Video summary
The Bethel Selectboard meeting commenced with the formal approval of the agenda and the adoption of a resolution to apply for the Fiscal Year 2027 Municipal Planning Grant, a move authorized by Chair Christina Fabiano that underscores the town's commitment to updating its master plan by 2028. During this session, the board also addressed administrative logistics regarding grant applications with Two Rivers, clarified internal financial policies concerning petty cash and billing, and reviewed the annual municipal checklist. Furthermore, the Selectboard accepted the resignation of Brad Andrews from the Developmental Review Board and appointed Bailey Gin to fill the resulting vacancy, while simultaneously updating the political sign policy to restrict signage on town property and utility poles while permitting it on private lawns with immediate removal requirements following elections.
A central and contentious topic of discussion was a proposed Local Option Tax (LOT) targeting local businesses, which drew strong opposition from several business owners including Justin Mel of Mel Mechanical, Bethel Mills, Babes, and Dave Samborn. These stakeholders argued that requiring them to pay sales tax on materials delivered before work is performed elsewhere would severely erode their already narrow profit margins of 3-4% and diminish their competitiveness against out-of-town contractors who do not face the same immediate material costs. While the board acknowledged these valid concerns regarding service businesses versus retailers, they also considered alternative strategies such as excluding the tax from the ballot or potentially positioning Bethel as a tax haven to encourage business retention. The meeting also covered routine public comments on road maintenance issues at Royal Hill Road due to contractor staffing shortages and approved logistical details for upcoming events, including a fire department parade route for Forward Fest on October 3rd and an authorized coin drop event.
In significant financial and infrastructure news, the Town Manager reported the receipt of two state grants: $200,000 requiring a 10% match for structural repairs to the box cover near Winterberry and $50,000 with no match requirement for replacing guardrails on Campbrook Road. The board also selected DEW and AES Northeast as design-build contractors for the new town garage project, sparking discussions about future hiring needs for a clerk of the works, potential integration of geothermal heating systems, and plans to inform voters via mailer regarding the November 3rd bond vote necessary to fund the construction. However, concerns were raised during the review of grant management, particularly regarding the administrative burdens associated with projects like the bike/pedestrian program, where overhead costs for engineering reviews, environmental checks, and third-party management firms often exceed actual construction expenses, leading some members to suggest that direct state funding would be more efficient for certain initiatives.
The session concluded with the approval of corrected minutes from previous meetings held on July 27, August 10, and a special meeting on August 18, alongside a note that the survey period ends on August 31st. Attention then turned to the anticipated release of Front Porch Forum results in September, which are expected to follow the fundraising group's success with their pool project. Before officially adjourning, board members briefly discussed upcoming personal travel plans, including trips to Montana and Boise, Idaho, marking the end of a productive session that balanced urgent infrastructure needs with careful fiscal scrutiny and community engagement.
Read the full video transcript
uh call the meeting to order and approve
the agenda.
We have a motion move to approve as
>> second. All in favor? I
>> All right. So, Ben has not joined yet.
Jordan will not be here tonight. And uh
Christina Fabiano as a chair.
>> Is she? I don't see her. Oh, there she
is.
>> There she is. Tina. All right. Okay. I
was making sure.
>> Planning Commission Christina Fabiano,
the chair of fiscal year 26 municipal
resolution of municipal planning grant
motion to adopt municipal resolution.
We saw that in our Y.
>> That's nothing different than what we've
done before,
>> right? No, but Tina has
>> she can tell you a little bit about it
and then um but if you want to make your
motion before she discusses.
>> Well, let's make the motion. We can move
after
>> I move to to
>> Yeah. Whatever.
>> Adopt.
>> Second.
>> All right. It's all yours.
>> Hi everyone. Thank you. So, for the
record, I'm Christina Fabiano, chair of
the planning commission. Um, I'm here
tonight to request your authorization to
apply for the state's fiscal year 2027
municipal planning grant and to adopt
the required municipal resolution. Our
current objective is to secure this
funding to assist with our comprehensive
town plan revision which needs to be
updated and adopted by 2028. As you
know, a current state approved town plan
is vital. It keeps our town eligible for
critical state funding and grants.
Updating this plan requires professional
consulting, public outreach, and data
collection, and this grant will help
cover those exact planning expenses. The
application window opens on October 1st,
and the Vermont Department of Housing
and Community Development requires this
formal resolution signed by a majority
of this select board to accompany our
submission. Therefore, I respectfully
request that the select board adopt the
fiscal year 2027 municipal resolution
for the municipal planning grant and to
authorize the town to move forward with
the application. Thank you for your
time. I'm happy to answer any questions
that you might have.
>> So, Tina, the municipal planning
resolution I have is says FY26 up in the
top. Okay.
>> So, would you want me to just put 27?
>> Yeah, I think so. I think it's the same
exact um form. Um,
>> and then I just had a question was on
the form. So, you need to sign it, which
you're probably aware of, and then I
need to sign it. And then at the bottom,
it says that we're supposed to designate
someone as a grant administrator, the
person with the overall administrative
responsibility for the miss planning
grant, program activities related to the
application, and any subsequent grant
agreement provision. So, is that also me
or would that be someone from Two
Rivers?
>> I think it's two. I think one is you. If
there's two fields, one is you and then
one is who is assisting us ultimately
from Two Rivers.
>> All right. So, we I can ask them that
question. I can shoot that to them.
>> Then, um you're away, but you I'll leave
it. You can just come to the office
sometime to sign it, right? Because we
need your signature on the first page
before we submit it.
>> Did you know that?
>> Oh, I'm sorry. Did you Was that to me?
>> Yeah, you you have to sign it yourself.
So, I'll leave it out front in the
office for when you get back. You can
swing in and just see Alice and sign it.
>> Excellent. Can do.
>> Okay. Perfect.
And just to explain too, we're going to
um Two Rivers is going to help with the
municipal planning grant. So, and
they'll help with the town plan as well.
Okay. We need to change the motion to uh
fiscal year 27.
>> Yep.
move as amended.
>> Second.
>> Okay. All in favor
online. Yeah.
Okay. All right. So, here you go. Pass
that around. You can get I put wrote
your names the three names on there
already so you can sign.
Thank you so much, Tina, for coming.
>> Thank you all.
>> You have some support here, too. We got
Dana's here and Eric Webb is here and
Mr. Greenberg's here. So, you've got you
got backup.
>> Perfect. Thank you. And I appreciate it.
>> Sure.
>> Okay.
All right. Uh continue discussion of the
local auction uh tax with local
business.
>> So, I do want to say that I've heard
from um Thank you. We've heard from
Bethl Mills. That's a no. They're not in
favor. I saw Dave Samborn from the
sandwich shop. That's a no. He's not in
favor. I spoke to Josh Tracy today from
Tracy's Plumbing and Heating. He's not
in favor. And Justin's here, but they
had also said the same thing before.
Well, it's Oh, babes. I heard from
Babes. Um, well, you've heard from Babes
before and they weren't in favor.
>> No, he's not in favor either. So, yeah,
I'm just trying. I think that's
>> Brad.
I haven't heard from Brad and
>> he's not in he's not around this week
but
>> Okay. Yeah, we did. Oh, he is not. Oh,
you already know. Okay. Because we did
send out or I sent out emails to
everybody that the businesses that I
could and then we put it on front porch
forum and Facebook. But so it looks like
the ones are here are
so
>> would you like to say anything else?
Come up to the mic and
Yeah, I also say we're not.
>> I'm Justin Mel owner. Well, past owner
mechanical and yeah, we're definitely
not favor our business for sure. We
would, you know, in town right off the
bat. Anyone who did any kind of work is
going to pay more. But it's going to
hurt us outside of here too because we
get a lot of material delivered to our
shop that we would be paying tax on
to the tune of, you know, $1.5 million
or so roughly gets delivered to our shop
over here roughly.
>> Yeah.
>> That's a lot of tax money that we're
then going to have to overcome when
we're competing with people in
Stockbridge on an install or any
anywhere but here. We're going to be at
a disadvantage right off the bat to try
to get that job.
>> Yeah. Yeah.
>> Right off the bat,
>> right? Because
>> if it's enough money for me,
>> we'll move.
>> Yeah.
>> We'll move shop.
>> For $150,000 every year and then we're
going to grow from there. I'll move shop
where I put that money in my pocket, not
the towns.
>> And I'm sorry to say that, but that's
that's the reality.
>> Yeah.
>> So,
>> we were just looking for Yeah. Because
you'd have to pass that cost along to
your course was
>> already a percentage below any
competitor,
especially commercial roof. the margins
aren't that big.
>> You get into some of the big work we're
doing, the margins aren't there. It's
like, oh, 20%, it's not funny. You know,
we're working 3 and 4% margins.
>> That's a great
already taken a big chunk right off the
bat.
>> So,
>> that's a really good point. I'm glad
that you brought that up because we were
Dave Eddie and I were just reviewing um
town garage estimates and you're right.
They're they're not playing with a big
margin.
>> Not big margin. There's a lot of
competitiveness. It's it's there's not a
lot of movement, you know, on the job.
It just gets the world, right?
>> Yeah. Oh, that's that's a really good
point. I'm glad that you brought that
up.
>> Anyway, that's kind of my
>> before we run away, could I ask you a
couple questions?
>> Yeah.
>> Um,
>> so you get most of your material
delivered to you and then you you lug it
to where
>> we do. Yeah. Because as we saw in the
beginning when we were looking at this,
there's a lot of counts us around us
that do the LT already. So if you're
doing any work in Woodstock, it doesn't
matter whether you have it delivered
here or there. The tax has to be paid.
>> So
okay,
>> but just
>> I just curious,
>> we would certainly have to look at how
we got deliveries, where we would take
them, you know, cuz if we're in those
towns, we're already competing in that
same market. puts the counter or not. If
we get it delivered here, it's going to
put us outside.
>> So,
>> right. I mean, how not?
>> So, if it's See, I don't understand that
because if the if the wholesaler
delivers to me,
>> but the actual retail buyer is Joe Schmo
in Stockbridge.
>> Well, taxically buy them, but the
homeowner isn't buying it, but we are.
>> Yeah, that makes sense. So when you're
buying income from us, if you will.
>> Yeah. So if he had a job, say, well,
we'll just pick um Royal. We know
Royaltton does not have the local option
tax. So if he had a project in Royaltton
and he had the stuff delivered to
Royaltton, he wouldn't pay the LOT. But
if he has it delivered here, which he
does, because he would need to know that
he had all of his pieces, parts, and
fancy equipment before he went to do the
install. You have everything bought and
paid for
>> prior to going to your job.
>> Correct. All the stuff that we bought,
we buy for the customer.
>> Yeah.
>> And again, you're right. It's not all
the jobs that we do, but it's certainly
a big chunk of our business that we do
is
all even a lot of our commercial stuff
has to come here. Even though you think
the job site
we're we're taking huge deliveries
sometimes trying to figure out how to
store it, you know.
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. One of the other
issues and I remember if you were here
last time we were talking about it was
specifically Bethl Mills. Their issue is
you know if they where they deliver to.
>> So that becomes they need to look at a
map because you could live in Bethl but
have a Randolph mailing address. And so
it adds
>> there's a lot of there's a lot of labor
out there
for my supplers really. I mean they're
going to
they're
but it is going to cost them more labor
too having to figure out that
I'm sure they do that all the time
anyway. It's not but you know it is
going to cost
>> for other towns but not here. Yeah. just
added.
>> No,
>> but that's good. That made sense.
>> Thanks.
>> Thank you. Thank you.
>> I would add that two
pass.
>> Oh. Oh. Oh. Oh. Okay. Sorry.
>> Is it true that one of the benefits of
hopes is that this will um this will get
money from people
Right. Yep. That is we did a during the
Bethl for all when we did that we did a
zip code survey. So the I that the hope
was that if that stands you know the
same then then basically Bethl residents
would not be paying 100%. Like you pay
100% of property taxes but if there was
a local option tax then maybe Bethl
residents would pay 60%. And or 40% not
the whole enchilada.
>> So just a point
of
>> opposite perspective that when we do
work or Anybody who does a business on
their own,
>> yeah,
>> they are going to it's definitely going
to discourage them from using a better
contractor
>> because they have to choose us for an
outfit or grand
>> not currently.
>> Okay.
>> But deliveries are there.
>> Yeah.
>> And they wouldn't have to pay for extra
person. Why might I choose that outfit?
It doesn't feel very businessfriendly
business.
>> It's like people going to West Lab,
right? So they can sales tax. Sure.
>> And so if we want to have people local
>> Yeah.
>> businesses.
>> Yeah. The whole thought was because you
know obviously the state is broke or
whatever you know they like to say to
us. So we were just this was an avenue
that's presented and the states has so
obviously so the state has to we give
have they get their 25%. Don't you worry
they get their pound of flesh. So and
then it's a percentage per you know
filing but because our only option is
for non- tax revenue. This was just an
opportunity for us to look at where
maybe as a Bethl resident, you wouldn't
be on the hook for 100% of it. You'd be
on a portion because when we did the zip
code survey, people from other towns and
other states were paying would be paying
for a portion of it. So, uh that's it
was just one of those options to try to
look at because otherwise it's property
tax is is it. So the thought was
certainly um Ben, we talked about it was
you know trying to look at it as
you know tax um what was the word you
used Ben? Not tax rebate tax
>> tax relief.
>> Tax relief. Thank you. Um and you know
trying to use the money that we would
collect from lo to maybe offset property
taxes or put it towards you know capital
funds that sort of thing. So, you know,
everybody's looking for money, right?
>> But Ben has his hand up.
>> Go ahead, Ben.
>> And no, I'm sorry. I I'm having trouble.
I can't hear from the mic that's over um
by the audience.
>> Oh, okay. So, I'll let
>> I haven't been able to hear uh some of
the commentary, but I'm hoping maybe you
could kind of paraphrase what the
concerns are.
>> Sure. the concerns that um Mel
Mechanical that Justin was talking about
or that he because they work in such
narrow margins three or 4% that he feels
that the local option tax because they
take possession of everything here in
Bethl is going to make him so he's not
as competitive and it's going to cut
into his profit margin. Is that a good
recap? Okay. And is that is that the
case that uh a business has to pay the
local option tax themselves on materials
before the consumer does?
>> That's my question.
>> I believe so. Do you know the answer to
that, Kirk?
>> Yeah, we believe so. Yes, because
they're taking possession of it and he
paid sales tax on his invoice. Now, yes,
he would turn around and charge his
customer, but to his point, that percent
that he's charging his customer could be
the difference in what's making him get
the job or not get the job.
>> Worse. Worse. Yep. No, I was just
curious if that uh that's how it worked.
>> Yep.
>> I think that's a fair point.
>> Another quick question because it just
came to me. What is the difference
between you taking material
in and Lang taking a truckload of lumber
in?
>> Lang doesn't pay tax on it until he
sells it. So Lang can get as much
delivered here as he wants. He's not
paying tax on that. So it goes out his
door.
>> Okay, there's a good point.
>> Only tax on one sale, which is not him.
>> Okay, so Ben, I'm not sure if you heard
Justin. He answered Dave's question
>> and said
>> and said that the the difference between
Mel Mechanical's business and Bethl
Mills is that Lang when he doesn't pay
sales tax when he takes possession of
it. He takes he pays sales tax when it
goes out the door. And that's different
for Mel Mechanical.
>> Gotcha. Either way, it's they're both
still paying sales tax on what they
receive.
>> Yes.
>> Got it.
We also have a choice, right? And I'm
sorry, I don't want to jump the line if
there's anyone else queued up.
>> No, go ahead. A choice. What?
>> Uh, we have a choice what we apply the
local option tax to, right? So, we could
exclude sales tax uh on on hard goods,
right?
>> You could. Yep. you could just have
sales tax on rooms and meals.
Um, so it would be like, you know,
Airbnbs, uh, food. So you can, yes, you
could exclude sales tax, which takes
out, you know, the bigger, um, you know,
alcohol, soda, you know, any of those
sort of things that people buy at the
convenience store level. So, but yes,
you could. And did uh I know you list
off all the businesses at the beginning
that were not in favor. Did they
articulate their reasons why other than
just no?
>> Well, we've heard from Lang, you've seen
his their email that Claudia did and you
heard from Babes. The only one um I did
hear from
Sandwich Shop Dave Samborn. He just said
he was against it um and didn't really
go into a lot of detail. just I think he
my assumption is that it's he just feels
it's not very businessfriendly but he he
didn't really elaborate just said no and
Jed spoke to Brad Andrews at Mills
Hardware and he also said no did he give
you any more information Jed
>> another tax
>> and the paperwork
>> yeah okay
>> goes a long way and worried of people
going elsewhere for the product
Did you hear Jed's response?
>> Yeah. Well, Jed's got a microphone, so
>> All right, good.
>> Um, no, these are all fair points. And,
you know, I'm I'm starting to go the
other way, right? Because it sound like
a great idea that we were, you know,
providing tax relief
um by having uh out ofers or or even
folks from other towns kind of
contribute to this local option tax. But
if it's if the if the if the businesses
are now having to pay that tax as well
on their goods, they're they're not
really it is cutting into their their
margins, right? It's not like they're
just passing that tax on. They're
they're actually they're paying it as
well. Um, so
maybe maybe it's even better that we are
the sort of the haven from the this
local option tax rather than being
another adopter, right? We might be the
only town that doesn't have it at some
point. And wouldn't that be cool?
>> Yeah, that's that's a good point, Ben.
That's that's a really valid point. And
like I said, you don't have to make it,
you know, you will in the end you, the
five of you will make a decision whether
or not you're going to put it on the
warning for the residents to vote at
town meeting or not. You could choose
not to do that. So
>> that's all we're doing really
>> anyways just giving them the town's
going to vote. Yeah, they either say and
but you have the choice of whether or
not you put it on the warning. And last
time we put on the warning, I think it
made it to
called the question and it was it was a
it was hard. It was a really one of
those two minute, you know, questions
that Tommy didn't ask.
>> No, no. It was a resounding move.
>> Yeah. So, we do know that Royal Tennis
is working on it because they want
they're hoping it passes so they could
pay for their share their bridge.
>> Rand's working
>> and Randolph's working on. So, maybe
Ben's right.
>> So, that's my next question. Look at the
crystal ball.
>> Yeah.
>> And everybody around us adopted adopts
it.
>> Yeah. So,
>> then we then we become the most business
friendly town in the area. Right.
>> That's right. Then so then we could
become the most business friendly town.
We just need to elect some new
legislators to go there. There's quite
so much damn tax in the state as it is.
>> Okay. You can tell her that
or you just did
>> just just maybe
there any more discussion on the uh
local tax.
Just a reminder, Jean Cross, I think
I've said this before, but a a sales tax
is equally implied that 1% of that $10
purchase is equally applied to all
persons regardless of their ability to
pay to pay. Not everybody who lives in
Bethle is uh
pays property tax. they may indirectly
be rented etc. But the it's an unfair
tax when you
in general and it's just something that
people need to be aware of when if and
when such a tax is done.
>> JJ Ben did put a note in here just to
remind people that um food and clothing
are
>> not our exception. He just wanted
>> Yep.
>> Okay.
I think everybody's all set for this.
All right. We now open the meeting to
public comment for stuff that is not on
tonight's agenda.
>> Hi. Um, can you hear me? Um, I'm Ellie
Griffin and I have a question. And I
have just a question as a Bethl
resident. This is just a question from a
Bethl resident. Um a little bit ago, um
the town was mowing on Roy Hill Road.
Now, North Road, you go up and then you
turn left on Royalton Hill Road. And
they were mowing. But I my question is
why did they only mow part of the road?
They didn't mow the whole road. They're
out up there mowing when they mowed the
whole road. And plus, I live off of
Royal Hill Road. So, my street is a left
turn called East Street. And if they had
mowed the whole road and then they could
turn on East Street and there was just
this amount of mowing needed on East
Street. But of course they didn't finish
doing Royal Hill Road and so they didn't
even do East Street. So I'm just curious
of why would you have a job and not
complete the job? I mean, if I rated the
job, I'd give them a C minus on the job.
And so I and I noticed in your town
report that in 2425
you saved $1,000 in mowing. I can't
there's no figure for this year. And you
got budgeted $18,000 for mowing. So what
are you going to complete the job? Are
you going to um um mow some more or?
>> Yep, I can tell you. So, normally we
hire we've hired a contractor in the
past and and um he last year and this
year he did not have people to run all
of his roadside mowers. So, he did a
state contracts and wasn't doing local.
So, last year we rented a roadside mower
and um we were only able for the price
to only rent it for a month. So, we did
what we could. We were able to rent it
this year for two months. Um we had a
couple breakdowns with it, so it had to
go back to the rental agency and come
back. And um it's it's not a job that we
like. We would prefer to to you know to
pay someone else to do it that that's
what they do. So um it's the roadside mo
has gone back. They hit pretty
everything they could within the time
frame that they had it. So he was aware
of your um complaint about East Street.
I think you might have mentioned it to
AJ or somebody somebody told AJ anyways
he he knew about it um and why they
didn't complete North I just I don't
know if he just ran out of time that day
or what the situation was but it is not
we are really praying that next year we
can put it back out. The savings last
year was just coincidence because we
budget we take what they normally
charged us and then each year I add like
a small percentage to it like maybe 3%
that's how I get the number because
we're never really sure what he's going
to charge us depends on fuel etc etc but
we're really hoping that he has a full
crew next year because when we had it
done with a professional guy he did a
great job and he made two passes and it
was lovely so yeah it wasn't wasn't the
Thanks for answering my question.
>> You're welcome. You're welcome.
Any other public comment?
All right, seeing none, we will head
into the fire department's request to
hold a parade at noon starting at the
school parking lot ending at Bethl
Mills. All invited to participate. And
this is during Forward Fest.
>> Yep. So it's October 3rd.
>> Yep. October 3rd and so I need a motion
>> use of the tail road
>> second
>> any discussion I just want to let you
know what the route is because it's
pretty short so they're going to go from
the school to Bethl Mills and then once
they get to Bethl Mills they will you
know when they go head back to the
school they'll follow regular traffic
patterns they're just going to do it
just for that little bit so they're
looking uh so certainly contact Josh
Tracy if you're interested. They're
looking for kids to walk in it, ride
their bicycles or you know kind of do a
get as many people interested as they
can um this year. So
>> I am curious um we we don't
>> we require sort of schematics and uh you
know insurance and all sorts of planning
for coin drops but not for a parade.
Actually, you guys, I don't know if you
you haven't done a parade since I've
been here, but normally no, especially
because the fire department, he'll have
people staged. He's already reached out
to the sheriff's office and has two
cruisers. Um, so, you know,
I'm not too worried because they know
what they're doing. They're
firefighters. So, plus two, like I said,
he already reached out to the sheriff's
office and has two cruisers. So, he'll
have somebody in front and somebody, you
know, behind. So,
>> so what's
>> when we let people use the roads for
bike races and stuff like that, we don't
get too
>> Okay, that's fair. Yeah, we didn't do it
for the 5K, right?
>> Yeah. I'll tell him if something
happens, it's on him.
>> Okay. I was just curious. There's a
reason we did things a little bit
differently between the coin drop and
the parade. But,
>> yeah. Oh, it makes sense. There will be
a coin drop that morning as well.
>> Yeah, we'll do that later.
>> All right.
All in favor of uh authorizing the use
of the town roads.
>> I post
carries. Uh resignation of Brad Andrews
from the developmental review board and
uh fence viewer. Motion to accept with
thanks and so much gratitude. Brad's
been on the DRB for quite some time now.
Um he was on when I was on the planning
commission.
>> I think six years. I looked back town
reports to see when he was on. So
>> he was on there for a while. So many
kudos to Brad for
>> um all he's done for the DRB.
>> Motion to accept many things.
>> Second. Motion to accept. Second.
>> All right. Any discussion?
>> All right. All in favor?
Opposed?
All right. Number three, request of
Bailey Gin to be appointed to the DRB.
Motion to appoint.
>> Second.
>> Any discussion? I think there's a letter
in the packet and he's been to
>> three meetings
>> like right two meetings. Yep.
>> Yep.
>> There you go. Hey, there that's like 90%
of the battle right there.
>> That's great.
>> Is he Is he in attendance?
>> Uh, he is not in attendance. No.
>> All right.
>> Any more
here? He could probably answer it.
>> Ben, did you have a question?
>> Uh,
nope. No. I just wanted to ask ask him
why he was interested.
Probably Dana's been pressuring him into
it.
>> That makes sense. Yeah.
>> Is that why he was wearing his sling?
>> Yeah.
>> Dana Dana said he encouraged him to uh
consider joining and his wife has
already joined the planning commission.
So
>> he's a friend of Dana is a friend of
mine.
>> There's no actual signature on here.
Dana, there's no actual signature here.
Did he actually write this?
>> All right. Motion to appoint been uh
moved and seconded. Is any more
discussion?
>> All in favor?
>> I opposed. All right. Uh select board
approval of annual municipal checklist
for municipal controls part one and two.
Master
approve
the initial checklist, please.
>> Second.
>> Uh, any discussion?
>> I got questions.
>> Okay, you go ahead.
>> I got
>> uh we don't do any petty cash in the
office.
>> No.
He asked if we did petty cash and I said
no.
>> And it says that the town manager
approved salary and wage rates but I
could have sworn that was part of our
budget.
>> It is. It's part of the budget but I
mean as far as the breakdown like you
approved the overall budget. So but just
because you've approved say 3% doesn't
mean every employee gets 3%. So,
>> okay. Well, I thought we we approved
each individual wage in the budget.
That's not true.
>> No.
>> Okay. Got it. Thank you. Uh and then
part two, section two, question one.
There's no response.
>> Oh, maybe I missed one. Part two,
section two. Whoops. Hang on. I got the
wrong page. Oh, yeah.
Are billing collection and posting
performed by separate employees or
departments?
Oh yeah, I had a question about that.
Billing
collection I posting
are they performed by separate
employees?
Kind of yes and no. Um Alice bills but
she also, you know, takes in the money
but I'm the delinquent tax collector. So
I guess I would just say yes to that.
Then I'll fill that one in.
>> Sure.
>> And I could put a little explanation
beside that. But thank you. I think I
was still mulling it over.
>> And the only other question I had, I
know you put NA next to uh the credit
card policy, but in the absence of one,
wouldn't that be a no?
>> Uh could be. I just said, yeah, it could
be. We all say no. I just didn't want
him to think that we had a credit card.
>> Gotcha.
>> But we didn't have a policy. So that's
why I wrote NA. We don't have a credit
card. I didn't want them to think we had
one. We had a credit card and we didn't
have a policy for it.
>> Sure.
>> That's why
>> I don't know who reads this at the
state. I know it goes to the treasur's
office. So I just
>> I mean to answer the question, we don't
have a credit card policy.
>> Yeah, exactly. Right.
>> That's all I had.
>> Okay. Thank you.
>> And then need to sign. The select board
chair needs to sign. Okay. Any other
questions?
>> All right. All those in favor?
>> Opposed?
All right.
>> Yes. You No, you need to sign or is that
like why are you like get that?
>> No, you just need to sign those.
>> All right. Sports uh request for a coin
drop on Saturday, October 3rd on
Pleasant Street from It's going to be
from 8 until noon because of the parade.
I just got that change approved today
from Jordan. I texted him because I'm
like, I can't have you collecting money
when the grade's trying to leave the
school. So, he said, "All right." He
said that we could do 8 to noon.
>> Motion to approve.
>> All those in favor?
>> I
drop.
>> Yeah.
>> Did you have any questions, Ben? Thought
I heard you say so.
>> No. No. No. We'll let him we'll let him
have the the
hand and then you just need to sign
right there. So, yeah, I did text Jordan
today to make sure that was going to be
okay with him and he said, "Yeah, he
hoped people still came and I said,
"Well, they're going to be parking for
the parade, so you might he might do
really well."
>> A little extra.
>> Yeah, he might do really well.
>> Should charge for parking. Yeah,
>> that's right. Exactly. So, he's all set
for that.
>> All right. And that is uh placement of
political science policy update.
>> So we had a policy before and then Dree
before she moves she's trying to get
through all the rest of the policies. So
I gave you the original and then her
replacement policy so you could see what
the changes were.
>> Okay. A motion for this, right?
>> Yep.
>> Second.
>> Any discussion?
I'm just curious if there was any
difference. I the only thing I could
really discern was that signs need to be
removed immediately after an election.
Is that the only change?
>> Well, I put in the whole policy. Um the
original, it's marked original. And then
this one, some of it she just felt was
redundant, so she was just trying to cut
it down. I think the whole, you know,
what they can be fastened to, that sort
of thing is all really much the same.
>> That's I agree.
>> Yeah. I think she was she's been really
good about trying to condense policies
for us so they're a little more
manageable and and again some of it is
as you can see is um
defined by state statute
>> but this so this was really just a
review. It wasn't sparked by anything.
>> No no it was not. No. Um, in the past, I
think there wasn't a policy when we did
the last one. And around, you know,
November, sometimes people get a little
out of hand and start putting signs
everywhere. Um,
>> so this was to kind of just let people
know you can't put them on trees and
utility poles and and they're not
allowed on town property because if they
are, then we have to remove them. And
but just a reminder for everybody, the
triangle is not ours. That's the state.
So if you're trying to take signs off
from there, there's no
>> state can
>> the state can but we can't. So um so
yeah, it was more of an issue around I
think the last presidential election
maybe. Ben
>> and same same with the school, right?
That's not town property. That's school
property.
>> That is school property. Yeah.
>> Okay. And again, the only difference I I
saw I agree it's mostly the same, but
there was that signs need to be removed
immediately after an election was the
only difference,
>> right? Yep. Just because Yeah. You know,
otherwise people they get left there for
a while and I've you know, sometimes I
think it was the last election I had
several in the office that people
collected because they just just sat
around and they're not cheap, I'm sure.
So
>> there's still one on the bottom of
Northro.
>> Yeah. We try to give them back to people
too as well after the election because
they're not cheap, are they, Kurt?
>> Yeah. So,
>> what does that really Oh, sorry. Someone
talking.
>> Go ahead.
>> What does this really apply to if it if
they can't be put on town property or on
on sign posts or telephone polls? Is
this just right away that we're talking
about or?
>> Right. You can put them on your lawn. If
you want to have political signs on your
lawn, that's totally fine. This is
really just preventing people Yeah. from
putting them
>> in um putting them on town property
because obviously we are not we're
non-political. We're not going to pick a
side. So, it looks like we are
politicking for someone if they're on
town property. And the state leaves you,
you know, we can't put anything on
utility polls. That's against the law.
It'll kind of just let people know.
>> Um Yeah. And we don't want them in the
right way. Blocking view. So someone
goes to pull out of a street and there's
a sign right there. So really just uh
traffic safety too. Most people are
really good about adhering to the rules.
>> Got it. Yeah. I'm not trying to make a
big deal out of this or anything. I'm
just Yeah.
>> Just trying to figure out why we would
say they need to be removed immediately
after an election if they can't put them
on town property anyway.
>> Well, yeah. Oh, I see what you're
saying. That's a I understand what
you're saying. Yeah. Why does it say
they shall be removed immediately after
an election? Um, that's a good point,
Ben.
It said that in the old one, too.
>> You sure? Okay.
>> Yeah. Yep.
Well, you know what? Nobody wants to
relive it, Ben.
>> I just want I didn't want to make it
seem like we're going to go around
ticking signs out of people's yard. I
don't think that's the intention, right?
So,
>> no.
yards. It's their yard.
>> Yeah, totally. Yeah.
>> All right. Any more discussion?
>> All right. Uh motion to
adopt the political science policy
update.
All in favor?
>> I opposed.
>> All right. Uh we have the town manager
support.
>> So we received two grants this week that
we applied for. So, one of them is
$200,000 with a 10% match. That's for
the structures grant um that we applied
for to replace that box cover on Gilead
near Winterberry.
So, you know, that's been in rough shape
for a while. So, we had I'd received a
what they call a brick grant to get it
engineered. That was FEMA money. So, we
were able to get it engineered and all
that, like a preliminary design, but no.
Uh, but when we applied for construction
money, we didn't get any.
So, now we So, we applied for a
structures grant from the state of
Vermont VR, and that's what we got. The
other one is for $50,000, which is with
no match, which is nice. This is hard.
This is rare. Um, we got that from the
state as well. And we're going to
replace guard rail on Campbrook. the
part that we paved, we have to raise up
that um guard rail because with the
paving now, it's not the right height,
but we're also have quite a bit on um
camper that we have to replace. So
50,000 is going to be nice a nice boon
for that budget. Um the other thing is
we received two responses. Um so I told
you we put out the RFQ, we received
three um our three responses. Um, I
removed one and we came down to two. We
issued the RFP and Dave, Eddie, and I
reviewed those and today we chose um,
DEW. So, we're going to move forward
with DU and AES uh, Northeast for the
paired together. So, it's a design build
project. So, which means it's open book.
We, you know, you know what their
percentage is, what their markup is, and
then the rest of it's open book. So, I
called both the contractors um today and
let them know and um Dave has agreed to
stay with me to help me through the um
construction process. One of the things
that we're going to have to talk about
at a future meeting is
whether or not we want to hire a clerk
of the works. Um, you know, I've
obviously had built buildings and and I
did have to work for the works uh when
we built a fire station in Bristol.
Um, so but I don't know. I mean, this is
just a that was not a metal building.
That was a different, you know,
situation. However, I, you know, neither
Dave or I qualified to make sure that
the specs are right on the concrete,
this and that. So, we could just add
maybe additional monies for certain
testing to come in and things like that.
But I think that's something that we
need to talk about and I think it would
be good to have Jordan's for sure input
on that. So, um maybe I'll put that on
the next agenda and we can talk about
that when he's back. Maybe he has some,
you know, insight to that. Um
>> we don't need to search the works for
>> No, we don't. We don't. I just it's
something we need to think about and I
want to look at um obviously the capital
building fund you know the the um you
know first take is 3.1 million um theirs
and I he knows because I'd given him 2.8
and first I started at 2.1 and they're
like
no so 2.8 8 and they came in at 3.1. So,
not bad. But we did say, you know, we're
going to look for some savings. Uh they
were they knew that. Um Dave Eddie also
make a great point which was
we are building a 50-year building. So,
while we may not see something right now
that we're going to do, we need to make
sure that the structure is there in case
something is for the future. So, um, but
anyways, currently, so we're at very
preliminary stages. I will be, we did a
video. Thank you, Finn. He did a great
job for Orca. So, we're going to be
releasing that. We also want to have an
open house so people can see the garage.
The video is scary enough, but we're
going to do that as well. I'm going to
start um with some numbers and try to do
and do a mailer so people are aware
because you'll vote that via bond vote
on November 3rd. I've already talked to
my bond bank and started my bond
application. Um, so something to think
about. Also something to think about
with money from, you know, the Quimby
Forest sale. What we maybe at that time
were able to buy the lawn down a little
bit or, you know, something like that
because the interest rate on your debt
that you had was like 3%. This is going
to be I think around five. So, um, but
we the garage is just it's it's coming
apart. We actually have to stabilize one
of the walls just to get through
another.
>> To your point, I'm sure it's cheaper to
make it as we want now.
>> Yeah.
>> To try.
>> Yep. Yeah. One of the things that we
talked about was for just for one
example was radiant heat. So, while
radiant heat is more money upfront over
the length over the you know uh life of
the building, it'll be cheaper. Um so
that was something that we talked about.
things like that. So, just trying to um
be playing and it will go in the same
spot. We were very clear about that. Um
it will, you know, one bay bigger, you
know, towards the road. But luckily, we
already had done a lot of the pre-
stuff. We have fuel tank, we move the
underground tank, we know where the
power is, we know where sewer, water,
that whole thing. Um so
uh so anyways we just felt like um do
just had a really good a much more
detailed proposal than Russell. So
anyway so that's what we're going to
move forward
>> propane.
>> Is there any thought of doing
the because that would be over the long
>> term
that would eliminate.
>> It's something that we could look at,
but just to remind you if you're not
aware is that the reason that we're
building exactly where we're building is
that that there are portions of that
which are an old dump. So,
>> yeah. So, we're
>> Yeah. So, we're
>> we could be going through it.
>> It's something we can talk about.
Yep.
>> Sure. And that's totally something we
can talk to them about when we're in the
process.
>> We have a lot of questions.
>> Yeah, we have a lot of questions. It's
just very preliminary. But no, it's
good. Actually, one of them mentioned
that in their proposal, and I don't
remember if it was due or Russell, but
um but it was in there and I was like,
Jean, it said geothermal. I thought of
you as soon as I read it on Sunday. So,
um so yeah, that's it was in there. So,
it's something that we'll talk about for
sure, but um you know, it's a long time
coming. We you know, 31,000
>> how much it cost for the building 50
some odd years ago.
>> Yeah. And the talk of the town garage
has been on agendas for at least 10
years.
>> Yeah. It's been a while. It's just it's
a big nut to crack, you know, and you're
just going to think about Yeah.
>> Yeah. Oh, I'm sure. I mean, it's it's a
it's a big nut to crack. So,
>> and it's questionable if it lasts this
winter. Yeah, exactly. Like I said,
>> heavy wet snow.
>> We were already up there. I was already
up there. We were looking at it stabil
and um AJ was, you know, we know there's
a portion of we have to stabilize the
wall. So, but the good news is the pole
barn is done and the salt shed is done.
So that's so at least we will have
equipment storage and because the very
preliminary date to finish would be
November 17th or 19th and so
anyway so hopefully that can go a little
faster but at least they'd have a place
you know right now for some equipment
and working because they will work there
and we'll have a trailer like a job
trailer there for AJ to work out of and
there's conx boxes the salt shed this
and that. So, you know, they the
contractor's aware it will be a working
garage or facility while they're there.
So,
>> um you know, so I think they would
demolish it in probably like April. As
soon as the snow was done, they
demolish. So, um you know, it'll be
we'll work it out. And AJ as certainly
we've already talked about prepared to,
you know, look at what we need, you
know, his wants and needs, right? And at
this point it was pretty basic and
that's what we told them when they came
because they were mentioning some other
places and I'm like you know that's too
rich for our book. We're not we're not
done that you know. So I think it'll be
a really good process and we'll start to
inform the voters and and um we'll be
definitely voting on November 3rd. So
>> I think that's all you got? I think so.
Yeah. I think so.
All right. Uh, next on the agenda, we
have three sets of minutes to approve
September uh July 27th
uh August 10th and August 18th because
we had a correction for the July 27th
one we had.
>> Yep. Are you going to do them
individually or all at once?
>> I don't see a problem with any of them.
So, I would be willing to move the
ability to move all three.
>> Let's see what Ben is up to. He's
shuffling papers.
>> A second.
>> Ben, what are you
>> Yeah, I didn't see the uh the older set.
Uh maybe is that in our packet?
>> Yep.
>> Well, that's on me then. I can't approve
last emergency meeting. I wasn't there.
>> Right. Okay. Yep. No Ben was No, there
was no Ben and there was no
>> Jordan on the 18th. Okay. Yeah, it says
that on the minutes anyways.
>> Joe, should we do them individually?
>> I guess so. Make it easier
>> for the uh July 27th 26th. Can I get a
motion to approve as corrected?
>> Second.
All in favor of approving the Monday,
July 27th
uh
>> you still thinking about it, Ben?
You have a question?
>> Is that the first one?
>> Yeah.
>> Sorry.
>> I I
approve that one. The oldest one, right?
>> Yep.
>> Yeah, that's the one we asked for the
edits on. Yeah, I saw those. Thank you.
>> Okay. And then we have the August 10th
one, which I believe you were at, Ben.
>> Yep.
>> Yeah.
>> Yep. Motion to approve the August 10th
minutes.
>> Okay.
>> Okay. All in favor?
>> I
>> And the last one we had was 8:18 2026,
our uh special meeting. All those in uh
Can I get a motion in a second? Motion
to approve. Second.
>> Any discussion?
All in favor?
>> This is just the three of you. So
>> thank you fellas. And then and we have
other communications in here. We have
equity inclusion. We have all kinds of
stuff. The planning commission, rec
committee, the um
whatever.
>> Where have all the lifeguards gone?
That's what um Dana had or not Dana.
Yeah, it seems like it, doesn't it? Greg
Hughes has written.
>> Yeah, that was in there. And yeah,
plenty of minutes and
Yeah, exactly.
>> Yeah.
>> Yep.
>> All right.
>> Sorry. When are we uh when are we
expecting the survey to end?
>> August 31st. Alice is putting out a
reminder.
>> We're almost there. Okay. on front porch
forum.
>> I hope I hope a pool wins. They put a
lot of energy into it in the fundraising
group.
>> Yeah, I last I heard it was a clear
clear front runner. So, we'll find out.
It'll be on the September 14th select
board minutes. All the working committee
will know before that. So, it'll it'll
all be out before then. But, um
>> I've got them scheduled the meeting yet.
So, but yeah, there's still time for
people to respond. So,
um, obviously a lot of people have not
responded, so hopefully more people.
>> There was a fair amount of delinquent.
>> Well, yeah. And there was delinquent
bills that went out last week, so
hopefully people will get those and go,
"Oh, yeah, we got this, too."
>> Yeah. All right. Any other business
necessary to come before the board?
>> I just want to say this was the neat
thing to see.
>> Oh, the grants.
>> All the the grants and what's what's
being worked on right now.
what our match was for the amount of
money
>> spent it's pretty impressive
>> yeah I try to keep it up to date I have
a you know I have a spreadsheet
spreadsheet I'm a but anyway so and one
of them is that's the current page and
then I have a whole other like another
page in that spreadsheet all the stuff
we have done and you know where that
money came from and what the match is
it's also you know you needed to track
it for um because we usually take the
match out of a capital fund like capital
roads, capital, whatever. So, trying to
make sure you have money, you know,
coming and going. But yeah, we were
excited about the no match for the
50,000 and then another 200 for that
box. That's probably going to be bigger
than that. Um, more than just our match,
but 200 will take a a bite out of it.
So,
>> but even to see like the cost of a
sidewalk project, our match is small. I
know. Still
>> it's amazing that it costs that much to
>> it. It it it is and and I think some of
it too is that is one of the grants. The
bike ped grant is a three to five year
grant. I'm not a big fan of those
because generally what happens is you
have to go through NEA. So you're
looking for everything. I mean, there's
wetlands and bats and arrowheads and,
you know, it's just it's a lot to get
through and you need an engineer to do
it and and so a lot of it is I would
like to see the state give us more
construction money, you know what I
mean? But a lot of it when you get these
grants comes with these hoops. So, you
pay a lot of engineering up front and
then and we see that with a sidewalk
project, the engineering and the, you
know, construction are going to be
fairly close. The other one we have is
Falcon Drive. That's also the same, you
know, process. But I think because we
had a 30% design from Duboce and King
and then we hired them again, I feel
like that might be a little more
manageable. But it it's tough because it
takes a lot of manpower too to like the
sidewalk project. We have Duboce and
King. We have the construction company.
Um, I paid Two Rivers because they're
our municipal project manager and we had
to pay GPI. We the grant required us to
hire another company to be to be the
on-site construction manager. So, you
know,
>> not a lot of construction workers.
>> I'm over there the other day like losing
my mind and they're like I pay all these
people but you know they wanted to work
on a Saturday and I said no more
Saturdays. you're not working in hours
that are available to you that you know
you the contracts is 7:00 to 5:00 and
you're getting here at 8:00 and leaving
at 4:00 and and my other thing was
clothing is not optional on a website.
You know, I go by and people are there
with no shirts on, you know, there's
standards for safety and stuff. So, I
don't know. I just feel like those
grants are
that's a lot of money to pay out that's
not construction. Like I feel like we
could have built if they just if we just
had construction money could have built
a sidewalk at Randolph for that, you
know, amount of money. So I do I
understand their point, but I'm also
just feel like sometimes it's too much.
So I guess I'm saying right away I'm not
really going to be quick to
write for another like bike pad grant
those. They're just it's a lot,
>> you know, I feel like. But but anyways,
yes, the spreadsheet is just to keep you
guys informed like where we're at with
and um you know trying to do it kind of
and that's how we do it. The supplement
that's right as many grants as we can,
>> right?
>> And you're doing a good job.
>> Well, we're trying we do what we can
and that's it. I think
>> no I will be here on the board.
>> I did not know that. Neither will I.
>> And I need to make sure that I have this
because I will have my computer with me,
but I'm going to be in Montana.
>> So am I.
>> Are you going together?
>> No.
I will be in
>> taking your family.
>> So will I?
>> They're going to be at a bar
on
>> I will meet you guys there.
>> Huh?
>> Are you gonna be here on the 14th then?
>> Oh, we're going out.
>> No, I'm gonna meet the guys at a bar in
Boseman. Oh, he's you're gonna meet the
guys at a bar.
>> I've got I've got three or four days.
I'll be out there 15 days. We're doing
Cameron. We're doing Belgrade. We're
doing
>> You got anything else, Ben?
>> Motion to adjourn.
>> So, where are you? Are you standing in
Idaho?