Video summary
Everton has completed an unprecedented straight swap deal to sign Brennan Johnson from Crystal Palace in exchange for Dwight McNeil moving back to his former club, a move that has left many fans and pundits baffled yet ultimately convinced of its strategic logic. The primary driver behind this transaction is the urgent need Everton possesses for pace and directness on the wing, attributes that were notably absent under David Moyes' previous management style which relied heavily on set-pieces and creative playmakers like McNeil or Anthony Grealish. While Dwight McNeil provided decisive moments in rougher times with his crossing ability, his defensive work rate as a left-back was not ideal for Everton's long-term ambitions of competing for Europe, making the departure necessary to take that next step forward.
The acquisition is viewed by analysts and fans alike as effectively securing a "free player," given that McNeil had only one year remaining on his contract and would likely have been sold at a fraction of Brennan Johnson's market value without generating enough funds to justify such an expensive signing elsewhere. This financial efficiency allows Everton to bring in a Welsh international with a proven track record, including winning two European trophies with Tottenham Hotspur, who offers the specific profile missing from their current squad: a genuine runner capable of beating defenders and delivering out-balls for teammates like Enner Valencia or Jack Grealish. Johnson's statistical output over his career demonstrates consistent goal-scoring ability in double figures combined with assists, which directly addresses Everton's recent struggles to find enough goals through their wide areas compared to the creative but less direct styles of existing wingers.
Beyond the immediate tactical benefits, this deal represents a significant cultural reset for the club by moving past an era defined by financial constraints and squad limitations that McNeil symbolized during his time at Goodison Park. By swapping players rather than selling one and buying another separately, Everton clears out a player who was no longer central to Moyes' plans while simultaneously injecting fresh energy and ambition into their attacking options for the future. The four-year contract signed by Johnson signals the club's intent to look beyond immediate survival and build a squad capable of sustaining success in the Premier League, proving that smart management involves making difficult decisions to weed out weaknesses even if it means letting go of players who once brought glory but no longer fit the evolving identity required for trophy contention.
Read the full video transcript
Welcome to Toffee TV. Everton have made
a signing. They have brought Brennan
Johnson in from Crystal Palace with
Dwight McNeil going the other way. It is
a straight swap. It's unheard of. It's
baffling to some people. Some people
just cannot get their heads around
why we we've signed Brennan Johnson and
Dwight McNeil has has gone the other
way. It's it's blowing people's minds
left, right, and center, but
it's happened. And he's now an Everton
player. What do you think about that,
James?
>> Yeah, I I we spoke about him quite a bit
now, but I think he sort of suits what
Everton need. I think Dwight McNeil, for
what his strengths are and his skills, I
think Everton have players
in that position who are much better
than him and potentially in the moment
of creativity if you end up getting him
as well.
So, he was always going to be a worse
option of them two. Yeah. And I think
the type of profile that Brennan Johnson
is, I think Palace also have like an
abundance of that profile with like Eze
and Olise and Ismaila Sarr and Everton
don't really have anyone. So, I think
it's one that really it works for both
teams. You both need that type of player
and we both could just swap it easily.
And
whether one team got the benefit or one
of them came off worse, I don't know,
but both teams have got a player that
they sort of need for their systems.
I think it's key.
>> I think I think that's the top and
bottom of it, isn't it? This idea that
um
you know, this idea that
why are we signing him or or how good
was he for the other team or any of this
kind of thing? I think it's it doesn't
it doesn't really matter. We know
Brennan Johnson has got attributes that
we don't have in our side, which is
pace.
Um you know, whether that's on the
right, that's on the left, whether it's
centrally, someone
that can come in at the far post and you
know, you you know, for the tap-ins
coming in from the other side. It's a
different profile from what we've got
and in
what seemingly like a tight market, you
know, because you know, you can we can
moan all we want
about why isn't there more money and why
isn't this being done and why isn't that
being done? And we say that we will moan
about it, of course we will. We can ask
those questions.
But until we get the answers,
we have to make smart signings. And I
think this is a smart signing. You know,
he's signing for four years, so there's
definitely an idea that this is a player
that Everton obviously are you know,
looking to the future with.
Um,
and for me I I just think it makes
complete sense because they didn't want
to be in a a straight swap. Dwight
McNeil was going out the door no matter
what. The question was
who was you [clears throat] know, who
was prepared to pay money for him or you
know, who was prepared to take that
chance on him.
Everton seeing that David Moyes made it
known that he's not really part of his
plans. He's He's He's done that since
day one. Yes, he's had moments and he
had moments last season where he did
come into the team and
he offered something a little bit
different, but
Everton have been desperate for some
pace and I just find that we are we
essentially
are getting a free player. That's the
way I'm thinking about it anyway.
>> Yeah. I think um,
just off of what you said about Dwight
McNeil. I think everyone knew his time
was over at Everton and obviously he
nearly went to Palace in January.
And
I I don't know. I I think you can
appreciate what Dwight McNeil done for
Everton probably in you know, rougher
times.
But I think Everton, if you want to
continue to grow, you sort of have to
get past that. And you know, relying on
things like set pieces and you know, his
crosses and stuff isn't what Everton
needs to do to take that next step. Now,
I think for a time it was perfect for
Everton and he did come up with moments
where, you know, decisive moments where
we needed someone to get a goal out of
nowhere or whip in a perfect cross. But
I think Everton now, you know, if we do
want to you know, start fighting for
Europe properly or really go at it, I
don't think having players like Dwight
McNeil especially starting yeah, makes
sense for Everton anymore. And the fact
he was on like nine months well, not
nine months, only 1 year left on his
contract.
He weren't going to get a new deal and
Everton were going to have to get rid of
him somehow and Palace seemed to have
like a plan in mind for him considering
they came back for him for the second
time.
And I've seen Palace fans online talk
about him saying, you know, he'll play
in left wing-back or play him as a bit
more of a 10. And I do think they
probably do suit him more than playing
on on the wing where he has been for
Everton just because,
you know, we seen it like
defensively his work rate was probably
suiting him at the left back and then
when he came into the 10 it was sort of
like a fresh
I don't know, fresh room for him. So, I
think for him having like a whole new
place to play at, a new new club and a
completely fresh start is perfect for
him and then Everton also in return get
pace which we've been absolutely crying
out for. Someone who's a bit more direct
and I think Everton's squad consists of
a lot of players who are like quite
creative and will, you know, create
chances for Brennan Johnson. And, you
know, we we were going through his
goals, you know, a lot of them at the
back post just tapping it in and stuff
like that. And I think at Everton he'll
get loads of them chances. It's just he
just needs to sort of finish off the
attacks which when you go through like
what Spurs fans are saying and what
Palace fans and even Forest, that was
that was sort of his best attribute was
just finishing the thing, maybe not
creating them but finishing them. I
think that's ultimately what Everton
needs.
>> I think just having someone who's got
who's an out ball as well, who's a
runner who can you can put the ball over
the top to. The amount of times,
you know, seeing the way Everton have
been playing under David Moyes, you
know, soaking up the pressure. We saw it
last season when we play away from home,
you know, those are games where we where
we soak up the pressure defensively and
then we try and hit teams on the break.
If you've got an out ball, if you've got
genuine pace where you can, you know,
put the ball into the into the corners
and then allow players to run at
someone,
>> Yeah.
>> it makes you it gives you a different
sting to your bow. We know that we've
got the likes of Enner Valencia pick the
ball up but
as as much as we all love to see Enner
Valencia pick the ball up, he does slow
down the play when he does that and that
allows the opposition to get back. Well,
you imagine if you've got like an engine
on the down and then
someone like Brennan Johnson going past
him and giving him and then a ball that
he can give it to him.
As I say, I like I don't think anyone's
making out like this is like the league
um
transfer that is going to like transform
Everton into this amazing side, but I
think he's just something that we
haven't had and I think
for me there's no real fanfare in this.
It's just like a really solid signing
and it gives him an opportunity the same
way it gives to Leighton opportunity for
a fresh start. Yeah. He has made a pass
long. We know that it hasn't worked and
sometimes that's sometimes it doesn't
work and sometimes it is better and
they've got a new manager in. Sometimes
it's better to just
get a change as fast as possible and
move on as fast as possible. And listen,
you know, a change is good as a rest. He
might go to Palace and he might be
amazing. He might find a position for
him and it might work and they get all
their attributes. For me,
Twice is a hangover from
an era that I don't want to revisit
again. It's an It's the dice here. It's
the era where we were really, really
struggling. He came up with some really
big moments, but at the same time he was
also a symptom of, you know, he was part
of the the reason we were there in the
first place like so many of those
players.
And I want to see those players, you
know, leave the football club because
they were they were never good enough
and you have to that you have to
do that. Like you said before, you have
to do If you want to improve, you have
to look past that and that's
that's the For me personally, I know
some people look at it very differently
and have more sorts of
a attach more emotion to it.
But if you want to start having big
moments in football and getting to the
genuine emotion, which is winning
trophies and being a team who gets into
Europe,
you'll have to move past those players
and that's for Everton to do one at a
time and we've still got more of those
in our squad and people shouldn't look
at it as in like oh, you're scapegoating
or
you're looking for the play you look
you're having a go with a player. You
should be like
you have to weed out
the weaknesses, yeah, and you have to do
that all as as much as you can.
And
when you got an opportunity to move them
on, you just move them on, and as I
said, some people will have admiration,
and some people just say thanks and bye,
and you know, and that's that's that's
football. People will leave your club
one way or another, so
I'm happy to see
I'm happy to see him in. Looking forward
to seeing how we use him.
Um
you know, I don't think this jeopardizes
the possibility Jack Grealish is coming
back. I don't think it it means we have
to sell Ings. I think what we're doing
is we're swapping
one player in the squad. Don't let's not
forget Dwight McNeil was on the bench
>> Yeah.
>> for most of last season, and was part of
the squad, and got into the team at
times. The only time he was never really
on the bench was when
the Palace move failed. So, he was part
of the squad. So, in other words, every
time David Moyes looked at the man
looked at the squad, there was a
possibility he could brought him on, and
he did bring him on in some games.
You know, it didn't work in some games.
I
But, that's where Brennan Johnson is
now, where you look he he he might be on
the bench, and he looks at him and goes,
I need some pace. Or, it might be a case
that he starts games.
But, what he's got is more is a fighting
chance. I don't I think the manager
looked at Dwight McNeil as in like,
that's the last sort of
that's the that's the that's the
scenario I don't really want, or or
whatever, you know.
So, now he's got a chance, and I think
he
it's on him to get into the team.
>> Mhm.
>> And that's it. And we've got a we've got
a good player
who showed he showed he was a good
player at Forest, showed good stuff at
Tottenham, top goal scorer season before
last, scored the winning goal
in a in a Europa League final.
>> Yeah.
>> You know, he's won two Europeans. I know
he wasn't really involved last season
with Palace, but he We one, you know,
two European trophies in two years.
>> yeah. My God, we
you know, to have some players like that
in our squad then
so
I'm I'm just I'm just
happy, positive with the with it and and
now now we move on to the next one.
>> Yeah, I think absolutely. I think
as you said, with Grealish, I think
Anthony Grealish, I think if you have to
sort of pick an ideal with that in mind,
you'd still have Anthony and Grealish as
your wingers, but I think he gives a
great option and more competition and
you know, in games where, you know,
Everton chasing it or, you know, you
need a goal, having a player like Dan
who is rapid is key. That's what we seen
him do with Forest at the end of last
season, you know, finding out he has
pace and that he was like sort of, you
know, causing issues to the opposition
with it. And so now we've got Brennan
Johnson, I think it works works
perfectly for both teams, really.
>> Yeah.
It's nice as well to have um
a Welsh international uh
sort of before your time, but Everton
have got a really really good tradition
of having Welsh internationals in our in
our squad. Ashley Williams.
They got I mean, they got they're the
the number one there, but we've always
had a really good tradition, so it's
nice to have one. Let's have a look at
uh
his numbers, Brennan Johnson's numbers
from um the last few seasons.
>> Well, last season it was split between
Palace and Spurs and across the season
he played 48 games.
Four goals, two assists. Obviously, all
four games were for Spurs. The season
before that, which is the big one we've
been talking about, I mean, talk all
scored he played 51 games for Spurs, had
18 goals and four assists.
Then the year before that, his first
year at Spurs, he played 34 times, five
goals, 10 assists.
And then the year before that, his first
season in the Premier League with
Forest, was 44 games, 10 goals, three
assists. So, if you're looking at
all of his seasons besides last year,
he's always around, you know,
15 mark, you know, sometimes way above
it, you know, like last like the season
before last again, 22 combined goals and
assists. And I think Everton especially
right now I think a lot of
the complaints is about you know like
body and stuff like that not getting
enough goals and I think he's a symptom
of sort of the environment because you
know
in Dwight the style and Grealish's style
and even like Joe Willock they're not
like notorious goal scorers it's not
like what they go out for whereas I
think Brennan Johnson that is sort of
his style you know he will get to
hopefully anyway get double figures in
goals or at least push it which then
alleviates pressure off I have a body
>> or the better.
>> And then I think that pressure you know
works like mentally for them to like go
on and play better and so this is the
type of player I think Everton needs
someone who's more of a forward out
wide.
>> Yeah.
>> But cuz going by them stats it sort of
proves it if he can get anywhere close
to them numbers it's more than probably
any our wingers have been getting
recently.
>> It's a It's a It's a fresh start a blank
slate and we just we take it and it's
the as I said before it's the same twice
the polish it's the same the new start
you know they don't bring don't don't
bring
you know you don't need to bring your
baggage from what you've just gone
through and and it's um
it's an opportunity and as I just I mean
just on Johnson as well you know he
moved to Spurs for 50 like 50 million
quid there there abouts he moved to
Palace for 35 million and we've just
effectively got him for nothing you know
like
that's the way to look at it we are
basically getting a player for nothing
as far as I'm concerned so
from that point of view I'm just looking
at it as all pluses.
>> And even if if if you count Dwight
McNeil how much do you think Everton
would even get for him now the fact that
you know he is on his last year they
would accept him 20 million in January
and it's like all they've done little
factors like him coming to the club
where to buy McNeil how much would they
realistically be paying
>> Well I'll be honest I wasn't really
sitting around
waiting for someone to for Dwight McNeil
to be sold and then to reinvest that
money do you know what I mean I was
that's not you know I don't believe that
the money we would have got for Dwight
McNeil would have
came round to being a sizable enough
money to to get a Brennan Johnson,
nowhere near. So, for me
for me, it's just a free play. And I I
think that's the mindset most people
should I think everyone should think
about. It's just a just a free player.
So, there we go. He's in, Brennan
Johnson, 4 years.
>> Signed up to 2030.
In the future. Well, I mean, literally
in the future, but you know what I mean.
Um
and good luck to him and hopefully
hopefully
you know, we see a player come to
Everton transformed and does the
business. Let us know your thoughts in
the comments on this signing. And then
who do you want next? Cuz that's always
the next one. Who do you want next? Uh
give this video a a like.
Hype this video as well. That's a new
thing. Start hyping the videos.
Uh and if you want more great videos,
join us over on Toffee TV. Premier link
in the description. QR codes coming on
the screen now. See you later.