Video summary
Alain de Botton addresses the challenge of healing a negative inner voice, suggesting that these critical thoughts are often artifacts inherited from society rather than authentic self-generated insights. He proposes using sentence completion exercises as a diagnostic tool to uncover where one's beliefs originate; when individuals complete prompts like "Men are..." or "Life is...", they frequently reveal deep-seated stories absorbed from the past, culture, or trauma. De Botton argues that while we are indeed interpenetrated by society—evident in the language we use and even our biology—we possess a capacity for self-authorship to distinguish between what was imposed on us and what truly represents our values. The goal of maturity is not to reject all external influence but to engage in an editing process where one consciously chooses which societal inputs to keep, thereby separating the "better us" from compensatory mechanisms formed by past experiences. The journey toward individuation involves a delicate balance between retaining childlike authenticity and navigating adult expectations, illustrated vividly through anecdotes about Picasso's artistic evolution and Philip Pullman's *His Dark Materials*. De Botton notes that children are remarkably authentic because they lack the social conditioning of adults who often wish to conform at age fourteen. He recounts how young Picasso painted like Raphael while his peers drew "Mommy," a skill he lost as an adult until late in life, highlighting that an adult returning to childlike expression is fundamentally different from a child's natural state due to accumulated depth and experience. This concept mirrors the protagonist Lyra's arc in *His Dark Materials*, where she possesses the ability to read the Alethiometer immediately but loses it upon hitting puberty; her eventual return to understanding represents moving through stages of unconscious incompetence, conscious competence, and finally a deeper mastery earned over a lifetime. A significant philosophical distinction is drawn between Western and Eastern approaches to wisdom, particularly regarding simplicity versus complexity in expression. De Botton observes that the West often equates depth with dense, inaccessible language, whereas Eastern traditions like Japanese poetry suggest profound meaning arises from collaboration between the reader and the work rather than just the text itself. If a simple saying seems empty to a Western mind, it may be because they are not bringing their full self into the interaction with the idea. This perspective challenges the notion that profundity requires obscurity; instead, true depth is found in how one engages with simple concepts over time. The speaker emphasizes that this collaborative process allows for a realization where meditating on existence reveals the world as an interconnected circle rather than isolated grains of sand. Ultimately, de Botton concludes that life's most exciting journey involves choosing specific areas to individuate while accepting limitations in others, acknowledging that no one can be fully unique across every domain like clothing or food preferences. The path from being swayed by societal norms to exercising agency is a lifelong effort where the depth of knowledge gained eventually surpasses initial simplicity. He encourages listeners to recognize their own conditioning without feeling diminished by it, understanding that even our most basic thoughts are shaped by generations before us yet remain open to conscious revision. By accepting this interpenetration while actively sifting through inherited values, individuals can cultivate a more friendly inner voice and achieve a mature form of self-authorship that honors both their history and their chosen identity.
Read the full video transcript
what's your advice for how people can
heal a negative inner voice we've got
this odd artifact that we've carried
with us this inheritance of our life but
kind of almost some previous life of
ours Y where should people begin if they
want to have a more friendly inner
voice such a good question I'd say you
have to start by finding the inner voice
because it doesn't announce itself as an
inner voice so how are we going to you
know we're not we're not talking here
about literally hearing voices some
people do but we're not talking about
that here what we're talking about is a
way of speaking to yourself a way of you
know way of conducting yourself in your
own mind that owes more to something
from outside than from inside and that
is more negative or we can put it this
way unfair to you and your chances your
hopes Etc so how do we how do we detect
this is even going on because I don't
think it's necessarily obvious here I
think that it's quite helpful to get
people to do what I call sentence
completion exercises where you start off
with a St
sentence and then you have an ellipsis
dot dot dot so men are women are life is
I am I want if dot dot dot because dot
dot dot and you say to people right
here's a list these
things without thinking too much right
important important prompt without
thinking too much just say the first
thing comes into your head men are women
are life is I am Etc um or or even
beginnings of stories story completion
exercises when I meet someone that I dot
dot dot just finish finish that sentence
and what people will come out with is
fascinating they'll go you know men are
cruel wow wow wow men are cruel are they
you know person might even be surprised
that they've said
that then you say okay where's that come
from where what what led you to believe
that and often what you'll find is a
story that owes more to something
outside than something inside you know
or um you know when when I meet someone
what will happen is dot dot dot you know
um they'll be very friendly to me then
they'll turn against me wow wow where
did that come
from it's it's going to be a specific
story in the past that you know is is
being carried forward isn't it
interesting that we're talking about
maybe the thing people identify with
most you know the texture of their own
experience the landscape of their of
their inner mind but you're then saying
well this may not fully be
self-generated this might be something
which you've absorbed from the past from
society from Norms from cultures from
the way that you've compensated for past
traumas Etc just habits yeah but it
brings up an interesting question which
is okay so who are you where are you in
this are you that voice in some ways you
are because you're inex linked to all of
the experiences you've had yeah but then
we have this sort of transcendent us
which is better it's the better us if
only I could it's the me without the
compensation the trauma the ETC such a
good question you know we're not there
sometimes this idea of you know the real
me that is separate from everybody else
we are penetrated by Society you know
think of how we're speaking right we're
using words as we speak to one another
every one of those words is both spoken
by us and was made by other people long
before we were even a rumor in anyone's
mind right we are we are penetrated by
Society every one of the words that I am
using is the result of generations and
generations of people who've used those
words refined their meaning Etc and then
given them to me so that's literally the
language we're permeated by social
language um even our biology as we know
you our gut bacteria is you know both us
and not us so the the neat you know
Chris Al we are we are these sort of um
you know entities where you can put a
strict circle around now we're we're
we're interpenetrated by Society biology
history uh you know Etc so then the
question comes well is there anything
you know that's that's more me less me
and I think here absolutely absolutely
and I think
that one of the journeys you know life's
full of Journeys one of the journeys
that I think we all are on is to start
to separate out a little bit well what I
I can understand there's a lot in me
that was just put there by Society by
the context in which I was
born which of those bits do I want to
keep or focus on and which of those bits
do not fully represent you know my
values my considered choices Etc and
this is where life gets interesting
because people start to say things like
where I come from normal meant dot dot
dot but the more I think think about it
the more I'm reflecting on who I really
am the more I want to ditch that and
that and that is a form of editing uh
process
self-authorship absolutely
and you know I think that the more
mature someone is I'll use that word I
could have used others um the more
mature someone is the more what they do
what they think uh the values they hold
owe more to their own work their own
sifting their own editing than it does
to the context that they were born into
um I think you know it's interesting if
if you look at the Arc of a life right a
a very small child is often remarkably
authentic which is why we adults in
small doses at least have such a great
time with little ones because they they
come out with stuff and you think oh my
God I can't believe they've just said
that thing you know they've just said
that Granny's nose is too big or that
this restaurant's boring or this very
expensive thing is a load of rubbish you
know Etc they'll come out with stuff
that is non-normative and that's very
interesting because as an adult you
recognize a kind of you know you
recognize your own spontaneity that's
been lost normally so it's kind of
Bittersweet you think o you know you
don't want exactly the child's version
of it because that would lead you into
trouble but you want an adult version
and it's very hard to get and and and
probably the high Watermark of the
opposite is when you're 14 and a half
and you're at school and you're most
fervent wish is to be like everybody
else you you want your parents to be
like everybody else you want your name
to be like everybody else you want your
appearance your haircut Etc you cannot
bear difference and then slowly slowly
you you individuate you know um and and
that's a very
exciting Journey
seeing I don't think anyone everyone
sorry anyone individuates in all areas
so I think the first choice is what are
the areas that matter a lot to you um
I'm interested in in idation but when it
comes to clothes you might have noticed
um I kind of you know it's a really
interesting area but I just just leaving
that one for another time you know I'm
just not engaging with that um similarly
food fascinating area you know very
interesting yeah not quite on my radar
yet but you know other areas what I'm
reading very you know opinionated very
individual so I don't think all of us
can do it in all areas but we choose and
that's also part of what makes someone
an
individual I love the idea of uh
children being unencumbered by sort of
expectation in that way and uh yeah
trying to find the balance between what
would the mature childlike version of
ourselves do or say in this moment where
we found ourselves
too swayed by the opinions of others by
Expectations by societal Norms Etc do
you remember that story of Picasso who
was going around an art school like
little kids were doing art
and some kid was s scrolling you know
Mommy whatever and and this kid was
seven and he Picasso said famously when
I was this when I was his age I was
painting like Raphael you know one of
the great Renaissance artist and it was
sort of true I mean young Picasso um and
then he went and it's taken me all my
life to remember how to paint like this
unreal um now he didn't you know an
adult painting like a child is not a
child painting like a child it's
something different you know which is
why people go oh a child could have done
that well when a child does it it's one
thing and when an adult does it it's
another thing and I think it's quite
different and I think that's why you
know when you look at Picasso and there
are lots of artists and lots of figures
you could sort draw that analogy with
but you know when you're looking a a
painting that Picasso did when he was 90
what 90 you know at the end of his life
and it it's got elements of stuff that a
child might do but it's gone through you
know that this guy has been doing so
much other stuff so he's got deeper
reasons did you ever read his dark
materials by Philip pman no okay uh
Trilogy of children's books ostensibly I
guess uh this was my favorite series
when I was a kid uh and in it the
protagonist Lyra um finds this truth
teller uh it's called an leomer and for
some reason uh this particular device it
takes an entire lifetime of study to be
able to read it and as a child she can
do it immediately so it's this beautiful
and it's the first time I ever thought
about it and pulman takes you through
unconscious incompetence to unconscious
competence to conscious incompetence to
conscious competence love it and one of
the final scenes of the entire book at
the very very end uh she goes back to
the uh uh nunery where she was being
raised 5 years ago before the Story
begins and uh she's lost the ability to
read it she hits puberty and it's kind
of this fall it talks about kind of the
awareness that her and her partner now
have and says I can't read it anymore
and the nun turns to her and she says uh
my dear it's going to take you an entire
lifetime but the depth of knowledge you
have will be greater than it ever was
before and it's that Arc unconscious
incompetence unconscious competence
conscious incompetence conscious
competence and that finishing side
something that's been earned yeah you
found your way there through effort
agency self-authorship is um yeah yeah
it's it's it's special yeah and I think
you know it's it's interesting isn't it
when
when people whove read a lot thought a
lot Etc come out with stuff and it
sounds very very simple and I think our
society gets a bit puzzled by that
because the the sort of obvious respect
goes to people that speak in a very
dense way and you can't quite understand
what they mean so you know philosophy
discipline I started out in you know the
heroes there or people like Vicken Stein
or um Hegel K Etc very very hard not
access to make Headway and then you know
you turn to the east you look at Eastern
philosophy um you look at the Poetry of
someone like baso in um Japan medieval
Japan it's so simple it's you know it's
four words on a piece of paper and um
very easy to go mumbo jumbo or or or or
child's play
whatever and to be kind of mature enough
to go okay I'm going to bear with the
anxiety that this is very simple
sounding simple sounding
um in the East the idea is that um
poetry for example can sound very very
simple the point is that it's
interaction between the reader and the
work so not everything is in the poem or
the saying you bring yourself to it and
therefore the ultimate impact of that
work is a collabor ation between you and
the work fascinating so the Western View
might be go there's not that much in
there uh and it's the artist's fault
it's your job um whereas in East views
well it's a collaboration so if you're
not seeing anything it's because you're
not bringing enough of yourself so very
interesting to get you know lots of the
Arts I me think of that Eno you know in
in in uh you know just a circle this is
the whole of Life whole of life it's
just you know you're just doing a circle
with your your
and um amazing amazing the the courage
to say okay we're going to go with this
we're going to you know the whole of
existence is this circle and if you
meditate profoundly enough on this you
will see the world not just in a grain
of sand but in a circle Etc and we
really meet a fault line here in the
western understanding of depth and
profundity where this takes a bit of
time for the Western mind to kind of get
scripts of that we're like come is this
a joke are they you know they just
pedaling as something yeah probably not
trust really is everything when it comes
to supplements a lot of Brands may say
they're top quality but few can actually
prove it which is why I'm such a massive
fan of momentos they make the highest
quality supplements on the planet if
you've been struggling with your Sleep
Quality their sleep packs are one of my
favorite products which I use every
single night before I go to bed they
contain only the most evidence-based
ingredients a perfect doses to help you
fall asleep more quickly stay asleep
throughout the night and wake up feeling
more rested and r vitalized in the
morning they come pre-loaded in little
pouches which means if you're on the
road if you're traveling or if you just
can't be bothered fishing around inside
of all of your different pots on an
evening it's perfect I've got them with
me here while I've been in London I've
been using them every single night
they're phenomenal they really really
improve my sleep also there is a 30-day
money back guarantee so you can buy it
completely risk-free try it and if you
do not like it for any reason they will
give you your money back plus they ship
internationally right now you can get up
to 20% off everything sitewide by going
to the link in the description below or
head to liv.com slod wisdom using the
code modern wisdom a checkout that's l i
v m o n t us.com slod wisdom and modern
wisdom a checkout thank you very much
for tuning in if you enjoyed that clip
with Alan you love the full length 2hour
long podcast which I've been waiting
over 10 years to do by going right here