The Bitcoin Show - 055 - Nick Flower and Robert Taylor, actors: "The Good Wife"
Watch on YouTubeVideo summary
In an engaging discussion recorded at CES 2012, hosts Bruce Wagner joined actors Nicholas Flower and Robert Taylor of *The Good Wife* to preview their upcoming episode titled "Bitcoin for Dummies." The plot centers on federal agents investigating an online lawyer suspected of being the elusive Satoshi Nakamoto. Although Nicholas admitted he was unfamiliar with Bitcoin before reading the script, both actors acknowledged its legitimacy after conducting research, noting that early internet misinformation often falsely labeled it a Ponzi scheme or pyramid scheme. They clarified crucial distinctions between cryptocurrency and fraudulent models like Multi-Level Marketing (MLM), emphasizing that unlike those schemes which rely on government issuance or central banks, Bitcoin operates as a decentralized network without any single authority controlling its supply.
The conversation delved into personal experiences with the asset, revealing that Robert purchased his first bitcoins in late 2009 for just $1.98 before selling them later during a surge to around $30, while Nicholas remained interested despite initial skepticism fueled by false narratives. Both agreed that airing this episode would significantly boost public awareness and potentially trigger short-term market speculation, leading them to advise investors wishing to buy immediately after the Sunday broadcast at 9 p.m. Eastern time to do so right away, rather than waiting for potential price bubbles in subsequent weeks. Robert shared an anecdote about selling some of his holdings following uncertainty caused by the Mt. Gox hacking scandal, though he still retains a portion today, while Nicholas promoted his YouTube channel *PraxGirl*, which teaches praxiology and accepts only Bitcoin donations to preserve user anonymity against stalkers or trolls.
Beyond personal anecdotes, the actors explored economic concepts such as intrinsic value, with Nicholas arguing that nothing possesses inherent worth independent of collective agreement and utility; instead, value arises from practical applications like facilitating anonymous transactions. They highlighted how Bitcoin's fixed supply enforced by cryptography distinguishes it fundamentally from fiat currencies like the US dollar, which central authorities can print indefinitely. While some speculated about Bitcoin potentially replacing gold in an anarchist society without government oversight, others pointed to its current practical uses ranging from purchasing goods and playing online poker to integrating into mainstream commerce through zero-fee merchant services.
Finally, Nicholas Flower argued that Bitcoin is superior to traditional assets like gold because it eliminates the need for physical storage, warehouses, or blind trust in third-party institutions such as banks; while both face theft risks if stored physically, Bitcoin offers unique advantages including digital encryption and portability without carrying heavy metal. Both speakers agreed that gold, silver, and bitcoin represent a future driven by growing public dissatisfaction with government-controlled banking systems, drawing parallels between US banks and Chinese state-owned entities. The discussion also touched on Flower's role as a federal Treasury agent in the show, noting he received minimal training beyond costume details like an overcoat and badge due to safety protocols regarding unused firearms, while confirming that creating cryptocurrency is legal in both the US and UK despite fictional bans depicted in the series.
Read the full video transcript
[Music]
Hello everybody and welcome to the
Bitcoin show. This is a live CES
consumer electronic show 2012 edition
and uh we have an amazing opportunity to
have uh the cast members from The Good
Wife. You've heard of The Good Wife on
CBS. Everybody watches it. and uh the
and everybody in the Bitcoin world knows
that there's going to be a Bitcoin
episode this Sunday at 9:00 p.m. Eastern
time. So, we have with us uh Nicholas
Flower. Hi. And Robert Taylor. So, stay
tuned.
[Music]
Hey everybody, welcome to the Bitcoin
show. This is Bruce Wagner, you know,
and uh I am live here in at CES, a
consumer electronic show in Las Vegas.
And um I just arrived late last night,
but uh we got the most incredible coup
because everyone knows that as I said
the the good wife on CBS is doing a
major episode all about Bitcoin. It's
called Bitcoin for Dummies is the title
of the episode and they're going to talk
about Satoshi and all kinds of stuff. So
uh but anyway, we got a major coup
because we have with us some of the cast
members from The Good Wife. And uh so
with us are Nicholas Flower and Robert
Taylor. They're in the studio in New
York. I'm in Las Vegas. Can you Hey
guys. Uh Bruce, we're actually taking
over. We're the hosts today. Yes.
You're the host. That's right. And I'm
the guest. So you can ask me questions.
Go ahead. Ask. Well, I I I also want to
I want to make clear you're a cast. Uh
Nick is a cast member. I was standing in
that day when we when we met. So I I'm
not a cast member.
So you're Oh, no. Not a regular cast
member, but you were standing in. Well,
you were in the cast that day. Is that
it? No, no, no, no. Only Nick. He's the
He's the guy that's going to get the
credits on the show. Oh, okay. Cast in
my house. Cool.
I'm sorry. Okay. The I've already been
um told to ask obviously the the obvious
question. Um what is it like to work
with Juliana Margill? Margillis, how do
you say your last name? Well, it was it
was really great. She was very nice. Um,
when I got on set, the very first
moment, it was it was pretty funny. I
didn't recognize her. Um, you know, we
went in for a rehearsal and we started
it up. It was with Jason Biggs and, uh,
David Fur and she interrupts the scene.
Um, and so here here she comes and, you
know, she's not in costume yet. She
hasn't she hasn't done costume or makeup
and she comes in and does her lines and
I'm like oh I wonder why her standin is
reading her
lines and then she introduces
herself and it was the straight hair
too. I I you know grew up watching er
and so you know I have this idea of her
with curly hair and so I just it was
kind of embarrassing. It really was. But
uh she was very very nice. Um, she was
very accessible and introduced herself
and just was totally normal, very very
relaxed, funny. She was, you know,
that's
how that's how I like my stars to be hot
and accessible.
That's all you need to be. Yeah.
You know, she was uh talking with people
on set and just being really nice. She
wasn't like um it it wasn't like she
needed everyone to know that the that
she was on set. She just kind of was on
set, you know? It was just living and
and doing her her job. That's great.
Yeah, that's great. That's how people
should be. People are just people
anyway. So, people that are full of
themselves are just full of themselves.
Yeah. So, um All right. So, we're gonna
we're gonna come back to the gossip and
and dish the dirt as I want to I have a
lot more about them, but I want to know
about Bitcoin. Had you ever heard of
Bitcoin before you were head of this
script? No, I had not. You guys I had
not. Okay. Yeah. Obviously. Yeah.
Robert, I have talked with you and I
found out you you were already a Bitcoin
fan, right? When did you find out about
it, Robert?
I I I don't know specifically the the
the date, but I do remember being in
California and I think it was either
late ' 09 or early I no, you know, I I
feel like it was somewhere mid or or
late '09 is when I first heard about it.
And I didn't get really into it until it
got very close to reaching par with the
dollar.
Yeah, it's funny how we measure Bitcoin
time by the value of Bitcoin, but when
it was $7, that's when I got I got in at
$1.98, you know, was so funny. Then when
it hit 30, I cra bought it at 30 and
sold it at a
dollar. So,
um Okay. So, Nicholas, when
um when like how long ago did you were
you hand and you the first time you
heard the word Bitcoin then? A few weeks
ago? Yeah. Well, I guess we shot the
episode maybe a month ago and I had I
was handed the script maybe a week
before we shot the the episode. And so I
had
very very little time
to kind of, you know, do my do my
research, but I I did and, you know,
kind of got the general overview of, you
know, it's obviously been around for a
while now to pick up some speed, but
um yeah, I find it really really
interesting. I I was talking to Robert
earlier. I find it so interesting that
uh it's really hard to counterfeit. I
think that's pretty cool.
And uh but yeah, I I was handed the
script a week before. I I knew nothing
about it, so I did my research and kind
of just jumped in.
I I I can ask him a couple of questions.
So, sure. Uh how about Jason Biggs? How
I thought he was super down to earth.
Jason Biggs was really cool. Um, my one
of my favorite moments on set, well, not
on set, just you know, in the experience
was my interaction, my first interaction
with Jason Bigs. I had to be at the van
at 7:30 in the morning um, in like
Midtown and we were just to be driven to
the studio and no one's really around.
It's kind of, you know, just the city's
just kind of sleeping still, right? And
I see a van and it has the sign that
says the good wife and the there's just
two people in the van. It's uh the
driver and the passenger. And the
passenger is his window is down. And I
start walking up and the passenger's
like, "Nicholas Flower." And I'm like,
"Yeah." He goes, "Jason
Bigs." My mind is blown. And so I got in
the van and just the the three of us
kind of just rode to the studio together
and it was it was funny. It it was, you
know, I didn't want to talk to him too
much cuz it was 7:30 in the morning.
Like we're all kind of groggy just
having our morning coffee. But but I
mean he he dresses like in the in like
these just casual like Yeah. homeboy
jeans and like you know just I think he
even saw him with a backpack and just
like a grungy jacket and he's really
chill. He's really really cool. Uh, and
I thought it was really interesting. Um,
seeing him kind of I mean I don't want
to say starruck but a little starruck
with Bob Balaban.
Yeah. I mean you know it like you know
Bob Baliban's it's Bob Baliban you know
so and they had never met before and so
I thought that was really cool to see
him being like you know around someone
who he really admired. And then who does
Bob play in the in the in the episode?
Um Bob plays a well I don't want to give
it away. He said he's he's actually re
um he's uh re he's a reoccurring
character now. This is his second uh
appearance on the show and he plays my
boss. So nice. Yeah. Yeah. I guess I
just haven't name but
I think we got him back.
Hey, I'm hoping back. So, Nicholas, when
you were handed this script and it said
Bitcoin in it, you had never heard of
the word Bitcoin. Like, did you have any
idea what it was? I had no idea. Um, the
only thing I really knew, you know, from
the very beginning was that my
character, uh, a federal agent from the
Treasury was very nervous about this
strange online currency that had been
created. and and my my job was to
basically nail the
creator. And so from then I just kind of
Googled it and did a little research
and, you know, found a bunch of
different, you know, topics on it, you
know, from Wikipedia to YouTube shows to
to everything. And it's it was really
clear to me
that that it's not just
some passing trend. It seems so you were
you knew that it was actually something
real. It wasn't completely fictional.
Yes, I did.
Knew it was real. Okay. And so but what
because somebody had said like, "Oh, no,
that's a real thing." I mean, I
literally just Googled it. I I just I
didn't really know what it was. And um
actually the original You read the
script and you Googled it. Is this real?
The original title uh was different. It
was called Finding Mr. Bitcoin kind of a
play on finding Mr. Goodyear, right?
Yeah, exactly.
So, uh, so when you So, you play the ro
I'm
I can't hear Robert, but when you when
you you uh I had to pass the phone back
and forth. I know it's crazy. So, when
you um were So, you play the the
attorney who uh has the client Satoshi
who um and you're protecting his
identity. Is that right? No, I'm
actually a federal agent from the
Treasury who I'm a pair I'm one half of
a pair of federal agents who's very
nervous about
Mr. Bitcoin himself and they're
basically after
um we're kind of aware that uh Jason
Big's character is an online lawyer and
we suspect that his client is Mr.
Bitcoin. So, Mr. Bitcoin. Yeah, that's
what that's actually the original I
don't know if I'm supposed to say that,
but that was the original title of the
episode was I don't think that I don't
changing titles. Finding Mr. Bitcoin.
That's funny. I like Bitcoin for
Dummies. I like that better. Say our our
website is Yeah. Yeah. I hope they don't
get sued by the four dummies book
series, but that's okay. It's all good.
That's CBS's problem. So um so what was
so um when you Googled it and I mean you
already knew it was a real thing. I mean
what was your first impression about it?
Does this seem like I mean did did it
seem like this is a real thing or I mean
not you know it's a real thing but like
this is a uh a growing movement or does
it seem did it seem like a real
off-the-wall uh u you know specialty
kind of thing? Well, you know, that's
that's really interesting because when I
Googled it, I definitely found a
multitude of of of topics on on it. And
I would say like the first three were uh
you know, Bitcoin and Ponzi scheme,
Ponzi scheme, Ponzi scheme. And it was
um that was the first thing that entered
my brain when I I uh read about it. And
so I definitely was approaching it
thinking like, okay, this is um
probably, you
know, passing quickly, but then as I as
I, you know, read on and kind of found
about found out about all the investors
and and you know, how how many people
were involved and, you know, how how
serious it is, could kind of see
that it it's going to be around. It
looks like it's going to be around for a
while. Yeah. Yeah. And then it's not a
it's not a Ponzi scheme obviously
because the definition of a by
definition a Ponzi scheme is that the
new uh new investors capital that they
put in goes to the old investors. Um so
obviously it's not a Ponzi scheme but u
you know that's people like to throw
those words around because they don't
know what it is. It's brand new you know
in the history of mankind. It's never
existed before. So they try and put it
in a box that already has a label. So
they'll put it in, you know, Ponzi
scheme or MLM or all kinds of crazy
nonsense. But it it is definitely not
that. So, um anyway, people people love
to and sorry to interrupt. Uh I just was
going to say people fear what they don't
understand. And when it's new like that,
it's scary.
Yes, that's right. That's for sure. They
do. And it's I mean like I I always say
I mean this is really new in the history
of mankind. There's never been a
currency that's completely decentralized
and limited in quantity. It's not issued
by any bank or government uh you know or
corporation. And this is really really
unique. So um of course you know the
good wife and uh is very timely with its
uh you know topics everything from
Occupy Wall Street to now Bitcoin
because it's it's in the news. Okay,
this seems like a good time to uh take a
break and thank our sponsors who are
bringing us to you obviously. Um Mount
Doc is
mpgox.com. Mount Doc is the place to go
online to buy and sell about Bitcoin.
They are the world's largest exchange.
Mount to is to Bitcoin like the New York
Stock Exchange is to stock. So, um you
there are millions of ways, not millions
literally, but lots and lots of ways to
get money into Mount Rock and out of
Mount Rock. Uh it's the only exchange in
the world actually Bitcoin is the only
exchange in the world that is 24/7
people at 365. People ask me what what
was the closing price yesterday and I'm
like there is no closing. The Bitcoin
market never sleeps. It's 247. So, Mount
Doc is uh like something like 80 to 90%
market share of all trades that happen
happen on Mount Do. So, that's the place
to do your online trading. It's
mpgox.com. They have 26 plus currencies.
Um they operate obviously globally. So
check it out, mounts.com and tell them
that you appreciate them supporting the
Bitcoin show
and buy bitcoin.com which is a new
venture that uh we've initiated to make
it easy to hold people's hand and help
them buy bitcoin easily and anonymously
instantly. It's buybitcoin.com in the
buy bitcoin hotline. So check it out.
You can call
646-580022 from anywhere in the world.
Uh that's a New York number and just
check out
buybitcoin.com and
bitcoinsolutions.com. Bitcoin solutions
is another venture of ours that we are
launching which is uh merchant services.
If your business whether it's an online
web store or a brickandmortar business
of any kind, whether you're an
accountant, a CPA, a nail salon or a
restaurant, it doesn't matter. You want
to get set up to accept Bitcoin in just
moments. There is zero transaction fees,
zero monthly and maintenance fees, zero
hardware investment, and there's no such
thing as a chargeback. You'll never ever
can get a charge back with Bitcoin.
We're there to help you set up your
business to accept Bitcoin. That's
bitcoinsolutions.com. Let's check that
out. Okay, so now back to uh Robert and
Nicholas. So, where were we? Um, so I
was asking you, um, Nicholas, so like
after you Googled Bitcoin, I you you the
first thing since you read where that
it's a Ponzi scheme or something, and
then you started read realizing and
reading that it's it's actually there's
more to it than that. What like how
large did you perceive that the
community was, the Bitcoin community,
the user base? Initially, I I didn't
realize how big it was. Um, you know, it
kind of it kind of seemed like uh your
standard internet bashers, you know,
your trolls just kind of lingering
around. And as I did more research, I I
realized that the community was very
large. And as a as a new
community, it's kind of amazing how how
fast it's grown and how much it's
expanded and and picked up speed and
Yeah. So, that was really really
interesting to me.
Okay. Did Did the uh I'm
wondering what was that? Oh, I didn't
say anything. Oh, that's my I'm sorry.
That's myself coming back. I'm hearing
myself. Um, sorry. No, my
questioning echo is if the uh cast or
anybody bought any Bitcoin knowing, you
know, that this is uh going to be major
major publicity.
Yeah, actually that's what we were just
talking about. Um, I I think that that
probably will uh in in some way uh help
help the uh market or help the
community. That's for sure. once this
this comes out uh once the episode airs
on Sunday. I think that
um I think you can expect something like
that. I mean, I'm definitely not a
uh you know, I'm I'm I'm not an
investor. I'm not well I'm not an
investor nor am I, you know, someone to
uh really uh share much of an opinion on
on on the the market itself, but I I
would I would say that if it's so
popular right now and then you take a
show like The Good Wife, which is an
Emmy and Golden Globe winning show,
which a lot of people watch, I think
that it's going to really raise a lot of
curiosity for the people that have no
idea what it is and
exactly what a great title for that, you
know, Bitcoin for dummies. What a great
title to get people even more
interested. That's the phrase I always
use when I was describing bitcoinme.com
is that I created it kind of as a
Bitcoin for dummies just to explain it
in really simple language to you know
margin barely can work a mouse
brows and uh but yeah, the price has
gone up like crazy. It's 691 at this
moment and it seems like it's going up
about 25 cents to 50 cents a day. Wow.
I mean, at least it seems like. So, um,
fascinating.
And this is right after early days next
week, like Monday through Wednesday next
week, there's be a huge buying spree.
Yeah, that wouldn't surprise me at all.
Who knows, you know, after all this, I
might I might go out and get some
Bitcoin.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, talk to me
after. I can tell you can hook you up.
Totally. Yeah, please do. I've got
connections.
I could just ring up Satoshi and he
could get you some more. All
right. I'm in the heart of the Mount
Blood at CES, so uh we can get you some
bitcoins. No problem. Nice. But yeah, I
would definitely I mean if you're I was
gonna I mean I've been telling my
friends if you're going to buy Bitcoin
definitely do it before Sunday at 9.
Yeah, I the Monday morning water cooler
talk they're going to say did you see
that the good wives last night? Yeah,
you know that's a real thing. We should
buy that and uh it's going to go nuts.
Who knows? It could be 10 times the
current value by then. There's no
telling really.
It could be but it's really exciting to
see all these products. We're we're
going to be doing some subsequent
episodes where we're uh showing you a
lot of the new products that are on
display here to dispense bitcoins from
an ATM and um also to dispense cash from
ATMs with you know from Bitcoin to cash
and vice versa and also also at the
point of sale terminals and devices for
um businesses to accept Bitcoin. Super
super easy. Uh, Bruce, that's I think
it's going to be huge. Mhm. I want to
say that, you know, it's all there's
always the possibility there that there
can be over speculation because of this
show and the people that are uh in in
the in the community um can I mean it's
there's always the foreseeable
possibility that there that there's a
kind of a confirmation loop, a kind of a
yes confirmation bias and they and they
might over speculate the the the value
of of bitcoins.
Um but then the But likewise, there's
always a possibility that such a popular
show like The Good Wife is just going to
open an entire new community of people
that are going to get interested and uh
start investing in in Bitcoin. So, it's
it's interesting to ultimately it's
going to explode. Oh, well, I know I you
I I think you've made some predictions,
right? What you're saying
you made some I think what I was what I
was saying was that Sorry, there's a
little delay. What I was going to say is
that I'm telling my friends I mean this
like um if you're going to buy Bitcoin
anytime soon, buy it before Sunday. Um
if you're I would not buy it necessarily
next week because everyone's going to be
buying it next week and you're going to
get caught by that speculators uh little
it's not a bubble, but it's like a
little bubble. It's going to it'll it's
going to go up and it'll come back down
a bit. It'll correct later. So if you're
going to buy it as an investment, buy it
and hold it for at least a year and you
can't go wrong. As long as you buy it
and hold it for a year, you really can't
go wrong. But if you're gonna buy it in
the next few weeks, definitely buy it
before Sunday.
Right. Right. Especially if you're
trying to do some some quick investing.
Yeah. It seems it seems like that's
because I mean it could go up to it
could go up to $70 a bitcoin next week
and then come back down to to 10. If it
goes up if it goes up to 70, I'm
definitely pulling out.
And it's gone. Yeah. Well, it's all
about timing, isn't it? Well, I was
telling you uh when we met that I was uh
I I made I made the decision to pull out
at 30. Okay. I was like, "This is this
is good." And I sent all my money to I
This is This is a true story. I sent my
money to Mount Gaus and uh it did it
Mount Gaus did not like give me a
confirmation that they had my money yet.
So, I had a birthday party to go to in
Brooklyn. And so I left my house and I
just left my computer and then uh the
next day it it went from 30 to 20 and I
was like I was like it's going to I I
thought it's going to go back up one
more time and then the I went to Vegas
where you are now Bruce and the the
Mount Gawk scandal
happened the the hacking the hacking
scandal there was a hacking scandal it
caused a lot of uh like
uncertainty in the fun when it doubles
but when it cuts in It's not so much
fun,
right? So, so I'm still holding on to my
bitcoins. Uh, and uh, but that's the
thing, you know, hold on to them because
the thing is if you bought them at at
uh, when you bought them at 30, even if
people bought them at 30, if it goes up
to 70, if it goes up to 100 by the end
of the year, it's still a great
investment even if you bought it at 30,
right? You have to hold on to it for a
year, right? And try not to buy at the
level, of course. I I actually my show
on YouTube, which is Praxgirl, P R A X G
I R L, where we talk about the science
of praxiology, we only accept Bitcoin
donations right now. Although there's
people that are really pushing us to
accept like PayPal donations and other
things like that, but uh we only accept
Bitcoin donations. So, I haven't cashed
in any of those donations.
Yes, that's great. You should you got to
hold on to them. By the way, I'm a big
fan of Frack Girl. I love it. I just
discovered it the other day because I
was uh you know, we were It's so funny
because we were hanging out with you
know, Dan and uh my friends uh uh Chris
and Fred were like, "Oh yeah, he's on um
uh The Good Wife." And they're like,
"Uh-huh." And then and uh he's he's the
one who created Prax Girl. And they're
like, "Prag girl? Oh my god, Pax
Girl." They weren't even impressed with
The Good Wife, but when they heard you
were you were Prag Girl, you were buying
Frag Girl, they were like real. But uh
yeah, that's an amazing production by
the way. Thank you. And I think it's
great that you accept only Bitcoin. I
think more businesses should do that. It
just really if you want to be a Bitcoin
evangelist, you're not a Bitcoin
evangelist unless you say our business
only accepts Bitcoin. Right. Right.
To get Bitcoin, you know, buy
Bitcoin.com. Right. Right. There's
there's reasons for us to want to only
accept Bitcoin. I mean, a lot of it had
to do with Pragirl herself uh valuing
anonymity.
um you know, she's a she's like an
attractive girl and she gets a lot of
like trolls and stalkers and stuff and
so there's a there's there's a value in
that that you can't really find out
who's behind it. Although although I
mean I'm I'm I'm I'm I'm here. I'm the
creator and all that. Uh but uh I was
going to say that the important thing
that I wanted to say out of this whole
thing is that I think everybody that is
either looking to invest in Bitcoin or
believes in Bitcoin for ideological
reasons or any reason why you're getting
in Bitcoin, it's always to your best
it's always in your best interest to
know as much as possible about what
you're getting involved in. And that's
why you should definitely learn about
the science of praxiology and um
understand what money is. Uh I'm not
claiming bitcoins are money, but they're
um they they are uh definitely a medium
of exchange. So you have to understand
um why do bitcoins have any value at
all? And uh uh you know why is it that
that bitcoins work when all these people
try to put it down and all that? And
mostly it's because the people the
creators of bit of bitcoin if it's one
person or a group of people they figured
out how to
um display property rights in bitcoins.
We can distinguish that a certain
bitcoin belongs to one person as opposed
to another person. this the the the fact
that you can't counterfeit bitcoins is
uh is is the way to show that there is
some sort of property right in the in
the abstraction because really it's just
a bunch of it's a bits bits of
information but that's that's really
what's going
to that's that's what's going to make or
break Bitcoin as long as they you can
enforce property rights uh there's going
to be a a value for it for anonym imity
for ease of use for avoiding taxes for
all these different things. I and it
varies with who wants to get involved.
Um but
uh I ju I just think it's important for
people to really you can never know too
much about what you're getting involved
in. So So it's definitely worth it for
people. If you want to learn about
praxiology, go to PRAGIRL. That's what I
say. Yeah. Go to PRAGirl's channel on
YouTube. Yeah.
What's the Oh, so it's you just go to
YouTube. It's in P R A Xirl RX R. Right.
P R A X G I R L P girl. And that's where
you know we we teach the science of
praxiology and it explains these kind of
things. It's it's really it's the parent
science of
economics. Um it's the logic of all
human action. from it is where you you
understand what what uh what money is
and how it comes to be and why it's
important and all that. And um well I
you know I'm telling you she's educating
me because I thought I didn't know
praxiology from reflexology. I didn't
know what I never heard of it before but
uh I'm getting an education just
watching those and it's so easy. She
makes it so um you know easy to
understand. It's excellent. It's really
really an excellent service to educate
people about that. Yeah, we we just did
our episode on money uh last month. So,
uh we we talk about how money comes to
be and why it's important. And uh our
last episode, which uh actually came out
on Monday, we talk about economic
calculation and what that is. And money
serves as a common denominator that
allows you to really determine
uh your the this the stat this the state
that you're in uh as to whether you're
going to be able to achieve an end or
not. Uh that sounds a little a little
complicated, but it's not. It's it's
just all it means is that if you're in a
barter economy, you have to determine
the value of something
uh as opposed to what you're what you
want to trade for it. So you so if
someone has oranges and you have an
apple, you have to value the orange more
than the apple. Uh and you have to
perform this type of valuation with
every single thing that you want to
trade. Money just removes that. Uh so
something like Bitcoin if it were to be
the predominant medium of exchange in a
society an online society for example uh
it allows people to do to to to
basically do accounting ledgers and you
can add and subtract and multiply and
divide one good which is Bitcoin against
all the other goods you want to buy.
It's very simple. This is it's we we
think in these terms all the time with
money. That's the definition of money,
right? I mean, we do this all the time,
right? We we say, well, how much money
do I have in my pocket and what am I
going to be able to do with that money?
And it just eliminates it allows a human
being to think in a certain mode that is
not possible under barter. And so,
that's that's like what we try to talk
about. So, exactly. Yeah. So, I mean,
barter Yeah. barter people bring it up
all the time and it's an excellent
concept, but really money is just an
intermediary
essentially. Right.
Yeah. It's essentially it's still
barter. The only thing is that now
there's this common good that we all
that we all trade every we we all agreed
upon it, right? Well, the it's not it's
doesn't come about like through a
central planner. That's what that's
what's so interesting about Bitcoin.
It's like Oh, I meant uh USD. I meant
USD. Well, yeah, USD. But but you have
to understand the history of why USD
still has value. This is this is a
concept that we have called the money
regression theory. We have to understand
how is it that pieces of paper that
aren't backed by anything, how is it
that people still accept them for
payment for real goods and services. And
what you find is that that actually uh I
think I have one in my pocket here. You
find that once upon a time
uh they were backed by this, right? So
every every dollar was actually the the
piece of paper was a representation of
one of these in the US Treasury, which
is where you're supposed to be from in
the show. And at some point they stopped
redeeming the pieces of paper for this.
But there's a reason why the piece of
paper still has a value because people
were trading it beforehand. Mhm. So this
this is the this is the logic that you
have to understand. And I was going to
say, Bruce, the only reason that we're
not going to cover uh Bitcoin on our
show is because if Bitcoin does turn out
to be some sort of trend that dies off,
because even if Bitcoin is even if
Bitcoin has a real use, it's foreseeable
that some technology could could surpass
and and replace bitcoins. And if Bitcoin
loses value
uh on a massive scale and and goes down
to 1 cent again, uh the the reason that
we don't want to talk about Bitcoin on
our show is
because this this in terms of propaganda
would would be seen as a as a as a win
for the people that talk badly about
Bitcoin and a lose for everyone that
supports Bitcoin. So, we don't want to
get into that kind of game and we don't
talk about Bitcoin. um aside from
accepting donations because it is
possible that that uh the the market can
go in another direction and people are
going to try to use that as some sort of
ad hominemum attack to show that
praxiology uh is not valid or something.
So we don't talk about that but but
nevertheless you can use the practology
is a universal principle a universal
truth regardless of Bitcoin before and
after right so I understand and also
Bitcoin I mean the thing that gives
Bitcoin value besides its functionality
it's it's very very unique properties in
that but but what really gives it value
is just an agreement of people saying I
agree to give it value you agree to give
it value we you know people give it
value by acceptting ing it and saying I
think it's valuable. Yes. And if
everybody changes their mind, which
could happen, anything could happen. Um
that could happen to the US dollar or
the euro in Greece, right? Whatever, you
know, it could happen to anything. Yeah.
Everybody suddenly uh it lost favor then
of course value would go to nothing.
Well, what we try to say
is um as opposed to people that talk
about Bitcoin and talk about they use
loaded terms like intrinsic value and
things like that. Uh because a lot of
people that try to dis people that try
to say Bitcoin uh is is worthless. What
they say is Bitcoin has no intrinsic
value. For example, silver has value as
a as a as a good because it's used in
industrial uses and computers and things
like that, right? But they say bitcoins
are just pieces of data and they don't
have any intrinsic value. Well, what we
say is nothing has intrinsic value.
So in a sense when you say people agree
on it, you both you Bruce and and um and
Nick said people agree on it. I think in
a sense that that it does apply. What
that means is that when you act to trade
your dollars for bitcoins, you're
acknowledging in your action that you
value bitcoins. So that's all that's all
that we're that's all that we're that uh
that we're concerned with. People are
val people are appreciating the val the
market value of bitcoins through their
actions. People are buying and trading
bitcoins and they're using it to buy
market uh market, you know, goods and
services. I play poker with bitcoins cuz
I can't play poker online with real uh
with I was going to say real money with
dollars anymore. Uh cuz the Obama
administration shut that down. I was I
was really into it. I really like
playing. I was too. Oh, are you online
pok Full Tilt? Uh, back in the day.
Yeah, all of them. Full Tilt, Party
Poker, Poker Stars. Yeah, that's I love
I love that. I love that. So, I can't do
that anymore, but I can do it with
Bitcoin. It's interesting. Yeah. Don't
tell me that. I don't want to know. Let
me intrinsic value. Yeah. Let me pass
you to Nick, though, because I've talked
too long. Okay. Okay. No, I was just
going to say about intrinsic value that
Yeah, I don't buy that at all. I think
that whole argument is garbage
because you know gold has some good
value in industry and silver does and
paper obviously paper can be used to
light a fire in your fireplace and
that's about as good as the US dollar.
You know, that's just all nonsense
because those values uh the intrinsic
value of the substance of the the thing.
Uh yeah, it has some value apparently,
but that has no relation whatsoever to
the value of gold as a store of wealth,
a store of money. So, you know, the same
thing with digital, by the way, the US
dollar is not really paper anyway. Like
99% of all US dollars are just a
fictional digital currency and they're
literally fictional. Well, they just add
more zeros at the Fed and type in more
zeros and they made more dollars. So, if
you want to talk about a fictional
digital currency, it's the US dollar for
sure. Um, Bitcoin at least has cryp, you
know, state cryptography behind it that
people cannot print more just because
they feel like it. So, you know, money
is, you know, money could be uh, you
know, clamshells. That's where that
term, you know, clams comes from. It
could be anything that we all say,
"Yeah, there's only so much of this and
let's let's call it money. Let's treat
it like money." You treat it like money,
it's money, like a word. Have you used
the word enough? Well, I I Yeah, I I do
want to say one thing about that,
though. It's it's not as though Bitcoin
could have been money because Satoshi
decided that it was money. The it the
when something becomes money is really
up to historians to look back at because
it's not easily definable. like uh you
know there's a lot of historians that
try to say that there was no money in
certain societies of the past but then
um uh historians that apply what I
consider to be proper economic theory uh
are able to identify that things that uh
wither away that we can't find anymore
must have been money because of
the size of the markets that that we can
see existed in in in this society. So
what I mean to say
is logically bitcoins must have had
value to people for some other use
before they became money. If in fact
they are money, they must have had some
other use. And what I believe that use
was is a facilitator of of of exchange
through primarily anonymous means. I
think that was the real
um that I think that's the real
interest. It becomes money once people
once once the society treats it like
money because what happens is uh rather
than being traded for 1 cent uh at some
point it gets the the value gets
appreciated in like this kind of
snowball effect because even people that
didn't want to use bitcoins before and
saw no value in the anonymity start to
value it simply because enough people
are using it as a medium of exchange.
So all all I'm trying to say is that
it's not money from the get- go. And
it's possible and I I wouldn't say
whether bitcoins are money now or not,
but it's possible
uh that at some point they became money.
Uh but I don't know. But the point is in
the last two
years people have started to use this
this device in order to buy goods and
services. sometimes illegal services,
drugs and things like that. Yeah. But
uh it's not really up it's not really
it's not Satoshi's decision or our
decision when it becomes money. It
becomes
money when the society treats it like
money and societies I mean that's that's
kind of a difficult term to to define as
well but but but but that's I don't
really care whether it's money or not.
All I care about is will it achieve will
it help me achieve my end. If my end is
to buy acid from on Silk Road, then
that's I need bitcoins, you know, that's
no seriously. Silk Road is this website.
It's like the Amazon.com of drugs. Okay.
And uh and you can you can buy illegal
drugs there using bitcoins. Wow. You
know, it's on this uh secret internet or
whatever. But but I mean I'm just the
thing is I mean that's yeah that's
definitely one use case and that's
obviously one that's uh very uh widely
reported but there's there's also see
like Google uh Google wallet I mean
everybody is going for a better form
factor for money um in day-to-day
spending everywhere I mean the the uh
subway fair or whatever restaurants and
you know hair salons and whatever it is.
So if I my my thing is I I believe that
I mean By definition, my definition,
Bitcoin is money already because I know
that I can go I can now get I go to see
a massage therapist and I can go to
lunch and at dinner and I can spend with
Bitcoin and I can also get cash readily
with Bitcoin too. So, it's it it's
already become money in my world at
least. Um, and we're uh a lot of our
initiatives are setting up all kinds of
brick and brick andmortar businesses to
accept it like every type CPAs, makeup
artists, you know, you name it. vitamin
stores. I mean, absolutely every kind of
business all throughout Manhattan and
throughout the world. Um, so as that
spreads and our point of sale systems
become better, I think it's going to
happen like literally like wildfire,
you're going to see that, wow, this is
even easier and better than Google
Wallet or any of these other
initiatives. And it's really funny. I
mean the the other thing is that the um
you know back in the old days when they
would literally travel down the the
trade routes like the road and they
would carry bags of gold and silver um
somebody discovered that the uh you know
the goldsmith's note on paper was a lot
better form factor. So from a technology
standpoint carrying paper was much
preferable to carrying bags of gold. So
this is the same thing. It's sometimes
the technology itself, the fact that
it's it's uh you know as anonymous as
you want it to be and it's instantaneous
and it's zero fees and all that. It's
just the technology that's going to win
and the form factor of it. So the by and
also the fact that it's decentralized,
not issued by anybody and it can't be um
you know uh they can't create more of it
just at a on a whim. That's true, Bruce.
because of those issues.
I I was going to say, but gold has the
same
um qualities to it. And in a in a
Well, I was going to say that in a you
can't give me a million of a bitcoin. I
mean, of gold. Well, I I can if I have a
an interface provided to me by some bank
in a in a libertarian society uh where
there's no, you know, if there's no
government, I can essentially do the
same thing with gold. You know, I can do
e- gold exchanges and things like that.
But it's got to be decentralized. It's
still it's still centralized. So people
would view it as preferable, but it's
not there's no authority that could be
corrupted, you know. Well, yeah. I'm and
that's why that's why I put the that's
why I put the the um the qualification
that this would have to happen in a in a
world where there's no government that I
as long as there's a government I see
that something like a Bitcoin technology
will have some sort of value to people.
But I'm just saying that in a in a in an
anarchist society I I don't think
Bitcoin would last very long. I think
that it would it would start to lose its
its value pretty quickly because you can
do the same thing with
gold and uh and gold's been money much
longer if than
Bitcoin. So people trust gold. Yeah.
Well, I mean I don't know gold you can't
do the same thing with gold. You can
only do the same thing with a
representation of like a digital
currency that's backed by gold and then
controlled by a central authority. So,
you know, yeah, I mean, it's people,
well, it's not it's not a central author
a central a central business that a
warehouse that holds your holds your
gold for you.
But there's a there's a it's called
money that exists now, not without a
government. But, but look, but Bruce,
you you kept your you kept your bitcoins
in my Bitcoin and you lost them all. you
were you were using a service to protect
your bitcoins just like people with gold
use banks to protect their gold, you
know. So, there's definitely a value in
having that. Doesn't matter what society
you're living in. I'm I'm just making
the case that in a world without
government, they that that bitcoins
wouldn't have any value. And that's just
to let everybody that that's an investor
know that's really the way you can gauge
what's what's the future of Bitcoin is
how tyrannical is your government
getting. You know is are are they
raising your taxes beyond the the point
of of no return then then Bitcoin will
continuously go up. But if if the
government's collapsing because of you
know debt ceilings and stuff and they
start to pull austerity measures and
destroy you know destroy part big parts
of the government and and liberalize
their their uh society then maybe
bitcoins go down you know uh then
they start you know you know if they
remove regulations on gold then suddenly
everyone will switch to gold. I don't
know. It's the job of the It's the job
of people like you, Bruce, who are
entrepreneurs to put your money where
your mouth is and and and tell us what's
going to show show us by example what's
going to be the uh the thing that makes
everybody money. But hey, let me let me
pass you to Nick.
I I keep I keep
I talking too much. I've tied. Nick is
the guy. Look, Nick is the guy on the on
the commercial. He's the one that
arrests Jason Bigs or detains him or
whatever. Yeah, you know.
Wait a minute. Can you hold the mic a
little closer because I couldn't hear
you. I just I just said Nick is the guy
on the commercial that puts his hands on
Jason Biggs and takes him away.
Oh, okay.
Yes. Yes, I can see him doing that.
Yeah, that's the tyrannical government.
Exactly.
One thought about the one one other
thought about the uh the idea. I mean if
if there were no government and we were
in an anarchist society and u we had uh
companies there would be a private
company that would warehouse gold. I
mean basically they're operating the
same as gold money. But I I disagree
with one thing you said and that is that
that Bitcoin would have no value because
in my opinion um Bitcoin is still
superior because you don't need any gold
and you don't need any warehouse and you
don't need to trust any company with a
back with a warehouse of gold. It isn't
going to just uh you know load up the
trucks and disappear in the night. You
can protect your your own Bitcoin. I
mean now obviously I've learned the hard
way. Lots of people have. But you there
you can protect your own gold. You can
predict your own Bitcoin. Easier than
predicting your own gold. I think a lot
easier to predict the Bitcoin digits. Uh
I I think Bitcoin is open the same
vulnerability as as gold. I mean, you
still have to I mean, if let's say you
print your bitcoins out on a piece of
paper and then put it in a safety
deposit box or in a in in a safe in your
house, it can be broken into just like
if you put gold in that safe, you know?
I mean, it has Yeah. But there's other
ways too, like you can you can encrypt
it in a patent and email it to
Switzerland, you know, or something and
you can literally leave the country
without a stitch of clothing and you
still have your bitcoins. You can't do
that with gold. You you have to
physically move uh a metal which is very
heavy. So, there's pros and cons. You
know, that's true. It'll it'll work its
way out. Yeah. Either way, I mean, I
think they're both good. I think they're
they're for their purposes, they're
they're different. Um, obviously you
can't get there any actual gold around
to go to lunch and, you know, shop uh in
the main street stores. Um, but but
anyway, they there's there are pros and
cons, but it's evolving. I think that
definitely gold, silver, and bitcoin are
um the future for sure. I think people
are just tired of the uh the banks and
especially the banks and the government.
You know, I pointed out that uh in
China, the government owns the banks and
in the
US the bank either way, it's basically
the same thing. They're in bed with each
other and people are fed up with it.
Uh I I hear what I hear what you're
saying. Ask uh
uh but you should ask Nick uh what what
uh how they trained him to be a
government agent because that's the real
question. Oh yeah, that's a great
question, Nick. Well, they didn't How do
they tell you?
They uh you know, they they kind of just
trusted me to to to do my own thing.
They didn't really give me any training
other than the uh the costume. The
costume was pretty um pretty great. And
I have this really long overcoat and a
really nice tie and it really, you know,
put me in the I even had a badge. It was
great.
But
you have a real government agents don't
dress so well probably, you know. I I
don't know. I think that if I were a
government agent, I would look like
that.
We We even had pieces apparently.
Apparently, we were we were supposed to
have guns, but never got to use them. I
I guess our We were always wearing our
overcoats, so they just never really
gave them to us. We were armed.
Interesting. Supposed to be armed.
What is the Treasury? You were supposed
to be a Treasury Department agent of
some sort or FBI or Federal Treasury?
Yeah, federal treasury. Not FBI, though.
No. Treasury. I wonder if the Treasury
even has their own law enforcement
people. I don't know. I doubt it. Well,
if uh Interesting. If you know, Mr.
Bitcoin starts to show his face, then,
you know, we'll pop out.
Yeah. It probably be the FBI or the CIA.
Yeah. Or NSA or something like that.
or they'll just give me a call too. I
mean, you know, after Sunday hopefully
hopefully people will realize we'll come
to the senses and just call me.
Yeah, that's
right. They can call you anytime we need
to find Mr. So, did you research about
Satoshi and you you know the whole
mythology about who this guy is? Yeah, a
little bit. I mean, I think that um
well, I actually I I I don't want to get
too much into the episode. I don't want
to give anything away. Um, but I I did a
a little bit, but you know,
um, but not not a ton. No, you know that
that it seems though that like the
episode is inspired by the the New
Yorker article. Um, maybe it's inspired
by something else. I'm trying to think
of I know that article. There was a New
Yorker article where this guy goes to a
convention and tries to find Mr.
Bitcoin,
a reporter. Yeah, I think that that it
may be based on that a little bit. It's
it's a the episode there is a scene
where um it's in a convention and I was
there. It's in Chicago and um
you actually may or may not I know see
uh you may actually meet the guy that
created it. You may not though. I don't
want to I'm not going to
say it. Leave it in the air.
You know, one of the things we were the
Bitcoin community was really intrigued
with was that they in the little
synopsis, they called it a uh an illegal
cryptocurrency. Like as if having a
creating a currency was illegal, which
it nobody has claimed that it's illegal
in the US or UK, right? I guess I guess
in this world, you know, this this
slightly fictionalized world, it's
illegal. Um, yeah, there was a there was
a senator that was calling to make it
officially illegal, Chuck Schumer. Okay.
Yeah. Um, he Okay, so you heard that one
guy. Mhm.
Yeah. So, who are the writers that wrote
this to come up with these stories? You
know, they they I I don't know. I' I've
never met the writers. Um, but I know
that they are basically always working.
I know that. Did they change the script
while you were at They did. We got
script changes every day. Um, and I'm,
you know, I'm under the impression that
that's just always happening and it's
just the way it goes because they're,
um, constantly in need of adjustments.
Uh, whether it be just
for a location situation or um, a line
adjustment or the fact that this
character is not in the scene anymore,
so they need to take out lines or
whatever it is. But they are always
always working and
Yeah, they they don't get a break.
Fascinating. They're really on the
cutting edge of uh what's happening.
They must be scouring the news to find
uh stories like this. Yeah, we got kudos
to them for finding these hot stories.
Absolutely. Um Yeah. So, I guess we got
to wrap it up here, Bruce. Yeah. Yeah.
It's time, isn't it? I I'm I I'm not I
don't have my time clocked here because
I'm all remote on the phone and
everything, but um in spite of our
technical glitches, I'm so appreciative
of you guys uh taking the time to join
us uh before this episode airs on
Sunday. I really appreciate you coming
into the studio. No problem. No problem.
Thanks for having us.
All right. Yeah. We we'll follow up
afterwards and see in the wrath of what
happens the
week of uh the Bitcoin for Nummies
episode. So uh be sure everybody watch
on CBS the good wife. The good wife.
Everybody already watches. They already
know. But it's Sunday night 9:00
Eastern. You're going to watch episode
which Oh yeah, I'll be watching it
anyway. Everybody will. I I guess that
on YouTube go to Frack Girl. It's P R
Agirl. Practical on YouTube. Check that
out. Science of praxiology. Yeah,
praxiology. Yeah, you'll learn all about
things you never knew you needed to
know. Well, thanks so much, Nick.
Nicholas Flower Flower Taylor again. So
appreciate it. We're going to do this
again. Thank you so much.
Take care. I'll see you when I get back
to New York.
Bye.
[Music]
Heat. Heat.
[Music]