Video summary
The video provides a comprehensive reaction and review of the 2020 Hindi film *Thappad*, focusing on its powerful exploration of domestic violence and patriarchal structures within Indian society. The reviewers praise the movie for using the singular event of a slap as a catalyst to examine broader issues regarding women's rights, which are noted to be prevalent not only in India but globally. They highlight how the film effectively challenges the normalization of abuse by showing how victims, including mothers and daughters, often perpetuate these harmful traditions under the guise of culture or family honor, thereby holding a mirror to societal flaws that need urgent change.
The discussion delves into the exceptional writing and performances, particularly commending Taapsee Pannu's portrayal of a woman who refuses to accept domestic violence as inevitable. The reviewers appreciate how the narrative weaves multiple storylines together without becoming convoluted, covering the perspectives of the husband, his abusive brother-in-law, the house helper, and even the father who struggles with his own complicity in silence. Specific scenes are highlighted for their emotional impact, such as the intense confrontation where the wife refuses to pretend her husband didn't admit to slapping her, and the poignant moment where a child asks if her father hit her mother, illustrating how generational trauma must be broken by at least one person.
However, the reviewers also express differing opinions on the film's ending, with some feeling that the decision for the couple to separate was necessary given the husband's lack of genuine repentance and his history of abuse. While they acknowledge the symbolic nature of his eventual realization after losing everything, many argue that true change requires more than just a momentary epiphany, especially when it comes to narcissistic behavior. The conversation touches on the difficulty of forgiving deep-seated abuse and the importance of not wrapping such serious issues in a neat bow, even if there is hope for personal growth through extreme consequences like losing one's job or facing legal repercussions.
Overall, the video concludes with strong recommendations for *Thappad* as a must-watch film that addresses critical social issues with nuance and depth. The reviewers encourage viewers to seek out more original content from the Hindi industry that tackles important societal topics rather than relying on formulaic storytelling. They also discuss Taapsee Pannu's upcoming projects, noting her consistent ability to deliver believable performances in complex roles. The segment ends with an invitation for the audience to share their thoughts on the film and suggest future movies or actors they would like to see covered, emphasizing the community aspect of their YouTube channel.
Read the full video transcript
[music]
You saw us on YouTube
version of this another film
probably go check that out and at the
end of this part we will talk about the
movie and review it. Okay, let's finish
this movie. Huh? Obama out. You've been
fapped.
You deserve better
a lot.
You were there for her when I wasn't.
I'm sorry for letting you down. I need
to reboot. You know, I need to become
someone better, someone who deserves
you.
>> That's all they need.
>> True repentance.
>> [music]
>> No privileges of being your wife,
his daughter-in-law.
I'm leaving.
You were right.
>> Yeah, I was with you for the wrong
reasons.
You be
good.
more.
>> Man, I hope they didn't have to do
multiple takes on that.
It's very tough.
Good plan. [laughter]
hospital.
for
Sir.
I was the first word he said. [laughter]
>> I messed up
and I never apologized to you actually.
>> Oh, it was blatantly obvious.
Sorry.
We know.
>> I'm sorry for it all.
Truly am
about time.
Hamstead job everything.
[music]
That's great.
>> I get you.
>> Yeah, that got me.
>> Yes.
Ah, you're hitting all the right
buttons.
Of course she's doing that.
Wow, [snorts]
[sighs]
that was great. It made me so mad.
>> Yeah, it's that's great. It was It was
It was a That's
It was excellent, but it's also
exceptional in many ways. And it What
year was this film?
>> 2020.
>> Okay. Yeah, we need we need the Hindi
industry to make more films like this.
They may be doing it and we're just not
catching wind of it. But original
content that has a wonderful message
that's saying something that's important
about society, it's a it's a gold with a
blue diamond for me. I put the medals
on, but Corbin hates me and he threw
them away.
>> I'm telling you, I think they're
>> they're not I know. I looked. They're
not under the chair. Who know? I don't
know where they are. Uh but it's it's a
>> in your chair.
>> No, like right here.
>> Yeah. No, like in here in the
>> No,
bro. I did not put them anywhere.
>> I'm sure you did in the two months I was
gone. But it's not a big deal. It's all
right.
>> I'm telling you, they're in here. I
wouldn't touch them.
>> They're they're probably back there
behind everything.
>> No, there's nothing back there.
>> But uh Yeah. No, they're not they're not
anywhere around here. I promise you.
>> And I don't know where they are. I had
kept them down in the seat, but when you
had Valerie or you had Alexis or
whoever,
>> they're gone. Uh I'll be doing some
cleaning up. It was it was uh
I thought it was exceptional
primarily because of the subject matter.
>> Oh yeah.
>> Uh just we need more films that talk
about important issues in society that
hold up a mirror to it and need to be
changed and that's this is one of them.
>> Yeah.
>> Uh
>> and uh I I love I fantastic uh movie.
I've heard about it for a long time.
People have wanted to watch it for a
long time. I'm sorry for just getting
into it now. Um,
I like that. Obviously on the surface
it's called I think the slap I think is
what it translates to, right?
>> Or slapped or the slap. Yeah.
>> And obviously that's an important aspect
of the movie
>> because in all cultures but in India
specifically it's obviously a very
prevalent issue that especially that
style of domestic violence. Right.
>> Correct.
>> Not the only place. It's prevalent here
as well unfortunately. Um but it's like
a very especially personal for India
because of like how rooted it is in you
know it's a family issue kind of kind of
that kind of stuff but that's not the
primarily thing I feel like about the
movie.
>> It's everything else.
>> It's that was allowed based off of
correct the patriarchal system furthered
by people that were um victims of the
patriarchal system. Correct. the
mothers, the the the daughters, the the
grandparents that further even though
obviously they were victims of the
patriarchy, but they still further along
it because of you know that's how they
were brought up. Um even though even
though they're right in a way, you're
still an adult and you're still
perpetuating something that you know is
wrong
>> in the name of culture or the name of
tradition or the name of whatever it is.
You're still perpetuating this thing.
that monologue of when she was on her
knees and her mother-in-law's feet there
was so brilliantly written and performed
by Tapsi and uh um as well the the
>> yeah everyone listening was very
believable
>> um and everybody's viewpoints was so
like you're like oh yeah I've heard
people make that like the brother and
the the brother who's like even though
like he didn't hit but he was justifying
everything in the name of so his sister
wouldn't go through a nasty divorce,
>> right?
>> Like you like even that aspect of like
furthering like and and um um what is
it? Uh being okay with what he did to
her in the name of her life being
easier,
>> right?
>> Um but I thought that it was brilliant.
Yeah. I like you said the slap is a
singular event that is the door opening
to what the totality of the film was
about which is just women's rights in
general.
>> Yeah.
>> Uh and and why they are the way they are
and it isn't just an Indian thing. This
happens all over the world but it is
very much part of Indian culture. And
it's always amazed me uh especially
you know how many men in India will you
know they'll be walking down the street
and stop at a shrine and take a moment
to worship a deity like Lakshmi or Durga
or you know you name the hundreds of
feminine deities but then they'll go
home and slap their wife
>> and and for a culture that so venerates
the divine feminine that consistently
has atrocities happen to women. It's
something that absolutely needs to not
just be addressed. It needs to be it
needs to be changed. And I loved Oh,
man. I loved the little buttons at the
end of, you know, the husband's the one
who cares about his wife's blood sugar
and him getting her the the music to
sing again. and just um it's also about
just relationally
making sure you you stay paying
attention to each other and don't just
get locked into the mundane of the day.
And it covers a lot of ground. It's
really well written for the amount of
subjects that they cover and the number
of story lines cuz we've got our main
story with Topsy and her husband.
>> We've got her brother. We've got uh his
uh house uh worker who's being abused by
her husband. We have the attorney. Yeah.
>> That it could have gotten really
convoluted, but it stayed. I mean, it
just stayed steady at the helm.
>> Yeah. And like there was
>> very well written.
>> Very well written. I agree. And like
there's like all those other subplots of
like Tapsy's father and mother's
relationship.
>> Yeah. and how
you thought in the beginning obviously
you're like oh he didn't say anything
that's wrong obviously he definitely
should have stuck up for his daughter
>> and then for him to make another
realization of like I haven't been
paying attention like I should even to
my wife and I thought I was a good
>> and I thought I was a good husband
[laughter] he's a good husband he made a
mistake he just he's a human being he
made a mistake
>> it's just opening your eyes to other
people's perspectives
>> right um and what they have done and the
things that they've sacrificed that you
haven't appreciated that they kind of
sacrif or that you lost sight of that
you allowed them to um you know not
follow the dreams or be happy or like as
happy as they could be maybe. Yeah.
>> Um and you know following their passions
and that kind of thing.
>> Um I thought that was a beautiful little
subplot. Obviously him giving her the
thing at the end was is is really good.
But yeah, showing all those different
perspectives
>> of, you know, everybody saw her get
slapped
>> and not a soul did a thing.
>> Correct.
>> And so the perpetuation of allowing that
to happen.
>> Yeah. Um,
and the really strong, there were a lot
of really strong subtle messagings
like putting the money down. I'm not
going to take the money. Another one
that's really powerful that can just be
overlooked, but it's really strong is
when the daughter's laying on the lap
and said, "Did dad hit you?"
>> Yeah.
>> And the understanding of this has been
passed down for generations and it's got
to change with one of us. just very
strong messaging. I thought the cast was
uniformally wonderful.
>> Yeah,
>> everyone was believable.
>> And it was another great scene was when
um
uh the husband came and he was like, I
might need you to tell the court that I
didn't happen like I didn't slap her.
Yeah.
>> And she's like in front of her daughter.
No less.
>> Right.
>> She's like, I'm going to need to pretend
like you didn't just say that to me
right now
>> cuz I want to have an ounce of respect
for you still.
>> Right. [laughter]
>> Yeah. And no, absolutely not. Um, but
yeah, I thought it was really well
written. Um, and uh, I'm sure it got um,
touted as like a woke movie, of course,
back in the when it came out. I'm sure,
>> especially by the men.
>> Yeah.
>> Um,
and all the people that are, you know,
just trying to justify it. Um, but I
thought it was it was really beautiful.
The writing is so wonderful. really
great writing
>> and it's performed really I loved the
the house helper
>> uh her name I thought she did a
phenomenal job
>> that one scene where she has with him
with her slapping each other and she's
like kill me kill me that was tough and
that was really believable
>> really well done well shot too they kept
us so many choices by the DP and the
director together who you know you know
unless you're there on the day you don't
know who made the final decision on the
shot but that scene having it be so
close we're not just over his shoulder
were right there and they just kept it
that way. Just makes it that you cannot
you're forced you cannot look away and
it makes the intensity that much more
dramatic. Really wonderful shot choices.
Really the score I thought was beautiful
to continue the tone and the messaging
of the film.
>> I agree. Um yeah and uh another
uh of the elements that I didn't I was
worried for in the end was when he was
like I quit my job next time I'm going
to be worthy of you. Didn't like it at
all. Um thankfully they then were like
that's symbolic. They're going in
different directions. Correct.
Obviously.
>> Yeah. The car is going in different
directions. Yeah. They then if you write
your own ending they don't get back
together. Yeah. Yeah. Um but I still
didn't like it. Uh he was given a
thousand chances. He didn't need one
more. Um that's who that man is. He was
given a billion chances to say
otherwise. And he he showed who he was.
>> I I like and you know me, the optimist.
I like the the hopeful optimistic
reality cuz it does happen where someone
does finally realize what they did was
wrong. And it doesn't mean that that
everything gets to go back to being
right. And I think for someone I I don't
think that she I think he changed. I
think the person that she fell in love
with. Um, I I I think he became more and
more selfish and more and more things
that he had been raised in that were
rooted and grounded in him came out and
that I would like to hope and the
writing conveyed it that he realized
what he did was I would have loved to
have seen him cry and actually shed some
tears over what he had done. Uh, but I
did like that they didn't try to I was
saying please don't wrap this up in a
bow and let them be together again.
>> I do appreciate his repentance but they
do need to go separate ways. But yeah,
repentance after how many how many
months?
>> Yeah. What's the timeline?
>> And how many how many opportunities?
>> I understand, but what is the timeline
on repentance? When does it expire?
>> Immediately. No, no, that's graceless. I
I'm I'm [laughter]
>> not a very graceful person.
>> I know. If somebody
>> I'm not a very genuine genuine
repentance uh is is important and it can
happen. It doesn't always happen at all.
>> Genuine repentance after you've lost
everything. It's it's that's just you're
going to go back to the way that you
were. I feel sorry for your next wife
because [laughter] you're you're a [ __ ]
narcissist.
>> No, I'd like to hope he learned his
lesson.
>> Hope all you want. It's not the reality.
It's a [ __ ] [ __ ] and deserves
death.
>> Uh [laughter] good.
>> I don't I He was gi his one chance was
immediately after being like I am so
sorry. The the the anger got the best of
me. That was his one chance. If Corbin
was a judge, no one would get decrease
time for good behavior. God damn right.
>> No one.
>> Goddamn right.
>> Well, it depends on what it's for.
[snorts]
[laughter]
>> It depends on what it's for.
>> I am not a forgiving person.
>> Uh well, here's the thing. I I
>> I can forgive you.
Well, maybe not in the real sense of the
word. Uh but I definitely will not be
forgetting ever.
It's always there. [laughter]
Especially with this [ __ ] [snorts] when
you're when you're a [ __ ] narcissist
and obviously abusive. That's a
completely [snorts]
can't deal with it. Can't deal with it.
And also like the the justification
and the obviousness of never realizing
that you were you are the problem.
>> But he does at the end after he lost
everything.
>> Yeah. That that often times that's what
after he was going to go to jail. Well,
often times that's the extreme someone
has to go to.
>> You're a [ __ ] adult. But
>> you're aing adult.
>> But sometimes someone needs to go to the
extreme to finally realize that what
they've done is right.
>> Why? Because he's a child.
>> It's it's Paul on the road to Damascus.
It wasn't until he was blind and
realized what he had done was wrong,
that he had a repentance. God, it sucked
to be a idiot. Um, [laughter] you know,
couldn't be me. [ __ ] that guy. I hate
him so much. Um, great job. It was
lovely to see Tapsi again, though.
>> Yeah, I miss watching her. She's such a
She's such a believable good and this is
a great role for her.
>> She plays these types of characters uh
so believably and I'm you root for her.
>> One of her best roles and she's had a
lot of great roles.
>> What's What's coming up for Topsy?
And why haven't we seen much of what
she's been
>> uh a lot of it either didn't do well or
>> I guess cuz Dunkey was the last thing.
>> Um but [snorts]
>> she's got quite a few credits that she's
done in the last four or five years.
>> Um
>> I guess they just weren't received well.
>> She's doing Alien. [laughter]
>> Gandhar
>> Gandhari is in post production according
to IMDb
>> which is her and
that's awesome. Haven't seen Schwastika
in a hot minute.
>> That looks like an intense kind of a
thing. Follows mother to find and rescue
her kidnapped daughter. Um
so it's like taken but uh with mother
>> a mother's rage. Go get her.
>> Go get it.
>> Um but then the guy in the end he's
probably going to repent and we come to
real repentance that he shouldn't have
uh kidnapped that child. And so he'll be
>> and then he works for law enforcement
and helps them catch kidnappers. Yeah.
So hope he could forgive himself.
Ah anyways
uh let us know what you thought about
the movie. If you like if you didn't
like it what your thoughts on it are.
Please if you saw us on YouTube you saw
a very cut version because cap like see
version of this and other Hindi Hindi
films. So you get a patron or turn me
top the link description below to go
check that out. Let us know what our
next Hindi film should be or tapsi as
well that we should do and uh anything
else we need to KNOW DOWN BELOW.
>> [music]