Submind YouTube summaries
Thumbnail for Friday Favorites: How Much Licorice Is Safe?

Friday Favorites: How Much Licorice Is Safe?

Watch on YouTube

Video summary

Stress contributes significantly to weight gain by triggering the release of cortisol, a hormone that promotes fat storage, particularly in the abdominal area. While managing stress is the ideal solution, dietary modifications can also help mitigate these effects. One specific compound found in licorice called glycyrrhetinic acid appears to block the enzyme responsible for activating cortisol within body fat cells. Research conducted in Italy demonstrated that applying this compound topically to the skin could reduce the thickness of superficial fat layers and improve cellulite, suggesting a potential mechanism for weight management without invasive procedures. However, consuming licorice orally presents a complex trade-off between fat loss and fluid retention. Studies indicate that while licorice can effectively burn body fat, it simultaneously causes the kidneys to retain water and sodium by blocking an enzyme that normally deactivates cortisol. This dual action often results in little to no change in overall body weight because the loss of fat is offset by the gain in water mass. Furthermore, this interference with kidney function leads to potassium depletion, which can cause muscle weakness and dangerous heart rhythm abnormalities. The FDA has issued warnings stating that consuming large amounts of black licorice, such as two ounces daily for over two weeks, could lead to severe health complications requiring hospitalization. The risks associated with licorice consumption are particularly high for specific groups, including individuals with hypertension, pregnant women, and the elderly. High intake can cause blood pressure to spike dangerously, potentially leading to comas, while use during pregnancy is linked to preterm delivery and cognitive issues in infants. Additionally, licorice negatively impacts testosterone production in men, causing a significant drop in levels within just a few days of high consumption. Because glycyrrhizin content varies wildly between products—ranging from artificially flavored candies with little real licorice to herbal teas with unpredictable potency—determining a truly safe dosage is difficult. Consequently, while small amounts might be tolerated by some, experts generally advise caution, suggesting that regular consumption should be limited to very low quantities or avoided entirely by those with underlying health conditions.
Read the full video transcript
[music] >> The three ways to alleviate the fattening effects of stress are number one, treat the cause by alleviating the stress. If that's not possible, you can number two, modify your diet to lower the production of the adrenal stress hormone cortisol, as I described in my video on the effect of animal protein on adrenal function. And if all else fails, you can number three, try to block the effects of cortisol on our fat cells. If you drip cortisone onto fat samples taken deep inside people undergoing abdominal surgery, you can accelerate the formation and growth of new fat cells. But you can disrupt this process with a compound that blocks the enzyme that activates cortisol in body fat. The compound is called glycyrrhetinic acid, which is what our gut bacteria make and ferry into our bloodstream when we eat glycyrrhizin. Any guesses as to where in our diet glycyrrhizin is found? I'll give you a hint. It derives from the Greek words glykos, meaning sweet, and rhiza, meaning root. We may be able to block some of the effects of cortisol in our body fat when we eat licorice. What works to slim fat cells in a petri dish or mice in a lab may not work in a person, but the licorice compound appears to work even when just applied to the skin. Researchers in Italy tried rubbing the licorice compound on women's thighs to see if it would help with cellulite. After a month of application, the thickness of the superficial fat layer on their thighs, as measured by ultrasound, was significantly reduced. The reason we know it wasn't just due to massaging it in is because there was no change on the control thigh or among the women that rubbed on placebos. The difference was only a few millimeters, but the researchers suggested it could be a gentler alternative to cosmetic surgery. What about eating licorice or or drinking licorice tea? Dozens of trials have been published on the effects of various licorice preparations on weight loss, and overall, there's just a small effect, about a pound of extra weight loss over a month or two compared to placebo. And one reason it may not be higher is that licorice causes you to lose body fat, but retain water. Check this out. After 2 months on licorice, no change in overall weight, but the women dropped their percentage fat mass by nearly 3% at the same time, though, increasing their water retention by about the same amount. Then when they stopped the licorice, they lost the water, but gained back the fat. Licorice can cause you to burn so much fat the surface of your abdomen heats up a degree within an hour of consumption, but it has the opposite effect on cortisol in your kidneys, which it turns out is actually a problem. In body fat, licorice blocks an enzyme that activates cortisol, but in our kidneys, licorice blocks a different enzyme that deactivates cortisol, causing your kidneys to hold on to extra water and sodium, and to lose potassium. If you lose too much potassium, it can cause weakness and abnormal heart rhythms, which is why the FDA sent out a consumer advisory warning if you're 40 or older eating 2 oz of black licorice a day for at least 2 weeks could land you in the hospital with an irregular heart rhythm. No matter what your age, don't eat large amounts of black licorice at one time. If you have been eating a lot of black licorice and have an irregular heart rhythm or muscle weakness, stop eating it immediately and contact your health care provider. Uh just because licorice is one of the oldest and most popular herbal medicines in the world doesn't mean it's safe to eat in large amounts. The retention of fluid and sodium can lead to blood pressure elevation, less than 2 oz of licorice a day. The regular consumption of just a few ounces a day can land you in the hospital in a coma with a blood pressure of 200 over 140. As many as 3% of hospitalizations due to high blood pressure are caused by licorice. Those with hypertension should probably avoid licorice completely, as should pregnant women, as licorice use during pregnancy is associated with preterm delivery and infant cognitive dysfunction. For non-pregnant individuals with normal blood pressure, what would be a safe dose? The problem is that glycyrrhizin levels vary in different licorice products, and some people are more sensitive than others. Now, a lot of licorice sold in the US doesn't even have any true licorice, and instead artificially flavored or cut with anise oil. Uh So, ironically, it's the black licorice you might find it at natural food store that may pose the greatest concern. Including a broad safety factor, European Scientific Food Committee suggests regular consumption of no more than 6 g of genuine licorice candy a day. A Hershey-funded study found that hard-coded licorice candies have 0.06 mg per gram. Um presuming that's referring to Good & Plenty, the limit would be about a box a day. Licorice tea allows you to access the herb without all the crap in candy, but a study of 33 brands found such varying levels of glycyrrhizin that the safe daily dose ranges from just a 10th of a cup up to 20 cups a day. A life-threatening arrhythmia reported in a case entitled Dying for a cup of tea was in a woman who was drinking 15 bags a day. Based on the average level, a half a cup of licorice tea should be safe for most people, though it's not clear that that would be enough to have a fat-reducing effect, which is why licorice never made it into my book how not to diet. Finally, cortisol isn't the only steroid hormone licorice can muck with. It also interferes with the production of testosterone. Feed men the equivalent of about 50 boxes of Good & Plenty, 9 oz of black licorice, or just a tablespoon of licorice root powder every day, and they experience a 44% drop in testosterone levels within 4 days. The blood levels bounced back within 4 days of stopping. The researchers suggest men with high blood pressure or decreased libido should be questioned about their licorice habits.