Submind YouTube summaries
Thumbnail for Rabbi Mizrachi Claims Jesus Father was a ROMAN SOLDIER (Insane!)

Rabbi Mizrachi Claims Jesus Father was a ROMAN SOLDIER (Insane!)

Watch on YouTube

Video summary

The video transcript centers on a critique of a Rabbi named Mizrachi's interpretation of the origins and nature of Jesus Christ. The narrator watches Mizrachi claim that Jesus was not a "mamzer," a term in Jewish law referring to a child born from adultery, because his mother Mary cheated with a Roman soldier rather than a Jew. According to this specific Talmudic tradition cited by the Rabbi, if Mary had been unfaithful to a fellow Jew, both she and her lover would have faced execution, but since the father was a Roman soldier, Jesus is described as being half-Jewish and half-Roman. The narrator expresses skepticism about using these later rabbinic texts and pagan accusations from around 175 AD as historical evidence for the life of Jesus, noting that scholars often view these stories as polemics created centuries after the events to attack Christian virgin birth traditions rather than factual accounts. The narrative further explores Mizrachi's story about a young Jesus being expelled from Rabbi Yehoshua ben Perahya's yeshiva for showing his teacher attractive women on the street, an anecdote the narrator questions as potentially fabricated or misinterpreted scripture. The transcript also touches upon the physical depiction of Jesus, with Mizrachi arguing against the common image of Jesus having long hair like a rock-and-roll star, asserting that such depictions violate Torah laws regarding gender presentation and are likely inventions by later generations who never saw the historical figure. The narrator agrees that many stories about Jesus, particularly those found in the New Testament written largely by Paul, were created three or four generations after his death, meaning the people telling these stories had no direct knowledge of him. A significant portion of the discussion focuses on a quote from Matthew 5:17-19, where Jesus states he came to fulfill the law rather than abolish it and warns that anyone who sets aside even one commandment will be called least in the kingdom of heaven. The narrator uses this passage to argue that if Jesus truly upheld the Torah, then modern Christianity, which often disregards dietary laws like keeping kosher or observing Shabbat, fails to meet his own high standards for righteousness. The video concludes with the narrator agreeing that Mizrachi correctly points out the idolatry inherent in worshipping Jesus as a separate deity, suggesting that according to Jewish law, one can only serve God and not a servant of God, effectively declaring Christianity invalid before it even began based on its own foundational texts.
Read the full video transcript
Anyways, okay, guys. I've been at it for 2 hours already. Let's watch Rabbi Mizrahi. What I actually wanted to see is the story of Jesus. This popped up on my feed and I think it will be very, very interesting to hear the story of Jesus by Rabbi Mizrahi. I mean >> [laughter] >> who else is an authority on this subject if not him? Let's have a look. I'm going to sit right here on Mizrahi's table and be a good student. Let's go, Rabbi. >> [music] >> It's pretty long. >> Mamzer means a married woman cheated on her husband and conceived from another man that is not her husband. Now a baby was born. This baby has a mark on him. Forbidden to marry any Jew besides a mamzeret. A girl that is like him. JC is not a mamzer because his mother cheated with a If a Jewish woman cheated with a although it's a horrible crime with a very big punishment but it's not the kid is not a mamzer. He's only a mamzer if she cheated with a Jew and she and the Jew has a death penalty. The married woman mot yum mot yum too an oif an oifet. It's written in the Torah. Mot yum too. Both of them. So JC is almost a mamzer because his mother cheated with a Roman soldier. You understand? So [laughter] >> Wow, man. Where is he pulling this from? Honestly, this is crazy. This here confirms, of course, what we know from Talmudic Judaism. Talmudic Judaism proclaims that Astaghfirullah, I don't even want to say it, but they proclaim that Mother Mary was a prostitute, was a That's how they word it. And yeah, that she cheated, apparently. So now he gives you the >> [laughter] >> the tafsir for this. Yeah, he tells you that it was actually a Roman soldier. So if she cheated with a Jew because according to them she was Jewish, if she cheated with a Jew then she would have been executed, but because it was a Roman soldier that is a-okay. So according to him, Jesus Christ, JC as he likes to say, is half Jewish and half Roman. Interesting. Let's proceed, dear rabbi. Thank you so much for your wisdom. >> Therefore, he wasn't a mamzer. That's why they accepted him to the Yeshiva of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Perahya. >> Yehoshua ben Perahya. >> he was a teenager >> Teenager. >> the brilliant JC walks on the street with his holy rabbi and he say to him, "Rabbi, look at the pretty women over there." Rabbi say to him, "Where? Where? Where? Right there." Rabbi say [laughter] to him, "You're not embarrassed? Of all the people in the world, you show the pretty women on the street to your own Rosh Yeshiva? You cannot learn in my Yeshiva. You have to learn the modest guy. What is the whole Torah you're learning and you stay like this? You're kicked out." Kicked out. >> Wow, man. I really want to know if this is just pulled out of his ass right now. He's just making it up as he goes. He comes up with a story. Jesus Christ is walking with his rabbi and then he sees some pretty chicks and he goes, "Wow, rabbi, check out those girls, man." Or is this really according to some scripture? I must assume because this guy is a rabbi that he is referring to some sort of scripture here. This must be Talmudic evidence, {quote} {unquote}. You have to do this, too. It cannot be just his opinion. And you know what? I'm going to ChatGPT this real quick. I have to. Yes, you're remembering two different anti-Jesus traditions. Wow, man. >> [laughter] >> And they often get discussed together. This is an important historical caveat. Scholars debate whether every Talmudic Yeshua passage originally referred to Jesus of Nazareth and the chronology in some stories is impossible if read literally. Mary plus Pantera Pandera. The Babylonian Talmud Shabbat 104 B with a parallel in Sanhedrin 67A discusses someone called Ben Stada Ben Pandera. It says in effect that the husband was one man and the lover paramour paramour was Pandera. And it associates the mother with a Miriam Maryam [clears throat] Mary accused through a wordplay of being unfaithful to her husband. >> [snorts] >> Uh, many scholars interpret this as a later Jewish polemic against the Christian virgin birth traditions. It is so amazing to see that this rabbi is a taking the Bible, okay, fair enough, and then he's a taking the Quran as well that is not reliable but he's going to take this Talmudic tradition as some sort of historical evidence. However, the specific claim that Pandera was a Roman soldier is clearer in an earlier non-rabbinic source around AD what 175 to 180 AD. The pagan critic Celsus, interesting it was a pagan critic, reports what he presents as a Jewish accusation. Mary committed adultery and Jesus was fathered by a soldier named Pantera. We know this because the Christian theologian Origen quotes and attacks Celsus. In contrast Celsus, the Talmud itself does not explicitly call Pandera a Roman soldier. Anyways, yes, it is written in the Babylonian Talmud in Sanhedrin and in Sota but the main story about essentially the attack on Mary that she was cheating is written by a pagan. And they take this as a source. Yeah, that makes perfect sense. You know what? If I want to learn about Judaism, I'm going to take as my source Adolf Hitler. Amazing. Anyways, let's proceed. >> [laughter] >> Rabbi, rabbi, rabbi, what you doing there, man? >> Came out. Later he regretted what he had done. He came back to ask for forgiveness. The problem was the rabbi was in the middle of praying, middle of Kriyat Shema. You're not allowed to hint >> Kriyat Shema. >> or to communicate with anyone in the middle of Shema Yisrael. Very s- you have to be very serious with full devotion and intention. >> Yeah. >> So, JC thought that the rabbi is called to him. Turn his back to him. >> JC. >> Say, "You know what? That's it. I'm done." And started to collect all the homeless people, some Jews, some and became their guru. [laughter] After all, he knew some Torah. They didn't know anything. They didn't even know how to >> It's interesting that he mentions here that JC, Jesus, became their guru. He is using this I believe that he's not using this just randomly and casually, but there are certain theories that Jesus actually went to India and there he studied whatever, right? The Bhagavad Gita and whatnot. And then he came back and became somewhat of a guru to the Jews and to the gentiles. >> They didn't like people on the street. They didn't go to yeshiva. And then he died. The Romans killed him. >> Finish. >> But he never started Christianity. [laughter] >> End of story. This is it. His mother was a and then they killed him. >> Yeah. >> Some people think. That was way after he died, three or four generations after. The people that started to tell stories about him never actually saw him in reality. Never. >> With this I absolutely agree. The stories that he references to is by Paul yet again. Paul never saw Jesus and most of the New Testament is written by Paul. So, Christians should re-second guess their sources. I most certainly agree with this. But not so much with the origin story of Jesus. >> It's like the grandfather of my father. Did I see him? No. And remember there was no pictures in those days. That's why all these fake pictures that you see JC with long hair like a woman someone made it up. That someone was very stupid. Because 2,000 years ago a boy in Yeshiva would have a hair like this. Even today you cannot find in one Yeshiva in the world a guy that have hair like a woman. It's against the Torah. The Torah said that you cannot behave like a woman, a woman cannot behave like a man, you cannot wear clothes of a woman, woman cannot wear clothes on a of a man. >> It's interesting, right? We have that in Islam as well. I don't know if long hair would fall under mimicking women, however. >> So, that statue in Brazil that JC have long hair like some kind of a rock and roll star >> [laughter] >> the imagination of some idiot that make >> Yeah, [clears throat] well, it's not so much imagination. So, there are certain depictions of Jesus and they are referring to What's his name again? Borga Borgia, Caesar Borgia, something on those lines. So, the son of a specific king back then in the Roman Empire, but the earliest traditions coming from the Orthodox Christians of course, you cannot trace them back right away to Jesus' lifetime. So, therefore, I'm not disagreeing with this. When we refer to the Bible, it says that he had curly hair, wavy hair, all right? Mhm. Yeah. I'm not disagreeing with the rabbi on that point. >> You know, for sure he didn't look like that. One way or the other, he died, he didn't start Christianity. Not only didn't start Christianity, even though he did some things that he should have not done, one good thing he did say, it's written in the book of Matthew chapter 5 verse 17 until verse 19. That's the source. Book of Matthew is one of the four evangelists. They have Mark, John, Luke, and Matthew. Matthew 5 verse 17, remember. It's written over there that Jesus >> The fulfillment of the law, do not think that I have come to abolish the law or the prophets. I have not come to abolish them, but to fulfill them. Absolutely, that's what we refer to every single time we talk about Jesus here on this channel as well. >> This he say. >> So, you can see that he makes some good points. Of course, there's always some truth there. But at the same time, the origin story, he bases it on the Talmud that came hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of years after Jesus Christ. And then, the pagan enemy of Christianity. >> [snorts] >> Yeah, well, go figure. >> I did not come to contradict the Torah. I came to explain and fulfill more. No one have permission to contradict one word of the Torah, not even one letter. >> He's paraphrasing, but yeah. >> anyone [clears throat] will change one mitzvah of the Torah, one commandment, or will change one word of the Torah, and will teach differently to others, he will be cursed by the kingdom of heaven. >> Paraphrasing, not a direct >> sentence, he already destroyed Christianity before it even started. Say >> Yeah, that's not really the sentence, but kind of. So, here's the whole sentence, right? The fulfillment of the law, do not think that I have come to abolish the law or the prophets. This is amazing, this is really beautiful here. Abolish the prophets. So, if he doesn't come to abolish the prophets, what is he doing? Right, why are Christians telling you then that he is actually God and now you have to worship a trinity if he doesn't abolish the prophets that all came with the same message. Anyways, I've not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. For truly I tell you, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen will by any means disappear from the law until everything is accomplished. Therefore, anyone who sets aside one of the least of these commands and teaches others accordingly will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven. For I tell you that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the Pharisees and the teachers of the law, you will certainly not enter the kingdom of heaven. Which is quite interesting, right? Because here Jesus tells you that you even have to surpass the teachers of the law and the Pharisees in order to enter the kingdom of heaven at all. >> Seven years after he died. In one sentence, it's already putting an X, big X on Islam, on Christianity and all these fake religions. You get it or not? He say anyone who change, they don't keep one mitzvah, the Christian. They don't keep Shabbat. They don't eat kosher. >> No, they don't. >> They don't keep anything. >> Nothing. >> They eat pork. Many of the things that they do. So, according to him, if you want to be a righteous Christian, you have to keep all the commandments of the Torah. Right there, you don't have one righteous Christian in the whole world. Right there. One of the laws of the Torah, you cannot be an idol worshiper. Meaning you cannot be a servant of JC cuz that's idol worshipping. So, he killed you from all >> Yeah, that is true. You can only be a servant of God and not a servant of Jesus Christ. I agree. >> directions, if you clever. That's the end of Christianity right there before it started. Before it started, it's over. >> [laughter] >> Like, share, and comment. Yeah, anyways, at the end there I really cannot disagree with him on most points because yeah, he's simply correct. He's pointing out towards the idolatry that the Christians are committing and that the abolishment of the law has been infiltrating their faith. We know by who, predominantly by Paul, of course, and then the rest of the church fathers. Anyways, at the beginning, as I said already, man, come on. What kind of >> [snorts] >> history do you give us here if those are your sources? You're talking about the Talmud hundreds and hundreds of years later, and then you're talking about the pagan enemy of Christianity story. >> [sighs] >> Amazing. Rabbi, thank you very much. Baruch Hashem.