2024 Summit Welcome and Keynote: The critical challenge of being a student leader in the 2020’s.
Watch on YouTubeVideo summary
The 2024 Summit, held on Gadigal land and themed "Agents of Transformation," gathered student leaders across Australasia to explore the critical challenge of leadership in the 2020s through a co-design approach that centers student voices. Opening keynote speaker Jimmy B shared his personal journey from a dyslexic student to a successful advocate, emphasizing that true leadership requires taking initiative, knowing one's purpose, and leading by example rather than merely discussing ideas. He introduced Dr. Earl Rome's concept of embracing failure and criticism while maintaining an obsession with purpose, outlining essential traits such as listening deeply, investing in people, delegating effectively, and building communities. A key warning issued was against the "ideation trap," where students mistake talking about concepts for actual execution, urging leaders to steward tangible projects that create real impact rather than just owning ideas.
To address the complexities of partnership dynamics, the summit introduced the "Jimmy Heater Test," an analogy derived from car heaters with one hot end and one cool end, representing the spectrum between decision-making and action-taking. This framework highlights a common disparity where experienced staff may control the "what" while students execute the "how," a separation that can alienate volunteers and render policies tokenistic. Effective partnerships must therefore engage those doing the work in discussions about execution to prevent dissatisfaction and ensure genuine collaboration. The session also explored the "two hats philosophy" of student leadership, distinguishing between acting as a personal sample representing one's own experience and serving as the voice of others representing a constituency. Leaders are encouraged to consciously switch between these roles, using deep self-reflection to explain personal limitations while suppressing their own perspective to build diverse alliances and listen deeply to others.
The event concluded by reinforcing that able leaders must be "sharply awake and reasonably disturbed," utilizing awareness as a tool to tackle tough challenges rather than seeking soulless serenity. By understanding the various "hats" they wear and applying tools like the Partnership Crucible, student leaders can plan future actions that foster maturity within their institutions. The overarching message was that moving from merely allowing student influence to ensuring it requires supporting non-selected leaders and creating environments where diverse voices are heard and valued. Ultimately, the summit called for a shift from passive participation to active stewardship, ensuring that student leadership is defined by tangible contributions, deep reflection, and a commitment to transforming the educational landscape through authentic collaboration.
Read the full video transcript
uh thank you good morning folks my name
is Charles Madden but known around the
inner city of Sydney as chick now that's
a nickname I got many many years ago
going to Red bur public school which is
now
NCI the national Center of indigenous
Excellence folks I'm from gadal Land
Aboriginal land that's the land we're on
at the moment for many many years lived
and worked around the city of Sydney
I've been involved with quite a few
Aboriginal
organizations over the years I've been a
director with the Aboriginal medical
service at Redfern for over 40 years
also a director with the red fern
Aboriginal housing company Aboriginal
ostel Australia and the Metropolitan
local Aboriginal land
Council got to mention it folks all Al a
life member of the red bur All Blacks
Rugby League Football
Club folks for many many years I've
lived and worked around the city of
Sydney I'd like to take this opportunity
this morning to extend a warm and sere
welcome to all my Aboriginal brothers
and sisters non-aboriginal brothers and
sisters we have any brothers and sisters
here from the Tor Street or further AP
far across the seas what welcome welcome
to gadal land the gadal clan is one of
29 that makes up the aor nation the Aur
nation is bordered by three distinctive
landmarks we have the oxbury river to
the north napen to the west and the
Georgia River to the South those three
rivers form the boundaries of the eor
nation folks if you've traveled across
this great city of ours today the state
of this great country or from afar
welcome welcome to gadal land enjoy your
stay have a safe and trouble fre tripo
once again
welcome
welcome welcome enjoy the day folks
thank you um thank you very much Uncle
Cher for that welcome to country that
was fantastic thank you um my name is
Bryson constable and I'm the president
of the University of Sydney's Student
Union um and it's my pleasure to welcome
you on behalf of the University of
Sydney to the student voice Summit for
2024 um thank you for making the trip to
the University of Sydney whether you've
driven uh 20 minutes solled out of bed
or flown for many hours um it's
incredibly exciting to have this level
of intellectual diversity in the room um
not only will our conversations today be
enhanced by the level of expertise um
contained amongst all of you but I'm
sure we will each be able to take
something something back to our student
unions to our student bodies to our
representative councils um something
that we haven't considered before um I
don't think we need to um reinvent the
wheel when we've got several takes on it
right before us but you might just find
today that you come up with something
you've never considered before and that
is the beauty of gathering so many
students um dedicated to student
leadership in one room um I'd like to
personally thank the office of student
life here at usid and um student voice
austral Asia for their role in
organizing The Summit this year in
particular I would also like to note the
work um that Anna has done uh in her
role as the coordinator this year it's a
fantastic um job that you've done to get
everyone in the room today so thank you
very much Anna um we'd also like to
thank uh noticing we've got Susanna
scaparo and Lydia duer here from student
life and would' like to thank all of the
work they do for for students at you
said um an opportunity like today is is
very unique this year's theme agents of
transformation is about centering
student voices and everything that you
universities do and you'll note that in
the spirit of today um much of the
program has been co-designed to reflect
important issues facing student bodies
around austral Asia to the many student
panelists and facilitators here today
ready to lead the conversations for the
next nine or so hours I say sincerely
sincerely thank you um the breadth of
conversations from a discussion of the
juggling act between life and Leadership
to empowering students in
decision-making to thinking about
student well-being and safety is
impressive it is only with buying from
students and staff like we have today
that successful codesign can be
undertaken uh it is certainly one of my
goals here as the USU president to
engage constructively with our partners
in co-designing to center student voices
and decisions I think indeed by by
taking the initiative on a number of
items such as our inaugural student
safety conference that we ran here uh
and a complete uh placemaking and
strategy refresh I hope that the USU um
is doing their bit to demonstrate that
sometimes uh with the support of our
universities students can also be the
adults in the room uh and it is our
drive for better outcomes that can set
up Monumental change uh in our
institutions so on behalf of the
University of Sydney I'd like to thank
each and every one of you for attending
today and wish each and every one of you
well in your deliberations thank you
thank you so much Bryson this was
fantastic
welcome Jimmy is um someone I really
wanted to bring to a student event and I
as a CO at SVA I really feel really
really privileged to um be in the
position to even suggest a speaker for
this event and it was really important
for me to um explain why to the Steering
group with students and staff who were
planning the program to really um
translate what I know about Jimmy
because Jimmy is my mentor he's my first
Mentor when I was at University of um
quenson university of
technology um he was my um first Mentor
uh and uh participated in a lot of just
inspired my student Journey as a leader
and then um my further Journey as a
professional in student affairs um he
was my first boss who believed in me I
was you know simple just doing like
simple admin tasks as a student never
worked in office before but with his
mentorship I was able to build
leadership programs trainings deliver
trainings deliver conference for
students and then take it away and take
it into what I know and build build
things and now I'm at SVA so I feel feel
really privileged and I feel like Jimmy
has direct impact to my journey and um
something to know about Jimmy he he
really wants to do that for everyone he
crossed paths with with any students he
works with students a lot and now he is
a manager of of student advocacy and
support at um university of Queensland
union he came uh today from Brisbane and
um he's you I'm not going to tell much
about what sort of you know what to
expect because it's all wonderful it's
really exciting uh for today but um
Jimmy has a lot of puts a lot of
intention into any training any speeches
he delivers to make sure you walk away
with something really tangible but also
you walk away challenged and really help
you feel challenged by some of the
questions that he brings up today and um
we we really needed to um kind of
concise the session for today for him
but I'm sure there will be a lot of
great content um that you will
enjoy um Jimmy is coming to us from
Canada originally and he's been in
Australia for about over 10 years uh
maybe more but um he's been working in
in Canada he's been working in Australia
and has is bringing all of that context
to you um a lot of that student
leadership um experience and experience
and bringing uh amazing programs on
campus and empowering students so I
really hope you feel uh inspired by his
speech today challenged by his speech
today as well as uh engaged by what he
is here um to just go through so without
any further Ado Jimmy Jimmy
B that's a lot of
pressure
thanks Hi how are you
that good
huh all right um before we get
started uh just to tell you a little bit
about who I
am I'm a white nearly middle-aged man in
a suit that means I'm very
important and almost everything I say is
in fact authoritative
Truth uh so let's get rid of that then
yeah
um uh that is who I am and it's not at
all who I am so
um if you don't mind uh I started my
student leadership Journey um back in
Canada I was lucky to go to university I
actually have multiple learning
difficulties um so school was a horror
show for me um but I grew up in a really
remote town and I really wanted to uh
experience something bigger and I
thought that my ticket to that was
University I did not have the grades to
get into University so I snuck in on a
performance degree wooo and then I was
like can't catch me now I'm in yo uh and
I did all right uh surprisingly the
first time I realized I was smart was at
the end of my first year after I had
dropped out of the program that I got
into thought I was going to get kicked
out um and then uh started taking
courses that I just took everything I
wanted to take before they kicked me out
kind of thing because I didn't
understand how universities worked back
then and uh they didn't kick me out they
didn't catch me which was amazing and at
the end of the first year all of a
sudden my grades were going up and I
didn't know what was going on and it was
because I was doing the things that I
loved and that was an incredible
opportunity I realized I was smart for
the first time in my life at University
I'd always thought I was stupid U and
that was very meaningful and so you can
imagine for me the opportunity that
University presented um it was not a
place that I thought I'd get into it was
not a place that I ne necessarily knew I
could afford to stay at um and then we
did all right um since then I was really
lucky I got really involved in campus
life um I got to reform our Student
Government um actually there are two
student governments at my University I
got to reform both of them um which was
very lucky um and I built my passion
there and then of course once you're at
University you realize all these
potential careers that you just didn't
know existed before that and so um it
had been so meaningful for me I thought
I need to give that back somehow and
so years later I am uh have been lucky
enough to build a career for myself in
higher education I've been um lecturer
done a bit of research um and I bounced
sort of between those types of roles and
professional roles uh looking at really
exceptional education and also education
in non-traditional spaces of which the
tertiary space is one of them how do we
educate beyond the classroom how do we
educate in the classroom better things
like that
um so I've been really lucky to do a
bunch of things um and so I'm really
lucky to be here um so before we jump in
I want to so say now what right this is
us um I want to recognize
um the I want to I want to first of all
thank uh Uncle chica for coming in today
and welcoming us to the country I want
to acknowledge the um
the indigenous uh traditional owners
here I want to welcome them into the
room in I think it's very very important
that we see um and when I say see I mean
take a moment to appreciate the fact
that these territories were always
places of of Learning and Development
and growth far far far before Colonial
Powers came here and that's really
really critical and important so I want
to acknowledge that and in the words of
my cousins that would say we would ask
our take a moment to welcome the spirits
into the room to help us have good
discussions today um I also want to say
that I see you so one of the um I come
from treaty 4 Grand River territory in
Canada before that my family was from
the treaty 3 S nation and um I think
that it's really important to teach you
a word that was taught to me by my
cousins and they've given me permission
to use which is a word is unin unin it's
a greeting it's sometimes informal
sometimes formal this is in aju
language but it means I see your light
and that's a very powerful word to me
Alin and so I want to say I see your
light and thank you for
coming I'm going to um read something to
you which is terrifying as a dyslexic
person um but it's something that I want
to read to you uh some of you may have
heard it before it's called a wish for
leaders how may have heard that
before I think it's important for
setting the stage for today and what
we're going to talk about today
so this is by Dr Earl Rome I did not
write this I
wish I sincerely wish you all have the
experience of thinking up a new idea
planning it organizing it and following
it through to
completion and then having it be
magnificently
successful I sincerely wish you had the
experience of thinking up a new idea
planning it organizing it following it
through to completion and having it
utterly fail
I wish you know how it feels to run with
all of your heart and to lose
horribly I wish that you can achieve
some great good for mankind and have
nobody know about it except
you I wish you could find something
worthwhile so worthwhile that you deem
it worth investing your very important
life
in I hope you become frustrated and
challenged enough to begin to push back
against the very barriers of your own
personal
limitations I hope you make a stupid
unethical mistake and you get caught
red-handed and are big enough to use
those magic words I was
wrong I hope you give so much of
yourself that some days you wonder if
it's worth it
all I wish for you a Magnificent
Obsession that will give you reason for
living and purpose and Direction and
energy and life
I wish for you the worst kind of
criticism and the best kind of criticism
in everything that you do because those
things sometimes the worst especially
make us fight to Achieve Beyond what we
normally
would I wish for you the experience of
leadership how does that make you feel
what a
bummer good all right inspired thanks
Earl there's a whole lot of stuff
coming yeah in life and in and maybe in
the talk we'll see right that's how I'm
starting all right thank you um I love
that the first time I heard it I was
very challenged I was young when I first
heard it and I was very challenged by it
and it gave me a lot to think about um
and I wanted to share that today because
that's kind of what we're talking about
today um when I heard about this I was
very very very excited about the
potential of coming and thank you to
everybody who is giving me this
opportunity to be here today it means a
lot it is a rare privilege and I have
been very privileged in my life to spend
it with student leaders whether I'm
teaching in a classroom working on a
policy doing whatever it is at at
whatever University I'm working at and
um and it's something I insist in all of
my work
because what are we doing it for if
we're not listening right what are we
doing it for if we're not learning from
the people that we're trying to help
discover who they are and what they're
about who we're trying to provide
education for um what are we doing for
not listening to that so this is core to
me and so I'm very excited to be here
um and I get the impression that
everybody here there's a real wide range
of experiences in the room how many
people here have been a student leader
for a matter of
weeks congratulations welcome how about
a matter of
months welcome matter maybe about a year
the student leader awesome coule two
years three
years too many to put up your hand
years nice um great
so I want to ask um to begin with I so
just to preface all of this I have very
very high expectations of all of you
congratulations this strange guy has
high expectations of you um so I want to
I don't want to just do one1 stuff today
right this isn't just the sort of like
motivational student
leader right we can do that but I
actually think when I knew who's in the
room and when I hear about what we're
here to do I got I was like no no no
let's just do something a bit more right
so some of the stuff we're going to talk
about today you're going to is kind of
going to be like I don't who I am not
signing up for this and some of the
stuff we're going to do today you're
like yes and some of the times you're
going be like oh that's me oh uh but
hopefully there's something here that
you're excited about all right so I want
to ask a question who got you here who
got you here I don't mean like literally
the Uber driver
um I want you to think of two people I
want you to tell this story to at least
one or two people at your table are you
sitting with people that you've don't
know great awesome so I want you to find
two people from your
life one who encouraged
you in like intentionally encouraged you
to do something you didn't think that
you could do or were the right person to
do the person who tapped you on the
shoulder and believed in you in a way
that you may have had not originally
believed in yourself I want you to think
about that person and the other person I
want you to think about is somebody who
constructively challenged
you that dyslexia by the M way means
that I will probably have spelling
errors so please forgive me it's better
than my handwriting though uh and also
the formatting I think shifted when we
moved it so apologize for that so two
people one who encouraged one who
constructively challenged I'd like you
to share at least one of those people
with somebody next to
you online I think you're going into
breakout
rooms great
spe
Wonder
not it was
if
than for
spe for
let's do about a minute and a half and
then we'll come back
way
all
right thank thank you for
sharing I hope everybody got a chance to
um share at least one person hear about
one person so really really important
people and I think it's very important
to take a minute to remember them and to
appreciate that moment because without
that you you wouldn't be here so we're
talking about where have you come from
these are really important people and
figures and moments
um someone chose you someone believed in
you enough
to do that it's such a rare thing isn't
it it's such a strange that it's a rare
thing sad that it's a rare thing I think
that's something we have to hang on to
as student leaders we need to recognize
that and and appreciate those people who
believed in you enough to say hey you
should try this or you should do this or
you need to or whatever they did to
encourage us um it's also really
important to recognize the people who
are trying to give us feedback I have a
philosophy but your hands up like
this say after me feedback is
love feedback is
love feedback
is yes feedback is
love the people who take the time to
give you feedback especially
constructive feedback that is that is a
minute small exercise in love and I
think that's really important and it's
something that we really need to
practice in our culture it's something
that is not a cultural EIC that means it
is not common across cultures right but
it's something that where I see it where
I see it strong in the cultures that
have that strong um tradition of
feedback um I see a kind of community
and a kind of relationship building that
cultures without it lack and so I think
we should encourage
that um and we need to work out on here
in Australia don't we we do we do I've
worked at universities I've worked at
six universities in three countries in
Canada us and Australia and um and all
of them are different all of the uh way
that they approach education is a little
bit different all the cultures are a
little bit different I've worked at some
other universities overseas as well um
briefly like for like short stints um
and yeah it's amazing and I think this
is one of those things that we need to
work on here in our educational
institutions so let's talk about student
leadership yes that's what we're here
for right awesome so my question for you
you
is what does a great student leader do
and I'm going to give you like three or
four minutes to talk to the person next
to you or maybe like if you're at an odd
numbered table the two people next to
you don't do the whole table as
diplomatic as that is just because of
time all right so what does a good
student leader do
go all
right let's come on
back okay I've been thinking about this
for a really long time
like an unfortunately long time no
actually it's unfortunate a long time um
and so I've come up with a few things
that I think great student leaders do
let's see how you went and let's see how
I went and afterwards if there's things
that I've missed you can let me know
um all right I've divided this up into
themselves and with others all right so
here's some of the things that they do
they take
initiative they act and they do do it's
very important this is going to be a an
emphasis of the day the due part right
they reflect
well they reflect
well I can't tell you how important this
is they know their
why if you're familiar with Simon sinx
Golden Circle knowing your why and this
really important they know their why and
they're also because they reflect well
they're able to fail well which is means
learning from our mistakes not allowing
them taking that in taking that personal
owning what they need to so they can do
something about it next time right
reflection is a core skill and if you
haven't exercise it start exercising it
it takes a while get somebody who's good
at self-reflection to teach you if you
need it right
they have a vision that vision is based
on values that's really really important
this also comes out of that reflection
piece right they have a vision are they
able to create a vision whether they can
articulate that Vision or not don't know
the best ones can they have a vision and
that vision is based on values that's
really important not just a vision for
the sake of vision but a vision for a
reason a reason they can articulate
they lead by example and they're not
afraid to get their hands dirty that's
also really important and that is
especially true in Australian
culture one of the biggest differences I
see in um workplace culture versus in in
like Canada versus um US versus
Australia is the importance of this one
as a as a professional
manager in Canada as a professional
manager I'm given a certain degree of of
credit and credibility B in my position
and and just the way that we talk about
things and do things but in Australia if
my staff don't see me in the trenches
with
them I have zero credibility and that's
the cultural thing here it's powerful
and there's some real value to that but
I think it's important that we keep that
in mind that's true universally this
piece is true universally but it's
especially true here in Australia I
find not afraid to get our hands dirty
not just the high-end decision maker but
actually the person is not afraid if
somebody's absent to get on on the
ground and set up that thing for that
event or hand out that bit of food at
the food hamper or whatever dirty job
needs to be done with others listen
deeply and by the way if I could that
would have been the first one that shows
up but I couldn't figure out in
PowerPoint how to get like that one and
then these ones and then that one it's
like 20 minutes of my life I'll never
get back
um listen
deeply
deeply that's a whole
Workshop or two that's a old day that's
that's a lifetime all right appreciate
those around them the best leaders
appreciate those around
them and practice appreciating those
around them practice seeing the value in
the people whose opinions are radically
different from yourself leaning in where
you're like okay wait hang on clearly
you're an intelligent human being so why
are all the things that you say so
dumb getting past that and leaning in
and figuring out what is is it that I'm
missing about this message what do I
need to understand but also taking the
moment to appreciate all the people
who've bothered to show up for them
right and understand and see their value
and appreciate
that a great leader invests in
others invest in
others a great leader delegates well
that's a hard skill to learn to delegate
well you need to build
trust to build trust what do you need to
do invest in others in order to invest
in others you have to appreciate those
around you order to appreciate people
you need to see it's all it's all
kicking together here's my list this is
my
list how'd you
go what did I
sorry advocacy advocate for others love
it
great say
again an objective mindset that's hard
we are going to get to that that is
excellent you're you're right balancing
mindsets is really tricky we're going to
talk about that a little bit later the
net value of all of this is a signature
that great student leaders have and
actually all great leaders have have but
especially great student leaders have
and I want you to think about the people
you've encountered who are great student
leaders and I bet you're going to find
some of the signature there the net
value of the signature is this great
leaders build right a great leader
builds communities everywhere they go
they build community they make people
feel
welcome right great leaders build
opportunities for others and not just
themselves if you watched the best
student leaders they are doing this
stuff all the time it's just like they
walk across the ground and like flowers
Sprout up it's
magic and they make more
leaders remember those people who
encouraged you remember those people who
gave you that
feedback feedback
is come on feedback
is
yes the signature of great leaders and
great student leaders is that they build
communities everywhere they go they
build opportunities for others
everywhere they go and they build more
leaders everywhere they go and how do
they do that through all those things
all those things result in this net
result so I was told once that every
great PowerPoint has statistics and a
chart so I have meaningless statistics
and an almost meaningless chart for you
here we go here we go
all right how do you score I want you to
think about
yourself you've talked about where
you're coming from how are you doing
with these this is by the way not one of
these things that you're born with these
things have to be practiced these are
not simple
skills these are
complex these are not skills that are
taught in your lecture theaters how
ironic is
that there's no lecture or maybe I
There's No Chorus on having difficult
conversations with a
peer right and yet it's one of the
things that employers are looking for
all the
time the course for that is student
leadership the education outside the
classroom that I was talking about
that's what we're here for that's why
we're here these are the things that
we're doing these are the opportunities
that the university presents right so I
want you to think about this for
yourself how are you scoring
which of those do you think you're doing
all right
with which would you like to move
further down the line which do you want
to practice identify at least two that
you want to get better
at write that down if you have something
to write with write that
down maybe you don't know how that's
okay you'll be able to find
somebody as you start to practice your
appreciation of others you'll find
people who are good at it you can ask
them and allow them to educate you right
so which of those I want you to find at
least two that you want to move you want
to get better at write that
down okay couple of core truths
are you okay yes are we doing all right
I had the chart right I got to be
winning at least to a degree right okay
so couple core truths about student
leadership you must act not just ideate
there is a giant ideation trap at
universities especially now because we
have really cool things like incubators
and
entrepreneurialism where we love to even
more id8 right so um here's a a
crazy has anybody ever seen an old movie
called Zoolander this this it's about
this male model and In This Moment he's
like he's like talking to his manager
he's like I want to do something better
with my life more than just being
ridiculously good-looking I was just
thinking the other day about trying to
help people who need help even just
thinking but was the most rewarding
experience of my entire
life so university has this really crazy
scenario where the whole thing is built
around ideas and exploring ideas and
Notions one of the drawbacks to that
which is even worse in a social media
age where we can like send thoughts and
prayers and like our causes um but
actually not actually manage to do
anything about our causes other than
like and sign a digital protest or
whatever um one of the things about
universities is that we have this idea
trap and when you spend years at
University and you're exploring your
ideas which by the way feels great it
feels great to explore idea that's why
we're here right but the trap part of
that
is that we start to think that talking
about stuff and thinking about stuff is
doing stuff and it's
not we get this trap of ideation I was
actually working with a bunch of of
innovation spaces in Queensland and we
were looking at student Innovation and
student entrepreneurialism and all that
stuff and there's this crazy the normal
entrepreneurial funnel looks something
like this it's really wide lots of ideas
and very few of them get to the little
bit there and the students is like I
can't bend my arms as wide as it is when
it comes to students right because the
whole system is set up to for us to
think that our ideas equate to action
and we have to be very careful about
that there's this other thing called The
False consultant the false consultant is
that like and if you're one of these
it's okay just breathe it'll be all
right the false consultant is is like a
university student who's like a
professional committee
member I know you know them and if
you're involved in unionism and all you
absolutely know them and you probably
are one and by intention or not they're
like on every single committee right and
then the line is like how's it going I'm
so busy I have very many important
committies to be and attend to but what
are you doing other than just like
talking right and it's really important
because this is the criticism of the
Ivory Tower right what good is the
talking if it's not grounded in
something in in real right this is why
if I spend time as a lecturer doing
research or something like that I'm
always bouncing out of that into
something grounded something in the
professional space because good theory
is grounded in practice and good
practice is grounded in theory so never
lose track it's an easy trap to fall
into because it feels good and people
start recognizing you our universities
love to pick up some sort of like
emerging student leader who fits all the
mold of what they think a student leader
should be especially and put them in
front of everybody and then have them
talk and then they ask them to go over
here and talk and then be on this
committee and on that committee and like
why wouldn't you say yes that feels so
good to be valued like that and maybe
your message is really important it does
need to get out there just don't lose
sight of the
doing because it's a trap and it's very
easy to fall into
right you must build something you've
got to try to make something it's one of
the most valuable things that you can do
for yourself at University it's very
hard to do once you go beyond that I'm
saying University but maybe people are
not from universities are people who are
not from universities have I been
ignorant this whole
time let's say institutions I'll try to
remember to say that instead you must
build something and the irony
is that it's never
yours how many people are familiar with
the word Steward or stewardship what
does that
mean what does it mean to be a steward
caretaking yeah it's holding in place
for others as student leaders we are
everything that we do even if it was our
idea that we built I want to do this
club and I want to bring my friends who
love this club and we're going to build
this club it's going to be the best club
and we do it and all of a sudden we got
200 people
there it's actually not your Club it's
your club but it's not your Club as
student leaders we are always holding
things in protection for
others build something and know that
it's not yours and that's very important
to keep in
mind very
important it will help you think in
terms of sustainability it will help you
think in terms of who you're going to
hand this over to it'll help you keep
purpose it'll help it be friendly for
people to join and to continue on and
that might mean that you might lose
control of it at some point in time and
that is a hard moment a very hard moment
but it's an important one so two truths
you have to act you cannot just ideate
you cannot just talk and you need to
build something and that's never going
to actually belong to you and that's a
weird thing that's a weird phenomenon
and while it's true in other spaces it's
part it's mostly it's really condensed
in student
leadership so now let's talk
institutions did I spell that
right okay we did a report card for
ourselves right we scored
ourselves let's score our
institutions all right what a great
institutions do here's what great
institutions
do they encourage student leaders that's
like level one stuff right they Embrace
emerging student leaders that's level
one stuff is your institution doing that
think about
it they intentionally and intentionally
you heard Anna say it intentionally
develop student leaders not haphazardly
not like you're a student leader
cool way to
go they're actually intentionally
developing student leaders that's level
two
stuff they allow students to influence
Community also level two
stuff right they're letting students
influence
Community now we get to level three
they're allowing students to influence
teaching and learning
allowing students to influence teaching
and
learning oh now we're getting into level
three stuff allowing students to
influence
policy this is a big dividing line in
the sand in terms of students that are
doing this or are not right or
institutions that are doing this or
not they fund student leadership
development now we're into level four
stuff here right level four stuff
they're letting students influence
policy they letting them they're funding
student leadership
development okay now we're going to get
into level five and I'm going to present
a whole R version of this list for level
five and I want you to pay attention to
what's different between level four
institutions and level five institutions
you ready here we go it's very nuanced
so take a really good look at those
words oh yeah right that wasn't it sorry
they intentionally build platforms for
all those above okay here we go the next
big one right that's all level four here
we
go what are the
differences has anybody found the word
that changed in a bunch of
them anybody found it yet there's a
couple of extras but there's one word
that changed in a bunch of those
yes we went from
allow students to
influence to ensure students influence
that is a very big
difference the absolute best level five
institutions are doing this and
importantly that last bit they're doing
all of this for students that they do
not
handpick that is a big
one it's a that's one of the big
differences in my experiences in
universities in Canada the US and
Australia how many student leader
leadership positions at your institution
are shoulder tapped here's a great
student getting great grades who's in my
research center come be on our
committee how often are saying how about
that dude who
failed we should find them
and we should bring them on this
committee and ask why they're failing I
was shocked about a year and a half
sorry two years ago I started a project
at ukq when I was working for the
University before I moved over to work
for the union and it was called the fail
project and I asked around and
apparently at the time nobody could
remember anybody who actually built a
student staff partnership about failure
with student Staff Partners who had
failed talking to other students who had
failed
what nobody has done that at least as
far as anybody could
know that's scary right so let's talk
about the student leaders that the
institution chooses and so and and many
of you will be them don't feel bad if
you were chosen right but are they doing
this for the ones that they don't choose
are they ensuring that they are in the
room are they listening as much to them
have they built a
platform for student leaders that they
don't select that's an interesting
question if you are coming from an
institution that does not have a student
union you should be asking
why you
should it's a very important question
and it probably relates to that right it
could relate to all sorts of things
Student Union histories are very
complicated but that's a really
important power question as a student
leader
yeah I can't read is it contemplation or
bored contemplation I'll take your word
for it you're very generous all right
so I want you to score your institution
how are they
doing you're gon to have a chance to
talk about this later you're going to
have a chance to share about your
institutions and some of the upcoming
activities and learn about it and it's
very important to have a chance to learn
about these other those institutions not
just the bad things but also the great
things what are they doing well what
have you seen them intentionally working
on what are some people trying to do
that the institutions just slow to
uptake and what are the things that
really need to have some change and this
is where it becomes a challenge for you
as a student leader to decide should I
be taking up one of those challenges
should I be pushing back in those
barriers should I be demanding more of
my university in this space
student leadership and student
partnership in Australia is
Young when I compare it to Canada and
the US when we think about it Canada the
US New Zealand and Australia right the
four Multicultural settler Nations right
English
speaking um Australia's engagement with
student Voice is pretty young on that
Spectrum
right and so there's a lot of work to be
done and that's exciting
but the institutions don't move on
themselves
right my daughter um who's four when she
was born we got her this great little
onesie as a baby had like all these
amazing female figures and it said the
patriarchy isn't going to smash
itself I love it we bought her one for
every single size as she's grown up it's
like a staple of her wardrobe we are
totally politicizing our four-year-old
daughter I am Unapologetic about that
um some of these institutions will not
move on them on their own right and
that's where the importance of student
voice is so critical even if we have
staff Champions who want to do this they
come to a committee and they say we
should do this thing we need students in
this room doing this thing and then
somebody on the committee says cool what
do the students think and there's an
empty chair where the student rep should
be and that's where that motion
dies that's where that motion
dies or maybe there isn't even a chair
right so without student voice those
things do not move along because the
institution has too many machines in the
way of the internal Champions and
sometimes you get a couple of Champions
funing each other and doing it from the
inside and working really hard to do it
but as they leave things start to
crumble right and that's where student
voice is so vital so vital so this is a
challenge for you to think about how is
my institution doing you'll have a
chance to talk about it later today but
think about it so what does this all
mean to you
woo that's a meaningful picture you're
going to have moments like that you
probably have experienced student
leaders in the room have you had moments
like that thinking about the student
leadership landscape yes you have this
is good I'm G to come back to that
picture
later we've taken a look at where you've
come from as a leader who brought you
here you've taken a chance to look at
where you want to go as a leader and now
we've taken a look at the context in
which you sit as a leader and I want you
to think
about what are you going to
do thanks for the burden
ji what are you going to
do what is the work to be
done at your Institution for student
leaders and where do you start as a
student
leader okay hang
on this is a big one I could give you
probably 40 minutes now in silence to
try to plan that out and write a goal
around it we just don't have that time
I'm probably already over time oh I'm
not oh my God that's
remarkable
um
so what's the work to be done how do we
get to he and we talked about Vision
this these are the seeds of
vision understanding where you've come
from understanding where you want to get
to as a student leader and understanding
the context in which you are and what
that means for what your next steps need
to be
so you need to plan how to get to there
even if you don't know where there is
yet I want to give you a couple of quick
tools that I think are really really
powerful for you how many of you are
student Representatives hands
up awesome how many of you are in
student Partnerships student staff
Partnerships how many of you run clubs
or are part of running a club how many
of you are campus
volunteers yep how many of you are
ah
mentors yep cool am I missing any other
major
populations cool
so couple things for you to pack on your
journey as you
go we need a measuring stick and we need
hats that's what we need for every
Journey right I know you thought about
that I know you packed those in your bag
I packed those in my carry-on right
measuring stick and hats let's talk
about the measuring stick oh we just we
just asked that question about hat if
you have a moment grab your phone QR
code quick question about what are the
hats that you're
wearing what are the hats that you're
wearing as a student leader take a
moment we just kind of we just kind of
talked about them some of those but
there's gon to be other hats that you're
wearing I like not sure right next to
student as a change agent that's awesome
the nice thing about this is that we're
all on a spectrum right we're all have
things that we want to push forward
things we want to do so don't worry
about that that's messy I'll show you in
a
second all right cool so I want to share
with you the partnership
Crucible I also call the heater test so
this is gonna have no context for you at
all but as a kid in Canada growing up in
19 I was had a car and and in our car we
had like this heater and then and it
didn't say airon it just said cool CU
like it's Canada right and back then
airon was like only for really rich
people apparently or people who because
it's Canada so you just roll down the
window um
so that heater like at one end it's like
hot and then at the other end it's cool
then if it's sort of in between you know
if you have one of those growing up or
ever saw that in an old car so when we
were I was working with uh with
University of Queensland trying to work
on training student Partners uh student
staff
Partnerships and I came up with this and
for a while they call it the Jimmy
heater test um so this is not just about
student staff Partnerships this is
actually for any kind of partnership
another really good context for you to
think about this in is if you run an
organization or a club and you have
volunteers volunteer members this is
also a really really important piece for
that so let's take those two
contexts in any partnership
you need to examine two
things decision- making and
action-taking
so when I developed this training for
student staff Partnerships at the
University of
Queensland what I did is we had on the
very first time that all of the student
staff Partnerships met they come around
a table and they're there all the staff
who were involved all the students were
involved and they've spent about 20 or
30 minutes talking about the project
talking about what they want to do and
things like that and
then I snuck them all a piece of paper
and I had this test on it and I said
okay without showing anybody at the
table without having talked about it
yet where on that Spectrum with this
project do you imagine keep it to
yourself don't tell anybody else
decisions sit decision- making sits and
the labor sits the labor of actually
carrying out the project sits and I want
you to think about what you think based
on what you've talked about now where
those sit and then because I love a
little bit of chaos I force them to
share it with everybody without having
looked at it yet to see where the staff
think it is and where the students think
it
is and that is an amazing
exercise and it is the best possible
beginning to a conversation around
expectations and
partnership sometimes it's the same
especially when you have experienced
staff and experienced students in the
room but often it can be radically
different and everybody goes oh crap
right especially the staff by the
way so this is a really powerful test
it's a powerful Crucible and you can
think about it in terms of student clubs
as well when you think about what we're
asking people to do where does the
decision making sit is it in the
executive portfolio over here or is it
in the volunteer portfolio over there
right and this is import a particularly
important where we have a power Dynamic
at play anytime you have a power Dynamic
at play this is a very good test to use
and there's a couple of key pieces to
come out of this it's a great Catalyst
for a discussion right who calls the
shots and who does the work and how
Equitable is
it it's also really important lesson
because as you decision making decisions
is a really important rule you need to
remember there's a what and there's a
how and there's a who to everything that
we want to do what do we want to do how
do we want to do it and who does
it never ever completely detach the what
and especially the how from the
who this is really important if you in a
highly structured environment student
unions are a good example of that where
students are making the decisions but
maybe staff have to carry out the orders
so the how is the magic solution to this
right because to be honest nobody likes
to be a minion no one signed up to be a
minion just doing stuff that you're told
is the fastest way to job
dissatisfaction possible it is the
fastest way for your Club volunteers to
never come
back how is the answer yes you can
decide what but have a joint
conversation about how because if you
divorce divorce the people who are doing
the actual work from having any say on
how it gets done you will alienate them
and they will not come back and your
relationship will be forever
jaded but if you are in the person who
is deciding on the what make sure you're
engaging in a how or even delegating the
how to the people that you trust to
carry it out and who have to carry it
out so it's really important to think
about that never divorce the what in the
how from the who has to do it never do
that
right this is a powerful powerful tool
for looking at any kind of relationship
let's say you're building a memorandum
of understanding with between your
organization and another organization
pull this out take a look at it what
sits in your bench what sits in our
bench where do we come together is it
realistic that we're all in the middle
because it's not always realistic that
we're all in the middle and that's okay
it is okay for decision- making to be on
lopsided and the work to be lopsided but
only so long as everybody's okay with it
and that's in the spirit of what we're
there to
do but the more extreme it gets the less
of a partnership it is right so it's
also a tool to say actually is this a
partnership that we're talking
about right and that also goes when you
get called into a committee if you're
called into a committee and all you have
to do is tell them what to do and they
have to go and do it don't think that
you're a student partner you're
not right because they're doing all the
work right are they exercising student
voice sure but there's something deeper
to be done you know and you can use that
opportunity to say cool this is what I
think has to be done great and that
feels good right and like great we'll
take all that and then we'll think about
how to do it right well hey can I help I
would love to help with the how to do it
that's what's actually going to make
sure that the thing you say becomes
actually a good policy and not just a
tokenistic comment that's acknowledged
in the acknowledgments but doesn't show
up in the actual policy right so this is
a very very useful tool I'm almost done
I
promise nobody's bobblehead yet nobody's
like okay all right two hats philosophy
this is around student representation
and as a student leader this is you are
going to be a student representative
whether you like it or not so if you are
a student leader congratulations you're
also a student rep because somebody at
some point in time is going to like
pluck you out it's like the machine from
Toy Story like take me to your leader
right I have been chosen and like pluck
you out because you're you're shining in
what you're doing right you wouldn't be
here if you don't and somebody's going
to see that shine and G like yep come
over here let's talk to you so and
they're going to ask
you why do students not show up to my
lecture theater or something like that
right so there's two philosophies here
right you as a sample as a
representative and you as the voice of
others and they're very different we
need to understand them and we need to
keep those in mind these perspectives in
mind sometimes you are there to speak
only about your experience and that is
fine that is okay to be on a committee
or be on a counsel or be whatever there
to speak about your own experience but
you have to control that because people
around you are going to misinterpret
that and think that you're the voice of
all students right and if you also come
from any kind of marginalized background
that's going to be Amplified tenfold
congratulations you're the voice for
your people as well right
so it's important that we think about
that and understand when when can we be
a sample when are we asked to be a
sample know what you're going into when
somebody invites you to be a
representative or to um join a committee
or hey you want to come and it feels so
good to get that invitation you need to
think about
okay what are the expectations are you
asking me as a
student just to be me or are you asking
me actually to be the voice of others
because there's a very different set of
work that goes with both those things
collecting the voice of other people is
hard
work reflecting yourself is a different
um sorry being a sample is a different
kind of hard work I'll talk about really
quickly about what those are right so
both of these have advantages and have
their own kind of hard work if you are a
sample you need to be really good at
that reflection thing right because at
some point in time they're going to
say
why and you're going need to know the
answer to why so they say how come you
don't show up to my
lecture now it's all on you because
you're the sample and it's actually
about your experience and you better
know why right and you might have to
face up to
say couldn't get out of
bed but then that doesn't look good so
you're like am I gonna get kicked off
the committee so how do you transform
that into a useful answer that's where
reflection is important why didn't you
get out of bed why was the bed offer
better than the committee meeting offer
and what's happening for you and that's
important being able to articulate that
in a professional way is important so
the hard work well it feels easier to be
a sample the hard work is being
reflective enough to be able to
articulate those answers really well and
to make sure that you're drawing those
boundaries I can't speak to why people
are showing up to your aren't showing up
to your lecture but I can tell you why I
wouldn't show up to your
lecture you got to be able to do that
you can't hide when you're a sample
right when you're representing as a
sample now representing as a voice of
others that's hard work because the
funniest thing is the very first voice
that disappears
is yours the exact
opposite if you are elected to represent
other people the very first voice that
has to disappear is your
own and that is important as a leader to
check and it's hard
and we use this excuse in Australia we
use it in federal politics which makes
me
cry we were elected therefore Everybody
Must Believe in everything about our
campaign
oh please don't ever say
that voice of others is tricky right
it's a lot of hard work it's hard nobody
has found the answer to getting broad
student voice it's a really it's a
perennial challenge right it's an annual
challenge it's an everyday challenge so
so that's hard you have to build a
diverse constituency you have to go out
and find ways to tap into people
especially those that you're not
familiar with to ask them and you have
to be able to listen really deeply you
have to be able to do something with it
there's a whole another workshop on how
do you do that some other time um but
student voice of others is a different
kind of hard work right in some ways
extroverts excel at one and introverts
excel at the other but both can be great
at both right so understand that and
more importantly being able to switch
those hats that's what really good
student leaders and student
representatives are good at doing
they're good at switching those hats and
telling people when they're switching
those hats actually we did a poll about
why students aren't going up to class
and here's what it found it found this
and this and this and here's how I
interpret that as a student
right or I can't answer that but I can
tell you why I am and what I've just
done there is I've shown the people that
I'm talking to that I'm switching hats
right now I can't tell you as a student
as a voice of students this because I
don't know or I can say I can tell you
exactly why I love this
class but there's a whole population of
students who aren't doing as
academically well as I am and they'll
have a different story and that's the
limit of my student student
representative voice right of others so
naming your limitations naming the
lenses with which you come which is by
the way very important to research if
you're doing research right um and
that's a really really critical thing in
terms of how do you balance both those
roles right telling people when you're
wearing the Hat as a sample I can tell
you what I do and here's the limitations
of that perspective or actually I've
asked people and here's what I found out
and here's a bit about that population
of people that I asked so and here are
the people that weren't asked in that
moment
right so you
have yeah did all that
stuff I want to give you one quote about
awareness this is my last
bit this is a quote from Robert K
Greenleaf who
is the parent of servant leadership and
it's one of my favorite quotes of all
that moment where you've had that moment
where you're sitting on the couch like
that that is about this moment it's
about
awareness as you are a student leader as
you are tackling tough things you become
more and more aware the more you listen
the more you becomeing aware awareness
is not a giver of soless it is just the
opposite it is a disturber it is an
awakener able leaders are sharply awake
and reasonably
Disturbed they are not Seekers after
soulless they have their own inner
Serenity love that it's hilarious and
true able leaders are usually sharply
awake and reasonably
Disturbed so I hope today you've had a
chance to think about where you've come
from where you want to go where you sit
in your context and what work there is
to be
done I hope that you feel a little bit
more
awake and a little bit more
Disturbed that's
leadership now you get
going thank
you yeah everyone another round of
applause for thanks very much enjoy the
rest of your day did