Fan Zone, your favourite football analysis segment |The Touchline Y254
Watch on YouTubeVideo summary
The Fan Zone segment of The Touchline Y254 brings together a full team to analyze global football developments as new seasons approach, with a primary focus on transfer strategies and squad preparations for Chelsea, Manchester United, Arsenal, Liverpool, and Real Madrid. John James opens the discussion by reviewing Chelsea's friendly matches against Juventus and Aston Villa, praising specific performances while expressing eagerness to see key players like Morgan Rogers return from their World Cup break. He highlights concerns regarding defensive stability under Mauricio Pochettino but notes that Enzo Fernandez is unlikely to leave for Real Madrid despite rumors, suggesting he will remain a crucial link in the team's midfield structure as they aim to integrate academy talent and new signings effectively before the league begins.
The conversation then shifts heavily toward Manchester United, where Mark Ha argues that while their current transfer activity shows improvement over past panic buying, the club still lacks sufficient quality depth to challenge for the title immediately. The panel critiques the reliance on Bruno Fernandes as a sole creative force without adequate support and points out vulnerabilities in defense due to injuries to Lisandro Martinez and other center-backs. They contrast United's approach with that of Arsenal, who are building their squad around Bukayo Saka and proven Premier League talents like William Saliba and Declan Rice, suggesting that Manchester United needs experienced signings rather than relying on developing academy players for a top-four or title challenge in the Champions League era.
Arsenal is described as looking very dangerous heading into the season after securing Bruno Guimarães from Newcastle to strengthen their midfield alongside Martin Ødegaard and Gabriel Magalhães, though the panel agrees they still need wing reinforcements to maintain dominance. The discussion also covers high-profile moves involving Luis Díaz joining Real Madrid for a record fee under an attacking coach like Carlo Ancelotti, which could make Los Blancos formidable opponents next season. Additionally, there is talk of Mohamed Salah moving to Turkey in a significant transfer that reflects the country's growing appreciation for Premier League stars, with expectations that his skills and energy will help him thrive in a new league environment ahead of AFCON 2027 hosting duties.
In conclusion, the panel emphasizes that successful teams are built around core leaders rather than assembled through reactive purchases, noting how Liverpool struggled after Henderson left while Newcastle faced challenges when Bruno Guimarães departed. They warn against copying failed strategies seen at Tottenham or Manchester United and urge clubs to prioritize building cohesive units with experienced players who can handle multiple competitions like the Champions League. As the show wraps up with birthday wishes for Wendy and final greetings from John James, Mark Ha, Karibu Busana, Gaspam Jumba, Barry, Peter, and others, they encourage fans to tune in next Saturday for more analysis before wishing everyone a blessed week ahead of the upcoming football season kickoff.
Read the full video transcript
Thank you so much for staying with us
here on Touchline. Now let's look at the
final bit of this particular show and we
are so glad to have a whole team here.
Gaspam Jumba from my immediate uh not my
immediate but my far left Karib Busana
Gasper good to have you for the second
week running this great Barry making a
return of course and Wendy good to see
you again and happy birthday right
[laughter]
and Peter of course Mark Ha in the
middle and John James on far right
Karibunis let's look at what's been
cooking across the globe and in this
case we begin with what's happening and
um transfer as well as teams that are
preparing for the new season. We know
that the new season is just about to
kick off and teams are busy signing and
also getting in shape. John James,
>> kick us off with Chelsea's friendlies.
[laughter]
>> Okay. Okay. Last time we played against
Juventus, you know what happened? One
goal to
the goal it's
>> amazing goal. There's no this world can
say that honest that goal was amazing.
But generally the play was good. I like
the link up between our new signing well
back with Joe Pedro in the first half.
Then after that we made some some
substitutions. We brought in some
academy players. Then we brought in a st
I think it'll be one of the players to
watch this coming season. I think he has
been playing amazing this
these are friendlies. But even now
talking about I just remembered we gave
Aston Villa one of our players Ganacho
in the wing and I saw him play on the
friendly and I he's still the same
Ganacho that you know I don't think is
going to to to revive him. But now
talking back about Chelsea. I'm yet to
see Morgan Rogers in the in the field
and I want him to I just want to see the
connection holding him.
>> I don't know I don't know maybe maybe
he's still on vacation because of the
World Cup. So I just want him to to see
him back and maybe see the connection
that he has with with Palmer mostly then
I think also then I think to see Jedro
there want to see the link I want to see
the the back line of the back center
backs between and the the guy we got
from Christo then I want to see maybe
not that is there but Mike P there I
want to see a new goalkeeper if he can
do it then I saw Pri has been he has
been playing amazing but I think The
problem is is playing more of malustoto
style of play which I don't really like
cuz it's not really you cannot really
say he's a good defender at the same
time you cannot say he's a bad defender
cannot say he's a good attacking
defender cannot say he's a bad like he's
someone who is confused but I think Shab
Alonso will start yeah and start
improving some of these players cuz I
know with our captain back L James will
be back so I think bring a little bit of
stability in the team I think I don't I
don't think Enzo Enzo Fernandez is going
anywhere people have been talking about
it so much saying might go Real Madrid.
>> Real Madrid is calling. Yeah.
>> But I've not had any call from Jose you
know Jose when he wants a play gets
them. So if you have not called up to
now that means he doesn't want want him.
So yeah just I [clears throat] just want
to see as Fernandez bing the team the
link up with maybe watch out for the
league. We might you might something.
>> It's exciting. The build up is exciting.
Mark I mean and they're playing today
Milan right?
>> Oh yeah. Yeah, I think I've seen the
lineup. The lineup we put up I don't
know I'm not really confident with it
cuz we are playing Jedro
in the wing then we have wellbeck up
front then Palma then Pedonetto then
Lavia then and Kisedo that is perfect
but now Aong and Tossin bro and I think
that's where that's where we might
suffer today then I think the even the
backline I think will suffer today but
>> yeah are you happy with the business
that the club [laughter] did? Yeah.
Yeah. Let's say let's say I know you
know you cannot say it's a bad business
after before seeing the the end product.
So just waiting to see the end product.
Maybe for for the first 10 games of the
of the starting of this new season then
I can say if it's bad business or it's
good business.
>> Begin with the coach of course.
>> Mark um Manchester of course getting
ready. they're playing PSG but talk
about you know just a breakdown of how
they've really prepared for this
particular season with the signings and
you know what what really matters to
Manchester now looking at how last
season ended maybe
>> uh thank you when you look at Manchester
United how they have contacted their
business up to this point I can say so
far so good
>> but
>> put it closer yes
>> but still to add more quality players in
that team but when you look how they
behaving this current transfer window. I
think Manchester United they're using a
system whereby they're not just buying
because other people are buying the
players. You know there we have had
previous seasons whereby when Manchester
United want to buy a player the teams
raise the thing then we just panic and
buy. that based on what I've seen this
this transfer window I'm I'm pleased but
>> I I think we need to add some few
players we need
>> especially what like what the attacking
attacking wise we need someone to
support Bruno because when you just take
Bruno Fernandez out of the equation then
the creativity level will drop from 100%
to around 20 so we need to add someone
there then when you when you look at our
backline
>> Mhm.
for Martinez injury prone delet
so we need some at least one to add on
the center back then
>> of course we need to add another also
CDM
>> yeah so that to also based on the games
that we having the coming season a lot
of matches
>> yeah Champions League
>> so we need to add someone who is
experienced not just to add but someone
who is experienced and will have an inst
impact
>> sure to the team right and especially
with Carrick remaining the momentum is
believed to go like go on or continue
>> I think since Carrick joined Manchester
United the fear factor is back so at
least now while we play against our
opponents it won't be like when
>> I just like chuckle like
[laughter]
>> the fear factor used to be talked about
during It won't it won't be like
it won't be like when Morim was in in
control because you could just see like
this game
>> the players were too scared
>> and compared to what Carrick is doing
even in the preseason when you see the
youngsters coming on they're doing
amazing so I think going into the new
season just additional one two to three
signings Manchester United ready to go.
Sure.
>> I'm sorry to interrupt on that
[clears throat] about Manchester.
You guys right now you don't have right
>> and you only depend on Bruno Fernandez.
>> Looking at Bruno Fernandez during the
World Cup, he was not that good.
>> Yeah. The whole of Portugal
>> if I imagine you [laughter]
play Champions League the same way you
know you know plays different roles. You
cannot say listen
>> he's just looking at she's just looking
at the players that he
If if you are listening to me carefully,
you could have listened. I said that we
need someone to back Bruno.
>> Yes. Who's who's the like one in the
market?
>> Nobody
>> to be honest. Nobody answer to my
question.
>> Nobody.
>> Nobody can nobody can can give you the
output that Bruno.
>> Let me finish before you. If you come
with the same squad to Champions League,
FA, Carabau and EPS, ask me.
>> Let me ask you a question.
>> Yes. [laughter]
>> So far, we have seen how many players?
Two players, right?
>> Do you know why they take the academy
players to preseason?
>> So that to prepare them for those
moments. So that Manchester is not
prepared. I remember when the okay
before the previous the previous season
the coming season they're two different
things based on how teams are preparing
>> the current when you look at the current
Manchester
>> but do you think Manchester have a
chance
>> no
>> we were saying for Manchester to prosper
this coming season we need to sign more
players
let me tell you let me tell you
sometimes quality is better than
quantity
[laughter]
>> you You don't you don't get
>> that's why I say if you are king I say
>> and he'sing
[laughter] listen if you are very keen I
say we need some
>> yeah sure so whoever wants to talk to
okay after
>> let's let's go on man you can just add
on what's beeviling the red devils you
know [laughter]
>> I think we are
>> and also add on Arsenal you know how
they've been so Good. [laughter]
>> Before even we have this conversation,
before we started the show, we were
having a conversation with Mark and
about the number of players that
Manchester United
>> and my interest
and then you have Bruno Fernandez and
then they brought in Andre Santos from
Chelsea. this guy did not even make it
to the first 11 of Chelsea. Do you
expect this guy to come in and you know
give us what Casemiro was doing? Is he
the same person to take Manchester
United to another level? Because
Manchester United finished top four. Now
we need to see Manchester United
challenging for the league. And the kind
of players they are signing, they're not
the players that will challenge the
league. I mean look at Arsenal. As are
bringing in Bruno Garez. Bruno Gumarez
is EPL proven. He has that experience.
He's the captain of Newcastle United. is
coming to
a midfield of Rice. We have the likes of
Martin.
You know,
>> the midfield is staked and you can say
that maybe that is what Manchester
United also needs. They need to go to
the market and find a player that can
come in and give them the results they
want. We don't need to see Manchester
United developing players.
>> Maki is saying that they're taking
academy players to preseason preseason
to prepare them
>> for the season. You don't win the league
with academy players.
>> Imagine imagine Manchester United.
Manchester United.
>> Wait, wait, wait. Finish.
>> Manchester United.
>> I go on this side. Yes.
>> Manchester United playing the And then
maybe you you place to play against
maybe PSG Barcelona.
>> Do you play against?
>> And finally about Arsenal.
>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Please do.
Please do. And finally about Arsenal. We
played against Real British last
weekend. we lost and uh we lost as a
result of playing academy players and at
the end of the [laughter] day tomorrow
>> tomorrow we'll be playing against
in the Emirates Cup. I expect to see
Bruno Gumarez starting because he has
been training with Arsenal and we have
Christo
>> but I still believe that we have to do
some business on the left and the right
wing. I mean we have the legs of
there of course but we need
and there's this guy
we need to go sign that guy. Yeah if we
need to defend the league.
>> Yes indeed Wendy.
>> Yes. Are are you impressed and how
hungry do they look in the market?
>> H we are we look very dangerous in this
[laughter] league. the kind of meat we
have right now having uh guar
okay merina not rice
>> and
I we will we will actually go far but
again I'm adding on what has just said
we need somebody
>> we were discussing with the scene that
last season
>> we had like two is it seven goals it was
>> Martinelli only always called once
>> one one goal and six.
>> So we need to be better coming this
season. So we [clears throat] need to
sign somebody there. But with or without
Arsenal is looking very very dangerous.
So stay guided to
>> the the champions, right? Have they st
their claim as champions? Barry
>> I mean what do you make of the signings
especially? Let's talk about Liverpool
signing AO. You know the man from
Barcelona.
>> Yeah. I uh first of all I have always
doubted [clears throat] if I is the
right profile for this club.
>> Sometimes I feel like
>> will it be the same case as what we saw
with team Frank at Tottenham.
>> Yes. And also um uh this guy is good for
mid table not for the top the top four
>> but looking at where Mourinho came from
Portugal what was it Porto and
>> Porto yeah
>> but Porto is not Bmouth is it? No, at
that time at that time port was nothing,
right?
>> But again,
>> and and you know, rearranged everything
in but go on.
>> Yeah. What I'm saying is unless he's
been set out to fail,
>> I'm not quite sure if he's going to
really deliver the goods for this team.
>> And allow me to say something on my
team.
>> You attacked my friend.
>> So [laughter] what I what I think is
happening is that Inos needs to open
their pass.
>> Yes. But number two, they so much into
it's called what? Um
and they kind of money. But number two,
do we have like like the right profile
of players to fit
>> the players? We need We need someone to
to help Cesco.
>> We need someone to Bruno.
>> We need somebody to to replace Casemiro.
>> And we need two people
>> to replace the injury prone Lisandro at
the back. We need like five guys. Is is
Ino is going to remove money because I'm
sure Carrick is is watching his
counterparts and he needs to do well.
>> Sure. Sure. It's it's a it's a it's a
quagmire for Manchester. Looks like the
dice is cast. Yes. Ja [laughter]
Manchester.
>> Okay.
>> We are here.
>> I think the only problem with Manchester
United
>> is they they don't build team around
anyone. They just buy it. Is I think
they are calling it panic buying. Mhm.
>> But like Arsenal they they have been
building team around
Saka
>> and Odard somebody who is capable of
playing with these guys.
>> And if you see Liverpool they they build
team around Henderson
>> and immediately after Henderson went out
of the team they lost it everything. So
you build team around someone. Newcastle
has been building the team around Bruno
Garez. So immediately when Isaac and
Tonali went
also requested to go out because nobody
understands him
>> and even the coach even coach said
Manchester is not building team around
anyone and from the I think the last
five season I've been saying Manchester
United should have been built team
around the guy who went out scoped
Mctomin that was the
guy
around.
So you build team around someone
when I bring in Ben White can play well
with Saka. If I bring
it failed completely because
let's buy so if you do buy
>> you will also
yeah I mean some of the as we barely a
minute here but let's talk about Tonango
leaving Right.
>> Mhm.
>> Yeah. When I mean that's quite
interesting because at the moment
>> his status with Kenya how when they
visited him what was what did they say?
>> He was impressed with the project and
he's open to playing for Aram stars
actually. And I'm saying that this is
the right move for him because we be
hosting the the AFCON 2027. So getting
that experience will be so important for
our
Yan as well leaving for from Ivory Co
joining Real Madrid at number
>> he will actually
>> and we are hoping for the best
>> I think and he's the most expensive
player in Real Madrid. So I think Real
Madrid will be dangerous next season
having a coach who is attacking minded
coach and having
>> they have Jo
defensive and attacking. Mourinho does
not build team around midfield. He's
defensive and attacking goals and
defending of goals.
>> Yes. Looks like we pressed with time or
we have 2 minutes.
Oh we finish. Okay.
>> I was to say you're saying will look
dangerous but I'm also saying if Rodri
comes to Barcelona he will also look
dangerous.
>> Barcelona have a striker. They depend on
they attacking midfield like Torres.
>> Sure.
>> Don't worry.
>> Vinnie Vinnie bouncing off James this
one for us.
>> We knew we knew the plan that Vine had
of course
[laughter]
>> that failed and Salah moving to quite
huge reception. Huge reception for Salah
in Turkey.
>> I think Turkey values more on Premier
League stars. When you go there, they
>> they give you a pride. Yeah. They give
you a pride feel as well.
>> You think he'll he still have some gas
and do some?
>> Yes. He still have energy. He has
skills. He's most talented.
>> I think he'll do wonders.
>> Okay.
>> Oh, John James, you think otherwise?
>> No, no, no. I think so.
>> We should be going.
>> Okay. Anyway, thank you guys. John
James, Mark, and thank you so much for
your time.
>> Wendy, where's the birthday? Anyway,
and thank you for watching the show.
Let's do this again next Saturday. Up
until then, have a blessed one.