Video summary
The video begins by recounting a chaotic sequence of events during a baseball game that escalated from a routine play into a major controversy involving three ejections over two days. The incident started in the top of the third inning when a foul ball hit an umpire's foot, leading to a review where the call was upheld as a strike despite some visual ambiguity regarding whether the ball crossed the foul line before bouncing. Following this, another fan suffered emotional and physical distress after catching a foul ball that subsequently bounced back into play, resulting in a home run off his hands. The tension rose significantly when pitcher Logan Webb hit a batter with a pitch while the same fan was still recovering from his injury, creating a brutal and dangerous situation that further heated the atmosphere between the teams and officials.
The conflict reached its peak during an argument between umpire Alan Porter and Diamondbacks manager Torey Lovullo regarding the etiquette of arguing calls. Lovullo insisted on challenging a call from the dugout, claiming he could not do so without immediate ejection, while Porter demanded that any disputes be handled by coming out to the field for a conversation rather than yelling from the dugout. The situation deteriorated when Lovullo accused Porter of missing strikes and refusing to acknowledge his arguments, leading to an intense verbal exchange filled with profanity and frustration. Ultimately, both Lovullo and pitcher Logan Webb were ejected simultaneously by two different umpires who issued identical commands for them to leave the premises, marking a rare double ejection that highlighted the breakdown in communication and decorum between the dugout and the officiating crew.
The aftermath of the game saw the tension carry over into the next day, where an assistant coach for the Giants was ejected before the lineup exchange even began due to his continued complaints about the previous day's calls. This incident underscored the lingering anger and the difficulty in resolving such high-stakes disagreements within the short timeframe of a professional sports event. The video concludes by reflecting on the personal nature of the insults exchanged, noting that it represented one of the most heated confrontations between a manager and an umpire ever recorded. While Alan Porter is generally respected for his ability to handle altercations, this specific incident demonstrated how quickly a disagreement over procedural etiquette can spiral into a full-blown conflict involving multiple ejections and lasting animosity among the participants.
Read the full video transcript
This insanely close call led to a lesson
in arguing etiquette and three ejections
over the course of two days. But it
starts with a little comeback in the top
of the third inning. Brought to you by
Fanatics Sports and Casino. One out,
runner on second, and then a big home
run which flips the score. They were
down one and now they are up one. From
the Giants point of view, they were up
one, now they're down one. So, they're a
little more heated. There's two outs,
two strikes. The inning doesn't end,
though. We've got a little flare that
drops into shallow center. So, we keep
going. A runner on first base. Two outs.
The scene is set. Aronado is coming to
the dish. And the first pitch of this at
bat will be Oh, a little weird. Excuse
me. Bunt swing down and foul. Hit him in
the foot. Foul ball. We all know that.
Coming up, one that we don't all know.
The next pitch, that's a strike. It's
called a ball by Alan Porter. And they
say, "Knock knock on my head. Use your
brain." That was a strike, dog. So they
say, "Okay, let's go to the review." And
yes, it was a strike. So that's good.
You know, ABS doing its job. The O2 now
is a fast ball up to set up the slider
in the zone, which gets hit down the
line. Ruled a fair ball, which means the
runners are all in motion. Now you've
got runners on second and third, two in
scoring position. The catcher's like,
"No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. Let's
take a look. It bounced first." So, it
doesn't matter where this ball lands. It
matters where it is while it's over the
bag. And obviously, this angle does not
tell us because we're way down the line.
But the umpire, he's in a decent spot.
He's got his eyes on it and he says,
"No, that was over the bag when it
crossed the bag." Meaning, it's a fair
ball. He likes his call. Here's another
look. So, it bounces there and then
right about where we're like there. It's
over the bag. You know, that's what the
umpire's saying. He's saying right
there. Now, his angle isn't straight
down the line. I I think he's not. He's
got himself on a little bit of an angle,
but he has a decent view. Better view
than any of the replays that we've seen.
Someone could do the math for me if they
found out where that ball hits there,
right? and the distance from the white
line and then the distance traveled
before it hits again and the distance to
the left of the white line and then do
that math and do a an arc in in yarn on
your kitchen table and send the picture
and say, "Oh, I think it was over the
bag." Or we can look at this tracking
technology they have, which I don't know
if we trust, but they have it. because
the ball is over the bag on this one.
The ball is also a quarter of the size
of the bag. So, that doesn't seem
correct. But the tracking tech does say
it was over the bag and the ump got the
call right. The Giants don't argue it.
They can't challenge it per the rules.
They just have to live with it and hope
they get the next guy out and it causes
no harm. First, we've got a foul ball
into the crowd. It causes this guy harm
emotionally and physical because it was
in his hand. And then he drops it. It
bounces. That lady who was just chilling
and sitting, she gets it. Look at the
agony on his FACE UP TOP. OH, IT WAS IN
MY HAND. OH, [ __ ]
OH, MAN. Nice job. Nice job. Nice job.
You know what they say? They say, "Let's
go back to the game and give another fan
a chance." the very next pitch as that
guy's still shaking his hand in pain.
Goes into the outfield for a home run
off of that fan's hands and then he
recovers it. Hit that guy in the arm.
They can't believe it. He's like, "Yeah,
nice job." Horrible situation here.
Brutal, dangerous. We go full turkey
here and he just banks him and then,
okay, they transition, but now he's gone
out of it. And then somehow they figure
it out and look at that. I mean, the
perseverance between these two, once
foes, now friends, is unbelievable that
they figured that out. And now this fan
is going to crack up the entire
bleachers and I throw it back. Oh, just
joking. Oh, no one noticed, cared, or
laughed. Anyway, it's a three-run home
run. So, it was two to one. Now, it's
six to2. And all of a sudden, that call,
they're mad about it. That's a Whoa.
That should be a strike. They don't
challenge it. They don't call it. The
next pitch is a ball. And then the one,
two, that should be a ball. He calls it
a strike. So, we're even. This at bat's
level. And then strike three ends the
atbat. And right afterwards, now you can
see Alan Porter throw the ball to home.
Then turn his attention to the dugout
where Vatello is yelling at him. It's a
foul ball.
It's a foul BALL
BY THIS FAR. It's a foul ball. Hey,
you're out of here. Boom. Why?
[ __ ] He can't believe it. WHAT? HOW?
WHY AM I TOSSED?
WHAT?
WHAT? I'm just telling you it's a foul
ball. I'm getting [ __ ] THROWN OUT FOR
THAT. And you can see here Alan Porter
is going to do the same hand gesture
that Vetello hit him with when he said
by this far. Which editor's note, who
says by this far? he should be saying by
this much. Unless that's a, you know, a
regional thing. Doesn't really matter at
all. Umpires, if you physically show
them up and everyone knows what you're
talking about, they don't like that.
They want you to just yell. And in this
case, he didn't even really want him to
yell. But Battello continues his case.
It's a [ __ ] foul ball. OKAY, THEN
COME OUT AND [ __ ] ALSO CALL THE
[ __ ] STRIKES. [ __ ] YOU. Get the
[ __ ] YOU GOT A [ __ ] PROBLEM WITH
YOU. [ __ ] that [ __ ] You don't
>> How is it [ __ ] in there and [ __ ]
yell at me foul through the godamn play?
>> You come out and [ __ ] argue instead.
Why can't I [ __ ] just do that on all
the [ __ ] strikes you cost us?
>> Yeah. About four of them. Get out.
>> About what? About what? What? What? You
just said about what? You're full of
[ __ ] THAT'S WHAT I [ __ ] SAID. YEAH.
>> OKAY. Check that and check the [ __ ]
strikes.
>> And remember that you said I'm full of
[ __ ] YOU ARE FULL OF [ __ ] IT'S A
[ __ ] FOUL BALL. FINE. [ __ ] So
what? You [ __ ] come out and talk to
us. Then you have that conversation.
You don't [ __ ] pop off on me
afterwards.
YOU DON'T [ __ ] POP OFF on me.
[ __ ] you. [ __ ] you. Okay, let's run
through that conversation
to try and figure out what's happening.
Allan Porter is saying, "If you've got a
problem with the call, argue with me
after it happens. If it's in between
innings, come out here and talk to us
and have a conversation about it. Don't
just yell at me from the dugout." and
Vitello, first year manager, he says,
"Why can't I do that on the bad calls?
If I come out and argue on the bad
calls, I'm ejected right away." But on
this one, I'm arguing from the dugout
and you're telling me to come out and
argue with you. So, I'm confused about
the decorum here. But the bigger thing
that happened was they were talking
about one call and Allan Porter was
ejecting him for how he was talking
about that call. And then the says, "And
also call the strikes." And that's when
you get umpire Alan Porter paused from
explaining the decorum and loses all of
it and just says, "Fuck you. Now you've
made it about my strike calling and I'm
mad at you." So, it's just a lot of, you
know, the etiquette of when and how to
yell an umpire. And I'm sure all the
umps have maybe different rules about
it. After all that goes down, Logan
Web's in the dugout. He's yelling and he
says, "Get the [ __ ] out." Yep. Get the
hell out of here. Get the hell out.
Yeah. So, he gets ejected, too. And it's
funny cuz Logan Webb actually got
ejected by two umpires at the same exact
time and they both said get the hell
out. This is synced up and both umpires
eject him and say get the hell get the
hell out this. So it's a double
ejection. I wonder who got credited. Now
I asked Logan Webb at the All-Star game
if he would get ejected for me. He said,
"Who's the home played umpire?" I said,
"Allan Porter." He said, "Well, I was
trying to get ejected the other day, but
they wouldn't listen to me." Hey, what
do you think about getting ejected?
>> Who's Who are the umpires? Uh Alan
Porter's buying the dish
>> and then a bunch of other ones.
>> I'll see I'll see what I can do. Thank
you.
>> I tried to the other day. I tried to get
ejected but they weren't listening to
me.
>> Didn't work out. Appreciate it, man.
Congrats. Thank god I searched the
umpires and remembered one of them. He
got ejected today. Good job, Logan Web.
You got what you wanted. He's just you,
hey, you guys [ __ ] it up. You know,
you [ __ ] it up and you [ __ ] it up
and that's why we're all mad at you. And
he's like, okay, let's chill out. The
next day, they're exchanging the lineup
card before the game even starts. An
assistant coach for the Giants, Ron Wus.
He says, "You got that call wrong. He's
mad." Now, next to him in the 24 jersey
is a fan who got to be out there for the
lineup exchange. And he gets to witness
an ejection, a very soft ejection.
You're gone. Get out of here. And he's
just like taking it all in. You got
Banister, the coach on the Diamondbacks
listening in. And then we have some hot
mics. So, here you go.
So yeah, carried over into the next day.
Alan Porter is a respected umpire,
especially for handling altercations
like this. That was the most personal
amount of FUS I've heard said to each
other for manager and umpire in one
argument. What do you guys think? Fair,
foul, good decorum, bad decorum. Thanks
for watching. Appreciate you. And thank
you to Fanatics Sports and Casino for
sponsoring this video. The only sports
book that rewards every bet. Earn up to
10% fan cash on every bet, win or lose.
Then turn that fan cash into more bets,
profit boosts, official team merch,
tickets, trading cards, collectibles,
and