“The Clash Of The Turbans” - Imam Tawhidi EXPOSES Islam Extremism, Iran’s Regime & War On The West
Watch on YouTubeVideo summary
In this high-stakes discussion, Imam Muhammad Tawhidi argues for a fundamental distinction between Islam as a religion of peace and "Islamism," which he defines as a contemporary political ideology hijacked by groups like the Muslim Brotherhood to gain power. The Imam asserts that organizations such as Al-Qaeda, ISIS, Hamas, and Hezbollah are not representative of mainstream Muslims but rather offshoots or paramilitary wings of the Muslim Brotherhood, an organization founded 98 years ago with a goal he describes as establishing a global caliphate through infiltration. He contends that while extremists may claim to be moderate, their true allegiance lies with this specific political agenda, which seeks to replace existing legal systems and courts rather than coexist within them. Tawhidi emphasizes that the decision-makers of the Muslim world in nations like Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, and the UAE are actively rejecting extremism and promoting peace through initiatives like the Abraham Accords, contrasting their approach with the policies driven by Tehran or radical elements elsewhere. The conversation delves into historical interpretations and theological nuances to dismantle common misconceptions about Islam. Tawhidi addresses sensitive topics regarding Prophet Muhammad's life, clarifying that he was an infallible messenger sent for monotheism rather than a founder of a new religion in the modern sense, and disputes popular narratives suggesting Aisha married him at age six by citing historical calculations placing her between 18 and 21. He also critiques how Western media often portrays Islam through the lens of extremists or political agendas set by regimes like Iran's Khamenei, whom he compares to Hitler due to his execution without trial. To illustrate the difference in interpretation, Tawhidi presents a Quran commentary produced by the Muslim Brotherhood, noting its unique and controversial nature where verses are interpreted solely based on the author's personal views rather than scholarly consensus or rational analysis, likening it to Joseph Smith creating new scriptures for Mormonism. A significant portion of the dialogue focuses on immigration policy and national security, drawing parallels between Western approaches and those in Gulf states like Abu Dhabi and Riyadh. Tawhidi argues that American immigration policies are often driven by political cycles rather than a rigorous security lens, whereas Middle Eastern nations employ strict vetting systems to prevent individuals harboring jihadi ideologies from entering or remaining within their borders. He cites the case of figures deported during the Arab Spring who built careers on online extremism as evidence of these effective screening mechanisms. The Imam urges Western leaders to adopt similar zero-tolerance policies for national security, warning that allowing groups like Hamas or Hezbollah members into societies creates a threat not just from foreign actors but from those radicalized within their own communities by external narratives. Towards the conclusion, Tawhidi calls for a "clash of turbans," urging Western media platforms and hosts to feature imams who reject extremism rather than preachers aligned with anti-Western agendas or specific political causes like Gaza without broader context. He criticizes certain influencers and academics appearing on shows like Piers Morgan's as lacking the depth required to represent Islam, noting that many are funded by radical networks seeking global domination. Instead, he points to Sheikh Zayed of Abu Dhabi as a legendary figure who built coexistence between Christians and Muslims before his death in 2004, leaving behind a legacy of harmony exemplified by institutions like the Grand Mosque. The interview ends with Tawhidi sharing resources on the organizational structure of the Muslim Brotherhood and emphasizing that while he is willing to be controversial for the sake of truth, his ultimate goal remains guiding society back to the religion's original principles of monotheism, ethics, and peaceful coexistence among all people.
Read the full video transcript
Kmeni is the Persian Hitler. That's
exactly how you need to look at them.
>> Kmeni is the Persian Hitler
>> 100%. Someone who could execute 30,000
people with no trial.
>> What percentage of Muslims
around the world would be seen as
extremism. Osama bin Laden, for example,
many people do not know he was a member
of the Muslim Brotherhood. Al-Qaeda came
from the Muslim Brotherhood. ISIS came
from the Muslim Brotherhood. Hamas is
the paramilitary wing [music] of the
Muslim Brotherhood. But Obama brought to
them and made them the face of the
Muslim community in America. The Muslim
population in America. Why do you say
Obama?
That's when they declared victory. They
became advisers to the White House. Kame
is useless. This guy is a real criminal,
Patrick. There needs to be the clash of
the turbans.
Turbans need to start crashing.
>> Did you ever think you were
supposed
[music]
>> What's your point? The future looks
bright.
>> My handshake is better than anything I
ever signed. Right here. [music]
>> You are a 101. My son's right.
>> I don't think I've ever said this
before.
>> Today we have a special guest with us,
Imam Muhammad Toidi. Tohidi Tahawidi
depending on how you pronounce it. I'm
from Iran, Tohidi. And uh this is a very
very interesting figure. I've been
listening to watching for many many
years. He is the governing member of the
global imams council, adviser to
counterterrorism
at trends research and advisory.
Imam Toidi, it's great to have you on
the podcast.
>> Delighted to be here. Thank you for
having me.
>> Anytime. Okay. So, uh there's a lot of
topics I want to go through, but before
we get started, uh if you don't mind,
take a minute and maybe share your
background before we get into the
questions so the audience knows.
>> Sure. Uh my name is uh Muhammad Talhidi.
I'm a third generation imam. I am an
ordained Islamic cleric. I was ordained
in the holy city of Bum in Iran which
you're familiar with.
>> And uh I'm a Australian citizen. I
currently reside in North America and I
also have extensive travel in the Middle
East with a focus on the UAE. I uh
specialize in Islamic law and um my
faith for those wondering I am a
orthodox Shia Muslim. Uh orthodox is not
an Islamic term but it is the closest uh
for the listener to um understand that I
am not a reformist in any way. I believe
in reform of societies
uh reform that does not involve change
of religion. So I I I want religion to
remain what God revealed it as and not
man-made because man-made is not
accepted within Islam.
>> Okay. So the current population of Islam
is what 1.7 1.8 1.9 billion
>> climbing up two billion.
>> Climbing up to two billion. Okay.
>> How many people of the Muslim Islamic
community, how many of them
>> view things the way you do? I've heard
you say about this before. It's not a
big percentage of people, but for you a
lot of people call you the imam of
peace. I think your handle is even I
imam of peace. You may even call
yourself imam of peace, right? And
there's always a, you know, confusion
between this is the religion of peace,
but we saw what happened on 9/11. This
is religion of peace, but we saw what
happened with uh Hamas and Israel. This
is the religion of peace, but we saw
what happened in Australia just
recently. this the religion of peace but
so but to me you seem you seem pretty
peaceful to me you give me the vibes
that you actually are trying to pursue
peace however of the 1.9 billion give or
take close to two billion how many of
them think the way you do
>> right so
I am a follower of my religion
and to break it down in a uh in such a
simple way I don't think it would be
fair for the religion itself or for its
adherence or for countries like the UAE,
Bahrain who are working very hard to
establish peace and harmony uh or their
populations. So the distinction we need
to make is between Islam and Islamism.
Islam as a religion and Islamism as a
contemporary political ideology that
uses Islam to gain power.
And
Islamists are not a monolith. So there
are Islamists who believe in uh
participating in democratic
um principles. you will find them
running for Congress.
>> And you have those who will uh simply
engage in jihad and jihad can be
categorized in many many ways. Uh and I
mean violent jihad. I don't mean the
struggle of the self against one's
desires.
>> No, I mean going into a society and
changing it. going into a community and
hijacking their values and then
preventing the host community from
enjoying those values free speech,
freedom of religion, expression and so
on. So I
would advise that we this we need to
separate we need to draw a fine line
between the Muslim Brotherhood that was
in the west first
and the Muslims who came afterwards who
just want to lead a normal life.
So there is no percentage that I can
give you because we're not talking about
the same issue. We're talking about a
group of people who have hijacked a
religion
and those people need to be understood
because in um in Arabic we say
which means you're stirring beside the
the pot or beside the cup. We need to
stir in the cup in order to get the
flavor of the sugar we put in it. So
that's exactly what the extremists want
to do. The extremist doesn't tell you
he's an extremist.
>> And the Islamist doesn't tell you he's
an Islamist. They tell you we're Muslim.
Osama bin Laden, for example, many
people do not know he was a member of
the Muslim Brotherhood. Ala came from
the Muslim Brotherhood. ISIS came from
the Muslim Brotherhood. Hamas is the
paramilitary wing of the Muslim
Brotherhood. This is not Sunni Islam.
This is an organization with its own
charter.
That's the distinction we need to make.
Otherwise, we will be discussing an
issue that is very distant from the
disease itself. Okay. So, how different
do you view the world? So, let's let's
put them in a different community. So, I
think it's very important to do this. Uh
uh you have those who are the extremist,
okay, which you're kind of talking
about. Then you have those who came
afterwards, not the first Muslim
Brotherhood that came. The other ones
that just came, they're like, "Look, I
just want to live in America. I just
want to live in Australia. I just live
in I just want to live my life and have
a regular life." Then you have those who
are
like you, you know, claiming, presenting
peace as the basis of the way you want
to live. Okay. Give me in your when
you're talking to Tommy Robinson, you
said, "I think there's around 5 million
people like me, like you." Then he said,
"And really really like me?" It's only
about 500,000 people that are like me.
You said this to Tommy, I think seven or
eight years ago when you guys did an
interview. Okay.
But today, if you're able to break it
down, I think the the the extremist is
this, the people in that are just living
their regular life is this and this or
maybe even if you want to add anything
else to it as well, how would you break
down those sects? Yeah, I think I uh was
very uh
general when speaking to uh Tommy in
that interview and I believe I believe
uh I understood the question to be
within Australia. So how many like you
within Australia and I still believe
those numbers are accurate. I think the
majority of Muslims are
not only supportive of peace, they lead
a peaceful lifestyle and they do not
want to see uh the Muslim Brotherhood or
Bin Laden or ISIS or Hamas as their
representatives.
>> And the evidence of that uh I would
point to is the reaction to October 7.
>> How many did we see flood the streets in
support of Hamas? How many did we see? I
could safely say across the American
continent round about 150,000 would have
flooded the streets between Toronto and
Montreal and and New York. Uh and and
that continues, but it's the same
community. I don't think we saw 3
million flood the streets Muslims
supporting Hamas. That did not happen.
And that be turns into a policy
question. Until when is the White House
and uh parliaments around the world
going to allow the Muslim Brotherhood to
be the face of the Muslim community? Cuz
that's exactly what it is in Obama's
time. K, which congratulations to
Florida and to Texas. Uh I think a very
very important move designating care as
a terrorist entity.
>> Um
>> which they're being sued right now. By
the way, I don't know if you saw that.
If there's anything we could do as
experts on Islam and on counterterrorism
uh to support the state of Florida
against care and Texas against care,
please reach out. I'll say this,
>> I don't know whether they'll win or
lose. It does not matter. The point is
we cannot allow them to operate freely.
>> Uh and I do understand there is a lack
of uh Muslim expertise pushing back
against K because they're intimidated by
them. They're like a mafia. That's
exactly what they are. They're a Muslim
mafia and so congratulations to that.
That is a very important distinction
because care cannot walk into certain
mosques. Please don't think care has the
ability to walk into any mosque in
America. No, they'll be kicked out. They
have their own mosques. They have their
own centers that they It's like a
ghetto. So they're very isolated. But
Obama brought to them and made them the
face of the Muslim community in America.
The Muslim population in America.
>> Why do you say Obama? because that's
when they declared victory, they became
advisers to the White House.
If a president of the United States of
America hosts a Ramadanar
where Muslims break their fast and then
he brings a member of the Muslim
Brotherhood community to initiate the
call to prayer, that is a symbolic
victory for the Muslim Brotherhood
worldwide. That is the that's like
infiltration 95% for them. That's how
they see it. And they simply go back and
tell their members, you know, it's it's
not just about symbolism. It's more
about motivation. Because the Muslim
Brotherhood can go 10 months with no
success and all of a sudden Ramadan
comes and they're in the White House.
So, it's it somewhat validates
everything that they have been doing
before they came into the White House
and it will by extension validate
everything they do afterwards. Okay. So
fair, which is celebration. Totally get
it. That's a big deal. I also think
Mandani winning New York City is also a
big victory because they they're taking
over the financial capital of the world.
That's a massive validation when when
Mandani won. But again, let's go back to
it. So you're saying when you saw
October 7th happen, how many people did
you see worldwide or in the streets?
Canada, US, I 150,000. Fair. We can
debate that number and we can fact check
that number. What
>> worldwide? I think it's more. Okay. So,
it's a it's a massive number that
happened worldwide, but that's not the
question I'm asking. I'm going to come
back to the comment you made about this,
but this is the question I'm asking.
What percentage we've seen the numbers,
but according to you, this is your
world, your study, and anything and
every article that comes out when I was
in the insurance space for 20 years. Any
article that came out on the insurance
space, I have to read it because it's my
world. So, this is your world. What
percentage of Muslims
around the world would be seen as
extremists? Sunni Shia doesn't matter.
What percentage would you say as
extremist?
>> I do not believe I could give you a
percentage because it would need to be
based on studies on this issue and I am
unaware of a study that uh presents it
in this manner. But I can tell you this
the UAE
how about we
speak on a very realistic level so I can
actually answer your question in a
different way. Uh, I might not be able
to give you a percentage, but I want to
give you an honest answer.
Decisions in the Muslim world happen
where they happen in Riyad, in Saudi
Arabia. They happen in Mecca and they
happen in Abu Dhabi, the UAE. They don't
happen in Thran. And they don't happen
anywhere else. This is important.
The decision makers of the Muslim world,
both religion and region, are heading in
a direction that is not only about the
Abraham Accords, but it's more towards
peace, coexistence, harmony, prosperity,
building bridges with societies, total
rejection of extremism, and so on. That
is a massive society because it's not
only about numbers. If we're talking
numbers, then we have to go to Indonesia
because they have the largest Muslim
population
>> uh per country. Mhm.
>> But and they're 98% 90 98 92% some like
they're massive.
>> So they don't make decisions for the
Muslim world. It happens in Saudi
Arabia.
My message is more than welcome in Saudi
Arabia. My message is more than welcome
in the UAE. And the same applies to
Bahrain. I'm not saying it's not welcome
in Indonesia. No, it is. But there are
decision makers in the Muslim world. And
if the decision makers are heading in a
certain direction that should be able to
answer where the religion is heading in
terms of direction and mood and
priorities and so on and will also give
you a clear understanding of the future
of the religion if it is being led by
Abu Dhabi the Abraham Accords the
Abrahamic family house that sort of
narrative and total rejection of the
Muslim Brotherhood. So I though I can't
give you a percentage of how many
Muslims out of the two billion are
extremist, how many are fundamentalist,
how many are just u Muslim by name, how
many are practicing, how many practice
only in Ramadan, that's a breakdown that
I cannot provide honestly. But what I
can say is that the decision makers of
the Muslim world are heading in a
direction that is very positive.
Right? And I also believe that they are
being supported greatly by the rest of
the Muslim world. Pakistan for example,
the Muslims in India for examp,
Saudi Arabia and the UAE are doing. And
there are other countries that are not
in line, right? Such as the Palestinian
territories uh and and others that are
obvious. Okay, so this is this is let's
use basic simple stats. I've seen all
the way up to 20% extremist, which I
think that's BS. And I've seen all the
way down to 1%, which I also think it's
a low number. Let's use 5%. Let's use
10%. Pick a number between 5 to 10%.
Most numbers you can see will give you a
number between 1 and 10%. a lot of
studies that are out there per percent
is 20 million
per percent is 20 million right so if we
go to 5%
that's
roughly aundred million give or take
right okay so now imagine a 100 million
is a third of America you know 100
million at 5% is a third of America
100 million when you look at Australia
Australia may be a lot of land but it's
not a lot of people, right?
[clears throat]
>> Canada may be a lot of land, not a lot
of people. UK may be a big island, you
know, it's so when you when you then
break it down that number and they go
into these different countries. So now
imagine you are the leader of that
country, you're the president of that
country and President Trump comes to you
as an adviser. Kirst comes to you as an
adviser. Mark Carney comes to you as an
adviser saying, "Imam Tawidi, you sound
very reasonable. You sound extremely
peaceful. You sound like somebody I can
sit down and have a conversation with.
We can laugh. We can talk. And I feel
the genuineess from you." Right?
What do I do when I'm dealing with
immigration? when I know a 100 million
of this sect this religion Muslim Islam
is extremist and they support the
violence a big percentage support you
know say you put one or three% support
what Houthis Hamas Hezbollah you know I
live with Hezbollah in Iran I was there
for 10 11 years I've met many many many
members of Hezbollah because you know my
sister and my mom we would walk in the
streets and you would see things and
they would pull up and like oh my god
shivering you're worried about what
they're going going to do next to you.
You live in fear. It's not a nice place
to be.
How do we filter out who we let in and
who we don't? Do you use a zero
tolerance policy? Don't let anybody in.
Do you take the risk with what we took
immigration the last four years in
America under Biden that people came in
and who knows what percent? How? Because
our job is to protect America first,
right? What advice would you give to
them? Yeah, your immigration policy
needs to be
tied to your understanding of
sovereignty. So if sovereignty is
sacred, then immigration policy needs to
be looked at through the same lens. You
cannot have a weak soft immigration
policy at all. The UAE is a perfect
example. So is Saudi Arabia.
How is immigration doing there? It's
perfect. 200 nationalities living
together. Why? because there is an
excellent, not just good, an excellent
vetting system. You cannot be someone
who ha who harbors uh jihadi ideology
and simply apply for a visa to go to a
Gulf state. They won't accept you
because there is a serious vetting
system. And if they figure out that you
somehow got through, and by the way,
there are some famous people who built a
career simply because they were deported
out of the UAE during the Arab Spring,
the so-called Arab Spring. Um, the
policy is beautiful. The minute they
figure out they made a mistake because
they let someone in who then went online
and made a comment or supported a
certain narrative that is against
national security, immediately, knock,
where's your bags? Pack up. DXP Dubai
airport straight out of the country.
There is no negotiation when it comes to
safety. Why? Because it's a security
decision. So, American immigration
policy needs to be looked at through a
security lens, not a political lens.
That's what we're seeing in America.
Everything with regards to the border
has been a political question,
not a security question.
In in the Middle East, the borders are
looked at through the lens of security.
That is why there are zero terrorist
extremists in Abu Dhabi. That is why
there is no one blowing himself up in
Riad in Jedda. That's why it's a it's
it's very important that we speak in
this manner. Though it may be foreign to
the American listener, but the
understanding of national security in
the Middle East is very different
because we know these people. The
extremists that are migrating to the
west are those who were rejected from
our societies
are those who would be in prison. Muslim
Brotherhood communities. You can mention
millions of extremists to me. I will not
deny that. I'll tell you you know what
that is exactly right and if we go to
those individuals and we understand
their ideology one way or another it
will take us back to the Muslim
Brotherhood an organization that is 98
years old who planned this disaster 100
years ago Patrick how do I deal with a
politician
who thinks in four-year terms how do you
discuss immigration with a politician
whose mentality ends in four years and
who sits with you 9 to5.
So whatever you tell him, he looks
through a he he he puts he fits you in
through the 9 to5 schedule. After 5 he's
in a bar, he's you know he's out of this
world. Fighting Islamist extremism is my
life. I don't have a 9 to5 schedule. I
can't sit with a a lawmaker
who before meeting with me is dealing
with I don't know something with the
economy and then he wants to deal with
LGBTQ with all due respect issues. It's
not about listening to us. It's about
listening, following up and acting upon
it. Which is why I have a policy between
me and myself. If I sit with a lawmaker
and I give him advice and he doesn't
listen and something goes wrong, I will
never speak to them again. There are no
second chances because this community we
understand. We lived with them. We ran
away from them. We can identify them
without having to study about it. We
know these people. When we say they're a
threat, they're a threat on many level.
Not not just on many levels, not just
[clears throat] because they reject
America. No, no, no. The whole idea
[clears throat] of immigration needs to
be uh revisited
simply because not all immigrants are
equal. Not all immigrants are equal. And
I dare mention someone like Ilhan Omar.
I would not see her as a legitimate
immigrant to America. I simply don't.
There is a vast difference between her
and a Muslim who came from another
Muslim country who built an amazing
career in America and serves in the
military for example and defends America
and you will find those Muslims who side
against her and her policies and they're
very visible.
What would happen if she went to
[clears throat] UAE or Saudi? What would
they do with her if she said she wants
to go be a resident there? Would they
welcome her? There are laws in place. If
she enters lawfully, I imagine that um
she again I'm I'm not a decision maker
here on immigration, but I imagine those
who follow the law will be
treated by the law uh equally. But I
doubt for a single second Muslim
Brotherhood narrative will be accepted
for a single second. I doubt you know a
like of a post by care could get you
deported. There is absolutely zero
tolerance to extremism.
Absolutely. In the UAE and when I say
absolutely I mean from top down. the the
youngest UAE citizen will not accept
extremism. It's that serious. And and
look, if you if you're looking for
freedom of expression, you'll find it.
But freedom of expression does not mean
I get to say I want you beheaded. That's
not a view that is considered respectful
or an ideology that has a place or
should have a place within society. You
know, the extremists in America openly
say, "We are here to bring down
democracy." That's exactly what they
say. We are here to establish a global
caliphate. We want Sharia law. Right?
Try that in Saudi Arabia and see how
long you last. Try that in Abu Dhabi.
See how long you last. The thing with
religion is it came to guide. So I'm a
Muslim. I believe that God sent a
religion to guide me. Religion is not
here to rule by the sword. Religion is a
source of spirituality and and and um
taking the human hand by by their hand
to areas where they can excel in their
humanity in their moral u understanding
of life in religion in their rel
relationship between themselves and God.
That's the role of religion. The minute
you turn the Quran into a constitution
like we have in Iran where people are
being hung and beheaded, that's when you
know, okay, so Islam has been used
as a constitution
so many can become king of Iran. And
that's what he is. He's a king. He's not
a cleric. He's not a man of God. Persia
was always ruled by kings. And now we
have a king with a turban. That's
exactly what he is. Not a man of God.
He's a pharaoh. He's a Persian pharaoh.
Kame is the Persian pharaoh.
>> Kmeni is a is a king of king of Iran.
Okay. So why do you say that? Because
what? Because he can do anything and
everything.
And the whole idea of [clears throat] a
de of of elections in Iran is a farce.
It's fake. There are no elections in
Iran whatsoever. No Iranian has a voice
under the system of which is the the the
guardianship of the jurist.
Can I just explain that to the American
listener? Now, uh we're familiar with
communism. We're familiar with
socialism, democracy. There is a system
in Iran that's not just theocracy. It is
the guardianship of the jurist
which means or a person in his position
before him
is the guardian over all Muslims, not
just the Shia Muslims, even the Sunnis.
He claims he's the guardian over Islam.
The Pakistanis, the Malaysians,
Indonesians, Saudis, UAE. It's
ridiculous. Okay, what does that mean?
It means he has the authority, absolute
authority on behalf of God to do
whatever he wants. He can look at you
and say, "Patrick, you and your wife are
divorced." And boom, just like that,
your your marriage is terminated simply
because he said so. So the whole idea
that 90 million people are expected to
vote for a president and then the
president goes and kisses the hand of
Kame and says you know what ignore the
people whatever you say I will do
that is the biggest scam in the history
of scams that the Iranian people have to
live through you know and it's not not
just a disaster it's something that is
somehow tolerated by the international
community especially the Europeans they
tolerate it there are no elections in
Iran United Nations S what do you have?
You have a president. You have prime
minister attend. You have kings attend.
Fine. You have chancellors. You have
chairman of of certain parties attend
like the CCP. Fine. But there is no such
thing as a president. And then above him
there is the supreme Islamic leader who
rules on behalf of God who gets to run
the country and he thinks in his mind
run the world the way he wants. That is
Islamism. There is no such thing as God
speaking to telling him you're my deputy
on behalf of the savior the so kill as
you like bomb as you like. Butcher as
you like. There is no such thing in the
Quran that says that. What we have is a
regime. We don't even have a government
in Iran. There is no government. And
it's very wrong for people to think
there is a government system in Iran.
There is no it's a regime. It's a cult.
a cult of clerics that govern Iran in
the name of God. Why? Because it's the
best tool to use against populations in
mass religion. Because the minute you
oppose,
it's not that you opposed uh the ruler.
No, no, no. You're certainly not Muslim
anymore. How can you oppose the supreme
ruler who is the guardian on behalf of
God and his savior on planet Earth? So
clearly you're not a Muslim. Clearly you
can't be praying because if you pray
then you would have had the piety to
stand with the regime
and if that's the case then you must
also eat pork and slowly slowly they
will drive you out of anything called
faith and that's when you become a
execution you're a corruptor on planet
earth and so on. We need to distinguish
between Islam and Islamism because there
is a lot there that the Islamist relies
upon you to ignore. The Islamist will
not tell you I am an Islamist
and they are Muslims. No, he'll tell you
I am Muslim
and they're again extremist doesn't tell
you he's an extremist and Islamist
doesn't tell you he's an Islamist.
They're using the religion. Half of them
don't even pray. You think Alhan Omar
can recite the Quran? You think she can
open the page and start reading that?
Impossible. These people, the majority
of care, don't even know the structure
and the chronology of the Quran. They
don't even know the context behind
revelation. These are people who, if
they need anything now, chbt, that's
their faith. But governments have
allowed them to be the face of the
Muslim community in America.
>> In 2009, 2008, late December 2008, you
went back to Rome, right? To go to
school there for three years. and Rome
>> from 2008 until 2013.
>> Right. But you went back 0809 to go to
school there and you were there for for
two uh 2013. Yes. And Rome is where Kame
is from I believe if I'm not mistaken. K
is in Rome. If not, that is where he
studied with Ruah Kmeni back in the days
when they were fighting against the Sha
in in the plans of the first time
exiled, the second time exiled. have
tried multiple different time and he was
kicked out and he went to all over the
place and then eventually at France when
you went to school there [clears throat]
you can break down what the school
structure is so the audience can also
understand when you went to school there
at what point was it when you said I
can't subscribe to this teaching I got
to get out of here what what caused that
>> okay beautiful question now
was born in mashed that'san the other
side of the country. Um, Mhashad and are
very important. So our listeners, Om is
where the holy shrine of hazatsum is the
sister of Imam Riza who is buried in
Mshad. Imam Riza is the eighth successor
of the holy prophet. So we are uh 12 12
vers. We have 12 imams. Number eight is
Imam Riza. So that's a holy city of
Mashed. And I was born in the holy city
of Om. And I went back to study in the
holy city of Om in December 2008. and I
stayed until 2013.
Now,
and both studied in the holy city of
and including Hassan,
the former secretary general of they all
studied in.
>> Now, Om is a seminary that has education
that is basic, intermediary and somewhat
entry level into the advanced studies.
People usually finish their studies in
and then head over to Najaf in Iraq
which is the main ancient seminary uh
for Shia Muslims uh in the world and
that's a thousand years old. When it
comes to Om
was a open society, an open seminary
where you had mosques and Islamic
centers and you had a cleric, a senior
cleric who had 20, 30 up to a thousand
students sit around him and he would
speak about theology, Islamic law,
doctrine, ethics, mysticism, you name
it.
Come the Iranian revolution of 1979, and
by the way, it's not an Iranian
revolution. There's nothing Iranian
about it. The listeners need to know
that Kummeni was an Indian man, right?
He's not even Iranian. Um, but it was a
Islamist revolution, not an Islamic
revolution, an Islamist revolution.
Coming to the 1979, Kmeni understood
that he had to do something about these
clerics. He had to do something about
Islamic law that is governing Iran and
governing society. So what he did was is
that he turned these freestyle education
circles and systems into institutions
and he turned the seminary into a
university and he called it al- Mustafa
International University.
The university which I studied in and I
should say Patrick one of the best
decisions I made in my life as I always
say was withdrawing from that
university.
>> Why is that? because it is the
university that is ruled by the IRGC,
ruled by the
military that is responsible for
supporting and Hamas and the Houthi and
so on. But um we should also mention
that it is not a university like the
traditional universities that we have.
It is the umbrella organization
for over 10 15,000 schools and
institutions educational and seminaries
in Iran across the country and now even
in the Middle East and they have
deputies everywhere recruiting students
now. Uh so it's building on on street is
not an actual university you can go in
and study. No, it is a administration
that sends you off to another
university. When you graduate from that
university, you get a certificate from
al- Mustafa University.
So these guys will teach you a
revolutionary Islam. How do we export
the revolution of Kumi to Australia, to
America, to Canada? How do we bring
American citizens? And if I could just
ask, could you on Google just put um uh
ali
school with an I? Yeah. School. Q M.
Yeah.
Okay. That's the first one there. You
see that is where Americans go to. Click
on that first picture for me, please.
Okay. So, you see on the left side where
that white banner is, that's my room. I
was in there with 13 students. That's my
dormatory. The first level is where you
have the uh uh classrooms
>> and that you see at at the bottom there
that that rails the blue and white rails
at the bottom that there takes you to
the basement.
>> Okay. Beneath there there are more
classrooms that look just the same. So
first level, second level from the top
coming down are where students sleep and
then the ground floor
is the classrooms and beneath that is
more classrooms. My room is room number
13 where no on on the right side where
the uh uh banner is
>> that's where you were at?
>> That's where I was for 2 years. This is
where the British, the Australians, the
Westerners who are taken from the west
are taken here. Why? to learn Farsy. You
learn Farsy, you can understand what
Kame is saying. He can move you
properly.
This is the first thing they do. You see
those two pictures there?
>> Mhm.
>> That's the main library that was added
in later and at the very top. That's a
library that was added later. That's
higher.
Who gets to go there? Anybody can go to
that library? Yes. Because everyone here
is vetted. Everyone here is an asset. So
the deputy of al- Mustafa University who
comes to the west sees you as an asset.
Okay, Immidi
Australian passport, you speak English,
you speak Arabic, you're somewhat
charismatic, you're convincing. You know
what? Let's take you to and so this is
where the brainwashing happened. From
here they take you to the Friday sermons
of
this is where they first come in. First
year is Farsy and second year is they
call it Tamia which is the basics of
Islam. Then you move on to the
university university style seminaries.
Right now here's the issue. They say one
year but it's never one year. We have 12
imams. All of them except one have
funeral days three days. Birthdays three
days. uh you know the holidays of the
revolution, the victory, this that this
that you're looking at a year and a half
to two years here for for learning Farsy
and they use that to not just strengthen
your language but for you to be
accustomed with this region this street.
>> Who were some of your classmates?
>> Okay, before we get there, next door is
the py of the bases. The besiege which
are the uh the youth corpse of the IRGC
is literally next door to this building.
So my classmates are I'm going to say
this and I haven't said this before. The
clerics who are now running the alutz
march which is the pro IRGCBA march uh
on the last Friday of Ramadan every
single year. Um running them in New York
and in Toronto. They were my classmates.
We studied together.
>> Did did they get brainwashed?
>> Of course. because everything they do,
look, a cleric needs to talk religion.
How do you know a cleric respects
himself when he sticks to what he is uh
meant to be doing? Religion, theology,
doctrine, community service, they're all
politicized, political clerics of no
value. Their their understanding of
religion is very shallow, very deep. I
mean, it needs to be deep, but it's very
shallow. You know, an atheist can take
them down easily with two questions
because they haven't been taught the
proper foundations of theology and
doctrine in Islam. It's always been
biography
biography. When he was born, he came out
of his mother's womb and there was a
scream in the in in the heavens, y have
you heard that? Okay. So, that's what
they're taught. Everything revolves
around the character of Kame
as the savior.
>> Did you ever meet him?
>> No, I have not. Here's the thing. Meet
face to face. No, but we were together
in a um so when he came to he came to
and we were chosen by a cleric. I'm
going to mention his name um Sheh Adman.
I won't mention his first name, but he
was the man responsible for the
Australian students. He came to me and
he said, "We're doing two things. We are
going the week before comes to Tehran
and I still have the entrance ID uh
badge that you wear and you attend.
You're not sitting in the front lines
because that's where the IRGC officials
sit. You're sitting towards the center
of his uh sermon. Um, I saw him and
again um to be honest with you, they
prepare you for a spiritual uh uh event.
It's not like you the bus drops you off
and you enter into a mosque and then
there he is. No, no, no. It's um not
tunnels, but it's it's it's um alleys
that you walk through that are prepared
with uh banners and signs and flags and
and just uh symbolism, revolutionary
symbolism. And then you enter and the
gods everywhere the sapaha and they're
green and and sometimes blue um and then
they usher you and you know your your
director of the group on that day he
changes because his life depends on
this. He becomes a different person.
He's not the guy that is nice with you
like so he's very strict. He takes you
in we sit here and then when you go in
you see there's a an ocean of people.
You're not the only one, not the only
group.
And before it comes, you have his
henchmen, clerics, who come up on the
microphone who rally up the audience. So
by the time Kame is coming out, that's
why people are walking behind him and
kissing the place where his feet touch
and you know, death to America, dead to
Ingaliz, dead to Israel, dead to the
hypocrites. That's that's how it
happened. They build you up. And I'll
tell you this, as deviant as Kame is,
and as crooked as his people are, they
are excellent speakers.
Is useless. The only thing he's good for
is he's a really good speaker.
Can move a rock when he speaks. And I
felt that. This guy is a real criminal.
I'll tell you. Um, there's a lot of
psychology involved. You see where Kame
sits? That's a shipping container. He
sits in a shipping container. So, two
shipping containers that are stuck
together and they welded together. If
you want to pull it, pull this up.
>> Yeah, pull this up.
>> He's actually in a shipping container
and it's bulletproof.
>> It's shipping container.
>> Yeah, not that's the that's the uh
Robent of Hitler.
>> Basic names. Rob, how are you getting
this wrong?
>> Shipping container.
>> Okay, hang on. You see that third
picture?
the the third picture. The third
picture. Yeah, that. So, that's a
shipping container. There's a curtain
behind him. Or you can just go back and
say uh um change the two words to Friday
sermon.
Yeah. Okay. See that? The first picture,
for example,
you see that that's a shipping container
that he's in. Uh or for example, change
the the the last two words put oh sorry
leave them add to them the word q m
because he was in a shipping container
in
of course with pictures they won't show
it but uh where he stands that third
picture on top the one I pointed to
earlier
that one there for example behind him is
two welded shipping containers that they
put him in and they're covered you know
they're not going to have DHL or
anything on them. Uh they're covered up
nicely
and because number one it's security and
no one can get to him except for a guy
called Wah. You want to pull up the name
Wah just next to put Wah
this guy. Okay. That guy that's his
number one henchman. He's the real ruler
of Iran. Not the president. It's this
guy to get he's the head of K's office
affairs. There should be a Wikipedia
about him.
>> Supreme leader of
>> he's a right-hand man to Iran's ali
often known as general vah.
>> Yeah. He goes by one name Wah in the
whole country.
>> Okay. So where were you going with this
with who he is?
>> Okay.
>> Rob, can we turn on the AC a little bit
now? It's a little bit hot. Wah is the
guy who decides where it goes and the we
need to understand the makeup of Iran as
a country so we can understand how we
got to how we got to Hamas because Hamas
is for sale. Hamas was paid by Iran.
They're Sunni but the Shia paid for them
in Iran.
I want to be fair to you and to the
listeners. I want to take a step back.
Many people say the reason why the
Muslim world is successful and they mean
the UAE
um and Saudi Arabia, they say is because
they pushed Islam to the side, not
because Islam is uh good in these
countries. That's what they say. And of
course, that's that's not right.
In Iran, we have a system where the
clerics rule over not only the
government but also the hospitals, the
technology sector, the education sector.
There is no sector in Iran in the
intelligence that the clerics are not
ruling in.
So you cannot have a fully functioning
vibrant society when you don't have
experts on top.
The UAE what they did was they respected
religion. Religion is sacred. It cannot
be placed in an intelligence department
or in a hospital. So they bring experts
to these fields. That is the difference
my brother. That's the difference. Iran
went down
down down this path of destruction
because it is run by mullas. It's run by
clerics. It's not run by experts.
Kame's family. I don't know if you've
looked at this or not. Apparently, the
family is worth $92 billion give or
take. If you type in Kam
uh um oh yeah, 95 to $200 billion on the
kind of money they've made. So, so
Vahid, are you saying Vahid could be the
who could he be in the future when Kame
is no longer here with us?
>> No, is the decision maker. He will never
be
>> anything.
>> No, because
>> he wants to be behind the scenes.
>> He He has to be behind the scenes.
>> So, he runs Iran. In other words,
>> he's the guy who runs the country.
>> He runs Iran.
>> He runs the country. He
>> Have you met him?
>> No, of course not.
>> What What do you mean, of course not?
>> No. I'll I'll tell you this. Can you uh
put just type my name in Google? Just
put Tahiti
t and then No, no, no. Tohidi. Okay,
you're going to do that. Okay. Wait. And
then next to it, just put Hassan
and then put
[laughter]
Rob is having a rough day today. Not
Yeah, there you go.
>> Okay. Just just go uh go to images.
>> Oh, so you met with Humeni's grandson?
>> Of course. I I I was uh you know
>> that's you and him.
>> You could even consider me somewhat of
an adviser to these guys at
>> this home.
>> This is in Thran. This is in the shrine
of Kumi in his private residence. Now, I
want you to take a look at this picture.
By the way, Patrick, I'm not being
arrogant here, but I I just want you to
see
what exactly you're looking at so you
know who uh you're doing a podcast with
today.
>> How long ago is this?
>> This is 2016.
>> Okay. Uh, zoom into the plates.
>> I see chai.
>> Okay. What do you see on my plate?
No, no, no. Go, go back. Go back. Go
back. Go back.
>> Okay. Stay there. Uh, what do you see on
on on that on my plate?
>> I see tea, but I don't know what that
other piece is.
>> It's an orange.
>> Okay.
>> But what am I missing?
I'm missing orange peels.
>> Okay.
>> He has the peels,
>> right?
>> So, he peeled it for you. Correct.
>> I got what you're saying. So the
relationship is
he was serving you.
>> More like being kind and generous.
>> Respect. Yeah. In a in a good way. Kind.
He Yeah.
>> How was he? How was Humen's grandson?
>> This guy doesn't believe in uh in
anything. He's an atheist in my view.
>> I I think he if he could, he would take
out Kame.
>> Oh, you're kidding me.
>> Yeah. No, this guy
>> and he still lives there.
>> Look, I'm saying this. I know this this
might bother him, but he in no way is a
is a cleric in the same manner as Kame.
>> Why do you say that?
>> No, this guy's fed up. His uh
grandfather made the revolution and he
gets no say in governance.
They give him a mosque. Here's your your
grandpa's grave. Go clean and serve it.
Yeah. He has no say. He's a teacher.
They won't even let him in. They say in
order for you to become on the expert
council of Iran, you know, you need to
take a test. And he tells them, I'm the
grandson of Kmeni. I take a test, I need
to be testing you guys,
right? What's his relationship with?
I mean, it has to be diplomatic
or else he's a pragmatic guy. He knows.
He knows. Look put his own brother. Do
you want to Google this? Go go go up to
Hadi. This is a K ha.
No, no, no. Hadi with just the
>> H A D I K H A M E. K H A M E. There you
go. Shakam.
>> No, no,
>> no. K H A M E N E. Nei. There you go.
No. Hadi. Hadi. So H A.
Yeah.
Okay, this is Kame's brother. He was
under house arrest. Many people don't
know this.
>> Why was he on house arrest?
>> Go down. It should it should say
opposition. He's a reformist. So many
got his people to attack his own
brother,
right?
Some conservatives blamed for the
attack.
Right? So this is Kame lives in a world
of contradictions. Do you remember the
Ahmed Nad and the uh the green
uprisings? Okay. So, Musvi is his cousin
is Kame's cousin and he would come out
and say Kami is corrupt.
>> His own brother says my brother is
corrupt. His uncle says my nephew is
corrupt. His um sister's husband who
fled to France wrote a letter to Kame.
He said how to sorry he said how dare
you appoint my wife's brother as the
head of Friday prayers in Thran when he
is 123 he accused him of being part of
the LGBT community right in a letter and
the guy lived in France and then yeah he
he's he's dead but um the point is very
u misunderstood in the west
misunderstood Americans don't know who's
speaking to their students
When these uprisings happen in
universities and puts out a tweet and
says, "I congratulate the students in
America and and North America and
they're up." That's not just foreign
interference. Americans don't know what
they're looking. This is the Shia Osama
bin Laden. That's exactly how you need
to look at him.
This is the Osama bin Laden was Sunni.
He's the Shia version of Osama bin
Laden. And Kmeni is the Persian Hitler.
That's exactly how you need to look at
them. How many is the Persian history?
>> 100%. Someone who could execute 30,000
people with no trial. I mean, no
comparison. You're looking at the
Holocaust. Two million more. But I'm
talking about the the concept and the
will.
Okay. You worked for the sha. What were
you? A chef or a driver? Execution. This
level of of of mentality and terrorism
we see in the likes of Hitler.
>> What caused you to leave though? What
caused you to say I'm leaving?
>> Australia. I did not come to the
seminary because I didn't have anything
else to do with my life. Many of the
people who go there go there because
you're given a stipent $30 a month. Uh
you're given you're given a room food,
right? And uh if you memorize the Quran
and and important books from our corpus,
what happens is you get a higher
stipent. And of course with religion
comes respect.
That's why many people choose to go
there. I did not do that. I went to
study. I went to because I'm a third
generation imam. I went to increase my
education, my theological education.
But the minute you tell me I cannot read
certain books and I cannot visit certain
scholars. You see I was a
fundamentalist. I am a former extremist.
I used to support I used to support
these criminals.
So the but the thing is I came from a
society that allowed me to read whatever
book I wanted to read and to visit
whatever scholar I wanted to visit and
sit with. For you to now tell me I
cannot do that. I didn't come from
Pakistan or Pakistan or Iraq like other
students were. No I came from the west.
You cannot tell me I can't read certain
books. So that triggered it for me that
you in a classroom that happened where
they told you you can't read those
books.
>> Oh no no no. What would happen is I
would naturally see signs of scholars in
their offices daft ayatah so and so and
I would go to their office and they
would give me books. So I would take the
books back to the dormatory and before I
knew it my dormatory was broken into. I
was they was they searched me when I was
praying you know congre congregational
prayers. They searched my room and when
I came back I found everything was uh
not how I left it. uh and and it
bothered me and so I began to understand
there's an issue here that I was not
aware of and then I started to um
investigate who the other clerics were,
what was their problem with these
clerics and I found out you know what
you can still be a good Muslim and
reject
because there are grand ayat who are the
grandsons of the prophet who reject him.
So I immediately started to visit those
guys and I sat with them and I read
their books and I saw you know this is
exactly what I came here for religion.
You had me in al- Mustafa University
telling me that Tel Aviv needs to be
bombed right and dead to America and
dead to the UK and and the queen
[clears throat]
is is Satan right and America is the big
Satan and Israel is the small Satan. I
understand your hatred towards them, but
that's not what I came here for. I came
to study theology. I I [clears throat]
found it in the offices of the grand
ayatas who were opposed to. That's when
I said, "Okay, there's more here." So, I
picked up the phone to my father.
I said to him, he didn't tell me. He
said, "Well, I wanted you to understand
on your own."
>> He knew.
>> My father was in Iran. We moved from
Iran to Australia.
>> How heavy how higher up was your father?
You're fourth generation. So
>> I'm I'm third generation.
>> Third generation.
>> Okay. How higher up was your father?
>> My father is a a community uh uh cleric.
>> Okay.
>> Community. I'm not involved in in my
world at all. Um but he didn't want to
get involved in this type of
conversation.
But I understood and when I understood,
I said, you know what? I'm not getting
involved with these guys anymore. And of
course once they realize that you are no
longer subscribed to their ideology, the
first thing that happens is that they
cancel your visa. Right? Though I was
born in Iran, I was there as an
Australian citizen. So they cancel your
visa. Um and then you have to figure it
out on your own. But my visa still had
time. I just did not submit to renew it.
I I had like eight nine months left. So
what I did was I stayed in Iran and I
stayed in another school that was
offered uh a dormatory that I was
offered by these other good clerics.
They're all fundamentalist but they were
less corrupt. So their corruption would
be financial wasting money on
unnecessary initiatives. It wouldn't be
murder and blood and and trying to take
down the West. None of that.
>> What were they teaching you there? Like
if you were to say the core core
teaching who is the enemy who did you
see them sell hate to the most? Who were
you supposed to hate and love you know
the most?
>> Okay so you love whoever he loves and
you hate whoever he hates. It's as
simple as that. If that is fixed love
changes doesn't matter. Point is you
need to be loving who the state loves.
>> So who did Kam hate? Of course, America.
Of course, Israel, of course, the UK, of
course, the West in general. I mean, who
is at the top? Who is at the top of the
hate for
>> America?
>> Number one.
>> Number one, the great Satan
>> ahead of Israel,
>> of course.
>> Okay. So, the Omrib
That was a regular thing.
>> That happens every single day. You see
it once a week after the Friday sermons,
but it happens every single day in every
single mosque that is operated by the
regime. Dead to America. And I'll tell
you this, I saw you ask me a question um
when you played my warning in 2009 after
uh the attack in Australia. You do you
remember what that question was
>> today?
>> No. when I thanked you for um playing my
clip from 2019.
>> When we set out to create a shoe that
blends comfort, [music]
function, and luxury, we had the choice
to make it fast. We had the choice to
make it cheap. We chose neither.
Instead, we chose Tuscan Italy. We chose
[music] true Italian craftsmanship. Each
pair touched by 50 skilled hands. We
chose patience, spending [music] two
years perfecting every detail. And we
chose the finest quality at every step.
Introducing the future looks [music]
bright collection. Not rushed, not
disposable, not ordinary, rather
intentional, luxurious, timeless.
>> What What was the question?
>> Question was, if you're criticizing
these guys, then why are you still
Muslim? Do you remember that question?
He said, "Well, one could ask him why
he's still a Muslim."
And I I really think we cannot uh not
answer that question. It's very
important
because it ties into the tens of
millions of Iranians who don't say debt
to America, who don't attend these
mosques, who don't attend these rallies.
What you're seeing is a few million,
fine, 20 million, 30 million. How many
millions love Kam 30? Fine. No problem.
I'll be generous in my numbers here. But
at least half the population is either
not practicing or they hate him. Why is
that the case? Why are they still
Muslim? It's
>> not enough though.
>> Yeah, but why are they still Muslim?
>> I don't know if they're Muslim. Like
like let let me give you an idea. I
think you said something very powerful
today. You said uh so so to an average
Christian, [clears throat]
they think every Muslims read every the
Quran cover to cover. Okay. So, think
about it. To the average Christian, what
do they think? Oh, you're a Muslim.
You've read the Quran. You've studied
the Quran. You know everything in the
Quran. And you said, "What?" You said,
"Do you think I Omar knows what what's
in the Quran?"
>> She doesn't.
>> She's a Chachibi Quran person, right? Is
who she is. Okay.
>> So, what do you call those?
>> I think there's a big percentage of
Muslims that are Muslim because it's who
their father was. It's who their mother
was. It's traditionally Muslim. It's not
Muslim because they studied all the
religions and they chose Muslim. It's
because they're traditionally there. Now
for you third generation, you listen,
that's a tradition. I had a guy here who
was the fourth uh uh generation of
Teamster Union from the union that Jimmy
Hafa came from. But he's a fourth
generation. Guess what his son is
probably going to do? Union. Why? That
tradition. However,
you're talking different Muslims. you
know what about these guys and what
about those guys and what about these
guys and what about these guys they all
follow the same book. So if you're
seeing what's going on, if it's a
hundred million around the world that
are extremist and the middle ones that
are good, they're just living their
lives, I don't know if they're
practicing.
I don't know if I would say 50% I don't
know if I would even say 70% of Muslims
practice Muslim their religion.
I would say they're just kind of living
their lives and they're not the
fanatical. That's not who I'm worried
about. That's not who the westerns or
the conservative or certain ideologies
worried about. It's the 100 million that
fully are the extremist that see the
west as the enemy.
>> Agreed. More than 100 million more. But
there that is a Could we uh go on Google
and uh just uh Google for me in the
shade of the Quran.
There we go. Now that is the Quran of
the extremists.
This is my Quran.
This is mine.
That is their Quran.
>> What's the difference?
>> Exactly. Is a highly influential
commentary of Quran. By who? By say, one
of the founders of the Muslim
Brotherhood.
The Muslim Brotherhood have their own
Quran. Patrick. They don't follow this
Quran. And the reason I didn't bring it
with me is because it is 30 volumes.
>> Is that English?
>> That is English.
>> May I? You will definitely
of course here it's English I bought in
English so you can touch the text
because only Muslims can touch the
Arabic text. So I have to clarify this
because there are Muslim viewers who
will think that Tahiti gave Patrick a
Arabic Quran. So it's in English.
>> Continue. I'm listening.
>> Okay.
This here is the first time in history
>> that a
Quran is interpreted by a man who says I
will interpret it based on my own views
>> based on my own understanding. Because
how does Quranic interpretation happen?
>> I need you with me.
>> Tell me how does it happen?
>> It happens when the verses are measured
against other verses or against other
teachings of the prophet.
>> Okay? or through scholarly consensus or
either through
which is analogy or through rational
um approaches.
>> When it comes to the Quran of the Muslim
Brotherhood,
>> it is the first time in history that a
guy says, "I will interpret it the way I
want it interpreted and I do not care
what the Quran says in other places and
I do not care what it says, what what
the prophet says. This is not
unacceptable.
>> Mhm.
>> That is the Quran of the Muslim
Brotherhood.
>> Okay.
>> Ask me your question.
>> No, but to me, you know, it's kind of
like saying, you know, Joseph Smith came
out and he came out with the Book of
and he said Jesus after he died,
he resurrected and went to Vermont and
he found six tablets. And that's how the
the the Mormonism and the Latter-day
Saints started. Then they went from
Vermont to I'm going to miss some of
this stuff from Vermont to Chicago.
Everywhere they went they get kicked out
and his father had some issues and
eventually they end up in uh you know I
I think gets killed. He gets killed in
one of these places and then they end up
in uh uh Utah and that's where they
build their thing. So they have the
Bible and they have the Book of Moroni,
right? The Book of Mormon.
>> Translation is translation. Okay. But if
you go to the OG of Prophet Muhammad,
let's go to that. To you, who was
Prophet Muhammad? Forget the
translation. The the face of Muslim is
Prophet Muhammad. Is that fair?
>> The face of Islam.
>> Face of Islam is Prophet Muhammad.
>> Correct.
>> Who is Prophet Muhammad to you? You seem
like a very reasonable guy.
>> Correct.
>> Who is he to you?
>> The messenger of God.
>> He's the messenger of God.
>> Correct.
>> Okay. Um
tell me you know
uh to you what you admire about him the
most.
>> Everything.
>> Please unpack that.
>> Okay.
The Muhammad that the west has been
introduced to is not our Muhammad. The
Muhammad of the Quran. Very important.
And please, Patrick, uh, ask me any
question and if you feel I haven't
answered you, please go back and make
sure that you, uh, you're satisfied with
my answer. Um, I'm not here to, uh,
evade any anything. So, please,
>> just so you know, you don't give me that
vibe at all, so you don't even have to
explain yourself.
>> Yeah.
>> Thank you. Thank you. Um,
Arabia
needed monotheism. This was a society
that was worshiping dates and stones and
burying their daughters alive,
worshiping idols. The tradition of
Abraham was corrupted in Arabia.
>> We call this the time of ignorance, is
Jah. God sent a man, we believe in the
same way he sent Moses and Jesus. His
name is Muhammad. Mhm.
>> He sent him to Arabia not to start a new
religion but to continue the religion of
previous prophets. Moses being you know
the the final Jewish prophet and uh
Jesus being the uh the messenger for the
Christians. Now you may believe him to
be the son of God.
>> I see him as a prophet of God. But what
we agree upon is that he was a messenger
of God. What he came with came from God.
Came from the you call him the father. I
call him Allah.
The prophet Muhammad you may read the
Quran that he came down with. Um and we
say came he came with but it was
revealed to him. Uh so it did not come
down as a tablet. It came down as verse
by verse or certain verses together.
His focus in Arabia was monotheism. Who
is God? Who is our creator and our
responsibility towards him? That's it.
That is the main fundamental pillar of
the message of the prophet. Do not
worship idols. Do not worship idols that
you create with your own hands and when
you get hungry you eat them out of dates
and so on. Do not have um sexual
relations with your parents. Do not kill
your parents. Do not murder the
innocent, for example. Uh, respect the
basic Noahide laws. This is exactly what
our prophet advocated for.
Then there is a development of a
religion.
That is where it gets more interesting
because it all goes back to those people
following the prophet Muhammad.
The prophet Muhammad was born in 570. He
passed away in 632.
He was a prophet for 23 years. In 23
years, all of his battles were
defensive. And you can look this up as
I'm speaking. They were all defensive.
And we can speak about treatment of
Christians, of Jews, of any group. Ask
me any question. I'll tell you this. But
before we do so, I want to just point to
a book that I think is valuable just for
context. uh by John Tolan uh the faces
of Muhammad
right
so this book shows you that the west
itself
in this book the author Mr. Tolan speaks
about the faces of Muhammad in the west.
Muhammad during the medieval era. How
did the western world view him? Muhammad
during the reformation era. Muhammad
during the enlightenment era. So to when
you ask me about my prophet, this
question is coming from the
developments and the events happening in
our time.
Muhammad was never looked at in a single
way by the west. He was looked at as
Muhammad the businessman, Muhammad the
poet, Muhammad the warrior, Muhammad the
father, the father of orphans, Muhammad
the statesman. Right? So when I when I
speak about the prophet Muhammad, I'll
tell you this. He was a man sent by God
to Arabia to guide them to towards
monotheism and ethics.
That's it. That is who he was and that's
what his mission was. And that is
exactly what the Quran um focuses on.
But yes, it's a book that speaks to a
developing community. There's going to
be conflict. There's going to be war and
there's going to be peace. There's going
to be a lot of difficult conversations
to be had. And we should not shy away
from them.
>> What's the what's the most difficult
part of the Quran that you had to
accept?
>> No, I accept it all with no difficulty.
>> None of it.
>> No. Because there's no question you can
ask me that I do not have a rational
answer for. The most basic one I'll go
to that you've probably been asked a
million times that you know of. So
Aisha, how do you process that?
>> Aisha was not married uh to the prophet
at a young age. She was an adult.
>> And I've heard you say this before.
>> She was an adult.
>> Do you know how many people who are
Islam Muslim scholars who do the
complete opposite who don't even debate
it? But you debate it.
>> They're preachers. They're not imams.
They are preachers. The son of an imam
is not an imam. Just because your dad
has an has a mosque and leads prayers
and gives you the microphone to speak,
it does not make you a theologian.
>> If the if the average person goes and
checks to By the way, let let's do this.
Let me ask a question in a different
way.
>> Right?
>> If he did marry Aisha at 6,
>> if he did consummate at night, would you
still be a Muslim?
>> The thing is he would never do that.
>> No, but here's a different question. I'm
asking,
>> right? He would never do that.
>> I'm not asking that question. If your
prophet,
if this is an if, it's a key word. If
he did marry a six-year-old, if he did
consummate, which means, you know, have
sex with somebody at night that some
people would, you know, define that as
rape. They wouldn't even cons consider
that as sex. If he did, would you still
be a Musl would you still see yourself
as a Muslim yourself?
>> Patrick, I'm not running away from the
question. I swear on my life and on my
mother's life. I'm telling you when you
say prophet to me it means an infallible
being that does not make a mistake or
make error. It it doesn't make sense.
Then let me ask a question in a
different way. Okay. Um
you're you're born into a family that is
non religious at all. You have to find
your own way. It's not third generation
imam. They're not Muslim, but it's not
atheist. Maybe it's agnostic. You go
pick and choose and find your own. Not
not Christian, not Presbyterian, not
Jehovah, not nothing. Right.
>> I would eventually end up as Muslim. And
as
>> you say that, you say that you say that
now. And you know, uh uh uh I understand
saying that, you know, I would also say
I would end up being a Christian myself
and I would say that, but neither one of
us know that for a fact. We can play
that and say yes, but I get what I get
the positioning of you having faith in
what you're saying. If we put something
on a board, facts of each religion out
there, let's name one of them the
religion of whatever.
But the founder of that religion who was
admired by a couple billion people, if
it was factually proven
that he married someone at six and they
had sex at nine, would you ever consider
that religion? If I didn't say Muslim, I
said if it was proven that the founder
had done that, would you ever accept
that religion?
>> No. Of course not.
>> You wouldn't? No.
>> Okay. Beautiful.
>> But but again, um the prophet for us
when you say Muhammad, you know what?
process an infallible human being that
does not make mistakes at all or any
error.
>> So it's impossible that he would make
such a decision and plus the issue of uh
Aisha uh you have to weigh it against
the society and the dates around her.
She was born after her sister Asma and
she died before Asma and I have it in in
a study which I can definitely send you.
She was either 18 from 18 to 21 years
old. There is no Muslim consensus that
Aisha was 3 or 6 or 9 or 15. There are
there are more popular opinions because
there is a state behind the publications
promoting them. Yes, that I accept. But
again, with all due respect, if you put
a book in front of me, a history book,
and you tell me this book was authored
by a very respected man, you know what
I'll tell you? I'll tell you, with all
due respect, Brother Patrick, I know you
you gave me a book. You put you put a
book in front of me, but God gave me a
brain and I can do mathematics and I can
understand exactly when she was born,
where she was. It's not hard to work it
out.
>> Well, 18 to 21.
>> Okay. Okay, final verdict
>> according to your opinion is 18 to 21,
right? According to your opinion,
>> but I have Islamic sources for it.
>> But those are also sources,
>> but they are
>> so the two sources are debating each
other.
>> Again, a source is is measured and is
judged based on the author and based on
the the credibility of the source.
>> So when you're telling me that she was
uh it's narrated that she's 609, I
understand where that comes from. And I
can also tell you that book is banned in
certain countries. So that's the same
book for and I don't want to mention um
I don't want to offend uh x% of Muslims
by saying this. But I'll tell you this,
if a book is rejected because it was
relied upon by ISIS, it should also be
rejected. If it tells you that Aisha was
six and that my prophet was a rapist,
>> you reject the book in its totality. Do
do you do you know uh so
what is the worst rumor ever made about
you?
>> Worst rumor about me?
>> What is the worst rumor ever made about
you?
Worst rumor ever made about you?
>> Um
>> that that it's almost like it's insane.
>> No, but the u you know I would weigh
worst by the value of the source of the
rumor.
So if there's someone important
>> Yeah. But but this is this is you have
to realize when when when people make
rumors about
um Clinton and they'll say he went to
Epstein Island
>> and you know he raped somebody, he did
this, he did that. Okay. And then there
is a moment where he's holding up a
check of $850,000. Another woman that
got $850,000 that they settled
>> and these Epstein pictures are coming
up. Okay.
How come these rumors are not there of
Jimmy Carter?
How come these rumors are not there? For
Jimmy Carter, the rumors were very
different with George Boy Senior. The
rumors were director of CIA, John F.
Kennedy, where was he the day John F.
Kennedy got assassinated. Okay. The
rumors of uh
everybody is different. Can you imagine
you are a the the prophet of a
denomination of a religion where the
main source Muslims have to overcome the
objection is the fact that your prophet
married a six-year-old
and consummated at 9 years old. That's
not one person spread. This isn't
President Trump saying Obama was born in
Kenya and you know here go show your
birth certificate and the day the White
House released the birth certificate my
graphic designer said this is a BS birth
certificate and Obama this is a fake
birth certificate we're looking at right
this is not that this is something
that's been been around for a long time
so it's not like it's a one person
that's against Muslims that is saying
the founder was six you know married a
six-year-old 9-year-old wrote that's
everywhere. Now let me ask you the
second one. The second one is uh uh what
is your impression of what happens if I
am a Muslim and I die and I go to
heaven. Are there 72 virgins waiting for
me? Where are you at with that?
>> Two questions, Patrick, that need
unpacking.
>> Oh, do it. Go for it.
>> Okay. Firstly, with regards to rumors,
um I gather you're a uh proud Christian.
>> I am.
>> Okay. What's the rumor about Mary?
peace be upon her.
>> Okay.
>> The mother of Jesus.
>> Yeah.
>> What do our Jewish brothers in Abrahamic
faith think of Mary?
>> Not the same.
>> Okay. And it's not nice either.
>> It's not nice either. No.
>> Does it bring you value that u
Christianity is uh part of an Abrahamic
lineage from Abraham? Well, Adam, Noah,
Abraham, Moses, this tradition all the
way down to Jesus that the Bible refers
to. Of course, you have something to
stand on theologically.
>> Okay,
>> I understand the whole um concept or
faith that uh Jesus Christ is the savior
and the son of God. I understand and
that being above everything I just
mentioned. I I understand that. But the
rumor about Mary, the mother of Jesus
Christ, is a very serious one.
And it still stands according to the
Abrahamic faith of Judaism, which both
your prophets and my prophets come from.
Your prophet was Jesus Christ
was Jewish at the end of the day. For
us, he's a prophet of the Israelites.
>> Okay? And all of God's prophets for us
were Israelites.
We don't have female prophets, by the
way, obviously. But the prophet Muhammad
is the only Arab non-Israelite prophet.
Do you know that that rumor still stands
in the tradition of every single Jew?
And that rumor stands in the seminaries.
You know how that rumor
was neutralized at least in the
Abrahamic
household of ours?
>> This book,
the Quran did the greatest service to
Christianity.
The Quran that I believe in, this is the
same Quran. When you say people follow a
book, this is the same book that if I
were to open the very heart of this
book. Now, give or take a few pages uh
here and there because of course you're
dealing with u a publication that puts a
license and a contents page, right? This
we call it Quran, the heart of the Quran
here. So the viewers can see it.
The first chapter in the heart of the
Quran is surah Mariam the chapter of
Mary and it begins by narrating the
miracle of the birth of Jesus Christ.
Islam is the only religion that told our
Jewish brothers and sisters that Mary
gave birth to Jesus without a husband.
This is the same book, by the way. You
point to a religion for me that did
disservice to Christianity and to Jesus
Christ and to Mary other than Islam.
>> You didn't answer the question.
>> No, but I'm getting there. You're not
answering. So, I So, you have to realize
I was an atheist for 25 years of my
life.
>> Right. And what you just said right
there was one of the reasons why I had a
hard time being a Christian because for
me it was that was an era of naive.
How hard is it for somebody to convince
the people that I was a virgin and I'm
[clears throat] pregnant and I I haven't
had sex with anybody. How did I get
pregnant?
for somebody to believe that who's a
logical person, who's a math guy, which
is me. I'm not a Christian 25 years. I'm
an atheist. You couldn't get me to go
into a church. I thought it was for the
people of the weak.
>> So, a lot of these things you're saying,
logically, I was the guy that you were
talking about. And I'm not even a Jew. I
was just an atheist. I'm like, "No, this
the life I lived living in Iran, seeing
all the bombings, seeing his Hezbollah,
see seeing what Saddam Hussein was
doing, seeing what Kmeni was doing,
seeing what happened to a once great
nation where anybody from around the
world would come to vacate an Iran
vacation for Iran. No. So, I came from
that, but you haven't answered the
question yet.
>> Please ask. The question is about the
prophet, you know, um
the the the criticism of him when you
read the stories about his wives, when
you read the stories about Aisha,
specific to Aisha, I ask you two things.
It was Aisha and it was the 20 the 72
virgins when I die.
>> Yes. Okay. So 72 virgins is real. That's
in in Islam. It's in the it's in the the
the the concept of it.
>> That's a little weird. The concept of it
is in the Quran. Yeah.
>> Um but uh again uh allow me to unpack.
>> So when you read these things in the
Quran, please Patrick, please uh let's
not forget the uh type of community
these statements were being issued to.
We're not talking about Oxford graduates
or Harvard graduates. This was a
primitive society
>> in need of guidance. And therefore in
their mentality there were certain
things they considered to be worthwhile
and rewards. And unfortunately one of
them again is women. Right? So the word
70 in Islam and in Arabic tradition in
Arabic literature in general means a
lot. It does not mean exactly 72. You
know, you'll have preachers, again, I'm
speaking about preachers, uh, preachers
who say, uh, every one of these virgins
comes with a hundred maids,
so we're not going to stop counting. And
every maid has a has a secondary mate.
So, what is this? You know, uh, at the
end of the day, there is a a solid
Abrahamic tradition that is focused on
purity and piety. And then you have the
development of a religion and there are
conversations between the um the the
religious hierarchy and the uh adherence
of that religion. We have traditions for
example where our prophet was sitting
down and uh people would come and ask
him the same question and he would
answer in a different way. He wouldn't
uh misguide people but he would give the
same answer in a different way and the
companions would say why would you
answer them differently. He says because
the first one was a farmer. If I give
him examples using trees and and fruits
he would understand. And the second guy
was a businessman. If I speak to him in
real estate he'll understand better.
It's more about being relatable.
So number one, the idea of 72 virgins is
not a pillar in Islam. Meaning that if
you don't believe in it, you cannot be a
full Muslim. No, it is there in the
Quran part of a conversation between the
religion and the develop and and and the
developing society with a reminder that
you're talking about a society. Patrick,
can I just uh ask my brother here, can
you just uh go to the uh go to Google,
Patrick,
firstly
I should have said this first. I
congratulate you on on your clarity.
Really? I haven't done podcasts in
America for seven years, maybe eight
years.
>> Yes. I don't I get invites
>> seven eight years.
>> I can open my phone and show you the
type of people invited, right?
>> But uh if I don't listen to a podcast
myself
>> and I don't respect the interviewer, I
don't when I listen to you on other uh
shows, I'll get to you now. when I
listen to you interviewing other people,
you know, when you're listening to
someone and and in your mind you have
something to say about it, you're that
guy. You always say exactly what I'm
thinking. Uh and I congratulate your
clarity on on many of these issues, but
please, this is good. I want to
continue. Uh go there and and put uh um
Quranic verse
uh enter the home from its door.
Okay, click click on that that go down
the there's a first link, right? Bakar
189.
Wait. Okay, there we go. Chapter 2 verse
189. You want to highlight that please?
The second sentence. Okay. Do you see
that, Patrick?
>> Uh, I'm going to go to the end of that
verse there. Righteousness is not in
entering your your houses from the back
doors. Rather, righteousness is to be
mindful of Allah. So, enter your homes
through their proper doors. Patrick,
tell me why is it that Archangel
Gabriel, this is again I'm speaking
about the Islamic tradition. Archangel
Gabriel who carried each and every one
of these verses down onto the prophet
Muhammad. And in the Quran, we are told
when revelation comes down the prophet
his temperature goes up, right? It's
something heavy that's being bestowed
upon him. He's receiving a message from
God. He begins to sweat. He's in fear.
Now, the prophet has to go through that
entire process for then a verse to tell
him, "Please tell your guys and tell the
believers.
He's speaking to the Muslims, the new
the first Muslim community in Mecca,
enter your home from the front door."
What were you doing? Like, what were you
doing? Do you see that's the level of
intellect we need to
be mindful of? These are people who were
not accustomed to anything logical that
you and I have. You know, you know, when
you meet someone basic common sense and
basic logic, that does not exist. And
you can't expect it from someone who
buries his daughter alive.
You can't. Someone who thinks burying
daughters alive is a shame. That's the
level of mentality our prophet had to
deal with. Patrick Jesus Christ came to
a civilization.
He came to a civilization where they
were Romans and the Jewish civilization
alone is huge. That's why he didn't have
to go through what our prophet went
through. Our prophet was dealing with
people who don't get it. The struggle
was real. I'm telling you, you're not
dealing with a single situation. This is
the type of people. He has to tell them
when you go home, please use the front
door. like revelation needs to take
place because they were digging holes
from the back of their homes and
entering from the back after completing
pilgrimage. But why would you have a
front door if you don't use it?
>> You're saying the the the the following
of Prophet Muhammad during the time that
he was and where he was there wasn't a
level of advancement. So it was a higher
level of naive with the people versus
Jesus came to a place where there was
already an established society. Is that
what you're saying?
>> Beautifully said.
>> Okay. So then then help me correlate
those two together because one would say
that's even a bigger opportunity to
manipulate and deceive and persuade a
more naive audience than you would a
more educated audience which would be
tougher to do so.
>> No, but they had their own traditions
and they had they had their own gods. As
I said, they worshiped their own idols.
They had everything in place. There was
a functioning tribal society. Who were
they who were they idolizing before uh
Prophet Muhammad? Uh
>> the idols. Do you want to pull that up?
Just put the idol of lat.
>> Yeah. No. No.
L with with a T. Yep. And
u Z A [clears throat]
U Z A
>> U
double Z.
>> No, no. U Z A
>> Yeah.
>> There you go. Also
the three chief goddess of Arabian
religion, pre-Islamic. And she was
worshiped by the pre-Islamic Arabs and
the Alat and Manat the stone cube of
Nakla near Mecca was held sacred as part
of her call. She mentioned in Quran
53:19 as being one of the goddess whom
people worship. So he comes in he comes
in a time where the level of nit is high
but prior to that they had some
traditions just like Abraham. Abraham
had to deal with the Nimrod and the idol
worshiing. But uh keep that go back to
that Wikipedia page please. Um, I want
you to click on right there where your
mouse is. You see preIlamic Qurayshesh.
Click on that.
Okay? That is the chief Arabian tribe
that ruled Mecca. It's called Quraysh.
And our prophet was from Quraysh.
So, he came not only to a society, he
was rebelling against his own people.
They were the establishment.
You see that? So many people think that
our prophet came against Jews and
Christians. That's tribal alliances.
We'll get to later on. But the
establishment itself was the prophet's
family. The so-called conquest of Mecca
where the prophet came in and took
Mecca, he was simply coming back home.
So by law, if the chiefs of by tribal
law, by international law, if the owners
of the land submit to you and by tribal
law and Islamically,
all laws submit that the prophet
entering Mecca without a single drop of
blood being shed, right? He took over
Mecca. So he came back home. He's from
Quraysh. He came to guide
and Quraysh opposed him and tried to
murder him. So upon return, what he did
was without spilling a single drop of
blood, he entered Mecca, which is today
the holiest site for Muslims.
>> And there are reasons why Mecca is is
the holiest site for Muslims. It's it's
not just the location where God um
placed his home. I don't know if if
we're aware of that. Uh can you just
click on Mecca, the first line right
there? Beautiful. Okay. Click on that
black cube there, the picture. So we
Muslims believe that Adam, our father
Adam, the father of humanity because
again Muslims believe there were humans
before Adam. So he was a prophet,
prophet to who? There must have been a
nation that he came to guide. Uh the
point is the pro prophet Adam. So we
refer to him as prophet Adam. Uh came to
Arabia and and created the base for this
Kaa for the house of God. And then
Abraham came and built it. And ever
since then it has undergone renovations.
So floods would take place. For example,
the flood of Noah we believe. And then
there's this uh theological question as
to why the flood of Noah would even
disrupt the structure of the Cabba. And
uh that's because it was full of idols
at the time. It wasn't uh the the as
sacred as it is after it was be it was
purified by uh the prophet. So this was
full of idols. Inside it were idols.
Where that door is, above it and around
it, we're full of idols.
So I think we came down a different
path. But going back, I still want you
to know the prophet came to an
established community that had amazing
poets, had mathematicians. But when we
say ignorant, they were ignorant of
things to do with religion, with God,
and they were firm in their belief of
idols. and they had some terrible
terrible traditions such as burying
their women alive. And to be honest,
when you said what's the the the issue
that you uh struggle with a lot in
Islam, I thought you were going to ask
me about the wife beating verse. I
really thought so. But then you took it
another path. But um we we can discuss
that too. But when it comes to the
community, please keep in mind the
community was not a highly developed
community at the time.
>> Okay? So what what happens if by the way
just so you know for me um you know
sometime people see and they're
wondering what Patrick's an Islamophobic
is this is that my chef that's been with
my family for 3 years who's with us in
our house is a Muslim chef from Turkey
and he still is a Muslim he's not
converted to Christianity he's a Muslim
himself he cooks for us uh I had an
assistant guy named Hutan who was a
Muslim who was with me for one year one
of the nicest guys I met in my
But then I got hundreds of stories on
the other side as well of what happened
uh uh that I've personally witnessed. So
I want you to know I've met many many
peaceful people like you who are Muslim
who are incredible human beings to have
dinner with, have conversations with and
uh uh major respect to those guys. This
is not a blanket statement on everybody.
A part of my challenge is trying to see
if the two can coexist because if you
can't coexist, then don't force it to
coexist. Let them individually build
their own societies and see what can
happen. Let me go to my next question
here with you. And I know how you are,
so you're probably going to want to
comment on that as well. And you can go
forward. I'm I'm really interested in
hearing both your answers on uh uh on
both topics. But let's just say you
leave today. Okay,
we finish the podcast. I tell you,
I imam respectfully
I don't think you're 100% there. I think
you need to consider, you know,
becoming a Christian.
And you say 100%, no way. You know, even
if I came from that agnostic family, I
would still end up being where I'm at
right now. You said that earlier about
30 minutes ago.
But say something happens. You have a
miracle that happens.
Something happens. You go to sleep
tonight. You have a, you know, dream.
You, it's a dream. You're you're
actually sitting down having a
conversation with Jesus. And anything
that you're seeing, all of a sudden,
next day,
you know what? I'm going to become a
Christian.
If that were to happen, what happens to
you?
Dreams are not uh evidence or proof for
us nor for the logical.
>> Forget about the dream. You read the
Bible. You had a moment. You pray
>> which I have.
>> And you pray and you decide you want to
become a Christian. Your choice. What
happens to you?
>> I already believe in Jesus Christ as a
prophet of God.
>> No, but you leave. You denounce as being
a Muslim and you become a Christian.
>> Okay. Let me answer you
>> please.
But please allow me to answer you.
>> No problem. I haven't interrupted you,
so you go ahead.
>> No, and believe me, it's it's a real
pleasure sitting with you, Patrick. Um,
not only are you respectful, you come
from a region where you understand
exactly what I'm saying. And I love the
fact that the the viewers will know that
if I am in any way not being direct, you
would have the knowledge to say, "Hang
on." Right? So, I I appreciate that.
These questions don't apply to me,
Patrick. This question doesn't apply to
me. And the question that you asked when
you played my u uh when I was warning
the West, you said, "Well, someone can
say why is he still a Muslim?" That
doesn't apply to me either.
>> Why? Because that would be asking me to
let go of what is mine.
I didn't say
leave a religion.
that I adhere to or believe in. I'm not
speaking about belief here. This is not
an issue of faith.
>> I will not let go of what is mine.
I repeat for you. It is mine. What does
that mean?
It means
I am a Muslim who is Arab who comes from
the tribe of Tai being one of the most
prominent the prominent tribes in
Arabia.
>> And God sent a prophet. You know how in
Judaism God sends uh prophets from the
Israelites for the Israelites, right? So
God sent a prophet to us
who spoke our language
and God
sent down his book in my language. The
Quran says inside that
we created it or we made it an Arabic
Quran in order for you to understand.
Meaning that its original language was
not Arabic. It was made Arabic for us.
If God in Islam wants to speak to the
Somali community, he speaks to them in
Arabic. They can translate it all they
like. But this is the language of Islam,
Arabic. God doesn't have a language. But
God spoke to us in Arabic, in my
language, in my mother tongue. And he
sent a prophet to us.
He didn't put us in a different
continent. And then a prophet came to us
from a different continent like Islam
moved and people converted after
receiving its message in Malaysia and
Indonesia and and in the Indian
subcontinent.
This is mine. My ancestors are the
companions of the prophet
gave two eyes for the prophet in
defending him.
I am not a convert that came walked into
this religion 50 or 20 years ago.
My DNA is as old as this religion. When
the prophet first came to Arabia, we
believed in him and we stood by him and
we did everything he said. This religion
is where it is today because of us and
people like me. The Arab Muslims, the
children of the companions of the
prophet, the children of the family of
the prophet, those who intermarried with
the prophet, those who took his message
and defended him and spread his message
for him. That's us. That is why Islam is
run out of Mecca. That is why it's run
out of Saudi Arabia and out of the UAE.
Because we are the first generation
Muslims who the prophet would receive
message from God and hand it over to our
people, my forefathers
to be suggesting that I leave. It's
mine. Why would I let go of it? Kame
needs to leave the religion, not me.
Kumini needs to leave the religion. Han
Omar needs to leave the religion. The
Muslim Brotherhood needs to leave my
religion. It belongs to me. Patrick, if
you have 10 homes, as an example, and
someone decides to squat in your home,
and then society tells you, well, you
have many homes. One of them is called
Bahrain, one is called Oman, one is
called naming Muslim countries. Mhm.
>> Why don't you leave? You're going to say
what? I understand,
but it's mine. That's how I feel,
Patrick, when I see these extremist
Islamists. It's not my opinion versus
theirs or theirs versus mine. It is them
who have crossed the line into my faith
and have hijacked it and with money and
influence have come here first and have
become the face of my religion. That's
how I feel. So please, it's not us
versus them. It's them thieves who need
to leave. He needs to swap his turban
for a crown representing my God and my
prophet with his turban. That turban
curses him daily. If he wears it saying
it's a symbol of religion and piety,
that turban curses daily. And my turban
is on it, then I am wearing it. That's
the difference. I'm a theologian, right?
I'm a cleric. I'm not a politician. I
speak to you in this manner. So when I
speak about my religion, I am speaking
about something that is mine, not
something that I subscribe to or heard
about or I was born with. No, it's it
belongs to us. I was born with it. I
will carry it till the day I die. That's
the difference. Patrick,
>> I wish you knew um
>> I wish you knew how much I respect
people
who have the ability to be reasonable
and have reasonable conversation and to
have conviction. We don't have to agree
on things. I have tremendous respect for
your
>> likewise
>> ability to be reasonable and have the
conviction that you have and the pride
of where you are and saying it's not me
that needs to leave, it's they need to
leave. But that still doesn't answer my
question. Okay, that was a beautiful
seven minutes you went on. I'm asking.
>> Sorry, I didn't.
>> No, no, I love it. And I would have let
you go 30 more minutes. I I I don't want
you to take it as if time is uh limited.
Although we are coming to the end, I'd
like to go a few more minutes with you.
>> Um is
if you were to leave
and let's change the question.
You have a very persuasive way of
delivering your message. You have a
following. You have tens, if not
hundreds of millions of online views.
You have millions of followers. People
follow you and what you have to say. Say
you influence somebody. You'll never
meet this person, but he follows your
teaching the way you suggest what books,
what sect, what scripture to go through,
and the way you deliver the message.
That person's been a follower of you and
the way you teach the religion of Islam,
the way you go through it last 10 years
and that person chooses to leave. What
happens to them? That person says, "I no
longer want to be a Muslim. I'm
>> like apostasy."
>> Yes.
>> They're free to leave
>> according to who?
>> According to Islam, there is no law,
>> okay,
>> that is agreed upon that says they need
to be killed.
>> Okay. So then then what is uh how do you
um and and I'm trying to see if you've
ever done anything cuz I don't know if
you have or haven't. How uh uh how do
you view some of these social media
influencers that are out there debating
uh the the religion of Islam? How do you
view some of these guys get a lot of
views?
>> Yeah, you said it. Influencers. They're
not not scholars.
>> So give me some names like who would you
see and say this is a valid person that
they you've called a lot of people out.
There isn't anybody bigger to call out
than today. You've called out
>> is not big.
>> You've called out vah. Okay. You've
called ameni. You've called out you
you've called out a lot of people.
>> They are midgets in the region.
>> They may be midgets in their region, but
there are giants with the amount of
money and influence that they have and
control that they have. So you can you
can say that but they have control. And
guess what? As amazing as the sha of
Iran was, he was able to only control
that beautiful place for 37 years. These
guys have been able to control it for 46
years. 46 years
>> because of the West, because of America.
>> That's a different conversation. We can
get to get to that as well. But I want I
want to I want to get to the question.
When you see some of these influencers,
who would you say reasonable? Just a,
you know, social media guy, not a real
guy, this guy's a real guy. Who would
you say?
And have you debated any of these guys?
>> I'm not a debater. I Sometimes things
happen um and you find yourself in front
of someone talking. Um I'm not a
debater, but um you have to realize the
young the youth
is consuming their content around the
world and it's just going to get bigger.
And that's depicting what you believe
in,
>> right? Um, if there is one man that I
would direct people to listen to or read
his words and read about him, it would
be Sheh Zed, the founder of the UAE.
It would be that man, the father of the
current president
Zed Sultan al pull him up. That man,
that man took the UAE from a regular
Arab state that could go anywhere
anywhere um other states went and he
turned it into a beacon of hope
>> and never once did he violate Islam or
his principles or his morals. This is
what a Muslim leader looks like. Why is
it Patrick that when the leader of ISIS
for example speaks people say look
leader Muslim leader why is it when Kami
speaks he's a Muslim leader but when
this man speaks no one says Muslim
leader no he is a Muslim leader this is
a legend who passed away and may God
have mercy on his soul this man is the
reason why we have the Abrahamic family
house today he's the reason why
Christians have the biggest parish in
the UAE. He's the reason why there's
coexistence. You know, he's the reason
why the Pope gets up from the Vatican
and visits Abu Dhabi to sign the Abu
Dhabi document on human fraternity. He's
the reason behind it. There's an archive
of books and text and speeches of this
man that if every Arab state had a ruler
like him, it would be heaven on earth. I
say that. And I chose this man because
he has passed away and no one can accuse
me of uh trying to to uh get closer to a
current ruler. He has passed away and he
left behind a legacy that is Islamic
that makes Islam look exactly how our
prophet wanted it to be.
>> When did he pass away? He passed away. I
I Yeah. of 2004.
>> Yeah.
>> So,
>> you know that amazing mosque, Grand Shos
in Abu Dhabi
>> that world leaders go to? He's buried
just outside the courtyard.
It's it's a fascinating place to visit
and see just uh I mean he didn't get he
started the mosque, the construction of
the mosque, but he didn't get the
opportunity to pray. Yeah. It's it's the
Grand Mosque of Abu Yeah, that one
there. She Zad Grand Mosque. If you want
to click on that in bold,
that is the mosque. These that one
there.
It's a fascinating place. You know
>> that's that's where
>> that's Abu Dhabi.
>> That's Dubai.
>> Yeah. This is what Islam looks like. No
extremist preachers.
>> I've been there.
>> Yeah. No terror cells. No Muslim
Brotherhood nonsense.
>> Yeah.
>> Right. And um Patrick, I know uh we're
limited on time, but I can't end without
showing this to you. I'm not selling
anything. This is important. This is the
cancer that has infiltrated America.
This is from our organization, Trans
Research and Advisory. The CEO sends you
his regards. This here is for you. This
is about the international organization
of the Muslim Brotherhood. It shows you
how they started 98 years ago in Egypt
and infiltrated society. This here is
their organizational structure.
Um,
tell me how we're doing with time. And
this, by the way, is their path to a
caliphate globally.
This is what the UAE is putting forward
to warn. And by the way, this is a few
volumes out of I think 30 volumes. The
project is it's like 15 volumes out and
and translated into 16 languages. This
is their path to a caliphate, the Muslim
Brotherhood cancer. And they need to be
called out. You know, we can speak about
Islam all day. We can speak theology. We
can speak about conversions. No problem.
But when I walk out of the studio, this
is the cancer that we have to face.
>> Which one should I read first?
>> The one you're holding.
>> This guy. Okay.
>> Yes.
>> Just so you know what what book my son
is reading right now. My son is reading
the Quran right now. Um, I have my
oldest son read Communist Manifesto
at the Shrug, the Bible, the Quran. He's
going to read about all these guys to
learn for himself and get questions. I
can tell you for me, I'm going to go
through this book and read them myself.
But, um, you know, I can talk to you for
six more hours. You know, I don't have
50 more questions for you, but we can't
do an 8 hour podcast. Um, go for it.
>> Well, I didn't give you this in the
start, but I came here with something
for you
>> because uh if if I hand this over to you
in the in the beginning, then it could
be bribery. You might be nice to me
throughout the whole uh conversation.
That's fair.
>> So, at at the end, this my brother is
100 real.
>> Oh, you got to be kidding.
>> From the time of the shing rare,
uncirculated.
>> I've had it with me for nearly 15 years.
And I said, you know, this needs to go
to brother Patrick.
>> You're amazing.
>> Because I feel you would appreciate it.
>> Are you kidding me? Like, you mind if I
show it to him to see what it is?
>> Yeah.
>> This is This is the kind of stuff that
just uh uh means the world to me. Gifts
like this. This is the kind of stuff
that you'll never be able to buy from
me. Never for the rest of my life will
you be able to buy this from me. This
goes in the safe. You're amazing. I
appreciate this gift. And and I have to
I have to tell you, you know, I think uh
uh there are some podcasts that that uh
you do where at the end um you know,
I'll I'll walk away like I'm going to go
have lunch right now with a guy and I'm
going to say, you know who won today? I
think the audience won today. I think
the audience won today because the
audience is kind of going to watch this
and they're going to say there's some
things I really like what uh you know
the imam had to say. He made a very good
point there and there's something
they're going to I was actually ask
interesting question Pat asking what he
had to say here but either way we're
getting smarter and and the basis that I
like about this a lot of times people
will say well come you know you come
bring me on bring me on if you can
respect I'll bring you anybody on and
you've been nothing more respectful from
the beginning to the end um I respect
that a lot and I look forward to us
having many many more conversations like
this again the two of us together
anytime you need to get a hold of me you
can get a hold of me anytime this has
been uh a pleasure sitting on here
talking to you.
>> Thank you very much, Patrick. I uh would
like to end with uh very brief statement
that uh we are all different people and
we don't have to be the same. We're
different. We were created differently,
but we find ourselves in the same
region, speaking the same language,
eating the same food, uh going the same
places. And I think
allowing the extremists to operate with
no criticism and without shedding light
on their cancer that they bring to
society is wrong. And with what we did
today, we were able to not only
highlight that but also give you an
understanding into what is in my mind
and also what made me who I am today.
There's a lot of things that we did not
discuss which we will leave for future
interactions.
But I want to say one thing. The truth
is worth it, Patrick. The truth is is
worth it.
It's worth losing friends over it. It's
worth being controversial over it. It's
worth uh the challenge. This could have
gone many different ways. Patrick could
have, you know, people were telling me,
"Be careful. You never know how this
would go." But I'll tell you this.
The truth is worth getting in front of
millions of people and saying this
religion is here to serve and guide. In
its principle, in its origins was
heading in a certain way that is about
uh belief in one God and harmony and
coexistence between all people
and that it was hijacked by the
extremists. That needs to be said and it
needs to be said by someone like me.
>> What do you do with the 100 million of
them?
>> The 100 million, believe it or not, are
governed. That's We're going to go with
100 million. Regardless of how many they
are, they're always governed by a small
number on top. If the small number on
top are dealt with,
then you will find the 100 million
dispersing like every other society.
There are religions that no longer
exist, languages that no longer exist.
Why? Because the scholars passed away.
>> What should happen to those guys?
>> Um, we have a few more minutes.
>> Yes,
>> Patrick. There needs to be the clash of
the turbans.
Turbans need to start clashing, not
physically, verbally.
There needs to be presence online on TV
of imams who reject the Muslim
Brotherhood. Saysama bin Laden does not
represent us. He would be executed in
Saudi Arabia had he been caught and the
people doing that would be Muslim for
killing so many Americans.
There needs to be imams who come out and
speak in English. Unfortunately, there's
a language barrier. I understand I'm not
the only one who speaks in this manner.
There are those in Farsy which you are
familiar with and those in in the Arabic
world as well.
I need to mention Piers Morgan.
>> Mhm.
>> After October 7, people were turning to
the Muslim world and they want to see
the face of the Muslim community.
And I'm I'm really sorry to say this.
The people that Piers Morgan had on his
show were not imams. They were preachers
or academics and they were anti-semites
at the same time. You know, Gaza,
>> who are you referring to?
>> You know, it's not about defamation. I
don't want to dirty my mouth with their
names. People like followers of
okay um they should not be the face of
Islam. What? But it's important for you
to qualify because I think you know if
you don't
don't assume everybody that is
non-Muslim that's a Christian or Jew or
something else that they know everything
about the different sex you're seeing
especially the naive in the middle that
will see so you you just said someone's
name what
>> it's an organization
>> what can you talk talk to us about that
organization and what their teaching is
>> is an organization that its logo just
pull it up please pull forb t a h
r i r
>> okay you see that logo that planet earth
just click on that logo for me please
look at that that's their logo the
banner of al-qaeda pierced through
planet earth that they want global
caliphate these guys exist everywhere
so one of the guests medical doctor from
the UK that appears had on after October
7 because that's when people want to
hear from Muslims
right was from this organization
and again I'm not blaming peers in any
way I'm answering your question I'm
saying such platforms need to bring in
Muslims who have clarity of mind and
thought and have depth in their
understanding of religion of the Quran
and can answer questions
right not Muslims who just want to uh
speak about Gaza and the Palestinian
cause which is neither here nor there.
You know, the Palestinian cause is not
central to Islam or to the region. It's
another issue like we're dealing with
every other issue.
>> Would Would you and Muhammad hijab agree
on a lot of things?
>> Of course not.
Definitely not. I'd be damned if he
approved of anything I said. I'll bury
myself alive if he agreed with me.
>> Why do you say that?
>> That's a disgrace. Why do you say that?
>> An absolute disgrace.
>> Hijab.
>> Him and his community. Him and his
>> Are they part of that community or not?
>> Correct.
>> Okay. So, the community you were talking
about.
>> The Muslim Brotherhood in general is not
a monolith. It comes in many faces. The
academic face. It comes in the long
beard uh no mustache uh appearances.
They come in in different forms.
But I if you look if you ask me um about
him it's the same as though telling me
if a deputy of Kame in America agreed
with you how would you feel? No. These
are people I do not categorize as
peaceful people who want to coexist with
Christians and Jews at all. This is not
a community that is the face of Islam at
all.
Our
father Abraham wants us to live
together. That's what I'm getting at.
What does Abraham want? When we say we
we are Abrahamic family, what does that
mean? It means our father Abraham wants
us to coexist, live in harmony, live
together, not spill each other's blood.
Whoever does not champion coexistence
and harmony and peace and I don't like
the word tolerance but I understand it.
You know I'm tolerating you. No
acceptance of one another. You're a
human. I accept you on that level as a
human without the need to change you so
then I can accept you. No, I accept you
the way you are. And that religion is
here to guide. You have yours. I have
mine.
>> And mine looks very much like yours. And
yours looks very much like the Torah.
Why? Because the one God spoke to Moses,
spoke to Jesus, spoke to the prophet
Muhammad. It's the same source of
information. No one copied anyone. No
one plagiarized anything from anyone.
But this is Islam, monotheism, and
Arabic characteristics for an Arabic
society.
A lot of blood was spilt for people to
then realize we need peace and
coexistence.
I believe in the professional way.
diplomacy, interfaith, dialogue,
uh, research, studies. That's the path I
take. I don't take the path of stripping
your shirt in public, which is what
these people do, and chanting and and
screaming and yelling. This is a
foolish, childish. What are you going to
change in the world? No, I believe in
professional discourse, which is why we
have the amount of followers that we
have. people listen to us and which is
why the extremists hate us the most
because of the impact we have on on on
people in society.
>> Yeah. Um the other doctor that you were
talking about what upset you about the
doctor the the what did she say? It's he
what did he say? Is that the
>> No. You want to put up medical doctor?
Yeah.
>> Here. Who's the medical do? But what did
he say?
>> I I'll tell you. Wait. I think if you go
on images
I think it's him I think yeah this this
handsome chap now this this is
tells you like peers needs to know this
guy would
enters a society in order to bring it
down. They want a global caliphate. If
if they if they rule they would execute
the king. If they rule, they will
execute the king and execute
non-Muslims.
And even Muslims like me would be third
class, not even second class, if not
total outright apostasy beheading.
Is cancer. Their Muslim Brotherhood on
steroids. The Muslim Brotherhood is more
pragmatic. They'll participate in
elections, you know, they'll uh like in
Morocco for example, they'll show
respect to the king. But when Gen Z
uprising starts, they start funding
them. So Muslim Brotherhood is more
strategic. Outright tells you, we don't
believe in your courts. We don't believe
in your incorporation systems. We will
operate without incorporation. There is
no legal status and there's nothing you
can do about it.
This guy cannot be. And by the way,
Piers did not agree with him on
anything. Piers was really good. My
issue is look, by the way, look look at
the hat that he's wearing. The red that
is the Muslim Brotherhood cap. If you go
to Hassan Baha, the founder of the
Muslim Brotherhood, that's the cap they
wear. He's he he's coming to studio
telling you he's an extremist and then
you expect him to condemn Hamas. Of
course, he's not going to do it, which
he never did.
But my issue with peers is that there
needs to be um proper imams from the UK
who are platformed
in an equal amount or bring them face to
face. As I said, clash of the turbons,
excuse me. Let them clash. Let the
British and let the Americans see the
clash within the Muslim community. Let
them see it because if they don't see
it, they only see this guy.
>> Are you proposing you're open to the
idea or you don't want to have anything
to do with it?
>> No. Piers invited me, but he invited me
at a time. his producer did invited me
at a time where people were eager to get
on screen to to capitalize
um on on the u suffering of the
Palestinians
and I prefer a more civilized calm
discussion with the host alone and I
prefer it in person. Uh and I also
appreciate being asked relevant
questions like you asked me today. These
are the questions Americans think of
when they see someone who looks like me.
And you ask me about Imam of Peace. When
I was first called Imam of Peace, I
adopted it, Patrick. Why? Because
unfortunately, if you if you don't put
yourself in a box, they will put you in
a box. That's the main reason why that
is my handle.
>> Well, this is part one of I'm sure many
and u it was a pleasure having you on.
>> God bless you.
>> Thank you for the gift. God bless you as
well.
>> Thank you. safe travels. And is there
anywhere you want people to go to to
learn more about you? Where would you
like them to go?
>> Just uh I'm on Twitter. I mean, okay.
>> Um I imoface.
>> There you go, Rob. If we can put that
handle below so the audience can go find
them, and I appreciate the gifts and the
books, folks. God bless. Have a good
one. Take care, everybody. Bye-bye.
Bye-bye.
>> God bless. Bye.
When we set out to create a shoe that
blends [music] comfort, function, and
luxury, we had the choice to make it
fast, we had the choice to make it
cheap. We chose neither. Instead, we
chose Tuscano. We chose true Italian
craftsmanship, [music] each pair touched
by 50 skilled hands. We chose patience,
spending two years perfecting every
detail. And we chose the finest [music]
quality at every step. Introducing the
future looks bright collection. Not
rushed, not disposable, not ordinary,
rather intentional, luxurious, timeless.