Video summary
Jimmy Carr begins by recounting an anecdote about a friend who uses his phone at night not out of habit, but because he possesses a mind that craves problem-solving opportunities. This concept extends to how people manage anxiety; when the brain is left idle and racing with counterfactual worries or panic attacks, it needs constructive challenges rather than passive worry. Carr suggests that engaging in creative actions, such as writing jokes about political figures like Keir Starmer, effectively redirects a restless mind away from unhelpful rumination. He argues that many mental health struggles stem not from having too much to think about, but from lacking meaningful problems to solve, leading individuals to obsess over distant geopolitical conflicts or other situations where they have no agency and cannot influence the outcome.
The discussion then shifts to the importance of human agency in how we perceive different groups of people, noting a societal tendency to grant empathy and understanding only to those who align with our values while denying it to others. Carr illustrates this disparity by comparing two hypothetical marches: one involving far-right extremists whose destructive actions are met with immediate legal consequences because they lack social license, and another involving social justice activists whose similar acts of vandalism are excused as "the language of the streets." He emphasizes that everyone deserves both empathy for their circumstances and agency over their choices, suggesting that we should strive to treat all individuals with fairness regardless of their background or actions. This perspective challenges us to recognize that while people are responsible for their deeds, they are also enmeshed in larger situations that shaped them, requiring a balanced approach rather than simple judgment.
Carr further explores the psychology of high performers and the pressure to constantly level up, citing Michael Smokes' observation that achievers often view success as merely meeting an obligation rather than something worth celebrating. This mindset creates a perpetual state where climbing higher only raises expectations, making any plateau feel like failure and fostering imposter syndrome even among those who have succeeded significantly. To counteract this exhausting cycle of self-imposed pressure, Carr advocates for changing the "game" one plays or finding new ways to define success, noting that his own comedy career has evolved from purely technical joke delivery to more heartfelt connections with audiences where he treats them like friends without filters. He believes that laughter serves as the shortest distance between people and that genuine connection is far more valuable than simply delivering a perfect punchline every time.
In conclusion, Carr reflects on how modern media consumption often provides an illusion of informedness while actually overstimulating our nervous systems with distant tragedies we cannot fix, such as wildfires seen on airport screens after periods of silence. He admits to feeling addicted to knowing about global events and speculating on solutions, even though he lacks the power to change them, highlighting a common human desire for control in an uncontrollable world. The video ends by reinforcing the idea that giving our minds better problems to solve—whether through creative writing, meaningful social engagement, or shifting career goals—is essential for mental well-being. By focusing attention on constructive challenges and fostering authentic connections with others, we can transform anxiety into purposeful action and find a healthier balance between ambition and contentment in an increasingly chaotic environment.
Read the full video transcript
I was in the gym a couple months ago.
Yeah, and
one of my friends was talking to me
about how his wife keeps on complaining
at him that he uses phone at night and
he's always sending messages, organizing
stuff, running businesses, or whatever.
And he came up with a very fortunate,
but I think actually philosophically
pretty interesting excuse, which was he
said
I've got a mind that likes to solve
problems.
I'm just trying to give it good problems
to solve.
I think lots of people have a
problem-solving brain, yeah, but only
some people have great problems that
they're going to solve with it.
>> Well, that's what I think of with
anxiety. Like I my my my mind is often
racing. Often like wake up
with I suppose what you call a panic
attack at like
4:00 5:00 in the morning. I'll wake up
and my mind's just on and I'll worry
about stuff. And it's it's often
counterfactuals.
Worry about you know things going wrong,
people getting hurt. You know, you just
kind of ruminate on crazy stuff. And if
I give it like I would we know but we
need to write a joke about Keir Starmer
or Andy Burnham or something. You go,
"Okay, right. I have to great.
Give it something to do."
>> So using action as an antidote to
anxiety then. Yeah, I love that. I love
the idea that you go, "Well, that's that
cures it pretty pretty well." It's very
difficult to worry about the future when
you feel like you're moving yourself
toward it. And yeah, that that
problem-solving brain thing is
interesting cuz I wonder how many people
are churning themselves up inside
because they have a brain that likes to
solve problems, but they don't have any
good problems to solve. So they pay
attention to politics or porn or their
ex or
this
situation that's outside of their
control in some foreign country that
they they can't get access to. Well,
having is that not what the news is
though? I mean if you were trying to
design something to
engender mental health difficulties,
you'd make someone aware of a problem
and and give them no agency, right? And
that's what reading about the Middle
East is, right? So you just go it's a
"Absolute [ __ ]
of a situation." And there's nothing
>> Good luck dealing with that.
>> we can do about it. There's nothing we
can
>> Well, there's nothing that you can do
about it. Because if
I don't know. I wonder whether it would
feel better or worse for the situation
to actively have nothing you could do
about. There's an asteroid coming to
Earth. No one can do anything about it.
It's the the simulacrum that someone
could fix this.
But not you.
>> Yeah, I mean, we're not we're not in
that game. It's uh yeah, it's it's very
I think that thing about having
uh
agency at a I think I think that Okay,
there's a there's a bigger thing here,
which is I think we give maybe empathy
to people that we like and agency to
people that we don't like.
So, if you imagine there's two marches,
right? And one of them is like super
far-right uh dudes marching with
skinheads and jackboots.
We give them agency. If they put a brick
through a window, we say, "Right, lock
them up and throw away the key." Right?
And then there's another
um
march, and it's people marching for
social justice, right? And we we And
they throw a brick through a window. We
go, "Well, you know, that's the language
of the the streets, you know, the
unheard." At that thing of like going
So, we give them empathy and them
agency. And actually, you should give
both both. You need agency and empathy
for everyone. Like the idea that you go
believe that people can handle it.
And believe that they're you know,
everyone's got like um a part to play.
>> We need to be responsible for the things
that you did, but also you're enmeshed
in the situation that sort of brought
you to that point, too. Like the
motivations of of what got you there.
But yeah, that that that problems thing
I really do think I I I wonder how many
people would
all that they need are better problems
to solve. All that they need is
something to focus their time and their
attention on in a better way. And And if
you've got this situation that's
occurring overseas. I came back from a a
meditation retreat last week. I'd spent
7 days without my phone
almost exclusively in silence and I came
back and I was flying out of SF and
walked into the departure terminal and
one of the pieces of advice that we've
been given was to put sunglasses on and
put AirPods in because you've basically
been in silence for a week and no
screens, no nothing. Like it's a lot of
stimulus to go from zero to a hundred. I
went and sat down in this some airport
restaurant thing and I looked up at the
screens and it was wildfires in Europe
raging. That was the first thing I saw
on a screen basically since I got right
off of this retreat. And I remember
feeling this like a strange constriction
inside of me. And I'm like
>> I better get a hose.
>> Why yeah how why the [ __ ] is that what's
on I mean what like is it newsworthy?
Like yeah kind of but like what is it do
it's it's it makes us feel like we're
being informed about the world but
really all it's doing is just piercing
our nervous systems and making us feel
worried about stuff.
>> It's strange.
>> And yeah, I want to be informed about
what's happening in the world. I feel
like I I'm so I guess addicted to that.
Like I like knowing what's going on. I
like thinking about what the solution
might be.
>> Mhm.
>> But I guess you don't you know you get
to chat about it but you don't really
get to
influence what happens.
>> Mhm. The gratitude point
is
Michael Smokes got this line where he
says I have a hard time celebrating my
achievements because in my mind it was
my obligation to achieve it.
A lot of people that are high performers
have this sense that the higher that you
climb the further you have to fall. As
you get better your standards are always
going to increase so you're always going
to suck in comparison to what you think
that you should do. That's great because
it continues to push you to work harder
to improve.
>> [sighs and gasps]
>> But also it means that
success isn't a cause for celebration.
It's just the minimum level of
acceptable performance.
And anything less than success becomes a
failure.
>> Yeah, well I think that that thing then
you need to
you need to be in a state of um
uh I guess
imposter syndrome once every 18 months
to years. You need to level up
constantly where you feel like you're in
a space where oh well, this is this is I
can't believe I did that. That was good.
Uh like push yourself a little bit. I
think try and do something else.
>> Is that difficult when you've got close
to the top of your game?
>> Well, it it depends what game you're in.
You can change games. You can you sort
of do things a little bit differently.
So, that thing of like going it's um
it's about I suppose you know my my
business is you know you I'm in the
service industry, right? I'm I make
something that people want. I make them
happy.
>> Mhm.
>> And no one seems to remember any of my
jokes, but they remember how I made them
feel.
And the show tonight is nothing more
than an advert for the show when I come
back next time. That's the way I'm kind
of thinking of it. And then you're
trying to find these moments now. I feel
I mean the show has changed over the
last couple of years where there's
moments in every show there's like a
moment someone will laugh something and
you'll chat to them and it'll be
slightly more um heartfelt and it'll
look there'll there'll always be kind of
there they're kind of sweetening the
pill with laughter.
>> Why did you change that?
>> I I I think it was I I don't know what
happened. I don't know what you know,
went on that I suddenly started chatting
to people in the audience and we started
to connect in a slightly different way.
It's been really lovely.
>> Mhm.
>> And people I think
I think comedy is is a
I love that line laughter is the
shortest distance between two people.
I've often done this thing I've spoken
about it I think to you before about
um
if you your best friend is the person
you have the least filter with, right?
So, so if you meet someone on a plane
and you go, "Wow, I see the World Cup.
It's a good game, isn't it?" Nothing,
right? Surface level. And if you say,
"Oh my god, you have to see these
hemorrhoids. It's incredible." Like
[clears throat] it's a you you know,
it's connecting at another level. You're
just like you've got no filter with that
person. That's your best friend in the
world. And if you treat the audience
like that, you get paid back
um 10 times over. Like people feel that
oh, okay, there's no he's treating us
like adults.
>> Did you know your gut controls your
energy, your recovery, how well you
absorb everything that you eat, and the
one nutrient that keeps it all running
properly is fiber. Well, it turns out
that 95% of Americans don't get enough
of it, which is why I'm such a huge fan
of Momentous' Fiber Plus. Most fiber
supplements are one-trick pony, one type
of fiber solving one part of the
problem. Fiber Plus is a three-in-one
formula built to tackle digestion, gut
barrier strength, and blood sugar
stability all at once. I use this every
single day. It is kind of hard to get
enough fiber just through food alone.
And best of all, Momentous offers a
30-day money-back guarantee. So, you can
buy it, try it every single day for 29
days, and if you don't love it, they
will just give you your money back.
Plus, they ship internationally. Right
now, you can get up to 35% off your
first subscription and that 30-day
money-back guarantee by going to the
link in the description below or heading
to livemomentous.com/modernwisdom
and using the code modernwisdom
at checkout. Congratulations, you made
it to the end of a clip, and the
full-length episode is available
right here.
Go on.