Submind YouTube summaries
Thumbnail for Is Luxury Makeup Worth It? Drugstore Alternatives That Look Identical

Is Luxury Makeup Worth It? Drugstore Alternatives That Look Identical

Watch on YouTube

Video summary

The video explores the concept that high-end luxury makeup products often have affordable drugstore alternatives that perform just as well if not better, primarily by saving consumers significant money without sacrificing quality. The host begins with lip liners, comparing Fenty Beauty's long-wearing "Trace Out" line to Morphe's Signature Lip Pencils in similar shades like Girl Talk and Bubble Teeny. While the luxury version offers superior longevity, the drugstore option provides an almost identical texture and color match at a fraction of the cost. This trend continues with lipsticks, where Maybelline's Color Sensational is presented as a fantastic dupe for Charlotte Tilbury's Pillow Talk Fair; although there are slight differences in sheen, both formulas deliver a creamy satin finish that feels luxurious on the lips. Moving beyond color cosmetics to skincare and treatment products, the host highlights impressive formula matches between expensive brands and their budget-friendly counterparts. A standout example is the setting spray comparison between Charlotte Tilbury's Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray and ELF Makeup Mist & Set; despite being released years apart, they share nearly identical active ingredients like co-polymers that fill pores for a flawless finish, with the drugstore version offering double the size at a much lower price. Similarly, Olaplex No. 7 Bonding Oil is compared to L'Oréal's Extraordinary Oil Miracle Hair Serum, which provides comparable hydration and fragrance without weighing down fine hair. The host also notes that while Fenty Beauty glosses are unmatched in their specific pillowy texture, Revlon Super Lustrous offers a very close alternative for those seeking similar hydrating effects. The review expands to face products including highlighters, primers, blushes, brushes, and concealers, where the differences between luxury and drugstore items become increasingly negligible upon application. Haus Labs' Glassy Opal stick highlighter is matched with Morphe's version, which dries down slightly faster but delivers an equally beautiful glow on the cheeks. For priming, Hourglass Vanish Airbrush Primer finds a strong rival in L'Oreal Prime Lab 24-hour Pore Minimizer, both of which blur pores and create a perfected skin texture using similar dimethicone-based formulas. The host also demonstrates that Rare Beauty's luminous blushes can be effectively replaced by Catrice baked blushes with comparable pigmentation and sheen, while Patrick Ta contour brushes are shown to have affordable equivalents in the Real Techniques collection that offer even more versatility for various makeup types. Finally, the video concludes with a look at concealers, where NYX Wonder Skin is praised as an exceptional alternative to Tower 28's popular serum foundation concealer. Both products spread evenly without creasing or looking mottled throughout the day, making them suitable for mature skin that requires lightweight coverage. Throughout the presentation, the host emphasizes checking ingredient lists and swatching colors side-by-side to verify performance rather than relying solely on brand reputation. Ultimately, the message is clear: consumers can satisfy their desire for high-quality makeup without breaking the bank by choosing these well-researched drugstore dupes, allowing them to allocate savings elsewhere while still achieving a flawless look.
Read the full video transcript
Hey friends, you know the drill. We're going to do cheaper and better alternatives to your favorite high-end and luxury makeup products, but I don't use the D word because apparently some companies don't like the D word, so it's right here. However, that's what it is. We are looking at all kinds of substitutions that you can use that for me are just as good, if not better, because of how much money they save you when you're going to purchase them. That's exciting. Now, I don't have a lip beyond. We're going to do that first so I can share with you the lip products that I found and I found some fantastic ones. And also we have that number system and all you have to do is watch the number on the screen, go down into the description box, find it, you'll find the color and everything else in case I don't say that to you. Let's get started. The first one is lip liners and I absolutely adore the Fenty Beauty traced out, let's see, the Fenty Beauty traced out lip liners. Now, these are special because these really are very [clears throat] long wearing. The one that I'm going to show you isn't super long wearing, but it's got the same texture. However, these are just there's something different. This one I think it's called bubble teeny. Let me find my spectacles. Got me spectacles by the way, you guys. I'll make sure I link them for you. I think they're fun. So, [laughter] this one is called, let's make sure I got that right, bubble teeny. Yes. So, we're going to put that on this side of the lips. I can't talk while I'm doing this. So, enjoy the fast forward. So pretty, easy to work with, but the one that I got that I think is very very close is from Morphe. And this one, look at that colors. They are so dang close. Maybe Maybe has a little bit more blue in it, but I kind of like that. But as far as the actual formula, it's really close. It just doesn't last as long as the ones from Fenty Beauty. Got to fill in the corner. I will do that now with Bubble Teenie. All right, look at the difference. No difference, right? And yet you're saving so much money with going for the Morphe. So, I think this is a fantastic dupe. I'm so excited to bring that one to you, and I better tell you the name of it, huh? Let's talk about the name. The name is the Morphe signature lip pencil pencils, and this is in Girl Talk. So, Bubble Teenie and Girl Talk. So pretty, love them, excited to bring those to you. Now, the next one is a lipstick. I feel like they've been talking about Pillow Talk forever, but when Pillow Talk Fair came out, I was like, oh yeah, because I always felt like Pillow Talk was just a little bit too much. This goes so well with the lip liners that we're using today. So, this is Pillow Talk Fair, very pretty, and it's very very smooth. It is a satin lipstick. So pretty, but your one that is going to be so close is from Maybelline. It is the Color Stay, and I think it's Color Stay. It might be Color Sensational. There we go. This one is Peach Buff, and it says it's matte, but it's not that matte. It actually is very creamy, and it seems to me, yeah, it probably has a little bit less of a sheen than Pillow Talk Fair from Charlotte Tilbury, but it's really darn close, and when you get it on your lips, you can't feel that this is matte at all. It actually feels more like a satin lipstick. Look at how close those are. Mhm, I can't believe the color on them is just so good. And then, the only difference is the sheen on it. So you got a little bit of sheen here and not much there. But oh my gosh, you're saving so so much money. So that's our number two. Our number three is from Fenty Beauty. And these are the ones that are her gloss bombs, just the regular ones with a little bit of shimmer in them. Now this isn't a color match. This is a formula match. If you've ever used these, they're very pillowy, they're very soft and luxurious, and they really do give you a ton of hydration. I don't even know if you can get this one anymore. I think I got it during the holidays. It's pretty close to what we're going to be looking at right now. Fussy Flex. Yes, I think it says Fussy Flex. So this is so pretty. They are just these lip glosses that really bring your lips to life. I just think that they're ones that really knock it out of the park. I love them so much. But guys, if you want something that is so close, go for the Revlon. These are the um ColorStay ones, I do believe. Super Lustrous. Revlon Super Lustrous The Gloss. Now again, this is not a color match. However, this is a formula match and it is so luxurious again. It just feels fantastic. And look at how close that is, even on what we're talking about for a color. Let's put this one on our finger or or hand here, so you can see, and I will tell you what the color is in just a second. And this we'll put the Fenty one on the other side. I'm going to say that the one from Revlon is going to be more color saturated. Not on all of theirs, because I do have another one right here, which is called Lean In, and it's really pretty. It's a pink. Um I'll show you it as well. Just a really soft light pink to go over things, not really to have any color. This one that is the color pretty close to the color match. I would say that's pretty close. Uh this one is called Dusk Darling. So pretty. Just love these so much. Give your lips so much life. Give them that juiciness, the hydration. I love them and you again, you're saving some major dollars here. First of all, I'm going to share with you how budge-proof those ones from Fenty Beauty are. Look at that. Isn't that incredible? So yeah, that that is where you are kind of, you know, doing the alternative just for the money because they do really have a budge-proof formula on the Fenty Beauty lip liners. They're pretty darn good. Next one, hold on to your butt because I honestly was shocked. I am somebody that goes down the rabbit hole of looking at ingredients also when we're talking about alternatives. And one of my favorites forever, for a very, very long time, has been the Charlotte Tilbury Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray. The mist on this is fabulous. I will say I have not found very many that really can come and compete against that mist. However, like this one, this one is a little bit heavier than ones I've gotten in the past. Um but the ingredients have not no alcohol in them. They have other ingredients in here that that do hold your makeup on, but they have these little cold polymers in there, which are little polymers that go in and they airbrush your face. They just make you look like your skin is just flawless. That's what the name is for. However, I was like, I remember so much about there being another one and I when I started to remember it and think about it, I was like, holy moly on a stick. You guys, this elf makeup mist and set, this has been out, oh my gosh, way before Charlotte Tilbury had hers. Go pair compare ingredients. You're going to be shocked. It's like the first three or the first four ingredients are exactly the same. The first one is water, obviously. But, oh my word, it has the same co-polymer in it, the little polymers that fill in pores and make your skin look absolutely flawlessly airbrushed. It has the same hydrator in there, which is an alcohol, but it's not the bad alcohol for you. Oh my word, I was in shock. So, this is my find for 2026. I am so excited and I am in shock, I'm telling you. The only difference is I'm not crazy about this mist. It's kind of spitty, but I can deal with it because this is so expensive, but this is a huge one, like a double one, and it is so inexpensive. But, compare ingredients. You're going to be shocked. I'm not kidding, you're going to be shocked. And so, yeah, cuz just go do it, take my word for it. Next, we're going to talk about this product, my favorite hair oil from Olaplex. It's the number seven bonding oil. I have very fine, very limp hair, and this oil is fabulous for my hair. You need an oil for your hair, whether or not your hair is fine, the and you need one that's not going to weigh it down. And this does not. I am so impressed with this oil. It has this fantastic smell to it. It is weightless. The bottom of your hair is an open tube. It's either broken off from you having breakage, or it's cut off when you get your hair cut. So, you need something that's going to seal it, hold the moisture in. This is what does it. So good. But, this is expensive. This is like $30 for this. L'Oreal comes in for the save and it is L'Oreal LV Extraordinary Oil Miracle Hair Serum. It is really good, too. I would say that this might be a tad, and I mean a tad, not a lot, heavier than the other one. But, it has a wonderful fragrance to it. Same thing. So, your hair's going to smell good besides. And it does not weigh my hair down. I actually use a little bit less of this on my hair than I do the Olaplex. I love them both, but I'm here to tell you, this is $30 and I think, sorry, backwards, I think that this one is probably holy cow, I don't know, maybe $15 at the maximum for what, like 40 times as much? I'm I'm exaggerating. Four times as much, five times as much. It's amazing that we can [clears throat] get these products at the drugstore that are every bit as good and we can satisfy our want to have the very best, but we don't have to break the bank. I've been talking about this one for quite a while. This is from Haus Labs. This is for stick highlighter. It's a balm-like product. So, you're going to want to put this on top of your makeup. You're not going to want to use this under or anything like that. The balm itself on this particular one has a little bit of an opalescent sheen to it. But, mostly it's just the product is super balmy and makes your skin look a little bit wet and gives you that pretty sheen. Hopefully, you're going to be able to see it here and we can just compare the two. Glassy Opal is what this one is called. But, again, Haus Labs is sometimes untouchable, but what isn't untouchable is Morphe. Now, Morphe came out with these stick highlighters. They have a little cap on them inside, so the top screws down, so you're holding in the moisture, and then this has a cap on it as well. And again, same exact product, although I feel like the Morphe one feels more cooling, and it doesn't really have any sort of an opal in it, but by the time you get it on your cheeks, you're not going to be able to tell a difference there. Hopefully, as I'm turning this, you can see the Morphe is over here, and the House Labs is over here. I will say that the Morphe does dry down a little bit, and the House Labs doesn't. I like that because I won't feel like during the day that I feel sticky or anything like that, but I do have that little bit of glow, that little bit of sheen, and I think that they are a fabulous substitution for the House Labs because we can't maybe afford that amount. Let me switch here. So, here's the one right here from House Labs. Here's the one from Morphe. I love these. I think they're so very pretty, both of them, but save yourself the big money. One of my favorite primers of all time when they came out with it was this one from Hourglass. It is called the Vanish Airbrush Primer, and it is so pretty. Now, this one is almost gone. I have used it clear down to nothingness, but it is so beautiful. I'm going to have to put it down here. It has the effect of giving you that blurred, just very perfected look on your skin. It has that dimethicone in it. You can feel it. It feels like it's going to fill everything in. It doesn't feel sticky, and yet it does feel like it's going to give your skin that airbrush look. It is beautiful under makeup, and your makeup looks flawless, but I did find from L'Oréal Prime Lab. This one is the 24-hour prime pore minimizer. And this one has AHA, LHA, and BHA in it. Blurs pores, skin looks smoother over time. So, we're getting a little bit of ingredients that are that skin-loving ingredients in there as well. So, we're getting a bonus with the L'Oreal. Here it is right here. Little tiny dot. The pink and Wow. It goes on You know what? It feels a little bit more moisturizing. So, you're feeling a little bit of cooling because you're when the air hits it, it's kind of dissipating that moisture. But, I am telling you texture-wise, wow, exactly the same thing. And as I wore them on my face, I could not believe that a side-by-side comparison showed me that these are identical as far as the way they perform. But, wow. For me, this was a no-brainer. Rare Beauty came out with their blushes that are the luminizer and the blush in one. And it's really a pretty product. Now, you have to be somebody that likes having a glow on their skin. You can't be somebody that just likes a matte blush to in order to wear these. First of all, look at this brush right here. How saturated that is. So, you're going to want to kind of tap tap tap in order to not get too much on you. But, already, can you see that sh- really beautiful sheen on there? So, I already put the other thing on here, but let's just kind of tap tap tap on here. We're going to kind of glow up big time. Now, I've got the balm on there. That probably wasn't the greatest thing. But, anyway, you get the gist. They're pretty. They're beautiful. They have color in them. Catrice. Catrice came out with their soft glam baked blush. And that's what this product is right here. It's a baked blush. Let's We better look at that. Yeah. You know me. Okay, this is in Hope, by the way. This is the powder blush. Just says powder blush. It doesn't even say illuminating blush. That surprises me. But, you get the gist. So, here is the one in Hope from Rare Beauty. Let's swatch it so we know exactly what we're dealing with. So pretty. It is not a blush that is going to knock you over, but it does have that extreme highlight in there. Catrice came out with their baked blushes as well, and we have this color in What color is it? Da-da. The color is and I don't think these are color match, but I do Midnight Berry. But, I do think that this formula is exactly the same. This has a luminous finish to it. This is going to have more pigment in it, but it is almost identical when you are looking at how they have the sheen and the performance of the two. I will say that the Rare Beauty one, let's switch this here. I will say that the Rare Beauty one does have a little bit finer of a mill on it, and it's not quite as powdery. However, they're both powder products, they've both been baked, and they do look very, very similar. This is a Patrick Ta brush. It is an angled contour and blush brush. It's very light. It's very airy. It's very fluffy. It's so pretty. It's a beautiful brush. It does the job so well. It really does a great job of chiseling things out. If you want to do your nose with this, it's an easy way to do this. However, this bugger is pretty darn expensive. Real Techniques, look you guys. Look at this. So, I actually like the Real Techniques a little bit. It's a little more fluffy. With the angle brush, which is right here and is the same, it's a little bit easier to go in around the nose and buff it out a little bit to definitely chisel everything in. Little bit fluffier on the end of the blush brush. I actually like that, too. I would use this one more for powder or bronzer or that kind of thing. These are exactly the same. I'm not kidding, they're so close. But, guess what? For the price, we're not just getting this brush, we're getting all of these brushes in here as well. I was shocked. I was in absolute shock that you get all these. First of all, this little bugger right here is a dupe for the Beautyblender one, this one right here. I use this every day. I use the Real Techniques one. I'm too excited. The Real Techniques one all the time as well. But, here you're getting this in this little package, too. And I cannot wait to use this particular one right here. It is a straight liner brush, and I can't get it out right now, but I'm excited to use it as well because it has this liner in it. You could very easily do the stamping on your eyes and get a really soft look with your eyeliner on that. So pretty. You have a foundation and a concealer brush right here. You have another foundation brush right here as well, which is the angled one. It's actually smaller than the normal foundation brushes that are out there, which is nice. I actually love to do cream other cream products with this, bronzer, lighter, blush, anything like that. So, you're getting this entire thing right here with this brush for a fraction of the cost of the Patrick Ta one. Hello. I mean, obviously, this is such a good deal. I could not believe what a good deal it is. So, yeah. Buy this, not that. Oh, baby, all the way. All the way to the bank. One more, do we all know that my favorite concealer of all time is Tower 28? I have mine in K-Town. I think it's 7.0. It is so pretty and I absolutely love it. I love that it is a serum foundation. I love that it spreads out very evenly. I love how it wears. It doesn't crease. I love that it is super thin for my 58-year-old skin and it never looks bad underneath my eyes. It always looks so good. In locks. >> [laughter] >> I was so surprised at this. I'm really surprised because I never thought that I would ever find anything that was as good. This is the NYX Wonder Skin. This is the wonder Why do they put these things where you can't see them just even from space if you got problems? Wonder snatch. This is the up to 24-hour wear concealer. Mine is in natural. Okay, not a color match just so you know that. It's a little bit darker but I did that on purpose. I love this stuff. I absolutely love this stuff. This to me has been one that I could easily change out. It doesn't matter. You could very easily put these on me and I would tap them out and I would go, "Oh, I don't know which is which other than the color right now." But, it is so good. It doesn't crease. It doesn't look mottled during the day. It doesn't look make me look older. It's very easy to work with. It's very thin but very pigmented at the same time. Very, very good. I'm so excited about it. It is a great alternative at the drugstore. All right, boom, boom, that's it. Everything I wanted to bring to you today. I'm so excited to be doing these for you. These are your very favorite videos and they are some of my favorite videos to have fun with and bring to you especially when I'm looking at ingredients and we're talking about the big bucks. And besides that, how much controversy has Charlotte Charlotte Tilbury had up right now. If you don't know, you need to go on to Instagram or you need to go on TikTok and find [clears throat] out because there's a bunch of brouhaha going on about Charlotte Tilbury. Everybody's kind of lost their mind about it, but yeah, we'll stay down-to-earth here as usual. I love you guys so much. I had a lot of fun with this video today. I haven't been filming for a while, but I did have fun. No, my back is not any better, so I am on a Cossacks pillow right now and yeah, my butt hurts, but I have only got two more videos to film and then I'm all done for the day and I hope you did enjoy it. So, if you did, please give it a thumbs-up and if you're not subscribed, please do because about 40% of you or 60% of you, I can't remember, are not subscribed to my channel and you have no idea how much it would help me if you would subscribe to my channel. Make sure you know that everything that I have on is going to be down in this description box as well. So, the the top, the earrings, and all the makeup will be down there along with the nails as well, unless they're sold out. So, thanks for being here with me. Have a great week or weekend wherever this video catches you and please come back and see me very soon in my next video. Take care of yourselves. Love you much. Bye-bye, friends.