Submind YouTube summaries
Thumbnail for Most Insurance Agents Are Advertising the Wrong Way

Most Insurance Agents Are Advertising the Wrong Way

Watch on YouTube

Video summary

The core issue addressed in the video is that many insurance agents and marketers fail because they are advertising the wrong way, often resulting in high costs per click or zero leads despite targeting the right audience. The speaker argues that if an ad does not get clicked by the correct demographic, the problem usually lies with the ad itself rather than the budget or platform settings. A common mistake is creating polished but ineffective ads without sufficient experience, leading to premature shutdowns of campaigns after only a few days due to perceived lack of results. The transcript emphasizes that successful advertising requires patience and a willingness to scale up budgets once proof of concept is established, rather than abandoning efforts too early when initial impressions are low. To succeed, marketers must focus on three critical components: precise targeting, compelling ad creative, and a cohesive landing page experience. Targeting involves ensuring ads only reach relevant demographics, such as showing Medicare ads only to individuals over 64 in specific states, while the ad creative must immediately hook the viewer's attention within the first few seconds. The speaker notes that generic or overly polished graphics often fail with older audiences who prefer more authentic messaging, and suggests using direct language like "If you're over 64 and live in Michigan" to create a personal connection. Furthermore, the landing page must feel like a seamless extension of the ad, avoiding distractions like mixing Medicare and life insurance topics on the same page, which can confuse visitors and reduce conversion rates. The video also highlights the importance of simplifying the user journey and qualifying leads effectively to save time for advisors. Instead of using long surveys that discourage completion, successful funnels often use a single clear call-to-action, such as booking a call or filling out a simple form, while still maintaining quality through verification steps like phone checks. The speaker shares an example where a simple ad shared by one person generated tens of thousands of views and leads from unexpected locations, proving that shareability and relevance are key. Additionally, the transcript illustrates how leveraging AI tools to research high-converting page structures can significantly outperform manually built sites, provided the campaign is given enough time to gather data and prove its effectiveness before making drastic changes. Ultimately, the conclusion is that even with advanced tools like AI or professional marketers, the fundamental element of a great ad is its ability to grab attention instantly and make sense to the viewer. Many agents struggle because their ads do not resonate within seconds, causing them to waste money on clicks that never convert. The speaker encourages agencies to seek help from experts who can tweak small aspects of their strategy to achieve massive impacts on their bottom line, regardless of whether they are small operations earning hundreds of thousands or large firms making tens of millions. By refining the ad message, ensuring brand consistency across platforms, and trusting the data over initial impressions, insurance agents can finally break through the noise and generate consistent leads.
Read the full video transcript
If you're targeting the right people, and they're seeing the ad, but they're not clicking, or your cost per click is like $12, the ad sucks. And in most cases, for most people, that's the actual problem. I'm not saying it is, but if you made it yourselves, and you haven't have experience with this, >> How long does it have to run, and what do you need to be tracking? Because we've run ads, we don't really know what we should be tracking. >> Yeah. >> But then we're getting no results, so our feet get cold, and we shut everything off. >> Yeah. >> So we don't even know how long we should be running ads, what our ads be >> How long do you normally run, and how much you normally spend? >> Where did you get the ad idea from? >> Most of them she creates our ads. >> Okay. That may be good. >> had We fired three marketers in the last year and a half. >> Yeah. Every marketer says they're amazing, and they're going to do a good job. Including me. >> But you know, I think we've done uh Medicare, and a final expense ad, and we may run it 5 or 10 days at what, 10 bucks a day? >> Yeah. >> Or something like that, and we don't know what we're doing. >> Sure. Sure. >> You know, I 20 to 30 30 to 40 dollars a day, and still Yeah, get nothing. >> No leads? No leads? So [clears throat] So let you guys think about it, okay? I think think it's a answer I think the Could you hear the question a little bit where they're like, okay. So I think this will help a lot of people in the room if I can touch on that. So a lot of a lot of times we don't Well, for one, um I like that you're starting with a lower budget, cuz you can learn a lot with 10 bucks. You can learn a lot with 50 bucks. You can learn with 100 bucks. Like like for road shows, we start out 50 bucks a day, and we build, and we try to get revenue ahead of ads. And then we slowly scale it up, but we want proof, right, that it's working. And some markets do better than others. So So we start a little slow. But what most people struggle with is if you think about it, there's different [snorts] pieces of the process. So, you've got you've got the targeting. Right? The targeting is very important because who is going to see the ad? Is it the right target? Uh so, in this example, if you're doing final expense ads, you shouldn't show it to a 35-year-old. We all know that, but maybe we don't know how to execute on that, right? Or Medicare, you shouldn't show it to somebody that's 59. Right? Unless they're on disability, it doesn't matter, right? So, but there's a very small pool, right? So, targeting. Then, you have the actual advertisement. Right? So, so what is the actual advertisement? So, if I'm targeting the right audience, so for for for Medicare, I might I might be targeting people in a certain state that are ages 64-plus. Okay? That's good. Well, in the advertisement, does it catch their attention and hook them, especially if it's a video, in the first second, two seconds, three seconds, right? And most advertisements, let's be honest, from even other marketing companies or that we make ourselves, and this may or may not be true, okay, are terrible. Terrible. Now, we think it's got to be perfect and polished. That's not always true, either. Like uh uh uh a senior is less likely to respond to an AI graphic. Right? They're They're reading the newspaper. You know what I mean? Like like So, so who is your audience and what should you be And if I if I'm doing if I'm doing an advertisement, if I'm doing a video, I would say, "If you're over 64 and you live in Michigan, listen up." Like Oh. So, when we do when we do ads, "Hey, if you're an insurance agent and you live near Boston, this is for you." They're like, "Oh, he's actually speaking to me." Right? So, very important. >> Cody, I want you to tell me about this. This is that happened last week, crazy crazy. [snorts] So, I have this ad that talks about the Medicare savings program, right? >> Mhm. >> Put that out in about five states. I got 200 impressions, 10 bucks a day. All of a sudden somebody shared it. >> Mhm. >> They came to my site to my my Facebook page. It got 51,000 views. >> Wow. >> I'm like, "What in the world?" >> Wow. >> I'm in Atlanta. Listen, I'm in Atlanta. Y'all know, right? >> Right. >> Yes. >> I'm in Atlanta. I'm not even licensed in Wyoming. A guy messaged me from Wyoming. >> Wow. >> [laughter] >> And that's just from somebody sharing the ad. >> Somebody shared the ad. >> Yeah. >> That That Check Check You know what that means, right? >> You need to get another license. >> Not [clears throat] me. >> Yes. So, so okay. So, in that example, though, like you can You can make it where the advertisement is shareable or not. Now, in this example, I like people that were able to share the advertisements unless I'm only doing a local Medicare seminar in Atlanta. Then it's like there's no point in sharing the advertisement. But, in your case, if you can help them get a license, you can allow the ad to be shared or not. You can turn that off in the settings, right, of the ad. Now, because what happens is though you go from the advertisement to okay, we're feeding them to the actual we'll just call it the actual site, right? The actual page. Okay? What does that look like? Um how does it start? So, like all of our stuff, we're always looking at what is the headline? What is the sub headline? Right? What What What are the bullet points? Because all of this that's on the site has to [snorts] directly relate to the ad and it has to directly relate to the people that are going to be And it's got to all be a cohesive. So, they've got to Yeah, smooth. So, they've got to You got to be a targeting the right person. They've got to see the ad. They've got to go to site and it's got to feel like the same. So, a lot of times what I see is I see ads and then I go to the site and I'm like, this feels like a totally different company. It doesn't make any sense. The brand's different. I I don't get it, right? Or or it's Medicare, but then it starts talking about um life insurance also on the page. That's a distraction. One. One. So, like one lead type. One. A lot of times even for ads I mean, events would perform even better probably if we just had one ticket. One simple form. One simple outcome. Like the simpler the better. Then you go from, okay, what are they actually filling out? What are they Are they booking a call? Are they filling out a form? Are they calling? What's the barrier to entry? The more questions you ask, the better the lead's going to be, but the less likely people are going to fill it out. Okay? So, if I had So, so like annuity leads, we ask We have a 15-step survey. They're really good. At the beginning of the form, we actually ask a question that says, "Hey, do you have at least $100,000 or more in investable assets excluding your home?" And if they put no, they're kicked out of the funnel. This is not for you. So, we have more people that kicked out of the funnel than actually go through it, right? But advisors don't want to waste their time. So, it works. They love it. Also, not only are they asset qualified, in our case we use phone verification, too. To where the we text them the six-digit code, right? From the phone verification tool. Okay? And then after that, we're also like introducing the advisor. Here's what they look like. Here's who you're going to be working with. Here's how you can reach them. We also text and email that all that to the client. So, we're trying to introduce and set them up, okay? Now, but what I see a lot of times is in this example, what you're saying is the targeting is probably fine. Probably. The form, if it's an internal lead form in Facebook or whatever you're doing, is probably fine. And I could we could even look at it at some point during the next couple days if you want me to. And maybe we even use it as like a live case study. But I guarantee you it's most and we can look at the data to tell us this or you can take the data like sometimes I'll just send screenshots of ads and put it in the cloud and say what do you think, you know? Like I'll give you an example. We're doing an event called the Visibility Blueprint. It's a virtual event. We're doing every month and we're trying to get like 50 to 100 people to register, nothing crazy. >> [snorts] >> For the first two days, it was 27 bucks to attend. For the first two days no tickets. >> Wow. >> Only money going out, no money coming in and I'm like I thought this was the best virtual event page we've ever built. What is going on? The ads are incredible. Like this is crazy. Put it in the [snorts] cloud and I said here's our road show stats. Here's our Visibility Blueprint stats for a virtual. And based on our conversation, I think we should add Well, should we have two tickets and two two ticket levels on there. And it's funny half people are buying the higher level ticket again. But I gave the numbers to Claude. 8% ads virtual event ads. I gave it to Claude and said actually the Visibility Blueprint ads are performing better. Just give it time. >> Mhm. Wow. >> And it was right. I almost freaking cut the whole thing and rebuilt it and like let's scratch this like this sucks, right? It is working it's outperforming. The ad is outperforming your road show ads. And your page is already built con- cur- conversions cuz I worked on building it with Claude. And then and I didn't build the page, Keegan actually built it. But what's cool about that is I went to Claude and said find me the best virtual event but best highest converting virtual event pages in the world and give me examples. And then it said based on research and study and sites and stats and and influencers, this is the best performing virtual event page in the world. >> How long did that take, Claude? >> Uh few minutes. Yeah. Yeah, few minutes. So >> Was it yours? >> So so yeah, no I wish it was mine. So then I'll come back to that. So, then, I gave it I said, "This page." And I gave it to Keegan and said, "Build our site exactly like this." So, I already knew it was going to convert. I And then, he's already telling me the ads are performing better. However, I just didn't want to give it enough time. Now, if it gives enough time, because what happens is if people are seeing that if you're targeting the right people and they're seeing the ad, but they're not clicking, or your cost per click is like $12, the ad sucks. And in most cases, for most people, that's the actual problem. I'm not saying it is, but if you made it yourselves and you haven't have experience with this, >> Claude did it. >> Claude did it. Okay, so, which Good. And a graphic? >> Yes. >> Okay. So, is it a How How busy is the graphic? Or what How much is on it or >> It was an ambulance. [snorts] >> Okay. Okay. So, it might be good. But, even if Claude built it, we might see that people aren't clicking through, right? Or maybe the you know, um I'll I'll We'll We'll just say this. Normally Normally, if Dylan builds it, it outperforms what AI builds for ads, specifically. Okay? So, Dylan builds all my ads. Nobody else does. Okay? Um Now, but most people, this is where it fails. That's where it fails is the advertisement does not get my attention. And I've got to know within seconds it's for me, it's getting my attention, and it's wanting me to do something. And it's got to make sense. What you just saw is us helping an agency scale their operation much faster, something that we are very, very good at at this point, whether that be through our Power Player Mastermind uh retreats, whether that be through our our intensive events live, or whether that be just helping an agency with brand awareness and exposure to enhance recruiting and speed up recruiting in a big way. Uh we would love to chat. You can go to scale.kodiakskans.com to learn more. We can jump on, get to know you, and the cool thing is like you're not too small or too big. Like we've helped small agencies doing hundreds of thousands a year. We've helped massive agencies doing uh tens of millions a year, and it doesn't take much. Like a some sometimes a small tweak can make such a massive impact in your bottom line. And so, book a call. Let's chat. See how we can help. Thanks for watching. Go to scale.codyaskins.com.