book. Um I'm uninterested in any
of the money. Just as long as you read
the book, I I'm happy. So,
um yeah. Awesome. Thank you again so
much for what you're putting out in the
world and for coming on to the show. It
was really, really wonderful. Speaking
of things that are really wonderful, if
you haven't already, be sure to
subscribe. And until next time, my
friends, be legendary. Take care.
Thank you guys so much for watching and
being a part of this community. If you
haven't already, be sure to subscribe.
You're going to get weekly videos on
building a growth mindset, cultivating
grit, and unlocking your full potential.