Video summary
Rajiv Ranjan from Michigan State University presented his work on developing Open Educational Resources (OER) textbooks for Hindi and Urdu, addressing the unique challenges faced by less commonly taught languages. He explained that while Hindi and Urdu share the same linguistic roots but differ in script—Urdu being Pakistan's national language versus India having no single national language—the primary hurdle is dispelling the misconception among non-linguists that they are entirely different languages. His project aims to create accessible, online learning materials that function effectively both synchronously and asynchronously, a necessity heightened by the pandemic. The resulting "Basic Urdu" textbook was designed with flexibility in mind, allowing educators to adapt its content for various pedagogical approaches ranging from deductive grammar instruction to communicative immersion, ensuring it serves diverse teaching contexts without being restricted by traditional publishing models or copyright issues.
A significant portion of Rajiv's presentation focused on the nuanced differences between heritage language learners and those learning a foreign language, particularly within South Asian communities in North America. He noted that while heritage speakers often possess vocabulary from their home environment due to cultural exposure like Bollywood movies, they frequently struggle with uninterpretable grammatical features specific to Hindi-Urdu syntax. Unlike Spanish or French programs which have mature gamified tools and structured curricula for beginners, less commonly taught languages lack these resources in higher education settings. Rajiv emphasized the importance of validating students' existing dialects rather than treating them as starting from zero, using representation in literature and media to build confidence while gently correcting fossilized errors through a zone-of-proximal-development approach that balances correction with maintaining learner self-esteem.
The structure of his textbook reflects these pedagogical considerations by integrating script learning early on followed by thematic chapters that combine reading, listening, video content, and cultural notes. To enhance engagement for students who may not have opportunities to study abroad due to travel restrictions or cost, the materials include simulated immersion experiences and interactive H5P tools that allow learners to record audio, drag-and-drop vocabulary into quizzes, and self-evaluate their progress on mobile devices. This gamification element was intentionally added to bring a sense of "coolness" often missing in college-level South Asian language courses, making the learning process more appealing to younger generations who are accustomed to interactive digital environments found in commonly taught languages like Spanish or French.
The impact and reach of these initiatives at Michigan State University have been substantial since their launch, with analytics showing thousands of page views for both the Hindi and Urdu textbooks from teachers across various institutions. Rajiv highlighted how his work is supported by a collaborative network involving grants, university centers such as Asian Studies and Muslim Studies, and mentorship programs like Fulbright Language Teaching Assistantships that produce additional cultural-focused books over time. By advocating for open access resources, he aims to reduce the financial burden on students who might otherwise face high textbook costs while simultaneously addressing the underserved publishing landscape for South Asian languages. Ultimately, his project demonstrates how strategic design, community collaboration, and a focus on learner identity can effectively bridge the gap between heritage speakers and formal language education in an increasingly digital world.
Read the full video transcript
so our next speaker Rajiv ranjan from
Michigan State University
and as we see his talk his topic is
basic Urdu so Rajiv thank you Carl um
thanks for the opportunity uh as you can
see it's another open education resource
textbook and I'm assistant professor at
Michigan State University in linguistics
languages and culture I have a PhD in
second language that Christian and I
teach Hindi and Urdu that's my humble
introduction to my cohorts here a
wonderful presentation man CG and and
those who are listening to uh my
presentation right after Man City you
would see that several of her thoughts
has been Incorporated and where she
divorced from me is talking specifically
about the Heritage language Learners
which in South in South Asian context is
little bit different because it's like
1800 different languages and the
Learners could be cultural heritage
versus linguistic educated so what C is
planning to do is to work on the
linguistic Heritage where my book is
considering Heritage even as a cultural
heritage and stuff like that so there's
a little bit advances for sure
forwarding our field forward so kudos to
one CG so challenges that as I have only
lightning moments and as everybody can
see that you can always approach me and
write to me
um so you know before I move forward
um
I okay I'll send the link of my book
later on and you can also in abstract
you can access the book from the
abstract so the challenge is that I
started this project and this is this
was my second oer project after basic
Hindi and Hindi and Urdu is the same
language with a different script and
little bit when you go to the advanced
level the the context from the Islamic
background and and the vocabulary can
change but grammatical structure and
everything is the same is this India got
divided in 47 in India and Pakistan and
India does not have a national language
whereas Pakistan made Urdu has a
national language and those who are not
linguist or in linguistics training they
do not have this idea that Hindi Urdu is
the same language with two different
script so the challenges that I have
when I thought this project out is that
how
um like the difference teaching
methodology but then I also have to see
who are my audience and the audience was
my Hindi Urdu Learners or Urdu Learners
and Urdu teachers in America who are not
like Spanish and in the morning I saw a
wonderful presentation on Spanish in
group b and how they are promoting more
which is based base work is done
unfortunately for Less commonly taught
languages we are me Mansi and people
like us are developing That Base so bear
with us if our presentation and our
project look very archaic in terms in
comparison with the commonly taught
languages other thing was
um how it could be friendly at
asynchronous and synchronous because
these projects came just right before
the covet pandemic hit so we were in an
aggressive need of the online material
that we are not just scanning things and
putting it there and how does it
approach to the hate is a non-heritage
language Learners I don't want to waste
time on this slide but what really
fascinates me about this definition is
its online learning content software
Tools circumulative digital curricula
and there's no restriction of copyright
but we as the author of these books we
have to go through all this training and
Carl rightly said that the session was
really helpful and I definitely
struggled before this oer uh conferences
for last three years that we are doing
it has been a challenge for the
developers like us
um my journey actually started off oer
in 2016 when I collaborated on a melon
Grant with Sango Kong from University of
Minnesota Sunil Bhatt from British
Columbia myself and lakhan gusa at that
time he was teaching Hindi at Syracuse
and we came up with the Hindi Urdu
intermediate level textbook which is
still available online Link is here
but these are the three solo project
that I did afterwards basic Hindi one
came in 2021 basic Urdu came in 2022 and
we just finished basic person which is
under the copy editing within our MSU
library of oer part of that and they do
the copy editing and check all the
copyrights check all the accessibility
and stuff and hence we have a basic
person which I'm a co-author with my
colleague nahid Siran who teaches
personal language at MSU
when we are thinking about the design
consideration the traditional versus
modern and as I said we are being the
the as a first author of any less
commonly taught languages at least in
Hindi Urdu or South Asian we I had to
think about how modern I could be is my
audience ready for the very modern
approach of language teaching and can
teaching materials interact with the
learner because we are thinking about
online and we all understand that how
the zoom as we are presenting no one's
video is on and everybody is just using
the materials at their home so can the
materials interact with them
um and and can be what should be our
proficiency goal can we gamify the
situation and as a SLS training myself I
understand the importance of
gamification because in school there's
people or the kids learn their Spanish
and French and all the commonly taught
languages they have amazing tools and
all but then they come to college and
try to learn Hindi Urdu or South Asian
languages and that kind of of a coolness
is gone so I wanted to add little bit of
a coolness part in that in in this game
too so what I did I did the mixed
approach and what I believe is a post
pedagogical approach which does not
really Define yourself in one pedagogy
it depends on you can adapt or adopt of
whatever the pedagogical approach the
certain teacher in a certain context
they are so as a author of the book
myself I wanted to be somewhere vague so
that everybody can use a little bit part
of it so that we can have a very solid
foundation
pedagogical approach you can see that
there's a Heritage and non-hate is kind
of a style like top down and bottom up
but in these all kind of Kagan and
Dylan's ideas of 2001 they very smartly
skip the grammar person and in Hindi
Urdu as as Mansi also little bit
suggested about oblique form I wanted to
make it clear that in in a languages
there are interpretable feature which
makes the sense or which adds to the
semantic value of the language and
that's really okay to teach you know in
a very communicative way but if there
are uninterpretable feature which does
not have any semantic value Learners
should go get the fossilized if they are
not taught explicitly or they are not
little bit paid extra attention to those
things so with that in mind I try to
build the book that you can use
deductively or inductively implicitly or
explicitly
um that little bit of a theater
background I came up with the
socio-cultural theory which definitely
is one of proximal development so the
chapter progressed in that way
interactionism that not only between the
speakers and and Learners and teachers
but but between the materials and the
Learners themselves and and hence I
landed up between the social
interactions approach of um as a
theoretical framework of my textbook
the structure is uh there are eight
chapters first chapters begins with the
the script which is non-roman script so
hence it is important for us to kind of
focus on that but two to eight chapters
are based on the different themes and a
sample here you can see that the review
of the previous section and then two to
three readings and a study abroad
because that component component was
really important because due to kovid my
Learners were not going to study abroad
so I wanted to kind of include some some
sort of immersion experience and then
there is a follow-up grammar so if you
are teaching in a different modality you
can start with the grammar and then
expose to the input flooding or you can
have an input flooding and if some
teachers themselves want to clarify some
grammar points or some students really
want to get into the grammar points they
can also
access that part and there was at the
end there was a cultural notes um
you can see some of the pre pre-reading
examples it's literally task based but I
kind of cater p and post reading and
listening and each reading has the video
uh that we have created with the
subtitles and all for the accessibility
and then there is a h5p material that
you can drag and drop and self-evaluate
yourself and this is accessible on a
phone too so you see that this slide
you'll see that there's a whole bunch of
words written there and then there's a
conversational style and this is to kind
of finder in the in the middle somewhere
for the Heritage those who can go top
down and for non-heritage which can go
on which can go bottom up so that kind
of I try to mix and match
um you can see the recording h5p gives
an amazing tools for asking students or
Learners to record and share that with
either the teachers or Advanced learner
or with their kind of language Partners
in in that manner
um I kind of gamified the vocabulary too
you can drag and drop to the true false
and so I kind of because we have less
time I wanna I'm not going much in
details but these are the other topics
that we are working like Advanced
Indonesian with the collaboration of
University of Michigan I finished basic
Hindi basic Kamai I helped my my
colleague and and all these projects I
supervise here at MSU with my uh friend
who is a coordinator of less commonly
taught languages Daniel Schneider we are
working on basic Turkish basic Urdu that
I finished basic who's back we have
basic Vietnamese is is done an
intermediate in intermediate Hindi is
ongoing process
I wanted to share this analytics that
since when I finished basic Urdu you can
see that how many school teachers and
and other universities teachers are
using that and it gives me every week or
every 15 days a kind of analytics on MSU
website and I'm very proud to share that
I have more than uh 497 visitors and
total page view is more than thousand
and and in the same stroke if I can say
Hindi which is the year old now it has
more than 3000 people using this book on
a regular basis
um
I want to acknowledge my oer of MSU team
a senior studies program at MSU my own
little less commonly thought language
program and my department of linguistics
languages and culture
and this is me if you want to talk more
about this project or uh
kind of ask me any question I'm here but
I'll let me share the Urdu book link
here with you also that was my
presentation
thank you I'm open for questions
thank you so I just want to ask people
to write their questions in the chat
and I guess I have a question for
um I guess we have a little bit of time
for both of you yeah Rajiv you were
mentioning
uh the issue of Heritage language
Learners are a little bit different in
South Asia than let's say you you
mentioned Spanish language Learners yeah
um so oftentimes people talk about
Heritage language Learners as
um suffering from a lot of linguistic
insecurity
Muncie did mention of course the many
differences between foreign language
Learners and but is that also is that
the case in both both Urdu and in Hindi
that they have a lot of this kind of
linguistic insecurity
um so let me share my thoughts and Mansi
can add more to that so my understanding
and there is a paper actually written
call on that by uh a wonderful scholar
of South Asia Gabriela Nick at NYU and
uh Surendra gambhir and they kind of
classified Heritage language Learners in
four different parts so one is
linguistic Heritage cultural heritage
and the generational Heritage so um what
kind of demography we have in at least
in Midwest that I can tell I'm at
Midwest
um which could be very different from
the East Coast or West Coast or
elsewhere but demography that we have
that we have Earth there are five main
language family in India and South Asia
and if somebody is coming from the
dravidian language family for example
Tamil Telugu Malayalam kannada speaker
they have no understanding whatsoever
how the indo-aryan languages which Hindi
Urdu Punjabi Gujarati Bengali would work
right so they are cultural heritage but
the Bollywood is the lingua Francais in
many ways so they understand some words
so they are not only like
the the linguistically not confident but
there are also some most of the time
when I when we do the placement test of
course like before we place our student
with the Heritage student and so
typically I'll place them in a second
year or three four weeks they can come
in first year and learn the script and
move on but
um but it's a challenge it's a real
Challenge and given that little is so
small we cannot create like a two
separate stream at the University that
hey we have seven students non-heritage
and seven students in Heritage that will
not be cost effective yeah thank you
yeah um um Rajiv has already
um talked about it mostly but then
um yeah I'll just add a little to it
that um well it very much depends on
like you know what kind of background it
comes from uh which tells how confident
um or in what insecurities they're gonna
have about their languages I definitely
since you know ever since I started
teaching I have taught Heritage track
consistently and then I have students in
my class who are very proud that they
speak uh you know whatever dialect or
variety of language they speak versus
sometimes as students who are not at all
comfortable or like you know they're
they they feel like that the dialect
they speak is not the right one or is
something wrong with it and then they
want to come to the class to learn
foreign to learn the formal language and
um the best way to like in my experience
address that is by giving them
acknowledgment that actually all of it
is still Hindi like whatever dialect or
variety that they may be speaking right
by showing them representation of their
dialect or their variety
um in Bollywood or like in literature
and so on and um and then taking from
there like building on the language we
we're in Heritage track the whole thing
is about building on what they already
have and like starting from where they
already are instead of like you know
um assuming that they all come with like
no knowledge or like similar knowledge
um they do have I mean
if you compare to foreign language
Learners it's very different but then
within themselves they have so much
variety because everyone there could be
some speakers of good like somebody
could be fluent in Gujarati and that's
how they speak some Hindi some could
somebody could be fluent in Punjabi and
that's why they have some Hindi or
somebody could just be fluent in English
but then they have some Hindi from their
parents talking in it so yeah so and
even linguisticated Mansi if I can add
like they are vocabulary wise they're
okay but you will see Punjabi speaker
adding the Hindi sentence and ending the
word with the Punjabi verb to be and and
you you are you're a little bit unsure
like should I correct it like how far we
can do with the zone of proximal
development is the right time to give a
corrective feedback or am I kind of
ruining their confidence of interrupting
them because it is Meaningful so most of
the Heritage to an even linguistic hate
is what they are struggling called is
with the as I said in my presentation is
an interpretable features and my PhD is
on uninterpretable features on on
language acquisition not just on Hindi
but across the world languages like how
can like as a second language learner of
English itself I write things and I and
my wife who is a native English speaker
she corrects me like one thing like your
article the is misplaced you never use
it when it is required and you use it
when it is not required but because we
don't have the idea of of definiteness
Hindi Urdu has idea of a specificity and
which does not have any semantic value
in our language right so those are the
things that Learners at the Heritage
level that language Learners are
definitely struggling yeah
um I have a follow-up question for Rajiv
about
um you've produced a lot of oer so you
you showed a picture a slide of your
different books
um and so I wanted to ask about the
context of Michigan State then because I
know that you also mentioned them you
have a melon Grant
so the first book I had is a melon Grant
but uh
so this is the Hindi book that I wrote
uh I sent a link again this is one year
or one and a half years old so when oer
Library started and I got a grant to
write the Hindi book and then Asian
studies Muslim studies and all those
different centers get really interested
and I was the advocate of less commonly
taught languages and even in this
conference my Arabic colleagues are
presenting in group a right now uh my
Chinese colleague is presenting so three
or four of us from MSU those who are
working on open education resources and
we in many ways we are we are trying to
produce more oer because in Spanish uh
kind of morning session there it is like
I can't remember that but in in one
presentation it was mentioned that how
it is also an outreach program because
Learners are learning language and it's
cost effective they don't have to buy
textbook but in that way we can bring
the coolness too like you know Learners
can say like hey we don't have to spend
eighty dollars or a hundred dollars on
textbook and it is gamified or so in
that way it is like MSU in many ways a
leader and not only that let me add this
at MSU I am also a mentor of Fulbright
language teaching assistant and I have
two all different foreign language
teaching assistant and a project that we
started is uh culture so Hindi culture
and every FLT every year their job is to
kind of write two section for beginner
intermediate and advanced level in on
interactive interpretive interpretive
and
production sort of a theme and at four
or five years we'll have 12 different
book which is just focused on cultural
aspect or on open education resources oh
okay we've got title six so yeah yeah
yeah so Michigan State's On The Rise and
I'm glad that you've been focusing so
much on oer and I think it makes so much
sense obviously for the little context
um that is underserved by publishing
publishing companies yeah thank you for
both vote to both of you
um our next