Video summary
The video explores the critical distinctions between burnout, secondary traumatic stress (STS), and vicarious trauma (VT), clarifying that while these terms are often used interchangeably, they stem from different causes and manifest uniquely. Burnout is primarily driven by occupational strain and unreasonable demands, whereas VT arises from a deep empathetic connection with clients' trauma, and STS results from knowing about a traumatizing event without direct interaction. Clinicians may progress through stages starting as optimistic new hires, moving into a "rescuer" phase where they attempt to fix clients, and eventually shifting to doing the bare minimum due to exhaustion, which can precipitate burnout or VT. This progression highlights how the nature of clinical work can itself be traumatizing, necessitating a trauma-informed lens to recognize these risks and implement careful case assignments for vulnerable employees.
The impact of these conditions is multifaceted, affecting individuals across physical, behavioral, intrapersonal, emotional, cognitive, and spiritual domains. Physically, symptoms include sleep disturbances, increased pain sensitivity, gut microbiome disruption, hormonal changes, and hypervigilance. Behaviorally and interpersonally, clinicians may experience over-involvement or withdrawal from clients, reduced trust in humanity, impatience, irritability, and social isolation from peers. Internally, they often suffer from reduced self-efficacy, an obsession with regaining control, lowered self-esteem, and feelings of hopelessness regarding their societal impact. Emotionally and cognitively, these individuals face anger, depersonalization, emotional numbing, executive dysfunction, difficulty concentrating, pessimism, intrusive thoughts, and cognitive rigidity. Spiritually and environmentally, this manifests as a loss of meaning in work and a diminished sense of safety, while risk factors include personal trauma history, high stress loads, close identification with victims, lack of social support, low resilience, and denial of impacts.
Organizational and individual protective factors play a vital role in mitigating these risks, ranging from radical acceptance of client choices and one's own limits to utilizing emotion regulation techniques like breathing and vagus nerve activation. Strategies such as self-compassion, mindfulness of personal resources, hardiness focusing on controllable aspects of life, connection to meaningful goals, varied work activities, realistic goal setting, active consultation, processing grief, and advocating for systemic change are essential. Addressing workload distribution is particularly critical; overloading senior therapists while underloading newer ones with easier cases burns out experienced staff, whereas spreading case acuity and intensity across the team allows senior therapists to mentor less experienced colleagues effectively. Supportive organizational activities like wellness fairs, debriefing groups, adequate supervision, and ensuring stable expectations further safeguard against burnout and injury.
Ultimately, both burnout and secondary traumatic stress lead to increased turnover and poorer patient outcomes, requiring joint prevention efforts between clinical staff and organizations. The video emphasizes that empathizing with clients' traumatic experiences can itself be traumatic, advising viewers to utilize mini breaks and self-care before the next session. A powerful example illustrates how a supervisor's support, such as reducing workload during personal crises like divorce or a child's NICU stay, significantly aids coping mechanisms. By acknowledging that counseling and social work regularly expose staff to trauma, organizations must foster an environment where employee dissatisfaction is addressed constructively, environmental safety is promoted through education, and the unique needs of at-risk employees are met to ensure sustainable clinical practice.
Read the full video transcript
I'd like to welcome everybody to today's
presentation on addressing secondary
traumatic stress and vicarious trauma.
I'm your host, Dr. Donnisee Snipes.
Today, we're going to distinguish
secondary traumatic stress, vicarious
trauma, and burnout. Burnout is not the
same thing. Interestingly enough, we use
those terms interchangeably,
but they're not necessarily the same
thing.
We'll identify sources of secondary
traumatic stress and vicarious trauma
for clients, significant others, and
therapists and identify risk factors for
vicarious trauma and then obviously what
to do about it.
Burnout is a condition that results from
occupational strain. When your job is
just pulling you six different
directions, making unreasonable demands,
giving you case loads that are just
incredibly difficult that can lead to
burnout. However, we need to remember
that people don't exist in a vacuum. So,
what constitutes occupational strain?
What constitutes a really difficult work
environment for one person is different
than what constitutes occupational
strain for another person partly based
on how much stress they've got going on
in the rest of their life. Going back to
that stress bucket, the person who has a
relatively empty stress bucket can
handle more
crap at work than somebody whose stress
bucket is already half full.
Trauma is the direct experience or
witnessing of a traumatic event.
Traumatic stress is the stress response
to a direct trauma.
Traumatic injury refers to the ways the
traumatic stress continues to negatively
impact any piece of your life. People
can experience a trauma and have
traumatic stress and resolve that stress
without developing
additional
um traumatic injury symptoms like
flashbacks and nightmares and
depersonalization.
I do like to separate that out because a
lot of people assume that when you have
been exposed to trauma that you're
naturally going to have acute stress
disorder, PTSD, what have you. And
that's not true.
Vicarious trauma and secondary traumatic
stress are often used interchangeably in
the literature. Okay, that's fine.
However,
when we get down to literal definitions,
vicarious trauma occurs when the person
experiences the trauma through
empathetic connection. We are
connecting with our patients in session
and we are getting into the well with
them so deeply so to speak that we start
experiencing
distress.
And I have talked about empathy and
sympathy before, but for those of you
who haven't heard the analogy, um,
empathy is when you see somebody down in
a dark, cold well, they're scared and,
you know, they just really want help.
You can't get them out. But what you can
do possibly is strap on some repelling
gear and go down into the well to sit
with them. What's the difference? You
can pull yourself out before you get
overwhelmed. You can pull yourself out
before you get hypothermic.
You have the ability to pull yourself
out before you start experiencing
significant traumatic stress and
possibly traumatic injury. But vicarious
trauma comes from empathetic connection.
Secondary traumatic stress is the stress
response resulting from knowing about a
traumatizing event experienced by
another. And again, see, you can see how
these can overlap. If you're
empathizing, then you obviously know
about it. But you can also know about a
traumatic event such as um the survivors
of Hurricane Katrina or Hurricane Harvey
or you know name a disaster. We saw it
on television. We saw the people. We saw
the suffering. And some people really
were impacted
internally by seeing that distress. they
could put themselves in that person's
position. So, they were kind of
empathizing, but it wasn't like you were
interacting with the person. Ultimately,
we're kind of splitting hairs here, but
I did want to clarify the definitions.
Compassion fatigue. Oops, I'm sorry.
Secondary traumatic stress occurs in
approximately 11.29%
of people. It's not an uncommon thing to
happen. And so one out of every 10
peopleish
may experience secondary traumatic
stress. Think back to 9/11. Think back
to Katrina. Think back to some other
disaster. Um even the hurricane and of
course I blocked it out of my mind. Uh
the name of the hurricane that hit North
Carolina and Tennessee.
Seeing the suffering and feeling
helpless to
do anything to improve or help relieve
the suffering
can be maddening, especially because we
were
trained, we went into this field because
we wanted to relieve suffering. And it
can be devastating to feel like you're
stuck on the sidelines.
Vicarious traumatization can be measured
sort of by the vicarious traumatization
questionnaire which assesses the
person's current level of
secondary traumatic stress. See, I told
you these words get kind of lumped
together.
The VTQ
measures physical and behavioral
responses, emotional responses,
cognitive responses, and life beliefs.
That's great. It doesn't measure
interpersonal and in intrapersonal
behaviors such as withdrawal.
Environmental and spiritual impacts of
the trauma are also not measured. I
think that's important that we consider,
but the VTQ is currently the preeminent
assessment for vicarious trauma. I did
look for
over an hour, maybe longer than that, to
try to find a PDF of the VTQ and I could
not find it. It is used regularly in the
research, so it exists, but you're
probably not going to run into it. Um,
my point in including it is to let you
know that there is a questionnaire out
there and,
you know, you might be able to find it.
when we talk about burnout. Um, and this
can also apply to secondary traumatic
stress.
It's important to recognize it doesn't
happen overnight. And this model was
taken from the police trauma stress
disorder literature. and which was kind
of neat because I got to go back into my
dissertation from 2000 to pull out some
research and you know uh but with law
enforcement they start out as a rookie.
They are optimistic. They're going to
save the world.
Obviously they went in to help people.
After a little while they start feeling
like what they're doing is not doing any
good. So they tighten down and they
become the John Wayne. They become
badgeheavy adrenaline junkies as they
say. Um when that doesn't work because
there's always going to be crime.
There's always going to be stuff going
on. Some of them get to the point where
they feel like they're not making a
difference and they move into
professional control or what we
sometimes call retired on duty. They
just do the job. They respond to the
calls. They do what they got to do and
they move on. They are often emotionally
divorced from it.
After a while, they move into burnout
because it's just day after day of same
stuff, different day, not making a
difference. What's the point? And oh, by
the way, um we don't get a lot of
appreciation and we're not paid very
well. Okay, so that's the police trauma
stress disorder model. Let's look at it
in terms of counseling. The new
clinician, those of you who've worked
with interns or people who are working
on their postmasters hours, they are
optimistic. They are eager. They are
excited. They think they can help
everybody. And
when they realize that that's not
necessarily the case, then they may
devolve into what I labeled the rescuer.
They start trying to fix people. Instead
of allowing people to fix themselves,
they start trying to take more control,
try to fix people, try to make it work.
When that doesn't work, they uh for
everybody or enough people, they move on
to just doing the job. And this is
especially true if they've got high case
loads, especially high intensity case
loads. Eventually, it's just like I I
just I don't have the energy to deal
with 15 people that have PTSD and
borderline personality. I just don't
have it in me. So, they move into just
doing the job. I'm showing up. I'm doing
my groups. I'm doing my individuals and
my notes and I'm going home.
Over time, that's still exhausting.
They're still exposed to hearing about
trauma. They're still exposed to the
stresses at work. They're still exposed.
And it erodess their energy and their
optimism and can lead to secondary
trauma.
And we want to recognize where we're at.
I remember and I think a lot of us can
think back and remember when we were
that new clinician. We were we thought
we knew everything and we were going to
change the world and then very quickly
we found out uh-uh especially if you
worked in addictions in my opinion um it
seems like that can be sort of a more a
rder awakening in some cases because you
see people relapse and come back through
a month later, three months later. I
know I took that personally and I
started to get really down and my
supervisor in in one of our sessions we
were talking about it and he said, "All
right, what are your expectations?"
And I said, "Uh, I'm expecting to help
them move into recovery and stop using."
and he sat back and put his hands across
his belly and kind of shook his head and
laughed and said, "That's part of your
problem. You're working with people who
are often in pre-contemplation or
contemplation, and you're expecting not
only to move them into action, but
through action and into maintenance in
30 days. That's not possible. You need
to adjust your expectations."
That helped a lot for me to reduce my
stress and reduce my feelings of failure
when people would relapse. um we would
take it as a learning experience and
helped me a lot to I think to not
progress further in that burnout
secondary traumatic stress
uh whatever we're going to call it. So
let's talk about domains of impairment
and most of us can probably check these
off.
sleep disturbances. You lay down, you
start thinking about a client, be
pondering it, ruminating on it, or you
wake up in the middle of the night
thinking about a particularly difficult
case, worrying about if somebody is
safe. Um, so we start having increased
sleep disturbances and part of it is
recognizing
and setting boundaries and recognizing
the client's autonomy to make certain
decisions.
Uh, increased pain. The more stressed we
are, the more we actually feel pain. our
nosioceptive, our pain receptors become
more sensitive and we actually feel more
pain. Our gut m microbiome gets
disrupted.
Those little critters in your gut do not
like stress and as the pH in your gut
changes, so do the microbes.
There's possible alterations in your
thyroid and gonatal hormones. So you may
have less energy, you may have lower
libido, hypervigilance
may increase and this is later in the
process for a lot of people. Um but
hearing about traumas, hearing about uh
dangers that people have experienced
or traumas that people have experienced
may make you hypervigilant. Maybe you
start becoming more protective, more of
a helicopter parent over your elementary
age child because you're worried about
their safety. You start changing your
beliefs about the goodness of human
beings.
Exhaustion. Well, sleep disturbances,
increased pain, altered thyroid. Yeah,
those are all going to contribute to
exhaustion. It just it does. And when
you are ruminating, your brain uses a
lot of energy. When your brain is
constantly on, that doesn't allow it to
shut down to activate deep sleep. So,
when people are stressed, especially if
they're hypervigilant, they often have
disrupted sleep architecture and they're
not clearing out those toxins.
And some people may turn to substance or
behavioral addictions. Substance use or
misuse is obvious, I guess, but other
people may choose more socially
acceptable addictions such as shopping
or scrolling online, um getting on Tik
Tok and staying on there for 4 hours,
playing games on their mobile device for
hours on end to avoid having to think,
to avoid having to connect with other
people because they just don't have it
left in them.
Interpersonally, we may see over
involvement with the survivor, with the
client, or sometimes under involvement.
Sometimes the clinician will want to
help. They'll want to fix it. They'll
get all up in that client's business to
try to help them fix it instead of
empowering them to take the steps
themselves instead of promoting
autonomy.
Under involvement often again comes
later in the process when the therapist
just doesn't have the energy and you
know I'll hand you a list of resources,
call them if you want, whatever. Good
luck.
The reduced ability to trust others and
questioning the goodness of humanity.
Impatience. Well, if we're in pain, if
we're hypervigilant, it's hard to be
patient. It's hard to hear a client say,
"Yeah, I know I was supposed to blah
blah blah, but I didn't." And therapists
can start feeling irritable and
impatient with clients for failing or
for being resistant. Again, behavior is
communication.
Why are they not engaging in that
behavior? Um, that's a whole different
class.
and they may withdraw from peers.
[snorts]
Most of the time when people start
experiencing secondary traumatic stress,
they don't want to hear about other
people's cases. They don't want to hear
about what's going on at another agency
or what have you. It's just I'm
overloaded with what I've got to do to
do my work right now.
Intrapersonally,
there's reduced self-efficacy when
therapists are regularly hearing about
trauma, especially if they are not
feeling like they're making a difference
or not a a big enough difference, they
may have reduced self-efficacy.
Even if they are making a difference
with every single one of their clients,
just the neverending
litany of people coming in with trauma,
it feels like we can't make a dent in
improving the health and well-being of
society, which a lot of us have set as
one of those goals.
Possible obsession with regaining
control intrapersonally.
thinking about how to fix somebody's
PTSD
and reduced self-esteem. When a person
doesn't feel like they are accomplishing
what they set out to accomplish, they
may and when they start withdrawing from
others, not having energy to spend with
their kids, feeling like they're not
doing what they need to do or could do
at work anymore. That self-esteem may go
down.
Emotionally, we often see anger and
irritability devolve into
depersonalization and emotional numbing.
Cognitively, problem solving
difficulties. Well, yes. Stress. When
people are experiencing secondary
traumatic stress or burnout, which is a
form of stress, what do we know? When
the stress response is active, the
energy and resources necessary to think
clearly are being shunted from the
preffrontal cortex to other areas of the
body to help us fight or flee. So, yeah,
we're going to have executive
dysfunction and problem solving
difficulties. We're going to have
difficulty paying attention and
concentrating in session. Even if the
client is doing everything right, we may
have difficulty focusing. But especially
if the client is not doing everything we
want them to do. You know, they're not
letting us control them like puppets, we
may start to get frustrated and check
out. We start ruminating on our own
frustration. Well, if you would have
done what I told you,
if we notice we're saying that to
ourselves in session, we need to check
it. Pessimism. Cognitively, people as
they become more burnt out become more
pessimistic.
Everybody has trauma. You know, instead
of thinking, you know, maybe everybody
on my case load has trauma. people start
feeling like everybody in the world must
have trauma because that's all I see
every day. And intrusive thoughts and
images
when you've heard details of traumas
um sometimes intimate details of
traumas. It's not unusual for
you to at some point have intrusive
images. you can actually visualize
that traumatic event happening. Um, if
you saw it on TV, obviously you can
visualize that happening.
And those intrusive thoughts can
become overwhelming. They increase our
stress. They make us feel unsafe in our
own head. I mean, it's a PTSD symptom.
We know this.
Environmentally, people often experience
a reduced sense of safety. Again,
hearing about all this trauma, it feels
like the world is wildly unsafe.
Spiritually, and we don't often talk
about spiritually here, but spiritually,
as clinicians, we may experience a loss
of meaning and purpose for the job. Why
am I doing this? How is this
contributing to
me being who I want to be? How is what's
the purpose of me working going to work
and doing this? How am I making a
difference?
And when you lose meaning and purpose,
you often develop a sense of
hopelessness. And
obviously,
most people are not going to have every
symptom.
Some people are going to have one or two
symptoms that are really intense. Some
people may have 10 symptoms that are
moderate.
We're not um competing here. What's
important is to recognize when
your job, what you're doing, your
interactions with other people through
your job are negatively impacting
you. all pe any or all pieces of your
life.
Risk factors for secondary traumatic
stress. If you've got a personal history
of trauma, they've shown that it is much
more likely that you may develop
secondary traumatic stress. And there's
some neurobiology behind it regarding
the priming of the amygdala and all that
other stuff. We're not going to go into
that right now, but suffice it to say,
and a lot of us do have a personal
history of trauma, makes us more
vulnerable. It doesn't mean we can't do
the job, but we need to recognize that
we may need to give ourselves a little
more self-care.
A personal history of mental illness or
addiction. When you're hearing about
other people's mental illnesses,
traumas, addictions, it may be more
triggering for you.
Current stress load. If that stress
bucket is already filled up or mostly
filled up, then it doesn't take hearing
about much trauma. It doesn't take much
organizational stress to make your
bucket overflow.
close identification with the victim.
And this one makes sense, but we don't
talk about it a lot. If you are working
with somebody who has a child who,
heaven forbid, drowned in their swimming
pool and that child was 5 years old and
you've got a fouryear-old at home, it is
much easier for you to empathize. is you
can envision your own child in that
position. And sometimes those intrusive
thoughts, you hear about it from your
client, but then you start having
intrusive thoughts about it happening to
your own child and you're you're
superimposing,
which is super stressful. I mean, you
see your own kids struggling or
suffering and, you know, it triggers
every mama bear hormone that you've got
or papa bear hormone.
Um,
proximity to home or safe spaces. A lot
of times we like to think that bad
things happen to them and
the the trauma stays over there, the
violence stays over there, bad things
happen to them. But if your client is
talking about something that rings true
um or hits close to home, as they say,
then you're at greater risk for
secondary traumatic stress. For example,
um when I was at the University of
Florida, I always thought that colleges
were safe and you know, 9 10 o'clock at
night, I was out jogging with my
headphones on, whatever.
my my uh sophomore year, we had a serial
killer and on campus and it was
terrifying because that was supposed to
be something that happened out there,
not on our campuses. Um, when you hear
about somebody who is very similar to
you in some way, maybe they're a parent,
maybe they're a therapist, maybe they
live in a neighborhood that's similar to
yours, uh, m like if you live in a gated
community and they live in a gated
community and they're they experience a
home invasion,
then it can trigger
more of a stress response because
you feel more kinship with them in some
ways
being aware of this that's okay you know
knowing and separating I'm safe my house
is safe that's not happening now
obviously if something happens to your
neighbor yeah that's really hitting
close to home that is actually your home
space but again recognizing what aspects
are different between you and your house
and your neighbor.
Another interesting one, if you have
high empathy, which I think a lot of us
do, and perspective taking with personal
affective distress and and this is one
of those interesting things that has to
do with sort of that repelling gear,
high empathy and perspective taking. you
go down in that well, you're feeling the
cold, you're in the dark, but you know
you can get out. So, the personal
emotional distress is a lot lower. But
for somebody who actually puts
themselves into the shoes of the person,
um, sort of without the repelling gear,
it can be a lot more impactful. And
recognizing how much affective distress
you have during and after a session is
important. Some of them are going to hit
closer to home and it's and trouble you
more effectively in which case you know
you're really working that stress
response system. It's going to be
important to downregulate and
to take greater steps in self-care in
the short term. recognizing that you
burn through a whole lot of energy,
empathizing, and through your own
distress. And it's going to be important
to allow yourself to recover. Think of
it like running a marathon. You wouldn't
run a marathon and get up the next day
and think that you're going to feel
great and everything's going to be hunky
dory.
Disruption of social support. Another
risk factor. If you don't have social
support, your spouse doesn't want to
hear about it. You know, even, you know,
avoiding PHI, your spouse just isn't
interested in your job. You don't have
friends at work that you can decompress
with. You don't have adequate
supervision where you can
decompress or um downregulate,
it starts to be a problem. And we do
need to have people that we can call,
other clinicians that we can call and
run stuff by. Again, we don't have to
give out PHI, but saying, "I do have
this client and I'm going through this
right now. I'm feeling really stuck." Or
what have you,
you'd be amazed at how much it helps to
have another therapist go, "I think
you're doing everything you can." or you
know when you see them next, I wonder
what would happen if you tried this. And
that can spark an aha moment and give
you a little bit of hope when you're
feeling stuck.
People with low psychological resilience
obviously are at greater risk. If you're
already worn down and exhausted and
having difficulty bouncing back from
life, then you're going to be at greater
risk.
Regret and denial are also risk factors.
If you regret
things that you said or do with a client
or if you deny how much the
uh interactions are impacting you, it's
going to sneak up and bite you in the
butt.
Burnout can also increase susceptibility
to secondary traumatic stress due to
cognitive inflexibility and resource
depletion. If your work environment is
intense,
nice euphemism, intense, unsupportive,
uh, etc. If your work environment is one
that would stress anybody out, and
you're also seeing high acuity clients,
then it's a recipe for disaster. the
burnout work environment already fills
your stress bucket up quite a bit than
hearing the traumas having to think
because I mean it's not counseling is
not easy we don't just sit in there and
listen and go along to get along we're
thinking we're processing we're
connecting we're exploring and that
takes a lot of energy and if you've
already expended your energy getting
upset over some stupid policy change,
then you don't have energy left and
you're going to start feeling even more
vulnerable.
things that can cause burnout. High
trauma case loads and these are
structural or organizational issues.
High trauma case loads,
lack of social or organizational
support,
excess work, long hours, night or
rotating shifts. And night shifts work
against our natural circadian rhythms,
which means the person's if they keep
that schedule seven days a week, they're
still fighting their natural rhythms.
Little bit easier on them. But if they
work night shift and then on their days
off they're keeping normal hours and
then they go back to working night
shift, their circadian rhythms are
constantly screwed up and that increases
stress on the body. It increases
inflammation. It disrupts sleep
architecture. It does all kinds of stuff
to deplete your energy and your
resources and make you more vulnerable.
Rotating shifts aren't much better. Your
body likes a a steady routine. Even if
you are a spontaneous person, your body
likes to know when it's going to work,
when it's going to sleep, when it's
going to wake up. Uh if you are working
the 8 to four shift three days and the 4
to 12 shift two days,
your body's like, "Okay, we were, you
know, by 10:00 when you're at work, your
body's like, "Okay, we were supposed to
be in bed already."
Um unclear scope of work or role
ambiguity.
At my old place of work, we had
something called PODS, performing other
duties as assigned. And I think PODS
took up about 60% of our time and 40%
was spent on like actual counseling and
documentation.
Um when that happens, when you've got um
creep and other things start creeping in
that you're expected to do, you're
expected to write grants, you're
expected to
do this, that or the other, it can
start taking up a lot of time and then
you're exhausted. You know, you're
stressed all the time. There's always
stuff in the inbox. you don't feel like
you can get everything done. You don't
feel like you're giving enough energy
and time to your clients, which is the
whole reason you're there. And it starts
to wear on people.
Um, dissonance between ethics,
expectations, and actual policies.
um you're in an organization that says
every person that you assess will have a
diagnosis and will be assigned to some
sort of treatment even if it's just
adjustment disorder. Now ethically that
that's not not
um
and we need to be able to rectify that.
We need to be able to address it with
human resources, with whomever
to point out the disparity between what
the policy is and what our ethical
obligations are.
an absence of secondary traumatic stress
informed organizational activities,
self-care days, wellness fairs, um
downregulation groups. Some
organizations actually encourage
therapists to get together once a week
for an hour and just decompress and
process what's been going on. Adequate
supervision. Um, every place I've
worked, I wish I could say that was an
exaggeration, but no. Every place I
worked has lacked supervision. Even when
I was working on my postmasters hours,
if I needed Well, when I needed my
weekly supervision, I would have to go
track down my supervisor and basically
wrangle him in order to get my hour. not
because he was, you know, incompetent or
irresponsible, but because he had an
unclear scope, role ambiguity, and too
much to do already.
Uh, for a lot of people, the
supervisory stuff um especially super
supervision of, uh, postmasters interns
is something that falls under other
duties as assigned. And to do that right
takes a lot of time.
And a lack of job satisfaction. This was
number one in some studies. Even if it's
a relatively decently working
workplace,
if the individual is not experiencing
job satisfaction, if they're not
deriving meaning from it, if they're
going to work and saying, "Why am I
here?"
they are at much greater risk for
secondary traumatic stress.
So, let's talk about protective factors.
What do we do? Because this is what
you're interested in. The earlier stuff
was to help you recognize some of the
symptoms as well as identify some of the
risk factors that you may not be aware
of. All of this, I think, is super
important for your postmasters interns
because I can tell you most of them are
probably not getting this information
when they are in graduate school. And a
lot of my uh supervises
very quickly start feeling completely
overwhelmed. They're like, I can't know
everything I need to know. I can't I
don't feel like I'm ever prepared to
work with a client because I don't know
all the techniques to handle anything
that they throw at me. And you know,
backing it up and reminding them 80% of
progress is from the relationship, not
from the techniques that can help with
down reggulation. But you have to have a
a supervisor there to say that. um and
and encouraging supervisees to be aware.
Having a history of trauma or depression
or anxiety or addiction, that's not a
deal breakaker at all. In some ways it
can make you able to empathize more but
it's important that when you empathize
you still maintain that boundary and you
don't over empathize with them or take
on so much that it starts triggering
those issues again. So anyway protective
factors resolution acceptance is
protective. Well that sounds good but
what in the world does that mean?
radical acceptance.
Accepting that you've done the best you
can. You are you've provided the client
the tools and resources they need to the
best of your ability and you are
empowering them to take the next steps
recognizing that you cannot control
them. We're not paternalistic. We're not
going to tell them what to do. We're not
going to do it for them. We we need to
resolve in our own mind that we've
provided them the resources and tools
and the stuff they need and accept their
choices.
That's hard. That is really hard for me
when I first started out and I would be
working with a client and they'd be
doing really well in their in their
sobriety and then they would relapse. I
would feel like it was my fault, like I
failed them somehow. And again, we go
back to my supervisor who said who would
say, you know, tell me what you did with
them. You know, what tools did you give
them? What things did you process? Let's
look at your progress notes. and
recognizing encourage me encouraging me
to recognize that I was working with
adults who were mentally competent and I
had to accept
choices they made even if they had all
the resources and information to point
them in a different direction.
That can be protective. Being able to
step back and go, I did my God's honest
best. Emotion regulation, super
important. Being able to
slow your breathing. Remember I said
those who who are more effectively
burdened by empathy tend to be at higher
risk for secondary traumatic stress. If
you can regulate your emotions in
session, that's super helpful. But
definitely if you feel really
overwhelmed and distraught after
session, being able to take a break and
downregulate, you've got to turn that
stress response down. If you go into
your next session and your stress
response is up here, you're not going to
think clearly. You're not going to
concentrate as effectively. You're not
going to problem solve as effectively.
you may end up feeling more ineffective
and you're just burning out, burning
through all that energy. Taking that
extra time to go to the bathroom or go
to the breakroom,
go outside even even better if you can
go outside. We used to have squirrels um
on the campus that I worked at and I
would go outside and feed the squirrels.
that made me happy and helped me
downregulate and refocus.
Self-compassion can blunt the effect at
high exposure levels.
Not telling yourself, I shouldn't be
this upset about this or I should just
let this go. What would you tell a
client who was shoulding themselves?
That's not going to help. having
compassion for yourself that you're a
human being and you're noticing and
recognizing the suffering of another
human being and that's natural. It can
feel overwhelming. It can suck sometimes
but it is a natural response and you
have the ability you have the skills to
downregulate and process through.
Sometimes we have to process through and
I think I'm getting ahead of myself but
process through our own grief about we
we hear these things and we have to
grieve sometimes for the client
sometimes it changes our worldview and
we have to grieve the loss of our own
worldview. But self-compassion
tells us that that's okay.
Self-compassion tells us it's okay to
grieve. It's okay to be angry. um it's
what you're going to do with it that can
be helpful or problematic.
Being mindful of your personal needs,
limits, and resources at any given time.
What your needs, resources, and limits
are today may be different a month from
now. You know, we talked in other
classes. Most of you know that I went
through a a a spate where we had two
animals die in close succession. And my
animals are near and dear to my heart.
And I was
done. I was devastated. I kind of walked
around in a fog for about six weeks. And
knowing that my
needs, limits, and resources were com,
you know, very different then than they
are today was really important. So I
didn't push myself too hard and overstep
over overflow my stress bucket.
Hardiness, one of my favorite tools,
proposed by Kabasa in 1978,
um encourages us to focus every day,
maybe multiple times a day, on all of
the things that are important to our
rich and meaningful life. The things
that we're committed to in our life, our
family, our health, our job, our
clients, you know, whatever. Focusing on
what is important in our rich and
meaningful life. That's what we're
committed to.
Identifying what aspects of those things
we can control and using our energy,
investing our energy in the things we
can control, not the things we can't
control. That includes nurturing the
positive, not just ameliorating the
negative. And viewing obstacles as
challenges. Problems come up, they're
going to come up. viewing it as a
challenge. I have this client right now
that is seems to be on a plateau and
they don't see they seem to be very
resistant. Hate the word going to use
it. Uh resistant to doing anything to
change their situation. I feel stuck.
Okay, that's a challenge. Now, how do I
use my energy to address that in a way
that helps me move toward what's
important in my rich and meaningful
life? For me, what I would do in that
situation is talk to the client about
what's going on that's causing their
resistance? Do they not believe in the
process? Do they not see a problem? Do
they not have the skills?
[cough]
Do they just not have the internal
capacity to do one more thing right now?
Um, do they not know where to start? Or
do they not have the self confidence
that even if they did start, it would do
any good?
Connection to self, others, and
something greater was cited in the
literature. And not all of you have
faith in a higher power and I can
respect that. Um, however, connection to
your rich and meaningful life if nothing
else is important because that's where
you want to go. Those are the things
that are important and connection to
that. Everything you do uses your energy
to either move you toward that and the
things that are meaningful or away from
that.
[snorts]
varied work activities. This is
something your occ your job can do. Some
days you're doing assessment, some days
individual psychoeducational groups,
administrative work. I find for me that
I lose effectiveness in my ability to
focus after about four hours of
individual. I need to do something else.
I can do a group and then I can go back
to doing individual or what have you.
But if I do more than four hours of
individual straight, my brain is fried.
Same thing is true for assessments
because I really try to understand
what's going on in the assessment. It's
not just paperwork. And
I find that I need to finish out the day
with something else.
If your
organization
can arrange that or can allow you to
arrange that, that is super helpful. Um,
veagal control and mini breaks are
really important. Working on developing
skills where you can actually trigger
your vag nerve and downregulate.
Mini breaks are those breaks you take
throughout the day. Um, I usually do
them every time I go make a cup of
coffee while the water's warming up in
the microwave. I will practice slow
breathing or I will massage my tragus in
order to activate my vagus nerve and I
will notice how my heart rate goes down.
Going out into nature, they've shown
reduces cortisol and alters blood
pressure and everything else. That's
another thing that I do when the
weather's a little bit nicer.
But taking these mini breaks throughout
the day allows your nervous system to
downregulate. Think about driving a car.
And if you're driving a car and you
know, pedal to the metal for eight solid
hours, that engine block is going to get
pretty hot. Um, if you periodically take
breaks to allow everything to cool down,
you know, it's easier on the car, you're
not stressing it quite as much.
develop specialized skills such as EMDR
or IFS, internal family systems theory,
to
address some of the issues that your
clients bring to you that are
heavy. Um, that way you feel like you
are more equipped to address some of
those heavy issues.
Set realistic goals. And that goes back
to what I was talking about earlier.
Don't think that somebody is going to
come to you and in three weeks they're
going to be skipping down the sidewalk.
It ain't going to happen. Uh set
realistic goals. Not only does this help
you and your own sense of self-efficacy
and mental health, but it helps the
clients. If you work with clients and
you're setting a treatment plan that is
unrealistic, they are going to feel
unsuccessful, defeated, hopeless.
What is realistic for
this client and you to expect
to change? What how much progress is
realistic to expect in the next four
weeks? and really set those realistic
goals and not expect perfection, not
expect fixed.
Actively use consultation, support, and
debriefing.
if your um organization isn't about
having those meetings where people can
get together and debrief. Okay. Um there
there are a couple organizations I've
heard of that actually have a
uh debriefing line where clinicians any
any staff member um but including
clinicians can call in and talk to a
peer um anonymously and debrief what's
going on. still talking to somebody in
the organization so you don't have all
kinds of HIPPA issues, but um
that has been helpful for some. Increase
awareness of and address the grief that
you're experiencing. And remember, grief
is denial, anger, sometimes bargaining,
depression, and acceptance. And
for some of us, we deny the problems
really. We deny that what the client's
talking about is really bothering us.
You know, it's just I deal with this
every day. It's not that big of a deal.
Once you move past denial and realize
that, you know what? I'm freaking angry
that this happened to this person or
that this could happen to any person.
Okay? Recognize it. Process it.
Depression.
I feel hopeless and helpless to change
the world. I can't prevent this from
happening to everybody.
What can I do? Increasing your awareness
of how clients issues are impacting you
and sometimes organizational issues are
impacting you and
using your energy to address the
threats, address the problems in a way
that's meaningful. What aspects of it
can you control? Now, organizations are
notoriously difficult to change or to
control. However, you can potentially
make a suggestion to human resources and
make one small change that could start
the ball rolling. For example,
engage in advocacy activities. if you're
working with a lot of
um trauma victims. When I when I was
much younger, I worked for um the child
advocacy center and we had a grant for
child victims of crime and every client
that I had on my case load was a child
victim of
usually sexual abuse, but sometimes
physical abuse. and you know that that
takes a toll. Um, engaging in advocacy
activities for child welfare helped me
feel like I was doing something to
address the bigger issue, not just
the the person, the child that was right
in front of me.
Work with your organization to ensure
that clear, reasonable, and stable
expectations are provided. You don't
want the goals to be on goal uh the
goalpost to be moving all the time. You
want it to be this is the number of
billable hours you have to have. These
are the things you're expected to do,
what have you.
If it seems like those change, it's
important to address it with your
supervisor. A good middle manager works
as an advocate for you between line
works as an advocate between line staff
and senior management.
Maintain or try to encourage the
organization to maintain reasonable case
loads based on intensity and acuity.
When I was assigning clients to people
in my residential program,
I wouldn't give all of the trauma cases
to one person because that would have
been overwhelming and
they probably wouldn't have been able to
provide adequate treatment to all of
them. So, I would break it up. Everybody
would have a couple trauma clients.
Everybody would have a couple of things.
If I had a client that I knew was
particularly
intense,
that clinician's case load may be
reduced. Instead of having 15 on their
case load, I may drop them down to 10 so
they had the time to address it and
maintain their own mental health.
Work for environmental safety and
acceptance.
Educate everybody in the organization,
not just the clinicians, about vicarious
trauma and signs of burnout because this
impacts the front desk staff. It impacts
medical records and impacts nursing
staff. It impacts everybody. Ensure
staff has access to training and
consultation and is appropriately
trained. They have to start out at a
base level of training that is adequate.
Identify and address sources of employee
dissatisfaction.
Suggestion boxes can be really helpful.
Promote a flow of clear communication
both ways between li line staff and
seuite. Often goes through the middle
manager, but that's okay.
Ensure feedback is delivered in a
constructive manner, not a punitive or
critical manner.
Encourage the practice of self-care
among all staff and ensure access to
traumainformed employee employee
assistance.
Evaluate employee deficits through a
traumainformed lens. If Jon is not
getting his paperwork done or maybe Jon
is spending too much time doing
counseling, not enough time doing
administration, that's usually one of
the bigger problems. Why is this? And it
could be that John clinician is feeling
helpless, feeling traumatized and is
getting over involved with the clients
um which is keeping him from doing his
work. So we need to use a
trauma-informed lens and recognize that
this work can be traumatizing
and use care in case assignments for
employees that are at risk. If you have
somebody who's going through a messy
divorce or when my when my husband um or
when my son was born, he was in the
neonatal intensive care unit for a
couple of months and it was a godsend
that his supervisor said, "You know
what? You've got a lot going on. Do what
you need to do. Take the time you need."
and
really cut back on his assignments some
during that time. That went a long way
to helping us cope with what was going
on.
Counseling and social work can
vicariously expose people to trauma on a
regular basis. Clinicians who are
already experiencing burnout are at
greater risk of secondary traumatic
stress and injury.
Burnout and secondary traumatic stress
both contribute to turnover and worse
patient outcomes.
Prevention and intervention must be a
joint effort between the clinical staff
and the organization.
Are there any questions?
Simply
me, you're very right. Overloading the
senior therapists or the more skilled
therapists and
underloading or giving the newer
therapists the easier quote unquote case
load just burns out the
senior therapists. What we need to do is
have the acuity spread across and the
intensity spread across therapists
so the senior therapists can mentor the
newer or less experienced therapists.
And you're right, Courtney, it is
extremely hard to hear what some clients
are going through or have gone through.
Um just imagining and empathizing can be
traumatic.
Everybody have a fabulous rest of your
week. Remember those mini breaks and
self-care and I will see you next
Wednesday.