OTIS, KONE, SCHINDLER - ELevate Your Portfolio With These Dividend Growth Stocks!
Watch on YouTubeVideo summary
The video provides an in-depth analysis of three major elevator companies—Otis, KONE, and Schindler—which are characterized as defensive stocks because their primary revenue comes from servicing existing equipment rather than manufacturing new units. The presenter begins with Otis, noting that its stock has declined approximately 40% from its peak over the last year and a half, presenting it currently at a P/E ratio of 19 with a dividend yield near 2.5%. While acknowledging significant debt resulting from being spun off from General Electric, which negatively impacts equity but not necessarily cash flow stability, the analyst highlights Otis's massive scale in servicing millions of escalators globally and expects the broader market to grow at nearly 3% annually over the next five years.
Moving beyond Otis, the discussion shifts to KONE as a more attractive alternative due to its superior financial health and balance sheet strength. Unlike Otis, which carries substantial debt, KONE maintains positive equity with negligible interest-bearing debt, offering investors higher cash flow yields and dividend growth without the same level of leverage risk. The presenter also touches upon Schindler, a Swiss competitor whose valuation appears slightly below current stock prices despite confirmed guidance, though he notes that valuations in such an exuberant market remain challenging to assess definitively. Across all three companies, the industry faces headwinds from weak new equipment sales, particularly in China, but these are offset by strong demand for modernization services and improved operational efficiencies driven by better IT connectivity.
The core of the investment thesis rests on the predictability of cash flows generated by long-term service contracts that typically last four to five years, allowing companies to eventually reprice their offerings amidst inflationary pressures. The analyst performs intrinsic value calculations suggesting that while these businesses possess excellent tailwinds from global development and an oligopolistic market structure, current valuations may be priced for perfection rather than offering a traditional margin of safety. Specifically for Otis, the fair value is estimated to be significantly lower than the current trading price unless growth expectations are tempered or dividends increase substantially, whereas KONE presents as cheaper relative to its cash generation capabilities even if it lacks aggressive buyback programs like some peers might employ.
In conclusion, while these elevator stocks offer stability and steady earnings growth suitable for a diversified portfolio focused on value investing principles, the presenter advises caution regarding entry prices due to high current valuations that leave little room for error in case of economic downturns or stagnation in new sales. The ultimate takeaway is that investors should appreciate the defensive nature and reliable cash flows of these service-oriented giants but must be prepared to pay a premium for them given their established market positions, making them interesting opportunities rather than undiscovered bargains at present levels.
Read the full video transcript
Good day, fellow investors. Otis, KONE,
Schindler, the elevator stocks,
defensive as they service things more
than they build new things. Let's see
how this might fit your portfolio. I've
done a research for my research
platform.
I've started with Otis and then it also
translated into KONE, Schindler, just to
get an investing perspective. I've got
some comments to research Otis. The
stock is down about 40% from the peak a
year and a half ago. The P/E ratio now
is 19, the dividend yield 2.48%,
the market capitalization 28 billion.
So, it might just not be big enough for
Wall Street and therefore offer
opportunities for value investors. As a
value investor, I look for businesses
that have the ability to compound,
margin of safety, at a fair price. And
then the goal is to see how those fit my
portfolios. I'm now working, starting
the research process to do the
diversified portfolio. Part of that will
likely be also on YouTube, hopefully. I
have my model portfolio, which is the
core that represents the research
platform, value, margin of safety,
double digits earnings, owners earnings
expected returns. And the personal
portfolio is I just buy the best option
for that year. And if you go to my
platform, you have the free investing
course and my research platform. You can
read a little bit what I do, but if you
want to read this research report, here
you have it. Otis, KONE, Schindler, it
will be on free preview and you can read
that there among other things. If you
want to check it, 21-day money-back
guarantee. So, Otis elevator escalator
business growing. The business should be
growing because the market should be
growing. They have 2.5 million
escalators and elevators that they are
servicing. This is the core of the
business, 14.4 billion in sales and 2.5
billion people moved daily. The
escalator and elevator market is
expected to grow 2.9% per year over the
next 5 years. Some estimations see the
market even doubling over the next
decade. That is always a positive having
a good tailwind when it comes to
investing. If we look at the business,
the core of it is service. Good stable
profits. A little bit the margin is a
little bit down on incremental costs,
inflation, and these service contracts
that usually last 4 to 5 years. So, they
have not yet repriced them, and the new
prices should be higher, and therefore
we could see some growth. New equipment
sales are down. Very bad situation in
China. The growth is gone there. Much
less new sales. So, that is something
plaguing the whole industry. The
financial outlook after Q2 was down a
little bit. So, we can call it flat, but
still adjusted free cash flow 1.5
billion, and they are keeping the share
repurchases there at 800 million. All in
all, despite the decline in guidance,
still 1.5 billion in free cash flows.
Earnings per share expected to be flat
for the year.
If we look a little bit at the
financials, we can see here, okay, the
market has been growing, but these
companies have not really grown their
revenues, which means there is some
significant competition. Earnings per
share over the last decade have grown,
but not that much. This is a little bit
of inflation, a little bit of buybacks,
and you go from 2.4 to 3.5.
Four expected now adjusted. Okay, slow
and steady grow, nothing spectacular,
but pretty interesting. So, Otis has
been spun off, and therefore whenever a
company is spun off, the parent company
dumps as much debt on it. So, they have
significant debt, as you can see here,
and negative equity because they are a
cash flow company, and as they do
buybacks above book value, this equity
becomes even more negative. As long as
they can keep the cash flow stable, not
a concern, but as long. If we look at
the free cash flow, pretty stable,
pretty high. This is what the
investors are buying. They're paying
dividends, growing dividends, and they
are doing repurchases. If we look at the
yield, buyback yield, a little bit less
than 3%. Dividend yield, also 2.5%. So,
a total shareholder yield of around 5%.
So, I did an intrinsic value
calculation, the standard that we
usually do. I took the dividend,
estimated here a terminal multiple of
25, which gives me a 4% dividend yield.
For the growth, for everything, I see
that as a good absolute number, not a
relative number that usually Wall Street
looks at. If we estimate a growth rate
of 6% going forward for the dividend,
the intrinsic value is 43, significantly
lower than the current stock price.
Let's see what's priced in now. We have
8% growth per year in the dividend, and
the dividend remaining, the yield in 10
years still being at 2.5%.
That would give the fair value for the
stock at current levels, which means
okay, a little bit priced for really
good things. A margin of safety price,
lower growth rate, dividend of 6-7%. Why
am I saying six or five? Because if
there is a disaster, recession, whatever
that might happen here and there, then
yes, Otis will likely be stable
from the services, from this. But, when
it comes to valuation, the market will
say, "Okay, for that stability, the
market is now happy with 2.5% and the
growth. For that stability, I want 5%
because there will not likely be any
growth for a year or two." And that is a
50% decline from where we are. So, we
get to 40-45, which would be something
very interesting to look at. Of course,
always comparing to other opportunities.
And that is why I have put here Otis. We
will follow it over time, see how it
works, and
compare also to the other things that we
have in our intrinsic value template
that you can download for free on my
free investment course. Let's look a
little bit at the competitive situation.
Otis is the leader, followed by KONE,
thyssenkrupp, Schindler. Okay, KONE a
little bit better. The stock is doing a
little bit better. They are focused on
dividends. Don't think there are
buybacks. If they would lever up like
Otis, they could do 7 billion of
buybacks and push certainly the stock to
double. But, that's a little bit crazy.
Uh same principles, business
modernization, IT, connectivity. All the
three players are working on that. You
can see here the greater China bad
situation from a selling perspective,
but still good on modernization. The
things that you click when you go into
connectivity, checking out less
maintenance, less travel for service
people, less costs, better efficiency,
better profitability. Sales also 3%
growth, stable over the years, slow and
steady, good cash flows, close to 2
billion, 1.something. So, from that cash
flow perspective, they are a little bit
cheaper than Otis, higher cash flow
yield, a little bit higher dividend
yield, much better balance sheet with
positive equity, net interest-bearing
debt at practically zero, so not that
impactful. Made also that calculation
there, still a bit cheaper from that
perspective depending on the growth
rates going forward. I have lowered here
the dividend required
returns.
And okay, not cheap, not a value
investment with margin of safety, but an
interesting situation for those who are
looking. There are a little bit of
differences between the players on
geographical sides, things like that,
maintenance, more maintenance, more
service. Someone started switching
earlier, someone later. Swiss company,
Schindler, guidance confirmed, valuation
again a little bit below the current
stock price, but we are in an exuberant
stock market. So, we'll follow them and
when this gets to 1, 1.something, if it
ever gets, we'll see. That's what I do.
My conclusion is that these are very
interesting businesses. I like the cash
flows, I like the service business, I
like the stability there, the
predictability of the cash flows, the
oligopoly that has been created, the
growth tailwinds, Asia development,
global, everything is positive. Don't
like that much the debt with Otis. And
also don't like that much the valuation
because for what I said that I liked, I
have to pay a pretty good deal.
Investing is about price. Therefore,
okay, let's put it here. I'll do a few
hundred more. If you like this analysis,
subscribe and then we'll see where we
get. Thanks for watching. If you want to
check my portfolios, check my research
platform.