Video summary
Andrew Huberman explores the intersection of neuroscience and spirituality, arguing that religious belief or faith in a higher power plays a critical role in helping individuals overcome severe addictions and recover from profound losses. He observes that while humans typically rely on top-down control mechanisms—such as willpower and cognitive suppression—to resist bad habits like alcoholism, this process is often insufficient for those struggling with intense cravings. Huberman notes that the most effective recovery programs, such as 12-step groups, frequently require individuals to surrender their need for constant self-control by attaching themselves to a higher power, whether defined as God, Christ, or an agnostic concept of a greater force. This shift from internal struggle to external reliance appears to provide immense relief and stability that pure neurobiological willpower cannot achieve alone. The core paradox Huberman addresses is how relinquishing control makes the task easier rather than harder. He explains that for many people, giving over their motivations and discipline to an entity outside themselves creates a concrete sense of support that abstract concepts like "tenacity" or agency often fail to provide during moments of crisis. This phenomenon suggests that human evolution has not discarded these spiritual mechanisms but rather integrated them alongside biological ones; billions of humans throughout history have successfully navigated life's hardships by assuming their motivations come from sources beyond the anterior midline singular cortex. Huberman emphasizes that this is not a rejection of science, as he views his own daily prayer practice and faith in God as practices that yield tangible neurobiological benefits, such as deep peace and reduced anxiety, even if one were to interpret them strictly through neural circuitry alone. Huberman shares personal reflections on how resisting the voice for spirituality until age fifty hindered him from experiencing sustained inner peace, a state he finally achieved by stopping his fight against these beliefs. He recounts giving an uncomfortable toast at his fiftieth birthday where he admitted that embracing prayer and reading the Bible became sources of intellectual stimulation and relaxation rather than just religious observance. Despite acknowledging that some successful individuals may appear deficient in this area due to their focus on material wealth, Huberman argues they likely suffer from a gap in understanding how these spiritual frameworks function as essential tools for mental health. He concludes that faith-based practices are not mutually exclusive with scientific inquiry but represent a convergent evolution where humans across different cultures and eras have independently developed similar mechanisms to cope with the burdens of life. In his final thoughts, Huberman urges listeners who may be struggling or doing well to explore these possibilities without fear, suggesting that morning sunlight is also essential for maintaining balance in one's spiritual and physical health. He admits that while he loves teaching science regarding neurons, cuttlefish, and ferrets, he regrets not having embraced faith earlier in his life before it became a source of immense comfort during difficult times. His message is clear: whether the mechanism behind prayer is purely neurobiological or involves something greater than us remains an open question for him, but the results are undeniable. He encourages everyone to try these practices, noting that even if they turn out to be filtered through standard brain mechanisms, the outcome of feeling better and finding peace makes them worthwhile pursuits worth continuing indefinitely.
Read the full video transcript
One of the reasons I'm so interested in
spirituality and notions of of God etc.
is that you know the virtues also I
believe can start to arrive through
things that are outside of us. Now I
realize that sounds very unscientific
but if you look at the science around
religious belief or belief in higher
power or the notion that humans don't
have all the answers not even the
collective consciousness what you find
is that for everything from recovery
from addiction to recovery from immense
immense loss I mean the kinds of losses
that go way beyond uh you know a death
of a family member although that's
intense you know death of all one's
children for instance horrible things
that people have been put through almost
without fail. Moving through that with
any kind of um sense of
self-preservation and not engaging in
just self-destruction, which is what
most people do almost always involves
some notion of top-down control from
outside. You know, being being um
encouraged or even instructed to do the
right thing, feeling as if something is
coming through oneself. Now we often
hear about this in the creative process.
People like Rick Rubin and I'm a big Twi
Art fan, the choreographer will talk
about, you know, it's most creatives
will talk about sort of downloading
things from outside of them. It kind of
moves through them as opposed to arising
purely within them because of all that
sensory experience. But and they can get
into kind of these higher realms of
spirituality. But when we're talking
about breaking bad habits, overcoming
immensely difficult scenarios that
normally would throw people into
complete self-destruction or just giving
up, which is a bad habit in in its own
its own right, it it's as if the the
top- down control is so immense like the
going against oneself that's required is
so immense that when people hand that
over to God, whether or not it's Christ
or whether or not some other form of God
that they that they are, you know, that
they're attached to, you know, It seems
as if they get some relief from the
process and yet it's very effective. And
you can't deny this, right? Just as a
phenomenon. I mean, let's take off our
hats as scientists and people with kind
of harsh things like the it how could it
be that the the thing that's hardest for
humans to do for themselves becomes far
easier when they stop trying to do it
for themselves? It's it's a it's a wild
mind bend that neuroscience doesn't
really understand. But but you know what
we're really talking about let's say
this were alcohol and I'm not an
alcoholic fortunately but let's say I
had immense difficulty in refraining
from alcohol and this would be the
precise environment in where this would
where alcohol would be attractive. The
amount of top down control that's
required is immense for somebody that's
recently sober. They have to you know
hopefully they're in 12step. They have
to call their sponsor. They it can be an
jarring anxiety. That anxiety eventually
subsides. I mean, alcoholics eventually
can hang out in bars and not have a
drink, but there's a long period of time
where they can, and many never will be
able to do that, but the notion of a
higher power is is central to almost
every alcoholic, at least who goes
through a getting sober. It's that it's
a it's a almost a prerequisite. And in
some sense, it is a prerequisite. And
it's so brilliant that it is because it
takes away the need for constant top-
down control. You give that over to
something else. this notion of a higher
power. For some people that's God. For
some people it's Christ. For some people
it's you know just general higher power
because 12step is very agnostic as to
you know what people consider higher
power. But
I think it is not a coincidence that the
Bible writes in these kinds of things
about sins and virtues and the need not
just good works but avoiding sin and
acknowledges in some sense that it's in
some cases near impossible for people to
do on their own. And yes, community can
help and yes, reward processes can help
and yes, punishment can help. These all
work. We know this. As you can see this
in animal learning studies where humans
are different is that they can as far as
we know humans are unique in their
ability to give this top-down
restriction process over to some other
entity and it makes it easier not harder
and it makes it more concrete somehow
not more abstract. The only abstract
piece of it is that you know you you
can't shake this entity's hand at least
not in the standard sense.
>> What do you think's going on there? I,
you know,
as usual, you always ask the question.
Um, which is why I I'm stomped, right? I
mean, it's I mean, I'm trying to parse
what could be going on, but it always
lands me back in neural circuits and
neural structures. I mean, I'm excited
by some of the data that are starting to
look at how consciousness might involve
things from outside the brain and, you
know, maybe multiple brains. And all I
know is that um, having spent nearly
three decades
thinking about and researching and
talking about neuroscience that you know
we know a great deal about how
sensations, perceptions, thoughts,
memories, you know, emotions and
behaviors are constructed, right? What
we do and um and yet we don't know how
this piece comes about. But this piece
has been central to the human historical
perspective and human experience. And I
don't think we're any longer in a place
where we can even talk about human
evolution without this, right? I think
humans evolved in the context of this
>> and that's why I don't see them as
mutually exclusive.
>> Much more a part of our history than the
anterior mids singular cortex is.
>> Yes. In fact, no one needed to know that
the anterior mids singular cortex
existed to know that there's this thing
called tenacity and willpower. I think
that the fun twist is that um it's a
highly plastic structure that we can
engage and grow and um and that
reinforces the the sets of behaviors
that are that are involved and I think
um adaptive, right? But
I I absolutely think there's something
real there. And I say that completely as
a scientist, right? I mean, I'm used to
immunustaining for proteins and running
less and you know like recording from
neurons and you looking at neural
circuits using any number of labeling
techniques. I mean I'm a man of science.
But there's just no doubt in my mind
that this process of giving over to the
understanding there's something much
greater than us and that we are not in
total control at least not in total
control. That feels very comforting to
me because of the way it's I've seen it
help so many people and you know I don't
I won't be shy about it's helped me
tremendously. I mean I'm I'm in a very
serious prayer practice daily now every
night before I go to sleep without fail.
I'm going on a couple years now where
I've not missed a single night. I'll get
out of bed if I fall asleep and do that.
It's it's it's like a and then also just
prayer is a thing. Let's say it's just
purely neurobiological. Let's say that
there's nothing outside of us that you
know that in in the real sense. I don't
believe that, but let's just assume for
a moment. Well, then my neurobiology
seems to be responding to all this very
very well. And I don't think I'm alone
with that. In fact, I think there are
too many burdens in life for anyone to
be able to navigate life extremely well
without these notions of higher power. I
I don't think people can do it. And if
and you could show me the most
successful, wealthiest people in the
world and I would say um yeah, but they
are highly deficient in this area. Not
because I'm judging them, right? We all
deficient in some area, but um I I it
must be it has to be because there's
this huge gap in the in in the knowledge
set. I've never thought that. I've never
thought of that paradox. The fact that
for
a lot of people, billions of people,
relinquishing control, the exact
opposite of what it is that for most of
the habits, okay, we're going to
suppress the anterior midsulate cortex.
We're going to use our our cognition to
limit our distraction. We're going to
narrow our focus. All the rest of it,
it's intention. It's lean in. It's
agency. It's taking control. And then
there's this other bit that literally
billions of people and up until
a hundred years ago almost everybody did
assume was the seat of where their
motivations and their discipline and for
a while with the bicameal mind maybe
even the voice inside the head came
from.
That was the thing that was real. That
was the that was the source of this.
>> We evolved in that in that context.
>> Yeah.
>> The brain
>> independently, right? This was
convergent evolution from a like 50
million [ __ ] different corners of the
universe.
>> Absolutely. And and and you know it's my
you know I love teaching science. I I
love learning and teaching science. I
hope that's obvious to people. I um but
it's my one wish for for people that at
some point in their life they at least
explore the possibility and um and get
morning sunlight. But the um [laughter]
but but you know
>> be open to faith and get morning
sunlight. Like I I just hit 50 recently
and and I will say um if I look back on
my life I I sure I wish I had done
certain things differently. I mean who
who doesn't, right? This notion of like
no regrets like yeah I wish I had made
certain decisions not others. Um but by
and large I'm very very happy with the
decisions I made by and large. And I was
happy to discover resistance training
and running and neuroscience and you
know cuttlefish and ferrets. I had a pet
ferret and um I don't recommend bulldogs
and I have the the an amazing
relationship to family and friends and
I'm very blessed in my personal life and
my romantic life is feeling awesome
these days and and it's just like it's
overwhelmingly positive despite a lot of
strain and hardship. But the one thing
that I wish that I had done earlier was
to stop resisting the voice in my head
that said, you know, I think I think
there's a God and I'm going to pray. I
kept pushing that away. I was like
incompatible with my notion of what it
meant to be uh a scientist. It was it
was just incompatible with with things.
I just kept pushing down and yet at the
same time wishing for it. And recently
on my 50th birthday, I had to give an
uncomfortable toast cuz believe it or
not, I'm somewhat introverted,
especially in large groups. I'm happy to
talk science and talk like this with
you. But um and I and I said it then and
I'll say it again now. Like I'm 50 and
for the first time in my life, my entire
life, I've experienced sustained
times of real deep peace like just peace
like just the like everything's okay
everything is as it should be not just
some little mantra that you say when
you're on the big cir like and why I
think it's because I stopped fighting so
hard to try and control everything
inside me
and in my life and as a consequence
everything has become much easier still
challenging but much much easier And
it's 100%
because of giving over to notion of
higher power. I'm very direct about is
God higher power for me, right? Reading
the Bible, this kind of thing. Prayer. I
mean, these are practices. This isn't
just I believe in God. These are
practices. Those are faith-based
practices. And it's become a source of
of immense um intellectual stimulation
for me and also just relaxation. And
it's really it's my wish for anyone
that's like struggling or doing well
because I I'm certain that it it holds
so much power and again even if it turns
out and I'll never know but even if it
turns out that it's all filtered through
you know standard neurobiological
mechanisms you know um okay I'm good
with that but in the meantime like I'm
going to keep praying like and you can
look at examples all around and all
through history where people have said
similar things in in circumstances far
more challenging than mine and they'll
always point to the same thing. I mean,
people are are pretty um can be pretty
irrational, but at the same time, humans
are also pretty miraculous in what
they're able to build and develop. And
this whole thing of, you know, God and
religion has not been discarded. If
anything, it's growing, right? Right? I
mean, you know the data on that better
than I. So,
>> in other news, if you're feeling tired,
you might not need more sleep. You might
not need more caffeine. You might just
be dehydrated. And proper hydration is
not just about drinking enough water.
It's about having sufficient
electrolytes to allow your body to
properly absorb those fluids. Element
contains a sciencebacked electrolyte
ratio. Sodium, potassium, and magnesium
with no color, no sugar, no artificial
ingredients or any other BS. It plays a
critical role in reducing muscle cramps
and fatigue whilst optimizing brain
health, regulating appetite, and curbing
cravings. This lemonade flavor was so
popular, a literally a truckload of it
was stole. That was a knuckle ball. Do
you see that? Moved in the air. Uh
anyway, this is phenomenal. I really
tell the difference between when I drink
it and when I don't. And uh you should
try it, too. Best of all, they've got a
no questions asked refund policy with an
unlimited [clears throat] duration
return. So, you can buy it for as long
as you want. And if you don't like it
for any reason, they'll give you
[laughter]
Damn it. Oh, you don't have to return
the box. They're confident that you're
going to love it. And um you can get a
free sample pack of their favorite
flavors by going to the link in the
description below or heading to
drinklement.com/modernwisdom.
That's drinklement.com/modernwisdom.
Thank you very much for tuning in. If
you enjoyed that clip, the full episode
in all of its glory,
waiting for you right here.
Go on, press it.