Video summary
In this segment of the discussion, Menno Henselmans addresses the role of caffeine in performance and daily life, characterizing it primarily as a psychological aid rather than a potent physiological enhancer for long-term metrics like muscle gain or fat loss. Research indicates that while acute doses might offer marginal benefits under specific conditions such as sleep deprivation or early morning hours, these effects diminish significantly when an individual is well-rested and highly motivated. Henselmans warns against the common misconception that caffeine solves life's problems; instead, it often creates a negative spiral where consumption interferes with sleep quality for up to seven hours in some cases, leading users to consume more caffeine to maintain baseline functioning rather than achieving genuine improvement. He emphasizes viewing caffeine as a drug and suggests monitoring tolerance levels by attempting one day without use, noting that receptor resynthesis occurs rapidly within nine days for most individuals who are completely dependent on the substance. The conversation shifts to pre-workout supplements, with Henselmans reflecting on his past experiences using brands like Jack 3D before peaking in popularity around 2011 and subsequently moving away from them due to safety concerns and diminishing returns. Scientific comparisons suggest that anhydrous caffeine is theoretically superior or at least equal to commercial pre-workouts for performance enhancement, as the additional ingredients often result in negative interactions with compounds like creatine, citrulline, or beta-alanine found in these formulations. While some users may enjoy their specific flavored mixes due to psychological effects, Henselmans argues that expensive fancy blends are largely unnecessary and essentially useless for the vast majority of consumers. He proposes using pure caffeine powder as a cost-effective alternative that allows for accurate dosing without bitterness or superfluous additives, though he acknowledges that if an individual prefers coffee or energy drinks like Red Bull, there is no strict requirement to switch unless they wish to optimize their wallet and intake accuracy. When discussing fat burners, the analysis concludes that these products generally fail to deliver on their promises of significant fat loss beyond minor increases in energy expenditure over a few hours until tolerance develops. Reviews indicate that while some ingredients might slightly decrease appetite or boost metabolism temporarily, many effective compounds are now illegal due to regulatory crackdowns by bodies like the FDA. In contrast, fiber supplements offer a more reliable and legal method for achieving weight management goals because they induce satiety, leading people to eat less naturally. Henselmans highlights that even though some fat burners work through mechanisms similar to caffeine or other stimulants, their efficacy is often short-lived compared to dietary strategies like increasing fiber intake, which avoids the digestive side effects associated with many supplements while providing consistent results in reducing caloric consumption. Throughout the dialogue, there is a recurring theme of distinguishing between subjective feelings and objective physiological realities, particularly regarding how substances interact with the body's systems over time. Henselmans notes that caffeine acts directly on adenosine receptors but does not provide long-term structural changes to muscle or fat tissue, reinforcing the idea that its primary utility lies in masking fatigue rather than eliminating it. He draws a parallel between caffeine and other drugs like heroin regarding safety profiles relative to abuse potential, though he clarifies that while caffeine is relatively safe compared to banned substances, it remains easy to abuse if one relies on it to function at baseline levels instead of improving rest quality. The discussion also touches upon the importance of electrolytes in morning routines, promoting a specific product containing sodium, potassium, and magnesium as a way to support adrenal health before the adenosine system becomes active later in the day, suggesting that proper hydration with minerals can be more beneficial than relying solely on stimulants for energy management.
Read the full video transcript
you mentioned caffeine earlier on what
have you learned recently about
caffeine I think that most of the
effects of caffeine in in light of that
earlier study that we talked about and
most research in general suggest that
caffeine is by and large a psychological
Aid it does very little long-term if you
look at studies where people are given
caffeine for a period of weeks and you
look at how much muscle they're gaining
how much fat are they losing much
strength are they gaining in the vast
majority of research there is no effect
on those measures even if acutely if you
give people a boatload of caffeine they
do perform a little bit better in
certain conditions and it also seems
that if you narrow it down to like which
individuals respond better it's works
better when you're sleep deprived it
works better in the morning it works
better in individuals that are not as
well trained which all shows that you
know or all Trends in the direction of
if you are well rested and you are super
motivated then the effect is probably
not really there maybe you can
use a little bit of a kick in the ass
but for most individuals it's going to
be a marginal effect and long term it's
pretty trivial so I think people should
use it that way as a psychological Aid
and it's very easy to overdo it on
caffeine the main problem for a lot of
individuals is that caffeine seems like
magic and therefore you can uh solve a
lot of life's problems including the
ones created by caffeine with more
caffeine or so it seems and you run into
this negative spiral where caffeine
starts interfering with Sleep Quality
and the effect of that in the latest
meta analysis is present for 1 hours for
the average individual if it's a good
dose some seven hours even at a low dose
and some research even finds that a a
strong double espresso in the morning
like 200 milligrams caffeine still
affects objective measures of Sleep
Quality at night which is long after the
subjective effects have waned off and
then you enter into this spiral where
you consume more caffeine worse sleep
more caffeine worse sleep and in the end
you're just consuming a lot of caffeine
and it feels like you're functioning
better than you were before but in
reality the caffeine is simply keeping
you at Baseline so you are not improving
your cognitive functions your life or
anything you are simply using the
caffeine to be where you would be if you
were well rested and not using any
caffeine I'm not saying don't use any
caffeine I'm just saying it's a drug
most people don't even realize it's a
drug use it as a drug not as a
supplement or not as food where it's
just like use it just to use it actually
see whether you get an effect out of it
monitor if you're still getting a
similar effect or if you're not getting
massive tolerance can you function after
one day without caffeine or do you get
massive headaches and are you
intolerable those are indications maybe
dial it back and the good news is only a
few days will resynthesize your
receptors to Almost 100% it's nine days
after massive tolerance so just a few
days for most
individuals nine days n nine days for
someone who who is completely dependent
on caffeine will reset them back to
Baseline mhm wow yeah so
you're why is that so fast is that that
it's just acting so directly on the
adenosine receptors and they they seem
to be quite robust at at kind of going
back to Baseline yeah it is a relatively
safe drug in that sense compared to say
heroin that's the that's what I want all
drugs to be compared to it's a
relatively safe drug dot dot dot
compared to heroin yeah it just it's
still easy to abuse but the abuse
effects are not nearly as bad as that of
the drugs that are commonly banned
because people would abuse them right
yes what about um the difference between
caffeine and pre-workouts I haven't used
pre-workout for quite a while probably
five or six years uh did for a long time
the world of Jack 3D and no explode and
and stuff and then dipped out presumably
the technology whatever that means uh
behind pre-workouts has continued to get
comp I know there's no stim pre-workouts
now I don't even know what that means um
talk to me what what's the science say
about pre-workouts for improving
performance that versus caffeine if you
are using a pre-workout what should you
look for etc etc we never Advanced past
jacked right we peaked we peaked in 2011
Jack was Peak pre-workout okay okay okay
um yeah Jack was not so safe actually
but
um caffeine uh is pretty much as good as
it gets and funny enough most
comparisons involv in caffeine with
pre-workouts find that enhydra caffeine
which is caffeine powder or pills Works
a little bit better it also works a
little bit better in at least a few
studies than
coffee and it works better in at least
some research than pre-workout
formulations it seems that there are
some negative interactions there they're
small and if you like your pre-workout
it's fine because in the end it's almost
a psychological effect anyway but there
is some negative interaction it seems
between at least caffeine and creatine
and possibly between caffeine and
citrine or B alanine one of the more
popular rework workouts that are at
least somewhat promising in terms of
supplements
so by and large I would say just consume
what you feel best or what you like best
but you don't have to spend a lot of
money on fancy pre-workouts they're
absolutely not essential in fact they
are pretty much useless for the vast
majority of products so if you like your
coffee if you like your Red Bull or if
you want the uh theoretically best just
in hydrous caffeine I don't care about
the bitterness and uh uh I care about my
wallet then you know just use caffeine
powder you can dose it uh super
accurately uh so that is the
theoretically optimal solution I suppose
but yeah though pre-workouts I have very
uh little uh regard for their
efficacy what about fat burners do fat
burners work uh no uh there have been a
couple reviews uh which all essentially
concluded that fat burners don't
actually burn fat at best they increase
energy expenditure a little bit and
maybe decrease your appetite the best
ones are illegal though and they are
decidedly worse than for example fiber
supplements and even those are not great
because of the digestive side effects
you're better getting it from food but
for example fiber supplements somewhat
reliably result in Fat Loss because when
people supplement fiber it decreases
their appetite it makes them Fuller they
eat less and therefore they lose fat fat
burners maybe increase energy
expenditure a few percent over a few
hours until you become tolerant to them
and that goes for caffeine and pretty
much everything else that works is now
illegal like jacked God damn it
an FDA ruining the party as per usual
this episode is brought to you by
element stop having coffee first thing
in the morning your adenosine system
that caffeine acts on isn't even active
for the first 90 minutes of the day but
your adrenal system is and salt acts on
your adrenal system element contains a
SS backed electrolyte ratio of sodium
pottassium and magnesium with no sugar
no gluten no coloring no artificial
ingredients or any other BS it plays a
critical role in reducing muscle cramps
and fatigue while optimizing brain
health regulating appetite and curbing
Cravings the orange flavor in a cold
glass of water is literally the best way
to start your morning I've done it every
single day for over three years now way
before they were a partner on the show
and I love it best of all there is a
nobs no questions asked refund policy so
you can buy absolutely risk-free and if
you do not like it for any reason they
will give you your money back and you
don't even need to return the box right
now you can get a free sample pack of
all eight flavors with your first box by
going to the link in the description
below or heading to drink LM nt.com slod
wisdom that's drink LM nt.com
slod wisdom thank you very much for
tuning in if you enjoyed that clip you
will love the ful length podcast in all
its Glory which is available right
here go on press it