Illuminating Viruses: Synchrotron Methods in Virology with Marjolein Thunnissen
Watch on YouTubeVideo summary
Marjolein Thunnissen from the MAX IV Laboratory introduced synchrotron methods as powerful tools for virology, leveraging highly intense X-rays ranging from infrared to gamma radiation to study biological structures at various scales. The presentation detailed three primary techniques that have revolutionized viral research: protein crystallography, which has historically enabled drug design and capsid assembly analysis despite being partially superseded by cryo-electron microscopy for large viruses; small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), a solution-phase method ideal for analyzing molecular size and shape without crystallization to study folding kinetics and vaccine stability; and soft X-ray cryo-tomography, which allows label-free 3D visualization of frozen-hydrated cells by exploiting the differential absorption of light between carbon and oxygen. These methods collectively facilitate the investigation of virus structure-function relationships under realistic physiological conditions while supporting high-throughput fragment-based drug discovery through specialized beamlines like BIOMAX.
Beyond structural analysis, synchrotron imaging provides critical insights into viral infection mechanisms within living systems by revealing how viruses alter cellular architecture without destroying samples or requiring complex reconstruction. For instance, soft X-ray tomography has been used to visualize SARS-CoV-2 infected lung cells, showing specific changes in organelles and membranes, as well as observing the Simplex virus remodeling nuclear membranes into nodules. Hard X-ray tomography offers a complementary approach similar to hospital CT scans that enables researchers to examine cellular-level vascular remodeling in heart tissue and abnormal blood vessel patterns in lungs from pathology samples during pandemics. Furthermore, combining these imaging techniques with spectroscopic methods allows for tracking viral entry pathways, such as respiratory syncytial virus moving into the cytoplasm and endosomes, while vibrational spectroscopy serves as an additional tool to detect viruses through cellular fingerprint changes at facilities like SOLEIL and SOLARIS.
Looking toward future applications and infrastructure development, the speaker highlighted Project Orion in Brazil, a biosafety level 4 laboratory construction that will integrate Sirius synchrotron technology with three unique beamlines dedicated to soft X-ray tomography, tender radiation studies, and hard X-ray tomography. Accessing these advanced facilities involves navigating specific pathways such as peer-reviewed open calls for academic research or paid contracts for industry applications, alongside options like fast access modes for urgent scientific needs and feasibility studies to validate sample viability before full proposals are submitted. The laboratory also supports researchers by adapting labs to biosafety level 2 standards and providing necessary data processing infrastructure and expertise from building staff to ensure successful experiments.
The session concluded with an emphasis on the expanding capabilities of synchrotron science, including upcoming webinars focused on Ebola viruses and protein production, as well as a forthcoming Panda symposium in November featuring keynote addresses by experts like Jonathan Grimes and Mel Landau. These initiatives underscore the importance of multimodal approaches that combine various spectroscopic and imaging technologies to understand complex biological processes under realistic pressure and temperature conditions. By fostering international collaboration through projects like Project Orion and maintaining open access routes for both academic and industrial sectors, these facilities continue to drive innovation in virology, ultimately supporting the development of new therapeutics and a deeper understanding of viral life cycles from atoms to whole organisms.
Read the full video transcript
Okay, so it's 1:00 maybe we start. Um,
welcome to uh today's seminar. Um, it's
my absolute pleasure today to introduce
myoline and tisen to you. Um, I met her
in March uh when I've been visiting the
university um of Lunt at the MX 4. She
will probably present to you and I was
really impressed about what the Max 4 um
offers. So um Mayoline is the senior
science advisor of the MEX 4 and who
doesn't know yet what the MAX 4 means.
So this is an Swedish national
laboratory uh laboratory providing um
scientists with um X-rays for their
research in collaboration with the L
University and as I told you it's really
impressive. I think you have 16 beam
lines on uh running and there's even
capacity for 12 more I read in the
internet. I'm not sure whether that's
[laughter] correct but I found it there.
So um by my line she um studied um
chemistry at the kingan university in
the Netherlands and she also received
her um doctoral um degree in chemistry
at this university and already as an um
undergraduate she became fascinated um
by unraveling the complex complex
structure um function relationship um of
proteins using X-rays and myoline has um
solved several protein structures. She
has been a posttock at different
universities for example the Glasgow
University. Um she has been a postto at
Croningan University and also at the um
department of molecular biology at the
Stockholm University where she then also
became an um associated um professor. In
2001, myoline um came to Lund um to
coordinate um the construction and the
development of a specialized protein
crystalallography beam line at the MEX4
lab and then since then she has been the
science coordinator for structural
biology at the MEX4 and associate
professor at the MEX for Lund
University. She also had been the head
of the user office of the MEX 4 and the
life science director of the MEX 4. And
currently my is the senior science
advisor at the MEX 4. And this means
she's involved in coordinating the
activities between um uh researchers,
scientists and and the MEX 4. This
involves a lot a broad spectrum of
applications including protein
crystalallography or cutting edge
imaging techniques, small angle X-ray
scattering and I'm sure you will hear
more about it in the next minutes. So
Marioan, thank you very much for taking
the time today um to give us an insight
into the world of synretron methods and
for providing us with food for new ideas
um how to implement this um techniques
in our research and hopefully also start
some um exciting collaborations in the
future. So I'm very happy that you're
here today and the stage is yours.
>> Thank you very much Ava for this very
kind introduction. Um the lecture I will
give is actually it's going to be an
introduction lecture and I'm going to
both highlight what synretrons are and
then I go into what synretrons have
meant for fology. It will be a little
bit historic, a little bit of an
overview, not very deep and really an
introduction in in what we can do and
hopefully followup events at Panda will
actually go much deeper into into the u
the matters at hand. So let me start
sharing.
So share and now I just have to start
the presentation
and I think this should work because we
tested it.
>> Mhm. Yep.
>> Um so um my lecture is called
eliminating viruses in control methods
for viology and I I thought because this
is really the first uh in a webinar
series organized by panda. Panda is a
theme at the links institute. I thought
I would make it really really an
introduction into basically the heart of
what panda is doing. So we're looking at
uh viruses understanding the virus and
fighting the virus as well as
complimentary methods all to actually
understand viruses more by the use of
synretrons and neutron facilities.
So as um Ava already said um I'm
actually part of Max 4 and this is an
area of Max 4 at the end stages of when
it was being built. Um it's hosted by
Lun University but it is also a national
laboratory. So it's a Swedish national
laboratory and in that sense it's run by
both Lun University and the National
Science Council.
Um I will talk at the very end of my
talk a little bit about how you can get
beam time at Max 4. So I'm not going to
go into that. I'm just going to say that
we have currently about 300 staff
members and we are the first what is
called MBA or multiband acromat based
synretron. And what that actually has
meant is that we have gone from a
facility where you can take photos of
material to a facility where you can
make movies of material and this is very
very broad but it's a huge step forward
and you need a lot more x-rays to do
that and that is what this technology
has brought us. But let me start from
the very basics
um to what we actually provide to our
users and that is light.
And um we we all know what light is but
I I still want to go through this
because I think there are some concepts
where I think it's good to to to know
what we're talking about. So as we all
know light is electromagnetic radiation
and it is formed of waves of different
wavelengths.
Um we we can see light the the visible
light but there is also light that we
cannot see and that light is especially
important for work at at synretrons
and this light can be infrared
ultraviolet x-rays and gamma radiation.
So if we look at the spectrum of light
the electromagnetic spectrum and we go
in the wavelengths you can see that and
I for for very long wavelengths radio
waves
you those we don't produce at the
synretron but what we produce at the
synretron it's actually from infrared
all the way to gamma radiation and there
is this relationship that longer
wavelengths
light
um has a lower frequency or a lower
energy while shorter wavelengths have a
higher frequency and a higher energy.
And this comes back quite a lot because
we talk about hard and soft X-rays. We
can also look at it a little bit like in
this picture. And this all picture also
highlights why we want to use different
types of lights because with different
types of light we can actually study
differently sized objects.
So if we go to hard X-rays which are
around 10 the minus 10 we really really
can look at atoms. Well, if we go to
longer wavelengths, let's say 10^ the
minus 7, we can see viruses. So
depending on what you want to study, you
kind of pick and choose. Um, and uh this
becomes very important at the synretron
because we have the capability to do
that.
Now X-rays are very important and we
know already that from the very very
start that X-rays were uh discovered
um because with X-rays you can see the
invisible and this was shown from the
very very moment almost the very moment
that found I discovered X-rays. So this
is the famous hand of his wife um one of
the first X-rays that that has been
made. Um and and this really um shows
that you can look through material and
and see things that you otherwise
wouldn't be able to see.
Of course, this was
150 years ago. Nowadays, we have
different methods to look at the
invisible.
So, if you work with X-rays, we actually
use three different methods um broadly
speaking. So the the first one is
imaging which is basically still the
same kind of idea as run's hand
uh but we can go in much more detail and
we can go to the nanometer or beyond
level to look at um to look at material
and to understand organization of matter
and matter can be on a cellular level.
It can be tissues. It can can be all
kind of different things.
Um very many experiments use scattering
and defraction. Um this is my field. Um
so I will talk mostly about this later
on in my talk. Uh and scattering and
defraction really um allows you to see
details on at atomic level. And then
finally you have spectroscopy
um which allows you to understand the
electronic structure of materials and
the chemical state. So these are the
three main methods that are being used
and I will show examples of all three.
So now what is a synretron?
So a synretron is basically an
accelerator of electrons and these
electrons we keep them then in a
circular ring and we used magnets to
actually steer these uh steer these
electrons to go around. And you can see
um in the picture you can see max 4
again and in the big ring um the
electrons go around a circumference of
527 m and they go around at almost the
speed of light. And this is also quite
important because if the electrons are
bent or we make them go through a kind
of slalom
um they will start to lose energy
and that energy is actually produced
that light
and that's the light that we then give
to our users to study many different
systems and we have applications from
medicine to hard physics.
So we produce light and we provide users
with light
and synretron light has very many very
special properties.
The the first one is that it's extremely
bright. Um it's very very intense. If
you look at a single ray of singleton
light it's much brighter than the sun.
Of course this we we talk here about one
ray and the total output of the sun is
of course much much bigger than a
synretron but in that single single ray
from a synretron the light is much
brighter.
Um, as I already pointed out, uh,
synretron light has a very wide energy
spectrum all the way from infrared to
gamma.
And it's tunable in the sense that we
can through monochrometers and insertion
devices pick out the light that we want.
It's polarized
um and that means that it can interact
in different ways material and it comes
out in small pulses which means that um
we can even use a time resolved uh
approach.
I also should say that it's really
really focused. So that means that it
becomes a very very tiny
ray of light that we can then match very
tiny samples with.
So if you look to a synretron
um we have different different
components that are being used to keep
these electrons going around. Um so we
always have an injection system. Um so
the uh electrons are produced in what we
call an electron gun and these electrons
are then injected into the storage ring.
We have then bending magnets that keep
the electrons going around and these
bending magnets are then also this one
of the sources um where light is
produced.
We also have other insertion elements a
wigler and an undilator
and these actually create slalom kind of
trajectories for the electrons and
because there many ups and downs and the
electrons start to wiggle they start to
produce light light and it becomes
stronger and stronger and stronger. So
these really really enhance the light uh
by many factors.
um in the picture in the little movie
that I now show this is from a synretron
that is called Astred which is in
Denmark in Orus. It's a very small
synretron but the principles are the
same. So we have the electrons that are
produced in the electron gun then
they're injected into the ring. Now in
this synretron the electrons in the ring
um are now bunched together so that they
form like very dense little pulses where
a lot of intensity from each pulse can
be achieved. So now you start to see
that the electrons are pulsed and then
going through the banding magnets you
can start to see that light is being
produced.
This light then goes into the beam lines
that you can see um shown here. Um and
then in the beam line they will hit a
monochromator where the the colors where
the color is selected in this case
green. It falls on the sample and then
in the detector uh the signal is then
collected and the data is written um to
the computer systems.
Maxuru is a is quite a big
singleton compared with with with um
with um Astred which is really small but
we work in the same way. Um in the top
left corner we have our electron gun or
our electron uh gun facility. The
electrons go into a purple device which
is called a lin. I can actually yeah a
linear accelerator and in this linear
accelerator the the the electrons are
then accelerated to almost the speed of
light. Max 4 actually has two different
storage rings. Uh a lower energy one and
a higher energy one. So depending on the
energy uh if you want to have the lower
energy the electrons are then pumped
into the small ring or they continue get
accelerated even more and then pumped
into the big ring. Uh and then at both
of these rings we have um the different
beam lines.
Now if you wonder how it looks like
inside a storage ring um sorry this is a
picture of our big ring and at the right
hand side you can actually see a tube
and that is the tube through which the
electrons go around. All the rest that
you see are magnetic devices. It's a lot
of analyzers. It's pumping. It's water
cooling. It's a lot of other stuff
needed to uh to run our synretron.
Now if we go to the beam line, um the
beam line also has a typical build.
Um so this is a very typical
crystalallography beam line. U
crystalallography beam lines are quite
often almost the simplest beam lines
that you can have. Um, and the elements,
the big elements that they use are a
monochrometer to pick out the exact
wavelength. And then we use focusing
mirrors to focus the beam. So to really
make it the size of our sample, but also
to place it exactly on the sample
position in our experimental hutch.
Then of course we have diagnostics
because we need to know where the beam
is and what shape and what intensity
and to to really shape the beam we use
slits. And then at the very end we have
experimental setup which is in the case
of a crystalallography beam line a
defractometer
which is actually uh a device that that
holds the sample but also rotates it. Um
we have a sample changer and a detector.
And similar as for the um synretron
itself, this is a picture of an
experimental hutch, in this case Biomax.
Um and what you can see is uh on the
right hand side we have the sample
changer. Um this sample changer can
actually hold 400 samples. Um then in
the middle where it says Arinox that is
our
very fancy sample holder where we can
very very precisely rotate, translate
and manipulate the position of the
crystals. And then on the left hand side
you have the detector. Uh and you look
actually at the back of the detector.
As a set we currently have 16 beam lines
at max 4. Um, I put here plus one
because we have a 17th beam line now
under construction. Um, the hutch has
been starting to build since last week.
So, it's it's real now kind of. And
these beam lines, they all kind of
specialized for for their technique. Um,
and they can be used for many different
types of studies. And like I already
said, um, one of the big things is that
we want to make movies or we want to
study material under what we call more
realistic conditions. So that can be um
looking at pressures, looking at heating
up um looking at catalysis for a protein
crystal um and and those kind of
studies. And this is what we call INC2
inner porando. The other thing that we
really want to that we really really um
working on is multimodal methods. So
combining for example defraction with
spectroscopic methods at the same time
on the same sample uh so that we get
complimentary information on the same
sample and I show actually um in my
lecture later on uh why this can be
important.
So now I actually will go much more into
the science. This was a short
introduction of of synretrons. Um and I
will go much more into the science and
like I already said the three big
methods that we are using are scattering
and defraction, imaging and spectroscopy
and quickly these actually show atomic
structure, micro nanoructures and
electronic structure. And all the
examples on this slide are actually life
science based.
Um and this shows that that um
synretatron has much to offer for life
science including for work within
viology.
For us, um, one way of of working, um,
with the beam lines and also with, um,
associated laboratories and instruments
is that we really like to think about
problems in biology need to be addressed
at different length scales.
And um, we have a set of beam lines um
that really allows to go to different
length scales.
So we have beam lines that are dedicated
to to um protein crystalallography
that's biomax and micromax where you
then can look at the atomic length
scale. We have beam lines dedicated to
scattering cosax and formax um which
really goes much more into micro
structures and molecular complexes.
We can go to imaging microscopy beam
lines like nanomax and softax
where we go from organels and cell
biology kind of questions and we can
even go to larger length scales using
the tomography capabilities of DMAX and
uh formax.
We also have a a couple of associated or
well
associated instruments. We have the Lund
University KUM facility uh for life
sciences and we also have AFM infrared
and optical infrared capabilities and
these are highly complementaryary to to
the beam lines and uh that we have.
So I will now go into how synretrons
have contributed for f viology. And the
the way that I'm going to approach this
is that I'm going to go basically from
the right hand side of the picture to
the leftand side and show examples on
the way. There is one little excursion
into infrared because infrared is very
difficult to actually uh pinpoint in
these length scales. Um but my main
journey will be from left from right to
left. So I will start with protein
crystalallography
and I think also historically um that's
the right way to do it. So I will start
with with a bit of um yeah history.
Well, first of all,
I I do think that it's probably the best
known method within life sciences that
is being used at the synretron. So, I
cannot um not talk about it. I'm also
myself a protein crystalallographer. So,
um there is that as well.
Um so
we all know that for protein
crystalallography it's important to
really have a pure enzyme protein
uh whatever you want to study or a whole
virus. Um we then have to crystallize it
and then we can collect data process the
data and get the structures and get the
hypothesis and ideas and uh and so on
and so forth. So the big thing here is
of course that that this method works
with crystals.
Um but it has been extremely successful
and it also has been really important
for phology
and the first structures of plant and
human viruses
um of capsit of whole caps
um they were already determined at the
end of the 1980s uh middle 1980s
and I think it's also noteworthy to to
actually um observe that the first virus
crystals were already obtained in 1935
by Stanley and this was some tobac
tobacco mosaic virus and he didn't only
grow virus um crystals but he also could
show that these virus crystals were
infectious
which means that the particles inside
these crystals were fully functioning
and I think this is really important so
the particles were fully functional know
inside the crystals.
[snorts]
But um going back to these first
structures of these plant and human
viruses,
um virus crystals, they defract just
like normal protein crystals, but they
defract weekly and the spots are very
close together because these are huge
complexes.
And this means that you have to have a
very clean beam and a very intense beam
to actually be able to collect data. And
here is where the synretrons come in. So
already from from those structures um
these were collected from from a
synretron called chess in northern New
York state in Cornell.
um and it it it would not have been
possible without without access to these
uh to the synretron.
So from the very beginning synretrons
were very important.
um
more modern there have been really
really huge capsites uh solved by
crystalallography and and I think the
record um that I could find anyways is
blue tongue virus
um by um uh Jonathan and now I just my
mind is blank but it will come back
because Jonathan Grimes he is actually a
keynote
later later I'll talk about that. Um but
anyways
um so huge virus capsets could be solved
by crystalallography but I also should
say um that nowadays if somebody would
ask me oh I have I want to study a
capset what should I do I would actually
say use cym
so I I just go a little bit in cym
because I think it's really important to
to say this Um,
Cayama has well electron microscopy has
of course been an essential method for
fagology from from the minute it became
available. Actually, one of the first
electron microraph microraphs ever made
was of a a mouse virus. That's the
little picture on the on the right on
the top. But for a long time, Caillou
was not really the method to go into
atomic details.
and um this hampered the field. But
since 2010 there have been really
revolutionary improvements and now CAM
is really the main method to study um
virus capsets and also large complexes
and the reasons are are manifold. Uh
first of all Kyom is very good for large
molecules. There is no crystallization
required. Um you can work in the near
native hydrated state by by um very
quickly freezing your samples in
glass-like ice. Um you can actually um
look at many different confirmers at the
same time. Uh which gives you really
insight in for example distinct
structural states like empty capsit or
fully fully genome fil capsit and so on.
And for the computational aspect, the
fact that viruses are so highly um
symmetric, this can be exploited in the
calculations to really get very very
high resolution structures.
So cryom if you really want to study via
capsit is the method to go to. Uh you
don't have to use a synretron for that.
Um I think you're much better off with
with cyang.
And you also can see this from um from
the database at Fifer DB which is
actually a a database that contains data
of all capsit solved. And in dark blue
on on in the right hand graph you can
see the structures done by
crystalallography
while in lighter blue the structures by
KEM are shown. And you can really see
that until
around 2010
this change came and and really since
2016
I think there are still a handful of of
uh capsit solved by crystalallography
but the majority is really by cryoam
and that that's really logical.
So I I think this is just a logical uh
way that the field has de developed and
and uh it's it's it's very good because
you can also see that we have many more
structures now
and there are many things many insights
that we have gained through looking at
capsit uh structures. uh there has been
a real understanding how how actually a
virus can build up these very complex
capsits with actually very few proteins.
Um there is an understanding how how the
capsit can be on the one hand very solid
outside the cell but then once it starts
to insert it falls apart and how it can
then fall apart disassembly but also
assembly again. The capsit have also
given us ideas about where there are
vulnerabilities
um uh which then can be exploited either
through vaccine or drug drug design. Um
they also given us ideas for
nanotechnology
um make virus like particles to deliver
drugs or genes or or or vaccines.
Um and looking at the capsit from
different families of of viruses, uh
there are uh ideas about the evolution
and the um those kind of relationships
between viruses but even
adaptations in their host cells.
So I think the the studies of capsits
have have been very very important
but not only capsit proteins uh capsits
have been studied of course by
crystalallography.
Um and again I start with a little bit
of history um because um and these these
are really beautiful structures of of um
the spike proteins from influenza virus
hemoglutin solved in 1980 and
neurominadase in 1983. Um an extremely
important pair of proteins. uh and here
the structure of course have has gave us
a lot of insight in how influenza
adheres to the human cells. Um the
scolidase activity of nurin days but
also
how actually the escape and antigenic
drift mechanisms of the virus work on a
structural level.
Um neuromminades
um is also from another aspect an
important protein because it was
actually one of the very very first
proteins where rational drug design was
used. So in the case of of um
neurominades
um the researchers um [snorts]
Peter Coleman and his colleagues they
really looked at the scaleic acid
binding site and they observed that
there is a little pocket which wasn't
really explored. Uh it's a it's um
pocket dominated by negative charged
residues and they actually designed from
from
there um the first drug Rela.
Um, Valencia is still on the market but
it has also been modified itself further
to to tummy flu and I think especially
when the um I can't the was it pic I
can't remember the name of the influence
in 2009 but but tummy flu was one of the
important drugs on the market um that if
you take it
just when influenza starts when the
symptoms come for the first time it can
actually really really lower mortality
and um shorten the disease. So um this
was really a success for for rational
drug discovery.
But of course many more virus proteins
have been studied
um and all these structures have given
insight in many processes
um from understanding and antion and
recognition replication maturation and
much more. And it is estimated and and
this is just a very rough estimate that
nine to 10% of the PDB entries are on
viral proteins. Of course, many of them
are copies of each other, but it's still
uh an indication that this is really
really studied.
And um when corona was going on of
course a lot of efforts uh have been
done as well in in structure
determination and already in 2020
>> [clears throat]
>> uh most of the uh proteins in corona
structures were available. So um for
really understanding uh viruses protein
structures are are a really beautiful
tool to to to understand um this and
synretrons of course play an important
role in obtaining these structures
and it's not only understanding the
virus but also um obtaining insights in
how the human body works um how our
immune system recognizes virus but also
how virus viruses can escape our immune
system.
Um and and um by studying different
imunog globulins against viruses in
detail, you you can get ideas that can
actually also be used in vaccine um
design.
And finally of course and this is
another example of a corona virus not
SARS but another corona virus
um working um in in complex with a
protease which is important for the
maturation of this this um virus
and and here also by really studying um
the interactions that the corona spike
protein makes with this protease
um it it creates ideas and it is
important to understand
um [snorts]
how these ho how this process of
adhesion but later also uh maturation
occurs.
Um
protein structures also have played an
really important role when it comes to
antiviral drug discovery and I already
pointed out the case for influenza.
Um I think the other case really to
point out is HIV
because without without structural
biology we wouldn't have many of these
um inhibitors and it's in particular the
inhibitors against the proteas against
the reverse transcriptase and against
the integrase
and in the case of HIV um because of
escape mechanisms of this virus and and
the very leaky uh transcription system
it has. Um it it really has been
important to make cocktails of different
inhibitors and we really needed the
overall structural information to to get
there.
Um at Max 4 we also be working with uh
drug discovery and um what we are using
is fragment based uh lead discovery. So
the idea is that we instead of big
molecules like this HTS,
we actually use smaller molecules to get
an idea where things can bind and then
by elaboration make a much quicker
journey intowards lead that can leads
that can lead to drugs.
Now, one of the things with doing this
kind of work is that this means
screening of many many different lians.
And
if you have just one liant, it's it's
actually not that hard. Um, you you soak
one crystal, you mount it, you collect
one data set, and you analyze it. It
becomes hard when you have many. And we
can actually collect easily 400 of these
in a day and then it becomes
problematic.
And what we are doing is trying to make
this easier.
So we have um developed um together with
actually LP3 and um Astroenica and
Ceromics
a facility for crystalallographic
fragment and compound screening. And it
it it um is built onto three pillars.
Crystal preparation so that we can
easily work with so many crystals. The
data collection which is very um reliant
on the stability of our high throughput
uh beamline biomax and then tools to to
really make the data processing and
analysis much more easy to get into.
Now a couple of um examples of the work.
Uh so the first one is is again um
is the results of um
of work on um on a complex of two corona
nonstructural proteins NSP 10 and NSP14
um where there were actually two crystal
forms. um 143 fragments were screened.
Uh and we then uh I mean um the
researchers here uh which contained then
people from LP3 uh as well as uh Max 4
and others um they could get 14 fragment
hits. And I think one one of the nice
things here is that it really also
pointed out where the interfaces are.
And it it gave
not just information about what is
druggable, but it also gave information
about interfaces important for other
interactions. And it's really the the
the start of building a structure
activity relationship for these proteins
on which you can build more um on which
you can then build towards proper leads
for drug discovery.
Another project um and that is going on
is a is a project together with silage
lab in Stockholm uh where we once again
work with viruses. In this case it's um
flavio viruses and one of the things
here is actually of course it's it's
interesting to work on the virus but
it's mainly really used to get all the
systems in place so that it becomes very
transparent for the user uh to come and
do these kind of experiments and this is
in collaboration with CDCs which is a
chemical biology consortium where you
can do virtual screening of a vast
chemical case together with experimental
HTS
um high high throughput screening and
[snorts] together with us we're trying
to really make this into a system that
can be used for drug discovery for
viruses uh for example
so that's all I'm going to say about
protein crystalallography and I'm now
going to change a little bit in length
scale and I go up towards small angle
X-ray scattering
Now small angle X-ray scattering
is a solution method
and um one of the things well it it's it
it is actually
in the nature
quite simple in a way because what you
do is you put your sample for example a
liquid in a capillary into the beam and
it will scatter and then you will will
actually um
collect that scattering pattern. Uh the
scattering pattern is of course round
but we then are smoothly integrated. Uh
which means that we we we take circles
and we integrate the whole circle. So
you get a line going from the middle to
the to the outside and you get then
these kinds of graphs.
And what you can see in these kind of
graphs is that these graphs are really
really dependent on the shape of the
molecule in the in the solution. So if
you have a solid disc, you get this this
red um bumpy bumpy uh line. But if you
have a long rod, it becomes this green,
you know, almost straight slightly going
down. So
this sensitivity to shape and there is
also a sensitivity to size uh makes that
this can be really used to study u
molecules.
So it's a method to analyze the size and
shape of of all kind of things. Um it it
can be proteins but it can also be
vesicles or it can be a combination
thereof. [snorts]
And um it actually covers a very broad
broad range of sizes from 1 nanometer to
1 micrometer.
And important uh to note is that the
samples do not need to be crystalline.
Um so it can be measured in solution
and you can measure it under different
conditions. You can vary the
temperature, you can vary the pH, you
can vary flow, you can vary a lot of
different things. salt concentrations
and so on. And like I said, it's
sensitive for size. It's sensitive for
confirmational change and also
structural fluctuation.
So what can you do with sucks? Um
so you can look at protein size and
shape. You can determine whether
proteins are folded, unfolded or
disordered.
You can look at the oric state. Is it a
monomer da tetma and so on. You can look
at assembly and disassembly and I will
show some examples.
Um if you go to lipids you you can look
at billayers and membrane structure. You
can look at internal messes.
We can look at higher organization such
as lipid nano bodies. Um and we can
actually look at changes in organization
because we can actually study the
effects of temperature, salt, pH and so
on. And um we can do this in a high
throughput manner which can actually
mean that you you really look at
formulation conditions.
We can study protein lipid or RNA lipid
interactions
and we can combine it quite easily with
separation techniques such as SAK or
AF4. [snorts]
So
just a couple of of examples uh how
people have been using um sucks in
biology. So um both of these examples
have to do with with with assembly and
um maturation.
And if you look in the in the left hand
side, you can really really see that
there is a difference at the bottom of
this graph and the top uh between how
these sucks curves look like. So the
bottom lines are always for monomeic
capset proteins and they don't they they
don't really show features.
But when you have a full virus as the
top, you start to see these bumps.
And in this case, people have now
measured different sax curves uh in
different concentration of salt and at
different temperatures. And then by
doing that they can actually start to
think about assembly processes and
kinetics of assembly processes.
In the left hand side, it's a maturation
of a of a capset going from a pro capsit
into intermediate forms and to the real
capset which is a kind of closing
locking down um process. And you can see
that that in this nicely rainbow colored
graph that you also there can follow the
process by doing sacks.
So you can do these time resolved or
or yeah series of sex measurements to to
really understand um
what's happening
and uh chef at all in 2020 actually
could by using these methods really
start to look into the kinetics of the
uh assembly and disassembly of a
hepatitis B virus capsit where the
assembly is much faster than the
disassembly. Uh one is minutes and the
other is hours and this kind of of work
can was completely done based on on
sacks and uh a bit of kio to to
validate.
we
sax also has been very very important um
for especially the way that nucleic acid
vaccines have been developed.
Now we all know that these nucleic acid
vaccines the mRNA vaccines have been
extremely
um powerful a Nobel Prize probably the
end of the corona pandemic
um quite a lot um of of things happening
there
um and sex has been quite important to
to really um getting there and I will
actually FL Y. So now one thing about
mRNA and and everybody who who has
worked in a in a microbiology or
biochemistry lab knows that mRNA is
pretty easy to to fall apart. So it
really needs to be protected and to
protect it you know you use something
which is called a lipid nanob body and
um these are kioam pictures um of lipid
nanobodies which is basically um uh it's
it's
I mean it looks like
membranes on top of membranes on top of
membranes so it's this very structured
kind of lipid lipid monollayers that
form these kind of complex nanobodies
and these nanobodies they are really
really excellent to give protection to
mRNA
but that protection can't be too good
because they have to fall apart when
they come into the body so the nano the
lipid nanobodies they actually can
easily transform membranes
and then within the cell they have to
fall apart because then the RNA has to
be used to make the proteins. [snorts]
So
um the lip lipid nanobodies they have
been studied by sacs really to see how
different lipids and how different
processes to produce them affect these
uh these these nanobodies structure
stability and performance
and sax is really a good method to do
that because it's in solution it works
on these scales it's quite sensitive for
for this kind of organization
So, it's it's it's a really good method
to do that. And we can actually because
a sex measurement is pretty quick. Uh, a
single sex measurements is probably
not even a second. So, you you can
easily collect many of them very very
fast. So you can actually do systematic
scanning of conditions and thereby
really find the the um
the the the kind of formulation the kind
of set of conditions to make the thing
that works for your particular vaccine.
Even more, you can couple it to new
separation methods such as um asymmetric
flow um which makes it really an
essential tool. So
um this is another example from actually
the cosax beam line at max 4 where we
have an integrated AF4 system now at the
beam line and people use this to
actually look at um empty and cargo
loaded liquid nom particles.
So, AF4 is is really a nice separation
method if you want to um separate
small from very big things because it it
is actually um it it tears it apart a
little bit better than than the
classical systems.
Um and like I said um it's really really
good for bigger things uh such as nanob
lipid nanobodies. So it has been very
important for vaccine development and um
it probably um we will see also things
in gene therapies and other um
approaches.
So now I will actually go into my very
little excursion into spectroscopy.
Um when I was looking through the
literature uh of examples for uh on
virus research
um even though spectroscopy has been
used in life sciences a lot um it hasn't
been used a lot for virus work and I
think one of the reasons is that um
[snorts] most of spectroscopy works with
natural occurring metals
and there aren't that many inology.
ology.
Um so I think there are one or two
examples but they were a bit ex es
exoteric and I thought well maybe maybe
not
but vibrational spectroscopy um infrared
and ramen and I will only talk about
infrared are actually more commonly used
and they also are available at
synretrons um not at max 4 but for
example at the sole
uh Synretron and at um Solaris in Poland
um there are u beam lines that are
dedicated to infrared.
So infrared is actually a really nice
method um to look at changes.
Um so what you get is a label free
insight in in kinetics of cellular
processes. And if you look at the
different classes of molecules that are
in a cell, lipids, proteins, nucle acids
and and sugars,
um each of them will give a a specific
fingerprint. It will absorb at specific
wavelengths in the infrared spectrum.
And what you then can do is you can for
example look at a cell not infected and
an infected cell and then see if there
are differences in these fingerprints.
So it has been used a lot for detection
of viruses
uh even with laboratory equipment
because infrared is also a very useful
laboratory.
Um but it can also really to be used to
monitor cellular interactions and uh
replication.
Um and one example of such um um
and there is I see a mistake in this
slide which bugs me already but anyway
I'll come to that. Um one example is is
infrared of um
hplex virus uh and what happens with
increasing virus particles in the cells.
And if you very carefully would look at
all these graphs, you would see that
infrared shows that there is an increase
in nucleic acids when there is an
increase of of uh virus copies. there is
a decrease in the lipids and there is no
change in protein and um it is um
hypothesized that the increase in
nucleic acid is due to increased number
of chromosomes and not an HPF but an HSF
sorry for that um and and um
not only is there an increase in
chromosomes but there is also an
increase in damaged DNA due to due the
activity of the virus. So you can follow
these kind of cellular processes using
infrared.
There are also really nice examples on
influenza virus um that that actually
produces a um
a co- protein an alternative reading of
its genetic material produces a small
protein that can form a kind of pryan or
fibrals. And this also has been studied
extensively by Inflet
uh and I think we will see more examples
in the years to come because it's an
upcoming method.
Then finally I will go to imaging and I
will actually highlight um one method a
bit longer than the other one. Uh and
that method is actually soft X-ray
cryotomography.
And I should say Max 4 doesn't have this
kind of beam line. Uh but it is
available at other synretatrons such as
um Hazard Bayi in Berlin, Alba in
Barcelona and Diamond in Ditkot.
And what the method does is that you
have a cell culture that you then place
on top of a grid. You freeze it. You
plunge it in um in liquid nitrogen. So
you freeze it very very quickly so that
you get this glass like ice,
you check it and then you you you
measure it um with the X-rays.
Um and you rotate your sample so that
you get different projections that you
then combine using computers to get a
three-dimensional picture of the thing
that you measure.
Now this method um it works in the lower
X-ray energies. So it's a low energy
method
um in an area where
oxygen doesn't absorb the X-rays very
well but carbon does.
And that means that water which is
oxygen
it doesn't show up
but all carbon based material will show
up. So organels and membranes and all
these kind of features of a cell will
show up in in the um in the images.
Um
it means that you don't need to label.
And the other thing I mean if you look
at the resolution and that's actually
shown in the in the in the slide to the
left uh right sorry right um it's
slightly lower resolution than uh cryop
um electron microscopy
imaging but the big difference is even
though it's lower lower resolution
you don't need to fip you can use the
sample
as a whole. So you don't have to
reconstruct by putting all the layers
back on top of each other. No, your
sample stays intact.
So it becomes um it becomes less
invasive.
Um
and um what you can look what you can
see with it is particle distribution
uh particle um aggregation. you can see
changes in membranes uh cellular
architecture and all these kind of
things [snorts]
and like I say it's available at three
different European synretrons and uh
also in the US in San Francisco at the
advanced light source and um also in
Shanghai um at the Chinese synretron
there
and the kind of things you can see is is
these kind of of pictures uh on the left
hand side we we see infected lung cells
with with uh SAS co virus uh where you
then really can look at the changes in
the different um in the different
organals and uh the different membranes
in the in the right hand side um there
is um a case um once again have a
simplex where you can see that these
particles which are called NP which this
nuclear p per p uh something. Yeah. The
nuclear membrane starts to remodel and
you get these small nodules forming and
this method really could look into that
how that works and um and and get more
information uh in these cellular
processes, how the virus actually um um
modifies the cell and and how that
works.
Um you can combine
these spectroscopic methods
um with with you can combine this
imaging with spectroscopic methods in
this case fluorescent
where you have virus um linked with
green fluorescent
um protein uh and you have um the uh
endosomes in red fluorescent
And combined you can start to to to see
the overall architecture by soft X-ray
tomography. And then you combine it with
these other methods to really get a
feeling on how these in this particular
case a rio virus how it tracks into the
cytoplasm and actually goes into the
endoome and uh is is encapsulated there.
Um finally
I would like to to say some words on
heart x-ray tomography. This is really
an upcoming method. Uh and it it really
can be used for looking at tissue and
it's it's somehow related to what one
does in a hospital. Of course, in a
hospital, the patient lies still and you
have the X-ray source circling around
and you get the the pictures. We can't
do that in a synretron. Instead, we have
the sample uh that rotates, but the
principles are the same. And this method
really uh made a lot of breakthrough
also during corona.
Um when looking at tissues uh from
patients or from some actually pathology
um samples
uh people could really really start to
see the damage at a very cellular level
that corona had caused. Uh so in the
heart there was definite vascular
remodeling
uh happening and also in the lungs you
start to see very abnormal
um patterns in in in the blood vessels.
Uh and um this was beautiful work and
and really the first kind of structures
of this level and I think uh there is a
lot more to come um in this area. I also
want to point out that I'm not the only
person that thinks that these methods
are really important. Um, and I think
this is an extremely um
um how do you say um
yeah, it's it's a very nice project to
follow and it's called Project Orion.
It's at um it's in Brazil and it's
actually the the um construction and
building of the of a PSL4 lab um the
first in Latin America. But what is
special about this particular project is
that it's actually linked to the serious
um synretron in Brazil and Sirius is
very very similar to Max 4. So it also
uses MBA technology. It's only a couple
years older and maybe one or two years
older than Max 4. So it's very very
similar. And they're going to have
within this BSL4
laboratory
um three beam lines that are part of the
project. Um CB Pirina which is a soft
X-ray tomography beam line as I just
showed. Timbo which is a tender. So
tender is in between soft and hard. This
is actually quite unique because the
arnot I think this actually the first of
its kind. So we will have to see what it
will produce. And then hibisc
um which is a hard x-ray tomography beam
line as as shown in the last example and
these all will have bsl4
capabilities somehow. So I think this is
extremely ambitious and it will um be
really really nice to follow what
actually comes out of this. And um this
also shows that that there is still a
lot to be discovered because some of
these methods they only are 10 years old
and they were mainly used by pioneers
but of course it has to become common
track now.
So the last um
five minutes probably of my talk I will
talk about um how to actually get beam
time
because I think um if you have ideas um
especially um for saxs for example but
also we have infrared in our hub also in
our facility not at a beam line but as a
site laboratory.
um if you have ideas uh then then I
think it's good to talk about this as
well.
So any experiment at at the synretron is
actually it builds out of different
blocks.
First of all um you have to have of
course your scientific question. Then
you have to prepare your sample and your
experiment. You do your experiment. Then
you have your data processing and then
finally you get your results and um so
what we offer at max is of course um the
experimental time but we also have
additional infrastructures for sample
preparation as well as computing and I
should say that for sample preparation
we are actually um adapting the lab at
the moment to that BSL2
u capability.
so that we are actually able to to
handle level two um samples.
Um I think it's important to say that we
not only offer light or x-rays uh and
instruments to our users but on the
technology side we actually have a lot
of expertise in our building.
um people who know a lot about what is
possible and what is not possible and
that is also part of the offer to our
users
and we do have a data storage and
analysis analysis cluster um it doesn't
go the whole way but it will give a
really start good starting um position.
So there are two different ways to get
beam time at Max 4. The first one is
through peer review. Um this means that
if you have a really good idea, you you
compete uh with other researchers. Uh
through an open call.
This is then um
gone to a peer review. uh proposals are
then ranked on scientific merit and then
if you're if you're high then you will
get beam time and that beam time is for
free. So you don't have to pay for it.
What has to be done is that if you get
results they have to be published. If
you don't publish and you ask for more
time at a certain time it will be no you
will not get more time.
Um you can go the other way. um which is
if you can't publish because it's
proprietary and there are
there are things that you don't want to
publish then you can pay for your beam
time and it goes through a contract. Um
but this is really uh mainly used by
industry. We actually don't allow
academics to go through this route. We
don't allow academics
to pay for beam time. they have to be
reviewed in competition.
We do however have a system which we
call fast access
and I think fast access is actually a
really good way to test the waters to
test whether things are possible.
So we offer different uh fast access
modes. Um the first one um is a mode for
scientific urgency. That can be a PhD
student that needs to finish a last
measurement for a paper so that the
thesis can be produced. Uh it can be
that you sit on a sample where you know
that there's a lot of competition.
Um those go under scientific urgency.
Um you have to make your case of course.
Um we also on some beam lines offer
standard measurement that is a very
precisely described measurements that we
do. Um no no extras
but it can be really important to get
that one spectra that you need for a
paper. But then we have something which
is called feasibility.
And this is really a short experiment
where we look if your sample is
feasible. Do we get anything? Do we get
any signal out of it? uh but also would
actually the data that comes out of it
help to answer your specific scientific
question because quite often if you
don't know the method and we don't know
the science it's it's not always easy to
know that the data actually will really
help. Um but feasibility uh should
actually lead to a general proposal that
then would lead to full beam time.
But it is very good method to come in
and and and really get a feel for what
it is to to use a synretron.
So if you have an idea of an experiment
um what you need to do is to contact us
uh to discuss what beamline would be the
most suitable and then really really
important is contact the beamline staff
and discuss your idea. So once you know
what beam line is the most suitable
really contact the staff because they
can really help. [snorts] They can make
um the design of your experiment such
that it is possible and then of course
you you have to also decide what kind of
access you want to do.
Um
I I will not stop here. Um I think
somehow we need to have this on a labs
web page but contact people for life
science for the different beam lines are
in this list. Um we probably will
produce this on our website one day in
the not so distant future.
And um with that said I I'm almost
finished. I just want to actually
highlight two things. Um this was the
first Panda webinar but there will be
more. Um the the next one is already um
scheduled on the 13th of August on 50
years of Ebola viruses by Nadine
Benedov.
And then on the 26th of August we will
have um a webinar on protein production
by Marlon Beex.
And then finally we will have in um in
be the beginning of November our panda
symposium
um which which goes much more in detail
on many of the things that I'm talked
about. Uh we will have keynote speakers
Jonathan Grimes famous by the blue
tongue virus that I showed earlier but
he will actually talk about influenza
uh Mel Landau from DIY
um on on antimicrobial and peptide
amoids
and then finally uh Marian Janas Arteta
uh who actually is going to talk about
these lipid nonobies and mRNA
And then my final final slide. Um, if
you're interested in Panda, use the uh Q
code and uh you get much more
information.
And I would like to thank my colleagues
at Max for for um some of the slides and
thank you for your attention.