Five Star Weekend Author Elin Hilderbrand: Nantucket Drama, Casting Jen Garner & Season 2 Details
Watch on YouTubeVideo summary
In this episode of the "House Guests" book club, host Kenzie welcomes author Elin Hilderbrand to discuss her novel *Five-Star Weekend* and its upcoming television adaptation on Peacock. The story follows Hollis Shaw, a successful food blogger whose life falls apart after her husband's death, prompting her to host a weekend gathering for friends from various stages of her life, including childhood, college, motherhood, and internet acquaintances. Hilderbrand shares insights into her own journey, noting that she moved to Nantucket in 1993 following a breakup and began writing professionally shortly after, eventually achieving bestseller status with her sixth novel thanks to consistent publisher support for marketing and promotion.
The author reveals that her disciplined daily routine involves three hours of exercise before dedicating six to seven hours to writing, attributing her creative clarity to physical movement. She emphasizes the importance of confidence and security in friendships, warning against relationships with insecure individuals who may cause unnecessary drama. The premise of the book was inspired by a real-life story of a friend gathering dying companions for a weekend, though Hilderbrand altered the plot to feature her husband's death rather than a terminal illness diagnosis to make the narrative less tragic. Additionally, she addresses concerns about filming on Nantucket, explaining that the island's natural capacity limits overcrowding and expressing hope that tourism will expand into shoulder seasons.
Regarding the television adaptation, Hilderbrand explains how she and showrunner Becca Brunstetter worked to make the cheating protagonist, Gigi, more likable by giving her a supportive best friend who offers vulnerability and counseling. She defends the inclusion of infidelity as a necessary tool for drama and reader investment, comparing it to exploring complex emotions in art. The discussion also highlights generational differences regarding "cancel culture," where older characters face backlash for unfiltered opinions while younger generations prioritize safe spaces and mental health. Jennifer Garner was cast as Hollis after overcoming initial hesitation about typecasting, and the actress quickly bonded with her co-stars during production.
Looking ahead to Season 2, filming will move off Nantucket to locations such as Greece or France, potentially featuring a cruise ship setting with *Titanic* references and introducing a new "fifth star" character. Hilderbrand notes that while she did not write the TV adaptation herself, she collaborated closely with Brunstetter on specific details regarding her hometown. When asked about book tropes she dislikes, she states she has none, prioritizing excellent writing above all else. The interview concludes with recommendations for readers, including Ann Patchett's *Bel Canto* and Allegra Goodman's *This Is Not About Us*, alongside announcements for the next book club picks featuring titles like *Into the Blue* and *Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo*.
Read the full video transcript
I think you are the Beatrix author,
right?
>> How did you have A the confidence to
follow a creative career or just follow
your dreams in general? Kind of a
do-what-you-want to be like this is
going to work. You're the reason that I
came to Nantucket to begin with.
>> not know that.
>> Were there any like cancellations
[music] that you were watching during
the time of writing this book or was it
just kind of the overall theme?
>> question. The the whole idea of being
canceled by the internet is so
interesting to me. The most interesting
thing, and this has been true throughout
my career, is that
>> Hi house guests. I hope you guys are
having a fabulous day. Did y'all know
that subscribing to this YouTube channel
is completely free? It is a very easy,
simple, free way to support the show and
help us grow. If you do this, we are
able to bring you better content and
guests that you guys really want to see.
All you have to do is hit that red
subscribe button. And if you guys are
new here, comment below where y'all are
coming from and if you are a returning
house guest, comment below the first
episode that you watched. Thank you in
advance for subscribing. I love y'all so
much.
>> Hi house guests. Welcome back to the
show. I'm currently on island, as they
say. I'm here on the beautiful island of
Nantucket and this is our book club
episode. We recently brought back book
club to house guests where we are
reading a new book every six weeks with
the author. And what better way to start
on book club 2.0, a little refresh, than
to bring on Elin Hilderbrand for
Five-Star Weekend. Nantucket has really
been, you know, such a topic of
conversation recently. I'm sure you guys
have all seen the no influencers sign.
I'm sure you guys have seen Five-Star
Weekend everywhere. It is really just
something and as you guys know on this
podcast, we do have a drinking game.
It's mainly on episodes of Harrison
where we say take a shot every time we
say Nantucket cuz we're actually so
obnoxious and so annoying but it's my
favorite place in the entire world.
We're just having the best week. Should
everyone say a little hello?
>> Hi.
>> Hi house guests. My friends are
We're going to film a little week recap
after this, so that'll be coming next
week. Um and it's just a fabulous
fabulous time in Nantucket. Vlogs. I
will say I vlogged a little bit less
than normal because, you know, I was a
little bit scared of the no influencer
sign. Anyway, um we have Elin on the
show today. I'm so excited. She's the
reason that I started coming to
Nantucket like 5 6 years ago was from
her books. So, it's such an honor to
have her on. I've wanted to have her on
the show forever and this just worked
out so perfectly. So, we read Five-Star
Weekend by Elin Hilderbrand with Elin
Hilderbrand. I will say like there's
probably going to be some like spoilers
and things in this if you guys haven't
seen the show. If you have like sorry.
We're going to be recapping some things,
but I will give y'all a little book
summary.
I read this book when it came out and
then I like relistened on audio and then
thank god Caroline was also reading it.
I relistened on audio like a week and a
half ago, but Caroline read it this
entire trip. She did read a full book
start to finish on this trip. Claps for
Caroline.
Woo!
So, she really helped me prep for this
episode, which was just fabulous. But
anyways, if you guys need a little
summary cuz I always do at the beginning
of Book Club, here you go.
Okay. The book centers on Hollis Shaw, a
hugely successful food blogger behind
Hungry with Hollis. From the outside,
Hollis has built a very like enviable
life. She's got this beautiful Nantucket
home. She grew up on Nantucket and she's
got expanded as like actually insane a
successful career. Um she's married to
like this surgeon Matthew and then their
daughter Caroline actually. Hi,
Caroline.
Um but when the book begins, it's really
it's really beautiful and picturesque
for like a second and then you find out
um that Matthew dies. Okay, so that's
not a spoiler. That's like literally the
beginning of it. But Hollis and Matthew
had already been struggling in their
marriage. She becomes this really
successful food blogger and in my
opinion, I think he was just threatened
by her success and also wanted more
attention. Um on one snowy morning, they
have a really bad argument before
Matthew leaves for the airport and he
dies in a car accident like on the way,
leaving Hollis obviously devastated not
only by grief but feeling like the guilt
of that final interaction. Her
relationship with her daughter Carolina
is also very strained, so Hollis is like
essentially trying to figure out who she
is without the life and the marriage
that had defined her for so long, and
she's very like homemaker, like making
cooking content, all that stuff. I also
will say normally when you have an
influencer, you know,
no influencers, my own influencer said.
Normally when you have an influencer in
a book, I'm like not interested at all,
but like it does not feel that way
literally in the slightest. So, while
grieving, Hollis hears about the concept
of a five-star weekend where you invite
one best friend from each major era of
your life for a weekend together. Hollis
decides to host one at her Nantucket
house and chooses Tatum McKenzie, who is
her childhood best friend that still
lives on Nantucket. She and Hollis were
very, very close, but of course like
these are all drifted apart. It's really
cool because every single woman in
that's invited to this weekend like
knows a different part of her in a
different life, so it feels like she's
so known with this group because it's
like literally every single era of her
life. Juran, who's my favorite, her
college best friend, she is a very, very
successful sports agent and like media
personality. Um she's been getting
canceled by like Gen Z basically. And
yeah, she's amazing. Oh, and her and
Tatum have beef, okay? Then we're moving
on to Brooke. Brooke is her friend from
her motherhood years, and she's like
very um what's the word I'm looking for?
She's very like insecure. Like she's
very needy, very insecure. Then we have
Gigi Leing, Hollis's friend from
midlife. This is a very unusual choice
because Hollis has never actually met
Gigi in person. This is like an internet
friend, she was a subscriber of
Hollis's. And after Matthew dies, Gigi
becomes an important source of comfort
to her. And obviously Gigi is just like
kind of the She's like the ticking time
bomb almost of the book.
Caroline is also her daughter, she's
there from film school filming
everything. And then Jack Finnegan is
her high school boyfriend and first
love. So, anyways, I'm going to get into
the book with Elin and also just like
her career and life advice that she has.
I love her podcast and when she's giving
advice to like people in their 20s and
30s, it's just like very comforting.
Also, she lives year round on Nantucket,
which you know I just now I'd die for.
Name one topic I love more, okay? And
the show's on Peacock and I actually
hosted a five-star dinner party, which
I've been wanting to do
since I read the book like years ago.
This has been on one of my top book
recommendations list for so long because
I just think it's like the most
wholesome book. It's one of my top Elin
books and I just I love it. It's so
good. I read it when I was here
probably like I don't know, when did it
come out? Like three years ago, four
years ago? Three years ago, I think. I
literally have no idea, but it's a
really, really good read. So, anyway,
we're going to be
doing the whole thing. I'm going to be
giving a lot more spoilers I think than
we normally would just because the show
is out and of course there's all sorts
of changes and stuff between the book
and the show, but that's the point of
these book club episodes. We're going to
like really dive into it. So, anyway,
without further ado, let's welcome Elin
on to the show. All right, we are with
the Nantucket icon herself, Elin
Hilderbrand.
>> Hi Kenzie. Thank you for having me. This
is fun.
>> This is so full circle cuz you know,
you're the reason that I came to
Nantucket to begin with.
>> I did not know that. Okay, wow.
>> yes. Obviously.
>> Thank you.
>> would have been able to bring me here? I
mean, it's just so perfect.
>> Okay, yay. Well, you're not alone. A lot
of people I think have come because of
my books and it's like a real It's a
real honor. It's always humbling.
>> that like all the time on Main Street.
>> I do, but it's it's humbling, you know,
that people would travel 30 miles to an
island 30 miles off the coast of America
just cuz they read it about it in a
book.
>> Well, the thing that's so cool about
your books though is that it is
literally Nantucket. Like it is all of
the spots. Like sometimes I This is my
sixth time here and sometimes I have a
hard time remembering if I've actually
been to the location or if I've just
read about it.
>> Right, exactly. I know a lot of people
feel that way. That's funny.
>> I feel like you really have When the
first time I came here, we were on like
the little like smaller plane to the
island and every single person, I'm not
kidding, had an Alan Ruck grandpa.
>> Oh, that's funny. Okay, good. Well,
that's nice to hear.
>> It's amazing. Um also, congrats. Like
this is season two.
>> Yeah. Yeah, we just got a season two for
five star weekend. Thrilling.
>> Thrilling. So thrilling.
>> The whole thing
this show in particular has just been
like a a dream come true. It's like what
I always wanted for my adaptations, like
this particular show.
>> It's so perfect. It's so [snorts] good.
And I'm you're just like it feels like
almost like the new
I mean, I know this is like a
controversial thing, but it does in a
way almost feel like the new Yellowstone
where like everyone was going to like
Montana or wherever it was. Now
everyone's dream is Nantucket. How do
you feel about that?
>> So, I feel okay about it. I think when
like last September when they came to
film, now mind you, coming to film here
requires bringing 275 people, cast,
crew, blah blah blah. And they want the
so they had to go to the selectmen,
which is our governing board,
Nantucket's governing board is five
select people.
And it only passed two to one. I don't
two people recused themselves. It only
passed two to one, like it they almost
didn't let them film here, which I'm so
happy that they did let them film.
People were worried that Nantucket would
become overrun, that it would become too
popular. The nice thing about Nantucket,
Kenzie, is that it it cannot be overrun
because it it's self-regulating. So,
there's only so many planes. There's
only so many spots on the boat. There's
only so many spots for the cars.
And what I hope will happen is that
people who want to come will spread out
their visits into the shoulder season.
So, July and August are at saturation.
This is probably the most populated week
on Nantucket, this week and last week.
Then people a lot of people left for cuz
kids went back to school.
Um and it'll trickle, like, it'll get
less and less as we get towards Labor
Day. Um, but I I see, like, the island
tourism
sort of spreading out, so it goes all My
dream is for it to go all the way from
Labor Day to Nantucket Stroll, which is
the first weekend of December. That
people will still come like in October,
November.
>> I was going to say, um, my dream is to
come to the Christmas Stroll. I can't
wait to see that one day. I can't do it
this year, but next year I'm blocking it
off.
>> Yeah. It's at least the first weekend
It's the weekend after Thanksgiving is
when it is, always. Yeah.
>> Okay, can you talk about like your
journey with Nantucket when you got
here?
>> Yes. So, I arrived
My journey, and a lot of your listeners
are younger than me, and that this is
perfect This is the perfect story for
them. So, I was living in New York City.
I had a boyfriend who went to Columbia
Business School. We lived together. We
broke up in April.
We shared an apartment, and back in the
day,
you know, it was $800 a month, which was
a fortune. It was a one-bedroom. It was
a fifth-floor walk-up. And he had a job
in the city, uh, he between years of
business school. And so, I had to
I had to find a place to live so for the
summer.
So, I was like, "Okay, I'm going to go
to Nantucket." Now, I had grown up
summers going to the Cape. So, Nantucket
was not that much of a stretch. So, this
is 1993.
If you can imagine, I called
information. I got the name of the
newspaper in Nantucket, called the
newspaper, had them send me the
classifieds in the mail. Six days later
they arrive. I'm like looking through
week-old classifieds trying to find a
place to live. Found a room in a house
on Hooper Farm Road. You do not know
where that is. It doesn't matter. It's
mid-island.
It's a little tiny shack, essentially.
And when I drive my children past it,
they are like, "You did not live there."
Yes, I did. So, I had a a room that had
a half bath, and a door to the outside
and I had roommates and I didn't know
anybody and then my roommates that
summer just became my best friends.
Um my friend Margie, she was my
bridesmaid, she's Shelby's godmother,
like she's one of my best friends to
this day and this was 1993 so 33 years
ago and I just fell in love with
Nantucket and
in love with sort of the lifestyle here.
I went back to New York, I was teaching,
I went back to New York, I taught the
second year and then I moved here
permanently in '94.
>> It's just the most magical place ever.
>> Yeah. I was like I'm never leaving. I
loved it so much.
>> Okay, so you were teaching but when did
you start writing?
>> [snorts]
>> So I've always been writing.
Uh I needed jobs that paid money so I
started teaching.
I you know, after I got out of college
and that's why I had the had the summer
off and I was able to come here. And
then I went back, let's see, so I moved
here, met a guy, we started dating, he
worked at the Cliffside Beach Club,
which is down next to the Cali.
And he had the summers he had the
winters off. So he came to New York for
that first winter and then I moved to
Nantucket and then our first winter as a
couple or I guess our second winter as a
couple, we traveled and we went all
through Southeast Asia, Australia, New
Zealand. And then we came back to
Nantucket, we were engaged and then the
following winter we went all through
South America. We went to the Galapagos,
we went to Ecuador,
Costa Rica, we were just backpacking.
And then after that, I decided it was
time to go to graduate school. So I
applied to the University of Iowa
Writers' Workshop, which is the best
writing program in the country thinking,
am I going to get in? I don't know. I
got in and then in the fall of '96 off I
go to Iowa. And this is where things
start to get like very sad and strange
and then extremely extremely good. So I
go to Iowa. I am a fish out out water. I
miss Nantucket. Iowa City is
like it's wonderful now that I can sort
of appreciate it. At the time I felt
like I'd been dropped in like amongst
the
cornfields and the
pig farms and I you know, and it was big
>> like simple life, honestly.
>> Yeah, it was yeah. And I was like, okay,
what am I doing here? And I really my
husband was back here in Nantucket, my
friends were back here. And I really I
missed the life so much. So they had
therapy that free therapy at the
university. Hooray. So I start going to
free therapy and
the therapist said I'm crying, I want to
go home. And the therapist said, I think
it's pretty clear what you have to do.
And I thought she's going to tell me to
go home.
>> I'm booking a flight.
>> And she said you need to start writing
about Nantucket. And I was like,
oh, yeah.
And when I say to you that beach books
at that time didn't really exist. This
is '96.
There was like chick lit, like Bridget
Jones had just come out.
And Jane Green had written a novel
called Jemima J. And those were sort of
they were called chick lit, right? For
like very specifically marketed towards
young women.
But the beach book didn't really exist.
And so me writing about Nantucket
had like writing about a beach place
hadn't really been done.
Um
so I thought, oh all right. So I
started a novel called The Beach Club
based on the Cliffside Beach Club where
my then husband was working. And
uh
and my very last class at Iowa
my professor had his agent come to the
workshop. And the agent says, which one
of you lives on Nantucket? And I said,
oh, it's me. It was very obvious it was
me. I don't want to get into it, but it
was. And um
I was not like the other workshop
students.
>> And I wouldn't I would never picture
that.
>> Right. So I said no, it's me. And then
he said, please stay after class. And I
literally had my U-Haul packed. I was
ready to go.
And I didn't even want to stay and talk
to him, but I did. And And has been my
agent for 20
eight years? That's unheard of. He's
been my agent for 28 years.
>> I feel like no one really talks about
how important it is to support your
fertility before you even start trying
for kids. Even if you are not trying to
get pregnant right now, there is so much
that you can do to support your body
early. WeNatal is so great for your
daily routine. It is an easy habit to
just stock into your routine, just three
capsules a day or one scoop of their
pre-natal protein plus powder if that is
easier for you. I always say confidence
comes from keeping promises to yourself
and keeping them. And this just feels
like one of those small daily things
that really adds up. It also just takes
the pressure off because you're already
doing something for your future
fertility now and your future self will
thank you. WeNatal is different than
other pre-natals for a multitude of
reasons. Most pre-natals only include
around 12 nutrients. WeNatal includes 24
key nutrients at optimal doses. All
intentionally chosen and formulated with
the help of functional medicine
practitioners. Every batch is
third-party tested for purity and
quality. It's backed by leading
functional medicine doctors and
fertility experts including Dr. Mark
Hyman, Dr. Casey Means, and nutritionist
Kelly LeVeque. If you don't know where
to start with your WeNatal routine, I
think the capsules are the way to go.
It's the easiest part of your daily
routine and I have been recommending to
all of my friends. WeNatal makes it easy
to cover all of your key nutrients and
support fertility, hormones, and overall
reproductive health. Whether you're
planning for a future pregnancy with a
partner or simply taking care of your
body for yourself. Visit
WeNatal.com/houseguests
for a free month supply of WeNatal Rest
and Digest Magnesium, a $40 value, with
your first subscription. It's a premium
magnesium supplement designed to support
relaxation, digestion, and overall
well-being formulated with four
bioavailable forms of magnesium. That's
WeNatal.com/houseguests
for a free month supply of WeNatal Rest
plus
Digest Magnesium with your first
subscription.
This episode is sponsored by cotton, the
fabric of our lives. One of the hacks
that I would recommend [clears throat]
when surviving a really, really brutal
hot summer. You guys know I hate the
heat. You know that summer's tough for
me unless I'm on Nantucket. Ask me now,
okay? Anyway, something that really does
make a huge difference would obviously
not just be the clothes that I'm
wearing, but the material that they're
made out of, okay? I love to wear cotton
because it is so, breathable. Cotton
breathes, so it allows air to circulate
making it a lot more comfortable in the
warmer months. And I'm doing anything
that I can survive these days, okay?
It's also really easy to layer for
warmer days and cooler evenings, which
is really nice. I love it even just in
like underwear, undergarments. I just
find that it's more breathable. I love
the quality. I also, especially in
undergarments, really like that cotton
does not shed microplastics like
synthetic fibers. It's also naturally
hypoallergenic and less likely to
irritate the skin compared to synthetic
fibers like polyester. It's also just a
lot more comfortable. It's more
breathable, it's more comfortable, and
it's just the perfect material for these
hot summer months.
You can always check your tag for
cotton.
Cotton is the fabric of our lives. Learn
more at the fabricofourlives.com.
Before we jump back into today's
episode, I have to tell y'all about a
company that is really, truly,
completely changing the wedding industry
for couples like us who want beautiful
flowers without the traditional floral
price tag because my god is that
expensive. Something Borrowed Blooms is
a floral rental service that delivers
premium silk wedding flowers straight to
your doorstep. They have bridal
bouquets, bridesmaid bouquets,
centerpieces, arches, garlands, and like
honestly, even just decor. Everything
arrives to use and look incredibly
realistic. Then when your wedding is
over, you just simply send it back. And
here's the part that couples love. You
can save up to 70% compared to
traditional fresh florals.
No worrying about flowers wilting in the
heat, no scrambling with last minute
florist issues, no guessing what your
flowers will look like day of, and no
spending thousands of dollars on
arrangements that you're only going to
use for one day and trash. It's really
tragic. Their collections are amazing.
They have something for everyone. And
plus, because you're renting, you can
get that luxury floral look without the
luxury floral budget, all while being
eco-friendly in the process. Again, the
process could not be easier. You place
your order online, everything ships
directly to you 3 days before your event
date. You can celebrate stress-free, and
then you simply return the arrangements
back in the boxes that they came in
using the provided prepaid FedEx return
labels. So, if you are currently
planning a wedding and wondering how to
have this like Pinterest-worthy
floral look while still staying on a
budget,
which is tough, do yourself a favor and
check out Something Borrowed Blooms. No
longer tough because of Something
Borrowed Blooms. Visit Something
Borrowed Blooms to browse their
collections, order samples, and see how
much you can save on your wedding
flowers. They were so kind to offer an
exclusive discount just for y'all, so
visit somethingborrowedblooms.com
and use code hosscast at checkout for
$100 off of $500 plus. That is
somethingborrowedblooms, b l o o m s dot
com, and use code hosscast at checkout
for $100 off of $500 plus. Trust me,
your budget will thank you.
>> Wow.
>> Yeah, and he had grown up on Main Street
in the summers, very fancy house,
and
uh
so, he was really into the idea of
selling this book on Nantucket. So, I
I finished the book,
mail it to him. This is still like I'm
printing it out, putting it in a box,
mailing it to New York. Send it to him
in New York, he gets it, he reads it.
He's like, I I love this. I want to
represent you. I'm going to make you
lots and lots of money. So, who doesn't
want to hear that? I was thrilled.
>> [laughter]
>> So, he sends it to, you know, at that
time there were 12 publishers in New
York. Now there are only five. That time
there were 12. Sends it to 12
publishers,
and they all turn it down. And then the
13th publisher
says, we will publish it, and they gave
me an advance of $5,000. Even in 1996
Kenzie $5,000 was not enough money for
me to quit my job. So, I said okay, but
I we didn't have any other offers. So, I
said all right. So, we published it
in the summer of 2000 for five grand I
got and
uh two weeks after it had been out
People magazine chose it as their beach
book of the week.
>> Wow.
>> I was so excited.
They immediately ran out of copies and
what you have to realize is this is
before the Nook, the iPhone. This is
before that. So, there was like Borders
and Barnes & Noble. This is before you
were born. Okay. So,
it was a hard lesson because for three
weeks over the like best part of the
summer you couldn't get the book. It was
completely sold out.
Um but they went back to press and it
ended up selling well enough that then I
was offered a two-book deal. I did not
hit the big time until my sixth novel,
Barefoot which came out in 2007.
And that novel at that point I had
switched publishers because my first
publisher
just wasn't really doing right by me.
They weren't sending me on tour. They
weren't putting any money behind the
book.
If I have If we have any aspiring
writers out there, almost more important
than how big your advance is is how much
money they're putting to promote you.
Right?
>> Mhm.
>> And now it's a little easier cuz you can
get it into the hands of book
influencers and
that can do the work for you, but you
know, taking out ads in the New York
Times and buying the end caps. So, when
you go to Target and you see the books
on the end of the aisles, those that
real estate is paid for by the
publishers. It's not just the guy at
Target decided that's where the book
should go. It is paid for and my
publisher wasn't doing any of that. So,
in 2006 I switched publishers and my new
publisher Little Brown, who I'm still
with,
totally changed my life and put a lot of
money behind the books and groomed me
summer by summer, like book by book,
year by year, I got a little bit higher.
I hit the New York Times bestseller list
in paperback with my novel Barefoot, and
then every book after that hit the list
a little bit higher, a little bit
higher. It was my 23rd novel,
Summer of '69,
in 2019 that finally
reached number one.
>> That is crazy to me.
>> It was a very slow, deliberate,
intentional climb to the top.
>> It's crazy to me though because it
doesn't feel that way as a reader
because your books are so even when
you're any title that you're talking
about, Barefoot, I can picture the cover
immediately and they're so recognizable
as your book even when there's books
that are like trying to emulate your
covers. Like you know if it's an Elin
book or not, right? So that is insane.
>> Yes, it is insane. And but it's because
so you're young enough that you would
have grown up seeing a book every summer
and they all looked the same. That was
an a decision by my publisher. Like
we're going to brand this,
>> Mhm.
>> right? We're going to give these covers
a certain font and a certain look. I
said to my daughter, my gravestone has
to have the Elin Hilderbrand font.
>> [laughter]
>> My name has to look like this. She's
like, "Okay."
Um
Yeah. So I, you know, that is like my my
font and my look and and then other
publishers and other writers started
using it. And I'm not going to come on
here and say I was the first person to
ever write a beach book. I most
certainly wasn't.
But
I was at the forefront of what has now
become an extremely big part of
publishing.
>> Of course. I I think you from an outside
perspective, I do feel like you really
pioneered it. Like
>> Yeah, I was one of the first ones who
did it and did it every year. So I think
between 2000 and 2024 there were only
two summers I didn't publish, which
would have been 2001 and 2004. Other
than that, I published a book every
single year.
And then, for 7 years in there, I
published two books cuz I was writing
winter books as well.
So, when I look back on it now, I do not
know how I did it cuz I also raised
three kids.
>> No, it's unheard of.
>> It was crazy.
>> That's like
>> How did I do it? I don't know.
>> It is a crazy, crazy, crazy amount of
books to put out.
>> Yeah.
>> I'm curious though, because you, like in
my own words, I think you've really
pioneered the like beach book space.
Like I think you are the beach read
author, right?
>> Yeah.
>> But doing that so young, how did you
have A, the confidence to follow a
creative career or just follow your
dreams in general without sounding
corny, and B, kind of the wherewithal to
be like, this is going to work?
>> I didn't know that it was going to work
because I had really, what I would
consider failed five times, because
my first five books
did not
they didn't do well. I mean, they did
well enough.
They did well enough that I was and I
obviously love like writing was in my
blood, so I was going to do it whether
or not I was getting paid or whatever.
They I did not break out until my sixth
try, but I was just going to keep
writing
until I broke out. And then when I broke
out, then I started getting more readers
and every year I'd get more readers. And
I when I tell you I did everything
under the sun. I have gone to every book
festival. I've been you know, I would go
and tour and
you know, I did a an event at the
Charleston library and three people
showed up. This was in 2012. It wasn't
even that long ago.
Three people came, but one woman had
driven like 4 hours to get there. And so
that I was like, oh my god, that made me
feel so special even though only three
people came.
And
it was just a lot of trying. Like really
trying and then
as I got more and more popular then the
social media came into existence and I I
do all my own social media.
I do my own Instagram. It's like my
fifth child. I mean I just I you know.
So, but it was it it wasn't that I set
out in 2000 in 2000 or even 2006 to be
like I'm going to be this. It was just
like I'm going to keep writing and you
can only do what's right in front of
you, right? So, I'm going to write this
book. And then when that book's finished
I'm going to write the next book and the
next book's going to be as good as if
not better than the book I just wrote.
Or different from, you know, and
now at the age of 57 I'm looking back
and I'm like I have something for
everybody. Right? There's a There's like
a love story, 28 Summers. There's a
historical novel, Summer of '69. You
know, there's the thriller which is like
the the Paradise series that's set in
St. John. There's the Christmas series.
You know, my daughter and I have written
two novels set at an at a boarding
school. Those are not YA but they're YA
adjacent because half the characters are
are Gen Z teenagers. Um
so we I really have something for
everybody
which is
it's fun and I and I did the murder
mystery which is the perfect couple and
I thought I don't I'm just going to try
and write a murder mystery and see what
happens.
So, yeah.
>> It's amazing how many books you put out
in a relative I mean a relatively short
time. I know it was 30 years but for the
amount of books like that's really
crazy. What is your like day-to-day
routine or writing routine? Like how do
you approach that?
>> most
interesting thing and this has been true
throughout my career is that the first
thing I do every day
is I exercise. So, I exercise every
single morning. I'm to a point now where
I I'm exercising and this has been true
for years, probably 10 years.
It's 3 hours a day. So, I ride the
Peloton, I do a bar class, and then I go
for what I call my yogging, which is my
very slow jogging.
You could walk You could walk faster
than I yog. A lot of A lot of people do.
But, I like it because the Peloton is
like really intense cardio, and then the
bar claw My bar class is outstanding
here. And then,
the walking and jogging yogging gets me
outside. So, it's like I call it my
green exercise cuz I'm outside inhaling
actual fresh air.
And that's a really important part of my
discipline because it's Exercising is
hard. Nobody likes it. If they say they
like it, they're lying. It's hard. And
once that's done, I think to myself,
"Okay, I've now done the hardest thing
I'm going to do today." And so,
therefore, writing would be de facto
easier. And then, so after I do my
exercising, if I'm writing a novel, I
will sit down
and write between 11 and a perfect world
like 11 and 6, and I'll take breaks,
and I'll take a nap, and I'll eat my
lunch, and
if it's summer and I'm at the I write at
the beach or I write at my pool, and
I'll go for a swim,
and I read also during my work day, and
I consider reading part of my work day
because I love to read, and it really
inspires me and gets
my juices flowing. It does. Like, "Oh my
gosh, like now I'm going to work on my
own book." And
and then,
you know, in the evenings like I had
kids, so I was, you know, a lot of a lot
of that was interrupted. Even though
that would be a perfect day like I
raised children, and they all played
three sports, and so I was always
picking them up from sports, and
you know,
taking them to the boat if they had away
games, and I mean, so many things, and
then making their dinner and doing their
homework, and reading their It was It
was a lot. It was a lot. But, um in a
perfect world, I I I worked
for 6 or 7 hours a day, and probably
composed
3 hours. And if you compose 3 hours a
day,
you can write two books a year.
It's so impressive.
>> Thank you. I also think the discipline
is just everything and I can't really
think unless I'm working out. This past
two weeks that I've been here haven't
been working out. My brain has not
worked. Yeah. Not a single second.
>> It is I think scientifically proven that
when you're moving
your brain is moving and a lot of people
have their best ideas when they're
exercising.
>> Oh, 100%. If I go on like my yoga, you
know, cuz I'm also the same. I suddenly
am like, oh, I'm literally Albert
Einstein. I could think of anything. I
could solve any issue, you know.
>> Okay, should we get into I guess the
book?
>> Sure.
>> Okay, to me I think the book is I want
to hear like your synopsis cuz I
obviously can't just give like a summary
for you. But to me I think the book is
largely about friendship, forgiveness,
and grief. And I also think it's really
cool because it's
I think a lot like when I'm applying
this in my own life I actually hosted a
five-star dinner dinner party and I
invited I had the idea when I first did
or when I first read the book when it
came out and I always loved the idea of
having like, you know, four different
women from different areas of my life to
come over for dinner and then I did like
an on the rocks thing and I was like,
oh, perfect. Now I really can.
>> Perfect.
>> And it was amazing. But I love like
kind of like what is revealed about you
when you're in the right kind of
relationships, you know? With the book
like Hollis is surrounded by people who
have known her almost at like every
single stage of her life.
>> So she they're like kind of like a
mirror to her in a way
>> Yeah.
>> which I think is so cool. Like where did
you originally get the idea for this
book?
>> So I got the idea for this book in 2020.
Another writer, a writer who's very
successful, she came to Nantucket. She
texted me. She said, "I'm here
for girls weekend. Can you meet for a
drink?" Now, if you remember, we weren't
really doing that in September of 2020.
So I thought that was a little strange.
I went and I met her and we went to the
Nantucket Hotel and sat in the bar. We
were the only people there. I said,
"What are you even doing here?"
And also like if If on a girls weekend,
why did you call me? So, she said,
"Uh my friend
is has been diagnosed with terminal
cancer.
She's not going to make it, but
she feels okay right now, so she
gathered
um her closest friends from throughout
her life to do this very special weekend
on Nantucket."
And then the writer said, "And not all
of us are getting along, and I needed to
get out of the house, and that's why I
called you for a cocktail."
And I was like, "Oh my god, that is a
novel."
And she said, "Well, it's an Elin
Hilderbrand novel." And so, then she's
There were certain things she didn't
want me to use. So, when I sat down to
write it, I wrote it with the intention
that this woman was dying, and she was
going to have these friends. And page
three, I'm like, "This is too sad. I
cannot do this." I just done 28 summers.
I'm like, "I'm not doing it to these
people again."
So, I said, "I'll have the husband die."
[laughter]
>> Yeah, who needs them?
>> better.
Much better. So, I did. I switched it,
so that the husband died, and that It
was so much happier.
>> [laughter]
>> Not in like a I'm not being flip. It
just was like one step removed was so
much better. It was so much better. Oh
my god, that is so funny. If you were
hosting your own five-star weekend, who
are you bringing?
So, I mean, I would bring my best friend
from growing up, and I grew up in
Collegeville, Pennsylvania, and then I
would bring my I had two best friends in
college.
One of my best friends from Johns
Hopkins, and I would bring my friend
Rebecca, who we raised. She's my best
friend now. I'm meeting her for dinner.
She was my best friend through raising
my kids. And then I did later in life
make a different friend group, like in
the last
like since like 2018, so like the last 8
years, I've made a group of friends that
are
like newer friends, but I would bring
one of them. I do have like the four the
four stages. And
I think it would be fine.
Um
I've lived on the Antek it for so long
that it almost feels like my entire life
lives it
exists here.
>> Totally.
>> And my friend from high school that I'm
thinking of has never visited me here.
So, although she has
>> miss.
>> I know.
I know. It's just I you know, I have so
many children I don't really have house
guests, which is really
its own benefit. But um
>> [laughter]
>> Yeah. So, I think it would be it would
be interesting anyway.
>> We we don't necessarily know if they
would get along, but like we could give
it a shot.
>> I feel good about everybody except maybe
my friend from high school cuz I I ended
some place different from where I
started if that makes sense to you.
>> Totally.
>> And so, my friend from high school is a
little different from the friends that I
made later in life.
>> Yeah. What have you learned like about
friendship in just like over the
decades? Cuz I think it's really cool to
hear like when I think about like my mom
making new friends in her like 30s, 40s,
50s like and on, it's really encouraging
cuz it's just like you forget that that
can continue to happen.
>> It feels so instant.
>> Right. Yeah. It Yes. I don't know. I
I've had a lot of friendships go upside
down. Like I've had friends um
like I had a girlfriend in college who I
no longer speak to. I mean, I've had
friendships go badly. And I think it's
because we get so close. And tell me if
you agree with this. There are instances
in which women get so close to another
woman
and then for whatever reason
it just
ends badly.
>> Like explodes a little bit.
>> It can. It can end badly. Um whether it
be jealousy or
I don't know.
>> too close maybe. Like maybe it's like
>> close.
Like there was one friend I had and I
was closer to her than I was to my
husband at the time and and then it just
ended it just ended badly. And
um
So, now
and when I say now, I mean for like the
last
almost 20 years, I've had a core group
of friends
here on Nantucket who
uh
they we we are all like super
independent, super busy, super
fulfilled, super secure, and there is no
friendship drama. So, I would say in the
last, you know, 18 I can definitely say
18 years, there I've had zero friendship
drama.
Would you say that
>> the most important quality, cuz I would
assume maybe like people when you
especially when you were gaining such
success and it just continues to go up,
would you say that
like the most important quality in a
friend would be like them feeling
confident, secure, and fulfilled?
>> Yes.
>> Cuz I I think that's maybe that's where
it happens.
>> Because and I think anybody that's
listening this will will appreciate this
comment. If you have a friend who is
insecure,
they are a problem.
>> I agree.
>> Low self-esteem, that is a problem. Cuz
they're looking to you for something and
you can only deal with yourself.
You know?
>> Totally.
>> my daughter's 20, she's in college, and
you know, we have had a lot of talks
over the summer about friends of hers
who aren't as she's extremely confident,
extremely self-possessed, extremely
self-aware.
All qualities that I just admire her so
much because when I was 20, I was none
of those things.
Um
but we had conversations about other
people in her life who maybe aren't as
confident and
and self-possessed as she is and how to
deal with them, right? Cuz it's hard.
>> No, it's really hard. And I do think
it's I think it's almost next to
impossible if that friend whether it's
you or them continues to be like if I
think it's different to like of course
everyone feels insecurity at different
times. I think when you're consistently
acting out of insecurity is like when it
goes south.
>> Yeah.
>> It's hard. It's tough.
>> Especially if you're someone who's very
driven and you live a full life, and you
have all these things going. It's like
you're not going to slow yourself down
for that, you know?
>> If we're Let's If we take it back to the
book, this is so interesting.
And you saw the show.
>> Yes.
>> Okay. So, Brooke, right, comes into the
event, the weekend, and she feels
insecure, right? And it's super obvious.
And
the best thing about the way D'Arcy
Carden played her is that
D'Arcy or
D'Arcy's Brooke knows that she's a bot.
Like she's like, "I am not like the rest
of you. I do not have my together
like the rest of you. I am not beautiful
like the rest of you. I'm not, you know,
I I'm just She feels less than." And
she really grows, I think, to accept
herself over the course of the weekend.
Which that doesn't normally happen in
real life. Like it wouldn't be a
weekend.
>> Yeah.
>> But that arc that she has,
I think it's really satisfying because
she comes in as sort of the one without
her together, and she leaves in a
much better place.
>> Was there a character that was
particularly difficult for you to write,
or someone that just maybe irked you?
>> It was very hard, obviously, and and and
we all found it hard on set to make GG
You have to walk such a fine line with
GG
because you want her to be likable.
>> Mhm.
>> And at the same time, she's like the
source of this enormous explosion,
right? Like she's the other woman.
And
nobody knows it. And
in the book, I'm like, "Okay, I have to
make her likable."
And And Becca, who is the showrunner and
the screenwriter, she felt the same way.
Like she had Like she gives
uh GG this fabulous best friend,
John Mark, who's
played by Torrey DeVitto Smith. I mean,
oh my god, he's so good. He's He's so
good.
But he makes Gigi likable because he's
likable and he's her friend and he's
like
counseling her and so that makes it if
she's it makes her vulnerable and if
she's vulnerable then we like her more
than we would have normally.
>> He also does a good job because it
almost feels as a viewer watching the
show like you're able to project
yourself and be him and understand that
your friend like you keep thinking of
your best friend that's made a mistake.
>> Of course.
>> I think Gigi is actually really likable
like that I think that was done so well.
I'm actually curious because I know that
you got I remember you posting an
Instagram story or something about how
much backlash you got for having
characters who were cheating and how
having characters in a book cheating is
essentially the way that people act is
like worse than murder. With like
approaching this book was that kind of
like did you just want to do it again
almost not like out of spite but like a
challenge?
>> Well, the way I always talk about it is
as follows. I
heard someone like Sting talking to
someone like Oprah. I'm not exactly sure
it was the two of them. It was it let's
but let's say for the sake of argument
it was them.
And Sting says to Oprah, "There are two
kinds of songs.
The first song is I love you and that's
a good song.
The second song is I love you but you
love someone else and that's a better
song."
>> Totally.
>> also a better book. It is a way better
book
um
if
there is drama. Right? And
it is I I find it when I'm reading like
as soon as something is going on like I
want to like turn the pages and so
that's why
I write about infidelity a lot because I
don't have that many tools at my at my
you know, disposal to write a beach
book.
You know what I mean? It's it's
absolutely
um
it's
pivotal that I have the tool of adultery
because people are instantly like, "Oh
my god, something Someone's doing
something bad. I'm now super invested
cuz you want to find out what happens."
>> Calling all serial hobbyist, host,
homebodies, readers, if any of these
things apply to you, this is for you. If
y'all don't know, I'm the founder of
Friend of Mine, a home and hobby brand.
I'm on a mission to bring people
together through the home and hobbies.
We have recipe journals to keep your
favorite recipes all in one place to
have and pass down one day, conversation
cards for your next dinner party or
bachelor night, nightcap cards for your
next date night. We even have family
cards for your next family dinner. Then,
of course, we have our needlepoint
products that you guys can add to your
stash, gardening accessories when you
need some extra peace and the cutest
Kindle cases that you've ever seen.
Also, we do have the best overalls in
the world, and as an overall connoisseur
myself, I can say that with confidence.
If you like the show, y'all are going to
love Friend of Mine. Go to
shopfriendofmine.com and use code
houseguest for 15% off your first
purchase and try it out for yourself. I
recommend going for either the overalls,
dinner cards, or a new canvas. Little
hint, if anything is out of stock,
always sign up for the restock list.
>> At Starbucks, full and part-time
baristas can build meaningful careers
while getting industry-leading benefits
like comprehensive health coverage and
up to 18 weeks of paid parental leave
without missing a step in their careers.
Because at Starbucks, great benefits and
opportunities to grow are just the
start. Learn more at
starbucks.com/partners.
If you have been putting off your smile
for years, SmileDirectClub is how you
finally do something about it.
Doctor-prescribed clear aligners done
from home for 60% less than braces.
SmileDirectClub delivers
doctor-prescribed clear aligners for
under $1,800. That is 60% less than
traditional braces or in-office
treatment. A licensed doctor reviews
your case and builds your custom
treatment plan.
Having braces and doing all that stuff
was so expensive. It's so amazing that
they're one making it more affordable
and two just making it easier. You can
start with an at-home impression and
your aligners ship straight to you. Your
progress is monitored remotely through
the Smile Set app with doctor check-ins
available whenever you want them.
Smile Set has treatment options and
payment plans that fit around your life.
Nighttime only aligners mean that you
can straighten your teeth while you
sleep, and monthly payments start at
just $89.
Over 2 million smiles treated with this
technology, 30-day money-back guaranteed
after starting treatment. It's the
easiest thing ever, like actually, and
even just the app alone makes this so so
so much better.
I got that home impression kit. I was so
impressed by the app. I was also just so
impressed by like checking with the
doctor. It's so user-friendly. I wish
that this had always been a thing. Okay.
Listeners of our show will get an
additional 35% discount when they go to
smileset.com/houseguests.
With this discount, you can get the
smile of your dreams for just under
1,200 bucks. That's insane. Go to
smileset.com/houseguests
to get started.
smileset.com/houseguests.
>> Something I really like about this book
as well, amongst all of the women, is I
love reading about a woman over really
like over the age of like 40, because I
feel like so often, especially just like
in Hollywood and shows and stuff, it's
like so boring. Like I love that who's
flawed and not always likable.
>> Yeah.
>> Like uh a good example of this, she's in
her 70s, but it would be the
correspondent, like that main character.
Very unlikable, but I found her to be
there's some sort of it's like a little
bit like endearing. There's something
about her that you feel connected to.
>> And I think with all of these
characters, like this weekend really
kind of like breaks apart, you know,
like their identities, and they kind of
there's all like some sort of solution
at the end, and it's like a really
beautiful wholesome like kind of like
full circle moment, but I really liked
how like my favorite character is June.
Like I really like how she just kind of
like doesn't give a Like she's
just going to do whatever she wants to
do, and is flawed, and maybe isn't the
most like, you know, PC person, isn't
exactly who everyone else wants her to
be, but that's just who she is and I
like that.
>> Yeah, I mean she's been a woman in a
man's business. So that's like she has
to be tough and I think she's shook that
she is getting cancelled
for expressing what a lot of people my
age
>> Yeah.
>> would express, which is that, you know,
we didn't have the luxury of safe spaces
or saying that we're triggered and need
to take a minute. Like we didn't have
any of that. We had to do
you know, our parents left us to just
raise ourselves and we didn't have the
internet so we didn't know what anyone
else was doing except for in the movies.
So we would go we would go to the
movies. We'd watch Molly Ringwald in 16
Candles. Like that was how we viewed
American high school. Like we'd watch
Ferris Bueller. Like that those were but
we didn't have the internet so we knew
what everybody else was doing. We had to
sort of figure it out by ourselves and
so Drew Ann is tough on Posey
as I feel like a lot of people my age
would be and she gets called on it cuz
it's just not the way the world works
anymore.
>> Yeah, totally. I think
I love this whole storyline with her
specifically. I think it's so funny
because I am Gen Z. I'm like thank you
very much. I'm like literally one year
on the cusp. I'm like no guys, I'm so
Gen Z. But I really like it cuz I think
of course most of the conversation
around mental health is a positive
thing, but there's of course things that
are going to be, you know, using it to
their advantage. Also I
being like a public person who's like
putting my life online, of course
there's you see cancellations, you know
people who've been cancelled.
>> And so often it is not actually what you
think it is and you know those people
and they're amazing. The people who like
it's just when you were have more
context from behind the scenes, like
that's actually not even what happened.
This is really messed up. So I think it
was cool to see it in a like in a like
story.
>> Yeah.
>> It felt exactly
>> It was just It felt timely, right? Cuz
you're like okay.
>> and satisfying.
>> Yeah, cuz you're like okay, this could
so easily happen.
Somebody's just saying what they think
and they get caught on film.
>> Like her kids.
>> And the internet just takes it and
decides what it is. And you there's no
room for conversation around that.
>> Right.
>> Something I think you did so, so, so
well in this book was it like I was
saying but before I went to this book, I
mean I knew I would love it because it
was your book, but like normally I don't
want to hear about like I am you know,
God forbid I'm an influencer on this
island, but like I don't want to hear or
like read about influencers in general.
>> Right.
>> Or like you know when you're watching a
movie and there's like like probably
like 10 years ago all of a sudden
there's like a tweet on the screen.
>> Yeah.
>> Like that was never what I liked. And
you did such an amazing job to where and
of course like this is not shocking.
This was never going to be an issue with
you. But you did such an amazing job
having like a food blogger and like an
influencer
>> Yeah.
>> be the center cuz nothing about it in
the book and also I mean in the show,
nothing about it feels corny. Like how
did you achieve that?
>> I don't really know. I originally what
was I
Hollis was something else. She was sort
of like a lifestyle guru or like a
self-help person and then I'm like this
is not working. It wasn't working. And I
love to cook. And all of my other books
as you know have like very good food in
them. And so I thought I'm just going to
it. I'm just going to make her a
food. I'm going to make her a food
blogger cuz that's that was a space
where I felt comfortable.
And as soon as I did that the book
really came together cuz then I'm like,
okay and now of course then she's going
to throw this fantastic weekend for her
friends and
that you know, food is going to be at
the center of it and I love to like
food is my love language. My children
will tell you like I cook for them all
the time.
As a way of saying I love you and I'm
feeding you and I'm taking care of you
and that's the same for Hollis. And so
once I figured out that she was going to
be a food blogger, it was super easy.
And then I made her the food blogger
that I would be if I were a food
blogger. Which I am not. But
>> I love that so much.
>> Yeah.
>> Were there any like cancellations that
you were watching during the time of
writing this book or was it just kind of
the overall feeling?
>> question. And the thing is is that there
probably were and I don't remember
because it goes so quickly and then that
person
I know cuz then it's
>> Wallen had gotten into some serious
trouble. Like the serious serious
trouble.
>> That was right around the time I was
writing this.
And I can remember saying there were I
know a guy that's in country that's in
the business of country music and he
said, "Oh, he'll be back. He'll be
back." And I thought, "There is no way
he's coming back from this." And sure
enough
>> Sure enough.
>> Sure enough. And so
nothing is insurmountable. I guess
that's what the the whole idea of being
canceled
by the internet is so interesting to me.
>> It is cuz it's in that space it's
your your boss is almost like just the
public.
>> Right.
>> Your boss is the public. And also you
don't know them and it feels like a mob
but they don't know each other.
>> Yeah.
>> So
>> And they're the loudest.
>> Yeah.
>> like overall I think it's interesting
too with Hollis because she feels like
in this book she's kind of like lost her
identity cuz she's lost her husband.
>> Yeah.
>> And then she in the book has a much
worse relationship with her daughter at
that time.
>> So it's just interesting because then
watching that she's going down Dorian
feels
I don't know. It's just like it's a cool
like juxtaposition to watch where I feel
like everyone's like figuring it out but
in the background Like I'm thinking
about if I'm during this I'm like
freaking the I'm not like the
chicken box crying. Like I you know what
I mean? Like I'm not doing well.
>> Regina Hall really played it she played
it a lot tougher than Dorian is in the
book. And I think in the book Dorian is
very upset because her identity is her
career. Totally. Right? So if your
identity is your career and your career
is in danger
it's very similar to being Hollis where
you're a mom and a housewife
and your husband dies. and then who are
you right then and then your daughter is
not speaking to you so then who are you
right so they both sort of feel I mean
you're right I have not thought of it
this way before but they're both like at
at a loss cuz they're like okay my this
is thing that's central to my identity
is under attack and has been you know
damaged they're like fish out of water
like they don't know what to do and then
naturally like you're going to kind of
flip out on each other and then there's
so much with I'm curious with when you
write a book and then it goes on to be
produced into you know TV shows movies
whatever it is and there's changes that
are made are there specific changes that
were made in this that were hard for you
like is it difficult at the beginning
does it get easier or you just not care
so my philosophy with adaptation is I
love the word adaptation because
I believe in it and I watch a lot of
prestige TV and I've seen things that
have been adapted again the internet has
their opinions I saw a friend of mine
novelist who had a show come out this
year and the internet was was not very
nice about it and I felt bad cuz I was
like
you know
I don't know [snorts] there are a lot of
ways to adapt a show my philosophy has
always been TV is a different form of
art a lot of people made noise with the
perfect couple cuz they did change the
perfect couple a lot from the book
because Netflix wanted a six episode
murder mystery
my novel has a lot of love story in it
right there's two relationships going on
and
that are two love triangles going on and
neither of them got any airtime in the
show and I think people were upset about
that but it was a six episode murder
mystery so that's what they got
and that didn't bother me at all I'm
like people can read the perfect couple
book and they can get things that I
wrote and that's it did not change the
book five star weekend is closer a lot
closer to the source material
there was nothing that they changed that
made me upset. I thought all the changes
were appropriate and beneficial for a TV
show.
>> Yeah, cuz also you can I mean
Well, I'm sure you love that everyone
always likes the book better.
>> Yeah, but you can't you can't directly
>> You can't cuz the book is what you want
it to be when you're reading it.
>> Right. Yeah, the show would suck if you
just completely just like directly
translated it to.
It's just not going to work.
>> I also think it would have been tough
for people
to like empathize with Caroline. I think
on a screen. Like in a book and as
someone who's like dealt with grief and
knows grief deeply, like I completely
understand and that makes sense and I
feel like in a book that translates so
well and it's like yeah, obviously she's
going through a lot. She's lost her
father. She's a teenager got like that
is already a tough time, but I'm sure
like you know, in a in a show you're
less connected typically than you are
with a book cuz it's just you in that
book. So I feel like people have like a
little bit less empathy when it comes to
shows. So I feel like that was probably
a good call to not make you just like
hate the character.
>> Yeah, exactly.
>> You know what I mean?
>> Yeah, it is their their relationship
Hollis and Caroline's relationship is a
lot more complex. They did change and I
thought this was so genius
because in the book Dylan is Tatum's son
and he has a child with Aubrey who is
like the baby mama and she's a real
in the book.
But they changed it so that Aubrey was
Tatum's daughter so that Hollis and
Tatum have daughters and then and then
Tatum and Aubrey and Dylan are still
involved in a love triangle, but it
echoes what's happening in the in the
mom's world. So I just thought that was
so brilliant.
>> I think that's really cool. I really
like that aspect. Um what was it like
with Jennifer Garner? Like could you
even like imagine like if you were to do
your perfect cast? I actually truly
think this is the best casting ever. I
would I don't even know how I could ever
if I'm you like
dream up of a better Oh my god.
>> a great cast. And the wonderful thing
about it,
I went out for the table read in
early June of last year. So, June of
'25, I fly out to LA for the table read.
And
I meet Jennifer Garner, I meet Chloe
Sevigny, I meet Regina Hall, I meet
Gemma Chan. D'Arcy Carden is not even
cast yet.
And
those four were in the van, we're
driving around to look at the sets. They
do They are not speaking because they do
not know each other. Somewhere in my
head, and I don't know if you feel this
way, I think all famous people know each
other. In fact, they don't. They do not
know each other. They had never met.
They were like chit-chatting a little
bit, asking each other like very like
small talk questions. And I It occurred
to me as I was saying them, I'm like,
they don't know They don't know each
other.
Fast forward to September when they've
they're coming to Nantucket and um
they all came to my house I had a party
at my house they all came to my house
and they were the best of friends.
>> I love that.
>> Because over the summer they had bonded
so much. They now have a group chat.
They're so excited about season 2. They
absolutely became actual
close friends.
Because they spent all that time
together. So, it was like a weird
mirroring of the show because they all
sort of bond over the course of the
weekend and over the course of filming
the show, they all became friends.
>> So cool. How like involved are you in
the show?
>> Um so, I did not write any of the show.
Becca Brunstetter wrote it. She's a
genius. She would ask questions. I don't
know, she'd text me
let's say two or three times a week with
questions very specific to Nantucket,
which is my
expert area of expertise and I wanted it
done correctly. So, she would ask me
like, "Okay,
where
the scene where Caroline goes down and
she bumps into Dylan and he's cleaning
the boat like she needed help. Like
where would this take place? I'm like,
"Oh, the boat basin." Is it close to
town? Yes, it's right there at the edge
of town. Like yes, it's in town
essentially. So, like those kind of
questions. Um and then I went to the
table read. I went
they filmed here for
30 days. I was on tour for 2 weeks of
it. So, I was here for 2 weeks. I went
to set a bunch. Had everyone over to my
house. Was there when they wrapped
uh wrapped it up. Went for drinks with
Jen Garner after they wrapped.
She is everything you want her to be. I
have
what you want her to be is what she is.
She is the coolest, nicest,
most wholesome, but she is not
um like a Pollyanna. Like she's a real
person and she will tell you real things
if you're in her confidence.
>> I feel like she is probably the most
likable person on this planet.
>> Yes. Like her and Keke Palmer.
>> Yes.
>> Like the two most likable people that
have ever existed.
>> Yes.
>> Like she just seems absolutely
incredible. When you were going into
this with casting, like who were you
picturing as Hollis?
>> I
I didn't really know. I don't like to do
that because
I'll end up disappointed. So,
I think
>> this one.
>> think we thought like maybe Laura Linney
would do it and then
when they called, they said we're going
to ask Jen Garner. I'm like, "Of course
you are cuz she already has a fake
cooking show." This is like so her. I
almost thought she wouldn't do it
because she would be afraid of being
typecast cuz it's so she does have her
like pretend cooking show and you know,
her children at home and her it so I
thought, "Oh, she might not want to do
it cuz it's like too close to her actual
person."
But what she said to me was, "If anybody
else had taken this, I would have been
so upset and jealous." I was like,
"Okay."
>> That's just so amazing.
>> She wanted it. Yeah.
>> She did so I mean, seriously, did so
>> Yeah.
>> amazing.
>> Yes. And very likable on the screen.
Unbelievable. Like she's just the best.
What can you say if anything about
season 2? Like Or maybe like where were
you when you found out season 2 was
happening?
>> I was on the beach and I got a text from
the producers and they said, "Ellen,
we're getting a season 2." This was a
couple weeks ago and I was so excited. I
can tell you this, it will not be filmed
on Nantucket. They are not coming to
Nantucket. They are going a la White
Lotus somewhere else.
Um there has been discussion about
Greece. There's been discussion about
France.
It will be on a cruise ship, part of it,
most of it, I think. And then
I said to the screenwriter,
"You have to do Love Boat jokes." And
she's she's she's younger than me.
She's like, "Oh, I was going to do
Titanic jokes." So then I'm like, "Okay,
yes. Let's do Titanic Let's have Brooke
on the masthead at the end of the yacht
with her arms out." And I go, "And we'll
we'll license My Heart Will Go On." And
we'll have Brooke like doing her
moment. [snorts]
>> That's perfect.
>> the king of the world moment. AND WE
WERE DYING LAUGHING. WE'RE LIKE, "We
have to do it."
Yeah, so they're going to take a trip
together. There will be a fifth star
coming I think Gigi may or may not
appear. I think Becca would like her to
sort of have been I don't know how you
can reasonably do this have her bump
into them.
But they will bring in a fifth another
fifth star who will be another actress.
And I'm sure it'll be somebody fan-
fantastic.
>> Well, especially after this I mean this
series is everywhere. It is truly
everywhere. I also love Brooke and she
like she is just so good. Like all you
do such an amazing job of not just
I think what's cool not just like world
building. I love an author who just
writes. Of course you have books outside
of Nantucket. But like who you are
unique to me in the sense of like all of
them most of them are on Nantucket. And
then I like that you have like
Constance. And people don't necessarily
pick up on it unless they read like a
multiple of them. So I think that that
is so cool. It's almost it's a weird
comparison, but in a way like
in a lot of her fiction that I read, I
don't feel like it's like super
world-building cuz I don't read fantasy,
but in a weird way it kind of like
resembles the world-building in fantasy
because Nantucket is a character. Like
Nantucket is yeah.
>> Yeah. You're correct. Um William
Faulkner has like a county that he
writes about in Mississippi and it's a
lot like that. So his county in
Mississippi it's has an unpronounceable
name and all of his novels and
characters take place but you wouldn't
even know it unless you read them all.
>> Totally.
>> You know what I mean? And that's the
same like you said like there's the
police chief and there's Fast Eddie and
Blancharin and the you know, characters
that reappear in other books, but you
don't they're sideways novels so you
don't have to read them in any
particular order.
Um but Blancharin appears in The
Five-Star Weekend.
>> Blancharin's my favorite.
>> Yeah, she's so funny.
>> She is something else. She really really
is.
>> sister.
>> It's so funny.
>> It's so good. Okay, so I have some
rapid-fire reading questions for you.
>> it.
>> All right. What is a book outside of
your own that you believe every person
on this earth should read?
>> What is the answer to that? So I would
say
What is the answer to that? I'm going to
go with one of my favorite novels of all
time by Ann Patchett is Bel Canto.
And I would say everybody it's a it's
about it it's about a hostage situation
in Peru. It is so that does not make it
sound good. It is so good. That that
would be my choice.
>> That's on my TBR and I really want to
read it.
>> Oh my god. Everybody's reading Whistler.
Everybody's reading, you know, The Dutch
House, whatever. Her best novel is Bel
Canto.
It is amazing.
>> I can't wait to read them.
Which book of yours was the hardest for
you to write and why?
>> The book for me that was the hardest was
Silver Girl. This book came out in 2011.
It went through six revisions. So when I
turn it in to my editor, I normally turn
it into my editor at Halloween. This is
the summer books. I turn it in at
Halloween. She would a week later, at
the beginning of November, get me my
revisions, and then I would spend 6
weeks revising.
And for that revising, historically, I
had gone to Boston cuz I had to get out
of my house, away from my kids, cuz it
was such intense work. That particular
book went into six revisions. Now, that
book is a fictionalized account of like
a Ruth Madoff character. So, a woman who
whose husband has created is the biggest
uh financial criminal in history, and
she's been outcast, and
she's got one friend left, which is her
friend from preschool, who lives here on
Nantucket, and she comes to Nantucket to
sort of hide. And making her likable,
sympathetic, was very hard, and took six
revisions that went over Christmas. So,
I missed
Christmas
with my kids. I was supposed to go to my
mom's, and my my then husband took my
kids down to my mother's, and I stayed
home and worked.
>> You got to do what you got to do. It was
hard.
>> Yeah.
>> I was watching a bunch of videos this
week cuz of all the cases that are
happening, and they were talking about
how like
lawyers were giving accounts of times
that they've had to make judges who make
obviously far less like defending their
clients who are billionaires to these
judges, and giving all of these accounts
to them, and how the judges are like,
"Okay, sorry, you lost $100,000. I have
nothing." And I feel like that's almost
an author trying to make like
a character who's done something so
wrong or so quote out of touch likable.
>> Yeah. It's
>> It's very hard.
>> Hard thing to do.
Um what has been your favorite 2026
read?
>> My favorite 2026 read is a book called
This Is Not About Us by Allegra Goodman.
It Allegra Goodman
is was I heard of her, and I think I
probably read a book of hers 10 or 20
years ago, 10 or 20, 10 or 15 years ago.
Um
but I hadn't read anything recently. So,
she wrote the book Sam.
Then she wrote Isola, and then she wrote
this and which are so vastly different
from each other and then from the book
that I'm going to tell you which I love
so much, which is called This is Not
About Us. It is connected stories
about a family with three sisters
they're in their 70s and two of them do
not talk to the third and then one of
them dies and it's it's just connected
fam- family stories.
Each one is so beautifully written and
you feel like a detective cuz you're
like, okay, wait, whose point of view is
the story from and how do they connect
to the rest of the
stories? It's amazing. It's amazing. It
is amazing.
>> All right, last question. What is a book
trope that you cannot get behind?
>> What is a book trope that I cannot get
behind? Like what would I never write
about?
>> Or read. It could be either or.
>> Or read. I mean, I'm pretty open-minded,
so I'm going to say I don't have any
that I would that I would not not get
behind and I feel
I feel
that if you are talented, like my number
one thing that I'm looking for when I'm
reading is excellent writing.
I just picked up a brand new book. I
finished a book I was reading this
afternoon and right before I came here,
I picked up the book that I'm going to
read next and I read the first paragraph
and there were two lines
that were so brilliant. Like
I thought, this I am in good hands with
this writer. I doesn't matter what
happens in the rest of the book. Like I
know the writing is going to be
excellent. So, I think you can take it's
called
The New People.
>> Okay.
>> And it just came out this summer and um
it's about a uh
a woman and her wife and they move into
a house and it turns out there are
people living upstairs. I haven't gotten
that far yet. I'm only on the first
page, but I could tell from the first
paragraph, I'm like, this book is going
to I'm going to like it because I can
trust the writer cuz you can tell right
away. Like, I think writing the first
pages of a novel is almost impossible
cuz you have to draw people in and and
give them something to hang on to to
keep them turning the pages.
>> Totally.
>> Right? It's hard. It's hard, but this
book managed to do it.
>> That's amazing. I love how open you are
and that is why you're the queen of the
beach read.
>> Well, thank you.
>> That's amazing. Okay, well, thank you so
much. It's truly an honor and so full
circle for me cuz truly, Nantucket is my
favorite place ever and I really have
you to thank for that.
>> I'm I'm very humbled by that and
thrilled.
>> I made it my entire personality after my
first trip. It's my style. No more crop
tops, ballet flats, [laughter] polos.
Like seriously, I was a new person when
I got BACK TO TEXAS.
>> THAT IS SO FUNNY.
>> I was brand new. Okay, well, thank you
so much. Um, where can they find you and
keep up with everything going on?
>> I'm sure. Yeah, I'm on Instagram
@elinhilderbrand. That's probably the
best place. Um, I'm on it every single
day and I do read my DMs and I have a
Facebook page that I ignore. But,
sometimes has good information on it and
is that it? Yeah, I think that's it.
>> you post great book reviews, too.
>> I do. I really read all the time and I
love to post about the books that I If
you see it on my Instagram, you know I
actually organically loved it.
>> How many books do you think you read a
year?
>> I think I read
I think I read 75 books a year.
>> Yeah. You're quick.
>> I'm constantly reading.
>> I love that. That's amazing. Okay, well,
thank you.
>> Thank you, Kenzie. Thank you, everyone.
>> This is Elin. This is Elin. This is
Elin. There's so many Elins all around.
Um, I do want to announce our next book
club pick, which is Into the Blue by
Emma Brodie.
Have you read it, Macy?
>> No.
>> [laughter]
>> Macy did read a book this this week.
>> Is this on?
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah, she's ch- hopping out a little.
>> Our next book club book is Seven
Husbands of Evelyn Hugo.
>> [laughter]
>> I started it in February, finished in
August, was stuck at 93% for months.
Apparently it's a page-turner.
Apparently not to me.
>> It ended up being You got chills. I love
that book.
>> Yeah. It was pretty good.
>> It's really good.
>> reading Broken Country.
>> You know what is the best Taylor Jenkins
Reid book of all time? Atmosphere.
Nothing compares. Holy
>> Caroline, you should read that.
>> Country
>> to read that, yeah.
>> Taylor Jenkins Reid?
>> No.
>> Oh.
>> Seven Husbands is, yeah.
>> Oh, okay.
>> But I'm excited. I'm I'm going to read
Broken Country
>> because of you.
>> Yes.
>> I love this book talk with you.
>> Let me know if you guys want to join.
>> Yeah, and Macy wants to read The Hunger
Games book for my club. Sunrise on the
Reaping?
>> I would love to. That one's really good.
Listen to the audio. The audio book is
incredible.
>> Okay.
>> There we go.
>> Caroline said to listen to the audio
book, so.
>> Perfect.
>> Going to go get ready for my segment.
>> Yeah, okay. Love you guys. Bye.