Itemized Deductions – Interest You Paid 5070 Income Tax 2025 26
Watch on YouTubeVideo summary
For the 2025 tax year, itemized deductions for interest paid on qualified residence debt remain a significant tool for homeowners aiming to exceed the standard deduction thresholds of $15,750 for single filers or $31,500 for married couples. However, this benefit is not universal; it applies strictly to loans used to buy, build, or substantially improve a primary or second home, while interest on unsecured personal debts like credit cards and car loans remains non-deductible unless incurred for business purposes. The tax code effectively subsidizes homeownership by allowing deductions that diminish over time as principal payments increase the portion of monthly installments allocated to principal rather than deductible interest, creating an economic incentive tied directly to property values in high-cost areas where mortgage balances are larger.
The scope of what qualifies as a deductible home includes specific criteria for second homes and rental properties; for instance, a boat can be considered a qualified residence if it possesses sleeping, cooking, and toilet facilities, whereas mixed-use properties require expenses to be prorated between personal use and rental activities based on square footage or usage time. Furthermore, the source of funds plays a critical role in deductibility, meaning that home equity loan interest is only deductible if the proceeds are used for home improvements; using such loans for debt consolidation, vacations, or paying off credit cards renders those specific portions non-deductible. Taxpayers must maintain rigorous documentation, including Form 1098s, closing disclosures, and bank statements tracing fund usage, to prove compliance during audits, especially given the strict IRS requirements regarding cash-out refinances where tracking proceeds is essential for determining deductibility limits under statutory thresholds and net investment income rules.
Beyond simple mortgage interest, other nuances such as points paid at closing require careful handling, typically being amortized over the loan term rather than deducted entirely in one year unless specific conditions for a primary residence purchase are met. Investment interest expenses face their own set of limitations governed by Form 4952 and Internal Revenue Code Sections 163 and 163H, where excess investment interest can be carried forward to future years instead of being lost immediately. While high-income earners may derive larger tax benefits from these deductions, relying solely on them is often misleading because economic factors like market compensation over time influence housing costs more than the immediate tax savings suggest.
Ultimately, while itemized deductions for mortgage and home equity interest provide a valuable financial advantage to many homeowners in 2025, their effectiveness depends heavily on proper application of rules regarding loan usage, property classification, and expense allocation. The system encourages specific economic behaviors like maintaining real estate assets but restricts personal consumption deductions, requiring taxpayers to engage in careful cost-benefit analysis rather than assuming automatic savings. To navigate this complex landscape successfully, individuals should consult critical resources such as IRS Publications 936, 550, and 17 alongside Schedule A instructions, ensuring they accurately report qualified interests on their tax returns while avoiding pitfalls related to consumer debt or improper refinancing structures that could jeopardize their filing status.
Read the full video transcript
United States income tax looking at
itemized deductions reported on schedule
A for the category of interest you paid.
So, get ready and some coffee so we
could stave off the government attack
with income tax preparation.
Note, you can find the form 1040
instructions for schedule A itemized
deductions tax year 2025 at the IRS
website irs.gov. That's irs.gov.
Remember in the first half of that
income tax formula is basically a funny
income statement replacing the expenses
with two categories of deductions, above
the line deductions or adjustments to
income, below the line deductions,
greater of standard or itemized
deductions, only taking the itemized
deductions if they clear the standard
deduction threshold.
This is the tax and credits section of
the form 1040 page two, 12E, where we
have the standard deduction or itemized
deduction, itemizing if we're greater
than the standard which is listed on the
left for single filers, 15,750, double
for married, 31,500, 23,625
in the middle. We got to clear that
threshold to itemize, typically
happening if someone owns a home in a
high cost of living area pushing up the
mortgage interest as well as property
taxes. This is the schedule A itemized
deductions. We're focusing here on the
interest you paid. This is the main
category that could push people over.
It's often also one that people get most
confused and have to work into and think
about when they think of their major of
purchase of their life, a home. So, in
other words, uh it's the deduction that
could push people over the threshold to
itemized in that if we have a standard
deduction,
uh we have to clear that hurdle. If we
buy a home, then we might have the
mortgage on the home and the interest
portion of those mortgage payments are
what we're talking about here, typically
reported on the form 1098.
You couple that with the property taxes
and it could push you over the
threshold. However, from a planning
context, we want to note upfront we'll
talk about it more as we go. You need to
actually do projections and be quite
careful to make sure that you're getting
the tax advantage you think you're
getting when you're thinking about it in
terms of a big purchase such as a home
purchase and also you would like to have
an external opinion giving you this
information. In other words, someone
that's not getting paid directly from
the sale of the home or the related loan
on the home such as possibly an income
tax professional so that we can actually
run the numbers and see uh what the
actual tax benefits are. One of the main
problems being that we have to clear
this hurdle. If we just barely clear
this hurdle, if you buy a home and the
interest on the home and the property
taxes are just barely bringing you over
15,750
or it's barely over 31,500 if married,
you're not really getting a benefit of
of the amount of the mortgage interest.
You're getting a benefit of the
difference between the standard
deduction you would have got anyways and
the high and the higher amount that you
got to because you were able to itemize.
Much more complex calculation. It also
has impacts in that the interest you pay
will actually go down over the life of
the loan. Therefore, the benefits you
get in year one of the loan will be
substantially higher than year whatever,
30, 15 of the loan because of that. Some
things to keep in mind. Okay. So, we're
going to then say that the schedule A
itemized uh interest you paid. So,
schedule A includes certain deductible
personal interest expenses.
So, note this
is one of those places where you would
think it's not a normal deduction.
What's a normal deduction for income
taxes? The things you needed to consume
in order to generate revenue, most
clearly seen on something like a
schedule C where the business income and
expenses were used to generate the
income. You might say, "Well, I need a
home in order to generate income." True,
but where the home is and how big the
home is isn't really directly related to
the income that you are generating. It's
a personal thing. And so, therefore,
these deductions are really kind of more
political deductions, which have their
benefit, but they also tend to subsidize
whatever they're they're aimed at, which
in this case is real estate market and
finance
uh market, right? So, that means that
the housing prices go up over time in
the long run, and basically, we just end
up with a more complicated system that
we got to figure out in order to
determine if we could afford the home
and what are the cost-benefit analysis.
So, the most common deductible interest
is the home mortgage interest. So,
interest deductions are generally tied
to policy goals encouraging home
ownership. So, from a political
standpoint, I just told you my opinion.
My opinion is in the long term, it's not
really helping you buy a home because
the market is going to equalize, and
it's just going to be a situation where
it's more complex to figure out how to
buy the home because you have to deal
with you have the the mortgage interest
and whatnot. Uh you know, that's it's a
little bit more nuanced than that, but
that's
the general take. In the short term, it
could be, of course, more beneficial,
and it's clearly something that the the
home owners or the home industry likes
because it's going to boost up in the
short run, and it gives a
a marketing capacity to say, "Hey, look,
the government basically wants you to
buy a home. The home is the American
dream. Is the quotes around that one,
right?" Ob- obviously, the people that
are in the industry of home selling
would like to push that narrative. I'm
not saying it's a totally bad or wrong
narrative, but I do think it's it's over
It's a little overhyped, or you have to
think about who's benefiting from
whatever narrative
is being is being put out there. So,
that means the mortgage on the on the
home interest possibly deductible.
Notice that other interest isn't
deductible. Meaning, if I bought a car,
it's also personal property, you would
think I need the car to go to work. Why
don't I get to deduct the interest for
the car? Well, possibly because the car
manufacturers aren't as good at
lobbying. I don't know. I'm just Maybe
I'm a little skeptical here, but
interest credit card interest, you have
a similar kind of situation. It also
leads to planning situations where if
you could basically consolidate things
under something that's deductible, that
could be beneficial, and then you have
to come up with rules to kind of stop
people from doing that, and we end up
with these games that are getting played
because of the deductibility of the
interest. So, many personal interest
expenses are not deductible. Meaning,
most other interest isn't. If you have
interest on your on your credit card,
not typically deductible unless it's
like a business credit card or something
like that. Similar with your car, not
deductible typically unless it's a
business car or something like that. The
home is the exception. It's a weird
exception, and it leads to all these
kind of things that you could start to
think about and say, "Well, wouldn't it
be better if I had debt if I had it in
some kind of debt that was deductible?"
Student loan interest is, you know,
sometimes deductible. Mortgage interest.
Is there a way to do that? You start
getting into these weird tax planning
because of it and so on. So interest
deductions reduce taxable income for
qualifying taxpayers. So rules for
deductible interest are highly
documented documentation driven. So the
IRS wants to obviously double check this
as much as they can so it doesn't get
out of control. They try to highly
regulate it and put pressure on the
financial institutions generally the
banks that being the typical place
people go for the home loans although it
doesn't have to be you know the only
place that they go for the home loan. So
taxpayers should distinguish personal
investment and business interest. So now
we have personal kind of interest but
the interest could still be for the home
now which is a personal investment which
could be deductible investment interest.
So now you have a situation where you're
trying to generate revenue but it's
typically passive income. That's why
it's kind of a different category and
business interest if you owned the same
property but it was part of your
business then you would think it would
be deductible not on the schedule A but
on like a schedule C as as a
business income.
Overview of the home mortgage interest.
Home mortgage interest is commonly
deductible on a schedule A but remember
you have to clear the threshold even
then it is the thing that typically
often could push people over but that's
not the one and only reason why you
should buy a home
but it could be calculated in the cost
benefit analysis to think about how much
home you could you can afford although
it's more complicated than you would
think. You have to run the projections.
The deduction generally applies to
primary residence and one second home.
So this is where it gets weird on the
itemized deductions. They kind of sell
it like where it's the American dream to
own a home and this and that but you you
get into second homes and I know it'd be
a you know a nice dream if we had two
homes, but obviously that would you
would think that's benefiting more
wealthy individuals on the personal side
of things. The argument I think for that
was that, you know, people that go to
Congress sometimes have a different home
in Congress or right. So now they have
two homes that they have to deal with,
but they're doing public business over
there or something, you know, but
anyways,
that's your primary So so now notice
this also introduces another rule. Like
if it's a home, a property, I have to
define it as the primary
residence or a second home. So right. So
now I have these What does it exactly
mean to be primary and second home
versus
you can imagine a home then being used
partially or totally for rental
property, which kind of compute confuses
the situation if I have one home, which
I'm using partially for rental property
now, but I pay one mortgage on the place
or I have five homes now
and then I have to categorize well, I
have one and a second home could be a a
a a one and a second and then
investment, right? So now you have these
different
categories that you can think of that
are going to cause kind of different
problems. You can imagine a rental home,
you can have multiple homes, one rental,
one non-rental, you can have one home
that could have a rental component to it
and so on. So then we have a mortgage
interest must relate to the qualified
residence debt. So now we have this
problem of what does it mean to be
qualified residence debt? Now in a
normal situation, it's pretty
straightforward. You you buy the home,
you get a loan out from the bank in
order to pay for the property. Note that
the property is now yours
just to structure this in our minds. A
lot of people kind of jokingly I think
it originally was a joke to say that,
you know, the bank owns 80% of the home
because what happened? I bought the
home. I took a loan out for 80% of it.
Therefore, the bank owns 80% of it.
That's not exactly correct. You own 100%
of the home, but you owe the bank 80% of
the value, you know, of the home in
dollars.
And uh and if you don't do that, the
loan is collateral and therefore they
can foreclose on the home. What's the
difference between that and the bank
owning the home? Well, the bank as long
as you pay off the loan doesn't have any
control of what you do with the home. If
they owned the home and had an 80%
interest, they would come into your
kitchen table and as you're as you're
eating, they would tell you what kind of
color they want you to paint the outside
of the house or something. They can't do
that. They can't do anything unless you
don't pay off the the mortgage. So, the
reality of the situation is you you got
the loan in order to buy the home. The
home is yours. You can do whatever you
want with it, but the the the the home
is collateral. Therefore, if you don't
pay off the loan, there is recourse,
limited recourse, but the recourse could
be, you know, repossessing the home.
There's a difference there. Any case.
So, interest is commonly reported on
form 1098 mortgage interest statement.
So, most of the time that's usually
pretty easy because you buy the home and
get the loan from a standard financial
institution. But again, you can imagine
getting a loan from other sources than
financial institutions where, you know,
again, their their process might not be
as streamlined to properly categorize
the loan interest and so on. Home
mortgage interest is often major
itemized deduction for for homeowners,
so it's the big one typically, but as
they increase the standard deduction,
it's really the home ownership in the
high cost of living areas that it's
likely to lead to these large
uh loan amounts that might in and of
itself kind of push us over the
threshold from itemizing from standard
to itemize.
Mortgage interest deductions can
significantly impact uh tax planning.
So, obviously when you buy the home,
that's a that's a big decision in and of
itself and it could have tax
implications, but those tax implications
have to be thought out carefully in
terms of the purchase process as well as
the changes of those tax implications as
time
uh passes.
IRS rules uh limit deductibility in
certain uh situations. So, qualified
residence interest. So, qualified
residence interest generally includes
interest on on acquisition indebtedness.
So, a straightforward thing uh a home
purchase is pretty straightforward,
right? You buy the home, you get the
loan out, you put 10 to 20% down or
whatever, and you take the loan out to
to to pay for the other 80%. Not all the
payments on the loan are deductible,
just the interest portion is deductible,
which could be quite significant if it's
a substantially expensive home. So,
acquisition debt is debt used to buy,
build, or substantially improve the
home.
This becomes important because you can
imagine a situation where someone's in
financial difficulty, and as a financial
planner, what would you want to do?
You'd want to say, "What kind of debt do
you have and how can we reduce the cost
of those debts?"
The largest interest on most on debts
are usually going to be from credit
cards or possibly uh auto loans and and
things like that. And it would be nice
if you could say, "Well, what I'd like
to do is consolidate that into the home
using the home as collateral." Why?
Because the fact that the loan is
collateral means that the bank might
allow a lower interest rate and it's tax
deductible if it were to qualify.
But the IRS wants to limit that because
because again, the whole purpose here in
in theory is to help you buy
uh the home. It's not so that you can
buy a car and then refinance the car
under the home so that you get a
deduction for the amount of of the your
car purchase. You see, these are the
externalities. These are from from uh
from a Thomas Sowell perspective that
the past level one tier thinking, you
know, I I you could see the ripple
effect that happens with these kind of
things uh as they go through and then
they got to go back and and put in new
definitions which further complicates
things uh as as we move forward. So, the
home generally secures uh the debt. So,
when you buy the home, the home becomes
like collateral on the debt. That
doesn't mean the bank owns the home.
That means if you don't pay off the
loan, then the then they have recourse
on it. But they can't show up at your
kitchen table and tell you to paint it
pink because uh because they need I
don't know, whatever they A qualified
residence usually includes the
taxpayer's uh main home, obviously. A
second home may also qualify under IRS
rules.
Uh mortgage proceeds uh used for
non-qualified purposes may uh reduce the
deductibility. So, now this gets
confusing again because you could
imagine a situation where you're trying
to help someone out on their debt and
they bought this expensive car and they
got this debt everywhere and they have
these high interest rates on their
credit cards and you would still think,
"Hey, it would be beneficial. The bank
will give me lower rates if I can
consolidate it uh with a home with a
with a with a house as collateral
because that's less risk to the bank."
So, so now you So, you could still end
up with a situation where the collateral
on the house is being used to finance
debt that wasn't used to build or
improve the home. And then you get these
weird situations of well, which amount
of the debt that has the home as
collateral is deductible and which is
not
deductible, right? You So, you have to
be careful in those situations. Uh
usually it's fairly straightforward, but
you got but you but when you get in
those muddy areas. So, interest on
unsecured personal loans is generally
not deductible uh on schedule A. So,
interest on unsecured loans. So, now the
now the house is basically not
collateral. You would think if you used
if you used the loan to buy the house,
normally the financial institution or
whoever gave you the money would want
the house as collateral, but you can
imagine situation where it wouldn't be,
in which case the IRS is going to be
skeptical of the structure
as something funny's going on, you would
think, right? So, main home and second
home rules. A main home generally
includes the taxpayer's principal
residence. A second home may include a
house, condominium, a cooperative,
mobile home, or boat. So, the property
generally must include sleeping,
cooking, toilet facilities. So, now you
end up with a situation where people are
going to be like, "Hey, that's great. I
would like to have some kind of second
home where I can finance something and
have it be deductible. What if I just
buy a boat cuz I want a boat?" Well, a
boat isn't really a home, but it could
be. But, you have to So, then So, what
what do I have to do to the boat so I
could possibly buy my cool boat, but I
still get to deduct it like a second
home? Well, the property generally must
include sleeping, cooking, and toilet
facilities, right? If it doesn't have
those things, if you just have a
speedboat, then it might not qualify.
So, again, you you end up with these
kind of ex- these kind of things that
are rippling out from this from these
rules that happen on the interest, which
personally I I don't think they probably
shouldn't have been in there in the
first place, but they're hard to remove
after they've already been in
in in there,
>> [laughter]
>> so the taxpayers may generally choose
which property is treated as a second
home. So as long as they qualify for it
under the rules. So now you've got two
properties that qualify. You have a
principal residence and your second
home. Well, is the houseboat your
principal residence and the second home
the secondary or the other is your you
know, which is the principal residence?
So this also becomes an issue when you
sell the property, right? Because when I
sell the property,
then I might have this exemption
situation on the principal residence.
Well, that means I have to have a
principal residence. So you could end up
in a situation where well, if I want to
sell my boat,
but I'm going to have a gain on it.
Maybe I move into my boat long enough
for it to be a principal residence. You
know,
and then I can sell it and and basically
not have an not have a gain on you know,
you again, you end up with these kind of
weird type of of scenarios or tax
planning that could come up
because of these specific rules that are
based on interest being deductible, but
only in specific areas even though it's
personal property. So rental use of
second home may create additional
limitations. Now usually if you have two
properties
that second property is is either going
to be vacation property or it's going to
be your boat or whatever or it's going
to be or it's going to be
or it's going to be rental property. Now
if it's rental property, then it's not
really your second home where the
interest would be deductible on a
schedule A. It would probably still be
deductible, but on a schedule E. So now
we have different kind of definitions of
of the property and the deductibility of
the of the interest depending on those
definitions. Now if if it was rental
property, then it makes sense that the
interest would be deductible because
theoretically the the purpose of that
property is revenue generation and you
had to have the debt in order to
generate the revenue. That's an ordinary
business expense you would think.
So so you would think that would be more
likely to be deductible than your
principal residence which is clearly you
know personal.
So mixed personal and rental use may
require allocation of expenses. So what
if you have a home it's your principal
residence but you rent out it's a big
home you rent out part of the home.
Okay well now we have a problem because
like the part of the home that's being
rented out you if the whole thing was
rented you would think that the that the
the rental portion and the loan applied
to it would be deductible. If it was
your personal residence you would think
normally it wouldn't be deductible
except that they made an exception that
it is deductible but they're deductible
in separate areas. The the personal
residence deducted on the schedule A and
the and the rental property on the
schedule E. But it's only one house and
you have one loan on it. Therefore
you're going to have to prorate or do
something you would think with the
interest basically taking the square
footage maybe of the rental property as
a proportion or ratio to the total
square footage and deducting it in the
proper place. So so if you have one
property but you're renting part of it
then that then you get this messy kind
of kind of situation
there. So vacation homes often require a
special analysis. So now what we might
have a whole another thing on schedule E
vacation home which of course is
something that comes up with more
wealthy individuals. More wealthy
individuals are usually types of
taxpayers where you're going to have
more complex tax returns but do less
taxes spending more of your time on like
tax planning. So mortgage debt
limitation rules. Deductibility of
mortgage interest may be limited based
on loan balances. So now we the the IRS
remember the the the the the marketing
pitch on being able to deduct mortgage
interest is that the owning of the home
is the American dream.
But if you start to say that you have if
you have these loan balances that are
massively high, it's kind of like really
do we really need to be supporting, you
know, a really like these cuz cuz if the
loan mean if you're borrowing a million
dollars, that's the loan. So you would
expect that that that that, you know,
that you put 20% down so that so the
house price would be even higher than
than that, right? So so that seems kind
of kind of excessive when you're when
the sales pitch is like that
the American dream is to own just like a
home, you know. So current law generally
generally limits acquisition
indebtedness
interest deductions. So
>> [snorts]
>> interest on debt above statutory
thresholds may be non-deductible.
Refinanced debt may retain acquisition
debt treatment in some cases. So home
equity borrowing rules change
significantly under the recent laws.
So so SALT work can help us with those
limitations, but they're usually going
to be more significant when we're
actually doing tax planning instead of
the tax preparation for higher income
individuals. Uh taxpayers should review
current IRS limitations carefully. Large
mortgages may trigger partial
disallowance calculations. Again, that's
usually going to happen on, you know, a
pretty high higher income or higher
thresholds. If it does happen, it could
kind of complicate and make us think
about, well, how exactly are we going to
figure this thing out because
uh it's based on the on the a
loan amount and we're trying to figure
out the deductibility related to the
interest, right? So, you probably have
to you know, you could do a imagine a
ratio calculation. But in any case, home
equity loan interest. So, home equity
loan interest is not automatically uh
deductible. Interest may qualify if loan
uh proceeds are used to buy, build, or
improve the home securing the loan. So,
uh when we think of the house purchase,
obviously when we buy the house, you
would think that you're going to get a
loan in order to complete the purchase,
putting 20% down, take it a loan to
possibly buy the rest. Now, over time,
you might pay off that loan so that so
and the value of the home might go up.
So, remember that the from a property
standpoint, the home is the one property
which you're
expecting hopefully will increase in
value. Most other property, personal
property, does not. Meaning, if you buy
a car, it's going to go down in value.
It's going to depreciate. If you buy if
you buy a lawnmower, it's going to
depreciate in value and so on and so
forth. The home, because it's it's
limited real estate, just the real
estate itself, may have it go up uh in
value instead of deteriorating
over time. So, that means that over
time, one, you're going to pay off the
loan, which increases the quote equity,
which is going to be the the the the the
value of the home minus the loan that
you own on it, the amount you would you
would get net if you sold it in in
theory, although we don't really know
what that is until we actually sell it.
And we're hoping that the value of the
home goes up in value, just because of
location, location, location, if nothing
else, which would also increase the
equity even if the loan amount was the
same. That adds the ability to say,
"Hey, bank, I you were willing to give
me 20% loan. Well, now I've paid off
some of the loan and the value is worth
higher if I give you this appraisal, I
would like to borrow more money against
the loan. Okay, great. But remember, the
IRS isn't in the business of doesn't
want to
to allow you to use that money to just
do anything with it just cuz the loan is
collateral because the the objective of
the whole thing is supposed to be to
allow you to buy a home. So it's they
shouldn't they don't really want you to
go buy a car
and then finance it with the home
because because that defeats the
purpose. So you end up with these weird
situations where you would like to to to
support things with the home, but the
IRS wants to limit it to when you buy
the home, build the home, or improve the
home, not using it to consolidate your
other debt on cars and and interest or,
you know, to buy personal stuff is is
the general problem here. Okay. So
personal uses of home equity proceeds
generally do not qualify. Using home
equity funds for credit cards or
vacations usually does not create
deductible interest. This becomes, of
course, a problem because it's still
like something that people would want to
do, right? Because you could say
I I I still might want to take the use
the equity in the home as collateral to
give me money to pay for these other
things, but now the the same mortgage
interest is going to give me as a tax
preparer this this documentation and I
have to somehow figure out what the loan
proceeds were actually used for, which
might not is not typically going to be
on the on the 1098 form. Okay, so then
so documentation of how proceeds were
used uh is important. So whenever you
take out a new loan, if you're going to
be building to the home, you want to
make sure that documentation is there so
that in the event that you have an audit
and they say, "Hey, look, you you you've
got this new loan. Did you use the loan
to actually improve the home? We're
going to have to prove that in in an
audit. Taxpayers should maintain records
tracing loan proceeds. IRS focuses
heavily on use of fund analysis. So, if
you take out a loan using the home as
collateral, if you want the
deductibility of the interest, then
you're going to have to prove that you
used it in the way that the IRS wants
you to use it, you know. So, refinance
mortgage interest. Refinance acquisition
debt may continue to qualify for a
deduction. Cash-out refinancing may
require a separate tracking of the loan
pre-
proceeds. Interest related to
non-qualified cash-out use uses may be
non-deductible.
Okay, so you have a common situation of
of a loan. If you took the loan out and
at the time you took the loan out, the
interest on the loan was like higher, it
was like 8% and then at some future
point, the the interest rates are at 3%.
Well, now you can imagine a situation
where you're going to change the loan,
but you're not going to actually take
out a new loan. You're not You're not
trying to get more money necessarily
to put to put into the house. You're
just trying to take advantage of the
change in the interest rates so that
you're paying less on the borrowing. And
you would think in those cases that the
that the refinance loan, the interest on
it would be deductible in in most cases
because why? Because the use of the
money is still to finance the home. It's
just that the the the
the uh
uh debt or the amount that you have to
pay for the usage of the money is
reduced because the market has changed.
So, points paid on refinancing are often
amortized. So, now you have this whole
thing about points become a problem
because you can because there could be
an issue with the definition of what are
points, what do points actually mean?
And some points could be basically
thought of as interest. And so if if
they're interest, then we might be able
to amortize
the interest or the points over the
lifetime of the loan. Or you could use a
more complex calculation, an effective
calculation, but that's the general
idea. Refinancing can affect future
deductible interest calculations.
Taxpayers should retain refinancing
closing documents. So the closing
documents are going to break out what
the funds were used for and give you
these points calculations and whatnot to
make sure that we're
doing that properly. So
the hardest thing about the the home
purchase is usually in the time or year
the home was purchased. We want the
closing documents and the loan
documentation to make sure that we're
properly doing the amortization for the
points or whatever, and then that we
have the loan about calculated properly,
and we've got the breakout of deductible
interest versus not deductible. Fine.
And then the refinancing. If a
refinancing happens or new loan happens,
we want to make sure that we have those
closing documents so we can get the
points calculated. And then once that's
already done,
then it's pretty easy from there if it
was done properly to start with cuz we
can just follow the procedure that
happened in the past. So from a data
input tax preparation standpoint, it's
basically like
we want to do extra research when we
first have the loan on the books or the
refinancing, making sure we have
everything properly allocated and
documented. So going forward, it should
be pretty easy so we can just copy what
we did last year. Deducting points.
Points are prepared
prepaid interest paid to the to obtain a
mortgage. So interest is something that
typically we pay over time, right? You
pay it over the life of the loan. So, in
this case, we're talking about points
that are prepaid interest paid for the
mortgage. So, you paid it up front, but
the IRS doesn't want to give you the
deduction for the interest that was all
paid up front because if you could just
categorize interest
and say you paid it earlier, you can you
can manipulate the whole thing. So, you
would think that you would have to
allocate the points then over the life
of the loan, possibly using an effective
method, meaning more interest up front
later at the end, like the loan
payments, but that's kind of a pain. So,
often times you might be able to use a
straight-line method over the 15 or
30-year loan period or whatever. Points
may be deductible in the year paid under
qualifying circumstances. So, purchase
of a a primary residence often receives
favorable treatment. So, again, we want
to determine what are the points, what
are not points, what qualifies as
points, could some of the points be
deductible up front? If we could deduct
it them earlier, that would be better
than later. If we can't do that, then
could we just do a simple amortization?
That's usually the easy thing to do over
the life of the of the loan. And then,
once we do it in year one, it'll just
populate automatically in the software
after that, or do I have to use a more
complex kind of method for the
amortization of the interest? So,
discount points and origination fees may
receive different treatment. Closing uh
disclosure helps substantiate deductible
amounts. So, IRS rules for points are
highly specific. So, non-deductible
mortgage-related costs, principal
payments are are not deductible. So,
obviously, when you make the loan
payments, it's not the whole loan
payment, it's just the interest portion
of it.
Homeowner insurance premiums are
generally not deductible as interest.
So, in other words, if you have a high
loan, you might have to get a homeowner
loan kind of premium
uh and so on. Ti- Title insurance costs
are generally not deductible. Appraisal
fees are generally not deductible.
Settlement and escrow charges are often
are often uh deduct- non-deductible.
Uh utility costs are not deductible.
Mortgage interest and most personal
living expenses remain non-deductible.
Now, note that all of these things here
are are common types of things that
might be in like a closing statement uh
and whatnot. And you might say, "Well,
why wouldn't they be deductible if
interest is deductible?" And the real
question is, "Why is the interest
deductible?" Because the interest is on
a personal residence. So, the whole
thing is the whole prop- the whole
weirdness here is happening is because
we're doing a personal thing, but we're
getting the deduction of interest for
some reason, which I think is mainly
political, right? And then and so and
then we have to very much limit all
these other things. Whereas, if it was a
real estate property, you would think
most of this stuff would be deductible
because it then would be a normal
business expense to generate revenue of
rental income. So, investment uh
interest expense overview. Investment
interest expense may be deductible on
schedule A. So, now we're talking about
some kind of investment uh property.
Deductible generally applies to interest
incurred to produce investment income.
Now, investment income is an in- income
generation thing. If it was on a
schedule C and it was it was uh uh
uh something you're actively involved
in, then it would be clear that the inv-
that it would be deductible. But,
investment is a category of passive
income, which which the IRS is going to
be more skeptical of and have more
limitations on, such as having it on the
schedule A as opposed to uh uh
deductible elsewhere. Deductible
generally applies to interest incurred
to produce investment income. Investment
interest is commonly reported separately
from the mortgage interest. Deduction is
generally limited to net investment
income. In other words, you can't really
have more they don't want they're going
to give you limitations on the losses
because it's a passive income. So they
feel like they're giving you a benefit
by allowing you the deduction at all
because it's passive income and not
active income. Meaning you're not
actively involved in it really. And then
and
and they're going to limit the losses.
So they don't want to have losses on the
passive. So excess investment interest
may carry forward to future years. So we
always have this kind of thing of well,
if I can't get the deduction this year,
it's kind of not fair. It's a legitimate
deduction. So it should be that I can at
least match it up against income in the
future. Meaning you have a carry forward
situation. Form 4952 is commonly used to
calculate limitations. Investment
interest differs significantly from
business interest. So examples of
investment interest. So margin account
interest may qualify as investment
interest. Interest on loans used to buy
taxable investments may qualify.
Borrowing to purchase stocks or bonds
may create deductible investment
interest. Now notice some of these are
kind of really
kind of
risky things for for the most part.
Meaning you're leveraging, right? So now
you're saying look, it's a business play
that I'm doing here. I want to buy
stocks and bonds, but I don't have the
money to do it. So I'm going to take out
a loan to buy the money on the stocks
and bonds. You're highly leveraged. So
you could like if the stocks and bonds
go up in value, it could work out great.
but if they go down in value, then that
could be a problem. From the IRS's
perspective, this isn't as useful of
economic activity as starting a going
business, like a schedule C kind of
business, because a schedule C business,
you're actually
providing something that people want.
You're generating revenue. When you're
doing this, you're basically
speculating, right? You take a loan out
to speculate
on the market going up or down. Right?
Which isn't something you really want to
incentivize, right? It's not really
exactly a business, you know. So,
interest related to tax-exempt interest
is generally non-deductible. Passive
activity rules may interact with
investment interest calculations. So,
passive activities is another kind of
thing that limits possibly losses for
the most part, oftentimes for uh for for
passive activities that you're not
actively involved in. Proper tracing of
borrowed funds is important. Investment
interest limitation often reduce current
deductions. Personal interest generally
not deductible. So, person personal
interest is generally not deductible
under federal law. Credit card interest,
for example, is personal interest
purchases usually non-deductible. Auto
loan interest for personal vehicles
generally non-deductible. Interest on
personal consumer debt is generally
non-deductible. You've got personal
loans type typically do not create
schedule A deduction. Congress
historically limited personal interest
deductions. Tax law generally favors
business and investment-related
borrowing. Why some some interest is
deductible. Tax law often encourages
economically favored activities. So, one
reason is they're trying to stimulate
the stock market, right? How how uh
ownership has historically received tax
incentives. So, that's the political
component. So, they're trying to market
it as uh we're going to give you a
benefit, right? We're helping you out
with the and and so that's politically
useful. Business borrowing is generally
connected to uh, gen- income generation,
normal business activity, so that
actually makes sense. Investment
borrowing may support tax taxable
investment income, similar to the
business income argument, but for
passive uh, investments. Purely personal
consumption is generally not substan-
uh, subsidized through deductions,
meaning if you want personal stuff, you
pay for your own personal stuff. It
shouldn't be subsidized by the tax code.
Interest deductions reflect economic and
policy considerations. Deductibility
rules attempt to prevent abuse and
double benefit. Schedule A versus
Schedule C. Schedule A generally covers
qualified personal items uh, interest
deduction. Schedule C interest relates
to business activities. So, business
interest is commonly deducted against
business income. So, if if it was
business debt, then yeah, it would you
would think it would be deductible.
Business interest often reduces
self-employment income. Schedule C
deductions generally do not require
itemizing. Interest allocation uh,
becomes important when loans uh, have
mixed use. So, if you have a home loan
and then you have a uh, uh, business
part of your home, you have an office,
then you might have a situation where
part of your home is is allocated to
business, possibly prorating the
interest to one portion deducted on the
Schedule C, portion on the Schedule A.
Proper classification affects tax
outcomes significantly. Schedule A
versus Schedule E. Similarly, Schedule E
commonly reports rental activity.
Mortgage interest for rental property is
generally deductible on the Schedule E
cuz it's a business kind of thing for
the most part. Again, rental interest is
generally treated as a business-like
expense. Personal residence mortgage
interest belongs on Schedule A.
Mixed-use properties may require
allocation between Schedule A and E. So,
now you have one property instead of a
business office in it, you have a rental
space within that home, then you might
have to prorate that one 1098 between
the two, EA. Vehicle rental properties
often involve complex allocation
vacation rental properties have complex
rules. So, accurate records are
essential. Common documentation
We have the form 1098 commonly reports
the mortgage interest paid. Lenders
generally issue form 1098 annually.
Closing disclosure support
mortgage-related deductions. So, loan
agreements help substantiate. Bank
statement may support interest payments.
Refinancing paperwork is important.
Investment accounts. So, obviously,
you're going to get the loan out, you
get the closing document whether it's a
first-time purchase or a refinance
or whatever. And then you're going to
get the 1098s typically annually and you
have your documentation going through
your bank for payments that you're
making to verify it. Common audit and
compliance issues. Deducting
non-deductible personal interest is a
common problem because maybe you you
you're not properly allocating the loan
proceeds. Incorrectly deducting interest
on non-qualified home equity debt.
Misallocating mixed-used proceeds,
that's always complicated. Claiming
rental interest on Schedule A. Poor
documentation of refinance debt used.
Deducting principal instead of interest,
can't do that. Failing to apply
investment interest limitations
properly. Evaluating the real tax
benefit. Mortgage interest deductions
may not provide a full dollar-for-dollar
benefit. Many taxpayers may already be
below the standard deduction threshold.
Incremental tax savings may be smaller
than expected, meaning don't let the
mortgage broker just talk you into
buying a home saying that it's going to
be this huge tax benefit windfall.
There's a tax implication, but you have
to make sure that you're you're
calculating it properly. High-income
taxpayers may receive larger benefits
from deductions.
Taxpayers should evaluate after-tax
borrowing costs. Homeowner deductions
should not rely solely on tax
deductions. Economic and lifestyle
factors remain important. Interest
deductions and the housing market.
Mortgage interest deductions may
encourage home ownership. That's the
argument. I again, I'm not sure it's
totally the as big an argument in the
long run as they map it to be because
again, the markets kind of compensate
for it over time. Tax incentives may
influence housing market. Real estate
market may partially price in tax
advantage. They certainly do. Tax
benefit often vary based on income and
location. High-cost housing areas may
produce larger larger mortgage
deductions, meaning
high-cost areas and high-cost states are
usually benefiting from this the most
from a you know, tax benefit. Interest
deductions can indirectly subsidize
borrowing. Policy makers continue
debating the effectiveness of these
incentives. What's new for tax year
2025? Mortgage interest limitations
remain important for homeowners. Home
equity loan tracing rules continue to
apply. Investment interest limitation
rules remain in effect. IRS continues
emphasizing documentation and
substantiation high interest rate invest
environments may increase taxpayer focus
on deductions. Refinancing activity may
create additional compliance issues and
the taxpayers should review the final
IRS instructions. So, what are the key
takeaways? Schedule A allows deductions
for certain qualified interest expenses.
Home mortgage interest is the most
common deductible personal interest.
Personal consumer interest is generally
non-deductible. Investment interest
deductions are subject to limitation
rules. Business and rental interest are
generally deducted outside of the
Schedule A. Documentation
is critical. Taxpayers should evaluate
the actual economic benefit when making
decisions. IRS instruments and
publications provide detailed guidance.
The resources for further research
include You can find these at the IRS
website irs.gov irs.gov or at least
start there. You've got the IRS Schedule
A instructions 2025, IRS Form 1040
instructions. We've got the IRS
Publication 936 Home Mortgage Interest
Deduction, Publication 550 Investment
Income Expense, IRS Publication 17 for
Federal Income Tax. You've got the Form
595 I mean 4952 Investment Interest
Expense Deduction. You've got the Form
1098 Mortgage Interest Statement. You
can look at the instructions. Internal
Revenue Code Section 163
163H.