Video summary
The reviewer attended the Los Angeles premiere of *One Piece* Live Action Season 2 and expressed immense enthusiasm for Episode 1, praising its grand set design which successfully recreates iconic locations like Loguetown with a passion reminiscent of Disney World or Hogwarts. A standout aspect highlighted was the natural performance of Jeff Ward as Buggy; his dialogue felt so effortless that it seemed he wasn't even reading from a script, making him arguably more likable in this adaptation than in the anime. Similarly, Usopp and Tashigi were portrayed with grounded vulnerability rather than exaggerated traits, allowing viewers to connect emotionally with their fears and personalities without them feeling over-the-top or unapproachable.
The episode made several bold narrative changes designed specifically for a general audience unfamiliar with the source material, most notably revealing early on that Garp is Luffy's grandfather through a tense conversation between him and Gol D. Roger in prison. This scene was executed well despite its confusion regarding timeline accuracy compared to the anime, as it served to hook new viewers quickly without requiring years of patience to understand character backstories. Additionally, the show introduced Bartolomeo early on, allowing his character arc from a menacing thief to someone with "sunshine in his eyes" for Luffy to unfold within the first episode itself, while also featuring an unexpected cameo by Sabo alongside Dragon, effectively revealing their secret brotherhood immediately rather than saving it as a long-term mystery.
While there were minor criticisms regarding the CGI effects used for Alvida's Slip-Slip Fruit power and some awkward line deliveries during those sequences, these issues did not overshadow the overall success of the adaptation. The reviewer particularly enjoyed specific translated moments such as Zoro retrieving his swords in Loguetown, which felt like a high-quality HBO drama, and the inclusion of classic scenes like Smoker eating ice cream or Sanji catching bluefin tuna that maintained their wacky charm within the live-action world. Furthermore, emotional beats like Luffy laughing while facing execution on the platform were delivered with such impact that they evoked chills in the theater by drawing a powerful parallel to Roger's fate, proving that despite necessary pacing adjustments for non-fans, the core spirit and excitement of *One Piece* remain intact.
Read the full video transcript
Last night, I had the honor of seeing
One Piece live action season 2 episode 1
at the premiere here in Los Angeles.
Here are my thoughts and a review in
under an hour because check out for this
hotel is at 11:00 and it's 10:00 a.m.
Also, I will not be talking about any
spoilers or anything throughout the
video. That'll be at the very end and
I'll give a heads-up when I'm about to.
So, let's go quickly. First off, as an
overall review, I absolutely loved the
episode. There was a lot in the very
first episode. It covers a ton. I don't
remember the the pacing being that
breakneck in the the first season. But,
one thing that still just blows my mind
about the One Piece live action is the
set design and just like how grand it
is. Like them walking into Loguetown, it
it's almost like you think of like
Disney World recreated like Hogwarts or
what is it? Diagon Alley? It's been a
long time since I've seen a Harry Potter
or been to Disney World. You can just
tell there's a lot of passion in it.
Now, standout actors and actresses,
dude, I I might like Buggy in the live
action more than the anime. I'm not
going to lie. I'm not the biggest Buggy
stan like some of you freaks. But, my
god, it almost feels like in the live
action, they don't even give what's his
name? Jeff actor. Jeff Ward. I don't
think they even give Jeff Ward a script.
I think they just say, "Hey, man, get in
there." That's how natural all his
dialogue and everything feels. Now,
another standout from the very first
episode was Usopp. He has a very like
not emotional but like heavy scene. And
I think it's because I haven't ever like
I okay, I've connected with Usopp in the
anime before, but I don't think on like
that quite of a level. I don't know. I
think they just make Usopp in the live
action a more easy to understand person
because it's not over the top like
scared. Kind of like Sanji. Like they
tuned down Sanji's flirting like
obviously in season 1 of the live action
and I think it makes him more
approachable. Same for Usopp. Usopp in
the live action, yes, is scared, but
it's not to the point of like cowering
after every tiny little sound or
possible threat. It's more of like a
real person vulnerability where you're
like, "Okay, anybody else in the world
would be scared right here." So, like I
can put myself in his shoes. I've
already run out of camera angle ideas. I
also want to say which until the end of
the video because I said I would hold
like sort of spoilers to the end, but I
think they did a really good job like
one-for-one as first per se, like
adapting certain scenes from the anime
or manga to the live-action. Because I
know there's a lot a lot of hardcore
fans that like there is these really
particular character moments that they
have to see. But, I think they also see
it as vital to the character and like
who they are in the in the story. Now,
if you remember season 1 of the
live-action where and this is spoilers
for season 1, I guess, and in the anime
technically. Not spoilers for season 2
yet. In season 1, they reveal very early
that Garp is Luffy's grandfather. And as
you guys know that watch the anime, that
doesn't happen until Post-Enies Lobby,
which is like episode 250 or something.
There are again, I'll talk about at the
end of the video, a lot of those moments
in this very first episode. I and if
it's this first episode like this, I
can't even imagine the rest of the
season. Like by the end of the season,
we might see Kaido. I ain't going to
lie, twin. But, I think they're doing
that in a in a way to try to hook in
viewers that aren't particularly
watching the anime because like the
live-action is going to take a lot
longer to come out. And if you haven't
had that connection to the anime or
manga, you're not going to have the
amount of time or patience to be like,
"Okay, where was that character and why
am I supposed to care about this
character? And just because you showed
this character in a flashback doesn't
mean I care about them now." So, I think
they have to rearrange some stuff for
the general audience to make it more
digestible. I think what's also cool is
they kind of started exploring more of
like or explaining more of the world in
this episode in terms of the geography
of everything because I feel like in
season 1, it's straight-up just like,
"Yeah, we're pirates. We're going to go
sail." But, Nami even starts like kind
of breaking down um how the oceans work
and like how they're supposed to get
into the Grand Line, which I feel like
is kind of vital for, again, the normal
audience, the normie, the norman
audience to understand that this isn't
just like a sea. Like, it's it's a very
different, very unorthodox. Can I say
another standout in the first episode is
Tashigi? I I don't know her actress's
name. I'll put her up on screen. Oh my
gosh. Again, very likable character. I
feel like they took her So, in the
anime, from what I remember, at least
from the first time you meet Tashigi in
the anime, she gives off the sort of
like stuck-up, always got straight-A
student. Which like, she's still kind of
likable, but still like she like there's
an inkling that she thinks she's maybe
better than you. At least that's what I
remember from her first interactions
with Zoro and like and and like seeing
him as lesser, but still connecting on
that point of of them both being
swordsmen. Just like Usopp, I feel like
they took her character and made her
extremely likable. She's this
intelligent, but still like doe-eyed,
happy to be there, excited to learn
about swords and find swords. Again,
maybe it's just because I had this
perception of the character in my head
before, but I just I think they nailed
it. Okay, I will talk about one thing. I
know I know, hold your gasps that I did
not like. And I don't know if it's her
fault, but it's sort of Alvida's
character. I don't know if it's the way
lines are delivered, but every time she
was like sort of part of like a
sequence, it felt a little bit awkward,
but I think in part to that, half of the
problem is the CGI for like her ability
and everything. As you guys know, she
has like Well, okay, this is kind of
spoilers for the If you're If you only
watch the live action, this is a spoiler
for Alvida's power. She has the
slip-slip fruit, like where it just
stuff goes off of her. It's not that
it's it's it's pretty simple. And I
think that power is just really hard to
translate to the live action because I
think the only time where I was watching
and I was I was like like I started
sucking my teeth was during those CGI
moments. I was like that just that did
not look good. There's one scene where
she takes her like her Is it a bōguwa?
And she like hits Luffy, but you never
even see it connect. Like it's her
swinging. It's a match cut to it moving
and then it's a match cut to it not
connecting, but Luffy just going flying
and I was like that
It's like early 2000s MTV skit
What what's going on here? But again,
the CGI isn't particularly at fault and
maybe the line delivery, like I said, is
almost a a
direct outcome of that, but yeah, that
was That was probably the only Was that
the only bad part really? Man, Nami's
smiling so much in this season, by the
way. It is so nice. Like I feel like in
season 1 she had to be reserved because
she was still doing all the stuff with
Arlong and was still like under his
control, but now like you you almost
feel like a new energy to Nami and I
feel like the actress Emily Is it Emily
Rudd? I feel like she understood that
completely. Like that she's supposed to
be this sort of like reborn fresh
adventure person. We also got to see all
the actors and actresses on the the red
carpet, at least all I think all the
Straw Hats and then just a bunch of
random characters. And man, dude, I knew
Iñaki Godoy had like crazy energy, the
guy that plays Luffy. And like sort of
infectious energy. It's it's unreal in
person, even more so. That guy, I swear,
could light up a room. I don't know if
he just turns it on and can turn it off
in private, but my goodness. I thought
bro was going to bounce off of the walls
of that red carpet. He saw someone cos
playing Ace, HE GOES, "MY BROTHER!"
>> [screaming]
>> OKAY, NOW I'M GOING TO TALK ABOUT LIKE
more specific stuff that happens in this
season and then I'll save like the
really big stuff for the end if you
really just want to save it for the the
live action. I think the best scene that
was translated from the anime or manga
at least this first episode was the
scene of Zoro getting his swords in
Loguetown. My goodness, I I every single
actor and actress Zoro, Tashigi, and I'm
going to be honest, I've never
remembered the store owner's name. I've
always remember what he looks like cuz
he's got the wackiest hair. But all
three of them were were acting their
damn hearts out, bro. It felt like I was
watching an HBO drama. I'm not going to
lie. Like I know Mackenyu is huge in
Japan and I think I understand why. Like
I thought he was okay as Zoro in the
first season. I thought he was a little
bit too over the top in terms of being
like, you know,
brooding like, oh, I don't I don't care
about anything like But I think in this
first episode at least, it's starting to
kind of I don't know if it's growing on
me or if he's changing the way he's
doing things, but man, the episode the
the the part with him getting his
blades, it was it was amazing, bro. So,
if you want to click off now, I'm going
to get into sort of spoiler territory
for specific things that happened in the
episode, specific characters that show
up that you might not think about. So,
I'm I'm literally going to spoil the
first episode. If you don't want that,
click off the video now. This has been I
mean, TLDR, I love the episode and I
can't wait for season 2 and I'm very
excited for the future of the live
action and I think it's got a bright
future. So, if this is the end with me
here, thank you for watching the video.
Now, let's get into it. So, I posted a
TikTok and a YouTube short talking about
this stuff. If you want just like the
TLDR First things first, first big
change they made. Do you remember the
conversation between Garp and Roger
before Roger's executed where Roger
tells Garp that he has a son. Remember
that scene? You remember when that scene
happens? Paramount War, like episode
400? It happens in this episode. He
doesn't tell him who his son is, but
it's kind of insane. I think it's the
very first scene in the in the the I see
a lot of discussion online that people
think that they're doing that to make
the viewer possibly think that it could
be Luffy, that Luffy is Roger's son. And
I don't know if that's possible because
Garp would probably know. But at the
same time he couldn't. Like Roger could
have had a son and Roger could be Garp's
son, kind of. So I I I think I think
that was an interesting change. I think
that was probably the most confusing
change to make because it didn't make
that much sense. But it's still really
well done scene. I think that was
probably the second best scene in it,
like I said, next to the Zoro Tashigi
sword shop scene. Because they're
starting to leave these long pauses.
Like when Garp and Roger are talking,
you hear the general ambiance of like
the prison that Roger's in. And there's
a part where they just stand there and
they stare at each other. And you just
you sit there and you feel it, bro. Like
I I don't know if they did that in
season 1 at all, like really let scenes
hang, but I love what shows do. All
right, second thing that they changed
{slash} kind of spoiled, um,
Bartolomeo, as we all know, was at
Loguetown when the whole thing happened
with Luffy. And that's where he first
saw Luffy, I'm pretty sure. He's in the
show. And I don't mean he's like in the
background and sees what happens. No,
uh, Nami, first off, I think he tries to
rob Nami. And then Nami like is like,
"Okay, you got to like work on like
robbing people. Like you suck at this."
Um, so he he then takes his target and
switches his target to Luffy and tries
to rob Luffy. And through this process,
um, follows Luffy through a lot of the
whole episode and learns about who he
is, like sees him dealing with Buggy and
everything and all that. It I I'm not
going to lie, as I was watching, I was
like, "That's so crazy they have him
here. Why is he here?" Like especially
when I first saw him. But then over the
course of the episode, I I don't know
who the actor is for Bart because it's
kind of a secret. Um, dude, he he killed
it in terms of his expression because at
first he's like he looks me, has no
eyebrows. He's got the nose ring, he's
got the hair and everything. At first,
he's like, he's like really just like he
looks like it's just like an evil dude.
Over the course of the episode, you see
him like open up more and more and more
and more. And by the end of the episode,
he's like he's like that Bart you know
where like uh he looks at Luffy with
this like sunshine in his eyes. So, I I
feel like whoever
he is, shout out you, man. You
understand the character very well. I
honestly thought they were going to
tease his devil fruit in some way, but
never did. But, I mean that would be
maybe going like a bit too far in terms
of just showing stuff. Because now is
since he's like an established
character, and I mean he's established.
He was in the entire episode basically.
But, the audience's reaction to seeing
him was priceless. I wish I could go
back. I wish I had been recording, but I
didn't want to get banned from
present and future events. Now, the last
thing, and this might be the thing
people talk about most, um
is that Sabo himself makes an appearance
in the episode after Dragon saves Luffy
from Smoker in Loguetown. It cuts to him
seeing Going Merry leaving.
Um also, Dragon's voice. I don't know
who plays him. My goodness, he's got a
buttery voice. It's almost like an
Avengers like Endgame moment where a
character makes a cameo. It's Honestly,
that's what this episode felt like with
like Bart, and then like Roger and
Garp's conversation, and this. It I'm
not even kidding. It It's Dragon
standing there, and then it does like a
a slight pan, and you can see someone
standing behind him. And you can like
assume right away, and then it like it
fades like uh uh Dragon's no longer in
the focus. It refocuses, and you just
see Sabo standing there.
The funniest thing though, I feel like
is like no one that just watches the
live-action will know who that is,
especially if they don't pause on it.
It's very short, and it's very obvious
who it is. He's got the hat and
everything. You can't really see the
actor or anything. It may not The actor
may not even be cast. It might just be
like an extra. To show him this early is
kind of insane because now that means
they're probably going to do the
backstory differently because it's
always a secret that Sabo's even alive
to the viewer in the anime because you
first see the backstory and you're like,
"Oh, there was a third guy, a third
brother between Luffy and Ace." And then
you're like, "Oh, he died." Now, I don't
know if they're going to tease Sabo even
more beyond that, but now they show that
backstory and they're like, "Oh, the top
hat." And you remember that scene.
You're like, "Oh, that guy's alive and
he's
>> [snorts]
>> with Dragon." I don't think they even
said Dragon's name, but he's with that
guy that saved Luffy. So, yeah, three
big things. Again, the first season, the
only thing they did or change was Garp
the the Garp reveal. This one was
episode one. We got Garp, Roger
conversation, Bartolomeo in the cast,
and Sabo. Sabo in Loguetown is just it's
insane. I I like it though. I I I think
it's bold and I I think in the long run
it'll pay off because like I said, they
don't have the time to get the normal
audience involved and and invested in
these characters like they do the anime.
Like they know the anime viewers are
psychos and will wait 5 years just to
see the you know Gaimon's left butt
cheek again. But normal viewers like
they're going to click off if they don't
have like these interesting, you know,
plot points and stuff sort of laid out.
And not to say that the anime doesn't,
it just takes a lot longer to do that.
You can't in live action. It's just not
possible. Couple of things I was on the
Reddit looking at like certain questions
people had and I wanted to talk on them
as well. They I said earlier in the
video scenes that they adapted that
people really were looking forward to.
The Smoker ice cream scene is in it,
which I I liked a lot. The bluefin
elephant tuna fish that Sanji gets in
Loguetown is in it. It looks as wacky,
but like at the same time you're like,
"No, I can see that existing in the
world of One Piece." Let me see what
else. Smoker's CGI powers look amazing,
by the way. I think they really nailed
it, but I I feel like that's going to be
one of the easier Devil Fruits to do in
comparison to stuff way later on. I was
talking to Cam after
I don't know how they're going to do
some stuff. I really don't. I was
talking about Bart
and like how his
inflection changes. After the execution
stand, Luffy's hat filters down and it
lands at his feet and you see Bart pick
it up. He's like like witnessing
everything that happened and Luffy just
comes strolling by, swipes it and like
he's going he's like, "Thanks, man." And
I swear it's like straight out of the
anime. It was perfect.
Yeah, someone did ask there there is no
Buggy mobile. Sorry, Buggy fans.
But like I said, Buggy absolutely killed
it in this episode. I'm not even going
to talk about the scene with Buggy that
I really liked because I don't want to
even say anything about it. I want you
guys to see it. It was hilarious. Again,
Jeff Ward, you're a genius. I don't know
who came up with that bit, but it was it
was the it was the most un- unexpecting
thing that that shocked me and I was
just like, "Yeah, [ __ ] it. Let's let's
run with it. This is hilarious for no
reason." And I think one more thing that
like really gave me chills in the
theater was when Luffy's on the
execution platform in Loguetown. It has
a scene with him laughing as he as
Buggy's about to execute him. Like which
we all we all we know is important scene
in the anime because it's sort of like a
parallel to Roger. Afterwards, there's a
scene with Smoker and Tashigi in a bar
and she's like asking about what
happened and he's like, "You know the
craziest thing is? When he was up there,
he laughed." And like it lets that line
hang and then it's like silence for a
bit and he turns around he goes, "He
laughed, Tashigi." And I I almost like
it felt like so direct of a reference to
like Roger laughing whatever either he
was being executed or he reached, you
know, Laugh Tale. Um, I don't know if
that was intentional, but I straight up
got chills up and down my body to when I
was Rock Oh, and one more thing. I think
this is the last thing. Um, they're
really they're really running with the
Zoro getting lost bit. I think there
were three jokes in this one episode
about Zoro getting lost. Like there was
one where like he offered to lead the
way and they all shouted no. There's
another scene where like where's Zoro
and the camera pans and it's like him
like 5 ft away like looking confused. It
I I love it, bro. And the whole theater
was busting out laughing every time that
happened. But yeah, guys, that has been
it for my sort of review for One Piece
live action season 2 episode 1. If you
have any questions, I'll try to answer
them in the comments because I feel like
there's a lot to cover and a lot of
people are wondering what did didn't get
adapted. Again, I only saw episode 1, so
I don't have all the answers, um, but I
will be reacting to season 2 on the live
channel, so make sure you subscribe over
there. Um, but that's been it. Again,
there will be a full vlog that I'm
uploading within a day or two or three
from now of just my whole journey
throughout all of it. Footage from the
red carpet, everything. This was just
more meant to be a video that I could
get up for you guys to know my thoughts
on the season. So, with that being said,
I will see you guys very soon. Shout out
Cam for inviting me to live action
premiere. Uh, you're ugly.