Video summary
The "Common Sense" exhibition at the Brooklyn Museum commemorates the 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence by exploring how contemporary art can engage with historical realities to present a complex vision of the United States. Curators Catherine Morris and Kimberly Gant explain that the show is built upon two foundational texts by Thomas Paine: "Common Sense," which argued for secession from Great Britain, and "The American Crisis," written later to inspire troops during the Revolutionary War. The exhibition uses these historical documents as a springboard to introduce modern artworks designed to provoke thought about democracy, protest movements, and the ongoing struggles that shape national identity, inviting visitors to connect personal experiences with broader political contexts.
A significant portion of the tour highlights works by artists like Paul Ramirez Jonas, Hank Willis Thomas, Kara Walker, and Joyce Kozloff who challenge traditional narratives regarding power, memory, and freedom. For instance, Jonas's installation "Commons" subverts the tradition of military statues honoring elite white male generals by creating a space for regular soldiers to leave objects representing their grievances, thus democratizing commemoration. Similarly, Hank Willis Thomas uses irony in his diptych titled "Once Upon a Time in America, There Were No Slaves" to remind viewers that African-American contributions are integral to the nation's history, while Kara Walker's "Freedom Fable" illustrates how freedom is often a fallacy for many who still face systemic obstacles despite legal emancipation.
The exhibition also delves into themes of immigration and cultural synthesis through pieces by Jason Kao Hwang and Maynard Monroe, emphasizing that all voices should be equal in the construction of history. Kao Hwang's oratorio "Immigrant of the Womb" blends Chinese traditional instruments with Western ones to create a sonic democracy that reflects his family's journey from China to America via the Boxer Rebellion era and the Golden Venture incident. Meanwhile, visual poet Maynard Monroe appropriates folk legends like Woody Guthrie to argue that in difficult times, creating beauty is the ultimate act of protest against criminalized dissent, asserting that true patriotism involves speaking out freely regardless of one's background or appearance.
Ultimately, "Common Sense" serves as a reminder that history is not just a story told by certain participants but a complex tapestry woven from both beautiful and ugly realities experienced by all people. The curators conclude by expressing hope that visitors will appreciate how art represents the past, present, and future while relating to community, politics, and society. By presenting works that strive for inclusivity and challenge viewers to think differently about their understanding of culture and individuals, the exhibition aims to foster a deeper appreciation for the importance of diverse perspectives in shaping a more complete national narrative.
Read the full video transcript
[music]
>> Hi, welcome to the Brooklyn Museum. I'm
Catherine Morris and I'm one of the
co-curators of Common Sense, an
exhibition
>> [music]
>> marking the 250th anniversary of the
signing of the Declaration of
Independence.
It is an exhibition [music]
that was undertaken to really think
about the ways that contemporary art can
interact with historical [music]
realities and present a vision of the
United States that includes its
complexities, its achievements, um the
current struggles that we [music] still
face and also
uh think about how contemporary [music]
dialogues continue to be shaped by our
history. And towards that, we started
the [music] exhibition planning from two
really important historical tracks. The
exhibition opens with two historical
documents written by Thomas Paine, the
celebrated American philosopher,
abolitionist, and nationalist.
Paine's two texts, starting with Common
Sense, which gives us the name of our
exhibition, was drafted to really
convince the American public in the
colonial era that secession from Great
Britain was possible. Common Sense is a
work that transformed
for many people in the United States
during the colonial period the idea that
independence was possible. And so it is
often credited as the catalyst [music]
for making the revolution possible.
We've also added another document by
Paine that it was written several years
later called The American Crisis. And
this is a work that begins with the
famous line, "These are the times that
try men's souls." Which continues to
feel very
resonant [music] to many people. The
American Crisis is a text that was
utilized during the Revolutionary War to
continue to inspire troops. [music]
There are apocryphal and other stories
of the text being read to troops by
George Washington and others as a way of
building morale and continuing to have
people focus on the goals of the
revolution to gain independence. Taking
these two foundational texts of American
history, we then move into a series of
contemporary works of art in much the
way that Paine's foundational texts were
meant to inspire the public. One of the
greatest things that artists do for us
is invite us to [music] think
differently, to think about the ways in
which we can expand our own
understanding of history, of
contemporary culture,
>> [music]
>> of what's important to us as a culture
and as individuals. And this [music]
exhibition represents artists who have
presented works that really
>> [music]
>> invite us to make that connection
between the personal and the political.
>> Hi, I'm Kimberly Gant. I'm one of the
curators of Common Sense
through the Brooklyn Museum's permanent
collection. This [music] exhibition is
really kind of thinking about what it
means to think about democracy and the
protest movements and the movements that
have just shaped [music] the United
States over the since it's founding uh
250 years ago. And which our first is by
the artist Paul Ramirez Jonas. It's
called Commons and he's looking at a
trope within the history of art, which
is uh military statues and often those
[music] are used to kind of commemorate
fallen soldiers. They come out of a
legacy of European sculpture tradition,
often with a kind of war hero who is
seated atop a uh horse with its legs
raised. Um often that's signifying that
the person who is being commemorated
died in battle. It is about trying to
kind of illuminate a particular figure,
usually was a white male, um [music] uh
someone of elite status. And so what the
Commons piece is actually doing by not
having the figure here is we're thinking
about the the people who are not
actually getting any sort of
commemoration when they pass, the
regular soldiers, not the generals or
the kind of elite leaders. And so, he
also purposely decided to put it such
that the individuals [music] could post
um objects on here because the idea of
also of the comments is that it was a
space that was usually kind of a grassy
area within the center of a town that
was actually used as a space for the
general public, not just those in power,
to be able to air their grievances
[music]
and actually get a sense of justice if
they were feeling that their um powers
were denied. So, he's really thinking
about moments in which those who are
usually powerless have an opportunity to
actually have some modicum of power in
their situation.
So, two works from our contemporary art
collection. The first is by Hank Willis
Thomas, which [music] is a photographic
uh diptych and is called Once Upon a
Time in America, There Were No Slaves.
And [music] he's really kind of taking
an ironic statement there with the title
because, as we know, there was
enslavement in the United States, but
[music] he's really thinking about that
as an opportunity to discuss the
importance of the contributions [music]
of African-Americans
um within the development of the United
States, whether it's through protesting,
um people having civil rights, um you
know, advocating for their freedom, for
their right to education, [music] for
their right to just kind of be equal
citizens. He's really just trying to
kind of ask and have us remember that
history [music]
is really formed by all participants in
the United States, not [music] just
certain ones, and that history of itself
can also be thought of in a very kind of
complex way. What What's often [music]
written is not the full story, it is a
story. So, how can we think of
>> [music]
>> the the creation of a civilization, of a
community, of a of a nation without
considering all of the people that were
a part of it, all of both [music] the
beauty and the ugliness that contributed
to where we are today?
And some of those similar thoughts
[music] are also in uh Kara Walker's
work, the short title Freedom Fable,
which takes her, you know, kind of
iconic [music]
silhouetted drawings that she does in
black and colors and is in a beautiful
[music]
illustrated book that's actually
thinking about
the kind of fallacy of what [music]
freedom means. You know, when you say
freedom, there's a certain understanding
that [music] it will be kind of
everything you need and want, and the
reality is that freedom is a fable. She
takes this idea thinking [music] about
that through a formally enslaved woman
and the kind of trials that she goes
through even after [music] she gains her
freedom, that doesn't mean her life is
without
>> [music]
>> senses of powerlessness and and agency.
And so, the the way in which [music] we
think about how we are supposed to be
able to kind of achieve these moments of
freedom and the ability to kind of do
what we want, but for a large part of
the population, both historically and
[music] one could definitely say now,
that sense of freedom really is a
fallacy because even if you have
the ability to kind of work where you
[music] want or live where you want,
there will always be obstacles in front
of you,
>> [music]
>> and can you ever really overcome them?
So, it's a, you know, it's not a kind of
a joyous tale, but I think it reflects
the
>> [music]
>> reality for a lot of people that you
strive and strive and strive for a
certain level of power, [music] and will
you ever really get it in a, you know,
in a very kind of capitalist society.
>> [music]
>> My name is Joyce Kozloff, and since
about 1990,
for about 35 years, cartography has been
at the basis [music] of my work. Whoever
makes the maps has the power,
and that has always interested me.
[music] So, when one country conquers
another country, they change the names,
they remap everything.
>> So, this work from 2004
>> [music]
>> was based on my mother
gave me some game boards from her
childhood, [music] which means they were
from like the 1920s.
We're talking about more than a hundred
years ago, and they had a map of
America,
>> [music]
>> and they had songs on them. And the
songs were, I guess, the songs that were
popular at the time. And I did a series
based on that of nine paintings called
American History.
>> [music]
>> It covers American history through our
wars. And this one is called Sing-Along
American History. There are three
Sing-Along ones that have [music]
these uh I cut them out, and then I
enlarge them, and I collage them, these
songs. And they all relate to the Civil
War and race in America. As [music] soon
as she gave them to me, it was just so
clear
that these [music] these songs
were just indicative of a kind of uh
deep [music] history, particularly in
the American South.
>> The garment factory, piecework, no
benefits.
I was unconscious and determined.
I was an immigrant of the womb.
>> Hi, my name is Jason Kao Hwang. Uh I'm
very honored to have a score page for my
oratorio, an operatic poem called
Immigrant of the Womb, um that was
produced in 1996.
The score page was part of a portfolio
um that was produced by an Asian
American visual artist collective called
Godzilla to show like several
generations of Asian American uh
activism. Immigrant of the Womb blends
my personal history, uh my parents'
history, um with that of the Boxer
Rebellion. my father came here in a
Boxer Indemnity Fund scholarship. So,
that imagery was important to me.
The recent story of that time was the
grounding of the Golden Venture, which
was a ship of immigrants that had come
here and the ship ran aground in Far
Rockaway. They were imprisoned for
multiple months as their cases went
through the courts. So, that was part of
this story. And also, my both my
parents' experiences in World War II
and the and the Civil War in China that
hurled them into
coming to America and making their home
here. So, this was a pondering of how
history and even a personal history
drives our generational and emotional
makeup and influences our behavior.
In music, when I blend, in this case,
Chinese traditional instruments with
Western European origin
instruments, I seek a bridge between
those sounds. I compose for a democracy
of sound, all sounds being equal and
merging and bridging together. And so,
in in the music is the democracy. And
so, being part of also this exhibit
where all voices are equal and they're
making something there's a synergy of
something whole
that is true to all of us. I think I'm
very proud to be a part of.
>> I'm Maynard Monroe. I'm a language-based
artist. My practice all commences from
language. I'm a visual poet.
A visual wordsmith. I'm constantly
whittling words. A lot of it is current
event realized. I'm interested in making
work that provokes, not pacifies.
Work that engages society, not merely
decorates it. I was invited to be part
of the Common Sense
installation here at the Brooklyn
Museum, and I wanted to choose three
[music] works that really spoke about
the 250
and this pivotal time where we are in
America right now.
This very uh diff- difficult and this
period of duress in the nation. This one
particularly here is about inclusivity,
and I'm appropriating the work of
American folk legend Woody Guthrie into
my work. In times of ugly, the best
protest is beauty. We're living in
difficult times artistically here at for
our nation and for the world. It's a
very challenging moment for many people
in many countries on many levels.
But, we have to find our joy sparks,
too.
So, in times of ugly and our My for me,
my joy spark is making beauty or
creating beauty, you know, out of the
ashes of phoenix rises, making something
hopefully something poignant, something
powerful.
Moving on.
I particularly chose this one and I
particularly chose this one to be on red
because I think it really empowered it.
The color and the language together was
very powerful symbiotically.
And it's the idea of how they're
basically criminalizing dissent these
days, and it's the highest form of
patriotism is to speak out. It's freedom
of speech.
And to
exercise that freedom. And you know,
patriots come in all manner of
persuasions, all shapes, [music] all
colors, all forms.
It feels enlightening
that I am not going to stand in the
shadow and be meek.
I'm going to come into the light [music]
and be bright and shine.
And hopefully that shine will shine onto
others.
>> We're really excited [music]
to have you come and see this
exhibition. Thank you for hearing the
tour about the Common Sense project and
just really thinking about [music] this
moment in time in which we are reminding
our visitors the importance of art and
the way in which it represents [music]
the world in which we live uh past,
present, and future and especially
relates to history, community, politics,
and society. And [music] we hope you
enjoyed it as much as we have having it
on view. Thanks so much.