Video summary
The video explores a compelling theory that Imu was originally a member of Joy Boy's crew and potentially part of Roger Pirates before his perceived betrayal. This interpretation is supported by Scopper Gaban's dialogue during their fight, where he refers to Imu as "the Pirate King's crew," suggesting that the title itself holds deep significance for him. The speaker argues that this connection explains why Imu reacts so violently when Gol D. Roger claims the title of Pirate King; it was not merely an insult but a rejection of someone who usurped his place in history. Furthermore, Gaban's desire to fulfill his captain's dreams indicates that he still respects and acknowledges the legacy of piracy established by Joy Boy and Roger, viewing Imu as a contemporary rather than just a distant figurehead.
A significant portion of the discussion focuses on Scopper Gaban losing his left arm during the battle with Luffy, Zoro, and Sanji. The speaker critiques how Eiichiro Oda depicted this injury, noting that unlike previous iconic scenes where characters lost limbs in clear, impactful moments, Gaban's loss was shown ambiguously through a wide shot rather than a visceral close-up. This lack of clarity led to confusion among readers regarding exactly when the arm was severed and whether it happened during Imu's attack or later via crushing force. The speaker also points out that while Luffy is now responsible for two former Roger Pirates losing their arms, Gaban survives with this permanent disability because Oda typically reserves brutal deaths for characters who have already suffered catastrophic injuries like Whitebeard did; instead, he seems to intend for Gaban to live on as a cautionary figure of the era's brutality.
The analysis extends to Imu's mysterious abilities and his ring of eyes, which may correspond to the nineteen weapons used by the Holy Knights or represent sixteen entities linked to the World Nobles' history. The speaker speculates that defeating Imu might require targeting these specific eyes rather than attacking him directly, though Gaban proved he can harm Imu without focusing on them. Additionally, there is a strong sense of urgency conveyed in this chapter regarding the impending Great War and Luffy's current lack of power compared to figures like Blackbeard or even his own grandfather Rayleigh. The video highlights a poignant moment where Luffy realizes his clownish behavior has become an obstacle, showing genuine pain and helplessness as he faces two god-like beings who treat him like ants underfoot.
Finally, the speaker reflects on Eiichiro Oda's legacy and how the conclusion of One Piece will be celebrated by future generations of manga artists, much like the line about celebrating a Pirate King's death in-universe mirrors reality where new authors aspire to become kings themselves after their predecessors finish their stories. The video concludes with an advertisement for Raycon earbuds before returning to the main topic, emphasizing that while Luffy needs to grow up and surpass his current limitations quickly, the narrative is building toward a climactic confrontation between humanity's greatest hero and its most ancient rulers.
Read the full video transcript
Got the vibe that Imu was a member of
Joy Boy's crew from Scopper's last line.
Interesting. So, that is certainly one
way that you can read what happened
there. Not sure if that's the way I read
it, but let's explore this idea because
it is very cool. During their fight, Imu
praised Scopper Gaban saying, "Old as
thou art, thou art still the Pirate
King's crew." And Gaban, he clapped back
with, "Is that what you think? Huh, I
could say the same about you, you know?"
And the way that I initially read this
was commentary about age. Imu was
saying, "You're an old man, but me, a
pretty damn strong old man." And Gaban,
knowing what he does about Imu and his
probable age, is returning that. "You,
Imu, are also an old man, and even older
man, and you're still pretty strong
yourself." But the fact that Imu
specifically mentions being a member of
the Pirate King's crew is quite
fascinating. And another way you could
interpret Gaban's reply is that he is
stating that Imu, as old as he is, is
still a member of the Pirate King's crew
with the potential implication that Joy
Boy could have been not only the first
pirate, but the first pirate king. And
that could be why Imu, he has a
flashback getting all upset at Roger
being named the Pirate King previously
in this chapter. Because the Pirate King
is a title that may actually hold some
meaning to Imu. And the fact that this
title was claimed by a filthy D was an
idea so uncouth that Imu demanded the
erasure of Roger's D. So, as far as most
of the world knows, just like Gol D.
Roger, this big old D, it never existed.
Despite the D, Imu does also seem to
have this It's really cool begrudging
respect
for Roger's accomplishments. He
addresses Roger as the Pirate King. And
I think that's a big deal. It takes a
lot for someone who claims to be the
King of the World to acknowledge, in any
way, shape, or form, another king. It's
like Imu was citing a contemporary.
Plus, there's also the moment in this
chapter where Gaban claims that he just
wants to see his captain's dreams come
to fruition. And that prompts Imu to
ask, "Captain, who is in the mouth of
any other character, it'd probably be
fairly basic,
irrelevant, not even worth mentioning.
But the fact that Imu is even saying it
tells us a lot about him, which is that
when it comes to this topic of piracy,
pirate kings, and pirate captains, Imu,
he does have an interest here. He has a
connection because he's not ignoring
these words like he has everything else.
So, I really don't hate the idea that
Imu may have also been one of the
world's first pirates and part of Joy
Boy's crew. And it would certainly make
whatever betrayal Imu believes happened
feel all the more potent. Because could
you imagine a situation where Luffy
betrays any of his crew? They have 100%
faith in their captain. And if Luffy
ever did such a thing, it would probably
send the Straw Hats spiraling into their
bad timeline futures and becoming just
as jaded as Imu. And I'm going to do a
video on this soon because it's very
fun. But this is another fantastic piece
of evidence that Imu was Joy Boy's
parrot. Mm. I don't know about you, but
whenever I leave the harm, I need to do
the exact same pocket check to make sure
that I have the big four: phone, wallet,
keys, and the sponsor of today's video,
Raycon. Because if I forget these, then
mate, my day is ruined. I listen to
music doing almost everything in my day.
Riding, cleaning, walking the dog,
lifting heavy things at the heavy thing
place. Gym. That's the word. And to make
all of these things more enjoyable, I
have Raycon's new everyday clip earbuds.
Unlike regular earbuds, these have an
open ear design so that I can listen to
music or podcast while still hearing
what's going on around me, which is
especially nice when I'm walking around
Sydney I'd quite like to know if a bus
is about to introduce itself to my
posterior or any other part of my body.
But these these are so good. They are
incredibly lightweight, and they clip
onto your ears without putting any
pressure on anything, and they stay put.
It is ridiculous how sturdy these are
considering it doesn't even feel like
I'm wearing anything when I'm wearing
things. They've also got a 30-hour
battery life with the charging case.
They connect seamlessly between devices.
They sound fantastic, delivering premium
quality without the premium price tag,
and over 3 million people already use
Raycon. And if for some reason you don't
love them, there is also a 30-day
money-back guarantee. So, if you're
heading back to school yourself or
buying for someone who is, the everyday
clip earbuds are the perfect
back-to-school companion, or the perfect
companion for any other use as well.
Just click the link in the description
or go to buyraycon.com/grandlineclip
to get 20% off the everyday clip
earbuds. I always feel like I should say
more about Raycon, but simple is better.
They're just a great product at a great
price. So, definitely check Raycon out,
but for now it's back to you. Me?
Thanks, me. If you go back to the
chapter on the double page 14-15, when
Kibun uses 8000/ Imu says "Honebami",
and you can see an omen entity eating
Scop Kibun. Yes, you can definitely see
something. In the big 8000/ attack, Scop
Kibun's left side is being assaulted by
the creature generated by Imu's
Honebami, and you can also see a spurt
of Kibun's blood. So, like I said in the
review video, this is where I assume
that Kibun's left arm was taken off. But
my criticism, and I wasn't very clear
about this, which is ironic, because my
criticism is that Kibun losing his arm
artistically it lacks that clarity and
that impact. And this is because I have
very, very high expectations for scenes
of characters losing their arms in One
Piece. Oda has been doing this ever
since the very first chapter. He is a
man who knows how to make impactful
scenes of characters losing their arms.
For another example, when Kiku lost her
left arm, that was extremely powerful.
Very memorable panel, just as it was
when Killer removed the left arm of
Basil Hawkins. Pretty much every time
Oda removes a character's arm, it
becomes an iconic piece of art. Whereas
this business with Scop Kibun it just
doesn't pack the same punch for me, or
or really any punch. And I also don't
think it helps that Oda chose a wide
shot of Kibun on the branch to end the
chapter on to reveal that the arm had
been removed, because not only do you
not really see the moment that the arm
gets cut off, but you also don't really
feel the visceral shock of it in the
same way that you did in chapter one
with the close-up of Shanks missing his
arm. And I just feel like because
removing arms is one of Oda's specialty
interest, it could have been drawn in a
much more clear or at least much more
interesting way. And the reason why I
can tell it could have been done better
is because I had so many of all of the
you in the comments arguing about what
actually happened during this scene.
Some people are saying it came off in
the attack, others are saying "Oda,
dummy, it just crushed and maybe kind of
wounded Gaban's arm and it came off
later." And craziest of all, I also had
comments saying that they didn't even
realize Gaban had lost his arm before I
said it in the video. Going to be honest
here, that last one might be a bit more
in the realm of a skill issue, but my
point is that no one was doing this when
Kiku or Hawkins lost their arms back in
the day because there was nothing to
discuss. Everything was objective and
clear. The weapons can't be random. Imu
gave Summers and Killingem the exact
blades of their families in the short
time they were with him. All right, this
might be becoming a bit of a theme of
this video because this is another issue
of clarity or lack thereof. Because we
never actually see Imu giving Summers or
Killingem their family weapons Gram and
Longinus. They're just suddenly using
them in chapter 1,189.
Before that, Killingem was still
wielding his standard spear against
Sanji and the last time we saw Summers,
he only had his standard Summer sword.
And what Summer says is that "Ah, the
great one, he used the omen to bring
these weapons back and grant them to
us." And I'm sure that this is the sort
of thing that the anime will expand on
because we don't even see Killingem or
Summers summoning these weapons. We cut
to Zoro fighting Summers and he just has
Gram out already, which is a big
invitation for the Toei anime to do a 30
to 60-second scene of Summers powering
up, reaching into the abyss or the omen
and manifesting it. But as it stands
right now, we don't know how any of this
happened or whether Imu can use these
weapons while Summers is in killing him
are also using them. Or why when Emu
himself used Graham, the sword had a
completely different shape and looks
more like a polearm than it does a sword
compared to when Summers is using it.
But if I had to guess, I'd say that each
Holy Knight is only capable of using
their family weapon and only granted
access to it with an omen by Emu as
opposed to Emu who can use all 19. So
there could still be a random element to
it. Let's say that Emu has a one in 19
chance of getting any given weapon. But
for the Holy Knights, they can only ever
draw their one and it has to be with a
funky omen. Luffy crying, "But Gabann,
your arm, your arm." Gabann, "It's all
right. You're a boy, aren't you? You
have to be strong. That axe is very
precious to me. Bring it back once
you've become a great mountain eater." I
just wanted to read that out loud
because this comment has pointed out to
me that Mr. Monkey D. Luffy is now
responsible for two of the former Roger
Pirates losing their left arms. And I'd
be very concerned right now if I was
Silvers Rayleigh or a Crocus because two
it is never enough. There's a reason why
it is called the rule of threes rather
than the general suggestion of maybe
sometimes three is a good number.
However, I suppose we do also have three
already if you count Buggy who removed
both of his arms in his fight with
Luffy. Honestly, this chapter confirms
for me that Scopper isn't going to die.
Oda isn't the type to brutalize someone
before their death, but that arm is gone
forever. I actually think it's quite the
opposite. If someone is going to die
anyway, it gives Oda full license to
brutalize them however he sees fit.
Whitebeard definitely comes to mind. We
saw this man endure 267
blade wounds, take 152 bullets, 46
cannonballs, a magma shot to the chest,
and have half his head blown right off.
So the more damage that Gabann incurs,
the more likely I think he is to die.
However, I do take the point because of
all of the damage that Whitebeard was
inflicted with, he never lost an arm.
The moment that Whitebeard had half his
face blown off, we knew that there was
no coming back from that. But Gabal, he
has been inflicted with a very
survivable injury. It's not
life-threatening by One Piece standards,
and it does feel more likely for Oda to
have Gabal live, but to permanently lose
that arm like every other character in
the series loses their arms. Man on the
internet, have we had a clear view of
Imu's circle with eyes thing? I am
counting 18 to 19 eyes depending on the
panel, with six to seven of them open,
which kind of matches the number of
weapons revealed so far. Maybe the
secret due defeating Imu is sticking our
fingers in those eyes so that he loses
access to the weapons. That would be the
perfect Usopp moment. I'm not sure. I
think that there are probably close to,
if not exactly, 19 of them. It would
make sense with the weapon number. But
to the best of my knowledge, the ring of
eyes has always been obscured by
something, so we don't have an exact
amount. It's also possible, I don't know
how probable, but possible that there
are 16 eyes because 16 is the iconic
number of the World Nobles. They shoot
their victims 16 times. Doflamingo had
his 16 holy bullets attack, and Imu's
name can even be read as the numbers one
and six, which put together are 16.
Unless you do it the other way around,
then it's 61, but we don't do that. But
I also agree because games have trained
me to think this way. If it was up to me
fighting Imu, I would assume that he was
invincible until I'd popped all of those
eyes. So we shouldn't be wasting our
energy or ammo on Imu himself until we
get rid of those eyes. However, Scop of
Gabal not a gamer, and he has proved to
me that Imu can be harmed without
focusing on that. However, I would love
to see something like Usopp sniping
those eyes, and to have my dream of the
weakest person on the island being the
key to stopping the strongest person, if
Imu is indeed a person. Because in this
chapter, Scop of Gabal says that Imu
doesn't seem to be of this world, which
could be hinting at Imu being a figure
who has existed since the second or even
first world. Or, and this idea it's not
completely off the table, but Imu could
be an alien. There are tons of planets
and moons around the One Piece world,
all with life forms of their own, and we
have barely touched any of these
glorious space races. The scale of
Gabans attacks is insane. Zoro and Sanji
still have a ways to go before they can
lift Luffy up as his wings. It's not
just them either. Gabans is only the
left arm of the pirate king. After this
chapter, it's good thing Roger doesn't
need that left arm anymore. But think
about what that means for Roger's power
in his prime. So I can understand why
Gabans got annoyed at Zoro and Sanji for
not being at the level they needed to
be, but also why Gabans got even more
upset with Luffy himself. Because it is
not good enough for Luffy to be on
Gabans level. He has to be far beyond
that, and right now he is not. He's not
even at Gabans level as a shriveled old
man. And there is definitely a sense of
urgency at play here. Because not only
are we fighting him right here and right
now. We've got to do this. We've got to
save Elbaf and all that. Not just that,
there is a much bigger picture. Because
at some point this year in world, the
great war is prophesied to happen. The
one that will bring about the dawn of
the world and all that. Gabans knows
that all of this is happening
imminently. So he sees Luffy and he's
all like, "Look, I'm pretty sure you're
the guy we've been waiting for, but you
are nowhere near where we need you to
be. And you, you need to get your [ __ ]
together immediately, because there is a
big war thing starting probably next
week." This chapter really made me doubt
that Rayleigh could not just wipe the
floor with Blackbeard on Amazon Lily.
Well, there is a reason why Blackbeard
decided to retreat as soon as Rayleigh
arrived, and I think we now know what
that reason is. If Gabans can exude this
sort of violence from haki and have his
own divine attack like Roger, then
Rayleigh must be capable of at least
that much as well. What we don't know,
however, is what Blackbeard is capable
of. Luffy, Zoro, and Sanji, they're not
where they need to be right now, but
Marshall D. Teach could be in a very
different position. He's been focused on
his goal for almost four decades now and
he could be much more prepared than
Luffy for what's to come and probably is
considering that he is the overall
antagonist of the series probably. So I
guess we just have to take Rayleigh and
Gaban's words as a direct comparison.
Rayleigh, he looked Blackbeard up and
down and also left to right as a as a
little bit to take in and Rayleigh said
to himself, yeah, I'd probably lose.
Whereas Gaban, he saw everything that is
Luffy and he said, "Ah, my
disappointment is immeasurable and my
day is ruined." Man on the land upside
down. About time Luffy starts behaving
more seriously. He's being clownish ever
since defeating Kaido and while it was
entertaining at first, it's becoming
anticlimactic now. So as always, I am a
big defender of Gear 5 and being a clown
in general, but this was always going to
happen at some point and this probably
isn't even the last time that Luffy will
need a dramatic wake-up call like this.
And one panel I'd really like to linger
on is this one. It's a sliver panel and
very easy to kind of blast past, but
this close-up of Luffy is fantastically
drawn. Oda perfectly captures Luffy's
epiphany of realizing that if he
continues as he is, he will not be able
to save his friends or his crew. It is a
very pained and dire [clears throat]
expression, the sort of face we almost
never see Luffy make. It's also a face
of powerlessness. Not only could he not
stand up against Im but this random old
man is now beating him up. It's very
much like on Sabaody when Kizaru,
Sentomaru, Kuma and Rayleigh, they were
all fighting around them. There's a
fantastic line in Jujutsu Kaisen that
explains this feeling. Think of them as
elephants tap dancing on ants and we're
the ants. That's what it was like on
Sabaody and that's also what's happening
right here in this very moment. Im and
Gaban, they're like two gods doing
battle stomping on Luffy and Loki who
are powerless in comparison. And so this
face, this wonderful panel of Luffy for
the first time since the original
Sabaody, he is feeling his own
powerlessness. Mr. Internet Dude,
Chopper went to the library with Robin
in the last chapter. I assume Robin
wants him to translate what the owl is
saying. Yeah, the owl's name is Biblo
and I think so, too. When Robin appeared
with her clone, she didn't seem to be
particularly worried about anything.
She's just quite chill, actually. And
being worried would be a reason to call
Chopper as if someone needed some urgent
medical care. And this does come off the
back of chapter 1,182 where Robin and
Saul found all of the books as well as
Biblo and Saul stated that he was around
the perplexed about Biblo. So, if Biblo
has made it clear that he has something
important to say or communicate, then we
need Chopper to translate. And Robin
also summoned Chopper in the same
chapter that Chopper first translated
what Ragnar was saying. So, we do know
that Chopper can speak to these most
ancient of creatures. I feel like the
praising your death line will also be
attributed to One Piece itself. Not
celebrating it's over, but celebrating
that it happened. I think very much the
same and this is intentional from Oda,
by the way. In his earlier interviews,
we're talking decades ago, in those
early interviews, Oda sounds very
Luffy-esque because he makes it clear
that his ambition is to be the best. He
respects those who came before him and
inspired him like Akira Toriyama, as
well as those contemporaries who rose up
alongside him like Kishimoto, and even
those who come after him. But, Oda
stated that he wanted to be the king of
Weekly Shonen Jump, which is a title
that I think he's quite comfortably held
for a very long time now. So, Oda ended
up accomplishing his dream well before
Luffy was able to reach his. However,
the line about the Pirate King being a
man whose death is celebrated is going
to be very true in reality, as well.
When One Piece does finally come to a
conclusion, each and every current Jump
author, as well as every upcoming
mangaka, will be celebrating. Not out of
malice, spite, jealousy, or any of the
bad words, but because this is their
chance to go for the crown. It is an
inspiration. With the passing of One
Piece as a series, a new era of manga
will begin as rookie authors set out to
sea to follow in the footsteps of
becoming the next king. That's still a
few years away though, so for now I want
you to let me know what you thought
about all of this in the comments below.