Video summary
The podcast opens with a discussion on how artificial intelligence (AI) and digital editing are fundamentally altering our perception of reality, using Alicia Keys' performance at the Super Bowl as a prime example. The speaker notes that while her voice initially cracked during a live piano solo, post-event recordings available online show a perfectly tuned vocal track, suggesting retroactive fixes were applied to erase this historical moment from public memory. This phenomenon extends beyond mere autotuning; it represents a dangerous capacity for AI to misrepresent history by erasing the present and rewriting recorded events. The speaker expresses concern that as these technologies become more sophisticated, distinguishing between authentic recordings and manipulated media becomes nearly impossible without specialized assistance, thereby threatening the integrity of historical records. This erosion of truth is compounded by shifts in journalistic standards and the rise of generative AI tools like ChatGPT and large language models (LLMs). Historically, credibility relied on named sources and rigorous verification processes; however, modern outlets now frequently publish stories based on anonymous information, making it difficult for individuals to verify clips seen on platforms like X or YouTube. The speaker argues that while the goal of search engines is to reduce friction in finding answers, this convenience often comes at the cost of accuracy. When AI provides quick but potentially incorrect summaries, users are less inclined to conduct their own research because the path of least resistance favors accepting convenient information over verifying facts through time-consuming investigation. The conversation then shifts to the mechanics of deception and why telling the truth remains inherently easier than lying, a principle emphasized during intelligence operations in the field. The speaker recounts advice from former bosses who encouraged admitting mistakes immediately rather than covering them up, noting that punishing individuals for errors only disincentivizes honesty. In an interrogation context, liars must expend significant mental energy maintaining consistent falsehoods and remembering conflicting details they have invented, whereas truth-tellers can simply recount events without fear of contradiction. However, the speaker warns that technology is shrinking this gap; AI now allows propagandists to generate disinformation campaigns with unprecedented speed and efficiency compared to old methods like cultivating networks of sympathetic journalists or creating memes manually. The scale of modern misinformation has evolved from labor-intensive operations involving human creators into highly automated systems capable of targeting specific demographics across social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok. The speaker references the Cambridge Analytica scandal as a precursor where targeted ads were used to sway voters by exploiting psychological vulnerabilities, but notes that current AI capabilities allow for the creation of thousands of fictional personas with followers who amplify fake narratives automatically. This acceleration means that state actors such as Russian or Chinese intelligence agencies can now deploy elaborate disinformation campaigns much more effectively than in previous decades, potentially influencing upcoming elections globally. Ultimately, the podcast concludes that while we cannot eliminate human nature's tendency to consume information passively and follow paths of least resistance, society must recognize that this problem is accelerating rapidly. The ability for bad actors to create deepfakes or bot-generated content has reached a point where it will inevitably impact future political landscapes worldwide, not just in the US. As AI continues to dominate content creation—potentially making human-authored posts rare within five years—the burden falls on individuals and institutions to navigate an environment where verifying truth requires more effort than ever before. The speaker suggests that without significant changes in how we approach information consumption and verification, the integrity of our shared reality will continue to be compromised by these powerful technological tools.
Read the full video transcript
did you see what happened with the Super
Bowl where Alicia Key's voice broke and
then they went back and retroactively
fixed her voice do you see this no I I
you know I did not the Giants were not
in the Super Bowl so I didn't watch it
right well look you missed you missed
Alicia Keys very good performance Usher
fantastic dancer still pretty ripped um
Alicia ke's voice broke on the first
note of this piano solo thing that she
was doing but if you go back and watch
the Super Bowl's recording of it on
YouTube her voice is perfect
W and this has been I look Alicia Keys
is not the Vanguard of us rewriting
history but you can certainly see
between AI being able to
misrepresent how history would have been
this sort of erasing of history and
rewriting of the present and then this
retroactive changing and even if it's
just a little bit with regards to
someone's voice this is different to
autotuning a song this is a record of
what happened in history right and and I
think I I'm this is starting to get
quite worrying like I ER on the side of
non-c conspiracism but yeah this is
starting to get a bit I don't like the
doors that are being opened to you well
and I think there's there are some uh
mechanisms that are and companies that
are trying to uh or have been trying to
get outad of the curve I'm not sure that
that's that's possible right now but um
you have to it's it's like it's like the
old days you you'd read an article in
newspaper and you think okay that's very
interesting well you know but is it true
right I mean so what's the basis for
this you know and used to be one of the
defenses was sources would be named
right you couldn't write an article you
you wouldn't get it published if it was
based on Anonymous sources well now
that's not true anymore New York Times
will publish a front page article on the
you know top half based on Anonymous
sources and so you're trying to verify
something right and and you push that
forward to today and you say okay well
now I'm trying to
verify um a a clip that I'm seeing on on
X right or on YouTube or something and
how do you do that because the ability
to manipulate video abil and
audio is remarkable right there's
there's you almost impossible to tell
the difference basically without some
assistance and so there's companies out
there that are trying to ensure that you
are basically imprinting actual the the
truth right so you take video and
that is the the original source and it's
it's imprinted in the in the code that
says this is the the date the time the
location and so you can verify that
what's being said by that political
candidate or whomever right on that in
on that Podium is accurate because then
you may see a day later you may see the
same clip but it's been altered aot
tuned and yeah autotuned and so there
are some companies out there that are
working to do that to to prevent deep
fakes but it's it's very difficult
because you're relying on people's
curiosity and um and them having the
interest right to pursue to make sure
that what they're seeing and most people
don't either they don't have the time or
they don't have the patience or the
interest well the point with chat GPT
and these llms and Ai and search engines
is to reduce the friction from getting
where you are to where you want to be in
terms of understanding in terms of
whatever it is that you're searching for
right and the fact that it's friction
is precisely where the attraction lies
it's the convenience and all the rest of
stuff right and if you could imagine a
world in which the most convenient route
also bakes in uh lack of accuracy so it
goes look you can find this out in 3
seconds but there's a a
accuracy yes EXA precisely you could be
a little bit wrong either way or you can
do your own research it's going to take
you a day and a half and you're going to
know what actually happened where were
people
to do of course of course and the thing
is you have the opportunity it is more
effortful to not portray the truth it
takes more effort to do that now it's
less convenient but it takes more effort
to lie than it does to tell the
truth well
um yeah that but that but that that Gap
that difference between lying and
telling the truth is is shrinking right
because of the technology because of the
access to to be able to do this so um
you know and and but you're right I mean
if you just if you pair it back to just
s of the human nature right if you're
you know but that's why if you're being
interrogated you know you got to stick
to the truth for the most part right you
want to stay as close to the truth as
possible obviously without veering off
into something that's going to get your
ass kicked but um the idea being because
otherwise if you if you're lying you got
to keep building on that you got to keep
remembering and then you spend all your
time thinking okay where was okay what
did I say there I said that and then I
said that and if you're dealing in an
interrogation situation you know and
that's what you're counting on you're
counting on if that person's lying to me
at some point they're going to get
confused right and they're going to
start mixing up that story and
particularly if you you know in the old
days you've got the ability for sleep
deprivation or whatever it is right you
can start messing with their mind a
little bit then yes that's that's what
you're counting on but so you're
absolutely right in the sense that lying
is much more difficult aside from the
fact that you know usually if you make a
mistake right the best we we were taught
this at the agency right as as as being
out in the field in operations I
remember uh one of my first uh bosses
told me when I landed on site before I
went and and off to do whatever I was
doing he said you know if anything
happens if you make a mistake just come
tell me we we'll sort it out right but
just just tell me smartest thing right
you can do to empower um young people
with responsibility who are given
responsibility to know that if they make
a mistake come forward with it tell them
and sure enough you know because of you
know operations in the agency out in the
field sometimes things happen so you
know and he was good to his word right
we had a bit of a goat rope and you know
it it worked out but you got to be able
to do that you got to be able to show
it's not enough to say Hey you make a
mistake come tell me we'll fix it you
know if you kick their ass when they
come Adit a mistake then you've you dis
incentivize yeah exactly so you got to
you got to follow through
but you're so you're right sense yeah
telling it's always the truth telling
the truth is always the easiest path
right but I guess my point being is in
the world of disinformation now if your
job is is propaganda or misinformation
or disinformation it's becoming a lot
easier right and a lot quicker a lot
more efficient right to create that then
in the old days if you were going to do
a propaganda campaign right change
hearts and Minds in some country right
that you're you're trying to sway the
people you I'm not talking about
overthrowing the government
you know those good old days are
gone so I'm sorry that's not true we
never did that sort of thing come on um
but the point being is that you had that
was a lot of work right because what
were you doing you were using old media
technology right you were finding
journalists who might be inclined for
whatever reason to write articles in a
certain tone right and you create a
network of them and you'd kind of pepper
the the country with you know this this
narrative and you'd build on that and
hope that you having in the impact
[ __ ] much easier now are you kidding
me think about you you remember
Cambridge analytica remember that so you
know targeted um memes and and ads that
were truned into cohorts and we have the
uh maybe Hillary is a non- US citizen
maybe Hillary is a you know all
different ways that this gets split up
you had all of these different uh um
vulnerabilities and vectors of attack
but there was still a person making a
meme or making an advert or whatever so
there was still human labor getting in
the way of the rapidity of this whereas
now you have both the ability for AI to
deliver it in a targeted Manner and also
to create it so you you can have Mike
Baker profile on Facebook or Instagram
or Tik Tok or whatever and it's who
wouldn't want that no one wants that at
all but and it's just you that it's
targeted at so yeah I think uh yet
increasingly we're going to
see real information original sources
you know maybe there'll be a way where
uh being an actual person on social
media will be a a rarity in the next
five years maybe humans are going to be
it's 99% of content will be created by
Bots and every so often you'll see a
tweet from you or or someone else that's
real yeah and it's look if if you're if
you're talking about a a a state right
if you're talking about um creating
something that's going to going to get
past the scrutiny of of um you know
Chinese Intel or Russian Intel or
something yeah then you're you're
working your ass off right you're
creating a very hard back stopped
elaborate elaborate cover um and it it's
it's a lot of work but for the average
person out there if what you're trying
to do is influence a campaign or you're
trying to do you know creating
10,000 uh fictional characters you know
saying interesting things out there who
then you know it's it's like the old
concentric circles who then get 5,000
followers each and then it's I I guess
but again it all comes down to the same
problem right we can talk about all the
you know the things you can do but it's
individuals right it comes down to each
person saying to themselves is what I'm
reading or hearing or watching true you
know and and I don't know how you you
impact that right because human nature
being what it is we're just you know
we're we're consuming [ __ ] and then
moving on path of least resistance yeah
path of leas resistance and and to be
fair most people are just trying to put
food on the table or take care of their
kids or whatever they're doing and so
you can't ask them to spend a lot of
time scrutinizing I don't have to time
to be my own personal Snopes every
single thing ex seeo it's not going to
happen I again so I think that
there's you know there there's a there's
always going to be this this uh this
this problem and not to say that it
hasn't always existed right but I I do
think the acceleration is pretty
impressive right the speed of which you
can create this this this fake right
this deep fake or or this Persona that
pushes information out there whatever it
may be and uh the speed with which
people are willing to consume it and
pass it along right so that's something
we're going to be battling I think for a
while and and it will it impact this
upcoming election of course it will and
and future elections right why wouldn't
you if I'm if I'm Russian intelligence
or Chinese intelligence or the Iranians
or who anybody who's got the resources
why wouldn't I try to [ __ ] with the US
yeah right so or or the UK or really
it's not it's again it's not just a
us-centric problem in other news this
episode is brought to you by surf shark
browsing the internet without a VPN is
like going for a walk in a muddy field
without any shoes on you can do it but
it's ill advised and you might catch
something you can protect your browsing
online and get access to the entire
world's Netflix library for less than
the price of a cup of coffee per month
if you're someone that works off public
Wi-Fi networks like cafes or libraries
or airports the internet administrator
can see all of the traffic going back
and forth between your devices and the
internet and that is Tre bad you do not
want this also your internet service
provider is able to see all of your
traffic and then sell it to companies
that can Target you with ads websites
are split testing you for prices on
products that you're already buying and
even flight websites are doing this too
so to protect yourself from all of this
plus to access the entire world's
Netflix Library you can do that right
now with one membership and it's across
unlimited devices you can have it across
your laptop your iPad your phone and
even your smart TV you can get an 83%
discount plus 3 months free by going to
the link in the description below or
heading to Surf shark.
deod wisdom that's surfshark dodeals
slod wisdom thank you very much for
tuning in if you enjoyed that clip with
Mike you will love the fulllength 2 and
1 half hour long podcast which is
available right here go
on there it is